You are on page 1of 7

At the Intersection of Health, Health Care and Policy

Cite this article as:


Vidhya Alakeson, Nalini Pande and Michael Ludwig
A Plan To Reduce Emergency Room 'Boarding' Of Psychiatric Patients
Health Affairs, 29, no.9 (2010):1637-1642

doi: 10.1377/hlthaff.2009.0336

The online version of this article, along with updated information and services, is
available at:
http://content.healthaffairs.org/content/29/9/1637.full.html

For Reprints, Links & Permissions:


http://healthaffairs.org/1340_reprints.php
E-mail Alerts : http://content.healthaffairs.org/subscriptions/etoc.dtl
To Subscribe: http://content.healthaffairs.org/subscriptions/online.shtml

Health Affairs is published monthly by Project HOPE at 7500 Old Georgetown Road, Suite 600,
Bethesda, MD 20814-6133. Copyright © 2010 by Project HOPE - The People-to-People Health
Foundation. As provided by United States copyright law (Title 17, U.S. Code), no part of Health
Affairs may be reproduced, displayed, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or
mechanical, including photocopying or by information storage or retrieval systems, without prior
written permission from the Publisher. All rights reserved.

Not for commercial use or unauthorized distribution

Downloaded from content.healthaffairs.org by Health Affairs on April 11, 2015


at NYU MED CTR LIB PERIODICALS DEPT
Emergency Department Use

By Vidhya Alakeson, Nalini Pande, and Michael Ludwig


doi: 10.1377/hlthaff.2009.0336

A N A LYS I S C O M M E N TARY
HEALTH AFFAIRS 29,
& NO. 9 (2010): 1637–1642
©2010 Project HOPE—
The People-to-People Health

A Plan To Reduce Foundation, Inc.

Emergency Room ‘Boarding’


Of Psychiatric Patients
Vidhya Alakeson (vidhya
ABSTRACT Overcrowded U.S. emergency rooms have become a place of last .alakeson@nuffieldtrust
.org.uk) is a senior fellow in
resort for psychiatric patients. Psychiatric boarding, defined as health policy at the Nuffield
psychiatric patients’ waiting in hallways or other emergency room areas Trust, in London, England.

for inpatient beds, is a serious problem nationwide. Boarding consumes


Nalini Pande is a senior
scarce emergency room resources and prolongs the amount of time that director at the National
Quality Forum, in Washington,
all patients must spend waiting for services. It is often the result of an D.C.
inability to gain timely access to community-based care. As policy makers
implement the new health reform law, improving access and continuity Michael Ludwig is pursuing a
joint master of business
of community mental health care through health homes must be a administration and master of
public health degree at
priority. We present a seven-point plan to address psychiatric boarding. Columbia University, in New
York City.

I
n a 2008 survey of 328 emergency room greater collaboration among hospital emergency
(ER) medical directors, the American rooms, community mental health providers, and
College of Emergency Physicians found law enforcement agencies, and and it proposes
that roughly 80 percent believed that investments in the development of community
their hospitals “boarded” psychiatric pa- infrastructure. The paper highlights opportuni-
tients.1 The term boarding is generally under- ties in the new health reform law that support the
stood to mean the time spent waiting in an implementation of this action plan.
emergency room for a hospital bed or for transfer
to another inpatient facility. Boarding times in
Georgia, for example, average thirty-four hours, Background
and many patients wait several days for an inpa- Psychiatric patients’ overuse of and boarding in
tient bed in one of the state’s seven psychiatric emergency rooms are symptoms of a lack of ap-
hospitals.2 In Maryland, many emergency rooms propriate care stemming from a severe crisis in
treat more than a dozen psychiatric patients a the mental health system. Beginning in the
day and can board up to a dozen for days at 1960s, the deinstitutionalization movement re-
a time.3 sulted in a decrease in the number of inpatient
Because emergency rooms are poorly equip- and residential psychiatric beds in state and
ped to deal with mental health needs, boarded county mental hospitals. The number of beds
patients do not receive high-quality care there. nationwide dropped from approximately
Their presence affects the care received by other 400,000 in 1970 to 50,000 in 2006.2
patients because boarded patients reduce ER The Community Mental Health Centers Act of
capacity and increase pressure on staff. In addi- 1963 was intended to create a mental health
tion, boarding has a negative financial impact on center in every community to serve those who
hospitals because reimbursement rates do not had been moved out of institutions. But this
account for boarding. vision was never adequately funded or fully
This paper presents a seven-point action plan realized.4
to reduce the boarding of, and ER use by, psy- This initial failure to create a robust commu-
chiatric patients. The plan aims to develop nity mental health system has been compounded

S ep t e m b e r 20 1 0 29:9 Health Affa irs 1637


Downloaded from content.healthaffairs.org by Health Affairs on April 11, 2015
at NYU MED CTR LIB PERIODICALS DEPT
Emergency Department Use

by several factors, leading to severe constraints A Seven-Point Action Plan


on the capacity of community-based mental The seven-point action plan described below
health care. Total state spending on mental builds a framework compatible with the Medic-
health services was 30 percent less in 1997 than aid health home concept to reduce the boarding
in 1955, when adjusted for population growth of, and ER use by, psychiatric patients.
and inflation. The growth of managed behavioral The plan is based on an extensive literature
health care and its use of strict medical manage- review,9 consultations with experts in the field,
ment techniques has resulted in poorer access to and interviews at nine hospitals. All of the hos-
care in the community, increasing the likelihood pitals are nonprofit. Eight are urban or subur-
of mental health crises and the use of emergency ban, and seven have a psychiatric ward. Three
room care.5 A number of states that have enrolled have psychiatric emergency services in addition
people with disabilities in Medicaid managed to a traditional emergency room.
care have cut back or denied coverage for high- We interviewed seven physicians who practice
cost antipsychotic drugs. Low reimbursement in or direct emergency rooms, eight nurse case
rates for behavioral health services under Medic- managers or social workers, and seven psychia-
aid and Medicare have further discouraged the trists who are chairs of psychiatry departments
provision of such services in the community. or on call at a hospital. We also interviewed six
Some experts and commentators have even community stakeholders, including representa-
warned of a “wholesale collapse” of today’s men- tives from community mental health centers and
tal health system.6–8 state facilities such as outpatient psychiatric
The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act facilities and mental health departments.10
of 2010 addresses the problem of boarding
through the creation of a $75 million demonstra-
tion project known as the Medicaid Emergency Step 1: Quantify And Monitor The
Psychiatric Demonstration. This project will al- Problem
low all hospitals to receive Medicaid reimburse- Psychiatric boarding was described by one
ment for emergency psychiatric care provided to respondent as the “number one problem of my
working-age adults. Emergency Department.”10 Quantifying the ex-
Outside the demonstration project, hospitals tent of psychiatric boarding is the first step to-
are not reimbursed for this care because Medic- ward tackling the problem. No comprehensive,
aid does not cover inpatient psychiatric services nationwide, scholarly evaluation of the extent of
for working-age adults in institutions with more the problem exists. Policy makers so far have
than sixteen beds. By expanding the number of relied on newspaper reports and surveys of medi-
hospitals willing to take psychiatric patients in cal associations. As a result, it is difficult to make
an emergency, the project could reduce the pres- the case for any substantial investment in solu-
sure on all hospitals. However, it does not divert tions. Addressing this information gap is critical.
individuals away from emergency rooms and, One key barrier to data collection is the lack of
therefore, is only a short-term fix. A longer-term a standard definition of what constitutes board-
solution will require increasing the capacity of ing, in terms of the length of time spent waiting
community mental health services. This increase in the emergency room for an inpatient bed. To
will be a challenge, given that the new health address this issue, information about boarding
reform law expands Medicaid eligibility and thus of psychiatric and medical patients in emergency
adds more demand for community mental health rooms could be added to the National Ambula-
services, whose primary clients in most states are tory Medical Care Survey conducted by the Na-
Medicaid recipients. tional Center for Health Statistics.
The most important opportunity in the new
law comes from the introduction of a Medicaid
health home state plan option. This targets peo- Step 2: Improve ER Care Of
ple with serious mental illnesses, as well as those Psychiatric Patients
with other chronic conditions, and is designed to Another respondent stated that what psychiatric
facilitate continuity of care in the community. patients need, “they don’t get.”10 Improving the
Under the law, states may file a state plan amend- care that patients receive in emergency rooms is
ment to put the health home option in place for an important step toward reducing boarding.
eligible chronically ill people in Medicaid. It is Because high-quality care in a time of crisis
not clear how many states will ultimately take up can reduce the need for inpatient admission,
the option, but because the share of the federal patients who get better care are more likely to
contribution toward this option will be 90 per- go home than to stay in the emergency room
cent, many are expected to do so. as boarders. Ensuring high-quality emergency
care will be an important part of implementing

1638 Health Affairs S ep t e m b e r 20 1 0 29:9


Downloaded from content.healthaffairs.org by Health Affairs on April 11, 2015
at NYU MED CTR LIB PERIODICALS DEPT
could be integrated into the Medicaid Emer-
Small, inexpensive gency Psychiatric Demonstration to ensure the
provision of high-quality emergency care.
changes in practice
can lead to Step 3: Make More Efficient Use Of
improvements in ER Existing Capacity
In the absence of adequate investment to expand
care for psychiatric capacity (see Step 6 below), communities can
make more efficient use of existing capacity in
patients. inpatient settings and community services to re-
duce boarding.
On the inpatient side, use-review teams have
helped some hospitals improve inpatient capac-
ity planning and implement more-timely dis-
charges of patients. These teams are often
the Medicaid Emergency Psychiatric Demon- given the authority to transfer or discharge pa-
stration. tients and cancel or delay elective procedures.14
Poor care is the result of several factors. First, Additionally, computerized bed management
emergency rooms are generally loud, hectic envi- systems can improve the flow of patients into
ronments that are poorly suited to deescalating a and out of the hospital.15 At the community level,
mental health crisis. improved customer service and better manage-
Second, ER psychiatric assessments are often ment of no-shows and cancellations of appoint-
inadequate,11 and when treatment is provided, it ments have been shown to create more timely
is generally no more than medication.9 This is access to mental health services for patients who
because psychiatrists are not available in all do keep their appointments.
emergency rooms,1 and ER staff members are Carlsbad Mental Health Center, in New
often not trained in psychiatry. Mexico, used these techniques successfully to
In fact, this lack of training contributes greatly reduce wait times for a nonemergency first ap-
to boarding. Evidence indicates that less experi- pointment with a clinician holding a master’s
enced clinicians are more likely than psychia- degree.Wait times fell from six weeks to 11.2 days
trists to admit patients, fearing that they will over a six-month period.16 The center used a
be held liable if a patient who is not admitted range of management initiatives, including
harms him- or herself or someone else.10 phone calls to remind clients of appointments
Small, inexpensive changes in practice can and letters sent to clients after two missed ap-
lead to improvements in ER care for psychiatric pointments to encourage clients either to dis-
patients. For example, hospitals that partici- continue services or to resume them.
pated in the Institute for Behavioral Healthcare
Improvement’s 2008 learning collaborative
found that they were able to reduce the length- Step 4: Implement Low-Cost
of-stay of psychiatric patients in emergency Collaboration
rooms and the use of seclusion and restraint Implementing low-cost collaboration between
in caring for these patients. The hospitals used emergency rooms and community outpatient
low-cost interventions such as training clinical alternatives can also reduce psychiatric board-
and security staff in deescalation techniques and ing. Collaboration provides alternative place-
changing policies that required all psychiatric ment options for patients who do not require
patients to remove their clothing in the emer- hospital-level care—and by the same token, in
gency room. Being forced to undress can cause the absence of collaboration, alternative place-
significant distress to individuals with mental ment options usually don’t materialize.
health conditions who have experienced trauma. For example, hospitals participating in the In-
This can lead to their mental health worsening in stitute for Behavioral Healthcare Improvement’s
the emergency room, prolonging boarding.12 learning collaborative that lacked strong com-
An immediate barrier to improving ER care for munity collaboration found it harder to reduce
people with mental illnesses is the lack of na- patients’ length-of-stay. This was because length-
tional standards for such care. In February 2009 of-stay was frequently determined not by the sta-
the major professional bodies for emergency bility of the patient’s condition, but rather by the
medicine jointly published an Emergency Care availability of an appropriate placement outside
Psychiatric Clinical Framework.13 Once it is ap- the emergency room.11
proved by the boards of those organizations, it One example of a low-cost collaborative effort

September 2010 29:9 Health Affairs 1639


Downloaded from content.healthaffairs.org by Health Affairs on April 11, 2015
at NYU MED CTR LIB PERIODICALS DEPT
Emergency Department Use

is using community mental health clinicians to County, in Florida—have invested in specialty


train ER staff in the management and care of training for law enforcement.
patients with serious mental illnesses. Another Lack of support from local police leadership
is having a social worker in the emergency room and inadequate funding militate against such
who can connect individuals with community collaborations in other communities. However,
services when they are discharged, improving federal support is available through the Justice
continuity of care.9 and Mental Health Collaboration Program in the
One of the major obstacles to collaboration is U.S. Department of Justice. The program pro-
the lack of shared responsibility and accountabil- vides grants of up to $250,000 for two years to
ity between the community mental health system plan, implement, or expand collaborative pro-
and the hospital emergency room. This is exac- grams between criminal justice and mental
erbated by the fact that the two systems do not health partners, including specialized training
share funding, governance, or licensing. State of law enforcement officers.
mental health agencies have little or no formal
relationship with emergency rooms.
Thus, the first step in establishing collabora- Step 6: Invest In Comprehensive
tions is to bring the relevant stakeholders to- Community Crisis Services
gether to develop joint ownership of the A comprehensive approach to mental health
problem of boarding, and to get everyone’s com- services must create appropriate alternatives to
mitment to remedying the problem. emergency rooms for crises and routine care.
For example, Bexar County, Texas, has devel- This type of approach is essential to achieving
oped an award-winning collaborative program to a reduction in psychiatric boarding.
keep psychiatric patients out of both the emer- Harris County, Texas, has developed the Com-
gency room and jail. The collaboration, which prehensive Emergency Psychiatric Program,
began in 2002, brings together representatives which the American Psychiatric Association
from public and private hospital systems in the has recognized as a model for comprehensive
area, as well as from community mental health emergency services in an urban setting. The pro-
services, law enforcement, the court system, and gram has six core features: a round-the-clock
public officials.17 The participants acknowledge public help line; round-the-clock psychiatric
that keeping psychiatric patients out of emer- emergency services; a mobile crisis outreach
gency rooms and jails is a “systems” issue and team; a crisis stabilization unit with beds for
take collective responsibility for managing the sixteen adult psychiatric patients; a voluntary
movement of psychiatric patients among their emergency residential unit with beds for eight-
institutions. een adult psychiatric patients; and a crisis coun-
seling unit.18 The most important of these six
features for reducing emergency room boarding
Step 5: Work With Law Enforcement are the twenty-four-hour community-based psy-
As first responders in many crises involving peo- chiatric emergency services and the mobile crisis
ple with mental illnesses, law enforcement offi- outreach team.
cers can play an important role in preventing the Developed more than forty years ago, psychi-
escalation of a situation involving a psychiatric atric emergency services focus on providing
patient and can thus make inpatient care unnec- high-quality psychiatric assessments and inter-
essary. Training these officers to manage mental ventions outside an emergency room. The psy-
health crises and giving them information about chiatric emergency service in Harris County sees
the appropriate use of local mental health ser- approximately 11,000 patients a year, including
vices can keep some psychiatric patients out of more than 1,000 children and adolescents. It is
the emergency room. staffed by psychiatrists, licensed social workers,
One model of specialized training is the crisis nurses, and psychiatric technicians. Seventy-
intervention team approach. Developed by the eight percent of adults and 71 percent of children
police department in Memphis, Tennessee, this assessed at the service in 2006–7 could be
approach educates law enforcement officers on adequately treated there and did not require hos-
how to recognize and deescalate mental health pitalization.19
crises. Another approach is the co-responder The service’s staff is trained to distinguish be-
model, developed in Los Angeles County, Cali- tween a psychiatric crisis and the effects of drugs
fornia, which involves a partnership between a or alcohol. Because the service is funded by the
trained crisis intervention officer and a mental county’s mental health agency, the staff is likely
health clinician. Several communities—includ- to be aware of community-based options that can
ing Bexar and Harris Counties, in Texas; Mary- reduce the demand on the emergency room, such
land’s Montgomery County; and Miami-Dade as detox beds for inebriated patients.

1640 Health Affa irs S ep t e m b e r 20 1 0 29:9


Downloaded from content.healthaffairs.org by Health Affairs on April 11, 2015
at NYU MED CTR LIB PERIODICALS DEPT
Ongoing, coordinated tive, accessible community mental health
services, such as Assertive Community Treat-
care would reduce ment,21 can prevent people from cycling into
and out of mental health crises. In fact, one of
mental health crises the recommendations from the first-year evalu-
ation of Texas’s statewide investment in crisis
in many cases. services is to dedicate a portion of the funding
earmarked for crisis services to improving out-
patient mental health services. This would create
better continuity of care for patients.20
As noted above, the option for states to offer
Medicaid health homes for the chronically ill
The Harris County mobile crisis outreach team provides an important opportunity to improve
is able to assess and resolve crises and provide continuity of care for individuals with serious
brief therapeutic interventions in community- mental illnesses. The option permits Medicaid
based settings, including individuals’ homes. reimbursement for coordinated care through
Of the 2,352 people seen by this team in an assigned health home, with the federal
2006–7, only 4 percent required hospitali- government contributing 90 percent of the costs
zation.19 in the first two years and an additional $25 mil-
In 2008 the Texas legislature committed lion in planning grants. Ongoing, coordinated
$82 million over two years to the development care would reduce mental health crises in many
of core crisis services across the state.20 The high cases and, where crises do occur, would provide
price tag for such services, the need for legisla- an alternative, trusted point of care that could
tive buy-in, competing priorities, and severely divert patients from emergency rooms.
constrained state budgets all make it difficult
to develop similar services in other parts of the
country. The provision in the new health reform Conclusion
law to permit home and community-based ser- Psychiatric boarding is much more than a behav-
vices to be offered as part of a Medicaid state plan ioral health problem. It is a health care delivery
rather than through a waiver could provide a problem. To ensure that people with mental ill-
funding mechanism for the development of nesses receive appropriate care, states need to
more community-based crisis services. couple efforts to expand Medicaid coverage with
To support the use of this mechanism, it will be efforts to redesign the delivery system for mental
vital to have detailed data about the return on health services. It is crucial to develop connec-
investment from existing systems such as the tions between community-based outpatient ser-
one in Harris County. Documenting the cost- vices, community-based crisis services, inpatient
effectiveness of community-based crisis systems services, and emergency room services.
compared to an ongoing reliance on ER services The health reform law’s new Medicaid health
is critical in making the case for greater invest- home state plan option supports the develop-
ment in these systems across the country. ment of community-based, coordinated services.
It provides an important opportunity to reduce
psychiatric boarding and improve the quality of
Step 7: Invest In Continuity Of Care community mental health services. If we fail to
Community-based crisis services can be a more take advantage of that opportunity, we will not
appropriate form of crisis care than ER services only compromise the quality of care and the
for people with mental illnesses. But they are not health of those with mental illnesses, but we will
a replacement for ongoing care in the commu- also reduce the quality of care for all patients
nity. Providing continuity of care through effec- needing emergency room services. ▪

Part of the work for this paper was the views of the authors and not those
completed under U.S. Department of of the U.S. Department of Health and
Health and Human Services Contract no. Human Services.
HHS-100-03-0027. This work reflects

S e p t em b e r 2 0 1 0 29 :9 H ea lt h A f fai r s 1641
Downloaded from content.healthaffairs.org by Health Affairs on April 11, 2015
at NYU MED CTR LIB PERIODICALS DEPT
Emergency Department Use

NOTES
1 American College of Emergency 8 Appelbaum P. Starving in the midst 15 Katz A. Patients wait for hours in
Physicians. ACEP psychiatric and of plenty: the mental health care hallways; strain felt throughout
substance abuse survey 2008 [In- crisis in America. Psychiatr Serv. state. New Haven Register. 2006
ternet]. Irving (TX): ACEP; 2008 2002;53:1248 (source of quote). Apr 16.
[cited 2009 Mar 22]. Available from: 9 Bender D, Pande N, Ludwig M. A 16 National Council for Community
http://www.acep.org/uploaded literature review: psychiatric board- Behavioral Healthcare. Access and
Files/ACEP/Advocacy/federal_ ing. Washington (DC): U.S. Depart- retention project: first year summary
issues/PsychiatricBoarding ment of Health and Human Services, report [Internet]. Washington (DC):
Summary.pdf Office of the Assistant Secretary for The Council; 2008 [cited 2009
2 Tuttle GA. Report of the Council on Planning and Evaluation; 2008. Aug 17]. Available from: http://www
Medical Service, American Medical 10 Bender D, Pande N, Ludwig M. .thenationalcouncil.org/galleries/
Association: access to psychiatric Psychiatric boarding interview sum- business-practice%20files/Access%
beds and impact on emergency mary. Washington (DC): U.S. De- 20&%20Retention%20Summary%
medicine [Internet]. Chicago (IL): partment of Health and Human 20Report.pdf
AMA; 2008 [cited 2009 Mar 22]. Services, Office of the Assistant 17 Hnatow D. Providing care for the
Available from: http://www Secretary for Planning and Evalu- acute mentally ill: a community re-
.ama-assn.org/ama1/pub/upload/ ation; 2009. sponse. Urgent Matters Patient Flow
mm/372/a-08cms2.pdf 11 Stefan S. Emergency department Enewsletter [serial on the Internet].
3 Maryland Patient Safety Center. assessment of psychiatric patients: 2005;2(6) [cited 2010 Aug 4]. Avail-
Strategies for handling the psychi- reducing inappropriate inpatient able from: http://urgentmatters
atric patient population [Internet]. admissions. Medscape [serial on the .org/e-newsletter/318774/318775/
Elkridge (MD): The Center; 2006 Jul Internet; login required]. 2006 Aug 1 318777
[cited 2009 Mar 22]. Available from: [cited 2010 Jul 21]. Available from: 18 Maples M. Texas mental health and
http://www.marylandpatientsafety http://cme.medscape.com/ substance abuse crisis services
.org/html/collaboratives/ed/ viewarticle/541478 redesign. Paper presented at:
documents/StrategiesForHandling 12 Institute for Behavioral Healthcare National Olmstead Conference.
PsychPatientPopulation.pdf Improvement. Summary of the pio- Washington, DC; 2008 Sep 29–Oct 1.
4 Grob G, Goldman H. The dilemma of neering collaborative on improving 19 Mental Health and Mental Retarda-
federal mental health policy: radical care for behavioral health clients in tion Authority of Harris County.
reform or incremental change? New emergency departments [Internet]. Local plan review FY2006–2007:
Brunswick (NJ): Rutgers University Castleton (NY): The Institute; 2009 part I; history and organizational
Press; 2007. [cited 2009 Mar 22]. Available from: overview [Internet]. Houston (TX):
5 The Interim Final Rule implement- http://www.ibhci.org/summary- The Authority; [cited 2010 Aug 6].
ing the Mental Health Parity and pioneering-collab-ED.shtml Available from: http://www
Addiction Equity Act of 2008 elimi- 13 International Society of Psychiatric– .mhmraharris.org/LocalPlan/
nated the possibility of using more- Mental Health Nurses. Emergency documents/1-LOCALPLANPARTI-
restrictive medical management care psychiatric clinical framework INTRO.pdf
techniques for behavioral health [Internet]. Madison (WI): The Soci- 20 Carmichael D, Jensen-Doss A, Booth
benefits than are used for physical ety; 2009 Feb 2 [cited 2010 Aug 6]. E. Year one evaluation findings for
health benefits, unless there is a Available from: http://www the crisis services redesign initiative:
clear, evidence-based rationale for .ispn-psych.org/docs/Clinical report to the Texas Department of
doing so. Framework0902.pdf State Health Services. College Sta-
6 Stefan S. Emergency department 14 Case RB, Fite DL, Davis SM, Hoxhaj tion (TX): Texas A&M University;
treatment of the psychiatric patient: S, Jaquis WP, Seay T, et al. Emer- 2009.
policy issues and legal requirements. gency department crowding: infor- 21 Assertive Community Treatment is
New York (NY): Oxford University mation paper [Internet]. Irving an intensive, multidisciplinary
Press; 2006. (TX): American College of Emer- treatment model with active out-
7 Brown C. Appelbaum outlines plan gency Physicians; 2004 Apr [cited reach that allows individuals with
to address country’s mental health 2009 Mar 22]. Available from: high levels of need to be treated in
crisis. Psychiatr News. 2002; http://www.acep.org/WorkArea/ the community.
37(12):8. DownloadAsset.aspx?id=8872

1642 Health Affa irs S ep t e m b e r 20 1 0 29:9


Downloaded from content.healthaffairs.org by Health Affairs on April 11, 2015
at NYU MED CTR LIB PERIODICALS DEPT

You might also like