Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1615-1622
Geotech., Const. Mat. and Env., ISSN: 2186-2982(P), 2186-2990(O), Japan
ABSTRACT: Oil leakage is considered as one of the significant environmental issue worldwide, which affects
the physical and chemical properties of the surrounding sand. A range of remediation methods for oil-
contaminated sand was recommended but none are considered to be cost effective especially in developing
countries. In order to find an alternative and cost-effective remediation method, the use of oil contaminated
sand in engineering and construction has been considered. This paper reviews the main sources of oil
contamination, the existing remediation methods and critically analysed several factors that affecting the
properties of oil contaminated sand. Emerging applications of oil contaminated sand in engineering and
construction are also presented.
1615
Int. J. of GEOMATE, Feb., 2016, Vol. 10, No. 1 (Sl. No. 19), pp. 1615-1622
litres of oil that affected about 110 km of the 23]. This quantity of produced water is expected to
Louisiana coastline [16, 17]. Moreover, around 71 increase in the future, which means this continuing
million litres of crude oil was intentionally discharge of oily waste water into the environment is
discharged from oil storage tanks at the Harouge Oil now a major concern [24].
Operation petrochemical and refining complex at the
Ras Lanuf Terminal in Libya in August 2008 [16,
17] to circumvent an explosion in the tank from the
fire caused by a human error during annual
maintenance [16]. This is an example of a crude oil
spill caused by negligence associated with the
operating companies. In fact, most crude oil spills
were caused unintentionally due to ageing facilities,
lack of maintenance, and human error.
1616
Int. J. of GEOMATE, Feb., 2016, Vol. 10, No. 1 (Sl. No. 19), pp. 1615-1622
current systems cannot remove particles (oil by the liquid and gaseous phases. The flow of pore
droplets) less than 10 µm, small droplets of oil can water can be affected by the size of the pores and the
interfere with oily produced water. Based on degree of saturation and hence the permeability (k)
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) might be decreased [33].
regulations, the daily maximum limit for OG is 42
mg/L and the monthly average limit is 29 mg/L [22]. 3.2 Sand contaminated with crude oil
Despite the fact that many countries have Understanding the properties of oil contaminated
implemented more stringent regulations for sand is very important [35] in order to determine the
discharging produced water to reduce the effect of extent of its adverse effects to the environment and
these components on the environment, huge amounts to decide the most suitable remediation method.
of produced water are still discharged onshore or Similarly, the physical and chemical properties of
offshore. The main issue with crude oil sand change as soon as they come into contact with
contamination caused by oil spillage and oily crude oil [36]. The degree of change depends on
wastewater is the resultant changes in the physical many factors such as the type of sand, and the
and chemical properties of the surrounding soil [3]. specific composition and quantity of the spilled
Hence, to eliminate or minimize the adverse effect hydrocarbon. When crude oil is spilled, the liquid
of oil contaminated sand on the environment, a hydrocarbon travels down to the groundwater
suitable remediation method should be implemented, causing partial saturation of the sand and the
but this requires a better understanding of the pathway of the hydrocarbons. Once a hydrocarbon
composition and properties of oil contaminated sand. reaches the ground water table, it spreads
horizontally within the capillary zone and further
3. OIL CONTAMINATED SAND
saturates the sand [36]. These spreads are much
greater with light crude oil than medium and heavy
3.1 Sand composition crude oil because light crude oil contains high
Sand is a naturally occurring material (NOM) that is percentage of light hydrocarbons that can easily
considered to be an important engineering material. penetrate and migrate through the particles of sand.
In most cases its physical characteristics are This is why sand contaminated with light crude oil is
determined by experiments and these properties are considered to be one of the most adverse
then used to predict its expected behavior under environmental issues.
working conditions, including its beneficial uses
[29]. Hydrocarbon contamination has a direct effect on the
erosion of sand and water infiltration, and may also
Sand is considered to be a three phased material cause fire on the ground. Whereas fire-induced or
(liquid, solid, and gas), whose geotechnical use is fire-enhanced sand water repellence has often been
mainly based on its mechanical behavior. When sand cited as the major cause of post-fire enhanced runoff
is contaminated with oil, the composition of these and erosion [37], hydrocarbon contamination can
phases is altered because the chemicals change its also affect the physio-chemical characteristic of a
mechanical properties [30, 31], and cases of sand [38]. Sharma and Reddy [30] concluded that
geotechnical failure due to changes in the the intrinsic permeability (k) of contaminated sand
mechanical properties of sand [32] have been increases when there is an increase in density and
reported. These failures occur because sand contains decrease in the viscosity of the fluid filling the voids.
different materials (organic and inorganic), and the This clearly indicates the significant effect that the
nature of each single particle is derived from the density and viscosity of oil contamination have on
minerals which are in turn affected by the original the permeability of sand. Furthermore, the
rock from which the particle has eroded. Unlike aggregation of fine particles and fusion of minerals
rock, sand is not a solid or cemented material may reduce the stability of the sand-organic matter
because the individual particles have not bonded aggregate.
together, instead it is considered to be a skeleton of
sand grains in frictional contact with each other [33]. Oil contamination can adversely affect the plant and
A further explanation was given by Murthy [34] contaminate ground water resources used for
who stated that sand is a natural aggregate of mineral drinking or agricultural purposes [1]. Rahman et al.
grains with or without organic constituents that can [39] also showed that not only is the ecosystem
be separated by gentle mechanical means. Its affected by the spillage of crude oil, so too is the
mechanical properties such as permeability, safety of civil engineering structures. Thus, it is not
compressibility, shrinkage, swelling, and shear safe to construct buildings on contaminated sand
strength are based on an interaction of the three because any changes in the engineering properties
phases of sand [30]. The solid phase is the and behavior of the layers of sand may affect the
framework surrounded by a pore space that is shared bearing capacity and differential settlement of the
foundations [40]. This demonstrates the need for a
1617
Int. J. of GEOMATE, Feb., 2016, Vol. 10, No. 1 (Sl. No. 19), pp. 1615-1622
detailed understating on the effect of oil contamination also adversely affects the physical
contamination on the physical and mechanical and mechanical properties of sand. These issues
properties of oil contaminated sand. have made the assessment and remediation of
contaminated sites very significant. In the next
3.3 Properties of oil contaminated sand section, the existing remediation methods are
presented and their advantages and disadvantages
Several studies have been carried out to gain a better are carefully evaluated.
knowledge of the mechanical properties of oil
contaminated sand. In 1992, Evgin and Das [41] 4. REMEDIATION METHODS
used a triaxial test to investigate clean and There are many limitations on the disposal of oil
contaminated quartz sand, and concluded that full contaminated sand. Equally, the remediation of sand
saturation with motor oil significantly reduced its contaminated with oil is complicated, takes a long
frictional angle. A similar investigation was time, very expensive process and needs to comply
conducted by Al-sanad and Ismael [42] using direct with stringent environmental legislations. Over the
shear, and tri-axial and consolidation tests to past decade, the awareness of contaminated sites has
determine how age affected the mechanical increased, especially where public water supplies
properties of sand contaminated by up to a rely on ground water, while contaminated sand has
maximum percentage of 6% by weight. They found also become a societal issue because it causes
that the strength and stiffness of oil contaminated adverse health and environmental problems.
sand increased due to ageing, while the amount of
oil actually decreased due to evaporation. The same The extensive seepage and contamination caused by
authors also investigated the strength, crude oil spills is based on the properties of the sand
compressibility, and compaction of soil [12] because contaminated sand would need major
contaminated with 3 to 6% of crude oil and remediation and/or reclamation to make it suitable
concluded that the compaction and California for any future use. Research studies have resulted in
Bearing Ratio (CBR) values improved when the several technical methods which could remediate
amount of oil was up to 4% by weight. However, these problems, but they do have advantages and
there was no significant reduction in permeability disadvantages [46, 47].
and strength and the friction angle had only
decreased by 2º whereas the compressibility The cost of alternative remediation methods as
increased and the strength parameters were affected described by US EPA-(1997) varies from 50 - 1000
more by heavy crude oil than light crude oil [14]. (US $ per ton). Figure (3) indicates that the cost
The effect of temperature on the strength, depends on the remediation technique and the
permeability, and compressibility of sand concentration of contaminants. The most expensive
contaminated with heavy and medium crude oil was methods are Incineration and Vitrification and they
also investigated by Aiban [43]. He concluded that vary between ($280-1000) and ($100-1000)
the compressibility increased as the temperature respectively, while the cheapest methods were soil
increased, and the shear strength parameters were washing and solvent extraction at ($60-230) per ton.
not sensitive to the testing temperature.
1200
The mechanical properties of clayey and sandy soils
1000
were investigated by Khamehchiyan et al. [10] and
they concluded that their strength, permeability, 800
Cost US $
1618
Int. J. of GEOMATE, Feb., 2016, Vol. 10, No. 1 (Sl. No. 19), pp. 1615-1622
In every instance a clean -up requires knowledge of Some studies have been carried out to determine the
the mechanical properties of the contaminated sand beneficial use of contaminated sand in construction.
in order to select the best remediation method in Mindess and Young [55] indicated that the potential
terms of cost and efficiency. Several methods were of sand contaminated with petroleum for use in road
addressed, as mentioned above, but they not and highway construction was good. Similarly, the
considered to be cost effective [6], especially in possibility of an end-use scenario of contaminated
developing countries where none of these methods sand based on their retained compressive strength is
are available, which means the cost would be high. For instance, lesser strength is required for
prohibitive. Eagle et al. [49] presented the capital landfill but a higher compressive strength is required
cost of the cheapest remediation method, i.e. soil to make bricks or some other structural objectives.
washing, where the soil washing plant used attrition, Based on the United States Environmental
screening, and wet classification and where Protection Agency (USEPA) guidelines, the
remediation took 23 months. This cost would be recommended compressive strength at 28 days for
magnified in developing countries where none of the landfill disposal material is 0.35 MPa and 1.0 MPa
above mentioned remediation methods are available. in France and the Netherlands [56] respectively,
On this basis, there is a definite need to find a better whereas a higher compressive strength of 3.5 MPa in
and more cost-effective way of utilizing oil a sanitary landfill is required according to
contaminated sand. One possible approach is to mix Wastewater Technology Centre (WTC), Canada
it with cement and then use it in the construction [57]. Nevertheless, based on the British standard for
industry. This method however requires an precast concrete masonry units (BSI, 1981) a higher
understanding on how the mechanical property of compressive strength of 2.8 and 7 MPa, respectively
concrete is affected by the oil contamination to assist is required for blocks and bricks, and a minimum of
the engineer in evaluating the suitability of this 7 days cube compressive strength between 4.5 and
material in engineering and construction. 15 MPa are required for sub base and base materials,
by the Department of Transport in UK. This shows
there is a high potential for using oil-contaminated
5. ENGINEERING APPLICATIONS OF OIL sand in construction, but an understanding of the
CONTAMINATED SAND details of its physical and mechanical properties is
important, in order determine the end-use
application of oil contaminated sand.
5.1 Stabilization with cement
Several researchers [4, 50-53] mixed the oil
contaminated sand with cement and investigated the 6. CONCLUSION
properties of the produce mortar and concrete.
The main source of, and the advantages and
Wasiu et al [4] investigated the effects of crude oil
disadvantages of the existing remediation methods
on the compressive strength of concrete, and they
for oil contaminated sand are presented in this paper.
concluded that 18 to 90% of the compressive
Similarly, the effect of crude oil on the mechanical
strength was lost due to 2.5 to 25% contamination
properties of sand and its concrete were reviewed.
with crude oil. Abdul-Ahad and Muhamed [52]
Emerging engineering applications of oil
made a similar observation and indicated there was a
contaminated sand are also presented. From this
significant reduction in the compressive strength and
review the following conclusions can be drawn:
about an 11% reduction in the splitting-tensile
• Oil leakage and oily wastewater are the main
strength of concrete soaked in crude oil. Moreover,
sources of oil-contaminated sand, which severely
the effect of used engine oil on the structural
impacts the environment and the mechanical
behavior of reinforcement concrete [54], and the
properties of the surrounding sand.
effect of used engine oil on the properties of fresh
and hardened concrete were investigated. It was • Oil contamination have an adverse effects on the
concluded that the oil acted as a chemical plasticizer physical and mechanical properties of oil
that improves its fluidity and doubles the slump of contaminated sand and its concrete. However, at
the concrete mix while maintaining its compressive a certain level of contamination, some important
strength [53]. A similar study was conducted by properties were enhanced.
Mindess and Young [55] and they concluded that • The existing remediation methods are into
adding engine oil to a fresh concrete mix could be expensive for producing but developing
similar to adding an air-entraining chemical countries. Thus, an alternative but cost effective
admixture, which enhances some of the durability method is to mix oil contaminated sand with
properties of the concrete. cement and use it in construction.
• The properties of oil contaminated sand and its
5.2 Construction application concrete were found to be suitable for some
engineering applications including road and
1619
Int. J. of GEOMATE, Feb., 2016, Vol. 10, No. 1 (Sl. No. 19), pp. 1615-1622
highway construction, landfill disposal material [10] K. Mashalah, H. C. Amir, and T. Majid,
and precast masonry units. "Effects of crude oil contamination on
geotechnical properties of clayey and sandy
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS soils," Engineering Geology, vol. 89, pp.
220-229, 2007.
The scholarship provided by the Libyan Government [11] N. Nudelman, S. Ríos, and O. Katusich,
to Rajab Abousnina is gratefully acknowledged. "Organic co-solvent effect on the
estimation of the equilibrium aqueous
REFERENCES concentrations of oil residuals in
Patagonian soil," Environmental
[1] Z. A. Rahman, U. Hamzah, M. R. Taha, N. technology, vol. 23, pp. 961-970, 2002.
S. Ithnain, and N. Ahmad, "Influence of oil [12] P. Fine, E. Graber, and B. Yaron, "Soil
contamination on geotechnical properties of interactions with petroleum hydrocarbons:
basaltic residual soil," American journal of abiotic processes," Soil Technology, vol.
applied sciences, vol. 7, p. 954, 2010. 10, pp. 133-153, 1997.
[2] A. W. Hosmer, C. E. Stanton, and J. L. [13] H. R. Abdolhamid, M. A. s. Al-baghdadi,
Beane, "Intent to Spill: Environmental and A. K. E. Hinshiri, "Evaluation of bio-
effects of Oil Spills Caused by War, surfactants enhancement on bioremediation
Terrorism, Vandalism, and Theft," in process efficiency for crude oil
International Oil Spill Conference, 1997, contaminated soil at oilfield: Strategic
pp. 157-163. study," Ann. Chem, vol. 20, pp. 25-30,
[3] E. Khosravi, H. Ghasemzadeh, M. R. 2009.
Sabour, and H. Yazdani, "Geotechnical [14] H. Al-Sanad, W. Eid, and N. Ismael,
Properties of Gas Oil-Contaminated "Geotechnical Properties of Oil-
Kaolinite," Engineering Geology, 2013. Contaminated Kuwaiti Sand," Journal of
[4] W. O. Ajagbe, O. S. Omokehinde, G. A. Geotechnical Engineering, vol. 121, pp.
Alade, and O. A. Agbede, "Effect of Crude 407-412, 1995.
Oil Impacted Sand on compressive strength [15] K. Mashalah, H. C. Amir, and T. Majid,
of concrete," Construction and Building "The effects of crude oil contamination on
Materials, vol. 26, pp. 9-12, 2012. geotechnical properties of Bushehr coastal
[5] J. A. Veil, M. G. Puder, D. Elcock, and R. soils in Iran," IAEG, p. 6, 2006.
J. Redweik Jr, "A white paper describing [16] T. F. S. B. Products, "Strorage Tank Fire
produced water from production of crude Protection-Leave Nothing to Chance,"
oil, natural gas, and coal bed methane," 2008.
prepared by Argonne National Laboratory [17] M. E. E. Survey, "Ras Lanuf Extinguished
for the US Department of Energy, National After Seven Days," Middle east economic
Energy Technology Laboratory, January. survey, vol. 51, p. 34, 2008.
Available at http://www. ead. anl. [18] Halliburton. (2010, 19/09). Halliburton,
gov/pub/dsp_detail. cfm, 2004. Water management [online]. Available
[6] R. Riser, "Remediation of petroleum from. Available:
contaminated soils: biological, physical & http://www.halliburton.com/ps/default.aspx
chemical processes," ed: United States: ?navid=1787&pageid=4051
Lewis Publisher, 1998. [19] Ray James P. and Englehardt F. Rainer.,
[7] J. Virkutyte, M. Sillanpää, and P. Produced Water:
Latostenmaa, "Electrokinetic soil Technological/Environmental Issue and
remediation — critical overview," Science Solutions.: In: Environ. Sci. Res, 1993.
of The Total Environment, vol. 289, pp. 97- [20] Z. Khatib and P. Verbeek, "Water to value -
121, 4/22/ 2002. Produced water management for
[8] A. T. Yeung and Y.-Y. Gu, "A review on sustainable field development of mature
techniques to enhance electrochemical and green fields," Journal of Petroleum
remediation of contaminated soils," Journal Technology, vol. 55, pp. 26-28, 2003.
of Hazardous Materials, vol. 195, pp. 11- [21] Scurtu Ciprian Teodor, "Treatment of
29, 11/15/ 2011. produced water:targeting dissolved
[9] A. A. Al-Rawas, A. W. Hago, and H. Al- compounds to meet a zero harmful
Sarmi, "Effect of lime, cement and Sarooj discharge in oil and gas production," PhD,
(artificial pozzolan) on the swelling Norwegian University of Science and
potential of an expansive soil from Oman," Technology, 2009.
Building and Environment, vol. 40, pp. [22] A. Fakhru’l-Razi, A. Pendashteh, L. C.
681-687, 5// 2005. Abdullah, D. R. A. Biak, S. S. Madaeni,
1620
Int. J. of GEOMATE, Feb., 2016, Vol. 10, No. 1 (Sl. No. 19), pp. 1615-1622
1621
Int. J. of GEOMATE, Feb., 2016, Vol. 10, No. 1 (Sl. No. 19), pp. 1615-1622
1622