You are on page 1of 141

!

" # $

$ #%

&" ' ())*


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

! "
# $! ! "
% $! !
& ! !!
& ! %
! %
" # ! %
% & ! ! %"
% ! ! %"
% & ' %"
% %( %)
% $! ! %*
% ! )
%%+ ! ! ! *
%% ( ,
%%% $! ! !
& ! ! )
- $! !
. $! !
!
%+ ! ! *
%( $! ! "%
% / '0 $! ! "%
%%# $! ! "
&! ! $ !' "1
( )
& ! )
2 ! )
! ! )"
%+ ! ! *
& ! ! !' ! **
%3 ! ,
% & ! ,
%%& ! ! !
% ! %,
% ! %,
% %+ ! ! %
" - ! %

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 1


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

" - ! %
"%4 ! %)
1 3 ! !
3 ! )
! *

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 2


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

# 5 !! ! 6!
6 ! 6 ! ' ' ' 7 # ! '
'! ! ! ' !8 '
! 6 ' !! 9 !

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 3


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

: $;! ! ' ! $ ! ! ! ;!
! $ $ !! ! $

'! 7 ' 6 ' ! 6 ! !


!$! '! ' 6 !! $! !

'! ! ' 2 6 ' 7


! ! ! <= '! ! ! !$! ! '
! ! 9 ! ' ! ' ! 4 $ '
! ! !!! ' ! !!8 !8 ! 8 2 !8 3 !
' ! ! ! ! ! ! !8 !8 ! ! '
' ! 6

! ! ' ' 8 ' ! $ !


5 ! ' 6 !

- ' ! $ ! ' $! ! 6
! /23 ! & ' ! !8 ! ! ' 6
' ' ! !! ' $ ' ! 6 $! ! !!

( ! ! ' ' ! ' ' ! /'


! /23 8 /23 %8 /23 1 /23 )8 ' ! '

' !!8 ! $> ! + %,,, . *


! ' ! !> !

# ! !8 !8 !! ! ! !
$2 ? $ 3 8 -

< $ '! 7 ' 6 !' ' ! ! ! $! ! !


! ! 6 ' 6 ! ' ' ! !
! 6 '

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 4


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

+ ! @
' ( ! ! '
4 @3 @% 8 !! @ !
@ ,, !
A !!
/< ,, 6 ! !
+ ! $ !@ B C
B!C
D ' B C% E:F
C! $ 6 ' $ ",E+
& ! & 4 !
3
C , )G% 4+ C%,4+
%F
C,% G C 14+
C,) G C 4+
B
C C , %4+
B

$ C ,,4+
C %", )14+
& ! !
- C B G-
#'
- C ' ! ! !
B C ! $ !
C !
C " 6 !
!
4 @H

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 5


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

' ! > /23 8 ** % $A


!! 5 8 8 !
- % ' ! ' $A
%
0 C, % E:F
? C ,E:
!
# !! I/23 8 ** J
"# !
# !! 5 ! ' !
# C0 3 I> J I3 J
#' 0 C !!
%
C KF% . I 1 J
KC ! $I ! ' 6 ! 6 J L %,,, I4 J
KC, * E F
. C 6 $
. C 3 3 3 .
C G G G%% F!
%
0 C KF% . C, G , * E F G%%% C%%1 ):F %

3 C !! ' ! ' ' !!8 '$


' ' 6 ' ' ! ! !

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 6


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

% 1 G ./
3 I>J C I- J G I- J G
I- J G I- J
#' E C
- - ' ' ! ' ! ! 6 ' ! $ '
6 ' ' !
E C,%
3 I> JC ' !!
CE I>F>,J H MH
3 I> JC3 IH J HNH
H, ! ' ' !! 'I % ) J
H ! ' ' '
H C " 8 H, C I % ) J
HC ' ' ' ' 6
HC " *
-
3 IH JCE G C,% G I "* F J
-
3 IH C , "1*
3 I> JC ! ' '$ I ) J ! $ '$
>
3 I> JC , "1*% G %GO =I1G , % FI "1* G JJPC ",%
3 ! ' 5 !! 6 5 /23 8 ** I %
' !J
' !' 6 > ! ! !'
$ ! ! %%
,)

Q
%"
")
A
,)

- < - %"

" "

%"

# C,,

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 7


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

' ' H C'C " *


C C%"
% % %
-C " * AC %, ) QC"1 "
% %
<C ) C%, )

- ' ' 5 !! ! 6 /23 8 **


# ! I J
,
+ C '
,
( ! RC
%
S , 3 C3 , I/23 8 ** % J

H UC,,
+ ' - < A Q

3 8 , 3 8 , 3 8 , 3 8 3 8
, ,
,* ,) , , ,

,% ,% ,% V V

$& ! ! ' ( )%%

F C 1 -

A
1
<

1 <
A
TC*,,

-
F C 1

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 8


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

F ,C, ") % 1%

C" )
C C" ) C" )
%'C )%

%
-C "
%
<C "
%
AC*% )
%
C "

"#

+ ' H U C *,,

- < A
3 8 , 3 8 3 8 , 3 8 3 8 , 3 8 ,

,
%, %, ," ,

# C 0 3 I>J
C %%1 )G ",% 3
%
C , " 3 E:F
(
C ) 01 $ .23

%
3 C 3 8 N
% %
3 C3 =I3 ,@3 J , N N ,
%
3 C3 , W N ,
' ' 5 !! '> !

'(%%
H - C , " G , *C , %)E:F %
C , " G, % C , ,1 E:F %
H < C , " G , ) C , %*% E:F %
C, " G, % C , ,1 E:F %
H A C, " G , C , ,* E:F %
C , " G, % C , ,1 E:F %
H Q C , " G , C , " E:F %

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 9


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

%
H C, " G C , " E:F

& '()%%
3 -
3 C3 = I3 , @ 3 J ,
"
C %= I =%J
C *"
- < C *"
- AC , "%

%
H -C , " G *" C , 1 E:F
%
H <C , " G *" C , 1 E:F
%
H AC , " G , "% C , %%" E:F
%
H C , " G , C , ) E:F

!
# C 0 3 I> J 3
#' 3 ! ' !! 5 /23 ** I
% *J
- ! ! ' ! ! ' 5 6 !
3 C,) 3 C ,
' ' '
&
# C, " G, ) C % &)& *+
&
# C, " G , C $% ,& *+

!
3 5 !! !
X > - < ! % C % - . *+ & /$0 1
X > -8A < ! C% %-2 *+ & /30 1
&
: 6 !! C , 1 , %*% ($ %%4 *+
&
: =6 !! C , ,1 =, )% ( % &55 *+

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 10


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

' ! 6 ! !'

-
F C, "1

< A

F C, "1
F ,C, %1 ,)

C% 1

C Y C% 18 %'C%I *JC ) Z
C% 1
!
-C "1 G %1C )% % <C G %1C " %
%
AC ,)G% 1C% * " C% 1G C

/5 !! !
- < A
' 3 , 3 3 , 3 3 , 3 3 ,
6 ! ) % % % ,1 % [, %

3 I>J ' !!
3 I>JCE I>F>,J > NH
H ! ' ' !! ' >,C I/23 8 ** % ) J
H ! ' ' ' C "
HC ' ' ' ' 6

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 11


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

HC *
3 I>JCE I>F>,J
C, % G I *F JC, 1,1
3 I>J ! '$ I ) J
3 I>JC '$ >
% %
3 IH JC, 1,1 G GI =I1G, % JFI, 1,1G JJ
C "))
# C 0 3 I>J
C%%1 ):F % I "))J3
C ) 3 :F %
' ' 5 !! '> !
H -C3 C %
H <C3 C %
% %
H AC3 C3 =I3 ,@3 J , N N ,
C %
H - C , ) G % C , )" E:F %
H < C , ) G % C , 1") E:F %
H AC, ) G %C , E:F %
H C , ) G % C , 1") E:F %
!
# C , ) G, )C, ,1%
# C , ) G , C, *%
!
X ! > -C , *"E:F %
X ! > C, ,11 E:F %
&
: 6 !! C , *" @ , ,1%C$ &4- *+
&
: =6 !! C, ,11 = , *%C % &4) *+

6
2$ ' !! ! 7 *8 9 : :9 : "
"9 " ; 8 ;8 9 * 8 * ;8 " ;""9 ;8< *= 7I > !
! $J ' 6 ! /< ,, ' ' !! ,
' !! !

' /< ,,
! !
D! /< ,, ' !! , ' 6 ! ' C E F ,, E:F
' ' ! 6 $ ' ' !'
CI, , E:F JF, )%
&(C, , )%E:F % I J

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 12


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

' ((C, % E:F %


$ ! /30 1
% %
#(C, % E:F G ! C, % " E:F
(
+C &( = "(( = #(
+C I, , )%J = "I, % J = , % " C, "*" E:F %
'! ' !! /< ' ! !
C -5
$& /$0 1 / 1
+ C I, , )%J = "I, % J @ ,," !
C , %% E:F %
- '! ! %
8 -5

; / 1
' ! ' ! ! !

$ 9 390 9 / 1
%,
,
) !

\ ,

%,

!! , ' ' !' 6 ' C, ,%,


+ C , , ) ! G % = E: ! G
C , , E:F = , *""E:
# ' 6 $ ! ! ' 6 ' /< !' #
' ' ' ' ! ! ! ! $ ! ' '
!!
$& 9 390 9 / 1
+ C, , ) ! =,% G G ! C , , "E:F = , % E:F
$2 9 3 9

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 13


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

%
+ I=6 J C,, "E:F = , % E:F G
C, , "E:F = , % E:F
%
+ I 6 J C , , "E:F @ ,,"E:F G
C , , "E:F @ ,,"E:F

- !
, *""E:

, , 1 E:F

C, , * E: E: % C ,1))E:
- ! % C, % * % C, *)
- ! I=6 J C , % ) % C, "
I 6 J C , "" % C
# ' 6 ! ! $ 6
,)@
% @ 8 /23 8 %8 8 **

&
' $! ! ! '
! ' ! ' ' +
$! ! $ ' ! ! ! $ ' ! ' ' ' !
! ' /< !' $ '! ' ! '
! ' 6 ' !8 ' E: !
' ' ! ' 0 !

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 14


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

( 3 '
3X42 C I&(J = I&( J = (( &( C
3X42 % C I&( = ((&J = &(+ &(+ C
3X42 C I&( = #(=J = &(+ (( C 6
3X42 C I&( = #( J = &(+ #(=C =6
#( C 6

+ ! I 5 ! J
3X42 C 1 "1
& C %1
2 C) "
3X42 % C)
& C *
2 C)%
3X42 C 1
& ! C 1* & !! C 1
2 C1
3 !
C )
& ! C ** & !! C *
2 C)%

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 15


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

2
' !! ! ! ' ! ' ' !! !

$ !
0 !
C , )* E: 5C
, % E:
$C , )"E:
% 5C , "E:
% $C 1%E:
* 0 / 1!
C E: 5C
, * E:
$C * E:
% 5C )%E:
% $C " 1)E:
$& 9 0 / 1
C ,* E: % C % )E:
$2
G"=
C "1E: % C, E:
G6
C, E: % C , E:
C, =, C," E:

9
3X42 8 % &( = , ) #(=
3X42 @ %8 % &( = ((
3X42 @ 8 % &( = #(

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 16


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

: <$ ' 5 C , *" E:


4 5 ! C " % E:
& 5 C , E:
4 5 ! C % " E:
2 ' 5 C , %E:
4 5 ! C E:

: < $& ' 5 C , %% E:


4 5 ! C 1 E:
& 5 C ) E:
4 5 ! C %1 E:
2 ' 5 C ,*E:
4 5 ! C , " E:

: < $2 ' 5 C "" E:


4 5 ! C %% 1)E:
& 5 C% E:
4 5 ! C * E:
2 ' 5 C %% " E:

# ( && -, *
( & .4 *
< ( &% %) *
6 ( 2 ,, *

# ( && -, *
( &5 .2 *
< ( &% %) *
6 ( 4 )) *

" =* : ; 8 " <"


4 - , -$C %1 4+
- C , 4+

& ! ! :! C % " E:

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 17


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

: C% E:
& ! ! ' '

,
C $F% %" $C , "
RC," F R C %) ", R $

C] = " C %)
! ! !! ' ! !

: C ^_ $
B4 ' _ C
- !!
^ ! ' 6
!! ' ^C,
% C , G G G%1 G , F
%
C%
! ! , ' C

" ; :* 9 6 :6" ; "


AC ,
C ,
, C
%
C ,
5C >C
# 5C >C%
, 5 C >C ,)

> #$
%
F M *, /
% F C ) M *,G, *%%C 1" 1
' ! ! ! !! ⇒_ C

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 18


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

& `
` C )"
`5C `>C F C %)F, , ,) C ) %
` 5C ` >C I ) %F)" J G F% C 1%
! 6 8 5C,
' :8
* ? ( &4 4. * @ * ( &5 .2 * ⇒: A
> X ! ! :! C % "E:
! ! C !!

: 8 C $F B4,C , G , %G%1 G ,":F %F C1 % E:


: 8 C, * $F B4%C, *G , G , %G%1 G ,":F %F % C * *E:
* (&5 .2 *B * ? (5) 5) * ⇒ : A
' ' ! ! $ ' ! !! !

6
& ! ! :! C )) E: : C " ** E:

>
! ! ' !!
: 8 C, * $F B4% ⇒ C: 8 B4 F, * C ))G , G % F, *G%1
%
C1,
! ! C !!

( ;! !! !0 ! % ' ' ! !
&
(% )2
.
#(% ,,
2
&5 (% -
(% )-
!(% )-
&5 C
' ! $ ' ! !!
`M ), ⇒ F M ),
⇒ S* , F ), C , " C , "
⇒ C, , "
- S, , " !> % G%
$C, *1
%
C,*

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 19


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

% %
⇒,* L,1
' ' : 8 : 8

>
:! C" **E:
C,* ' 6 !
F M*,/ % F M*,G, *% ⇒ % M)% ) XEa
' ' !! ! ! !! ' ! ' !_ C
& `
` C )"
`5C `>C F C* ,F*1 C* )
` 5C ` >C I* ) F)" J G F% C, ,*
A ! 6 3 ' 6 '
5C% 1) ' ! !!
: C ^_ $ C % 1) G G* G%1 F C " 1 E:LL" **E:
B4

!
:! C%% 1)E: ! - , $C%1
& ' (C 1
! $ !! 6 5C, )
%
: C ^_ $ %% 1)C, )G G G%1 F C *
B4
! ! , ' !! ! !
C%
C% 1%
, C

,
3 !! 5 !
F M *, /%
% F% C % % M *,G, *%%C 1" 1
' ' !! ! ! !! ' ! ' !_ C
& `
` C )"
`5C `>C F C 1G ,%F C ,

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 20


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

` 5C ` >C I , F)" J G F% C %
A ! 6 3 ' 6 '
5C, ) ' ! !!
: C ^_ $ C, )G G% G%1 F C % % E: L%% 1) XEa
B4
.
C" : ;"* :*
: 8 C, * $F B4% C, *G% G%1 GF % C.& 2- * D&& -, * : A
' ! , ' ' !! % ' !

;
:! C) E: ! - , $C%1
& ' (C,
! $ !! 6 5C,
%
: C ^_ $ ) C, G G G%1 F C1% "
B4
! ! %, ' ' !! C
%
C, 1
C, 1
%, C, 11
C %
%,
3 !! 5!
F M *, /%
1F % C 1 M *,G, *%%C 1" 1
' ' !! ! ! !! ' ! ' !_ C
& `
` C )"
`5C `>C F C, G ,%F, 11 C %
` 5C ` >C I % F)" J G F% C, " "
A ! 6 3 ' 6 '
5C, 11 1 ' ! !!
: C ^_ $ C , 11 1G G1 G%1 F C . 4 * D, . * : A
B4
<
:! C) % E:I ! J ! %, ' ' !! C
C, 1
C, 1

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 21


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

C, 11
: 8 C, * $F B4% C, *G1 G%1 F % C E:L) % E: XEa

" =* ; :* : ;C" =:* 9 " <"


:! C **E:
: C *E:
4 b) 8 ,, $C%", )
3' ! ' !! ! !
3' !! !!

c)

' @ ! C %)* *
!! ' !! ' ! ! !
!! %⇒_ C
! !! I`J

` C* *dC* *G, *%C)"


]
`5C `$C F 8 C I F J8 Ce&%F CeG, )%F C, , %

Ce F C, ,%
C ]I, ,%F, , JC, ** , %
`5C `$C%) * F, % C
F%
` CO F)" PG _ C "1
! 6 3 8 ^ C, %""1
!!

%
: C ^_ $ C, %"11G, , G , G%", )1G ,":F %

B4
: C * E: L : C *E: XE a
3' ! $ 8:! C **E:
C !!
%
: 8 C $ C, , G , G%", )1G ,":F %

B4

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 22


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

C
* E: L **E: XEa
: 8 C , * G $ C , *G, , G , %G%", )1G ,":F %

B4% %
C* E: L ** E: XEa
' ! $ ' ! !! 6
5
- ' ! ! ' 5 ! 6 !! ' ! !! ! $
$ ' ' ' !
: ! 6 !! C , %"* E:

3' 0 6 ! ! 2 ;! 0
/0 6 !
F C *F C , 1) L , %
C%F OI% = JG FI = JP C 1*

1* C Y GI @ J Z
"GI = J
C % ** % "

&4

O- /23 % ** % P !

C O, = , "G $ P C, ) G%",,F% C ,) %
,, _
- C,) G " ,C " )1
%
D! '! ! 6 '8 &C = = C " )1 = = C " )1
D! &C ,
9 E$
- ' 6 $ ,,, C

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 23


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

C * ) E:F
+C G* ) C * , E:
&! C * , E: C ,) E:F %
%
%,
' ! C , G % E:F C " E:F %
(6 C, E:F %
# C, %"* E:F %
+ C % &(= (( = , )#( C % G1 ") =, = , )G %"*
+ C , E:F %

- !

$F 5C )
! C)
R5 C, ,*%%
R$!C , , )
R$ C , ,

4 C R G+ G 5%
4$! C, , ) G , G% 1%C " E:
4$ C, , G , G% 1% C E:
45 C , ,*%%G , G% 1% C " ) E:
4 6 ! ! 8 C % E:F
%
4C , G C % G " f%G, C1 ,** E:
4 7 !

4 ! !
1 ,* %, *" % "

%
! CK G G C , ,,%G ,,,G ,C%",
%
! N ! ⇒ ! ! C%",
C ,,,G , C * "
%",
D! b) F *,

' '

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 24


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

& ! ! % ! ' ! ! ' ' 6 ! ! ! b) F


*,

45 2)

& ! ! :! C%% 1)E:


: C%% 1E:
' ! ! '
, '% ' !!
- C ,
! , 8(! 6 C ,
! ! C ,
C, 1,1 , 1,1G , C1 ,1
! ! $C%1,4
C ,4
- 8 C6 8
6 8 C, " $F ," F
' - 8 C ! ! ' ' , '
6 8 C ! !' ! '
C %
6 8 C, " G%1,4 F % C " ,)4 ," F
- 8 C " ,) :F %G1 ,1 C*"% ,) :F
2 :! F%- 8 C%% 1)G ,f :F%G*"% ,) :F C )
' 6 (!C , L' (!C )
! ' ' (!C , ! ! '- , ' !!
% ! ! '! ' 7 !! ' ! ! !! ' ' !

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 25


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

& " =* : 9 <


& $ :9 9 < " =*

&
' 6 ' 0 $ ! '
I/23 %W ** % J

& S I, =, " $ J (
,, _
#' $ C ! ' ' ! !! ' '
( C ! ' 6 ! ! ' !' !
g C ! ' !

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 26


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

($F(5 C
(5 C ,,,
($ C ,,,
_ C

S I, =, "G ,,J ,,, C*


,,
6 .

(5 C ,,,
($ C ,,,
($F(5 C
_ C ,
S I, =, "G ,,J ,,, C ," %
6 , ,, ,

($F(5 C F " C ,

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 27


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

_ C %
S I, =, "G ,,J " , C " ))
,, %

C h i&% C , GiG )% C "1 %

_ C %

/0 6

S I, =, "G ,,J , C ,) 1
,, %
3 ' 6 ! S " ))
X6 ' & C " )) = , = C ))
8 ( 5%
' C ,@ ,@ C %

- ! ! ! !
& & 9
D ' 6 @ " E:F
3 @ % E:F
>> % E:F

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 28


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

3 % E:F
& 6 C " G, ,,) C , %) E:F %
%
3 ! C % G, , C , "* E:F
>> C % G, ,% C , " E:F %
! C % G, C " E:F %
! C % G, , C , "* E:F %
C 8% E:F %

&( C I+.3 !'J C I, %) = , "* = " = , "* = %J E:F % C " E:F %


&(% C I >> !' C I, " = , "* = " = , "* = %J E:F % C " " E:F %

(6 I /23 ** %* % ,J
3 $& I ! !' !J C E:F %
- ! !C E:F %
2 !C E:F %
& 2
& !
' ! ! ! $! I 5 !J $ 5 I !
!J !

4 C R + (j%
#' W 4 C ' ! '
+ C ' $ !
R C ' 6 ! ! I($F(5J

(5 C !' ! '
($ C ! '

-
#' W!C!
C I! J
5C !' !
$C !

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 29


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

($F(5 C
R5! C , , * R$! C , , *
R5! C , ,%* R$ C , ,%*
%
&( C " E:F
(( C E:F %
+ C II G &( J = I "G((JJ
II G " J = I "G JJ E:F % C " %, E:F %

4 C R + (j%
%
4$! C 45! C , , *G " %, E:F GI J% C ) E:
%
4$ C 45 C , ,%*G " %, E:F GI J% C 1 E:

6 &?2 .

($F(5 C
R5! C , , % R$! C , , %
R5! C , ,% R$ C , ,%
%
&( C " E:F
(( C E:F %
+ C " %, E:F %
4$! C 45! C , , %G " %, E:F % GI J% C % *" E:
4$ C 45 C , ,% G " %, E:F % GI J% C * 1% E:

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 30


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

6 5

($F(5 C
R5! C R$! C , , *
R5! C R$ C , ,
+ C " %, E:F %
4$! C 45! C , , *G " %, E:F % GI J% C ) E:
4$ C 45 C , , G " %, E:F % GI J% C % E:
6 4

/0 6 !

( ;! 0 6
-
($F(5 C F, *, C % $!
+ C " %, E:F % G C " %, E:F
-

45! C + (5%
%

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 31


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

C " %, E:F G I,8*, J% C " " E:


%
6 -

/0 6 !
% % %
C h i& C , GiG ) C "1

/0 6
%
($G(5 C "1
%
(5 C "1 C *
)
($F(5 C )F * C % $!
+ C " %, E:F
-

45! C + (5% C " %, E:F G I * J% C 1 *)"E:


% %

6 ,

/0 6 ! 2 ! '

C%GII% = J G J
I = J
C @ I @ J
I = J
! 8 C%GII%G % = * J G * JC 1 "
I * = % J
C @ * I * @ % J C 1
I * = % J

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 32


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

($F(5 C 1F 1 " C % " L % $!


+ C " %, E:F
4$! C + (5% C " %, E:F GI 1 " J% C % ) E:
% %
6 )

/0 6
C%GII% = J G J
I = J
C @ I @ J
I = J
! 8 C%GII%G , % = % JG % JC ,
I % =, % J
C @ % I % @, % J C%*
I % =, % J
($F(5 C % * F , C%)L% $!
+ C " %, E:F
4$! C + ($% C " %, E:F GI , J% C ) ) %E:
%
6 %

(5F($ C F C% %L% $!
+ C " %, E:F
4$! C + ($% C " %, E:F GI J% C 1"E:
% %

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 33


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

/0 6

($F(5 C % F C % "% L % $!
+ C " %, E:F
4$! C + ($% C " %, E:F GI J% C )) E:
% %
6 &F 2? . 5

($F(5 C F C % L% $!
+ % C " " % E:F %
4$! C + % ($% C " " %E:F GI J% C * *) E:
% %

6 -

%
+ % C " " % E:F

4$! C + % ($% C " " %E:F GI J% C * *) E:


% %
6 ,

($F(5 C " F C % L% $!
%
&(% C " E:F
(( C E:F %

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 34


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

+ C II G &( J = I "G((JJ
II G " J = I "G JJ E:F % C " %, E:F %

- ! + C " %, E:F

4$! C + (5% C " %, E:F GI J% C % E:


) )
6
! 6 ! ' ' ,
%
+ % C " " % E:F
4$! C + ($% C " " %E:F GI , J% C ) )%E:
% %

G
2 9 9
4 C ) E:
4 C % *" E:
k4 C ) @ % *" C % )
k4 C % ) G ,,l C 1 *1l N %,l W '
4 C ) = % )" C )E:F
%
< ! 5H4

4 C " " E:
4( C ) E:
4 C ) E: W ! 6

6 H5
45 C 45 = 35 k4
C 1 = , )GI% ) J C % ) E:

6 5
45 C 45 = 35 k4
C % = , )GI% ) J C ) E:

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 35


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 36


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

7 ! ' ' 5 8 ' 5


4 5 C% ) E:

- ! ' ! ! !
C 4 C, ,) )
$ C %", )14 %C ,1
C %) 1)
K C , )/ G
I / = /$ J $
C ,,, 8 / C , ,, 8 /$ C I%", )1FI%,,G , J C , ,,
K C, )G, ,, G G, 1 C
I , ,, = , ,, J G%", )1
3' 6 '

C1* )*N % XEaa

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 37


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

4 E E! ! ! 6
* *) 1" ,) " " "% % % * I % + %
%) %) "" , " % % )* 1) I % + ,%
1 *)" *% ,* )) , % % * I % + 2%
% ) *) " )% ") % % * ,1 I % + )%
) , , " * % % ") * I % + 4%
* 1% % * , % % % % ) I % + &5%
% *" %) ) , ) )1 % % )1 I % + ,%
1" ,1 ," 1* , % % " 1 I % + 4%
)) )) ,1 1, % % )% I % + 5%
) %* ) , * ** % % 1) I % + -%
% % % )1 1 ) % % % "1 I, + &&%
)) % 1 *)% %), 1 % % 1* " I, + -%
"" %, " *" % , % % % "1 I, + &&%

:2 ' ! ' ' 3 & !

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 38


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

& &6 $
=
+ ! !
!$! ! !$! ! ! ' '
! !8 ' ' ! 7 8 !
& ! 8 ' ! ! 6 !8
' ' ! ! ! ! ! ' !
! !! ' ! ' ! ! ! !' ! ' !
! ! 3 ! 6 ' ! ' !
' 7 ! ' ! ! ! ' '
8 ' ! 8 !' !!
' !8 ' ' ' !8 ! ' !
' ! ! ! 5 ! $ ' ! ' ! !
! ! ! '
' ! ! ! ! $ $ ' ' < H '
' ! ! ! !

! ' !! ! ! ! ' A32 ! 6

%%,

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 39


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

3% C,) !! C F !
' C 4 C ,4 ! ,, $ C$ F !
%
A IA32J C E:F

$
- ! ! b , ! b) !
&& 9
1

"%

& @ ! A 2
+ ! C G, %G, ,)G% C, %**E:F
A C G, ,"*G C % " E:F
(6 C "G%G, "% C %E:F
J ( % &))3 &543&( 2 4 *+

<1

'
",
%),

%%,

"%

& @

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 40


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

+ ! G %G ,)G% C %** E:F

A 2 G ,"*G C % " E:F


3 ! ! 3
I "% G ,"=%I G, ,"JJG% C "*E:F
3 - !' !
+ C, "% G %G C, *1 E:F
+ ! C G% G, , G, "% C, " E:F
+.3 !' C G "G, ,,%G, "% C, , E:F
>> !'C G% G, ,%G, "% C, 1 E:F
(6 C G, "% G "C E:F
J ( % &))3 &543 4)3% )-53% 54 3% %.35() ,,. *+ / 6K 1
J &( % &))3 &543 4)3% )-53% 54 3% 2-.35( % 5. *+ / LL 1
&&&
%
4 5C F)C , G %F)C 1 E:
% 5. *+

' ' 0
S I = "G ,,F ,,J ,,,F%,C% %
C& bF% @ 6
C %), "F% C% 1L% % XEaaa

M = F C %,= ,,,F C %,
C"%
C "%
#
% %
KC h ]I 4FI % JJ

KC , ,, ,
C $ F G, )C%", )1F, )G C%) 1)

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 41


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

5C K C, ,, , G%) 1)G% 1C%% "


$C, )jC, )G%% "C ) , N",
' ! ! ' C C"%
4C 1 ! !
E CI]I F JJF C %1 1%
E!C ,%
%
!CE!4F C ,% G 1 F, % 1C *" )
' ! &M&%
>
!' .! C F%C , 1 G F%C% ) E:
' !' .3 $ ' ! ' ! 5 ! !'
!
.3 C , %
E E%
#' E C " C " , % 1C
E%C I = ,KJC m
C 4
. C, % G G G G %,G% 1C E:
- ! . C G C % E:
. &C, % G G G C, % G G %,G% 1C)1 E:
.!C.! . C% ) % C % ) E:
C
!! ! C ,
C%G , G%", )1GI% 1 %,JI !1% "=! 1% "JF % )
C%)* "* % ,
,
!! !C%,, "1

_C RC"1 ), %,,
C%G , G%", )1GI% 1 %,JI !"1 )=! "1 )JF % )
C 1% ""
( ;! ! b) F %,,

>

2$

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 42


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

0C "E:F n C%,,
C0Gn F% C "E:F G, % F%C, "E:
+& (% , *

9 #
!! ' 5! '5 6 ' ! I 5N ),J

4 :
! G5C !%GI% jJ
C "%)GI% 5J
1) 5 C 1 ) "%) 5
jC%,) )*
' ' $ ' !! !
%
I %,GI%,) )* %,,JC ,"" )
- !! $ ! !
%
C 4 G ,"" ) C % ,)"E:
' !! 6 ! ! ' 6 ' ! ! &
!! ' ! ! ! ' !! 6 ' '
! !! $ ' !

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 43


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

+ !
I J 4 5 ! C" E:
I%J 4 5 3 !! C * E:
I J4 5 !! C% 1%E:
4 5 ! C **E:
I J4 5 ! , E:
3 $ ' !
/23 8 **
: 8 M G $ F B4 B4 C
,* DF B4% B4% C %

' !o , ! - ,

: 8 1) G%", )1F C ) "% E:


, *G1) G ,,F % C " *" E:

: C " *"E:

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 44


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

! ' !! 5 !! ! !
: 8 C : C ^_ $ F B4
& ! 5 :! C * E:
2 ' C, %
& `
` C )* %
`5C `>C F C), _ C
` 5C ` >C I),F)* %J G F% C, )*)
! 6 8 5C, **)
' :8
:8 C "E: ! !! ' :! C *
' ' ! ! ' ! ' ! $!
! ' :! ! ; $ ' ! ! ;! ! 2 ' ! $ !
! ' ' !
3 ! ' ' (( ' ! ! ' 5 !

% %
3 ! % ' 6 ! ! 6 ' ' !

- ! + C F%GI "G, %JC, " E:


+ ;C F%I "G, %JC, "E:
- ! % +%C, "E:
3 !
' 5 ! I%JC * E:
3 !! I%J C% 1E:
& I J C % E:
! C E:
2 I J C E:
! C, 1E:
- ! %
- I%J 5 ! % 1E:
4 5 % ,%E:
- I J C %E: !

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 45


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

- I J C ,% E:
! C, 1"E:
- ' > C, E:
3 ! ' ! !
! C % 1E:
3 !! C % 1E:
: C , * G $ F B4%
C , *G1) G ,,F %
C " *"
: ! C% 1N : C " *" E:
- !! 5C, **)
: C ^_ $ F B4 C, **)G1) G%", )1F
: C 1 E:
:! C% 1N 1E: XEa
- !
4 5 ! C
4 5 !! C %
: C , * G $ F B4% C, *G , G ,,F % C , )" E:
:! C N: C , )" E: XEa

2 ' C, %"
` C )* *%
`5C `>C F C , _ C
` 5C ` >C I ,F)* *%J G F% C "
! 6 8 5C, %
: C ^_ $ F B4 C, %G , G%", )1F
: C *" E:
:! C % N *"E: C: XEa
- ' 5 3 !! ! ! 8 ' !
'
A ! o , ' ! o) ' !
p ,

p)

% p%,

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 46


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

:2 ' ! ! ! $ ! ' ! ! !

*<E ' ! ' ' 3 & !

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 47


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

2
" =* : ;
: ! ! ' C*
! !' ' C, 1
( ' ' C,
qC, 1 C%* ,
,

" % %
& ' 0
- ! 6! $ ! I/23 % 8 ** % J
C I, =, " G $ JF ,, I F_ J $ C ,, 8 _ C% I ! J
C ,,
C, ) G ,F% C "
& C " = =) C ) & C *, !
C "1
( I ! J
& ' !
3! I J C , * G G% C % E:F
3 ! %*
& ! ! ' C , G, 1G G% G C % , E:F
% ,
- - !'
>> I% J C , ,%G% C , "E:F %
3 I% J C , , G% C , "* E:F %
+ ! C% G, , C, "* E:F %
X ' C I, "=, "*JG C E:F
X ' ! C G, 1G G*F% C, 1 E:F
& ! C I % =% , = =, 1 =, "*F !%* J
C * * E:F
& '
( C , *G G% C "E:F
+ ! C , G G% C , "*E:F
3 ! C , "*G C , "*E:F
>> C% G, ,%G C , "E:F
" E:F

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 48


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

' C " E:F


(6 (
X ! $ 8 0 C E:F % I/23 %8 ** % ,J
%
6 ! ! C E:F G C E:F
& ! (
X ! 8 &( C G* * = "G C 1 1 E:F
X 8 &(% C G" = "G C % E:F

' - &

2 &

& !
! ! !
! 4 ! C 1 )"E:
E C ]I4F J C ]I 1 )"F J C %
, "1
E! C **
A
%
! C E! G 4 C ** G 1 )" C %1 %
, "1
%
! C, ,,%G ,,,G "1C

C !G C G ,,, C %" "


! %1 %

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 49


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

6
p % F %",
!6 !
!C, % !C, %G %1 %C) %
C ! G C , G ,,, C )) )
! ) %
5 %& C ),
,

D! p) F ,

C " E:
E C C ") E!C ,)1
%
!CE! F C ,)1G " F, "1 C11 ,
C C C *)
! q % F ,
&!
C, % !C )
C C C % *
! q) F %,,
& ! %
: ! ! ' C
! !' ' C% F C, "
( ' ' C,
qC, " C%) ) ,
,

* %
& ' 0
C I, =, " $ J F $ C ,, 8 C%
,, C", ,

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 50


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

CI, =, "G ,,JG", , C% %1


,, %

&C% %1= =) C % 1 %1

D! &C% ,
C% , )C% 1
( I ! J
& ' !
3! I J C , % G G% C" 1 E:F
3 ! %) )
& ! ! ' C , G, " G G% G C *)E:F
% ,
- - !'
>> I% J C , ,%G% C , "E:F %
3 I% J C , , G% C , "* E:F %
+ ! C% G, , C, "* E:F %
X ' C I, "=, "*JG C E:F
X ' ! C G, " G G F * C, ") E:F
& ! C I" 1 = *)=, ") = =, "*F !%) ) J
C 1 E:F
& '
( C , % G G% C 1"E:F
+ ! C , G G% C , "*E:F
3 ! C , "*G C , "*E:F
>> C% G, ,%G C , "E:F
1 "E:F
' C 1 "E:F
(6 (
X ! $ 8 0 C E:F % I/23 %8 ** % ,J
%
6 ! ! C E:F G C E:F
& ! (
X ! 8 &( C G 1= "G C * % E:F
X 8 &(% C G1 "= "G C ") E:F

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 51


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

' - &

2 &

& !
! ! !
! 4 ! C)% * E:
E C ]I4F J C ]I)% * F J C *1
,% 1
E! C %,*
A
%
! C E! G 4 C %,* G )% * C ",) "*
,% 1

C !G C %, G ,,, C % *
! ",) "*
6
p " F %,

!6 !
%
! C, ,,%G ,,,G% 1C
%
! C, % !C, %G ",) "*C % 1 )
%
! C
C ! G C , G ,,, C "
!
D! p) F ,
3' !'
. C,% E E%
C% , )C% 1

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 52


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

#' E C I = ,KJC 1 M % ,
E%C " C ) S , I J
- CI, I% F % Jf%F JF C , %
. C, % G , %G ) G 1G ,,,G% 1
. C ," ,1 E:
.! C " "1N ," ,1E: XEa

! !

% %

: ! ! ' C*
! ! ' ' C% F C, 1
( ' ' C,
q C , " C%* ) ,
,
& ' 0
C I, =, " $ J F $ C ,, 8 C%
,, C", ,

CI, =, "G ,,JG ,C "


,, %
&C " = =)C ) &C *,
( ! ' 6 ! ! !
X ! C 1 E:F
X C % E:F

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 53


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

'

' !
C * " E:
C *, )C "1
E C C 1 "* E!C
% %
!CE! F C G * " F, "1 C*) )% L ! C
C C C 1
! q % F ,
' ' ! ! ' ! ! 6 $
- ! ! q % F ,
!6 ! !
D! q) F ,

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 54


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

. " * 9N
. K
' ' ! ! 8 ! 8
890
/23 %8 ** I J ' ! !! $!
! ! ! !' /23 %8 **
.
' ! ! !! ' ! ! !! ! ' !
! $ ! ! $ !! !! $ ! /23 % ** )
' 0 ! 6 $ ' 8
.C 6 + (5
6 ! ! ' ! ' ! ' (5 ! '
!' ! ! '
' !! ! ' ' ! ! !' #' ' !! !
' ' ! !! ! $ 1 l ' '

6 ! ' ! $ ! ' ' ' ! 8


' 5 0 6 ' ' ! 0 6 '
5
- 5

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 55


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

-5
4- 2C 4- 2 C#G F% I (% %
J

4 C, 1 (F%G#(F% , ,1"#(%= I, 1 (F%J%G#F%


- ' 0 6 ' 6 D&( # '(

-5 4- 2C 4- 2 C # (%F %
4 C # (%F%
/0 ' 5 0
% % %
#G F% I ( J C #( F % # C,* #
/0 ' ! 0 !
,1 (F%G#(F% , ,1"#( = I, 1 (F%J%G#F% C # (%F%
%

# C, *) #
' !
C, * =, *) F%C, * *
( % ).)K
! !
! %
_65 _6$
$
(5 ($ ($F(j _65 _65& _6$ _6$& + (5 65 65& 6$
9 , " ,% , " "% %1 ") ) %1 ")
%8 8 , ,% , "% % 1 % 1
" 6 "% ,* ""
1 6 "% %
) 6 "% ) %)
* 6 "% "*
, 6 "% % )1
6 "% %% ")
% 6 "" " % 1)
8 8 6 "" " % 1)
" 6 % 1 %, %
1 6 "" " % 1)
) 6 "% 1 )%

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 56


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

O $2

O $.

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 57


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

O $

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 58


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

. & 6 $
' ! ! ! 8 ! ! 6 ! '
! ! ! ! ! !

O $

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 59


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

O $"

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 60


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

O $2

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 61


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

.&9 9
' ! !
J '0 $! !
J $! !
' $! ! ' ' !
' !
.& " J >

/23 )8 ** ! ' $! ! ! !
' ! ! ! !' - ' ! $ ' 0
- C I J#
#'
I JC ' ! ! ! 6 $
CR_B
' R ! ' ' !
6 $8 8 6 $
RCR
R, C ' ' ! !
' ! ! > ! 6 /23 )8 **
- > 8 8 R C, ,
C ' '
!! ' !' ! % ! ' ! ! ! !! !
6 ' ! 0 ! !! ' ! ! ' !8 !! $ ' !8
! ! I % 8 /23 ** J
! C %
' _ ! ' ! ! ! ' ! ! 6 $
_C % M%
%F

C! ! ' ! !8 %
C , ! ! !! I ! !8 ! ! ! ! 8 6 6 ! $
C ' 6 ' !
I J ! '
- ! '' '! ), 8 ' 6
$ 5 !
r
C3 A
AC' ' ' C *
3 C, ,1 !! !
r
C , ,1 G * C, "*

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 62


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

_C %G %C ) M% a
%F
, "*
' 8 B8 ! ' ' 6 $ !! $ 6 $
BCB & # ,1
BC ! $ ' ' 6 8
! $ I %J
!$! 8 B C, %,
&C $ !! 8 ! & C% , &3 s(t
C ' ! $ 6
! C ,
#C ' 6
!$! ' !
C , 0 6 !$! !
B C, %G% ,G ,G ,C, ,1 a
I JCR_B
C , %G ) G, C , ,))
# C! ! 8 ! '
C 24% &4
' ! !'
- C, ,)) G ", %" C ,, E:
0
' ! !' !' ! 6 ' ' ' ! 8
' 6 8
I # J4
4 + +
+ ,

#' C ! !
- C '
- C ' 5 ' '
' !' ! 8 ' ' !
6 $
- C, ,1G G- I/23 )8 ** % % J
C, ,1G, "* G ,,%E:
C ) 1E:
# 8 #7 C ' ' # !!
6 78 ! 6 $
' 8 '7 C ' ' 6 ' ! 6 78 ! 6 $

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 63


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

0 ! / *1
= 5% 5.4 -4 2 &)
5 2% &&-4 -. %5 .5
, 25 )%,& -- 42 )%
.% &4544 52 &&, ,
. .5 25 4 ) 2%& %%
- 5% &-%. 5 %) &
&% 55 24-- 42 2 5)
P % 5,

.&& 9
/23 8 ** 8 ' !! 5 ! 8# 9 ! 8
#
# C0 3 IH J3
# C0 3 IH J3

5 $ ,6
0 7 F%GKG. %
#' . C3& 3 /4+3 ( . 8X
C ,G ,G ,G%% 3
C %% 3
KC ! $
C,* E F
A 8
0 C, G, * G%%% C%%1 ):F %

8$
' ' ' ! ! '

( ! 6 '

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 64


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

"

%1 1

3 IHJC3 I>J%3 I>J%Y =1E F 3 I>J3 I>JZ

#'
H ! ' ' $! !
' '
3 !! '8 C%)
'N 8 ' ' ! ! !
$ $ 8 ! ' ' ! l ' ! ! 6 '
! ' 6 ' ' 5 ! I 8 /23 ** J
E C, %
HC
H C "
' !! 8 3 I>J

E IHF H J W H S H
3 I>J C
3 IH J W HNH

$
#'
H C " CH C "

3 I "J C 3 I "J C , % G "C, "1


$&
#' H C%,

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 65


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

3 I%, J C , % G %, C, 1%

'$
3 C 8 !! ' ! '$

' 5 ! W
$
3 I "JC3 I "J%3 I "J%Y =1E F 3 I "J3 I "JZ
C , "1%G GY =1G, % FI, "1G J Z
C 1

$&
3 I%, JC 1

8 $ , $
# >
C C %1 1 C%1 1 8 N
%'C %
' > ! /23
> 2 & /
F'C, % 3 , 3 , 3 , 3 ,
M ,) ,) ,
S ,) ," ,

& 5 !! ! !!
- \ \ :
5 3 , %, "
& ,) , % , %* , %
/ , , % , ,
& , ,% , ) , 1
/ ,) , % , %* ,

# ' 7 ! ! !! !! ' '

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 66


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

2$ ' '0 !! ! ' '0 !! 6 ! !


! ' '0 !

.2
' ' > ! ' 6 8 -8 ' 6 !
!! 6 ! ! ' ! !!
' !
J & !!
3 !! ! 6 ' ' ' !! !
! ! 0 6 !!

j C u# j Wv C u# v
u# u#

j v C ' ' - ' ' ! ! !


' v j@ ! 6 $
< XD:& -(XX
2(&:< + X (# X ( 4X4/:
#j #v
" * %1 * )1 " %) , %
%,* ,* %)*, ), " )%
"% )% % "% )1 1" "
X ( , 1 1 ,) %%* 1
j 8v , ,

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 67


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

-(XX-
2(&:< + X (# X ( 4X4/:
#j #v
1,* "* *)1" 1 %1*)
%* % * 1) ,, "
% ) , % ,* , )
! 1 * )*)" ) %,,
! " % *) *
* " "% 1
6 !' * ,1 1* 1, ,
! !' % , ,*, 1 "11 1
% " 1 %, 1 )%
j 8v 1

/3X:& -(XX
2(&:< + X (# X ( 4X4/:
#j #v
1,* "* *)1" 1 %1*)
%* % * 1) ,, "
)1 * %1 * )1" ,"
! 1 * )*)" ) %,,
! " % *) *
* " "% 1
6 !' * ,1 1* 1, ,
! !' % , ,*, 1 "11 1
%%) " ,"1* 1 )," 1

j 8v %

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 68


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

A & -(XX
2(&:< + X (# X ( 4X4/:
#5 #$
1 % 1) *"" "" %**% )
%* % * 1) ,, "
)1 * %1 * )1" ,"
! 1 % )*) " %, "
! " % *) *
* " "% 1
6 !' , %% 1 ,"
! !' % , * ) "* 1,
% , , , % " ) ,* *
j 8v , 1

-XD A -(XX
2(&:< + X (# X ( 4X4/:
#5 #$
) 1 ,* 1 *% ,", "
%* % * 1) ,, "
)1 * %1 * )1" ,"
! 1 % *, ) %,)
! " % *) *
* " "% 1
6 !' ,, "*
! !' % %) * ,) "*, )*
% , "% ) ,% 1
j 8v % *1

XX- (/./(
2(&:< + X (# X ( 4X4/:
#5 #$
% 1% 1) ), 1, )
% %% , 1 1" 1 ,
1 % *, 1) %, ,
! * 1 1* )" %*1 ,
! " % *) *

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 69


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

* " "% 1
D =/< =3A +#XX& , 11 * 1"
1% * % * ) 1
j 8v 1 %1 ""

A/ & XX4 (/./(


2(&:< + X (# X ( 4X4/:
#5 #$
% *% ), , *,
% % )) )1
! " " 1* 1 ,1 ,
! %) %" ** ,1 %,1 1,
* 1% % % ) "
1) *" )"1 " % *%
j 8v % " "

3 ! !! ! ' ' ! !! ! ' ' !


j! C u & $j W v! C u & 5v
u&$ u&5
#'
j8v C ! ' !' '
& 58 & $ C ! !! j v 5 !8 ! 6 $
' $8 & ' ! '
! !! ' !
! !! !
' '! !
!' !
! $
&C E
E C ! !!
C $ !
Q F
E ! ! ' ! ! !! ! ! 6 '
6 $ %E 8 ' 5 w ; ! ! !
C E F I%=EJ

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 70


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

' 6 5 !! ! w ; ! ! 5 ! !

C I, =EJ E C uE
I%= J E

! !

(/./( 5 ! &$ j &$j 5! &5 v &5v


< XD:& , ,,,)* , , , ,,%** , ,
2 , ,,,)* , ,, 1 , ,, )% , , *,)%
3 , ,,,)* , , ,,)* % , ,, 11 1 1 , , ,",%"*
& , ,,,)* ,, , ,, *) * , , ,1) "
/ , ,,% * %, , , 1) u , ,,)1 " , , 1%*%
- , ,,, 1" % ,, " v! %" 1%%%1
< , ,,, , % ,% , ,,% 1
A , ,,,* % , ,%%)
u , ,,1 " , %
5 , 1
- 5 ! &$ j &$j 5! &5 v &5v
, ,,, ) , , , , % 1% , ,
2 , ,,, ) , ,, * , , %*1" , ," ))%%%

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 71


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

3 , ,,, ) , , ,, ) % , ,, 1** 1 1 , , "* *


& , ,,, ) , ,, 1 , ,, *,) * ,, 1 )
/ , ,,**" %, , **% u ,, ) 1 , ", %*
- , ,,%))" % , ,"1* v! ))*"
< , ,, 1 % ,% , ,) ,
A , ,,% % % ,,
u , , *)) , 1
j! %, 1111
'
5 ! &$ j &$j 5! &5 v &5v
, ,,, ) , , , ,, 1 , ,
2 , ,,, ) , ,, * , ,, "1) , ,,) ))"
3 , ,,, ) , , ,, ) % , ,,,"% 1 1 , ,, 11,
& , ,,, ) , ,, "* , ,,," * , ,, 1,),
/ , ,, 1 %, , ,%)1 u , ,, , , , ))"1
- , ,,, "* % , ,,)"* v! )111)
< , ,,, %* % ,% , , ,
A , ,,, % % ,, ,
u , ,, *" , ,1, )
j! " 1%"%
XX- 5 ! &$ j &$j 5! &5 v &5v
, ,,,%) , , , ,, % % , ,
2 , ,,,%) , ,, , ,, %* , ,," "%
3 , ,,,%) , , ,,%) % , ,,, ) 1 1 , ,, 1% "
& , ,,,%) , ,, % , ,,, * * , ,, 1,
/ , ,, ) %, , ,% 1 u , ,, 1* , , ", ,
- , ,,, , % , ,,1 ) v! *1 ,,*
< , ,,, ") % ,% , ,,))
A , ,,, % , ,,) "
u , ,, % ,, " )
j! 1,
A XX4 5 ! &$ j &$j 5! &5 v &5v
/ , ,,,%") %, , ,, , ,,,%," , ,, , )"
< , ,,, " % ,% , ,,%) % , ,,,% 1 1 , ,, ) "*
A , ,,, " % , ,,%* , ,,, " , ,,%)11
u , ,,, , , ," u v! " ,)" )
j! %% ,*)

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 72


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

- 6 ! $ !'
? 5 C & 5 G ?8 ? 5 C & $ G ?
u &5 u &$
# #$ #

-(XX < XD:& - /3X:& A &


-X 3/ %* , 1) " % %%) %1
& & & &
j . (D/ ? . (D/ ? . (D/ ? . (D/ ?
, ,, 1 , , % " * )% , ,,% 1 , ,, 1 1* 1
, ,, % ) " ,, * 1) , ,,% " % , ,, "1) ) ,,1
% , ,, % ,*% * , ,, " "/ , %% " , ,,,"% *
, ,, % )%,%" , ,, )* 1 "/ , % , ,,," %
, ,,)1 ,, , ,, , ,, ,

-XD A XX- A/ & XX4 -(XX


,% % ,* " ", -X 3/
&
& . (D/ ? . (D/ ? & . (D/ ? j
, ,, 1 11 , ") , ,, % % ) , * 1
, ,, "111 % ,) , ,, %* , % , ,,,%," 1% " *
, ,,," * % 11 , ,,, ) 1 , ,,,% *1 " *), ) %
, ,,," % % ,* , ,,, * *1*
, ,, , % , ,, 1* , ,,, ",1%

# $ #
-(XX < XD:& - /3X:& A &
-X 3/ %*, % " , 11 1%"* " %% 1 ) %%) %1 "
& & & &
. (D/ ? . (D/ ? . (D/ ? . (D/ ?
, ,,,* 1 /, % ,% , ,,, ) )1 , ,,, ) %, "
2 , ,,,* 1 /, % ,% , ,,, ) )1 , ,,, ) %, "
3 , ,,,* 1 /, % ,% , ,,, ) )1 , ,,, ) %, "
& , ,,,* 1 /, % ,% , ,,, ) )1 , ,,, ) %, "
/ , ,,% %," % ,, % ** , ,, " % , ,, 1 1) *1
- , ,,," , %),* , ,, %* , ,,, 1 1 , ,,, "* %, ,)
< , ,,, , ),)*" , ,, 1* , , ,,, ") , ,,, %* % )
A , ,,,* ", % , ,,% * , ,,, 1 , ,,, % % ,
, ,,1" , ,% , ,, % , ,, *"

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 73


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

-XD A XX- A/ & XX4 -(XX


,% %,1%,* ,* *1** **) -X 3/
&
& . (D/ ? . (D/ ? & . (D/ ? j
, ,,, 1* %1 ," , ,,,%) * %%%1
, ,,, 1* %1 ," , ,,,%) * %%%1
, ,,, 1* %1 ," , ,,,%) * %%%1 %
, ,,, 1* %1 ," , ,,,%) * %%%1
, ,, 1%* , * * , ,, ) * , "* , ,,,%"1 1 " )** % ,
, ,,, "* %" ) ,) , ,,, , ,, ) ,
, ,,, %)* , ))11 , ,,, ") % ))) , ,,, " 1) 1 ,% ) ,
, ,,, % ) " , ,,, , 1 " , ,,, " 1) 1 ,% )
, ,, * 1 , ,, % , ,,, ,, %"

/ $ ! ' ' !! ! !! '


!
5Cj @ j!
$ C v! @ v
!
- 6 ! ! ! ! ' !! ! !
6 ! ! 8 $8 ! !
' $
! 6 $
C[,,
#' ! ' ! ' ! !

85 C =
5 5
8$ C $ = $

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 74


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

'
! ! ! ' '
5 , 1% 1 %% % " 1" ,% , *
$ , " , "% ," , "% ,1 , " ,,
5 [ % [ % [ % [ % [ % [ % [, %
$ [, [, [, [, [, [, [,

&/ <:
/33/: 3 /

'
(/./( ! ! ' '
5 *1 ) 1 " )) , , 1
5% , *1 *" % ) % " , 1"
$ ," ,1 ,* ,1 ) ,, , "
$% , %* , 1 , * , 1 , %) ,* ,

#' ' !' !! 8 ! 6 '


! '! ! ! ! ' $ ' ' 5!
! ! ! ' !' ! 6 '!
' !' ! !

R 5 C =I& 5J $ G$
Q
R $ C =I& $J 5 G5
Q

Q C Q5 = Q$ ' Q5 Cu I& 5 $ %J
Q$ 7u I& $ 5 %J
5 C j @ j!
$ Cv! @ v

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 75


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

& j v! j! &jIv &vIj R58 R$8


v j &j &v ! v J% j!J% R5 R5% R$ R$% 5 5
% ,, , , **
" , ,, ,

,1 , ,, , ,, , ** ,,
% 1 ) ,,

, ,, ,, " , ** ,,
% % ,,%

1 , ,, , ,%" , ** ,,
j % * ,,
, */ , , *)
" , ,% ) ,
,, */ ,%) , **
2 " , , ,* ) % ,%*
, */ , , **
3 1 , , ,% " ,
,, */
& 1 , ,
, ,, , *"
/ *) % , ," 1 , ,
"/ , *) ,,
- ) % , ,, % ,,
/ ,,
< * ,, , ,, , **1 ,,
*/ , *1, ,,
v A * *) , , ,* 1 ) ,,)
, ,**
% ,
Q5 Q$

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 76


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

,, % ,% ," , ,"
* % " 1 1

,) , ,,) , *) , ** , **
,, " ) )

, ,, ,, * , *1 , ** , **
% ) % ) " "

) , ,, , , *" , ** , **
j * " *
%, 11 / , ,)% , ,)
) , " ) %
11 / ,, ,"% , ,"
2 ) , *
, 11 / ,, , % ,
3 ) , 1 ,
111 / ,, ,%% , ,%
& 1 , * "
, 111 ,, ,), , ,)
/ 1 ,, 1 1
, ,, ,, ,* " ,* ,*
- % 1"% % *
, ,, ,, , ))"
< % % , *% , *%
, ,, ,, , *, ,* ,*
v A %%% % )
, * ,
* %
Q5 Q$

* , ,, " , ,%1" ,% ,, ,%

,) , ,, 1 , ,, , ** , *** , ***

% , ,,," , ,,1" , **% , *** , ***

j ) , ,,," ,, 1 , *)* , **) , **)


" 1%" /, , ,*, , ,*
v 2 1%" /, ,, ," ,%) ,"

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 77


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

3 " 1%"% /, , ,% , " , " , "


& 1%"% /, , ,,* ,, ,,*
/ %1 , ,, , ,% ,* , *1 , *1
- ") /, , ,% , *" % , *) , *)
< 1 %* /, , ,% ,* , *) , *)
A ) %1 /, ,, , * 1* , *11 , *11
,, , %"
Q5 Q$

;
4.00 4.19 0.00 0.03 1.02 1.00 1.02
3.00 -0.81 0.00 0.00 1.00 1.00 1.00
2.00 -3.51 0.00 0.01 0.99 1.00 1.00
X 1.00 -4.81 0.00 0.01 0.99 1.00 1.00
A 16.73 0.00 0.11 1.10 1.05 1.10
B 11.73 0.00 0.05 1.07 1.03 1.07
C 6.73 0.00 0.02 1.04 1.02 1.04
D 1.73 0.00 0.00 1.01 1.00 1.01
E -3.27 0.00 0.02 0.93 0.96 0.96
F -6.81 0.00 0.02 0.96 0.98 0.98
G -7.29 0.00 0.02 0.95 0.98 0.98
Y H -8.27 0.00 0.03 0.94 0.97 0.97
0.05 0.26
Jx Jy

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 78


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

4.00 4.26 0.00 0.03 1.03 1.01 1.03


3.00 -0.81 0.00 0.00 0.99 1.00 1.00
2.00 -3.51 0.00 0.01 0.99 1.00 1.00
X 1.00 -4.81 0.00 0.01 0.99 1.00 1.00
A 16.73 0.00 0.11 1.10 1.05 1.10
B 11.73 0.00 0.05 1.07 1.04 1.07
C 6.73 0.00 0.02 1.04 1.02 1.04
D 1.73 0.00 0.00 1.01 1.01 1.01
E -3.27 0.00 0.02 0.93 0.96 0.96
F -6.81 0.00 0.02 0.96 0.98 0.98
G -7.29 0.00 0.02 0.95 0.98 0.98
Y H -8.27 0.00 0.03 0.94 0.97 0.97
0.05 0.26
Jx Jy

% , ,, % , ,% , *)
,) , ,, , ,,,) ,, ,,
% , ,,, , ,, * ,," ,,"
j ) , ,,, ,, ,,* ,,*
1, /, , ,) ,%,1 , *1 ,%
2 %, /, ,, , " , *1* ,
3 1, /, ,, ,,)" , *)) ,,*
& %, /, , ,,% , **" ,,%
/ %* 1 , ,, ,, , *) ) ,% ,%
- " )1 /, ,, , ** , % , %
< " *"1 /, , ,% , *))* , " , "
v A 1* 1 /, , ,% , *)) , " , "
,, * ,%
Q5 Q$

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 79


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

, ,,, , , *"
% , ,,, ,

% , ,,, ,* , ,
j % % , ,,, " * *
% ,*) / , )1 %)
/ , , %)1 1
/ , ))
< *%% , , " , ,
/ , )%1 ,1 ,1
v A % *,% , , " "
, ,,,) ,
Q5 Q$

3 !' ! 6 $CR 5G ?

(/./( < XD:& - /3X:& A &

5! R 5G? R 5 R 5G? R 5 R 5G? R 5 R 5G?


", ,1 * % ,% ) 1" ,% )
) ,, * %* ,, " ) ,, ) *
% % , ,, ,, %% ) ,,
) ,, )% ,, % , ,, % ,)
" ,) % * ,* " %% , %% "*
2 "% ," % ," )% ,1 %% ,)
3 * , % , , % 1
& 1 ,% % ,1 , , , %, )"
/ % ,) 1 %1 , *1 "1 , *" 1 ,
- ,% ,* , *) % , *) * 1,
< , ) , *% " , , *) " ) , *) %% 1)
A "% ,* ," , *) "* , *1 % *

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 80


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

-XD A XX- A/ & XX4 (/./(

R 5 R 5G? ? R 5 R 5G? ? R 5 R 5G? 5!


, ,) %, ,, ),
,, % 1 ,, ,1 , %
,, " , %1 , 1" %
,, % ,
, , ,* ,% *
,1 %* %1 , * " 2
, %) , * , 3
, %1 "% ,, *% &
, *" ** " ,% * )* %* % 1 /
, *) %" , , , ) -
, *) , % ,% % , 1 1% <
, *1 ,* ,% %, ,) 1* A

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 81


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

" J >

O $

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 82


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

O $"

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 83


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

O $2

..9

' ! !8 !' ! 5 !
' ' 6 ' 6 ! ' ! '
3 ! 6 $
& 3 ! 1 l 6 ' '0 ! 6 j@
2 3 ! 1 l 6 ' '0 6 j@
. 3 ! 1 l 6 ' '0 ! 6 v@
5 3 ! 1 l 6 ' '0 6 v@
' ! $> ! ! %,,, 6 ! *

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 84


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

:2 ' ! ! ' ! ! !$!

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 85


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

5 " =* : <" * :98 *


5 <
2 ! 5 ! ' ' ! ! ' ! ! !
2 ! $ ! !' ! 5 I J - ' ! !! '
! ' ! ! ! !' 2 ! $ ! 5
' ' ' j ! ! ! ' ' '
' ! $ 8 $ x!

' $ 6 ! $ ! 6 $
%
4CK $ I , K J
K ! ,1 K !! $ ' ' 6 !
! ! 8 ' 0 ' 4
! 6 $
!CK
#'
%
K C F%I = I 9F % # %
J
4C
C $ F I, ) J
C 6 '

! ' ' ! ' ! ! 8 ' $ ! 7 ' '


!! ! !! ' ! ! ! ' !! > ' !
A ' ! 84 ! $
4 C 4 =4%
#' W
4C' !! $ ! !
4% C ' !! $! !! 8 !;8 ' 6 ! !%
4 6 ' ! $ !
%
4 C, )K G I , K J8 K ! ! 6
! CK ! 4%C4 4 C !; !;I ;JC !% $ I ;J
$ ' !! ! ' ! ! 0
; ; ;
!;C !%C I4 4 JF I $ I J C I4 4 JFI !;I J $ C !
!;CI5 ;J/!Gy F5 85C K

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 86


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

'!! 7 ' 6 ! ! ! ' !


' 6! /23 %8 **
5
j
(X3 X: E E pI ! J
%% % 2 ,% , ,1 ,) ," %*" ** %p %
% 2 ,% , ,1 %% * *) ! %p %
*1 2 ,% , ,1 "* % % "%% ) ) p %= p "
1 ! 9% ,% , " *, % , 1% p% = p "
,% 1 ! 9% ,% , " %*" *)* "% % p "
1 ,) ! 9% ,% , ) ,, % , 1% p% = p "
%) 9 ' ,% , " ,) % %1 * " p%,
1 , 9 ' ,% , 1, % " ) p "=%p%,
9 ' ,% , "" *" % " ) %p %
%) 9 ' ,% , %% 1 )1 *" p%,= p
*" < ,% , %) ) p%,
,% < ,% , 1 ,% %1 ,*" p%,
"" " < ,% , *) ," ),1 )%** p "

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 87


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

j 2
(X3 X: E E ! pI ! J
1 1 2 ,% , ,1 %" ** , %% % %p %
" 2 ,% , ,1 ), %p %
* ") 2 ,% , ,1 %) *, , * % )* 1 %p
1* %) ! 9% ,% , ", ) %1 1%, %)% p%
, )1 ! 9% ,% , " % " p%
%, ! 9% ,% , " % %1,1 "p%
1, 9 ' ,% , " % % * %, p% 9 p%,
*, " 9 ' ,% , % ") %% ) ,,, %p%, =%p %
) 9 ' ,% , " ) * %, p% 9 p%,
,, 1 < ,% , 1 " %% % %1 ,*" p%,
,% , < ,% , 1 " * %1 ,*" p%,
"* % < ,% , 1 "" % ) 11 % %p%, =%p %

j 3
(X3 X: E E pI ! J
%% 2 ,% , ,1 , "" ** %)) "" p %
* )* 2 ,% , ,1 %, * *1 %1 )* %p %
", 2 ,% , ,1 %" ,1 %,) ** %p %
11 *) ! 9% ,% , " * )% % " p% = p "
% ! 9% ,% , " 1* " 1 ") p%,
! 9% ,% , %" 1 , % * %p "
)% % ! 9% ,% , * %% p% = p "
"" ) 9 ' ,% , " 1 )" * p% = p "
* % 9 ' ,% , " 1) %" * , " %p%,=%p
, 9 ' ,% , ) * ,% %p% = p "
< ,% , ", , p% = p%,
%) < ,% , * , p% = p%,
" ) < ,% , %* * 1%* p "

j &
(X3 X: E E pI ! J
% )" 2 ,% , ,1 % ) ,1 %* 11% p
%1 2 ,% , ,1 % % *) " " %p %
2 ,% , ,1 % 1" *)) )1 1)* %p %
"" % '9 ,% , " 1) * p% = p "
*" ,) '9 ,% , " *" %" * 1 1 ) %p%,=%p
1 * '9 ,% , " * %, p% 9 p%,
" )1 ! 9% ,% , " 11 * p% = p "
, ! 9% ,% , " ", , )) p%,

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 88


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

), * ! 9% ,% , * " 1 ** %p "=%p%,
! 9% ,% , ,% % %,* p%,= p "
, ) < ,% , 1 *) p%
** < ,% , " ) *) p%
1 , < ,% , ) 1 1 * , %1 %p =%p%,

j /
(X3 X: E E pI ! J
% %% A/ & XX4 ,% , ,1 " *) % % *)1 p
" % A/ & XX4 ,% , ,1 " ! %p %
% 2 ,% , ,1 " % ) " % p %
% *) 2 ,% , ,1 , ," %*, "), %p
% 2 ,% , ,1 % )1 ! %p %
, 2 ,% , ,1 % ,% ! %p %
% " 2 ,% , ,1 % ,, *1 " %11 %p %
* 2 ,% , ,1 % )1 ! %p %
1 '9 ,% , " " %% 1 ) p%
% 1 '9 ,% , " 1 " * ,*" 1,* %p% = p "
% 1 '9 ,% , " * 1 *" ** " %p% =%p
1) '9 ,% , , * , % ,) p
, * '9 ,% , ,% %"1 %p% =%p "
) )% '9 ,% , * 1" "" 1 * 1 %p%,= p %
% 1 '9 ,% , )1 , ") *%* %p = p "
1* ,) ! 9% ,% , " ", , 1 ") p%
%, 1 ! 9% ,% , " * %1 *% )) )* %p% =%p
" " ! 9% ,% , " ", 1 ) p%
, ) ! 9% ,% , " % %* *1* %* %p%,=%p "
" )" ! 9% ,% , " % %,* p%,= p "
* 1% ! 9% ,% , " )1 1 1 p%
,) ! 9% ,% , " ,1 1 1 p%
,, ) < ,% , ** %1 %)" ) * p%,
* < ,% , ", ,* 1% 1,, %p%,
*1 1 < ,% , * ,% %) % )" p%,
) "* < ,% , %1 % ,1 %% p%,
* < ,% , " %1 )" " * %p% =%p
," *1 < ,% , ) %1 % , 1 * %p%,= p
, "% < ,% , " * "%* ** p%,= p%

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 89


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

j A
(X3 X: E E pI ! J
" 2 ,% , ,1 * " * )* *"* p "
% 2 ,% , ,1 %% ) ! %p %
%1 *1 2 ,% , ,1 ,*% 1% ) * %p "
'9 ,% , " " 1 1 p%
1, '9 ,% , " ) 1 1 1 p%,=%p %
) % '9 ,% , " ,* ) 11* *,1 %p%,= p
1 ! 9% ,% , " *, % % p% =%p%,
! 9% ,% , " "1 1 ) p%
*" "" ! 9% ,% , " ,* %" *% ) p%,
,, < ,% , " * 1 p%
)" " < ,% , % % ) ,*% ",1 %p% = p "
) < ,% , " , % %)1 %p%,= p

j
(X3 X: E E pI ! J
)" * % ! 9% ,% , " " % p% = p "
) ) ! 9% ,% , " ", )" % p% = p "
,% ! 9% ,% , )) * )*" p% = p
1 ! 9% ,% , " * 1 * ,1 p%
1" ) * ! 9% ,% , ) " 1 , % p%
), 1 ! 9% ,% , * ,* 1 ") p%
*% * ! 9% ,% , % %, % )" %p%
) ) ! 9% ,% , *" % 1 % p "
1 )" ! 9% ,% , 1 %" " %" p = p "
) "* ! 9% ,% , , "* %% 1* 1 % p "
, * ! 9% ,% , , ** , 1 p "
*) 9 ' ,% , " ", % ), 1) p% =%p
) *" 9 ' ,% , " 1 1 1 p%
%* 9 ' ,% , , ") %1 %* " %p% =%p "
1 9 ' ,% , , *1 % * p%,=%p "
% 9 ' ,% , , 1 % %) )* p%,
1) 9 ' ,% , ", 1) % %p% = p
)% 9 ' ,% , ** % 1" p "
1, 9 ' ,% , " )" " *1 1 p "= p
) 1" 9 ' ,% , , "* , %* 1 p
"1 1 9 ' ,% , " ,) " * %p "=%p %
1 " 9 ' ,% , 11 " "1 ,, 1 %p %= p
% 2 ,% , ,1 % % )1 % p %=%p
1" 2 ,% , ,1 * *1 * ) p "

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 90


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

* 2 ,% , ,1 1* ) 1*) p "
% " 2 ,% , ,1 % *) 1* %p "
1, 2 ,% , ,1 %" *, , %%% *%1 %p %
% )* 2 ,% , ,1 ,)% % % %p %= p
11 2 ,% , ,1 %1 %p %
* 2 ,% , ,1 % % %p %
* %1 2 ,% , ,1 *) %p %
)" 2 ,% , ,1 * % %p %
"* 2 ,% , ,1 %p %
*1 < ,% , 1 %" *) % ) p%,
1) *" < ,% , 1 * 1) , *1 %)% %p%,=%p "
) < ,% , 1 , ) % , , " %p%,=%p "
) < ,% , 1 , " %p%,=%p "
) *% < ,% , 1 ,1 % , * %p%,=%p "
%% 1 < ,% , 1 %" 1% % 1)** %p
1 < ,% , 1 ) "" 1 *% % p%,
"" ) < ,% , 1 ") %* 1*) )11 p "
") )% < ,% , 1 " 1 ) 1,1" %p%,=%p %
"* % < ,% , 1 "" ) % 1 1 %p%,=%p %
1 1 < ,% , 1 1 ** )* * * %p%

j
(X3 X: E E ! pI ! J
% " 2 ,% , ,1 , *1 %1" % )* %p
*% 2 ,% , ,1 %% * *" 1 " %p %
) ,% ! 9% ,% , %" % 1 ) p%
11 1% ! 9% ,% , ) ", ) 1 p%,=%p "
" 1 ! 9% ,% , " 1 % )* p%,=%p "
1 9 ' ,% , 1" * 11) p%,=%p %
, % 9 ' ,% , )) %)% *) ,, %p% = p %
1 )% 9 ' ,% , 1% " ) c =%c %
%% * < ,% , "% " " ) 1 p%
%% ," < ,% , "% % ) 1 p%
* 1 < ,% , 1 % %" p%,
j %
(X3 X: E E ! pI ! J
, A ,% , ,1 1 , , %p "
A ,% , ,1 % ) *1 )1 ,) %p %
%1 2 ,% , ,1 % )1 *" 1% %p %
%) * 2 ,% , ,1 , )" " " %p "
% )% 2 ,% , ,1 1 % " ) p %

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 91


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

11 , ! 9% ,% , ) ) 1 ) 1 p%,=%p "
1 ,* ! 9% ,% , 1 , % % p% =%p%,
% )1 ! 9% ,% , ) ) %,% %p% =%p
," 9 ' ,% , 1 ) ,1 " %p% =%p %
, )% 9 ' ,% , 1* %) *1" *% %p%,=%p "
1 " 9 ' ,% , %* , , "1 %p "= p %
)) < ,% , " % " 1 % p% =%p "
" )* < ,% , ", * , p% = p%,
)1 , < ,% , % , * %p% =%p %

j
(X3 X: E E ! pI ! J
A ,% , ,1 % % ** ** 1 %p %
%1 A ,% , ,1 % * % )) )* % %p%,
%) 2 ,% , ,1 % "% ,* *, % %p %
%% " 2 ,% , ,1 ,, %" *)* p %
" 2 ,% , ,1 %" * ,% % " %p %
1" 2 ,% , ,1 %1 " , % ",* %p
%1 2 ,% , ,1 % ,* " %p "
) 2 ,% , ,1 , * %" ) %p % =%p
** " ! 9% ,% , " " " % "* p% =%p "
1) % ! 9% ,% , " * )1 % 1, p% =%p "
)% 11 ! 9% ,% , " ", "% %% p% = p "
)% ! 9% ,% , " ", %% p% = p "
) 1 ! 9% ,% , 11 1) p% = p
* ! 9% ,% , " % " p% =%p%,
1 ! 9% ,% , 1 1 ** p%,=%p %
)1 %) ! 9% ,% , ,1 % ), "" %p%,=%p %
1 ! 9% ,% , ) ) ")" % p =%p %
* ! 9% ,% , %1 % )11 ))11 p "= p %
1% ! 9% ,% , 1 "" 1 *) p =%p %
)" 9 ' ,% , " *1 1 " %p% =%p "
% 9 ' ,% , " "1 ,1 p% =%p %
*1 9 ' ,% , " )% "1 ,) p% =%p %
% )* 9 ' ,% , " ", %1 p%,= p "
"" 9 ' ,% , " % 1 * )"" p% = p %
,1 )1 9 ' ,% , " " 1 %) , " %p%,=%p "
1" " 9 ' ,% , ) ) 1,% % 1 %p "=%p
11 1 9 ' ,% , ) "1 ) 1 , )%*1 %p "=%p
11 ,% 9 ' ,% , ) ) ) 1,1 " %p "=%p
1 1 9 ' ,% , ) * 1 "* 1,") %p "=%p

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 92


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

) * 9 ' ,% , , ) , %" 1, p
* < ,% , ,1 % % p%,
* < ,% , " % % * p%,
*% ) < ,% , %) % % , p%,
, < ,% , ", " , p% = p%,
* * < ,% , 1" % % % p%,
,, 1 < ,% , " % " p% = p %
") " < ,% , " ") 1 ) ,1 ) %p%,=%p %
" )* < ,% , % * %1 ") %)% p =%p %
1 < ,% , % ") %1 "*, "* %p =%p "
1) < ,% , % ,) %" ""* " p =%p %
" 1 < ,% , %" 1 *% p "= p

(X3 X: pI J !
< %" p%,=%p " (X3 X: pI J
< 1 p%,=%p % < % 1* p% =%p "
< *" " %p%,=%p " < )*) " p% = p "
< % ,* p%, < %%% " p% = p
< *% 1 %p%,=%p ! 9% ", 11 p% =%p %
! 9% " * p% =%p ! 9% 1 p%
! 9% * %* %p% =%p ! 9% 1%) % p% =%p "
! 9% %, %" %p% =%p 9 ' 1*, ) p "
! 9% ,* " p%,= p 9 ' " " p
! 9% *1% ,) %p% = p 9 ' * p "=%p
9 ' 1*" ) p = p % " %p "
9 ' "") "" p =%p % %% %p %
9 ' " * * p =%p % %% %p %

9 ' "*" * %p =%p "


9 ' % 1 %p =%p %
2 1 %p %
2 )1 " %p %
2 * 1 %p %
2 1 %p %
A 1 %p %
A 1 %p %
A 1 %p %

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 93


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

5 & 6 $
j
(X3 X: E E pI ! J
2 ,% , ,1 % 1 ,,1 %, %b %
* )% 2 ,% , ,1 *) "** %1 %b "=%b
1, ! 9% , , % , )%* % b% =%b%,
"" %% ! 9% , , %" ,1" * %)1 b "
" ! 9% , , , %, ** b%,
*1 % ! 9% , , " % *" b% =%b%,
%* 1% 9 ' , , 1,
,* 9 ' , , *% ,) % *) % b%,
11 ,1 9 ' , , * %, ) %b "= b% =%b
)) " < , , ) % " ,)) " * b =%b%,
* * < , , *) ") * b%,=%b %
) * < , , 1 %

j 2
(X3 X: E E pI ! J
,) 2 ,% , ,1 % *"" * *,) %b %
% % 2 ,% , ,1 % ,"1 ," %) %b
* * ! 9% , , *" b% =%b%,
") ! 9% , , % ,* )%* % b% =%b%,
% )* ! 9% , , "% *% %", b% = b "
1) " 9 ' , , ", %,)" b% =%b "= b
*) ) 9 ' , , " % *" b% =%b%,
* 9 ' , , * )1 " * b% =%b
) 1 < , , 1% , 1 b =%b%,
*% %*" < , , * ) b%,=%b %
)* * < , , ) 11

j 3
(X3 X: E E pI ! J
" % 2 ,% , ,1 " " zzzzzzz %b %
)* 2 ,% , ,1 %) , % % )1 * b = b %
*" ! 9% , , "% % 1 b% =%b%,
1 ! 9% , , , * ) b% =%b%,
%%) ) ! 9% , , " " * ,", " b% = b%,
" , 9 ' , , , *% 1 ) b% = b
"* 9 ' , , )" %1 ") b%,=%b %
)* %% 9 ' , , %, %%%% % b% = b

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 94


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

) , < , , " )" % , ,) %b%,=%b "


* < , , * 1 ), ) b "=%b%,
*% < , , * % * b "=%b%,

j &
(X3 X: E E pI ! J
"1 2 ,% , ,1 ,) %c %
1 2 ,% , ,1 %1 %, , ) %%) %%* %b %
" 1 '9 , , ", 1* 1* b% = b
1 '9 , , ), " 1 * %b% = b
1* %" '9 , , 1% %,)" b% =%b "= b
*" " ! 9% , , "% % 1 b% =%b%,
1 % ! 9% , , % *, 1 b% = b %
% )% ! 9% , , * %) %1" , b% = b%,
) ) < , , " % % **" % ) %b%,= b
* % < , , * ,* ), ) b "=%b%,
* ,% < , , * )1 %, 1 b "=%b%,

j /
(X3 X: E E pI ! J
, ** A/ & XX4 ,% , ,1 " %1 ) % %b = b %
%1 )) A/ & XX4 ,% , ,1 , ,* 1 1* * %b "
%) * 2 ,% , ,1 , , )" 1% %b "
) %) 2 ,% , ,1 %1 ) ,%" % * 1% b %= b
%% 2 ,% , ,1 1 %, %b %
) 2 ,% , ,1 )* %b %
, 2 ,% , ,1 % *)" )% %* %b %
%1 2 ,% , ,1 , 1% %b %
, ,1 2 ,% , ,1 %, "1 *" %* *%" %b %
) '9 , , , % " * b% =%b
% " '9 , , "% %1" "% , ) b%,=%b %
*" *1 '9 , , * "% ))1 ,,* b "=%b
) %* '9 , , " "% 1 ,)) b
* "* '9 , , 1 " %1 b%,=%b "
"1 '9 , , % % *)" % ) ) b %
)1 % '9 , , 1 ) 1* *1** b "
) *% ! 9% , , % %,)" b% =%b "= b
! 9% , , "" %" %) )1 b%
"" ! 9% , , 1 " " "*% b% =%b
, ! 9% , , % %* % 1 ,%* %%" %b%,=%b "
, )1 ! 9% , , %% % " ,%1 %b%,=%b "

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 95


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

1 " ! 9% , , %) *) 1 11" b%
% % < , , % %% , " %b%,=%b "
1% < , , , % " %b "= b
*) * < , , , " % , 1,* b%,
,1 * < , , 11 * * b%,= b
,) " < , , ", )) ) " b%,= b
" ," < , , * ** *%" * b% = b %

j A
(X3 X: E E pI ! J
1 2 ,% , ,1 ) ) ), * ) %b "= b %
%" * 2 ,% , ,1 ) ,)) ) *)) %b "
% " '9 , , " %1 " %*1 b%,=%b %
,1 %" '9 , , " %,% ** ,%, b "
'9 , , )% " ) ,) b%,= b
" ! 9% , , , * ** b%,
%% ! 9% , , ) " %*1 b%,=%b %
" " ! 9% , , 1 " "*% b% =%b
,, ) < , , " %" * %b% =%b "
) 1* < , , 1 ,) ,%% * " %b%,=%b "
)* % < , , ) * 1 ,** * % %p%,= p

j
(X3 X: E E pI ! J
! 9% ,% , %) ", b%,=%b "
, ! 9% ,% , )" , *) ,* 1 b "
", ! 9% ,% , ,* ,* ," %b "= b
) 1" ! 9% ,% , 1 *, " ) b%,=%b %
,, 1 ! 9% ,% , % %" * 1"%" b%,
%, * ! 9% ,% , ) " ) ),% b%,=%b %
*1 1* ! 9% ,% , 1 % ) * % ** % b%,
% ! 9% ,% , ) *1 %," b%,
* ! 9% ,% , % %% )") %"1 b "=%b
% , ! 9% ,% , * % * b%,
%) ! 9% ,% , , " , b%
, ,*" ! 9% ,% , %, " %) b% =%b %
"1 9 ' ,% , 1 * " ) %b% =%b %
) ) 9 ' ,% , * 11 " 1 )% %b%,= b
* 9 ' ,% , %, % ) " %1%% %b%,=%b %
"% )% 9 ' ,% , ) ,*) " 1* % b "
, 9 ' ,% , % *) %" *,1% %b

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 96


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

) %1 9 ' ,% , , 1% 1" % ) %b%,= b


*, 9 ' ,% , 11 ,)) , )%% %b "= b
* 9 ' ,% , % % %% )" ) 1* %b%,=%b %
1 9 ' ,% , % ** %*" % )% %b
" ," 9 ' ,% , ) , 11 ) 1 b "
"" , 9 ' ,% , 1% ,1 *" *% b "
* * 9 ' ,% , % % ) , ) %b%,=%b %
* ,% 9 ' ,% , %) % )) ) " b "=%b
*1 2 ,% , ,1 , * *1, %b "= b
1 "% 2 ,% , ,1 %1 , * % , ""1 %b %
* 2 ,% , ,1 , *" )* * ) * %b "= b
2 ,% , ,1 % *)1 ) 1" " %b %
2 ,% , ,1 ) 1* 1* % , %b = b "
*% 2 ,% , ,1 * 1* * ) *,11 %b %
% *1 2 ,% , ,1 % ,1) ")"% b "= b
) "1 2 ,% , ,1 %) , % % %, %b
) % 2 ,% , ,1 ) 1* %b %
%% 2 ,% , ,1 , 1* , ) %* %* %b
% 2 ,% , ,1 , %b %
*" "* < ,% , 1 ,* * % *1 b%,
1 < ,% , 1 ) "% 1* *% 1", b%,
) % < ,% , 1 , " ,,1 % %b%,=%b "
") 1* < ,% , 1 " " % ) % ") %b%,=%b %
) ) < ,% , 1 * " , *) %b%,= b
1, ," < ,% , 1 " )* % ) , *) %b%,=%b %
) ,1 < ,% , 1 ," % , * % %b%,=%b "
1" 1" < ,% , 1 * ,) *% * b%,
), % < ,% , 1 , ) ,, )* %b%,=%b "
** % < ,% , 1 ) " %)% " %b% =%b "

j
(X3 X: E E pI ! J
%1 2 ,% , ,1 , 1) %b %
% 2 ,% , ,1 % 1, *) 1 * %b %
%% " 2 ,% , ,1 ,, ," %** ,) %b
1 ) ! 9% ,% , ) %* ) ) p%
% % ! 9% ,% , % % ) , ," M 43.M&%
) 1 ! 9% ,% , " " % % %" % b% =%b "
1* )*" 9 ' ,% , * %* ) 1 , %" %b%,= b %
)1 ,1 9 ' ,% , ,% * ), ),* b "
,) * 9 ' ,% , )) ,1 , % * %b%,=%b "

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 97


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

% ,* < ,% , "% , %,, b% =%b %


*1 " < ,% , "% ",* %" b%
% ") < ,% , "% * %,, b% =%b %

j %
(X3 X: E E pI ! J
)1 A ,% , ,1 1) %p %
A ,% , ,1 % ) *)* )) *% %p %
,* A ,% , ,1 " % % ) %b = b %
* 2 ,% , ,1 %% ) *1 ** %p %
% 2 ,% , ,1 1 "" * 1,, b
) ! 9% ,% , , 1" , b%
1" ! 9% ,% , 1 ") % % %,1 %b% =%b %
1" 1* ! 9% ,% , " * "% ) b%
11 " 9 ' ,% , ) "* ) 1," "%) %b "=%b
) %* 9 ' ,% , *" " 1 * 1 %b%,= b %
* 1* 9 ' ,% , % % ) ** * %b%,=%b %
,, * < ,% , " * %* b "= b%,
* * < ,% , )) %%, , b%,
,) %" < ,% , ) "% "1 b%,= b %

j
(X3 X: E E ! pI ! J
" %1 A ,% , ,1 %" %) ,," % % , %b %
%, * A ,% , ,1 %* ), , ) %1 *1" %b
%) A ,% , ,1 )" %,1 " ") * b "
) 2 ,% , ,1 %) , ,%) % % %b
* 2 ,% , ,1 %, ,) * 1 %% 1* %b %
) 2 ,% , ,1 % *) *1 1 " " %b %
)) 2 ,% , ,1 * " * % "") %b %
" )" 2 ,% , ,1 %" 1 , % %%, %b %
1% 2 ,% , ,1 %1 ," , " %% " 1 %b %
*% 2 ,% , ,1 *) * * " %b %
%* ) 2 ,% , ,1 , * %1) %b "
)% 2 ,% , ,1 ) ** ) " ) %b = b "
11 2 ,% , ,1 %% *1% % %) " %b %
%" )% ! 9% ,% , * , % * b%,
, ! 9% ,% , " , % , % "% %b% = b
, ! 9% ,% , " * , 1 " %b% = b
,1 , ! 9% ,% , 1 %*1 , , *) %b% = b %
*) 1 ! 9% ,% , "% % * * 11 1 %b =%b%,

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 98


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

," * ! 9% ,% , " , ," % %b% = b %


, % ! 9% ,% , % %"1 * * 1% b%,
,* * ! 9% ,% , " ,) % % b%,
, ! 9% ,% , 1 %1) *1% " b %=%b%,
* %% ! 9% ,% , 1 ** " % " b%,=%b %
)% " 9 ' ,% , ** 1 1 1 ,1 %b%,= b
)) % 9 ' ,% , *) ) 1*" %b%,= b "
)% 9 ' ,% , ,) %% 1*,% %b "= b
%" 9 ' ,% , % ,, %*% ")1 %b
1" "1 9 ' ,% , ) * 1 "*) 1*% %b "=%b
"* 9 ' ,% , " ,)% , " %b "= b %
) 1% 9 ' ,% , %1 , * %, % %b "
1" ,1 9 ' ,% , ) % "*% )1) %b "=%b
", "% 9 ' ,% , %% ,*% ), %b "= b
) * 9 ' ,% , * 1, " 1 " )"% %b%,= b
1 9 ' ,% , 1 ,"" ", ) b
** 9 ' ,% , )% % " *%* 11% b%,
)* * < ,% , 1) b%,=%b "
)1 < ,% , %" % " )% b%,
)" " < ,% , % %* % " )% b%,
) < ,% , * ", * b%,=%b %
) 1% < ,% , % " % " )% b%,
)* % < ,% , * 1) b%,=%b "
1 ) < ,% , 11 )), " ) b "=%b
1, % < ,% , 1 %, ) ) % *1 %b%,=%b %
") % < ,% , " % ) )% %b "=%b
1 < ,% , ) ) " )*) , " b "=%b

I +J !
(X3 X: pI J (X3 X: pI J
< 11 % p%,= b < % 1% "% p% =%p "
< % p%, < %,,% %) p% =%b %
< 1" 1 %b% = p%, < %%* % b% =%b%,
< *" )" b " ! 9% ,, % b%,=%b
< *"" b " ! 9% 1 1 b%,=%b %
! 9% 1% %% b% ! 9% ) * b%,=%b%
! 9% %" % b%,= b " 9 ' 1%* b "
! 9% ) * %b% = p%, 9 ' "*1 " %b "=%b
! 9% ** %* b " 9 ' *) 11 b "
! 9% %"* ) b% * %b "
9 ' ) 1 % %b%,=%p % %% %p %
9 ' 1 b " %% %p %

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 99


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

9 ' "*% )) %b "=%b %% %p %


9 ' %, "* %b =%b %
9 ' "1) % %b "=%b
2 *" %p %
2 "% * %p %
2 %, *" %p %
2 1 %p %
A 1 %p %
A 1 %p %
A 1 %p %

!
% ,% , ") %%1 %b %
" ,% , , *, %%1 %b %
% ,% , 1 )) %%1 %b %
* ,% , ) ") %%1 %b %
" ,% , , %%1 %b %
" " ,% , 1 1) %%1 %b %
" "% ,% , %%1 %b %

5 2

2 ! ! ! 7 !' ! 5 !
' ! !! $ ' ! '
' !! !! >
' ! ! !
& ! ! !!
!! ' ! >

*
' !' .3 $ ' ! ' ! 5 ! !'
!
.3 C , % E E%
#' E C I = ,KJ N % ,
E% C " L , I !J - ! ' ' ,l '
! 8 E% C

5 C, ,

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 100


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

! ! ' !
' ! !' ! ' > $ ' !!
!' !

6 !! ' !' !! ' ! 8. & !'


!! ' ' !' .
#'
. &C, % G G G
. & N . ::::

; !
' !' . N . & L ' !' !! ' ! . '
6 ' ! '! ! ! 6 $
CI ;J !6G $ FI. . J !"# $%&'(( )
' !' ' ! ' ' ! ! ' ' ! 8
' $ ' ' 5 ! ! ! ! $ ' !'
$ ' $ '! ! ' 5 ! I $
*&!"# $%&'(( &+ ,$ *)
' 5 ! 5 ! !8 ' !'

C ),,
C

5 ! @&
!
9% 6
%
!8 C * 8 C " 8 C% ,
KC !F C, , 1
.3 C , % E E%
E C = ,KC )1 %C " C
' . C"% E:
. &C, % G G G C, % G G% ,G "C E:

'
! !' ! ' ' . C % "E:
CI ;J !6G $ FI. . J C %G , G%", )1GI " JFI % " "% JC%,* 1
2 . N %F . ! /23 % ** 5C , C%%,

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 101


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

D! c) F %,, ' 9' ! ! ! !


8 ! ! c) F %,, ' ' ' '
' !' ! ! ! $ '

;
! ! ! ' ' ' ! W $ !!$ '
' ! ! ! ' ! !
! !' ! !! ! ! ! ' !8
6 ' ! ! ! ! 6

;
! $ ! ' 6 ' ! 0 & ! !! ' 3 6 $I
! "
/23 %8 ** 8 )J
3C % ' ' 6 8 $ 6 ! ' $ '
K C, F $ 8 ' ! ! ! !' 5 D F)

4 6 8 ! !' ' ' ! ! '


! 5 ,

9 0
6 !! ' ' ! !! 8 &8
! !' !! ' ' 0
#' &C,) ' L !

#' ! L ' ' ! A 8 ' ! ! 9 ! ! ! !


! 6

J ! ! 5 !
! ! $! $ ! $
J ! !'
6 ! ! !'
8 C_ . 8 C _6. ' '

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 102


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

- ' ' ! !' !! ' !'


38 C_ 3 .38 C _6 .3 ' '

* * !"# $%&'(( &+ ($ - )


O $. /;: :* 9 " =*1
!' ! 8 ! C" ,
.! C % *
, /0 6 ' !
%
% , C% ,G ,C)1 G ,
DC%I% ,= ,JC %,,
A C F CI , JF C" N FDC1% *%
% ,
%
CO , " P)O% , " PC %* *"
D CYO , " P=O% , " PZG%C*
3' !' $
.3 C , % E E%
KC !F CO G%, PFO% ,G ,1PC, ,,")*
E C = ,KC "
E%C " C %*
. C, % G , %G %* G "G% ,G ,*C "
. &C, % G G G C% ) )
!
3C % ' C

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 103


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

& C,) ' C , %*


D!
-
D! ' 6 _ C, ), _ C, ) %
_6C, * " _6 C, ,
3 ! $
. C_6 G. C, ,G "C ) "
. 8 C. G_6C, * "G% ) ) C ,
8 C G_ C, ) %G C )
8 C G_ C, ), G , %*C% %
3' .! ' .38
.! C % *L. 8 C )"
0 ! !'
CI ;J !6G $ FI. . J C O%G , G%", )1GI ,* JPFO "G , P C ) "1
%F . C)" *
5C, C, G ,*C
D! c) F ,
C )" N ! C" , ! !
C ! C% "
(
%
C C)1 )
%
F%C *
%
C",% = * C" " ,
! %c%,
2 C% = * C%1*
! %c
C C "

5C, ' ! c) F ,
' ! ! ' !

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 104


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

5&
3 ! 5 $ 6 !8 ' ' $ ' $ !!
' 7 $ !! ! ! $ ' ' '
$ ! ' ! ' ! ' ! ' !
! ' ! 5 $ ! ! ' 5 ' '
$ - '! ! 8 ! !! ' ' 5 $
! !' ! ! ' ! !
5& 6
! ! ' ! !! ' ' !! $
! $
% ' ' ! ! ' ! ! $
! !
' 6 ' 5 '! ! ! $ '
5 ' ' ! $ ! '

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 105


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

' 6 ! ' ! !! ! ' ! ! ! 6 $


- !C%GuE
- CuE
#' E ! !!
#' E ! !!
' 6 ' ' ! ! ! '! $ !! !! $
! !'
' 6 ' ( 6 ! '
5 0 6 ' ! ! '
J : ! $
( F(C IR =, JF IR =, )J S , )
J $
3 ! 6 6 $
( F(C] I =, ) R J S
#' R ! ! !! ' ' ! !!
D! ' '

E E % ! !! ! I/ F J
E ! ' ! !! ' !
RC , ! ! $ $ !
RC , ! !
RC , 6

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 106


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

' 6 5 0 6 ' ! 6 !
R R% 5 ,
! ! ! !! ' $ ! ,

" ' ! ' ! ! ! ' '


! I J
1 ' 0 $ ' ! ! ! '
' ' ! ' ' !
!
8 ' ! 84 8 ! '
! ! $ !
4 C R%= A(
R = R% ="
#' AC ' ' > ' ' ! $
(C ' ! $ !'
) ' ! $ $ !! 0 ' ' ! !
2 8 $ !
%
: C /
( %
#' / ! ' 6 ! !! ' ! ! !
( ! ' 6 '
8 ' 6 ! !! $ !
/ C , %/ = /! !
#' / C ,,
/! ! ' ! ! $ !
8 ! ' '
! !8 ! 6 $
' ! ! 8 ' !
' ' !
3 ! ' ! '
'

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 107


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

$
%

!" #
$

' ! ! ! ' 5 ' ! ' !


{ C :! G ,
G
| C 4 G ,"
G G
C !8 G $
G

# ' 6 ! 6 ! ! !5 ! ' ! ! !$! !


!
& ! ! ' 5! ! ! ! !'

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 108


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

' ! ' ! ! ! ! !
j

(/./
( R R% A ( ( :! A( 4 | 6
,
- ) *% ,, , ,* , *1 " " ) ,,
< ,
%* ) *% %% , ), * , *, 1) ) * "* , , %, ,%
,
%% % *, ) )) , "" " ") ) ) % )* , ,)
,%
% %% %% *) "1 , 11 *** , ,, * , 1 ,,
,
%% %% , , 11 ,% ) 1" * ,,
,,
"* %% "1 , "% , ) 1 1* % 1 ,, %

:! F:
! } ! / :
%)/= " ,,11,
,,) ,}%, *"* 1,,% , 1 %*/= ) ,, ! $
%)/= *% ,, % )
, *" )}% %%") ,, , 1 1%1/= ,% ~~! $~~
%)/= % * 1"% ,
,,) ,}%, *"* 1,,% , 1 %*/= % , ,1 ! $
%)/= % %"*
,,) ,}%, *"* 1,,% , 1 %*/= 1 ,, ! $
%)/= % %"*
,,) ,}%, *"* 1,,% , 1 %*/= 1 , ,% ! $
%)/= ) %1 %% %
,,) ,}%, *"* 1,,% , 1 %*/= * ,, ! $

j %
(/./( R R% A ( ( :! A( 4 | 6
- * ,, % ) , 1 ) )1 ), 1) ), % , ,1 , %
< ,% * *1 ), , 11) %% 1 * ,* 1 , % , , , 1*
" ,% ,1 , " * "%1 ), %* % %,) ," , 1 ,% ,%
% " " * , " % 1 *" %1* 1 * ) , , ) ,
" " 1) , " % 1) 1* 1) *" , ," , % , ,%
%" " % ) , ) "" %* 1, 1, %% )" , ,% , ,"

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 109


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

" %" 1 * , )* 1% * % ,, ,,

! } ! / : :! F:
) % ",) "}%, ") " "* %1)/=,* % /= 1%"%%1) 1% ,, ! $
111 , ,} % %* *) )% %1)/=,* " *,"/= " ) )1) *"* , % ~~! $~~
*") }%" 11,)*%"* %1)/=,* % ",)/= "%* ) * *" , , ! $
) % ",) "}%, ") " "* %1)/=,* % /= " 1, "% , ,) ! $
) % ",) "}%, ") " "* %1)/=,* % /= " 1, "% , ," ! $
) % ",) "}%, ") " "* %1)/=,* % /= %* * )) ,, ! $
) % ",) "}%, ") " "* %1)/=,* % /= ,,*)%1 % , ,% ! $

j
(/./( R R% A ( ( :! A( 4 | 6
- )* % %," ) )" %% %* , , , "
< %* )* %1, " ) * ,* * % ,%) % ")1 * , % , ,
%% % * %,, 1 , "" % " % %*1 ** , ,
% %% %% % , 11 , 1 1 " )1 1 , ,1 ,%
%% %% * *" , 11 ) 1* )% )) * ,, ,
" %" %% %" , " ") ) ) ,, ,,
1 )% " %" , 1) * " *% 1" , ,, ,,
! } ! / : :! F:
,,) ,}%, *"* 1,,% %)/= , 1 %*/= " ,,11, ) , ,, ! $
)} , * ,, , %)/= , ,%*/= %%11 * , ,, ! $
,,) ,}%, *"* 1,,% %)/= , 1 %*/= % * ,)" , ,, ! $
,,) ,}%, *"* 1,,% %)/= , 1 %*/= % %%1 )" , ,, ! $
,,) ,}%, *"* 1,,% %)/= , 1 %*/= % %%1 )" , ,, ! $
,,) ,}%, *"* 1,,% %)/= , 1 %*/= 1 *%" %* ,, ! $
,,) ,}%, *"* 1,,% %)/= , 1 %*/= ," " 1 ,, ! $

j
2
(/./( R R% A ( ( :! A( 4 | 6
- * * ,1 %% % % 1) *% )1 " , ,1 , )) , ,)
< ) )" %"* ) % % ,) ,%% % 1 , , %" , 1 ,
1 ) %,* * , " )) "" " , ,* ,% ," ,
% 1 1 , 1 ,% , % *% ,* ) %, *, , 1 , , ,
1 1 1% "* , 1 ,% , %) %% 1 ,) , ,* , % , ,%
1 )% 1 )1 , 1" ** 1 )) % * , ,% , ,% ,,
! } ! / : :! F:

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 110


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

) % ",) "}%, ") " "* %1)/=,* % /= )1 " 1* , ,, ! $


* )}% %%") ,, %)/= , 1 1%1/= * %)" % ) , ,, ! $
* " %% )}%" 1) * %1)/=,* /= )" "1 , ,, ! $
) % ",) "}%, ") " "* %1)/=,* % /= )")%) 1) , ,, ! $
) % ",) "}%, ") " "* %1)/=,* % /= )")%) 1) , ,, ! $
) % ",) "}%, ") " "* %1)/=,* % /= ,%,% " , ,% ! $

j /
(/./( R R% A ( ( :! A( 4 | 6
- 1 % "1 %," ) 1,* % ), , % , 1
< ") % ) " *" * % ** )1 * , , , 1
" %*, " , % ))" " ,% , , ,%
% " " * * , " , 1 *1 "% %*) ) , , %) ,
" " 1 , " ) 1* " )% 1 , ,) , " ,,
" ,% , )) %" "* % ,, ,, ,,
% * , ) * * " ,, , ,%
! } ! / : :! F:
% "% ) ) "}% * ," % ) %/=,* * /= "1*" ,* ) , ,, ! $
1*** ," ,} % , "% 1 %)/= , %)/= %1, %" , , ,, ! $
%,, %% "}%" " * *1 ) %/=,* , /= % 1%, % , ,, ! $
% "% ) ) "}% * ," % ) %/=,* * /= %%1*1% 1 , ,, ! $
% "% ) ) "}% * ," % ) %/=,* * /= %%1*1% 1 , ,, ! $
% "% ) ) "}% * ," % ) %/=,* * /= % *% , " ,, ! $
% "% ) ) "}% * ," % ) %/=,* * /= " %*1 " ,, ! $

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 111


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

5&&

- !8 ! ' $ ! ' ' !! ! ' !! !


! ! ! !' ' 5! '
;
' $ ! ' ! ! ! !! ! '
! ! 6 $
C = = %
#'
! 0 6 ! ! $ ' ! 5
! $ ! 0 ' !
C
! 6 $ $ ' '8 ' 0 6 $ ! '
' ' ' 6 !
C, " % = ,
C, %
% ! ! ' ! %
! 6 '
! ' $ 8 $
! ' $ ' ' ! 6

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 112


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

C ( F ,, S%,
( ! ' 6 ' !
& ! ' ! $
/23 %8 ** "I%J ! ! !! 6 !
' ! !
J ! $ ! '
`M % W ' ' 6 ! 5
F]• • C :! F

J ! $ !
` M , @ % I4 F4%J
#'
4 4% ' ! I !
' !8 4% $! ! 6
' 4 8 4 ! 6 !
! 6 6 6
- ! $ ! ' ! ! ' ' ! $ !
!
' $ ' ! $ $ $ ' $
6 $
€! C FI @ :! F: J 6 W :! F: M , %

4 $
6 4 4% + ,% , " %=, , % 4

, "% 1 ") % , ,,11",) , ,,) " , ,, 1* , ,, %" , ,, %" ")

" ) 1 ,1" , , ,1,% , , * , ,% ," ,, ,1) ,, ,1) 1 %)

! ** " ,) )," , % ," , 11 ,, ,, ,*" ,, ,*" %

! 1 " %, 1 % , ,"1 "*) , ,1 , , )%" ,, , ,, , " ),

' * " )" , %,% , ) , , ), " , , "1% , , "1% 1 )"


' ", %) , *" , )%% , 1%1, ) , %)* , 1%1, * "
4 5

, )1 1 " ") % , ,,1* , , %) , ,, %% , ,, , ,, 1 ,%

1 * ,1" , , , %11)1 ,, ) , ,, 11"* , ,, *%" , ,, *%" " 1"


! ) % )," , ,%%1 , ,%""1 , ,,"*, * , , ,""* , , ,""* ) ",
! 1, * , 1 % , " % , , 1 **" , ," %*" , ," %*" " ,

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 113


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

, %" %

' "% "* ), ) )" , ** , ,% " , ,1 , , )" , , )" % ,1%

' , ** ") %) , ,*1, "% , *1 , , 1"" , % *)* , , 11 1, %

2 4 $
6 4 4% + ,% , " %=, , % 4
, % , )* %% % % , ,,, )" , ,,, , ,,, 1 , ,,, ) , ,,, % , 1,%

%, )) ",% )% , ,1 1 , ,) *% , , )*) , , %1"1 , , %1"1 % %

! % % %1) %) , ,,)1 ) , ,,* ) , ,,%%, , ,, 1* , ,, 1* ) )

! % * , %* , ,,%%%"1 , ,, 1 , ,,% * , ,,%%*" , ,,% %" )

' ) % )% %* , ,, , ,," 1 , ,,% ",) , ,,%"%" , ,,%"%" %)

' " ,) 1 ,) ** , , 1 1 ,, , " , ,"%* 1 , ,"%* 1 %) %


4 5

*" * ") %% % % , ,,%" " , ,, , ,, %, , ,, 1 * , ,, 1 * )1%

% "1 ",% )% , , ) 1 , ,%%* , ,,1"" , ,,* * , ,,* * ")

! " )) %1) %) , ,))1 " , ,* , , * """ , , " 1 ,, " 1 "1 %

! " " )* , %* ,, " ,, ,) ,, %% " , ,%%, , ,%%, %% 1 "

' 1 1 *% 1* %* , ""*))1 , % ",% , ,"%) " , ,)" ,1 , ,)" ,1 1 "

' " * ,% ** , %, " , *1) , ,% % , * 1" , ,% % ) "

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 114


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

/ 4 $
6 4 4% + ,% , " %=, , % 4

, "1 1*, , ,,, 1 , ,,% % , ,, % % , ,,,*%1 , ,, % % %%%

,1 ) " , ,,, *% , ,, 1 , ,, 1 *% , ,, %"* , ,, 1 * % ),)

! " )1 1 * *, , , )) * ,, * 1 , ,,) **) ,, )%" ,, )%" ,%

! % " ) "1 *) ,, ) "% , , *"1 ,, , % , , *)1 , , *)1 %

' ,% % %% )1 " , ,11* , ,) " , , )1 ") ,, %" ,, %" % )))

' " ) % % *, ) , ) % ) ,% * , ,)%*) , , " , , " * ")

A 11 % ,1 %) *1 , 1 * , )" ) , %*,** , " , " , ,%)


4 5

% 1" *1 ") 1*, , , ) ,, ,, 1 , ,% * , ,% )%" , ,% * ,

, 1" * %) " , ,"% , , ,1 , , , ))*"1 , ,%*% % , ,%*% % 11 %

! 1 1 ) * *, , * ,1% , ,) ,, %" , ,"%, , ,"%, ) )1%

! %, ) %* *" "1 *) , 1*) * , * ,, , ,11 * , ,11 * *)

' ,, " % ,) )1 " , % *%1) , %)*%1 , ,"*) *) , 1,1 , 1,1 ) %

' * " *, ) , )" 1 ," , ,% 1%) ,% % ,% % %% ,"

A * %* % %) *1 , ", ,,*"1 , ** 1)1 , , )"" , , )"" 1

/% 4 $
6 4 4% + ,% , " %=, , % 4
%) ) ) ) *1 , ,, ) , , ,, , ,,"" %* , ,, , * , ,,""
1 " 1 , ,, 1%% , ,,* , ,,1 *,1 , ,, ), , ,,1 * %)

! % 1 " ) , ,,%")1" , ,, * , ,,,) "" , ,, %1 , ,, %1 , ))

! * "* , , ,,*1*%* , , ) , ,, * , ,, "1 , ,, "1 % %1"

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 115


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

' * * * 1) %*1 , , ,))1" , , %)1 , ,,1 "1 ,, ) ,, ) * %

' * 1 ) , , % *" ,, * , ,%% "*" , ,% 1 * , ,% 1 * 1 "

A * )* 1 1 ") * , , * , % 1"" , ,*" ) , , ," , , ," 1 ,%)


4 5

"% , , *) ) *1 , ,1 , % , %1,) , , " )" , , ,) % , , ,) % % *%

,, " " 1 , ,"" " , ""% , ,"1 11 , %"" ) , %"" ) 1)

! %% %" * " ) , %" * , %1 , , ))%1* , ,, , ,, , 11%

! *1 , % , , % %11* , % *11 , , )1 % , , *,* , , *,* 1

' ") * 1" "% %*1 ,% 1,11 , % 1 % , ," )%* , , ,,) , , ,,) ," )

' ,% *) 1 ) , %,*) ," , % * ,, "%% , ,)" " , ,)" " *%

A % "* %% ") * , "%,1"" , 1%% , ) * , )))) , )))) % ))

A 4 $
6 4 4% + ,% , " %=, , % 4

" *) 1 1 , ,,%* ** , , %1 , ,," *% , ,, ,* , ,," * , ,"

)* %* ) ", , ,, 1% , , %" , , ,% " , ,% , % , , ,% "* %

! " "% %% * ** , , %%1% ,, ,, ) 11 , , 1) ) , , 1) ) * 1"


! " ") ) * ") ,, ) 1 , , %11 ,, ,,* , , 1 ,1 , , ,,*
' * 1 % %* % %1 , ,%) , ,1% * ,, * , ,%)**1 ,, * 1" %

' %* % % , )) , , %, *% , ,*1%1 ,, , , )*,1 ,, % )*)

A % " % % * , ,",%1) , 1* , , """ , , %1 1 , , %1 1 " ")


4 5
) *% *" 1 1 , ,,*)1 , , *"* ,, )" * , ,% )1 ,, )"% * "%

" " ) ", , %,1 ),% , %* * , ,* %* , ) " , ) " "" %

! ") ,) % 1" ** , % *"1 ,% , % , ,* , , ,*" %" , ,*" %" * ,

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 116


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

! *1 )* ") , % %%* , %% % , ,) %) , ,*,,) , ,*,,) * "

' 1 1 % %1 , " ")" ,% *% , ,*% %" , ,*%1"* , ,*%1"* %* ),

' % " % % , )) ,, * , , " , , % ")* , , %,"% , , % "* ,%


A 1 %) 1 % * , )"* , *1 , ,%) " , , )* , , )* " *"

/
% 5 5
6 ( %, :! 4
*% , ,, " % , ,% , ,% ) *1 " "1*
, %* 1 ,, ," , ,% , , , " "1 ""1 )
! % ), , ,,* ) , ,% , ,% " ) * %%1"
! % ) 1" , ,,* 1 , ,% , ,% , ) ,%"%%
' % ) 1" , ,,* 1 , ,% , ,% %*1 * ,"
' %* ) , ,,*1%) , ,% , ,% 1 ) 1"
A % * ,* , ,,*11 , ,% , ,% ") * " )
$ 5
6 ( %, :! 4
% 1 1 , ,, % , ,% , ,% ) *1 " "1*
"1 , , 1)* , ,% , ,% "1 *
! % %% 11 , ,,1 , ,% , ,% " ) * %%1"
! % % ,) , ,,1 11 , ,% , ,% , ) ,%"%%
' % % ,) , ,,1 11 , ,% , ,% %*1 * ,"
' % * )) , ,,) , ,% , ,% 1 ) 1"
A %1 , ,,* ) , ,% , ,% ") * " )

/
5 5 ,
6 ( %, :! 4
,* , ,, 1 , ,% , ,% 1*, ),
%1"1 ,, %" , ,% , ,% " % """
! % "% * , ,,) % , ,% , ,% * *, ) *)
! % 1*%% , ,,) *1 , ,% , ,% "1 *) *"
' % 1*%% , ,,) *1 , ,% , ,% )1 " 1 1 *%
' % 1"" " , ,,*%%% , ,% , ,% *, ) ),1"
A % )) %) , ,,*" , ,% , ,% %) *1 , 1*
$ 5
6 ( %, :! 4

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 117


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

%* "1 , ,, ," , ,% , ,% 1*, ),


%1 )) , , ,* " , ,% , ,% " % """
! % , ,% , ,,), , ,% , ,% * *, ) *)
! % % * , ,,),1 , ,% , ,% "1 *) *"
' % % * , ,,),1 , ,% , ,% )1 " 1 1 *%
' %" ) , ,,))%1 , ,% , ,% *, ) ),1"
A % 1) * , ,,*%1* , ,% , ,% %) *1 , 1*

5 5
6 ( %, :! 4
), % , ,, ", , ,% , ,% ") % %1 ")
, , 1) , ,% , ,% ,1" , % %,%
! % ")"% , ,,)* , ,% , ,% )," " %*
! % 1,, , ,,* , ,% , ,% 1 % ,
' % 1,, , ,,* , ,% , ,% )" " %*1%
' % 1 % " , ,,* 1 , ,% , ,% %) % %" "
A , , , ,
$ 5 ,
6 ( %, :! 4
% , ,, 11 , ,% , ,% ") % %1 ")
" 1% , , % * , ,% , ,% ,1" , % %,%
! %) ) , ,,* 1) , ,% , ,% )," " %*
! %) % , ,,* ,) , ,% , ,% 1 % ,
' %) % , ,,* ,) , ,% , ,% )" " %*1%
' % )) ,* , ,,*" 1 , ,% , ,% %) % %" "
A , , , ,% , ,% , ,

2
5 5 ,
6 ( %, :! 4
,* , ,, 1 , ,% , ,% %% % % , "
%1"1 ,, %" , ,% , ,% ",% )% %, "
! % "% * , ,,) % , ,% , ,% %1) %) % " "
! % 1*%% , ,,) *1 , ,% , ,% , %* %, " )%
' % 1*%% , ,,) *1 , ,% , ,% %* ) *
' %" % , ,,)) , ,% , ,% ** , )**)
A , , , ,% , ,% , ,
$ 5 ,
6 ( %, :! 4

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 118


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

% , ,, 11 , ,% , ,% %% % % , "
" 1% ,, % * , ,% , ,% ",% )% %, "
! %) ) , ,,* 1) , ,% , ,% %1) %) % " "
! %) % , ,,* ,) , ,% , ,% , % * %, " )%
' %) % , ,,* ,) , ,% , ,% %* ) *
' % )) ,* , ,,*" 1 , ,% , ,% ** , )**)

6 :! 4
, ,% 1 1 *
, ,% ", %,)%
! , ,% ** , %**)
! , ,% ") ) "* "
' , ,% % %1 " %
' , ,% % , )) ) 1"
A , ,% % * % * )

/
%
6 4 5 4 4 5 4 $ 4 4 $
% *% " "1* * ,1 " "1* %% %%
"% %* % * 1 "* ""1 ) * %,
! , 11% * %%1" ", ,, , )) * %%1" * )%
! 1 ) ,%"%% *1 % %1" ) ,%"%% , ,
' ," ) * ," " ", * % * ," * )"
' *% 1" "1 1 " 1" " ))
A % )) " ) % 1 ,%) " ) ) *

/
6 4 5 4 4 5 , 4 $ 4 4 $
, ), ) % %%% ), ),
11 % % """ ), ) % ),) % """ 1
! ) )1% ) *) 11 ) ,% ) *) ,,
! *) *" " % % *" %" 1*
' ) % 1 1 *% % ) % ))) 1 1 *% %, "
' %% ," ),1" % )1 * ") ),1" )
A 1 , 1* % %) , ,%) , 1* ,"

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 119


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

6 4 5 4 4 5 , 4 $ 4 4 $
1 ,% %1 ") * ") %1 ") )
" 1" % %,% %1 *, 1 %) % %,% ") *
! ) ", " %* % 1 % " %* ", "
! " , , 1 " ), , %1 *
' % ,1% " %*1% ) 1 1 )" " %*1% % "
' 1, % % %" " * %) * " % %" " % )

2
6 4 5 4 4 5 , 4 $ 4 4 $
)1% , " ) *% , 1,% , " 1
") %, " "1 % % %, " ) )
! "1 % % " " 1% % ) ) % " " ,
! %% 1 " %, " )% %" ) %, " )% % ,
' 1 " ) * 1 %) ) * * 1%
' % ) " , )**) % 1" %) % , )**) 1

6 4 5 4 4 5 , 4 $ 4 4 $
* "% * ), 11 , ," * %
"" % %,)% 11 "* % %,)% %)
! * , , %**) * ), * 1" , %**) * )
! * " ) "* " 1) 1 )%" ) "* " %" %
' %* ), " % "% 1" % " % % ,1
' ,% ) 1" ,1 % )*) ) 1" 1 1%
A " *" % * ) * " " ") % * ) * ,"

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 120


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

5&2
5&2
(
! C , ,,)
! 5 C , ,)
3

6 :! 4 5 4 $ { |' | • ! ! ! 6 p
") % * ) , , ,1 , ,1 , %) )* 1, *), )* 1, )p "
,1" , %1 *, ") * , ) , ," , , %* % *,1 *), %* )p "
! )," % 1 ", " , " , , , % , %, 1 *), *), p %9 p
! 1 % 1 %1 * , , , , ," , ," * %%%% *), *), p %9 p
' )" ) 1 % " , % , ,) , , ,, % * "1 *), *), p %9 p
' %) * %) % ) , , ," , ,1 , % "* ," % 1%, 1%, p "

2
6 :! 4 5 4 $ { |' | • ! ! ! 6 p
%% % % ) *% 1 % , ,1 , ," , " *" " %), *" " )p%
",% )% "1 ) ) , * , ," , % , % %% ) %), %% ) p% 9 p
p%,9
! %1) %) 1% % , ,* , , ," , % 1,% ) *), 1,% p %
! , %* % , ,1 , ,* ,, ,, %*% "%, *), *), p 9 p %
' %* 1 * 1% , , , ,% , % "* ," % 1%, 1%, p "
' ** % 1" 1 ,, , ,) ,, ,% 1) 1")1 1%, 1) 11 p "

/
6 :! 4 5 4 $ { |' | • ! ! ! 6 p
1*, ) ), , , ,, , " % , "" %), % , 1 p% 9)p %
" ), ) 1 ,* , ,, , %1 * , ** %), * p%,9 p "
! * *, 11 ) ,, , 1 , " , ,1 , )"% *), )"% p%,9 p
! "1 *) " % %" 1* , , , ," , " ) %" *), *), p %9 p
' )1 " % ) %, " , , ,, , ," * %%%% *), *), p %9 p
' *, ) % )1 ) , , ,) , , , * 1 1%, 1%, p "
A %) *1 % %) ," ,, ,, ,, , *, )) 1%, 1%, p "

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 121


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

/%
6 :! 4 5 4 $ { |' | • ! ! ! 6 p
) *1 * ,1 %% %% , " , % ,, , ,* 1) ) *), *), p %9 p
"1 1 * %, , , ,, , " ) % *% *), *), p %9 p
! " ) ", ,, * )% , , % , ,% , ," * %%%% *), *), p %9 p
! , *1 , , , , , , ,% , , *" *), *), p %9 p
' %*1 " ", * )" , , % ,, , ,1 %1 " * 1%, 1%, p "
' 1 ) "1 " )) , % ,, , ,% , , 1%, 1%, p "
A ") * % ) * , ,, ,, , ," % ," 1%, 1%, p "

A
6 :! 4 5 4 $ { |' | • ! ! ! 6 p
1 1 ), 11 % ,* , , ," , %) * 1 %), * 1 p%,9 p "
", 11 %) , , " , ," ,% %% ") *), %% 1 p%,
! ** * ), * ) , , % ,, ,, %"" , ) *), *), p%,
! ") 1) %" % , , " , ,* , 1% " 1%, 1% 1 p%,
' % %1 "% % ,1 , , % , ,) , ,) *1 1%, 1%, p "
' % , )) ,1 1 1% , % , , , ," , , 1%, 1%, p "
A % * * " * ," , ,, ,, ,, " 1 1%, 1%, p "

5&2& $
- ' ! ' ' ! ! ! !

6 :! 4 5 4 $ { |' | • ! ! ! 6 p
%% " *, , , ,1 , ,) , *" *), *" )p "
1, 1 %" % ,) , ,, , % 1, *), 1,% % p%,= p "
! ) ,1 " " % * ," , ,, , ) % *), *), ,, p %= p
! "%" %" *, 1 1% , , ,, , ,% ," *), *), ,, p %= p
' , * ,, " , , ,, , ) 1, " 1%, 1%, ,, p "
' )* *" *% 1 ,) , ,, ,, ,, ") 1%, 1%, ,, p "

6 :! 4 5 4 $ { |' | • ! ! ! 6 p
1 % ) 1, ) , , , % ,, , 1 % 1 %), % 1 p% = p "
"," 1* % " 1 ,* , ,, , %1 )1" %), )1" % p%,= p
! * ") *, %) " , 1 , , , , , ," 1 %), %), ,, p "= p
! 1*1 * 11 ) 1, , , ,) , , ,, * ,* %), %), ,, p "= p

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 122


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

' , * 1, , , ,, , ,) 1%, 1%, ,, p "


' ) %, % "" ,, , ,1 ,, , ) 1, " 1%, 1%, ,, p "

6 :! 4 5 4 $ { |' | • ! ! ! 6 p
%" 1 1% ,) , ) , , , , , " % %), %), ,, p "= p
*") 1 ) % , , % ,, ,, 1 * %), %), ,, p "= p
! 1 ) ) 1 % )1 , , ,, , , %), %), ,, p "= p
! 1 "* * , , , ,, ,, ") %), %), ,, p "= p
' %" *% * , , * ,, , % 1%, % %* p "= p %
' *" " %) % 1 , , ,* , ,% , 1% 1%, 1%, ,, p "
A ,) * ,, ,, ,, , , 1%, 1%, ,, p "

/
%
6 :! 4 5 4 $ { |' | • ! ! ! 6 p
%" , ,, % "1 , % , , , , , ,) % " *), *), ,, p = p %
*%1 *1 1 , , ,, , * , *), , , )1 p = p %
! %) ", %) , ") , , % , ,% , ,1 ** *), *), ,, p = p %
! 11 1 * 1" ) ) , , " ,, , 1 "" 1%, 1%, ,, p "
' %) ) " 1 , , , % , ,% , ,1 %* % 1%, 1%, ,, p "
' * 1 ,% ,, , ,% , , 1%, 1%, ,, p "
A "" " ) ) ,) , ,, ,, , ," % 1%, 1%, ,, p "

A
6 :! 4 5 4 $ { |' | • ! ! ! 6 p
% % ), * , , ,) , , ," ,% *, %), )* ) p "= p
1 ,* * * " )1 , ) , , ," , %1 )1" %), )1" % p%,= p
! 1 )* " , , ,% ,, , 1 "" 1%, " )% p "= p
! )1 " ,% 1 , , %, , ," , " ,1 1%, ,1 ) p "= p
' % % *" %% ) , , ) , ,1 , * 1%, ) p "= p
' ") * , %" , ,, ,, , ," % 1%, 1%, ,, p "
A " %" ** % % , ,, , ,) , ,) 1%, 1%, ,, p "

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 123


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

6 :! 4 5 4 $ { |' | • ! ! ! 6 p
% 11 " %"1 ,% , 1 , ,% , %" , " 1%, , " , p = p %
% *1 % ,% , 1 ,, , 1 1%, 1% " p "= p %
! %,) % %1 * %% ,% , ,* , , ,, * 1%, 1%, ,, p "
! " ) * 1% %1 ,% , , , ,* , , * 1%, 1%, ,, p "
' , %1 ) * ) 1" , , , , ," , ,1 %* % 1%, 1%, ,, p "
' %) 11 ") "" 1 ,, , ,% , ,% , , * 1%, 1%, ,, p "

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 124


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 125


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

4
1 / / 211
N

8 $
4$
<6
(
45 C *" : (; 45 j
4$ C , % :
+ C%% % % :
!! (C2

$ ' ! !
C ", E+ 3 % ,,

6
%% % %
D! W+ C ",) 1

9% , %
8 , ,, 1
",) 1
, )*
98 *"
% , ,,,%"
",) 1
! 82C( ,"

$ %
GI "G 8
"G J

",) 1 , ,,,%" , ,, 1
", %
GI "G "G J

6 0 ' $ 8 2C 1
# ! 2C(C 1
",) 1 %
GI , , , ,,,* J "% 1 F
1%
",) 1 %
# GI , , , ,,,* J " % F
1%
",) 1 %
GI , , , ,,,* J C ) ,, F
1%

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 126


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

",) 1 %
GI ,, , ,,,* J C " *" F
1%

"% 1 "

5.,
5.4 )4

0 ( 55. -

6
/23 %8 ** 1" ' !! ' ' !'
! 6 $
. C,% G G G %G G
#' E C = , %,
E% C " @ , I J
!! C , ,,%8 C , = , G , ,,% C , = (;
DC GI, = JC "=
. C , % G , G G ,GI " = G JG 2;
. C I 1G 1 @ I, = J%JG 1 , =
' . L. I ! J 2;
A ! 6 ,
' 8 & C * = , = , C",
0 4 %

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 127


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

/23 %8 ** 8 8 ' !' . $ ' ! 6 $


. C, G G G %G G
D! , 6 "
C " , @ ,@ ) C ",
. C , G , G G G 1G, % C %1 " :
. C I2F% 2;F% JG0 G2
C , ,* G " %G 1C) )* :
. L. ' ! ! ! aa
' 6 ! ' 6 ' ! " ,

4C " )G G , G , F% C %,, 1 :
D! :
- !
9
. # C * "

%, **9 %
E! C *" ! C E! G C *"G
% %) %%
, "
%
C G G C ,,%G 1,,G ", C *,
G# %, G 1,,
" ,
% %) %%
" F , I ' J
1,, ,,J
: C I %
,
A 6 % " F ,
$ ' ' ! ! ! ! ' ' 6
' ! ! ' ' ! !

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 128


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

4&
' ! ! '! ! $
! ! ' ! - <= '
$ ", ! ! ! !
! ! 6 ! ! ' ! $ ! !! ' '
' ! ; ' 6 '! ' ! ' !
' ' ! ! 6
' ! ' ! !$! ! ! ! ! ' ! !
' ! ! ' !

/ < - <
,

%1

, , ) , *) ,

! "$ H $
3 + - 5 4$
/ 11 ,% 1 * %
- %1* * ** 1 * ) ,"
/% ), 1 1 ,) 1
<% ** ) %) ** % *
/ % *" ,)* *1 ** ) %*
A % % ,)" " * , "

C ,% 1 ** 1 = 1 1= %) = ,)" "= ,)* *1C%)1" E:


5!/

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 129


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

;5 C ," = 1 % *=% * " ** 1 G = %) G ,%= ,)" "G


%)1"
C% %
5C, =% % C % 1
! $ 5!
$C )
' !
5C % 1*1 $C% )%
/ !
/5C 5 5C % 1*1 % 1 C, , 1
/$ C% )% ) C ,
' 45C G $C %)1" G , C%*, E:
4$ C G 5C %)1" G, , 1C " , E:
'
5C , 1" $C % 1"
C [ [ C , "[ %5 [%% %%$

2 3

&

C , "= %G% 1*1= %% %%G% )% C 11 , E:F %


%
C , "= %G% 1*1 %% %%G ) C 1 E:F
C , " %G 1 %% %%G ) C%* E:F %
%
C , " %G 1 =%% %%G% )% C " E:F
& "$ H $
3 + - 5 4$
/ ," 1 1", * ) *
- ,)1 11" 1 *
/% ), 1 1 ,) 1
<% ) 1 1" " %1 )1 )" %%
/ % *" ,)* *1 ** ) %*
A % % ,)" " * , "
' ! ! !9

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 130


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

C [ [

!
2 + < 3 - I % 1*18% , J 8Q I , %18 % ) J
- A / I % 1*18, , J
+%
A I% "8% , J
/ I% *8, , J

+
Q < I , %18 )J
+

+
&

$C, " 45C $C%1 E:


5C, 1 4$C 5C"1 E:
%
F C 1* *E:F
45F 5C%, **E:F %
4$F 5C % )"E:F %
%
C 1* *= % )"G% 1*1 %, **G% )%C " E:F

2C 1* *= % )"G% 1*1=%, **G )C%)% "% E:F %


3C 1* * % )"G 1 =%, **G )C%% % E:F %
%
&C 1* * % )"G 1 %, **G% )%C1% 1 E:F
%
-C 1* *= % )"G% 1*1=%, **G% , C% ) ) E:F
%
/C 1* *= % )"G% 1*1=%, **G, , C% " E:F
%
AC 1* * % )"G% "=%, **G% , C * 1 E:F

C 1* * % )"G% *=%, **G, C * , E:F %


<C 1* *= % )"G, %1=%, **G )C% E:F %
%
3C 1* *= % )"G, %1 %, **G% )%C %1 E:F
' ! !! ! % ' ' ! ! ' ! ! ' !!
!

O$

u+ C1", =11" 1C 1 % E:
%
C "
? 6 C% , , E:F %
?C% , , E:F %G " %C , ) E:
6 C , ) E:= 1 % E:F%C % )" E:
4 ! 5 C?GI J

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 131


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

% %
C % , ,%E:F GO PC %", 1* E:F
( C C % )"F 1% C,*
3
/ 8 C 1,1 E: - 8+C1%% E:
' ! ! ' 5 ! ! ' ! ! ! !
u 6 ! 6 4 ! (
5 5
% )" %, 1 " 1 ", )
% 1" 1 )1 % " * %% ,1
% % % %, %",) ) * ,)
% 1" "* %)*1 * 1 *" 1
*< .H5 $
0
+ ! ' ! ! ! ! !
; 6

<
&

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 132


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

; 62
/ 1
3 ! ' ' ' ! !!
+ ' ' ' / ' ' ! ' ' 5 5

. C I, = JI, 1=, J
, = C "" * %%I, = JI, 1=, J
C %1 % % "* " %
, . !C, I = ,KJGI )= J
C ,% ") = %G %
, , %=, 0 6 M6 !
, 1=, ' C , ",%

, 1=
, , %=

- ! ! C * E:F %
. C "" * I, = JGI, 1=, J
. C % "1 1% * 11 %
. ! CC ,% ") = %G %
/0 6 M6 ! ' C,"

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 133


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

3 ! ' ' ' ! !!

, =

, =
> !
4 5 !' C ," E: !
. !C, I = ,KJ G
C, G , G ,f G G G, 1))C % E:
. !N 6
! ,6 ' ) ,
C) , , %C1)

! ! ! ! 6

" ," , 1)) %% ) *1 ) 1, *" 1 c%, F *,


" 1% , 1)) * * ) % ** %
%
% 1 % ,, , 1)) % ** % b%, F *,
%% % ,, , 1)) * % ** % b%, F *,

1 %) , 1)) " * " ** % b%, F *,


%, %) , 1)) * * " ** % b%, F *,

% ) % %1 , 1)) % " 11 % ** % b%, F *,


* % %1 , 1)) * ) 11 % ** % b%, F *,
%* * % %1 , 1)) * ) 11 % ** % b%, F *,
1 ) % %1 , 1)) 1 % 11 % ** % b%, F *,

"" " %" , 1)) * ," " ** % b%, F *,


1 %% %" , 1)) * " ** % b%, F *,
)* ) %" , 1)) " "" " ** % b%, F *,
1, 1% %" , 1)) * " ** % b%, F *,

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 134


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

E E! ! ! ! 6

" 1) , 1)) % 1 *)) %% , "% " b%, F ",


1* ," , 1)) , % 4 ) % ** % b%, F *,
%
*" % ,, , 1)) % *% *"* ,, ,% %,* b%, F *,
%1 % ,, 1)) ) ,% 4 % ** % b%, F *,

%*" ) %) , 1)) %1 ,"" , ) ""," " b%, F ,


"% %) , 1)) ), 4 * " ** % b%, F *,

*, * % %1 , 1)) %, ) *" %*"* " % , b%, F *,


* 1 % %1 , 1)) ) "" 4 11 % ** % b%, F *,
*" "% % %1 , 1)) ) %) 4 11 % ** % b%, F *,

* , %" , 1)) " 4 " ** % b%, F *,


"* %" %" , 1)) * 1 4 " ** % b%, F *,

; !

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 135


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

$ 8< ; 8 ;8 "
:* ";" :
, 0 $ 3 % 8 ",
F 8
6
I
! ! $J
J- 8< 9
%
1 ,, ,, "*8) " ),
%, + 6 8 5 ! !
> ! ' '
6
J- 8< 9
%
) %" 1 ,, %)8) * ,
, 4 !
! ! + !
8 8 !
$ 0 ! !
J c) c% , %, %" ,, %8)" %,
J c" ) % % ,, %,8 ,

;:; 9 " ;:
8 N & ?,5& 55

<$ 86" ; 8 ;8 "


:* ";" :
, 0 $ 3 % 8 ",
F 8
6
I
! ! $J

J ! ! % *1 % , ,, %8 "% ,

J ! "% * % , ,, 1181 % 1

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 136


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

J ! %" " % , ,, 8%"% ,


%, + 6 8 5 ! !
> ! ' '
6
J/ 6 8 !9
%
! ! % , , 1, ,, )18 %) ,,
, 4 !
! ! + !
8 8 !
$ 0 ! !
J c) c% %))1 " % ,, 1% 8) ,,
J c" 1 " %" ,, *8%*" "

;:; 9 " ;:
8 N ?%,&? 22 2
= 8%, 8*)* *"

! !
! !
:* ";" :
, 0 $ 3 % 8 ",
F 8
6
I
! ! $J
J ! !
1 1 % , ,, % 8)* %
&1 " % , ,, " 8 * 1
21 1 1" % , ,, *81,, 1

J ! 1" 1 % , ,, * 8% % ,

J ! %" %* % , ,, %8)"% ,
%, 3 !! 3 %,, ' A32
' ' ! !$ ' !
! ' 8
I J+ !' ! **% ,, * ", 18*% %,

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 137


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

, + 6 8 5 ! !
> ! ' '
6
J/ 6 8 !9
%
! ! ") )" 1, ,, 181 , %,
, 4 !
! ! + !
8 8 !
$ 0 ! !
J c) c% %" " * % ,, "" 8" ) 1
J c" %* %, %" ,, 18 * %,
;:; 9 " ;: 8 N ?% ,?2&& %
<
:* ";" :
, 0 $ 3 % 8 ",
F 8
6
I
! ! $J
J- 8< 9
%
% 1) ,, ,, ")8",) ,%
%, + 6 8 5 ! !
> ! ' '
6
J- 8< 9
%
)" 1 ,, % 8 *) 1
, 4 !
! ! + !
8 8 !
$ 0 ! !
J c) c% ),, "* % ,, %,8, 1 %
J c" , 1, %" ,, %8)1) %,
;:; 9 " ;: 8 N 4?)%& &&

= $ 8 8%% %

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 138


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

' ' 7 ! ' ! 6 ! ! !


!$! ! '! ' 6 $! ! ! ' ! $
' 6 ' ' ! ' !$! ! !'
!I J
! !

,8 * *1 8 * 18, ) ,%

1% 81, , 1 8 ,) %8",
1 %) * " 1 8% )
8 8%% % 8%, 8*)* *" ")81" "

C I 8%, 8*)* *" 8 8%% %JG ,,FI 8%, 8*)* *"JC 1 l


! ' 6 !' ! ' ! ! $ ! !! ! ' ' ! $
! ! ' ' 7 ! ! $ ' !
! !
< $ ! ! ! ! ! 6 ! $ > ' ! 8
!' 8 ! 0 0 $ !

' 6 ! ' !' ! ! 6! ' ' '


! ' 6 ' ! ! '

3 !' ' ' 8 ! ' !


/! $ ' ! ! ! ' ! ! '
6 !$ ' !

! ! 6 ' !
!$! 8 ' ' ! ' '

' 0 $ ! !' ' ! ! '

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 139


$ + , structural design & cost comparison June 2008

/' 2 3 8 %8 8 18 9 ) @ **

<> '

E $! ! $ ! 9 !

Mekelle University, Department of Civil Engineering Page 140

You might also like