Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Livestock Science
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/livsci
A R T I C LE I N FO A B S T R A C T
Keywords: Production performance of silkworm (Bombyx mori L., 1758) play a pivotal role in sericulture industry and good
Analytical hierarchy process quality cocoon represents the economic driver of farms. Silkworms are monophagus insects and differences
Cocoon between cocoon characteristics may depend both on mulberry tree leaves quality as well as on genetic selection
Digestive efficiency of hybrid lines. While a huge work was carried out to identify the best feeding sources to optimize yields, genetic
Hybrid line
types of silkworms with desirable production and economic traits were studied to a limited extent to date. This
Silk
experimental feeding trial was carried out using a commercial variety of mulberry tree leaves (Morus alba var.
Ichinose) to feed a total of 1600 silkworms in 4 replicates, allotted into 32 box consisting of 50 larvae each. Feed
consumption, manure production and feed conversion ratios were monitored throughout the experimental
period across five instars of 8 hybrid lines (200 larvae each). Efficiency, Profitability and Eco-compatibility were
identified as criteria to evaluate the best performing hybrid lines: in descending order hybrids 32 × 31,
153 × 154 and 104 × 103 have appeared the best in terms of feed conversion ratio to larva weight gain and to
cocoon weight, shell to cocoon ratio and wet manure per g of dry matter intake per silkworm. Our results point
to promising outcomes as to animal selection to improve yields of silk production at farm level. Sustainable and
modern sericulture industry can therefore point to raise genetically selected hybrid lines of silkworms together
with opportune feeding practices, to optimize feed conversions and rationalize manure in farms.
⁎
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: alirezaseidavi@iaurasht.ac.ir (A. Seidavi).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.livsci.2019.06.015
Received 22 February 2019; Received in revised form 23 June 2019; Accepted 23 June 2019
Available online 24 June 2019
1871-1413/ © 2019 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
R. Samami, et al. Livestock Science 226 (2019) 133–137
The feeding trial took place at the experiment station of Silkworm Data were analyzed by using a one-way ANOVA according to each
Research Centre, which is located in the Pasikhan district of Rasht. hybrid line (8 in total), throughout the five instar stages, in four re-
Silkworm eggs from the 8 hybrid lines, including 31 × 32, 32 × 31, plicates. An analytical hierarchy process (AHP) approach was used to
103 × 104, 104 × 103, 151 × 154, 154 × 151, 153 × 154 and evaluate the different hybrid lines according to production performance
154 × 153, were prepared and hatched. Eggs from every hybrid line (Fig. 1). In particular, the hybrid lines were evaluated by way of three
were allotted into four replicates consisting of 50 live larvae each. To criteria based on Efficiency, Profitability and Eco-compatibility. The
prevent the loss of larvae during the experiment, a number of additional criterion Efficiency was based on feed conversion ratio to weight gain
larvae from each hybrid line was reared as replacers. After weighing as indicator 1 and to cocoon weight as indicator 2; the criterion Prof-
and placing in hatching boxes, silkworm larvae were moved to the itability was based on cocoon weight as indicator 3 and shell to cocoon
hatching room, which is approximately 40 m2s in surface area, under weight ratio as indicator 4; the criterion Eco-compatibility was based
controlled conventional temperature and moisture (room temperature: on wet manure to dry matter intake ratio as indicator 5. Weights were
27–28 °C and relative air moisture: 85–90%, 1st to 3rd instar; room attributed to each criterion by way of an adjusted matrix based on a
temperature:24–26 °C and relative air moisture: 70–80%, 4th and 5th three-level score as follows: 1= alike; 2=preferable; 3= highly pre-
instar). Fluorescent lamps were used in the hatching room and the hall. ferable. The adjusted matrix was created to calculate the weight for
The feeding plan was designed to carry out eight feeding trials, ac- each criterion as reported as Table 2. Significant differences of means
counting four replicates for each trial. Four trays (corresponding to between parameters of production performance according to each hy-
each treatment) were placed following one another, but adequately brid line were used to score (1= worst to 8= best) indicators weighed
separated. For this purpose, metal shelves (called Montan) were used. according to values attributed to the respective criterion of Efficiency,
Such procedure was adopted on each replicate to assure nearly identical Profitability and Eco-compatibility. Pearson's correlation analysis was
environmental conditions, meanwhile preventing different larvae of carried out among variables of interest.
different trays from mixing. Newly hatched larvae from each egg were
placed separately in breeding trays, after body disinfection by way of a
disinfectant powder (a mixture of 5% paraformaldehyde and 95%
134
R. Samami, et al. Livestock Science 226 (2019) 133–137
Fig. 1. Analytical hierarchy process (AHP) of efficiency, profitability and eco-compatibility criteria and respective indicators for the evaluation of production
performance and economic traits of 8 hybrid lines of Iranian silkworms.
Table 3
Production performance of silkworms of the 8 hybrid lines. Values are expressed as mean and pooled S. D. and p-value.
Hybrid lines 31 × 32 32 × 31 103 × 104 104 × 103 151 × 154 154 × 151 153 × 154 154 × 153
Production performance (1–5 instar) pooled SD p-value
−1 a a abc ab c c bc abc
Total feed intake (g*larva ) 25.10 25.07 24.40 24.87 23.76 23.72 24.03 24.33 0.410 0.000
Total DM intake (g*larva−1) 5.300ab 5.325ab 5.125b 5.925a 5.100b 5.225ab 5.700ab 5.750ab 0.324 0.007
Total weight gain (g*larva−1) 3.367a 3.375a 3.350ab 3.375a 3.117ab 2.980b 3.150ab 3.082ab 0.128 0.000
FCR (g feed to g gain*larva−1) 7.463ab 7.375ab 7.300b 7.360ab 7.598ab 7.967a 7.630ab 7.890ab 0.280 0.017
Cocoon weight (g) 1.575ab 1.587ab 1.572ab 1.612a 1.517ab 1.507ab 1.510ab 1.473b 0.053 0.012
Cocoon DM (g) 0.504 0.482 0.475 0.475 0.494 0.507 0.505 0.493 0.030 0.625
FCR (g feed to g cocoon weight) 15.92ab 15.75ab 15.52b 15.43b 15.62ab 15.72ab 16.19ab 16.52a 0.387 0.009
Shell to cocoon ratio 0.233 0.236 0.233 0.231 0.214 0.210 0.240 0.208 0.019 0.145
Wet manure (g*g DMI−1*larva−1) 3.877ab 3.627ab 3.741ab 3.218b 4.081a 4.187a 3.667ab 3.875ab 0.305 0.006
Digestibility of DM 40.37ab 44.13ab 39.02b 50.15a 43.63ab 43.48ab 49.47ab 45.94ab 4.488 0.019
a,b,c,
Superscripts in a same row indicate a statistic significance.
135
R. Samami, et al. Livestock Science 226 (2019) 133–137
Fig. 2. Histogram of the Global Score (minimum 1.003 and maximum 8.024 points) of production performance and economic traits of the different hybrid lines of
silkworms in descending order from the best (left) to the worse (right) performing for profitability, eco-compatibility and efficiency.
silkworm farming practice in light of mass of fresh weight of cocoon acknowledge the kind advice of Mr. M. Mavvajpour, Mr. A.R.
achieved from feed consumption and manure outputs. However, values Bizhannia, Mrs. K.H. Taieb Naeemi, Mr. Y. Kheirkhah and Mr. B. Jelveh
obtained across the 8 hybrid lines did not point to significant differ- and their valuable comments and helpful assistance. Preparation of the
ences between shell to cocoon ratio. In contrast, cocoon weight gave final version of the manuscript was supported by the Opole University
rise to significant differences among the different hybrid lines. As a Grant, Poland (No. 1/KBI/14-S) and the University of Sassari, Italy.
consequence, the heavier the cocoon, the heavier the shell and pupa.
While the pupa is being investigated as potential ingredient in animal References
nutrition, thus favoring the recycling of this by-product, the cocoon
shell weight represents the economic trait of silkworm farming. As to Bongale, U.D., Chaluvachari, B., 1995. Evaluation of eight mulberry germplasm varieties
the eco-compatibility, manure production pointed to significant dif- by leaf biochemical assay moulting studies. Sericologia 35, 83–94.
Cappai, M.G., Wolf, P., Rust, P., Pinna, W., Kamphues, J., 2013. Raw hulled shredded
ferences among hybrid lines. Indeed, also approximate digestibility of acorns from downy oak (Quercus pubescens) in the diet of pigs: effects on digest-
DM pointed to the output of wet manure produced per g of DM intake, ibility and faeces characteristics. J. Anim. Physiol. Anim. Nutr. 97, 1–5.
as significantly affected by the different digestive efficiency displayed Chapman, R.F., 1998. The Insects: Structure and Function, fourth ed. Harvard University
Press, Cambridge, pp. 919.
by the difference hybrid lines, with a direct impact on waste manage- Chinnaswamy, R., Sugnana Kumari, S., Anuradha, C.M., Lakshmi, H., Chitta, S.K., 2010.
ment at farm level. Nutrigenomic analysis of mulberry silkworm (Bombyx mori L.) strains using poly-
merase chain reaction - simple sequence repeats (PCR-SSR). Int. J. Biotechnol. Molec.
Biol. Res. 1, 92–100.
5. Conclusion Datta, R.K., 1992. Guidelines For Bivoltine Rearing. Central Silk Board, Bombay, pp. 19.
ESCAP, 1993. Principles and Techniques of Silkworm Breeding. United Nations, New
York, pp. 114.
The investigation on production performance of the 8 hybrid lines of Hamamura, Y., 1959. Food selection by silkworm larvae. Nature 183, 1746–1747.
silkworm raised in Iran pointed to significant differences in terms of Hamamura, Y., Hayashiya, K., Naito, K., Matsuura, K., Nishida, J., 1962. Food selection
Profitability, Eco-compatibility and Efficiency. In fact, three out of the 8 by silkworm larvae. Nature 194, 754–755.
Hiware, C.J., 2006. Effect of fortification of mulberry leaves with homeopathic drug nux
lines displayed the best production traits. As economically important
vomica on bombyx mori l. Homeopathy 95, 148–150.
traits, the differences in FCR to cocoon weights and similar shell to Horie, Y., Watanbe, H., 1980. Recent advances in sericulture. Annu. Rev. Entomol. 25,
cocoon ratios pointed to different rates achieved by the different hybrid 49–71.
Ito, T., 1980. Application of artificial diets in sericulture. Jpn. Agric. Res. Q. 14, 163–168.
lines, fed with the same variety of mulberry tree leaves. The variety
Kanda, T., 1992. Genetical study of feeding habits of the silkworm, bombyx mori, to new-
Ichinose was administered to silkworms throughout the five instars low cost diet designed by linear programming method and application to the
until pupa stage, for cocoon production. As a direct effect of digestive breeding. Bull. Natl. Instit. Sericult. Entomol. Sci. 5, 1–89.
efficiency, wet manure per g of DM intake gave rise to significant dif- Mavvajpour, M., Mirhosseini, S.Z., Ghanipoor, M., Seidavi, A.R., 2008. Performances of
six iranian silkworm hybrids under four different environmental conditions. J. Agric.
ferences among hybrid lines. In light of the cumulative evaluation Sci. 13, 357–363.
carried out on the basis of Profitability, Eco-compatibility and Meenal, A., Ninagi, O., 1995. Comparative study of ingestion pattern in polyvoltine and
Efficiency criteria, it is recommendable to raise hybrids 32 × 31, bivoltine silkworm races at different feeding levels. Sericologia 35, 747–752.
Mirhoseini, S.Z., Seidavi, A.R., 2011. Iran Silkworm Atlas. University of Gilan Press,
153 × 154 and 104 × 103. Rasht, pp. 282.
Muniraju, E., Sekharappa, B.M., Raghuraman, R., 1999. Effect of temperature on leafsilk
conversion in silkworm bombyx mori l. Sericologia 39, 225–231.
Declaration of Competing Interest Muniraju, E., Sekharappa, B.M., Raghuraman, R., 2003. Relation among food consump-
tion, conversion and cocoon production in silkworm, bombyx mori L. reared at dif-
Authors declare no conflict of interest. ferent temperatures. Int. J. Indust. Entomol. 7, 203–208.
Murugan, K., Jeyabalan, D., Senthil Kumar, N., Senthil Nathan, S., Sivaprakasan, N.,
1998. Growth promoting effects of plant products on silk worm. J. Sci. Ind. Res. 57,
Acknowledgements 740–745.
Nagata, S., Nagasawa, H., 2006. Effects of diet-deprivation and physical stimulation on
the feeding behaviour of the larvae of the silkworm, bombyx mori. J. Insect Physiol.
Financial support by Rasht Branch, Islamic Azad University, grant 52, 807–815.
number 17.16.4.8774 is gratefully acknowledged. The authors Naskar, D., Barua, R.R., Ghosh, A.K., Kundu, S.C., 2014. Silk Biomaterials for Tissue
136
R. Samami, et al. Livestock Science 226 (2019) 133–137
Engineering and Regenerative Medicine. Woodhead Publishing Series in selection efficiency for some quantitative cocoon characters at 3P lines and its cor-
Biometarials, pp. 3–40. relation with reproduction and resistance against diseases parameters of hybrids (F1)
Rahmathulla, V.K., 2012. Management of climatic factors for successful silkworm silkworm. Iran. J. Biol. 20, 262–268.
(Bombyx mori L.) crop and higher silk production: A review. Psyche: A J. Entomol. Seidavi, A.R., 2009. Determination and comparison of nutritional indices in commercial
121234, 1–12. silkworm hybrids during various instars. Asian J. Anim. Vet. Adv. 4, 104–113.
Ravikumar, C., 1988. Western ghat as a bivoltine region prospects, challenges and stra- Vaez Jalali, E., Seidavi, A.R., Lavvaf, A., 2011. Determination and comparison of per-
tegies for its development. Indian Silk 26, 39–54. formance and production properties in eight iranian silkworm hybrids. J. Anim.
Sabhat, A., Malik, M.A., Malik, F.A., Sofi, A.M., Mir, M.R., 2011. Nutritional efficiency of Veterin. Adv. 10, 1141–1157.
selected silkworm breeds of bombyx mori L. reared on different varieties of mulberry Yamamoto, T., Gamo, T., 1976. Studies on the breeding in relation to the improvement of
under temperate climate of kashmir. Afr. J. Agric. Res. 6, 120–126. the food utilisation in the silkworm, bombyx mori l. J. Sericult. Sci. 45 (Japan),
Seidavi, A.R., Bizhannia, A.R., Sourati, R., Mavvajpour, M., 2005. The nutritional effects 81–86.
of different mulberry varieties on biological characters in silkworm. Asia Pac. J. Clin. Zamani, P., Ghanipoor, M., Mirhosseini, S., Abdoli, R., Seidavi, A.R., 2019. Comparison of
Nutr. 14 (Supplement), 1–122. different selection strategies for mulberry silkworm, Bombyx mori. Int. J. Trop. Insect.
Seidavi, A.R., Mirhosseini, S.Z., Bizhannia, A.R., Ghanipoor, M., 2007. Investigation on Sci. 39, 139–145.
137