Professional Documents
Culture Documents
DOI:10.19026/ajfst.11.2664
ISSN: 2042-4868; e-ISSN: 2042-4876
© 2016, Maxwell Scientific Publication Corp.
Submitted: September 12, 2015 Accepted: September 25, 2015 Published: June 25, 2016
Research Article
Osmotic Dehydration Combined with Microwave Drying of Tilapia Fillets: The Impacts of
Osmosis Dehydration
1
Bingyang Hu, 1, 2Zhenhua Duan and 1Yan Liu
1
College of Food Science and Technology, Hainan University, Haikou 570228, Hainan,
2
Hezhou University, Hezhou 542899, Guangxi, China
Abstract: Tilapia fillets were processed by osmotic dehydration combined with microwave drying. The quality
aspects were compared in terms of moisture content, lightness, shrinkage, rehydration and recovery capacity. The
results indicated that saline solution had superior dehydration effect and the solid/liquid ratio had no obvious impact.
With the increase of osmotic concentration, time and temperature, the moisture content, rehydration ratio and
recovery ratio decreased and the shrinkage ratio increased to a certain degree, while the lightness index did not
change significantly. The ideal combination was that the samples were permeated in 20% saline solution with
solid/liquid ratio 1:20 for 2 h at 30°C.
Keywords: Moisture content, osmosis dehydration, osmosis-microwave drying, quality indexes, tilapia fillets
Corresponding Author:Zhenhua Duan, College of Food Science and Technology, Hainan University, Haikou 570228, Hainan,
China
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (URL: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
476
Adv. J. Food Sci. Technol., 11(6): 476-485, 2016
Table 1: Nomenclature
Nomenclature
OD Osmotic dehydration
MD Microwave drying
OD-MD Osmotic dehydration combined
with microwave drying
MC Moisture content
LI Lightness index
SR Shrinkage Ratio
RR Rehydration Ratio
ReR Recovery Ratio
Fig. 2: Effects of osmosis media on moisture content; (a): Shrinkage ratio, rehydration ratio recovery ratio; (b): and lightness
index; (c): of tilapia fillets permeated in 20% solution with solid/liquid ratio 1:20 for 1 h at 30°C
tilapia fillets moisture content is shown in Fig. 3a. As that were obtained under different solid/liquid ratios.
can be seen, the variation of the moisture content was Similar to the conclusion above, the influence of
fairly small. solid/liquid ratio to the permeation process can be
The main reason might be the solid/liquid ratio ignored when the ratio is lower than 1:10. As a result,
values are lower than the point that would significantly the solid/liquid ratio had little impact on these qualities
affect the permeation process. When the solid/liquid indexes.
ratio is relatively high, water exuding from samples On the basis of the above results, it can be
would exert slight dilution effect on the solution, which suggested that there was no obvious impact of
results in slightly decreasing of osmotic pressure and solid/liquid ratio on the process of OD-MD and this
finally influences the samples dehydration to a certain agreed with the study of Xu (2011). Therefore, the
extent. Nevertheless, with the decreasing of the solid/liquid ratio was kept with 1:20 referring to Xu’s
solid/liquid ratio, the dilution effect from the exuding report in the following research.
moisture gradually recedes until it can be ignored when
the ratio drops down to 1:10 or lower. This result was Effect of different osmotic concentrations to
same to the study of Zhang and Cao (2004). In this moisture content and qualities of dried tilapia
work, the range of solid/liquid ratio was 1:10 to 1:25, fillets: Osmotic concentration is a crucial condition of
so these solid/liquid ratios would not contribute permeation process which directly determines the
significantly to the moisture content of the permeated dehydration effect by controlling the osmotic pressure.
and dried products. FigURE 4a reflects the effect of osmotic concentration
Figure 3b and c show the effect of solid/liquid on permeated and dried tilapia fillets. It is evident from
ratio on shrinkage ratio, rehydration ratio, recovery Fig. 4a that the higher the osmotic concentration was,
ratio and lightness index. According to these Figs, there the lower the moisture content remained in permeated
was hardly any difference among the quality indexes and dried products.
479
Adv. J. Food Sci. Technol., 11(6): 476-485, 2016
Fig. 3: Effects of solid/liquid ratio on moisture content; (a): Shrinkage ratio, rehydration ratio recovery ratio (b): and lightness
index (c) of tilapia fillets permeated in 20% saline solution for 1 h at 30°C
It can be interpreted as that with the increase of the 2012). With the osmotic concentration increasing, the
osmotic concentration, on the one hand, the osmotic osmotic pressure differences constantly increased
pressure between solution and fish increases, which following with more moisture and salt molecules
brings greater impetus of mass transfer. On the other transfer. These salt molecules decreased the porosity of
hand, according to Fick's law, the permeation rate from samples, hindered the penetration of external moisture
fillets cell interior to surrounding solution becomes into internal fillet voids during the rehydration process
faster (Mayor et al., 2006; Đspir and Toğrul, 2009). As a and this subsequently reduced the capacity of
consequence, the products treated with higher rehydration and recovery of dried samples (Changrue et
concentration solution can get relatively lower moisture al., 2008). Furthermore, high concentration of
content. permeated solution may cause more moisture transfer
Figure 4b indicates that the shrinkage ratio which results in fish tissue collapse and destruction as
increased, while the rehydration ratio and the recovery well as a small amount of cytoplasm dissolving out (El-
ratio decreased at first and then gradually leveled off Aouar et al., 2006). This not only increased the
with the osmotic concentration increasing. shrinkage ratio of the samples but also generated the
The reason can be explained as follow: There are decrease of the rehydration ratio and recovery ratio.
two opposite mass transfer processes underway in the As is shown in Fig. 4c, there was hardly any
permeation process. One is moisture diffusion from the change in the lightness index of dried tilapia fillets at
interior structure of samples to the exterior permeated different osmotic concentrations. The reasons are
solution; the other is solute diffusion from osmotic primarily as follows: It has been proved that the color
solution to the material internal. The extent of these change of the tilapia fillets is mainly caused by two
two processes is depended on the osmotic pressure reactions during the OD-MD process. One is the
differences of both sides of the cytomembrane (Zou, protein denaturation after heated by microwave, which
480
Adv. J. Food Sci. Technol., 11(6): 476-485, 2016
Fig. 4: Effects of osmotic concentration on moisture content; (a): Shrinkage ratio, rehydration ratio recovery ratio; (b): and
lightness index; (c): of tilapia fillets permeated in saline solution with solid/liquid ratio 1:20 for 1 h at 30°C
causes product color white. The other is the Maillard cells diffused by degrees with the intracellular osmotic
reaction triggered by rich amino acids and sugars in pressure increasing. Thus, the osmotic pressure
tilapia with a high temperature brought by microwave, differences between fish and solution decreased and
which causes product color brown (Yang, 2012). finally resulted in equilibrium of the whole penetration
Nevertheless, these two reactions both have no direct process. When samples were permeated for 1hr,
relation with the osmotic conditions studied in this osmotic pressure differences between the two-phase of
study. So the slightly change brought by different osmosis system still existed so that the dehydration
osmotic concentration caused no marked differences of process proceeded as before. However, when extended
lightness index. to 2 h, the pressure differences became small and the
Therefore, synthesizing moisture content, quality penetration process was close to equilibrium.
indexes including sensory quality and costs, 20% salt
Continuing penetration made no difference to the
concentration was selected as an optimal concentration.
moisture content of the samples, whereas, it would
decrease the sensory quality and nutritional quality of
Effect of varying osmosis time to moisture content
and qualities of dried tilapia fillets: Figure 5a shows the products and samples was easy to be contaminated
the effect of osmosis time on moisture content of by microorganism (Zou, 2012).
permeated and dried tilapia fillets. As can be seen, with Figure 5b, the effect of osmosis time on shrinkage
the extension of osmosis time, the moisture content of ratio showed the trend of increase and then followed by
permeated and dried tilapia fillets decreased at first and flat. At the same time, the rehydration ratio and
then gradually came to flat. The main reason is that, as recovery ratio firstly decreased and then tended to level
osmosis time prolonged, the moisture inside the sample off.
481
Adv. J. Food Sci. Technol., 11(6): 476-485, 2016
Fig. 5: Effects of osmosis time on moisture content; (a): Shrinkage ratio, rehydration ratio recovery ratio; (b): and lightness index
(c): of tilapia fillets permeated in 20% saline solution with solid/liquid ratio 1:20 at 30°C
As previously mentioned, the penetration process from the results analyzed above, 2 h was chosen as the
tends to equilibrium with the extension of osmosis superior osmosis time.
time. However, when the permeation process lasted too
long (permeated for 3-4 h), the outermost cells were Effect of different osmosis temperatures to moisture
observed to be severe dehydrated with cytomembrane content and qualities of dried tilapia fillets: Figure
shrank and collapsed. Meanwhile, the cytosol such as 6a, with the osmosis temperature increased from 10 to
organic acids and minerals effused as well (Wang, 30°C, the moisture content of permeated fillets slightly
2011). Consequently, the cell integrity, even the tissue decreased at first and turned to be steady, while the
structure of material was damaged. The destruction values of dried fillets constantly reduced. The reasons
process was almost irreversible and would ultimately might be that, the increasing of osmosis temperature
cause the increase of shrinkage ratio and the decrease would aggravate the thermal motion of ions and
of the other two quality indexes. In addition, molecules in osmotic solution and then increase the
some scholars believed that the reduction of diffusivity of the system. Therefore, the mass transfer
rehydration ratio and recovery ratio was due to the between osmotic solution and fish was accelerated,
formation of a layer of dense structure and it would which finally leaded to the reduction of moisture
impede further mass transfer (water transfer) during the content (Nahimana et al., 2011).
rehydration process (Singh et al., 2007). Figure 6b shows the effect of osmosis temperature
The effect of osmosis time on lightness index of on shrinkage ratio, rehydration ratio and recovery ratio
dried products is shown in Fig. 5c. From the figure it of dried tilapia fillets. The figure indicates that with the
can be found that there was little difference between increase of osmosis temperature the shrinkage ratio of
samples treated by different osmosis time. Therefore, tilapia increased, while the rehydration ratio and
482
Adv. J. Food Sci. Technol., 11(6): 476-485, 2016
Fig. 6: Effects of osmosis temperature on moisture content; (a): Shrinkage ratio, rehydration ratio recovery ratio; (b): and
lightness index; (c): of tilapia fillets permeated in 20% saline solution with solid/liquid ratio 1:20 for 1 h
Science Foundation of China (Grant No. 31360395, Đspir, A. and Đ.T. Toğrul, 2009. Osmotic dehydration of
No.31060218) for the research work. apricot: Kinetics and the effect of process
parameters. Chem. Eng. Res. Des., 87(2):
Conflict of interests: The Authors declare that there is 166-180.
no conflict of interest. Li, J., B.S. Li and W. Li, 2009. Study of tilapia
pickling technique. Mod. Food Sci. Technol.,
REFERENCES 25(6): 646-649.
Li, J.Y. and Z.H. Duan, 2013. Study on the effect of
Arason, S., 2001. The drying of fish and utilization of vacuum microwave drying on quality of okra.
geothermal energy, the Icelandic experience. Adv. Mater. Res., 791-793: 132-136.
Proceeding of 1st Nordic Drying Conference. Mayor, L., R. Moreira F. Chenlo and A.M. Sereno,
Keynote Lectures, Trondheim, Norway. 2006. Kinetics of osmotic dehydration of pumpkin
Bellagha, S., E. Amami and A. Farht and N. Kechaou, with sodium chloride solutions. J. Food Eng.,
2002. Drying kinetics and characteristic drying 74(2): 253-262.
curve of lightly salted sardine (Sardinella aurita). Men’shutina, N.V., M.G. Gordienko A.A. Voinovskii
Dry. Technol. Int. J., 20(7): 1527-1538. and T. Kudra, 2005. Dynamic criteria for
Changrue, V., V. Orsat and G.S.V. Raghavan, 2008. evaluating the energy consumption efficiency of
Osmotically dehydrated microwave-vacuum drying equipment. Theor. Found. Chem. Eng.,
drying of strawberries. J. Food Process. Pres., 39(2): 158-62.
32: 798-816. Mujaffar, S. and C.K. Sankat, 2006. The mathematical
Drouzas, A.E. and H. Schubert, 1996. Microwave modelling of the osmotic dehydration of shark
application in vacuum drying of fruits. J. Food fillets at different brine temperatures. Int. J. Food
Eng., 28: 203-209. Sci. Tech., 41(4): 405-416.
Duan, Z.H., M. Zhang and J. Hao, 2003. Preparation of Nahimana, H., M. Zhang A.S. Mujumdar and Z. Ding,
crispy bighead carp slices. Sci. Technol. Food Ind., 2011. Mass transfer modeling and shrinkage
2: 44-47. consideration during osmotic dehydration of fruits
Duan, Z.H., J. Shang, S. Xu, X.B. Wang and M.H. and vegetables. Food Rev. Int., 27(4): 331-356.
Raghavan, G.S.V., T.J. Rennie, P.S. Sunjka, V. Orsat,
Yi, 2006. Study on characteristics of hot-air drying
W. Phaphuangwittayakula and P. Terdtoon, 2005.
of tilapia and its main components changes. Food
Overview of new techniques for drying biological
Sci., 27(12): 479-482.
materials with emphasis on energy aspects. Braz. J.
Duan, Z.H., L.N. Jiang, J.L. Wang, X.Y. Yu and T.
Chem. Eng., 22: 195-201.
Wang, 2011. Drying and quality characteristics of
Singh, B., A. Kumar and A.K. Gupta, 2007. Study of
tilapia fish fillets dried with hot air-microwave
mass transfer kinetics and effective diffusivity
heating. Food Bioprod. Process., 89(4): 472-476.
during osmotic dehydration of carrot cubes. J.
Duan, Z.H., Y.D. Wang, J.L. Wang, A.G. Feng and
Food Eng., 79(2): 471-480.
Y.P. Zheng, 2015. Effect of two kinds of osmotic
Stojanovic, J. and J.L. Silva, 2006. Influence of
media on quality of tilapia fillets. Adv. Mater.
osmoconcentration, continuous high-frequency
Res., 1081: 119-124.
ultrasound and dehydration on properties and
El-Aouar, A.A., P.M. Azoubel and J.J.L. Barbosa, F.
microstructure of rabbiteye blueberries. Dry.
Elizabeth and X. Murr, 2006. Influence of the
Technol. Int. J., 24: 165-171.
osmotic agent on the osmotic dehydration of Torreggiani, D., 1993. Osmotic dehydration in fruit and
papaya (Carica papaya L.). J. Food Eng., 75(2): vegetable processing. Food Res. Int., 26: 59-68.
267-274. Venkatachalapathy, K. and G.S.V. Raghavan, 1999.
Garcia-Noguera, J., F.I.P. Oliveira and M.I. Gallão, Combined osmotic and microwave drying of
Curtis L. Weller, S. Rodrigues and F.A.N. strawberries. Dry. Technol. Int. J., 17: 837-853.
Fernandes, 2010. Ultrasound-assisted osmotic Wang, N., 2011. The study of osmosis dehydration
dehydration of strawberries: Effect of pretreatment mass transfer kinetics and the characteristic after
time and ultrasonic frequency. Dry. Technol. Int. osmosis dehydration followed by hot-air drying of
J., 28(2): 294-303. lettuce. Kunming University of Science and
GB5009, 2010. National Food Safety Standard Technology.
Determination of Moisture in Foods. GB5009.3- Xu, C.F., 2011. Studies on mass transfer model of
2010. tilapia fillets during osmotic process and its
Giraldo, G., G., P. Talens, P. Fito and A. Chiralt, 2003. dehydration characteristic under osmotic and
Influence of sucrose solution concentration on microwave. Hainan University.
kinetics and yield during osmotic dehydration of Yang, Y., 2012. Studies on vacuum-microwave drying
mango. J. Food Eng., 58(1): 33-43. tilapia slices. Hainan University.
484
Adv. J. Food Sci. Technol., 11(6): 476-485, 2016
Zhang, H. and A.K. Datta, 2005. Heating Zou, K.J., 2012. Studies on osmotic dehydration and
concentrations of microwaves in spherical and explosion puffing drying of mango. M.A. Thesis,
cylindrical foods: Part two: In a cavity. Food Guangxi University, China.
Bioprod. Process., 83(1): 14-24.
Zhang, M. and H. Cao, 2004. The advances in food
osmotic dehydration research. Dry. Technol.
Equip., 2(4): 3-9.
485