Understanding Measurement Errors in Physics
Understanding Measurement Errors in Physics
2
CHAPTER
5
Desire. He carried out research in acoustics and optics. On February
28, 1928, through his experiments on the scattering of light, he
discovered the Raman effect. He was the first Asian and first non-
White to receive any Nobel Prize in the sciences. In 1941 he was
awarded the Franklin Medal. In 1954 he was awarded the Bharat
Ratna. He retired from the Indian Institute in 1948 and a year later he
established the Raman Research Institute in Bangalore, where he C.V. Raman
worked till his death. 1888-1970
AKASH MULTIMEDIA 40
PHYSICS - I A MEASUREMENTS OF PHYSICAL QUANTITIES
No measurement can be made with complete i) Instrumental errors : These are inherent
'accuracy.' For this , it must be shown by a value errors of the apparatus and the measuring
with infinite number of decimal places. insturements used.
Example : Example :
The length of a straight line is measured a Zero-error of a measuring instrument. If a scale
number of times by a number of observers. The is worn off at the starting end upto 0.3cm reading
following are the results of these measurements. and we do not notice it and treat it as zero, then every
Actual length = 3.785 cm 0.001cm length we measure will be always 0.3cm more than
1st set of measurements 3.8 cm, 3.9cm, 3.7cm the true value.
2nd set of measurements 3.478 cm, 3.479 cm, The instrumental error can be detected by
3.478 cm, 3.478 cm, 3.479 cm interchanging two similar instruments or by using
different methods for measuring the same physical
3rd set of measurements 3.55 cm, 3.65 cm,
3.45 cm, 3.35cm quantity.
4th set of measurements 3.784 cm,3.785 cm, ii) Constant errors : When the result of a series
3.784 cm, 3.785 cm, 3.784cm of measurements are in error by the same
amount, such an error is called constant error.
First set of measurements are accurate because
it is closest to the actual value but not precise. These are also instrumental errors. Zero error is
Second set of measurements are not accurate a constant error.
but it is most precise because the readings are iii) Environmental errors : These arise due to
reproducible. external conditoins, that is, due to changes in the
Third set of measurements are neither accurate evnironment. During the experimnetal measurement
nor precise. there maybe changes in external conditions i.e.,
Fourth set of measurements are accurate as changes in temperature, pressure, humidity, wind
well as precise. velocity etc. For example if a metal scale is calibrated
2.6 CLASSIFICATION OF ERRORS in winter and is used in summer as it expands in
Errors creep in the observed or calculated values summer the measured values will be less than true
due to various reasons. They are categorized under values.
two heads. iv) Personal errors : These are entirely due to the
(a) Systematic errors personal pecularities of the experimenter. Individual
(b) Random errors bias, lack of proper setting of the apparaturs,
2.7. SYSTEMATIC ERRORS carelessness in taking observations (without taking
the required necesary precautions.) etc. are the causes
Error that is allways unidirectional is called for this type of error. A perosn may be habituated to
systematic error hold his eyes (head) always a bit too far to the right
If some error is occurring in the positive (or left) while taking the reading with a scale. This
direction only (or in the negative direction only) all will give rise to parallax error.
the time, it is systematic error.
If a person keeps his eye-level below the level
Example : of mercury in a barometer all the time, his readings
If measured value is allways 2 units more than will have systematic error.
true value it is systematic error. (positive) These errors can be mimimized by obtaining
If measured value is allways 3 units less than several readings carefully and then taking their
true value it is systematic error. (negative) arithmetical mean.
AKASH MULTIMEDIA 41
MEASUREMENTS OF PHYSICAL QUANTITIES PHYSICS - I A
As the lengths are measured to a resolution of This means that the length is (2.62 ± 0.11m)
0.01m, all lengths are given to the second place of i.e., it lies between (2.62 + 0.11 m) and (2.62 –
decimal, it is proper to round off this mean length 0.11m)
also to the second place of decimal. i.e., between 2.73 m and 2.51 m.
In the first measurement 2.11. COMBINATION OR PROPAGATION OF
Error = a1 = 2.63m – 2.62m = + 0.01m ERRORS
Absolute error = 0.01m Suppose we want to calculate acceleration due
2 L
Relative error = 0.01/2.62 =0.0038 to gravity using the formula, g = 4 2
T
Percentage error = relative error x 100 = 0.38
We can measure length L using scale and we
In the second measurement can measure timeperiod T using clock.
Error = a2 = 2.56m – 2.62m = –0.06m There may be errors in all measuring
Absolute error = 0.06m instruments and measurements.
Relative error = 0.06/2.62 =0.023 We should know the errors in individul
measurements of length(L) and time (T) , then combine
Percentage error = relative error x 100 = 2.3
them to find the error in the calculation of ' g '.
In the third measurement So we must know how errors combine(or
Error = a3 = 2.42m – 2.62m = –0.2m propagate) in addition,subtraction, multiplication and
Absolute error = 0.2m division.
Relative error = 0.2/2.62 =0.076 i) Combination of errors in case of addition
Percentage error = relative error x 100 = 7.6 Suppose a physical quantity Z is sum of the
physical quantities X and Y
In the fourth measurement
Z = X+Y
Error = a4 = 2.71m – 2.62m = +0.09m
Let X and Y be the respective absolute
Absolute error = 0.09m errors in X and Y. Then the values of X and Y will
Relative error = 0.09/2.62 =0.034 be X X and Y Y
Percentage error = relative error x 100 = 3.4 Let the error in Z be Z
In the fifth measurement Since Z = X+Y
Error = a5 = 2.80m – 2.62m = +0.18m Z Z ( X X ) (Y Y )
Absolute error = 0.18m Z Z ( X Y ) X Y
Relative error = 0.18/2.62 =0.068 Maximum possible error in Z is Z X Y
Percentage error = relative error x 100 = 6.8 (If Z =X+Y then), Maximum possible error D Z
Mean or final absolute error = absolute error D X +absolute errorD Y
15 a i X Y
Percentage error in Z = 100
5 X Y
(0.01 0.06 0.20 0.09 0.18)m ii) Combination of errors in case of subtraction
5 Suppose a physical quantity Z is difference of the
= 0.54m/5 = 0.108 m = 0.11m physical quantities X and Y
Z=X–Y
AKASH MULTIMEDIA 44
PHYSICS - I A MEASUREMENTS OF PHYSICAL QUANTITIES
Note : In both addition and subtaction maximum iii) Combination of errors in case of
possible error = sum of absolute errors multiplication
Suppose a physical quantity Z is the product of
Problem : 2.3
the physical quantities X and Y
If L = 2.06 cm ± 0.02 cm
B = 1.11 cm ± 0.03cm
Z = XY
What are (L + B) and (L – B) equal to ? Let X and Y be the respective absolute
Sol. L + B = 3.17 cm ± 0.05 cm errors in X and Y. then the values of X and Y will be
L – B = 0.95 cm ± 0.05 cm X X and Y Y
Please note that actual values i.e. 2.06 cm and 1.11 cm Let the error in Z be Z
are added in case of (L + B) and subtracted in case of
Z = XY
(L – B), but absolute errors are added in both cases.
logZ = logX +logY
*Problem : 2.4 differentiating both sides
Two objects A and B are of lengths 5 cm and 7cm dZ dX dY
determined with errors 0.1 cm and 0.2 cm respetively. = +
Z X Y
What is the error in determining (a) the total lenth and
Z X Y
(b) the difference in their lengths ? Maximum relative error
Sol . a = 5cm, a = 0.1cm
Z X Y
DZ D X D Y
b = 7 cm, b = 0.2cm In multiplication (Z=XY), Maximum relative error = +
Z X Y
If x = a + b is the total length, then
iv) Combination of errors in case of division
x = a + b = 0.1 + 0.2 = 0.3 cm and x = ( 5+7) ± 0.3
= (12 ± 0.3) cm.
Suppose X,Y, Z are physical quantitie such that
If 'x' is the difference between the lengths, X
Z
then x = a + b = 0.3cm and Y
x 5 7 0.3 2 0.3 cm
Let X and Y be the respective absolute
errors in X and Y. then the values of X and Y will be
Note : If a 'constant' is multiplied with an observed/
X X and Y Y
measured value, the result will have its absolute error
equal to 'constant' times the absolute error in the Let the error in Z be Z
observed / measured value. This means, the X
percentage error in the result will remain unchanged.
Z
Y
AKASH MULTIMEDIA 45
MEASUREMENTS OF PHYSICAL QUANTITIES PHYSICS - I A
If L = 20.04 m ± 0.01 m
Note : Both in multiplication and division Maximum
B = 2.52 m ± 0.02 m
relative error in the result is the sum of the relative
What are the values of (L × B) and (L / B)?
errors of the quantities being multiplied or divided.
Sol. Given errors are absolute errors, while the rule says that
Similarly Both in multiplication and division percentage errors are to be added. Hence, the first step
Maximum percentage error in the result is the sum will be to convert the given absolute errors into
of the percentage errors of the quantities being percentage errors.
multiplied or divided. 0.01
L = 20.04 m ± × 100%
20.04
*Problem : 2.7 = 20.04 m ± 0.05%
The length and breadth of a rectangular object are 0.02
25.2 cm and 16.8cm respectively and have been B = 2.52 m ± × 100%
2.52
measured to an accuracy of 0.1cm. Find the relative
= 2.52 m ± 0.79%
error and percentage error in the area of the object.
Sol. Area A = l × b L × B = (20.04 × 2.52)m2 (0.05 + 0.79)%
l = 25.2 cm and l = 0.1cm = 50.50 m2 ± 0.84%
b = 16.8 cm and b = 0.1cm This is the result. However, since the data given in the
A b question was in terms of absolute errors, so we should
\ Relative error in area A b give our result also in absolute errors.
0.1 0.1 0 .8 4
L × B = 50.50 m2 ± × 50.50m2
25.2 16.8 100
= 0.004 + 0.006 = 0.01 = 50.50 m2 ± 0.42 m2 Ans.
A Note : The result should be rounded to which place of decimal
100 0.01 100 is explained later in this chapter.
A
Percentage error (a = 1%. Similarly,
L 20.04 m
= ± (0.05 + 0.79)%
* Problem : 2.8 B 2.52 m
In an experiment to determine the value of acceleration 0 .8 4
= 7.95 ± 0.84% = 7.95 ± × 7.95
due to gravity g using a simple pendulum, the measured 100
value of length of the pendulum is 31.4cm known to 1 = 7.95 ± 0.067.
mm accuracy and the time period for 100 oscillations
of pendulum is 112.0s known to 0.01s accuracy. Find v) Combination of errors in case of a quantity
the accuracy in determining the value of g. rised to different powers
Sol. (Accuracy is to be taken as the error involved) Suppose the physical quantity z depends on
the quantity x as z=kxn where k is a constant and n
l = 31.3 cm and l = 1mm = 0.1cm
is a real number
112.0
T= = 1.12s and T = 0.01s Let x and z be the respective absolute errors
100
in x and z.
2
Formula for g is g 4 2
T Let z kx n
AKASH MULTIMEDIA 46
PHYSICS - I A MEASUREMENTS OF PHYSICAL QUANTITIES
AKASH MULTIMEDIA 47
MEASUREMENTS OF PHYSICAL QUANTITIES PHYSICS - I A
AKASH MULTIMEDIA 48
PHYSICS - I A MEASUREMENTS OF PHYSICAL QUANTITIES
AKASH MULTIMEDIA 49
MEASUREMENTS OF PHYSICAL QUANTITIES PHYSICS - I A
4(a) All zeros to the right of a decimal point are * Problem : 2.23
significant if the number is more than one. 60.00 Write down the number of significant figures in the
contains four significant digits. following.
(i) 0.007 (ii) 2.64 × 1024 (iii) 0.2370
4(b) All zeros to the right of the last non-zero
digit after the decimal point are significant. (iv) 6.320 (v) 6.032 (vi) 0.0006032
Sol. (i) 0.007 has one significant figure.
0.007800 has four significant figures. The zero
(ii) 2. 64 × 1024 has three significant figures.
between decimal point and 5 is not significant from
(iii) 0.2370 has four significant figures.
rule-3. But the zeroes after eight are significant.
(iv) 6.320 has four significant figures,
Otherwise it would have been reported as 0.0078,
only with two significant digits. (v) 6.032 has four significant figures.
(vi) 0.0006032 has four significant figures.
5(a) All zeros to the right of the last non-zero
digit in a number having no decimal point are not 2.13. ROUNDING OFF THE NUMBER
significant. The process of omitting the non-significant digits
4060 contains three significant figures as the and retaining only the desired number of significant
zero to the right of six is not significant. digits, incorportating the required modifications to
the last significant digit is called 'rounding off the
40,6000 has also got only three significant number'.
figures.
Rules for Rounding off Numbers :
5(b) However, there is an exception to rule 5(a).
i) The preceding digit is raised by 1 if the
All zeros to the right of the last non-zero digit in a immediate insignificant digit to be dropped is more
number having no decimal point will be significant than 5.
if they come from an actual measurement.
Ex : 5728 is to be rounded off to three significant
Suppose a distance measured in metres is
figures. Here 8 is the non–significant digit to be
reported as 4.500 m having four significant figures. dropped and is more than 5. Hence 5728 = 5730.
Expressed in cms it will be 450 cm. It has only two
ii) The preceding digit is to be left unchanged if
significant figures. To have four significant figures,
the immediate insignificant digit to be dropped is less
we should express it as 450.0 cm. Similarly, if we
than 5.
want to express the value in km, we have to write
the result as 0.004500 km and not as 0.0045 km. Ex : 5728 is to be rounded off to two siginificant
When expressed in mm, the value becomes 4500 figures. Here the immediate or first non–significant
digit to be dropped is 2(along with 8 also) and is less
mm. It has only two significant figures from rule
than 5. Hence 5728 = 5700. In the above two example
5(a). Now arises a problem. We cannot write 4500
1 and 2, zeros are to be placed in the places of digits
mm in any way as we have done with cm and km to dropped. Otherwise the values will change drasticaly.
have four significant figures.
iii) If the immediate insignificant digit to be dropped
To avoid such ambiguity, we write the number is 5 then there will be two different cases (a) If the
in scientific notation as powers of 10. Now 4500 preceding digit is even, it is to be unchanged and 5
mm is written as 4.500×103 mm and by rule 4(a) the is dropped.
number has 4 significant figures. Similarly the result Ex : 6.7258 is to be rounded off to two decimal places
is expressed as 4.500 ×102cm and 4.500 ×10–3 km. (or three significant figures). The digit to be dropped
Note : Very large and very small quantities of physical here is 5(along with 8) and the preceding digit 2 is
measurement are usually expressed in scientific even and hence to be retained as two only.
notation to denote accuracy of measurements. 6.7258 = 6.72
AKASH MULTIMEDIA 50
PHYSICS - I A MEASUREMENTS OF PHYSICAL QUANTITIES
(b) If the preceding digit is odd, it is to be raised Rule 1: In addition or subtraction the final result
by 1. should retain only that many decimal places as
are there in the number with the least decimal
6.7158 is to be rounded off to two decimal
places.
places (or three significant figures). As the preceding
digit 1 is odd, it is to be raised by 1 as 2. Note : In addition and subtraction, the rule is in terms
of decimal places (and not in terms of significant
6.7158 = 6.72
figures)
In the above two example 3(a) and 3(b) zeros
Rule 2: In multiplication or division, the final
should not be placed in places of decimal digits result should retain only that many significant
dropped. Otherwise the number of significant digits figures as are there in the original number with
will drastically change. the least number of significant figures.
* Problem : 2.24 2.14.1. EXPLANATION OF THE RULES
Round off to 3 significant figures: i) Addition and subtraction
(i) 20.96 (ii) 0.0003125 In addition or subtraction of numbers, before
Sol. (i) 20.96 has four significant figures. The fourth signifi- performing the operation we must identify the
cant figure is more than 5 and hence on rounding off to number with the least number of digits after
three significant figures, the given measurement will decimal point (say n ) and round off other numbers
become 20.9 + 0.1 i.e., 21.0. to one extra digit in the decimal part (say n + 1). The
(ii) 0.0003125 has four significant figures. The fourth final result is again rounded off , such that it contains
significant figure is 5 and hence on rounding off to same number of decimal places as that of the number
three significant figures, the given measurement will with least number of decimal places (say n) among
become 0.000312 or 3.12×10–4. This is because 2 be- all other numbers.
fore 5 is an even number.
* Problem : 2.25
2.14. RULES FOR ARITHMETIC OPER- Find the value of 2.2 + 4.08 + 3.125 + 6.3755.
ATIONS WITH SIGNIFICANT FIGURES Sol. Out of all the four numbers 2.2 has got the least number
Because of the errors involved in measurements, of decimal places – one.
the measured values of physical quantities have Hence we should retain only two decimal places in the
limited number of significant figures. To obtain many remaining numbers. Hence 4.08 remains as it is 3.125 is
physical quantities we have to make arithmetic to be rounded off as 3 : 12 (as 2 before 5 is even)
operations (addition, subtraction, multiplication, 6.3755 is to be rounded off as 6.38 (as 7 before 5 is
division etc.) of the measured quantities. To obtain odd). Now adding 2.2 + 4.08 + 3.12 + 6.38 = 15.78.
linear momentum, we have to multiply mass with Finally we should have only one decimal place and
hence 15.78 is to be rounded off as 15.8.
velocity. To obtain velocity we have to divide
distance travelled with time taken. Now, any reuslt * Problem : 2.26
of such operation should also indicate the errors A stick has a length of 12.132 cm and another stick
involved in the original measured values. The result has a length of 12.4 cm.
can never be more accurate than the original (a) If the two sticks are placed end to end, what is
their total length ?
individual measured values.
(b) If the two sticks are placed side by side, what is
So the final result of arithmetic operations the difference in their lengths ?
should never have more significant figures than Sol. (a) Let lengths of the sticks are named as
the least number of signigicant figures in the l 1 = 12.132cm, l 2 = 12.4 cm
original components. Here l2 has one decimal place and l1 has to be rounded
off to have only two decimal places
This results in the following rules. l1 + l2 12.13 + 12.4 = 24.53.
AKASH MULTIMEDIA 51
MEASUREMENTS OF PHYSICAL QUANTITIES PHYSICS - I A
This is to be rounded off to have one decimal place figures (say n)as that of the number with least
only. number of significant figures among all other
The total length is 24.5cm numbers.
(b) l1 = 12.132, l2 = 12.4.
Note : The final result of arithmetic operations should
l1 - l2 = 12.4 - 12.132 never have more significant figures than the least
Here 12.4 has only decimal place and hence 12.132 number of signigicant figures in the original
should have only two decimal places.
components.
l1 - l2 = 12.4 - 12.13 = 0.27
This should be rounded off to have only one decimal
iii) In square root value of the given number,
place. there can be same number of significant figures
l1 - l2 = 0.3 that are present in the given number.
Hence difference of their lenghts is 0.3cm Example : 58.97 7.679
iv) In case of Transcendental Functions:
* Problem : 2.27
Find the value of 44.8 – 21.235. Transcendental functions have the same number of
Sol. Only one decimal place is there in 44.8. Hence the other
significant figures as their arguments.
number is to be rounded off to have two decimal places. Non-algebraic functions like sine, sin –1
21.235 = 21.24 (as 3 before 5 is odd). exponential and logarithmic functions are called
Now 44.8 – 21.24 = 23.56. transcendental functions.
Finally this is to be rounded off to one decimal place
Arguments are quantities on which some
44.8 – 21.235 = 23.6.
operation is performed e.g. in case of sin 30°, 30° is
* Problem : 2.28
argument; in case of log x, x is argument, etc.
AKASH MULTIMEDIA 52
PHYSICS - I A MEASUREMENTS OF PHYSICAL QUANTITIES
Sol. Out of the two numbers 53.2 has three significant dig- * Problem : 2.32
its. So p should be written with 3 + 1 = 4 significantent
The mass of 1.2 cm3of a certain substance is 5.74g.
figures.
calculate its density with due regard to significant fig-
= 3.1415 = 3.142 (as 1 is odd it is raised by one). ures.
3.142
Now = 0.0590601 Sol. Mass, m = 5.74 g, volume, v = 1.2 cm3
53.2
m 5.74 g
This is to be rounded off to three significant figures density, d = =
0.059060 = 0.0591
v 1.2 cm 3
5.74 has significant digits and 1.2 has two significant
* Problem : 2.31 digits.
no need for rounding off.
2.31 Find out the results of the following operations. 5.74
(i) 117.3 × 0.0024 (ii) 9.27 ¸ 41 d= = 4.783333.
1.2
(iii) 42 × 0.041 (iv) 124.2 + 52.487 This is to be rounded off to two significant digits.
(v) 124.2 – 52.487 (vi) 58.97 The density of the given substance is 4.783 = 4.8 g cm–3
(vii) (17.5)2
* Problem : 2.33
Sol. (i) 0.0024 has 2 significant figures. Hence 117.3 is
rounded off to have 2 + 1 = 3 significant figures. It If a circular piece of tin has a measured radius of 2.6
becomes 117 only. cm, then what is its circumference ?
Now 117 × 0.0024 = 0.2808 Sol. r = 2.6 cm
This is to be rounded off to have two significant figures Circumference of circular disc = 2r
only. The result is 0.28.
= 2 × 3.1428 × 2.6
(ii) 41 has only 2 significant digits. Hence 9.27 can
have 2 +1 = 3 significant digits. It has 3 significant Here 2.6 has onley 2 significant digits. Hence in the
digits only. No need for rounding off. abovemultiplication value shoud be written with
9.27 2 +1 = 3 significant figures.
= 0.2260975 This is to be rounded off to two
41 = 3.1428 = 3.14
significant digits. The result is 0.23. Circumference = 2 × 3.14 × 2.6
(iii) Both number have two significant digits. = 16.328
42 × 0.041 = 1.722. This is to be rounded off to 2 sig-
This is to be rounded off to 2 significant digits. Cir-
nificant digits. The result is 1.7.
cumference is 16cm.
(iv) As this is a sum, we have to consider decimal
places. 124.2 has only one decimal place. Hence 52.487 * Problem : 2.34
is to be rounded off to 1 + 1 = 2 decimal places.
The diameter of a sphere is 4.24 m. Calculate its surface
It becomes as 52.487 = 52.49 area with due regard to significant figures.
Now 124.2 + 52.49 = 176.69. This is to be rounded off
Sol. Diameter d = 4. 24 m
to one decimal place. The result is as 176.69 = 176.7.
d 4.24
(v) Here again, we have Radius r = = = 2.12
2 2
124.2 – 52.487 = 124.52.49 = 71.71. This is to be
surface area of sphere = 4 r2
rounded off to one decimal place
The result is 71.7. = 4 × 3.1428 × 2.12 × 2.12
(vi) In the above multiplication 2.12 has 3 significant
58.97 = 7.679. This has got the same number
figures.
of significant digits (4) as 58.97. But for square roots
its is customary to have the number of significant fig- Hence 3.1428 is rounded off to have 3 + 1 = 4 significant
ures one less than the number that is, 7.68. figures. It becomes 3.143.
(vii) (17.5)2 = 306.25. The original number 17.5 has Surface area = 4 × 3.143 × 2.12 × 2.12 = 56.50
only 3 significant digits. And hence the result will be 56.50 this to be rounded off to have 3 significant figures.
306 (Here we have to consider the significant figures). Area is 56.5m2
AKASH MULTIMEDIA 53
MEASUREMENTS OF PHYSICAL QUANTITIES PHYSICS - I A
AKASH MULTIMEDIA 54