Homepage

Accessibility links
• Skip to content
• Accessibility Help
Sign in
• Home
• News
• Sport
• Earth
• Reel
• Worklife
• Travel
• Culture
More menu
Search BBC

What is BBC Future?

Earth

Future Planet

Health Gap

Sustainability on a Shoestring

Time: The Ultimate Guide

The Next Giant Leap

Green Tech
Best of BBC Future

Latest

More

TRENDING

Millions of monarch butterflies

have gone missing - but
solutions are within reach
Share using Email

Share on Twitter
Share on FacebookShare on Linkedin

(Image credit: Getty Images)

By Mia Taylor9th February 2024

Monarch populations are teetering on extinction, their numbers down

to 5% of what they were a few decades ago. Here's what to know and
the simplest way to help.

D
Decades ago, monarch butterflies were so plentiful that the sound emanating from
overwintering groves filled with the brightly coloured insects flapping their wings was
described by observers as being akin to a gentle summer rain or a rippling stream. In
some cases, tree branches would even collapse under the weight of clusters of
monarchs. But recent overwintering counts of the western and eastern migrating
monarchs conducted in California and Mexico make clear that gatherings of that
magnitude are part of a bygone era.

In the forests of central Mexico, where eastern monarch butterflies have long wintered,
the species were estimated to occupy a mere 0.9 hectares (2.2 acres) during the
2023-2024 winter season. That's 59% less than one year earlier, when the
butterflies occupied 2.2 hectares (5.5 acres) – according to the results of an annual
survey released this week by the World Wildlife Fund and its partners.
The 2023-2024 winter figures not only represent the second-worst year ever recorded
for the butterflies in central Mexico since monitoring began in 1993, but the report is
also considered a benchmark for the overall health of the species. There has been a
largely downward trend in the fortunes of the eastern monarch since 1996-1997, when
the butterflies took over 18 hectares (45 acres) of central Mexican forest.

The report follows the release of the 27th annual western monarch count conducted
by Oregon-based Xerces Society for Invertebrate Conservation. The tallies of that
effort, which is focused on the overwintering monarch population throughout coastal
California, found slightly more than 230,000 butterflies across 256 sites. Here, too, the
figures represent a drop from 2023 when the population was around 300,000. Perhaps
more importantly, the latest western monarch population amounts to just 5% of what it
was in the 1980s, when they were estimated to be found in their millions.

"This is absolutely concerning, but perhaps not surprising," says Deborah

Landau, director of ecological management for the global environmental non-profit The
Nature Conservancy, "There are so many factors now adding stress to the monarch
population."

The hopeful news, according to Landau and others involved in studying monarch
populations, is that people increasingly appear to understand the importance of
pollinators such as monarchs. What's more, there are a few key steps individuals can
take to help save monarchs around the globe.

Monarch butterfly populations are declining, but humans can do one easy thing to help.
The forces driving monarch decline
Two distinct populations, the eastern and western monarchs, are being impacted by the
same set of threats: habitat destruction, pesticide exposure and extreme weather
brought about by climate change.

When it comes to habitat, there are very few measures in place to stop development of
areas critical to butterflies, says Emma Pelton, senior endangered species
conservation biologist and western monarch lead for the Xerces Society.

"We do not have comprehensive legal protection for their overwintering sites," Pelton
explains. "Legal protection could help prevent the cutting down of groves of trees that
they need."

In both Mexico and California, a big part of the problem is deforestation driven by
logging, urban development and the demand for agricultural land.

Proliferating use of pesticides has also been devastating for monarchs. A report from
the Endangered Species Coalition identifies monarchs as one of 10 species imperiled
by pesticides, including insecticides, herbicides and rodenticides that are used on crops,
commercial and industrial developments, as well as homes and lawns. Some popular
herbicides used to target weeds in domestic gardens also kill milkweed, which
monarchs depend upon not only as a food source, but to also lay their eggs.

"There are so many more pesticides in use today than historically," says Landau. "And
cumulatively, it's impacting the monarchs more and more."

Finally, there are increasingly frequent extreme weather events triggered by climate
change, which has also been detrimental to the fragile butterflies. Fluctuations in
temperature caused by climate change disrupt and impact the monarch butterfly's life
cycle. At overwintering sites in particular, cold temperatures may cause a switch in the
direction of the migration from southward to northward, for instance.

Temperature also impacts the food sources available to monarchs. "These insects are
very closely tied to the natural cycles of plants that bloom at certain times and are very
dependent on this," says Landau. "If the plants leaf out or flowers bloom too early, then
the monarchs might arrive too late to take advantage of their nectar or leaves. But the
opposite is also true, if the monarchs fly early because it's warm, then they may arrive
before the plants are ready to serve as a food source for them."

Extreme rain events like those California recently experienced can also have a
devastating effect, especially if it coincides with colder temperatures in overwintering
areas. Monarchs have a hard time surviving such conditions for very long.

"I definitely think climate change could be the straw that broke the camel's back for
monarchs when combined with the problems of habitat loss and pesticide use," says
Pelton.
Ranger Timothy Puopolo releases about 125 monarch butterflies in Kingsley Park.
How to help save monarchs
Despite all the challenges they face, there is hope for the monarchs. Their extinction is
not a foregone conclusion, Pelton and other experts say. There is still much that can be
done to help shape the monarch's future.

There is hope, for instance, in the fact that the general public has begun to
realise how critical it is to incorporate plants into landscapes and gardens that support
monarchs.

Monarch caterpillars are 100% reliant upon milkweed for food. The plants also serve
as a host for monarch eggs. And because milkweed plants are inexpensive to purchase
and don't require a great deal of space, they offer an accessible way for the general
public to help the butterflies survive.

"Even if you have a postage-stamp-size backyard, every little bit counts," says Landau,
who stresses that using native milkweed is key.

"Sometimes people plant non-native, like tropical milkweed that has a longer growing
season, which can disrupt the monarch's migration pattern because they might not
leave when they are supposed to," she explains.

Non-native milkweed is also more susceptible to a parasite that's harmful to monarchs,

she adds.
Planting nectar-rich flowers and plants is also critical to a monarch's survival. Like
milkweed, these should be native to your area. In California, some of the native options
include Yarrow, Sunflowers, Coyote Mint, sunflowers and goldenrod.

"Nectar plants that adult monarchs eat are equally important because if they don't have
that food source, they're not going to have the energy to make that migration," says
Kelly Bills, executive director of the non-profit Pollinator Partnership, which focuses its
efforts on supporting the preservation of all pollinators.

For those where planting is not an option, downloading the Monarch Watch app is
another way to help. The app is a community science effort that allows users to
contribute data about where and when monarchs are being spotted using geotagging.

All three experts also suggest one last, perhaps less obvious way to help monarchs in
the longer term: reducing carbon emissions.

"We know that climate change is driving much of this decline for monarchs and other
pollinators, so you can still do your part by taking into consideration – and reducing –
the impact of carbon in your daily life," says Bills.
Share using Email

Share on Twitter
Share on FacebookShare on Linkedin
SHARE

RECOMMENDED ARTICLES

If you find a frozen iguana, don't bring it home

•
 Why 1,000 manatees gathered at a hot spring

The giant structures where underwater life thrives

;
AROUND THE BBC
CULTURE

Why Gen Z are dressing like Mob Wives

WORKLIFE

Big Tech jobs have lost their glamour

TRAVEL

White Lotus 3 Thailand filming locations revealed

Explore the BBC

• Home
• News
• Sport
• Earth
• Reel
• Worklife
• Travel
• Culture
• Future
• TV
• Weather
• Sounds
• Terms of Use
• About the BBC
• Privacy Policy
• Cookies
• Accessibility Help
 • Parental Guidance
• Contact the BBC
• BBC emails for you
• Advertise with us
• Do not share or sell my info
Copyright © 2024 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read about our approach to external linking.