Professional Documents
Culture Documents
To
Law
Chapter 1 Introduction
What is law
1. Rules and regulations that maintain order in society in society
2. Binding standards for behavior
3. Prescribes what is acceptable and what is not acceptable types of
behavior must be rewarded or punished
4. It hold people accountable
5. An attribute to human life
6. To organize the group to ensure its survival
7. An integral part of our lives
8. The body of our lives
9. Prescribes how human beings should ought to behave
10. Orders society
Whites owned most the land whereas black people belong to the
homelands also known as the bantu stands
Systems of the pass laws were based on the 4 key factors of Apartheid
1) White supremacy
2) Land dispossession
3) Economic subjunction
4) Institutionised patriarchy and discrimination
Rule of law and the transitional justice
Rule of law
Law applies equally to everyone
State conduct must be in accordance with and sanctioned by law
Law should apply to everyone
People should receive the equal benefit and protection of the law
State nothing about the substance of the laws. Are, in essence, a set of
procedural guidelines for the enactment of laws.
Generate the morality that makes law possible (inner morality of the
law)
When compared to the Apartheid legal order, the rule of law means
that where there is a deviation from equal benefit and protection of the
law, that deviation cannot be arbitrary and must be justified by, or be in
terms of the Constitution. The Constitution recognises, that as a result
of unfair discrimination on in the past, vast inequalities exist in South
African society. Sec on 9(2) of the Constitution
That ‘to promote the achievement of equality’, legislative and other
measures can be taken to protect or advance those against whom
unfair discrimination was exercised in the past.
The Constitution :
Source of Law
Something that provides authority, a point of origin of law or legal
analysis.
Primary sources
Laws generated by institutions vested with law-making authority
Secondary sources
Provide further information on primary sources of law
State
An organised political community made up of various features,
including people, territory and government.
Government
Individuals and bodies that hold the power or authority to govern a par
cular society.
Primary legislation
Legislation passed by parliament
Secondary legislation on
Legislation, such as regulation, formulated by a minister or o cials in a
department
Ultra vires
To exceed powers which therefore renders it invalid
Doctrine of legality
A minister or other functionary must comply with the Constitution on
and the enabling parent law when making secondary legislation
Ratio decidendi
Reason for the decision
Treaty or convention
A formally concluded (adopted) agreement between states
Ratification
An act of consenting to being legally bound by a treaty or conven on by
a state
Domestication
An act of incorporating a treaty or convention on into national law
Protocol
Agreement to amend, supplement or clarify a treaty or convention
Status quo
The existing state of affair
Introduction
Source of law
Something that provides authority
Legislation
Judicial Precedent
Created by the judicial authority
Is responsible for resolving legal disputes arising from statues
Rules of law that emerge from some type of judgements of the courts
Develop a new legal rules and these cases are not reported even
though they are not reported cases can be brought to a courts attention
by the parties and relied on as the judicial precedent
International law
Body of law created by many countries
Regional law
Members of states of a specific region have law making powers
Customary international law
Section 233 of the Constitution interpretation of the legislation that is
consistent with international law
Section 39 of the Constitution the bill of rights must consider international and
foreign law
Common law
The South African legal system is mainly based on seventeenth and
eighteenth century Roman- Dutch law as influenced by English law.
Common law is therefore an important historical source of modern
South African law. The importance of common law is underestimated
most in the fields of contract, delict, property and criminal law.
The legislative or judicial authority can amend the common law position
on a specific matter in spite of its historical status. This is done by
enacting a new statute or passing a binding judgment which may vary
significantly from the common law position.
It is important to be aware of the fact that where legislation on does not
regulate a specific issue or it is not sufficiently regulated, the common
law can be relied on.
It is, however, important not to create the impression that legislation
and the common law are mutually exclusive. While it is possible that
legislation on could amend or change the common law position, many
common law principles have ultimately been incorporated into South
African legislation.
In terms of sections 8 and 39 of the Constitution there is an obligation
on South African courts to develop the common law in light of the
provisions of the Constitution, specifically the Bill of Rights. The
development of the common law may be necessitated by changing
social conditions, values and contemporary legal needs of society.
Custom
A specific act or form of behaviour in a specific society could develop
into a rule of custom over a long period of me. A custom, however,
does not automatically receive the status of a legal rule. Those who
want the custom to be made a legal rule must assert it and then it must
fulfill various requirements before it can be declared a customary rule
by a court of law.
The requirements are:
1. It must have been in existence for a long time.
2. It must have been observed generally by the community.
3. It must be reasonable.
4. Its content and meaning must be certain and clear.
Indigenous law
Indigenous law is a form of unwritten customary law, which means that
it has become law through customary use, and it cannot be found in a
statute. Long before the Dutch and British brought their legal systems
to South Africa, many indigenous African people inhabited the country
and lived according to their own indigenous legal systems. While many
of these indigenous law rules have fallen into disuse over the centuries,
people still faithfully observe, enforce and comply with some of these
indigenous rules.
The Law of Evidence Amendment Act 45 of 1988 orders that par es
may choose to rely on indigenous law before a court of law. The
advantage seeking to rely on indigenous law is that they do not have to
prove that an indigenous law rule is custom as is the case with
customary law. Courts are under obligation to develop indigenous law
in agreement with the constitutional standard - no rule or principle in
indigenous law may contradict any of the provisions contained in
The Constitution
Modern day commentary on the law
Current authors, in particular law academics at universities write
commentary on South African law. A considerable part of a law
academic’s duties is conduct legal research and to explain legal
problems from a therefore call viewpoint.
This research typically requires the legal scholar to investigate a legal
situation in depth and then to provide critical comments on the legal
status quo.
This includes:
a. A statute.
b. A court judgment.
c. Commentary that another academic has published.
d. The commentaries by these modern-day legal scholars is
recognised secondary source of South African law, however the
commentary is not authoritative and binding, only persuasive.
These arguments are o en used by advocates in support of their
own views and to persuade the court to follow their interpretation
of the law. Sometimes the courts themselves rely on these
secondary sources to inform and support their decisions.
The operational provisions and practical application of the South African Bill
of Rights
Introduction
The bill of rights is set out in chapter 2 of the constitution and consists of
33 sections
Section 7-8 and section 36 are the operational provisions
Operational divisions are divided into 3 different stages
1. Procedural stage
2. Substantive stage
3. Remedies stage
Who may claim these rights
Introduction
Legal rules derive from the sources of law
It is possible to distinguish certain categories of divisions of legal rules
Law as a discipline and its various sub-divisions
Classifying the law into the sub-discipilnes or fields enables lawmakers
to compartementalise the laws that they make
The sub-discipline of law will tell you little about the contractual
agreements and legal remedies
In many instances sub-disciplines can not be separated
Classification of the law also informs us how legal institutions are
structured and organized
International Law
Governing the relations and dealings of the nations with each other
Regulate more than one state
The organization at the center of enforcing international law is the
United Nations
Different sources of international law including
1. Treaties
2. International custom
3. International relations
4. International human rights
There are also international law issues such as
1. Rules for recognition of the state
2. Sovereignty of international crimes doctrine of dealing with international
law norms
National law
The rules apply only within the territory area of South Africa
Substantive Law
Public law
Relationships between the government and the people
Rules that tell us how the state must and may interact with the people
Constitutional law
Constitutes the state
Constitutionalism refers to the protection of the subjects of the state
from arbitrary rule
Administrative law
To regulate how the state goes about its administrative duties
Provides the laws regulating how the state governs
Core of administrative law is set out in section 33 (1)and (2) of the
constitution states that everyone has the right to administrative action
that is lawful reasonable and fair
Criminal Law
Matters where people have been accused of committing crimes
Divided into substantive and the law of criminal procedure
Substantive
Collections of persons as one entity
Regarded by the law as a being or a person
Collection of persons is called juristic persons
Sub-categories of substantive law
Family law
Law of persons
Property law
Law of obligations
Law of personality
Law of persons
Determines a persons status in the eyes of the law
Affects everyone
Legal subjects are capable of holding rights and duties
Deals with important issues such as
Domicile
Citizenship
Adoption
Minority
Prodigality
Curatorship
Insolvency
Legal capacity
Family law
Covers the legal rules applicable to family relationships
Law of patrimony
Regulates the relationship and his/her patrimony
Property law
Regulate the competing interests of legal subjects acquiring property
rights and interests
Persons patrimonial assets within his/her estates
Section 25of the Constitution referred as the property clause which
protects the property
Law of Obligations
Regulates personal rights and obligations
Law of contract
How different forms of contract into being are managed and terminated
Regulates the legal relationships created by people entering into
agreements
Law of delict
Dealing with the circumstances which a person can claim
compensation from another for harm that has been sustained
To deal with the wrongful and blameworthy conduct of a person which
caused harm to another
5 elements that must present before the conduct complained of will be
classified as delict
1. Positive act or omission
2. Wrongfulness
3. Fault
4. Harm
5. Casual link between the act and damage
Law of succession
Deals with what happens to a persons estate after he/she dies
Personality law
Relate to issues of someone’s personality
Law of civil procedure and civil evidence
Is the body of law concerning the claiming of relief by means of civil
proceduring in a court of law
Hybrid sub-divisions
Environmental law
Deals with the issue of sustainable development
Provide resources to sustainable for current and future generations
Focuses on the environmental issues
Legal rules relating to
1. Climate change
2. Protecting plants and animals
3. Protecting people from pollution
Commercial law
Business law or mercantile law
Important for commerce
Encapsulates many different branches of law including the following
Banking and Finance Regulates the powers and functions
of banks
Law of insolvency Concerned with insolvents estates
Labor laws Regulating the relationships between
empolyers and empolyees
Taxation law Relationship between taxpayers and
SARS
Integration of disciplines
The solving of a legal problem mostly require the integration of various
legal disciplines
A single legal problem may require of you to apply different rules and
principles from, for example, the law of contract, the law of civil
procedure and evidence as well as labour law.
South African law, although consisting of different disciplines, should
always be seen as an integrated, closely interrelated whole.
Civil disputes
Refer to the matter to the courts for a resolution
Exists where there are one or more parties sue for or claim something from another
party
The parties are collectively referred to the litigants
Types of disputes
Action
Application
Criminal proceedings
A person complains that the other person has stolen from him or her the state will
still imitate and conduct the criminal proceedings on the behalf of the complainants
Primarily have punishment for the wrong as their aim
Party against whom criminal proceedings are instituted are known as the accused
Process by way of which an accused is brought before a court is referred to as the
prosecution
Interpretation
Law is textual the reading of law is not far removed from the act of interpretation
Most of the theories focus on legislation and have developed into an area of study
referred to statutor interpretation
4 theories of interpretation
FORMALISM Core belief: the law is essentially
separated from questions of
politics and morality. It exists as
a system of ‘self-determining’
rules that can be applied to the
facts of the case in logical
fashion.
• formalism is o en represented
as a calculation:Rules + Facts =
Conclusion• This form of
reasoning is also referred to as a
syllogism.