Professional Documents
Culture Documents
COORDONATOR:
PROF. FAUR ELISABETA SILVIA
CANDIDAT:
DAVID ROXANA-ALESIA
2023
1
Table of contents
Introduction……………………………………..…....3
Chapter I: Sylvia Plath and her work…….…………..5
Chapter II: Summary of The Bell Jar………..……….7
Chapter III: Character analysis - Buddy Willard…… 9
Chapter IV: Character analysis - Doctor Nolan…….. 10
Chapter V: The Fig Tree……………………………. 11
Chapter VI: Cover evolution………………………... 12
Chapter VII: Précis…………………………………...13
Bibliography………………………………………… 14
2
Introduction
The Bell Jar is a classic coming-of-age tale that also serves as a societal critique. I consider
“The Bell Jar” to be a timeless work about the struggles of womanhood, Plath’s attempt to
forge her own destiny and tell her own story in a society that dismisses both the ambitions
and the suffering of women.
It tells the story of Esther, a 19-year-old who wins an essay writing contest organized by a
fashion magazine and as a reward is given a job within a company in New York. There she is
introduced to a glitzy but high-pressure lifestyle whose trappings aggravate her undiagnosed-
but-very-real depression and cause her to suffer a mental breakdown that then prompts her
return to her New England hometown to recuperate.
Despite being published in 1963, Sylvia Plath’s novel has recently gained a lot of popularity
on social media. One reason is that it speaks to the experiences of many young people who
are grappling with issues such as depression, anxiety, and the search for identity. Despite the
existence of better mental health facilities today, the youth is still struggling to make sense of
the post-modern world and often fail to recognize their role in our society. Teenagers and
young adults often face external pressure when choosing a career and are constrained by
society’s expectations.
The publication of Sylvia Plath's novel "The Bell Jar" coincided with the rise of the feminist
movement in the 1960s. This movement aimed to challenge the traditional gender roles and
societal norms that had long restricted women's opportunities and freedoms. As a result of
this movement, women have gained increased legal protections, greater access to education
and employment, reproductive rights, and a shift in cultural attitudes towards women and
their role in society.
Despite these advancements, many women still relate to the experiences of Plath's
protagonist, Esther. Throughout the novel, Esther grapples with numerous challenges related
to her mental health, relationships, and societal expectations. Her struggles with depression,
anxiety, and identity resonate with many women who continue to face similar challenges in
their own lives.
Esther's experiences highlight the ongoing societal pressure on women to conform to certain
expectations and roles. She faces the pressures of achieving success in her career,
maintaining relationships with men, and adhering to societal expectations of beauty and
femininity. Sylvia Plath's "The Bell Jar" remains relevant today as a reminder of the ongoing
challenges that women face in navigating societal expectations and achieving personal
fulfillment.
While "The Bell Jar" includes a romantic plotline, it is not the primary focus of the novel. In
fact, the novel works to challenge the cultural belief that women's primary purpose in life is
to marry and have children. Plath's protagonist, Esther, struggles to find meaning and
fulfilment in a world that limits women's options and opportunities. The romantic
relationships she experiences are fraught with complications and fail to provide her with the
happiness and stability she expects.
3
Instead, the novel's most compelling aspect is its raw and honest portrayal of mental illness.
Plath draws on her own experiences with depression and hospitalization to create a vivid and
deeply personal depiction of the emotional turmoil that people with mental health challenges
often face. Through Esther's experiences, Plath shows how mental illness can impact all areas
of a person's life, from their relationships to their sense of self.
Plath's treatment of mental illness in "The Bell Jar" is ground-breaking in its frankness and
openness. The novel was published at a time when mental illness was highly stigmatized and
rarely discussed in public. Plath's willingness to confront this taboo subject and portray it so
vividly and honestly was a major contribution to the cultural understanding of mental illness.
Overall, "The Bell Jar" is a powerful and thought-provoking novel that continues to resonate
with readers of all ages and backgrounds. Its themes of mental illness, societal pressures, and
the search for identity are as relevant today as they were when the book was first published,
making it a popular topic of discussion on social media platforms.
“The Bell Jar tells the story of a young woman’s breakdown and recovery, but it is also a
devastating critique of a paternalistic psychiatric system that regarded ambition in women as
neurotic.”
“The Bell Jar shows us immense pain, but it also shows us recovery. It's ultimately hopeful.”
4
Sylvia Plath and her work
Sylvia Plath, who was born in 1932, began writing as a child and had her first poem
published at the age of eight. She continued to write throughout her teenage years and was
given the opportunity to edit Mademoiselle magazine in New York City during her third year
of college. However, her time there was not as she had hoped. She spent the month of June
attending fashion events, contributing to features, and helping manage magazine’s day-to-day
production. The pressure was intense, and the experience left her exhausted, disillusioned and
hopeless. Was this all an aspiring woman writer could hope for? Would she be forever
limited to penning fashion captions? Combined with her struggle with clinical depression,
this experience inspired her semi-autobiographical novel, The Bell Jar, which was released in
1963 under the pseudonym Victoria Lucas.
Plath only published one volume of poetry (The Colossus and Other Poems) during her
lifetime, but several other anthologies were released after her death, including Ariel and
Winter Trees. These collections, along with her published diaries, have contributed to the
perception of Plath as the archetype of a depressive and angsty woman. Despite her being one
of the most well-known female writers in the literary canon, she is also one of the most
misunderstood.
Plath's personal life has overshadowed her literary achievements. Her struggles with mental
illness and her tragic suicide at a young age have become the primary lens through which she
is often viewed. This has led to a tendency to read her work solely in the context of her
personal struggles, rather than on its own literary merits.
Plath's reputation as a confessional writer has also contributed to her being misunderstood.
While her work is undoubtedly autobiographical to a certain level, it is important to recognize
that Plath was also a highly skilled poet and writer. Her work should not be reduced to mere
confessional writing, but rather should be read for its artistic and literary qualities.
Plath's passion for writing began at a young age, with her first poem published in a Boston
newspaper when she was just eight years old. Her works regularly appeared in school
magazines, and by the time she was eighteen, her poetry and fiction had been published in the
Christian Science Monitor and Seventeen after more than fifty rejections. She excelled in the
English department at Smith College, where she graduated summa cum laude in 1955 and
won top prizes. Following a Fulbright Scholarship to Cambridge University, Plath began
publishing poems in prestigious literary journals, and her first book of poetry, The Colossus,
received excellent reviews upon its release in 1960.
Plath struggled to write a novel until she was nearly thirty, but The Bell Jar came to her in a
rush while living in London with her husband and young daughter. After a brief
hospitalization, memories of her experience as a psychiatric patient at McLean Hospital in
Belmont, Massachusetts flooded her, and she wrote fluently and without shame about this
painful period in her life each morning. Following her separation from her husband, Plath
became determined to support herself and her children through her writing, hoping to live a
vibrant literary life in London on her own terms. “All I want is my own life,” she wrote to the
5
poet Bill Merwin in November 1962, “not to be anybody’s wife, but to be free to travel,
move, work, be without check.”
Plath initially found the topics of mental breakdowns, suicide attempts, and mental hospitals
too shameful to explore in her own novel in the mid-1950s. However, the success of novels
like Jennifer Dawson's and Shirley Jackson's, which dealt with such themes, inspired her to
consider mining her own psychiatric history. Plath grew more confident and willing to speak
out against the cultural and medical injustices that had threatened her sanity, acknowledging
that the conservative American Cold War culture may have contributed to her breakdown.
The Bell Jar addresses the repressive cultural conditions that limited women's opportunities,
independence, and power. Plath implies that the fashion and beauty industry's exploitation of
female insecurity could have contributed to Esther's breakdown. Esther's protest against
women's objectification and powerlessness is evident when she throws her tight-fitting
wardrobe off the roof of the Amazon hotel. Despite being an accomplished student and
writer, Esther fears that her future will be limited to "a waitress or a typist," highlighting the
societal limitations imposed on women.
The Bell Jar was published in January 1963, and Plath hoped it would be a bestseller, but the
novel's initial reviews did not lead to high sales, despite being favourable. This, along with
other difficulties in her life, brought on severe depression, and Plath died by suicide in
February 1963. The Bell Jar, Sylvia Plath's sole novel, has attained an unprecedented cultural
durability and has come to be recognized as a seminal work of feminist literature, thanks in
large part to extensive promotion and its incorporation into popular culture. The novel's
protagonist, Esther Greenwood, has evolved from a distressed individual to a relatable hero
as a result of these efforts. The Bell Jar has since become one of the most well-known
American novels of the 1900s and a significant touchstone for young women. Sadly, Plath
was unable to witness its tremendous triumph.
6
Summary of The Bell Jar
7
Esther dislikes her psychiatrist, a young, successful man with what appears to be a perfect
family. When she isn't cooperative with Dr. Gordon, he suggests to her mother that her
daughter would benefit from elctro-shock therapy. Esther undergoes one treatment, a
harrowing, painful experience that leaves her terrified of the procedure. At this point, Esther's
thinking becomes more scattered, and she becomes obsessed with suicide. She tries to slit her
wrists, but can only bring herself to slash her calf. She tries to hang herself, but cannot find a
place to tie the rope in her low-ceilinged house. At the beach with friends, she attempts to
drown herself, but she keeps floating to the surface of the water. After several unsuccessful or
aborted attempts she wedges herself into the crawlspace of her house and takes dozens of
sleeping pills. She wakes up in a hospital and is later moved to a state mental hospital.
There she is uncooperative, paranoid, and determined to end her life. Eventually, Philomena
Guinea, a famous novelist who sponsors Esther’s college scholarship, and was once herself
committed to an asylum, pays to move her to a private hospital. In this more comfortable and
humane environment, Esther comes to trust her new psychiatrist, a woman named Dr. Nolan.
She slowly begins to improve with a combination of talk therapy, insulin injections, and
properly administered electric shock therapy. She becomes friends with Joan, a woman from
her hometown and college who has had experiences similar to Esther’s, and who once was
Buddy Willard’s romantic interest. She is repulsed, however, when Joan makes a sexual
advance toward her.
Esther continues to have contact with Joan, who later moves into an apartment, becoming
roommates with a nurse from the hospital. Esther agrees to come visit Joan in her new
apartment, although has no intentions of following through.
As Esther improves, the hospital officials grant her permission to leave the hospital from
time to time. During one of these excursions, she meets a math professor named Irwin. They
end up at Irwin's home, where she loses her virginity. Following intercourse, Esther finds she
is haemorrhaging heavily. She asks Irwin to drop her off at Joan's apartment, and Joan takes
her to the emergency room where she is treated.
Joan soon moves out of her apartment and returns to the hospital. One morning, Joan's
psychiatrist comes to ask Esther if she has any idea where Joan might be, since she hasn’t
returned from the previous evening. Esther doesn't. Later, Joan's body is found in the woods;
she has hanged herself. Buddy Willard comes to the hospital to visit Esther. They both
understand that their relationship is over. Buddy asks whether there is something about him
that drives women crazy, as both Esther and Joan ended up in a mental hospital after being
with him.
The novel ends somewhat openly, with Esther stepping into a room in the hospital where she
will be interviewed to determine whether she can leave the hospital and return to college for
the start of the winter semester.
Esther believes that she has regained sanity, but knows that the bell jar of madness could
descend again at any time.
8
Character Analysis-Buddy Willard
Buddy Willard is important to The Bell Jar because he is Esther's first real "boyfriend."
A reviewer of The Bell Jar once noted that Buddy Willard is a near-perfect representation of
the ideal 1950s American male. At first, Esther admires Buddy's handsome and athletic
appearance, his love for his parents, his academic success, and his ambition to become a
doctor. His parents and Esther’s parents have been friends, and it is clear that both sets of
parents are in favour of this match. However, as she gets to know him better, she discovers
his flaws, and it soon becomes evident that they are not suited to each other.
In spite of the fact that she has adored him from afar for some time, and Buddy, when he gets
to know Esther, is enamored of her intelligence and her poetic sensibilities, Esther realizes
that her feelings for Buddy are not as strong as she thought. Buddy has the attitudes of most
males of his generation, including the notion that Esther will give up the idea of being a poet
once she's had a baby. Esther realizes that while Buddy is intelligent, he is not particularly
thoughtful. He does not understand Esther’s desire to write poetry, telling her that poems are
like dust. He gets a poem published to prove Esther that he is sensitive too, but this gesture
comes across as insincere to Esther, as she knows that Buddy does not truly understand or
value her artistic pursuits.
In terms of his personal life, Buddy is limited by the conventional ideas imposed on him by
his mother. When it comes to his sexuality, Esther finds it lacking in excitement and passion.
His kisses are lackluster and unimpressive, and when he undresses in front of her, he does so
in a matter-of-fact way, with no sense of intimacy or sensuality. He seems to expect that
Esther should simply accept his nakedness as a given, rather than acknowledging the
potential for eroticism and emotional connection in such an encounter.
Esther is only truly happy with Buddy after she finds out that he is taking her to the Yale
prom. That coup and her need for a boyfriend seem to be her major attractions to Buddy.
In the end, Buddy appears to display unconscious cruelty, as he justifies his infidelity by
saying that the waitress was "free, white, and twenty-one," expresses satisfaction when Esther
gets injured on a ski slope, and, during their final encounter, speculates aloud about who
would want to marry her after being hospitalized in a mental institution.
Because of Esther's distaste for Buddy and because he comes to represent hypocrisy in men
in general, and especially after he tells Esther of his summer affair with a waitress, his
character is never developed fully.
The reader sees him, for the most part, as a shallow, insensitive fellow, one who tries to
initiate the innocent Esther into sex by suddenly undressing before her so that she can "see" a
man. When he asks Esther if there is something wrong with him since both she and Joan
Gilling have attempted suicide, we see him again as an almost laughable figure.
9
Character Analysis-Doctor Nolan
Dr. Nolan, Esther's primary psychiatrist after she attempts suicide, is everything her mother is
not. Unlike Mrs. Greenwood, Dr. Nolan understands how a bright, ambitious young woman
such as Esther might chafe under the dominant social expectations for women to be
subservient to men. Eshter has formed what Freud called a “transference” relationship with
her psychiatrist, transferring the feelings that she would normally have for her mother onto
her doctor. In Freudian theory, this relationship marks the beginning of healing, because now
Esther can explore her feelings about her actual mother in the safe space. Doctor Nolan
understands Esther’s hatred for her mother, unlike her first psychiatrist, who condemned her
feelings: ″‘I hate her,’ I said, and waited for the blow to fall. But Doctor Nolan only smiled at
me as if something had pleased her very, very much and said, ‘I suppose you do.‘”
Nolan is also the third successful woman figure in the novel who tries to help Esther, and is
an alternative mother figure to Esther. She is a slim, young psychiatrist and works at the
private hospital where Esther is given insulin and electro-shock treatments after she is
transferred from the state hospital.
Dr. Nolan is a kind, helpful therapist, but she is wrong not to consult Esther before her first
shock treatment as she promised. Esther’s greatest fear is not the therapy, but the possibility
that Dr. Nolan has betrayed her. She explains, “I liked Doctor Nolan, I loved her, I had given
her my trust on a platter and told her everything.”
Even though Dr. Nolan arrives early at the hospital, Esther already knows that she is due for
shock treatment because she did not receive any breakfast.
Dr. Nolan tries to be warm and supportive, but she is not an intellectual equal of Esther, and
Esther does not totally trust her. Dr. Nolan helps Esther by advising her about getting a
diaphram, and, thus, in a practical way, she helps Esther with her fears about sex and getting
pregnant. Esther continues to sort out her feelings about men, recognizing the truth of what
Dr. Nolan says: many women lack tenderness in their relationships with men. Esther
continues to feel she needs to lose her virginity in order to mark her rejection of the
conventional expectation that she will remain “pure” for her husband.
The reader might suspect that Dr. Nolan encourages Esther to leave the hospital before Esther
is ready to be self-sufficient, but otherwise one cannot fault this woman for trying to do her
best, with the limited techniques and ideas available to her.
10
The Fig Tree
11
Analysis on The Bell Jar’s cover evolution over time
Women’s fiction is often treated as a subgenre of fiction itself. This becomes painfully clear
when evaluating the marketing strategies for fiction books written by women.
Because of its recently gained popularity with high school students, and high school girls in
particular, The Bell Jar has sometimes been given a “girly” cover treatment—notably for its
50th anniversary, in 2013. This feels kind of strange because of course, though it concerns the
life of a “college girl”, The Bell Jar is not particularly girly. The Bell Jar is far from being
overtly feminine; in reality, it is quite somber. Its focus lies on mental illness and features
vivid portrayals of electroconvulsive therapy and suicide. However, it also delves into the
theme of ambition and how one can navigate the world's inconsistent limitations and societal
demands to survive.
Emily Harnett, in her article for The Atlantic, discusses how readers who admire female
fiction writers such as Elena Ferrante are infuriated by the simplistic covers of their books,
which suggest that their profound works are nothing more than light, easy reads. This label of
being a "beach read" is perceived as a judgmental categorization that can harm the reputation
of these authors in the eyes of those who consider themselves to be "serious" readers.
The fixation on Plath's image and its portrayal is unparalleled among writers, owing to her
beauty and tragic persona, which our culture tends to conflate. Earlier versions of her image
appear to receive better treatment than later ones, which could be attributed to the growing
cynicism of book publicity. The development of The Bell Jar's cover design is not only linked
to the gender of its author but also to the book's ascent to prominence in American popular
culture.
The anniversary edition of The Bell Jar contributes to the disheartening pattern of
categorizing women's fiction as a genre that men would not typically read and that women
can only identify as being intended for them if a woman is depicted on the cover.
12
50th anniversary edition cover
Précis
The Bell Jar, with its haunting and deeply personal portrayal of mental illness, has become a
cultural touchstone and a beacon of feminist literature. Its influence on generations of
readers, particularly women, cannot be overstated.
As a poet, novelist, and essayist, Plath was a trailblazer who pushed the boundaries of
language and form. Her confessional poetry and unflinching explorations of mental illness,
gender, and identity continue to resonate with readers around the world.
While the world may be more accessible to young women now than it was in the 60s, the
struggle for personal growth and self-discovery remains just as relevant. The Bell Jar reminds
us that it's okay to explore and experiment with different paths until we find the one that feels
right, even if it takes a lifetime. Ultimately, the book's message is one of hope, encouraging
us to keep searching for the fig that will sustain us and nourish our growth, even in the face of
overwhelming choices and uncertainty.
The book's association with lovelorn women in pop culture has overshadowed its more
significant messages, leading some readers to underestimate the depth and complexity of the
novel's themes.
The novel provides a candid and unflinching portrayal of the protagonist's descent into
mental illness, including her experiences with electroconvulsive therapy and her thoughts of
suicide. Plath's willingness to confront this taboo subject and portray it so vividly and
honestly was a significant contribution to the cultural understanding of mental illness at the
time of its publication. The novel helped to break down some of the barriers surrounding
mental health and contributed to the growing movement to address mental illness in a more
open and compassionate way. Today, "The Bell Jar" continues to be an important work in the
literary canon for its depiction of mental illness and its impact on individual lives.
While Plath’s work is undoubtedly deeply personal and draws heavily on her own life
experiences, it is important to recognize that Plath was also a highly skilled writer. Her work
13
should not be reduced to mere autobiographical writing, as this oversimplifies and diminishes
her artistic and literary achievements as a woman. Instead, Sylvia Plath’s writing should be
appreciated for its nuanced exploration of complex themes such as identity, gender, and
mental illness, as well as for its masterful use of language and imagery. By reading Plath's
work in this way, we can gain a greater appreciation for her contributions to literature and
better understand the profound impact her writing continues to have on readers today.
The book's cover designs over the years, and the controversy surrounding them, highlight the
persistent gender biases and stereotypes that exist within the publishing industry and society
as a whole. Despite this, The Bell Jar continues to captivate readers and serve as a reminder
of the power of literature to challenge societal norms and offer insight into the human
condition.
Sylvia Plath should be remembered as an iconic poet and novelist of the 20th century, known
for her vivid and emotionally charged works. While Plath's life undoubtedly adds a layer of
complexity to her literary legacy, it is important to recognize her work as a standalone
achievement.
Bibliography:
https://lithub.com/the-coming-of-age-tale-as-societal-critique-sylvia-plaths-the-
bell-jar-at-60/
https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/rereading-the-bell-jar-by-sylvia-plath-
review-young-and-unhappy-read-this-novel-swkbvhmg2
https://www.nylon.com/articles/bell-jar-female-sadness
https://www.bbc.com/culture/article/20210720-sylvia-plath-the-literary-icon-
destined-to-remain-an-enigma
https://i-d.vice.com/en/article/4a3v79/unpacking-our-undying-obsession-with-
sylvia-plaths-fig-tree
https://faroutmagazine.co.uk/the-cultural-misunderstanding-of-sylvia-plath/
http://letters.to.stephanie.gportal.hu/portal/letters.to.stephanie/upload/
745843_1406744742_07068.pdf
14