You are on page 1of 5

Inventory risk:

XYZ company maintain inventory very seriously based on their analysis but when you went to
physical count of stock then you have encountered stock physical record does not align with
system record.
Q : What are the risk and what will be the audit procedure

Ans. Encountering discrepancies between the physical count of stock and the system records
poses several risks to a company, including potential financial misstatements, operational
inefficiencies, and the risk of fraud. To address these issues, auditors would typically follow
specific risk and audit procedures:

Risk Audit procedure


1. Financial Misstatements: 1. Identification of Discrepancies:
o The primary risk is the o Compare the physical count
potential for financial with the system records to
misstatements in the identify the extent and nature
company's financial of discrepancies.
statements. If the physical o Investigate the reasons behind
count and system records do the differences, such as errors
not align, it may lead to in recording, theft, damage, or
inaccuracies in the reported obsolete inventory.
inventory value, impacting the 2. Risk Assessment:
balance sheet and potentially o Assess the risk of material
the income statement. misstatement in the financial
2. Operational Inefficiencies: statements due to inventory
o Inventory discrepancies may discrepancies.
highlight operational o Evaluate the impact of
inefficiencies in the company's discrepancies on the
inventory management company's financial position,
processes. This could include performance, and cash flows.
errors in recording, inadequate 3. Understanding Internal Controls:
controls, or issues with the o Evaluate the effectiveness of
accuracy of the tracking internal controls over
system. inventory management and
3. Increased Holding Costs: record-keeping.
o Inaccurate inventory records o Identify weaknesses in the
may result in increased holding internal control system that
costs. Excess inventory that is may have contributed to the
not accurately reflected in the discrepancies.
system can lead to unnecessary 4. Audit Sampling:
storage and carrying costs for o Use statistical sampling
the company. techniques to select a
4. Stockouts or Overstock: representative sample of items
o Discrepancies can lead to for physical count verification.
stockouts or overstock o Examine the sampled items for
situations. Stockouts can result accuracy in both physical
in lost sales opportunities, count and system records.
while overstock can lead to 5. Documentation Review:
increased holding costs, o Review supporting
potential obsolescence, and the documentation for inventory
need for markdowns. transactions, such as purchase
5. Customer Service Issues: orders, sales invoices, and
o Inaccurate inventory records shipping documents.
can lead to customer service o Ensure that transactions are
issues, such as delayed order accurately recorded and
fulfilment or the inability to classified in the system.
meet customer demand. This 6. Observation of Physical Counts:
can harm the company's o Observe the client's physical
reputation and customer count procedures to ensure
relationships. they are conducted
6. Obsolete Inventory: systematically and accurately.
o If the system records indicate a o Confirm that the counting team
higher quantity of inventory is independent of the inventory
than physically present, there management process.
may be obsolete or outdated 7. Analytical Procedures:
items in the stock. This poses a o Perform analytical procedures
risk of inventory obsolescence, to assess the reasonableness of
and the company may need to inventory balances in relation
write down the value of such to sales, production, and
items. industry benchmarks.
7. Theft or Fraud: o Investigate any unusual
o Inventory discrepancies may fluctuations or trends.
be indicative of theft or 8. Subsequent Events Review:
fraudulent activities within the o Review subsequent events and
organization. Whether transactions that occurred after
intentional or due to weak the physical count to identify
internal controls, discrepancies any adjustments or
can highlight vulnerabilities discrepancies that might affect
that could be exploited. the financial statements.
8. Regulatory Compliance Risks: 9. Management Inquiry:
o Inaccurate inventory records o Interview management and
may lead to non-compliance inventory personnel to gather
with regulatory requirements, information on any known
affecting financial reporting issues or changes in the
and potentially leading to legal inventory management
and regulatory consequences. process.
9. Supply Chain Disruptions: 10. Adjustments and Corrections:
o If the inventory records are not o Recommend adjustments to the
accurate, it can lead to inventory records based on the
disruptions in the supply chain. findings of the physical count
This may affect production and audit procedures.
schedules, supplier o Ensure that corrections are
relationships, and the overall appropriately reflected in the
stability of the supply chain. financial statements.
10. Impact on Financial Ratios: 11. Fraud Detection:
o Inaccuracies in inventory o Perform additional procedures
valuation can impact financial to assess the risk of fraud,
ratios, such as inventory especially if there are
turnover and return on assets. indications of intentional
Investors and stakeholders may misstatements or irregularities.
use these ratios to assess a 12. Management Representation:
company's financial health and o Obtain written representations
efficiency. from management regarding
the accuracy and completeness
Addressing these risks requires a thorough of the inventory records.
investigation into the causes of the
discrepancies and implementing corrective By following these audit procedures, auditors
measures to improve inventory management can gain a comprehensive understanding of
processes and controls. Auditors play a crucial the reasons behind inventory discrepancies
role in identifying and mitigating these risks and work with the company to address any
during the audit process. issues identified.

Revenue Recognition:
XYZ company maintains and invoices all delivery note on time in system, but they are not aware
when goods is takeover by customer C&F due to invoice team and delivery team are different.
You encountered during your stock count revenue cut-off does not align.
Q : What are the risk and what will be the audit procedure
Ans. Encountering a revenue cut-off mismatch, where the delivery of goods to customers does
not align with the invoicing in the system, poses several risks. This discrepancy can lead to
financial misstatements and impact on the accuracy of the company's financial statements. Here
are some risks associated with revenue cut-off issues and suggested audit procedures:
Risk Audit procedure
1. Revenue Recognition 1. Inquiry and Observation:
Misstatements: o Interview personnel in the
o There is a risk of recognizing invoicing and delivery teams
revenue in the wrong period if to understand the processes
goods are delivered but not and controls in place for
invoiced, leading to potential recording and recognizing
overstatement or revenue.
understatement of revenue. o Observe the handover
2. Inaccurate Financial Statements: procedures between the
o Financial statements may not delivery team and invoicing
accurately reflect the team to identify potential gaps
company's financial or communication issues.
performance and position if 2. Cut-off Review:
revenue cut-off issues are not o Select a sample of transactions
addressed, affecting key around the period-end and
financial ratios and metrics. examine supporting
3. Potential for Fraud: documents, such as delivery
o Revenue cut-off discrepancies notes and sales invoices, to
could be indicative of verify the accuracy of the
fraudulent activities, such as revenue cut-off.
intentional manipulation of o Ensure that goods delivered
revenue recognition to meet are matched with the
financial targets or inflate corresponding invoices and
financial performance. that revenue is recognized in
4. Compliance and Regulatory Risks: the correct accounting period.
o Non-compliance with revenue 3. Analytical Procedures:
recognition standards and o Perform analytical procedures
regulations may result from to compare revenue trends,
incorrect revenue cut-off, sales orders, and delivery notes
exposing the company to with corresponding invoices
regulatory scrutiny and for reasonableness and
potential legal consequences. consistency.
o Investigate any unusual
fluctuations or patterns that
may indicate revenue cut-off
issues.
4. Subsequent Events Review:
o Review subsequent events and
transactions occurring after the
period-end to identify any
shipments or sales that should
be included in the current
period but were recorded in the
subsequent period.
5. Internal Control Evaluation:
o Assess the effectiveness of
internal controls related to
revenue recognition, focusing
on the segregation of duties
between the delivery and
invoicing teams.
oIdentify and test controls that
ensure timely and accurate
recording of revenue
transactions.
6. Documentation Examination:
o Examine documentation, such
as shipping records, delivery
confirmations, and customer
acceptance documents, to
ensure that revenue is
recognized when the risks and
rewards of ownership have
transferred to the customer.
7. Management Representation:
o Obtain written representations
from management regarding
the completeness and accuracy
of revenue cut-off procedures
and the related financial
statements.
8. Fraud Risk Assessment:
o Assess the risk of fraud related
to revenue recognition,
considering factors such as
management incentives and the
control environment.

By conducting these audit procedures, auditors can gain assurance about the accuracy of revenue
recognition and help mitigate the risks associated with revenue cut-off discrepancies. Addressing
these issues is essential for maintaining the integrity and reliability of the financial statements.

You might also like