Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Petra Bizikova*, Keith E. Linder†, be included in the broad spectrum of clinical signs
Steven E. Suter*, Arnaud J. Van Wettere† presented by canine cutaneous epitheliotropic T-cell
and Thierry Olivry* lymphoma.
Accepted 10 February 2009
*Department of Clinical Sciences, College of Veterinary Medicine,
North Carolina State University, Raleigh, North Carolina, USA
†Department of Population Health and Pathobiology, College of
Veterinary Medicine, North Carolina State University, Raleigh,
North Carolina, USA
Correspondence: Thierry Olivry, Department of Clinical Sciences,
Introduction
College of Veterinary Medicine, Veterinary Teaching Hospital, Canine cutaneous epitheliotropic T-cell lymphoma is a
North Carolina State University, 4700 Hillsborough Street, Raleigh, rare progressive neoplastic skin disease affecting the
NC 27606, USA. E-mail: thierry_olivry@ncsu.edu
epidermis, adnexal structures and mucosae. It is caused
Source of Funding
This study is self-funded. predominantly by the proliferation of neoplastic γδTCR+,
Conflict of Interest CD3+ and CD8+ T-lymphocytes.1
No conflict of interest has been declared. Due to the substantial heterogeneity of its clinical and
microscopic features, several different variants have
been described in the literature. ‘Classic’ epitheliotropic
lymphoma is the most common type seen predominantly
Abstract in older dogs,2,3 with median age of 10 years.4,5 Three
The broad spectrum of clinical signs in canine cutaneous clinical stages are recognized: patch, plaque and tumour;
epitheliotropic T-cell lymphoma mimics many inflam- however, an overlap of these stages is commonly seen.
matory skin diseases and is a diagnostic challenge. Canine epitheliotropic lymphomas that present at a tumour
A 13-year-old-male castrated golden retriever crossbred stage from the onset are described as the ‘d’emblée
dog presented with multifocal flaccid bullae evolving form’.3,6 The coexistence of cutaneous epitheliotropic
into deep erosions. A shearing force applied to the skin lymphoma, spleen and lymph node involvement and
at the periphery of the erosions caused the epidermis presence of circulating tumour cells in the peripheral blood
to further slide off the dermis suggesting intraepidermal is described in human medicine as Sézary syndrome. This
or subepidermal separation. Systemic signs consisted form is very rare in dogs.7–9 Another variant of cutaneous
of profound weight loss and marked respiratory distress. epitheliotropic lymphoma in dogs, called pagetoid reticulosis,
Histologically, the superficial and deep dermis were is described as an exfoliative erythroderma with alopecia,
infiltrated by large, CD3-positive neoplastic lymphocytes erosions and ulcers without obvious neoplastic masses.
and mild epitheliotropism involved the deep epidermis, Mucocutaneous junctions and footpads are often affected
hair follicle walls and epitrichial sweat glands. There while generalized skin lesions are a common accompanying
was partial loss of the stratum basale. Bullous lesions feature.3,10
consisted of large dermoepidermal and intraepidermal Canine epitheliotropic lymphoma is considered to be
clefts that contained loose accumulations of neutrophils a ‘great imitator’ because of its considerable clinical
mixed with fewer neoplastic cells in proteinaceous pleomorphism. Indeed, early lesions are often misdiagnosed
fluid. The lifted epidermis was often devitalized and as inflammatory skin disease.2 Four main clinical phenotypes
bordered by hydropic degeneration and partial epidermal are usually seen in this entity: (i) exfoliative erythroderma,
collapse. Similar neoplastic lymphocytes formed small (ii) mucocutaneous form, (iii) tumoural form and (iv) ulcerative
masses in the lungs associated with broncho-invasion. form affecting the oral cavity.6,11
Clonal rearrangement analysis of antigen receptor To emphasize the clinical heterogeneity of this condition,
genes in samples from skin and lung lesions using this paper reports a patient with unusual flaccid vesiculobullous
primers specific for canine T-cell receptor gamma lesions diagnosed with an epitheliotropic T-cell lymphoma
(TCRγ) produced a single-sized amplicon of identical confirmed by histopathology, immunohistochemistry and
sequence, indicating that both lesions resulted polymerase chain reaction (PCR) for antigen receptor gene
from the expansion of the same neoplastic T-cell rearrangement (PARR). Interestingly, the clinical signs and
population. Macroscopic vesiculobullous lesions histopathology closely resemble human bullous mycosis
with devitalization of the lesional epidermis should fungoides (MF).
© 2009 The Authors. Journal compilation © 2009 ESVD and ACVD. 20; 281–288 281
Bizikova et al.
282 © 2009 The Authors. Journal compilation © 2009 ESVD and ACVD.
Canine bullous mycosis fungoides
Figure 2. Skin lesion spectrum found during the examination: (a) An eroded area previously affected with a flaccid vesiculobullous lesion. (b) The
consequence of a shearing force applied to the skin at the periphery of the erosions; the epidermis has slid further off the dermis – the direct Nikolskiy
sign. (c) A depigmentation of the caudal aspect of the nasal planum merged into a well-demarcated patch of alopecia with crusts and scarring affecting
the cranial third of the dorsal muzzle. (d) An erythematous, partially alopecic plaque with partial depigmentation extending to the mucocutaneous junction.
Post-mortem examination
Gross examination revealed a thin body condition with
marked atrophy of axial and appendicular skeletal muscles
and skin lesions compatible with those described above.
Upon opening the thoracic cavity, multiple (40 to 60), 0.3
to 2.0 cm tan-white, firm, spherical masses were dis-
tributed multifocally throughout the parenchyma of the
right and left lung lobes. These nodules had a nearly flat
surface where they contacted the pleura (Figure 3).
Mediastinal lymph nodes were slightly enlarged (approxi-
mately two- to threefold). In the liver, there were a few,
scattered, slightly raised tan nodules of variable size (0.5
to 1.5 cm). A larger (6.0 cm) friable and spherical mass
with a tan to pale mahogany colour was found in the left
lateral liver lobe. The heart appeared grossly normal.
Histopathology
A perivascular to coalescing infiltrate of large neoplastic Figure 3. Post-mortem examination – lungs: Examples of the tan-white,
lymphocytes expanded the superficial and deep dermal firm, spherical masses (0.3 to 2.0 cm, arrows) in the parenchyma of a
stroma and extended a short distance into the panniculus lung lobe.
(Figure 4a). Segments of intimate epidermal contact by
neoplastic cells were accompanied by multifocal areas of
epitheliotropism in the deep epidermis (Figure 4d) and one high-power microscopic field (×400) in most areas. The
in occasional hair follicles and epitrichial sweat glands. cells had small to moderate amounts of grey cytoplasm and
Nuclear profiles ranged from round to slightly oval, were moderate anisocytosis. Discrete Pautrier’s micro-aggregates
sometimes slightly indented and exhibited moderate were not a feature. Vesicular and bullous lesions consisted
anisokaryosis. Zero to four mitotic figures were seen per of dermoepidermal and deep intraepidermal clefts that
© 2009 The Authors. Journal compilation © 2009 ESVD and ACVD. 283
Bizikova et al.
Figure 4. Histopathology: (a) A superficial and deep dermal infiltrate of large neoplastic lymphocytes expands the dermis and superficial pannic-
ulus. Epidermal lifting (arrow) leading clinically to vesiculobullous lesions is apparent even at this low magnification. Haematoxylin and eosin (H&E),
bar = 5.0 mm. (b) Jumbling and loss of basal keratinocytes due to necrosis lead to early intrabasal clefting at the margins of bullous lesions (arrow-
heads). H&E, bar = 100 μm. (c) Bullous lesions consist of large dermoepidermal and deep intraepidermal clefts containing loose accumulations of
neutrophils admixed with fewer neoplastic cells in proteinaceous fluid. The lifted epidermis is undergoing necrosis (asterisk). H&E, bar = 200 μm.
(d) Multifocal areas of epitheliotropism present in the deep portion of the epidermis (arrowheads). H&E, bar = 100 μm. (e) Immunohistochemical
staining of a serial histological section, of the one depicted in image Figure 4d, exhibits diffuse membranous staining of the epitheliotropic and
dermal neoplastic cells with CD3, which confirmed the T-cell origin of the neoplasm (positively stained cells are brown), bar = 100 μm.
contained loose accumulations of neutrophils admixed with was usually extensively collapsed and/or completely necrotic
fewer neoplastic cells in proteinaceous fluid (Figure 4c). often with significant loss of the viable layers of epidermis.
At marginal areas and away from bullous lesions variable Remaining cells exhibited hydropic degeneration usually
basal keratinocyte death and loss, mild to severe, was in marginal areas. These changes were superimposed
evident with vacuolation and disorganization of remaining on a diffusely hyperplastic epidermis with moderate to
basal cells (Figure 4b). Vesicles appeared to form first in marked, laminated, orthokeratotic hyperkeratosis of the
the basal layer and/or in the immediate supra-basal layers stratum corneum, which often formed the central roof
due to loss of keratinocytes. Centrally in vesicles and bullae, of developed bullous lesions. A periodic acid-Schiff stain
where the dermis formed the base, the lifted epidermis revealed an intact basement membrane zone below bullae,
284 © 2009 The Authors. Journal compilation © 2009 ESVD and ACVD.
Canine bullous mycosis fungoides
© 2009 The Authors. Journal compilation © 2009 ESVD and ACVD. 285
Bizikova et al.
Finally, the presence of a plaque-like lesion on the upper Finally, PARR using TCRγ primers confirmed that the skin
lip and depigmentation of the caudal portion of the nasal and lung lesions were the result of a neoplastic expansion
planum led to the inclusion of epitheliotropic lymphoma on of the same T-cell clone. This method is now used to detect
the list of differential diagnoses; however, the coexistence lymphoid malignancies in dogs with a reported sensitivity
of unique vesiculobullous lesions in this patient was not and specificity of approximately 91% and 96%, respectively.17
typical of this entity. Factors affecting the sensitivity of this test include the
In this dog, the histopathology of skin lesions confirmed number of the rearrangements that bind to the TCRγ
the diagnosis of epitheliotropic lymphoma with unusual primers, the number of neoplastic cells in the sample, and
intrabasal and suprabasal clefting that progressed to bulla the quantity of ‘background’ immune cells in the neoplastic
with necrosis of the deep layers of the epidermis. To the lesion. In contrast to studies reported previously, the PARR
best of the author’s knowledge, except for one personal analysis was performed on formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded
observation mentioned in a recent dermatohistopathological tissue. This technique is widely used in human medicine,
publication, a similar combination of clinical and histological and previous studies confirmed an identical sensitivity
lesions has not been described in the veterinary literature.6 regardless of tissue fixation (formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded
Intraepidermal and subepidermal clefting are distinctive versus fresh-frozen tissue) and biopsy site when the
histological features of several autoimmune blistering skin histological degree of confidence was very high (i.e.
diseases and therefore negative immunofluorescence diagnostic).29
test results have been proposed as one of the diagnostic To increase specificity of this technique, the lung and
criteria for human bullous MF.19 The indirect immunofluo- skin tissue samples were duplicated to rule out pseudo-
rescence test utilizing normal and salt-split lip tissue in this clonality, and heating and re-annealing were used to rule
dog failed to detect circulating antibodies against keratino- out any potential oligo- or polyclonality. To the authors’
cytes or basement membrane ruling out the coexistence best knowledge, this is the first reported use of PARR
of epitheliotropic lymphoma and pemphigus vulgaris or followed by amplicon sequence analysis in veterinary
other autoimmune blistering skin disease. medicine to establish that cutaneous and lung lesions are
Similarly, dogs with paraneoplastic pemphigus usually derived from an identical neoplastic clone. This technique
exhibit circulating antibodies against keratinocytes and may be useful in the future to definitively prove that
basement membrane,26,27 and the absence of the antibodies lesions of lymphoid origin at varying sites are the result of
and the histological and clinical incompatibility ruled out the proliferation of one neoplastic clone, multiple clones,
this diagnosis definitively. or that they are not neoplastic.
The mechanism of blister formation in human bullous In conclusion, this report presents a clinically unusual
MF is not clear and it can only be speculated in this patient. case of canine epitheliotropic T-cell lymphoma with
One of the proposed mechanisms for the development vesiculobullous lesions resembling human bullous MF, which
of subepidermal and intrabasal separation is an excessive was diagnosed by histopathology, immunohistochemistry
subepidermal aggregation of neoplastic lymphocytes under and PARR. Moreover, the patient fulfilled the majority
the epidermis with prominent epitheliotropism in the basal of the criteria that have been proposed for diagnosis of
cell layer eventually leading to loss of cohesion between human bullous MF.19
basement membrane and basal cells. Moreover, the release
of cytokines and chemokines from the neoplastic cells These criteria include:
may also interfere with normal epidermal cohesion and
eventually lead to keratinocyte cell death and formation of 1 Clinically apparent vesiculobullous lesions with other
intrabasal or intraepidermal blisters.19 The latter mechanism findings compatible with epitheliotropic lymphoma.
could explain the blister formation in the dog as there was 2 Typical histological features of epitheliotropic lymphoma
individual basal cell necrosis and prominent necrosis of with intrabasal, intraepidermal or subepidermal blisters.
the lifted epidermis. 3 Negative immunofluorescence to rule out concurrent
Another proposed mechanism for intraepidermal blister autoimmune blistering diseases.
development is the coalescence of the Pautrier’s micro- 4 Negative evaluation for other possible causes includ-
aggregates,19 but these were not a feature of this case. ing a lack of previous therapy that can lead to blister
Bacterial culture is recommended in cases of human formation.
bullous MF because some bacteria are known to produce
exfoliative toxins responsible for superficial acantholysis.28 This case report also emphasizes the clinical heterogeneity
Although bacterial culture was not performed, it is unlikely of canine epitheliotropic lymphoma and the suitability of
that bacterial infection alone – even if caused by exfoliative its description as a ‘great imitator’.
toxin-producing bacteria – could explain the depth of the Therefore, macroscopic vesiculobullous lesions with
clefting observed in the canine samples. devitalization of the lesional epidermis should be included
The pulmonary involvement in canine epitheliotropic in the broad spectrum of clinical signs exhibited by canine
T-cell lymphoma is a very rare feature reported previously cutaneous epitheliotropic T-cell lymphoma.
in only one dog with Sézary syndrome.7 This diagnosis
could not be supported in the present case due to a lack
of lymphocytosis and absence of atypical neoplastic Acknowledgements
lymphocytes in the peripheral blood. Regrettably, neither The authors thank Sandra Horton and Monica Mattmuller
flow cytometry nor PARR of peripheral blood could be for careful preparation and processing of the histological
performed. and immunohistochemical slides.
286 © 2009 The Authors. Journal compilation © 2009 ESVD and ACVD.
Canine bullous mycosis fungoides
Résumé Les symptômes du lymphome T épithéliotrope canin présentent une large diversité et peuvent
mimer de nombreuses dermatoses inflammatoires ce qui constitue ainsi un défit diagnostique. Un croisé
Golden Retriever mâle de 13 ans présente une dermatose bulleuse multifocale évoluant en lésions profondes.
Une pression appliquée en périphérie des érosions fait glisser l’épiderme sur le derme, suggérant un clivage
intra-épidermique ou sub-épidermique. Les signes généraux consistent en une perte de poids importante
et une détresse respiratoire marquée. Histologiquement, le derme superficiel et le derme profond présentent
un infiltrat de larges lymphocytes néoplasiques, CD3+ avec un épitheliotropisme modéré de l’épiderme
profond, de la paroi des follicules pileux et des glandes sudoripares épitrichiales. Une perte partielle de la
couche basale est notée. Les bulles consistent en de larges clivages dermo-épidermiques et intra-épidermiques
contenant des neutrophiles et quelques cellules néoplasiques au sein d’un exsudat protéique. L’épiderme
© 2009 The Authors. Journal compilation © 2009 ESVD and ACVD. 287
Bizikova et al.
soulevé est souvent dévitalisé et bordé par une dégénérescence hydropique et un collapsus épidermique
partiel. Des lymphocytes néoplasiques identiques forment de petites masses pulmonaires associées à une
invasion bronchique. Le clonage des gènes codant pour les récepteurs antigéniques dans les échantillons
de lésions cutanées et pulmonaires utilisant des sondes spécifiques pour les récepteurs gamma des cellules
T (TCRγ) produisent des séquences identiques d’amplifications de même taille, indiquant que les deux
lésions sont issues de la même population de cellules T tumorales. Les lésions vésiculo-bulleuses macroscopiques
avec dévitalisation de l’épiderme devraient être inclues dans l’éventail des signes cliniques du lymphome
T épithéliotrope canin.
Resumen El amplio espectro de signos clínicos en el linfoma epiteliotrópico cutáneo canino mimetiza
muchas enfermedades inflamatorias de la piel y es un diagnóstico complicado. Un perro macho castrado
de 13 años de edad de raza cruzada Golden Retriever se presentó con bullas flácidas multifocales que
evolucionaron a erosiones profundas. La aplicación de tracción en la piel de la periferia de las erosiones
producía mayor separación de la epidermis, indicando una separación intraepidermal o subepidermal. Los
signos sistémicos consistieron en pérdida de peso marcada y respiración anormal. Histológicamente la
dermis superficial y profunda estaba infiltrada por linfocitos neoplásicos CD3 positivos de gran tamaño y con
ligero epiteliotropismo en la epidermis profunda, paredes de los folículos pilosos y glandulas sudoríparas.
Había una pérdida parcial del estrato basal. Las lesiones bullosas se formaban por separación dermo-
epidermal e intraepidermal extensa que contenía acúmulos de neutrófilos mezclados con un número menor
de células neoplásicas en fluido proteináceo. La epidermis que se había separado aparecía a menudo
devitalizada y rodeada de degeneración hidrópica y colapso parcial de la epidermis. Linfocitos semejantes
formaban pequeñas masas en los pulmones asociadas con invasión bronquial. El análisis de clonalidad en
el alineamiento de los genes del receptor antigénico en muestras de piel y pulmón, utilizando iniciadores
específicos para el receptor gamma de linfocitos T (TCRγ), produjo un solo amplicón de idéntica secuencia,
indicando que ambas lesiones resultaron de la expansión de la misma población neoplásica. Lesiones
vesiculobullosas a nivel macroscópico con devitalización de la epidermis deben incluirse en el amplio espectro
de signos clínicos con los que puede presentarse el linfoma cutáneo epiteliotrópico canino.
Zusammenfassung Die große Bandbreite an klinischen Symptomen des caninen kutanen epitheliotropen
T-Zell Lymphoms kann viele entzündliche Hauterkrankungen nachahmen und ist eine diagnostische
Herausforderung. Ein 13 Jahre alter, kastrierter Golden Retriever-Mischlingsrüde wurde mit multifokalen
schlaffen Blasen, die sich zu tiefen Erosionen entwickelten, vorgestellt. Scherkräfte, die an den Rändern
der Erosionen auf die Haut ausgeübt wurden, bewirkten, dass die Epidermis sich noch mehr von der Dermis
abhob, was auf eine intra-epidermale oder sub-epidermale Spaltung hindeutete. Die systemischen
Symptome bestanden aus einem markanten Gewichtsverlust und deutlicher Atemnot. Histologisch waren
die oberflächliche und die tiefe Dermis mit großen, CD3-positiven neoplastischen Lymphozyten infiltriert
und in der tiefen Epidermis, in den Wänden der Haarfollikel und in den epitrichen Schweißdrüsen bestand
ein geringgradiger Epitheliotropismus. Das Stratum basale war teilweise verloren gegangen. Die bullösen
Veränderungen bestanden aus großen dermo-epidermalen und intra-epidermalen Spalten, die lose
Ansammlungen von Neutrophilen gemischt mit wenigen neoplastischen Zellen in proteinöser Flüssigkeit
enthielten. Die abgehobene Epidermis war oft devitalisiert und von hydropischer Degeneration und
teilweisem epidermalen Kollaps begrenzt. Ähnliche neoplastische Lymphozyten bildeten kleine Umfangs-
vermehrungen in den Lungen aus, was mit einer Invasion der Bronchien einherging. Bei der klonalen
Rearrangement Analyse der Antigen-Rezeptorgene aus Haut- und Lungengewebsproben mittels Primers,
die spezifisch für den caninen T-Zell Rezeptor Gamma (TCRγ) waren, wurde ein einziges Amplikon gleicher
Größe und identischer Sequenz produziert, was darauf hinwies, dass beide Veränderungen aus der Expansion
derselben neoplastischen T-Zellen Population resultierten. Makroskopische vesikulo-bullöse Läsionen mit
Devitalisierung der läsionalen Epidermis sollten in die große Bandbreite der klinischen Symptome, die von
einem caninen kutanen epitheliotropen T-Zell Lymphom präsentiert werden können, inkludiert werden.
288 © 2009 The Authors. Journal compilation © 2009 ESVD and ACVD.