Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Muromachi (1333–1568)
Circumstances must indeed be unusual for an emperor to rebel, but that is
what happened next. A succession dispute had emerged between two
branches of the imperial family, which had been resolved with an agreement
to alternate the throne between the two lines after 1290. Rather than
abdicate to that other branch of his own family, however, in 1331, Emperor
Go-Daigo (r. 1318–1339) rebelled. The Kamakura Shogunate might have
had the military resources to contain this rebel emperor, but too many
warriors rallied to the imperial cause instead. Even some of Kamakura’s
own leading vassals defected, including a man named Ashikaga Takauji
(1305–1358). Takauji’s mother was from the Hōjō family of Kamakura
regents, and he claimed descent from a branch of the Minamoto family.
With such leading vassals turning against it, in 1333, the city of Kamakura
was burned, the Hōjō family and its remaining faithful retainers committed
mass suicide, and the Kamakura Shogunate came to an end.
Emperor Go-Daigo’s aspiration was not merely to keep the throne but
to achieve a genuine imperial restoration: a return of real power from the
military headquarters of the shoguns to the central imperial government.
Emperor Go-Daigo therefore made his own son shogun, and combined the
previously separate offices of civilian and military provincial governor into
a single new office that was to be appointed by the emperor rather than by
the shogun. Leading warriors were naturally dissatisfied with being
excluded by this imperial arrangement, however, and rivalries between
great warriors also created fissures at the court. In 1336, Ashikaga Takauji
forcefully expelled the emperor from Kyōto, enthroned a new emperor of
his own choosing, and had himself appointed shogun in 1338. Takauji thus
became the first in a new line of Ashikaga shoguns. This Ashikaga
Shogunate is also called the Muromachi period, after the name of the
section of Kyōto where the Ashikaga shoguns established their
headquarters.
But Emperor Go-Daigo did not relent. After being driven from the
capital, he took refuge at a location south of Kyōto called Yoshino. There
were now two imperial courts, and sporadic warfare between these
“Northern and Southern dynasties” would continue for more than half a
century, until 1392. Questions of imperial legitimacy were now subsidiary
to personal ambition, however, as warriors used the pretext of loyalty to one
or the other emperor to raid their neighbors and acquire land. In 1351,
Ashikaga Takauji himself even changed sides, after his brother had
temporarily gained the upper hand in Kyōto. Once Takauji had defeated and
killed his brother, he changed sides again. It has been observed that
Takauji’s rise was accomplished through three betrayals: first of Kamakura,
then of Emperor Go-Daigo, and finally of his own brother. Japan was
entering an age of instability, when it became commonplace for vassals to
treacherously overthrow their lords.
Ashikaga Takauji returned the seat of power to the imperial capital
Kyōto, though he made sure that real power remained in the shogun’s hands
rather than the emperor’s. Kyōto flourished once again, and the Ashikaga
shoguns were now able to tap into a growing urban commercial economy.
By the time the Northern and Southern dynasty courts were reunified in
1392, under the third Ashikaga Shogun Yoshimitsu (1358–1408), most of
the Shogunate’s revenue actually came from trade: from taxes on shipping,
at barrier gates and markets, and on wealthy money lenders and sake
brewers. Yoshimitsu also sponsored trade with China, approaching the
Ming Dynasty with a request for a resumption of friendly relations in 1401.
The Ming Dynasty interpreted his lavish gifts as tribute, and in 1403, the
Ming even conferred on Yoshimitsu the title “king of Japan” (the memory
of which has outraged modern Japanese nationalists because it disregards
the legitimate Japanese emperor). It was this commercial prosperity that
made possible Yoshimitsu’s construction of his fabled Golden Pavilion
(Kinkaku-ji) in 1397, a literally gilded retreat in the northwestern suburbs of
Kyōto (see Figure 5.4).
Even at its peak, however, the Ashikaga Shogunate’s control over the
countryside beyond Kyōto had been limited. Ashikaga Takauji had worked
to appoint many of his own relatives as provincial governors (or
“constables”), but this was an age when even family loyalty could not be
depended on, and the provincial governors – or their deputies – tended to
become independent regional lords. After the assassination of the sixth
Ashikaga Shogun in 1441, the power of the shoguns effectively ended. As
the Shogun Yoshimasa (1435–1490) explained in 1482, “the daimyo do as
they please and do not follow orders. This means there can be no
government.”55
This word, daimyō, was a relatively new term that would continue to
be important in Japan until the late nineteenth century. Literally, it means
“great name,” and it refers to the holders of many rice fields. Unlike the old
aristocratic estates of the Heian and Kamakura periods, which had been
scattered across many locations and involved a complicated hierarchy of
production rights culminating in great court nobles or temples, the lands of
these new daimyō were now compactly consolidated territories dominated
by on-the-spot warlords from heavily fortified castles. These daimyō
exercised largely independent authority over domains that even came to be
referred to as “countries” (kokka).
A dispute between the Hosokawa and Yamana families over who
should succeed Yoshimasa as shogun resulted in the outbreak of the so-
called Ōnin War (1467–1477) in 1467. This war lasted for a decade and
involved hundreds of thousands of warriors, yet it was fought mostly in the
streets of Kyōto, and neither the shogun nor the emperor involved himself
in its conduct. Amid the battles, Kyōto was reduced to two separate walled
and moated camps about a half mile apart. Much of the rest of the city was
destroyed by fire. As one contemporary recorded, “across our charred land,
all human traces have been extinguished. For blocks on end, birds are the
sole sign of life.”56
Having been notably ineffectual in handling the warrior squabbles that
devastated his capital, in the wake of the Ōnin War the Shogun Yoshimasa
retired to his villa in the Eastern Mountains (Higashiyama) section of
northeastern Kyōto. There he cultivated the arts, and constructed an
intentionally rustic Silver Pavilion (Ginkaku-ji), into which he moved in
1483. Although it is called the Silver Pavilion, it was never in fact coated
with silver leaf – an omission that only intensifies the contrast with the
garishness of Yoshimitsu’s older and more ostentatious Golden Pavilion on
the other side of town.
If Yoshimasa was a failure as a warrior leader, he was an outstanding
patron of the arts. Yoshimasa actually helped establish many of the cultural
styles that we have come to think of as “traditionally Japanese.” These
included a conscious aesthetic of rustic simplicity. Yoshimasa’s Silver
Pavilion became something of a model for the “traditional” Japanese house,
including such characteristic touches as tatami matting on the floors (which
became widespread only in the fifteenth century), sliding internal papered
partitions called shōji, a special alcove for the display of artwork (the
tokonoma), and staggered wall shelves. Other features of traditional
Japanese culture that were particularly cultivated, if not actually invented,
in this period include Nō theater (developed in the late fourteenth and early
fifteenth centuries out of older entertainments), the art of flower arranging
(ikebana), raked-sand gardens, and linked-verse poetry (renga). Although
tea drinking had been introduced from China centuries earlier, the first
known use of the Japanese word for the tea ceremony, chanoyu, appears in
1469, and the characteristically Japanese art of tea matured in the time, and
in the company, of the Shogun Yoshimasa.57 (Still other aspects of
“traditional” Japanese culture are even more recent, such as Kabuki theater,
the geisha girl, the “Way of the Warrior” bushidō, and such cooking styles
as tempura and sushi.)
Kyōto was ravaged by the Ōnin War, and in the war’s aftermath the
great lords and their warriors returned to the provinces, leaving behind a
now powerless shogun and emperor. Although the last Ashikaga Shogun
would not be driven from Kyōto until 1573, after 1467 there simply was no
effective central government in Japan. The century following the Ōnin War
is often called the Warring States period. It was a century of conflict and of
almost total decentralization. In the provinces, governors found themselves
unable to control their own subordinates, who were often themselves
confronted with similar insubordination from below. As one European
observer reported in 1580, Japan was “continually torn by civil wars and
treasons, nor is there any lord who is secure in his domain. This is why
Japan is never a firm whole, but is always revolving like a wheel; for he
who today is a great lord, may be a penniless nobody tomorrow.”58
Rural society, meanwhile, reorganized itself from scattered farm
residences into more compact villages, often initially with a defensive
orientation. Although the samurai had originally been household attendants
of top court nobles, now many wealthy peasants who happened to possess
swords, a little land, and ties of vassalage to some lord began to call
themselves samurai. At least in places, samurai may have made up as much
as 20 percent of the rural population.
Even as decentralization reached an extreme, however, some of the
more successful and energetic of the two or three hundred daimyō who
divided the Japanese islands between themselves at the start of the sixteenth
century began reversing the process and consolidating their control over
surrounding land and warriors. Some daimyō began conducting systematic
land surveys to convert their domains into more closely integrated
economic units. The income of vassals gradually began to be assessed in
regular standardized units (called koku), and this was eventually translated
into an actual paid salary, as daimyō began to pull their samurai off the land
and into permanent residence as garrisons in the daimyō’s castle. In the
sixteenth century, some daimyō even began to issue their own money, and
the increasing monetization of the economy enabled the mobilization of still
larger armed forces and the construction of even greater fortifications. In
1568, one daimyō named Oda Nobunaga (1534–1582) marched into Kyōto,
and the great age of Japanese reunification began.