Professional Documents
Culture Documents
NOTES 851
age capacity. We simply have the computer store only the A SCREEN-CAGED THERMOCOUPLE
number of root intersects in a vertical scan and then dump
the rest of the data for that scan, thus drastically reducing PSYCHROMETER AND CALIBRATION
storage requirements. Rotating the photographic image 90° CHAMBER FOR MEASUREMENTS OF PLANT
did not affect the goodness of fit, thus indicating the validity
of using nonrandom vertical scans. This may not hold true AND SOIL WATER POTENTIAL
for all types of root systems, but for corn and soybeans, we
have encountered sufficient root branching to prevent a biased Ray W. Brown and James M. Collins1
orientation of root placement during photography.
This method of determining root length is fast. Table 1 ABSTRACT
shows the time required to complete three scanning replications. Estimates of water potential with thermocouple psy-
Included in this time interval is the calculation of root length chrometers are subject to errors due to temperature gradi-
plus hard copy printout of each of the three replications and ents. The objective here is to describe the design and
their average. A scanning interval of 14 columns (35 vertical construction procedures of a new screen-cage single-junc-
scans per replication) provides accurate and fast sampling. tion psychrometer that minimize these errors. The screen-
cage design restricts entry of contaminants into the psy-
Routine Root Scanning Procedure chrometer cavity; allows rapid vapor equilibration be-
tween the sample and the psychrometer; and provides a
Once the photography technique has been developed for a 360° concentric evaporation surface that reduces the in-
given root system (image with proper contrast between root fluence of vapor condensation due to temperature gradi-
and background), a set of calibration pictures is taken using ents. In addition, a calibration chamber that can also
known lengths of string or thread with size and color similar be used for plant and soil samples is described.
to the roots, keeping all conditions constant (i.e., camera focal Additional index words. Thermocouple psychrometer,
length, size of root photography area, lighting conditions, film Temperature gradient effects, Water potential estimates,
type, and development). When root pictures are to be digitized, Psychrometer design criteria, Screen-caged psychrometers.
the calibration pictures are digitized first. The computer then
calculates the calibration regression equation and stores it for
later conversion of root intersects into root length. Root trans-
ECENT evidence shows that temperature gradi-
parencies can be mounted in individual slides or left uncut in a
continuous strip.
The scanning and digitizing takes only 5 sec per picture.
R ents cause spurious estimates of water potential
with thermocouple psychrometers (15, 16). Errors due
Eye fatigue is minimal using this technique. One person can to temperature gradients are particularly severe with
easily digitize over 500 root pictures in 8 hours under ideal double-junction units and with those that are enclosed
operating conditions that require a minimum of adjustment
on the digitizer. This compares with about 25 pictures a day within end-window type chambers. Double-junction
for one person using older versions of Newman's technique. psychrometers (5, 8) mask the detection of tempera-
Roots can be scanned directly, rather than using photographic ture gradients by reducing the magnitude of zero-offset
images. We use the photographic technique for three reasons: voltages to near zero, hence errors are not readily
1) it generally is not feasible to have the computer and digitiz- evident (16). Psychrometers with end-window geome-
ing equipment in the same laboratory where the roots are try enclosed in solid chambers of either Teflon (4) or
being prepared; 2) too much computer "dead time" would be
wasted waiting for the next root sample to be prepared and stainless steel can trap condensed water within the
positioned prior to scanning; and 3) the photographic tech- chamber. Voltage outputs from these units can be
nique provides a hard copy, permanent record of the roots. either erroneously low or high as a result of tempera-
Original cost of the system (excluding computer) in 1974 was ture gradients (15). Psychrometers with both the dou-
~$15,000. While this cost is substantial, it does represent a ble-junction and end-window design features are most
tremendous savings as compared with the manual labor and subject to error.
time needed to determine root length by other line-intersects
methods. This equipment can also be used for other measure- Single-junction thermocouple psychrometers with a
ments, like leaf area determinations and other image processing concentrically located junction surrounded by a cy-
procedures.
lindrical sample surface appear to be least subject
to temperature gradient errors (15). Ceramic units,
such as those manufactured by Wescor (Wescor, Inc.,
Logan, UT 84321)2 and screen-caged units (2) gen-
erally meet these criteria; however, both models have
some advantages. Ceramic cup units lag behind actual
changes in soil water potential, particularly under
drier conditions when liquid contact is lost between
soil particles and the ceramic (2). Also, salt adsorp-
tion by the ceramic matrix may be a problem in saline
soils. The original screen-caged psychrometers (2)
were designed with a large-mesh screen that may have
allowed soil particles or other matter to contaminate
the thermocouple junction (6), although recent re-
search showed this to be insignificant (4). In addition,
1
Plant physiologist and forestry technician for the Intermoun-
tain For. and Range Exp. Stn., Forest Service, USDA, Ogden,
Utah 84401, respectively, stationed at the Forestry Sciences Lab.,
Logan, Utah. Received 5 July 1979.
"Use of trade or firm names is for reader information only,
and does not constitute endorsement by the USDA Forest Ser-
vice of any commercial product or service.
a52 AGRONOMY JOURNAL, VOL. 72, SEPTEMBER-OCTOBER 1980
bient temperature.
Increased use of thermocouple psychrometers to .MELTABLE,SHRIINK
TUBING LINER
measure soil and plant water potentials in both the
field and the laboratory requires a more reliable de- POLYPROPYLENE’ SHRINK
TUBING LINER
sign. Also, it would be advantageous to measure the
MYLAR SHIELD
water potential of in situ soil, soil samples, or plant &COLOR-CODED INSULATION
tissues interchangeably. We present design criteria for
a new screen-caged psychrometer that appears more re- EPOXY RES IN
liable and versatile, together with design features for
a unique calibration chamber to be used with this
psychrometer. -TEFLON PLUG
U
Design and Construction