Professional Documents
Culture Documents
com
ScienceDirect
Procedia CIRP 40 (2016) 568 – 573
13th Global Conference on Sustainable Manufacturing - Decoupling Growth from Resource Use
Abstract
Machining of composite materials is difficult due to the high abrasiveness of reinforcing constituents. This creates friction between work piece-
tool-chip interfaces resulting in high temperatures. The risk of developing elevated temperatures can be controlled by coolants, however, they are
known to cause environmental problems. In the interest of ecological and environmental safety the global focus is towards achieving sustainable
manufacturing. In the present study, a pressurized liquid nitrogen (LN2) feeding system is developed to supply LN2 over the tool edge-work piece
interface. Comparative experiments are carried out during cutting of Al-5%TiCP under cryogenically chilled air (CCA), LN2, wet and dry
conditions. It is found that LN2 reduces surface roughness, tool wear and cutting temperatures. Further, there is a reduction in built up edge
formation. LN2 assisted machining has shown to improve machinability of composites while achieving sustainable manufacturing.
©© 2016
2016 The
TheAuthors.
Authors. Published
Published by
by Elsevier
Elsevier B.V.
B.V.This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
Peer-review under responsibility of the International Scientific Committee of the 13th Global Conference on Sustainable Manufacturing.
Peer-review under responsibility of the International Scientific Committee of the 13th Global Conference on Sustainable Manufacturing
Keywords: Type your keywords here, separated by semicolons ;
2212-8271 © 2016 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
Peer-review under responsibility of the International Scientific Committee of the 13th Global Conference on Sustainable Manufacturing
doi:10.1016/j.procir.2016.01.135
Sravan Kumar Josyula et al. / Procedia CIRP 40 (2016) 568 – 573 569
wet cutting conditions. This result was attributed to the rapid LN2 exactly on the machining interface based upon a new
abrasion of the cutting tool (coated tungsten carbide) by the concept of having a high lubricity despite of penetration of
particles even under wet cutting conditions suggesting the LN2. In this research work, turning experiments on Al-5%TiCP
incapability of the cutting fluid to create any protective film composites are carried out under LN2 as coolant and lubricant.
which would reduce the frictional conditions on the tool flank Tool wear and surface roughness are the two important
face. Due to effective cooling, prominent results were performance characteristics considered in this work.
witnessed at higher cutting speeds (240 m/min) in terms of Comparative studies are carried out to analyze the effectiveness
cutting forces and reduced tool flank wear. Under wet cutting of LN2 with dry, wet and cryogenically chilled air (CCA). The
conditions, surface quality was found to have deteriorated by experimental results indicate that the new method can be
using coolant. Also the micro-hardness of the machined surface applied to industry for improving operation environment and
increased. In another study Shetty et al., [7] examined the lowering manufacturing costs.
machining performance of DRAC under steam, oil oblique
water emulsion and dry conditions. It was inferred that high 2. Experimentation
pressure steam improves the turning performance of DRAC
composites in terms of cutting force and cutting temperature Machining studies were carried out on Al-5%TiCP
reductions. From these studies it can be clearly understood that composite fabricated by stir casting process under inert
conventional coolants fail to provide desirable cutting atmosphere. The chemical composition of matrix material,
temperature in the cutting zone. reinforcement properties are given in Table 1. 5% TiC particles
Global focus is towards achieving sustainable were preheated at 300oC and introduced into molten metal in
manufacturing, in the interest of ecological and environmental the form of capsules during mechanical stirring. A blanket of
safety. Liquid nitrogen (LN2) is an ecofriendly coolant and argon gas was maintained to prevent reaction of molten
lubricant used for the desirable control of cutting temperature aluminum with atmosphere. After addition of TiC particles, a
and enhancement of the tool life [8]. It also reduces power 15 min nonstop stirring produced a homogenous mixture. This
consumption and friction force, improves dimensional mixture of molten metal was poured into a mold to form test
accuracy, surface quality, chip breakability and chip removal material in bars. These bars were fully heat treated to the T71
for precision machining [9]. Further, it reduces manufacturing condition before carrying out the cutting experiments.
cost and manufacturing time by providing machining with
higher cutting speeds [10]. Different cryogenic machining Table 1. Work material details
strategies such as 1) Cryogenic pre-cooling the workpiece/tool Titanium carbide (TiC): Source: Himedia labs Pvt Ltd
2) Indirect cryogenic cooling 3) Cryogenic spraying and jet Density: 4900 Kgm-3
cooling (by delivering the cryogen to the tool-chip or tool/work Average particle size: -325 mesh size
interfaces) have been applied to the cutting operations. (40microns)
Aluminium (Al): Commercially pure aluminum
In all of the three strategies, the cooling effect is observed
composition (by weight %) Si, 0.15; Fe,
to be the cryogenic spray and jet cooling strategies, however 0.15; Cu, 0.021; Ti, 0.053; Mg, 0.92;
have shown both cooling effect as well as lubrication effect. Mn, 0.044; Zn, 0.072; Cr, 0.005; Al
Studies by Hong et al., [11] studies reveal that LN2 possesses remaining
lubrication effect. A fluid cushion was formed by LN2 at the Workpiece material: Al-5%TiCP composite
tool-chip interface and provided a lubrication effect by Manufacturing method: Stir casting (argon gas as blanket)
absorbing heat and evaporating quickly. Thus the feed force Dimension of work piece: 30 mm diameter×150 mm length
decreased at cold temperatures because of the lower friction
between the chip and tool face. This lower friction can be 2.1. Liquid nitrogen supply system
achieved by reducing the cutting temperature and micro scale
hydrostatic effect. In order to maximize the hydrostatic effect
LN2 should be applied as close as possible to the contact area
with high pressure [12].
Singh et al., [13] used cryogenic spray method for
improving the grindability of ceramic matrix composites. It
was observed that that there is an improvement in surface
quality of the ground surface with cryogenic cooling because
of lubrication effect of cryogenic mist at grinding zone under
high pressure application of the cryogen. It was also stated that
specific grinding energy was reduced by cryogenic cooling,
depending on the reduction in cutting forces.
In the past few decades, numerous studies have been carried
out on cryogenic machining. However, machinability studies in
cryogenic machining of MMCs are very limited. Further Fig. 1. Schematic view of LN2 supply system
effective supply of liquid nitrogen into the chip-tool interface
has shown to improve the machining performance. The main LN2 supply system was developed in which the jet flow
objective of this study is to develop a supply system to apply parameters (pressure and flow rate) and cooling distance were
570 Sravan Kumar Josyula et al. / Procedia CIRP 40 (2016) 568 – 573
adjustable. A schematic design of LN2 supply system is shown machined surface. The flank wear was measured using tool
in Fig.1. The experimental setup consists of cryogenic tank, makers microscope (Olympus STM6). The temperature under
compressor, a servo valve, pneumatic pressure gauge, solenoid all machining conditions around the chip at the cutting zone
valve, and a specially designed L shaped nozzle (shown in was monitored using thermal IR imaging camera which was
fig.2), LN2 pressure regulator, and rotameter for LN2 flow rate positioned 350mm from the top of the cutting tool.
measurement.
3. Results and discussion
Table 2. Details of cutting tool & Machining condition 3.1 Surface roughness
Tool geometry
Tool holder and its P type tool holder in k20 grade
common angles (20×20×125); Inclination angle: -60,
orthogonal rake angle: -60, orthogonal
clearance angle: 60
approach angles ψ 900
(degree)
Cutting insert PVD Coated carbide insert of
CNMG1204 in grade of KCU10
Rake angles γ (degree) 0, 4, 8, 12, 16
Nose radius re (mm) 0.4
Process parameters
Cutting speed vs (m/min) 250
Feed rate f (mm/rev) 0.3
Depth of cut ap (mm) 0.5
Environment Dry, Wet, CCA, & LN2
Coolant distance (mm) 10
significantly affecting the quality as well as the rate of The variation in average flank wear (Vb) as a function rake
production [14]. This could be the reason why more grooves angle during turning of Al-5%TiCP is shown in Fig. 6. It is
result upon dry machining when compared with CCA and LN2. observed that as rake angle increases, flank wear value
LN2 condition gives more cleaned surface than CCA. This increases due to variation in contact area between workpiece-
supports the surface roughness value discussed earlier tool interfaces. Under LN2 lubrication conditions the maximum
wear values reduced by about 28-48%, 15-47% and 12-42%
when comparing with dry, wet cutting, and CCA at various rake
angles. This is occurred due to significant reduction in
temperature under CCA and LN2 than dry and wet condition.
Further, recent studies have revealed that LN2 acts as lubricant
under high pressure. This might be a reason for low flank wear
in LN2 than CCA condition. CCA provides the same cooling
a b c effect as LN2 but the fluidization effect varies. Pressurized
liquid state LN2 breaches the space between tool and work
Fig. 4. Microscopic images of surface topography of machined composite at piece due to its effective evaporation rate and creates a cushion
0o rake angle under dry, wet and cryogenic condition.
effect which reduces wear. Similar trend has been seen in one
of the previous work [12], where higher pressure LN 2, enters
3.2 Tool wear
effectively into interface zone and results in relatively lower
frictional forces, leading to lower cutting temperature.
During machining of MMCs, tool wear is not only intensive
but also irregular due to the presence of hard reinforced
particles in the matrix this further causes premature failure of
tool. The primary wear mechanism of the tools was abrasion
wear of the tool face by the reinforcement particles, with the
greatest wear on the flank face of the tool. Two body and three-
body abrasion causes flank wear between the tool and work
piece [17]. This occurs due to softening of matrix and easy
removal of particles at high cutting temperature. Therefore,
change in contact area and proper lubrication strategies will
directly influence cutting temperature and frictional generated.
This study is an attempt to investigate the effect of LN2 cutting
fluid on flank wear while turning of Al-5%TiCP composite.
Fig. 6. Flank wear measured under various rake angle while turning under
various lubrication strategies
around the tool and the workpiece. Figure 9 shows some of the
chip shapes obtained during machining of composite under
different cutting conditions. It is clear that the chip shapes
formed during LN2 assisted machining of Al-5%TiCP
composite are in the form tubular and helical chips are formed.
Fig. 8. Sample thermal image while turning of Al-5%TiCP under (a) Dry (b)
Wet (c) CCA (d) LN2.
on outer surface of the chip. This is due to the matrix material References
undergoing shear by the movement of cutting. Once the
[1] Sayuti, M., B. T. H. T. Baharudin, M. K. A. Arifin, S. Sulaiman, and T. R.
material was sheared, the amalgamation of voids forms cracks
Vijayaram. Manufacturing and Properties of Quartz (SiO2)
and they propagate in a zig-zag manner along the shear plane ParticulateReinforced Al-11.8% Si Matrix Composites. INTECH Open
throughout the thickness of the chip. Segmented chips are Access Publisher, 2012.
formed due to fracture. Propagation of fracture through the [2] S. Jerome N, B. Ravi Sankar ,Pranab Kumar Mahato ,S. Natarajan
matrix material seems to develop along the stress concentration Synthesis And Evaluation Of Mechanical And High Temperature
Tribological Properties Of In-Situ Al–Tic Composites, Tribology
zone, i.e. at the boundary of the TiC particles with in the matrix.
International 2010; 43: 2029–2036.
In comparison among various conditions, LN2 chips found to [3] Luliano L, Settineri L and Gatto A, ‘High-speed turning experiments on
be more brittle and chip break occurs more easily than other metal matrix composites’, Composites Part A 1998, 29A, 1501–1509.
conditions (refer Fig. 10). [4] Quan YM, Zhou ZH and Ye BY , ‘Cutting process and chip appearance of
aluminum matrix composites reinforced by SiC particles’, Journal of
Materials Processing Technology 1999, 91, 231–235.
4. Conclusions
[5] Hung NP, Yeo SH and Oon BE, ‘Effect of cutting fl uid on the
machinability of metal matrix composites’, Journal of Materials Processing
The performance of LN2 assisted machining process during Technology 1997, 67, 157–161.
turning of Al-5%TiCP composite has been demonstrated [6] Kannan S and Kishawy HA, ‘Tribological aspects of machining aluminium
successfully. LN2 machining endow machinability of MMC metal matrix composites’, Journal of Materials Processing Technology
2008, 198, 399–406.
when compared with dry, wet and CCA. LN2 assisted
[7] Shetty R, Pai R and Rao SS, ‘Experimental studies on turning of
machining demonstrates the benefits in curtailing the heat discontinuously reinforced aluminium composite under dry, oil water
generation at tool-workmaterial contacts. Further, it also emulsion and steam lubricated conditions using Taguchi’s Technique’,
improves the production of short chip of the same shape as G.U. Journal of Science 2009, 22(1), 21–32.
other environments. [8] Hong SY and Ding Y, ‘Cooling approaches and cutting temperatures in
cryogenic machining of Ti-6Al-4V’, International Journal of Machine
Average flank wear in LN2 assisted machining reduced on
Tools & Manufacture 2001, 41, 1417–1437.
average by 36%, 20% and 12% respectively for that of dry, [9] Dhar, N. R., Paul, S., & Chattopadhyay, A. B, The influence of cryogenic
wet and CCA. There was gradual reduction in BUE formation cooling on tool wear, dimensional accuracy and surface finish in turning
with LN2 as coolant in turning of Al-5%TiCP composites. This AISI 1040 and E4340C steels. Wear 2001, 249(10), 932-942.
is because of the significantly lower temperature achieved by [10] Franci Pušavec, Janez Kopač, Sustainability Assessment: Cryogenic
Machining of Inconel 718, Journal of Mechanical Engineering 2011, 57(
LN2 which causes reduction in thermal softening of matrix.
9), p. 637-647.
This in turn reduces the adhering tendency, makes BUE spare, [11] Shane Y. Hong , Yucheng Ding & Jason Jeong (2002): Experimental
decreases chip fracture and improves surface quality. Surface Evaluation Of Friction Coefficient And Liquid Nitrogen Lubrication Effect
quality was improved by 17%, 10% and 8% respectively In Cryogenic Machining, Machining Science and Technology: An
corresponding to dry, wet and CCA. International Journal 2002, 6(2), 235-250.
[12] Jun, Seong-Chan. "Lubrication effect of liquid nitrogen in cryogenic
The results also suggest that the rake angle directly
machining friction on the tool-chip interface." Journal of mechanical
influences the temperature on the tool-chip interface which in science and technology 2005, 19(4), 936-946.
turn effects the surface quality and tool life. It was observed [13] Singh V, Ghosh S and Rao PV, ‘Grindability improvement of composite
that as rake angle increases cutting temperature decreases ceramic with cryogenic coolant’, Proceedings of the World Congress on
under all environments (dry, wet CCA and LN2). Since the chip Engineering 2010, Vol 11 WCE, June 30–July 2, London, UK.
[14] Jomaa, W., Songmene, V., & Bocher, P.. Surface Finish and Residual
flow is directed by rake angle, using an optimum rake angle, all
Stresses Induced by Orthogonal Dry Machining of AA7075-T651.
the following factors can be controlled i.e. flow of chip, tool tip Materials 2014, 7(3), 1603-1624.
temperature, tool life and surface quality of workpiece. Further, [15] Ko, T. J. and Kim, H. S. Surface integrity and machinability in intermittent
it is also concluded that optimum rake angle for machining of hard turning. Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Technol., 2001, 18, 168–175.
Al-5%TiCP composite material is γ=80. It would be clearly [16] Guo, Y. B. and Sahni, J. A. comparative study of hard turned and
cylindrically ground white layers. Int. J. Mach. Tools Manuf., 2004, 44,
viewed that rake angle of 80 gives better surface finish (Ra =
135–145.
0.42 μm), lower tool wear (vb= 56.618 μm) and a close [17] Pedersen, W., and M. Ramulu. "Facing SiCp/Mg metal matrix composites
observation on the chip flow shown that, it yields short and with carbide tools." Journal of materials processing technology 172.3
continuous tubular chip formation under LN2 assisted (2006): 417-423.
machining. [18] U M Reddy Paturi and S K Reddy Narala, Experimental investigation to
study the effect of electrostatic micro-solid lubricant–coated carbide tools
LN2 as a coolant and lubricant has the added advantages of
on machinability parameters in turning, Proc.IMechE, Part B: Journal of
being harmless and ecofriendly. No need for disposal and Engineering Manufacture 2014, 1-10.
recycling makes it a lubricant of choice for machining [19] Quan YM, Zhou ZH and Ye BY. Cutting process and chip appearance of
processes. LN2 provides the fundamental theory for green aluminium matrix composite reinforced by SiC particle. Journal of Material
cutting and is the future of sustainable machining. Processing Technology 1999, 91,231-235.
Acknowledgment
The work has been carried out under the financial support of
the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of
Canada (NSERC).