Similarity Report ID: oid:19654:45377691

PAPER NAME

Kunal Gidwani 2023 M 020 Law and Justi

ce in Globalised World ResearcH Paper
REPRODUCTIVE RIGHTS ON

WORD COUNT CHARACTER COUNT

2396 Words 14049 Characters

PAGE COUNT FILE SIZE

6 Pages 159.8KB

SUBMISSION DATE REPORT DATE

Oct 25, 2023 3:43 PM GMT+5:30 Oct 25, 2023 3:44 PM GMT+5:30

16% Overall Similarity

The combined total of all matches, including overlapping sources, for each database.
16% Internet database 2% Publications database
Crossref database Crossref Posted Content database
14% Submitted Works database

Excluded from Similarity Report

Bibliographic material Quoted material
Cited material Small Matches (Less then 14 words)

Summary
REPRODUCTIVE RIGHTS ON PRIVACY, GENDER EQUALITY
BY
Kunal Gidwani
LL.M
Roll No. 2023 M 020
MAHARASHTRA NATIONAL LAW UNIVERSITY,
MUMBAI
Mob- +91 9082828055
Email Id- 2023m020@mnlumumbai.edu.in
TABLE OF CONTENT

SR.NO TITLE PAGE NO

1 INTRODUCTION

2 BODY

3 CONCLUSION

ABSTRACT:
This research paper examines the concept of Reproductive Rights on Gender Equality and
Human Rights in India Albert Venn Dicey Perspective. Reproductive rights play a vital role in
achieving gender equality and human rights in India. This abstract explores the interconnection
between reproductive rights, gender equality, and human rights in the Indian context. In India,
the historical context of gender discrimination and unequal power dynamics has often led to
violations of women's reproductive rights. This abstract discusses the significance of
reproductive autonomy, access to comprehensive healthcare, and family planning as crucial
components of women's rights. It emphasizes the need for legal and policy frameworks that
support women's reproductive choices while addressing socio-cultural norms that may hinder
these rights. Furthermore, this abstract examines the link between reproductive rights and
gender equality. The ability to control one's reproductive choices is intrinsically linked to a
woman's ability to participate fully in society, education, and the workforce. By ensuring
reproductive rights, gender equality is promoted as women can make informed choices about
their bodies, fertility, and family life. However, India faces challenges in effectively implementing
these rights, particularly in marginalized and vulnerable communities. The study also
investigates the legal framework surrounding reproductive rights in India, scrutinizing the
existing laws and policies aimed at promoting gender equality and safeguarding human rights. It
assesses the implementation gaps and societal attitudes that hinder the effective enforcement
of these laws, thus perpetuating discriminatory practices and limiting women's agency over their
bodies and reproductive choices. The impact of reproductive rights on gender equality and
human rights, emphasizing the correlation between women's reproductive freedom and their
overall empowerment. It discusses successful interventions and policy initiatives that have
positively influenced women's reproductive health outcomes, underscoring the importance of
comprehensive sexual education, accessible healthcare services, and economic opportunities in
fostering gender equality.

1. INTRODUCTION
Reproductive rights, gender equality, and human rights represent three pillars of a society's
progress, intertwining in complex ways to shape the lives of its citizens. In the context of India,
these issues assume particular significance due to the country's diverse and multifaceted social
landscape. India stands at a crossroads where rapid economic development coexists with
deeply rooted cultural norms, which, at times, challenge the principles of gender equality and
human rights. Reproductive rights encompass a range of critical aspects, including the right to
decide when and whether to have children, access to safe and legal abortion, and
comprehensive sexual education. These rights are intrinsically linked to gender equality
because women, more often than not, bear the burden of reproductive choices. Achieving
gender equality necessitates addressing the disparities in access to reproductive healthcare,
education, and economic opportunities that affect women's capacity to make informed decisions
about their reproductive health. The foundation of gender equality and human rights in India is
enshrined in its Constitution and various international agreements to which India is a signatory.
However, the implementation and realization of these rights face considerable challenges in a
country as diverse and populous as India. This introduction serves as a gateway to
understanding the multifaceted challenges and opportunities that lie at the intersection of
reproductive rights, gender equality, and human rights in India. Over the course of this
exploration, we will delve into the societal norms and cultural practices that continue to influence
reproductive choices and gender dynamics. We will scrutinize the legal framework, policies, and
programs aimed at promoting gender equality and safeguarding human rights, shedding light on
their effectiveness and the persistent gaps in implementation. We will also analyze the intricate
relationship between reproductive rights and women's empowerment, highlighting successful
initiatives and interventions that have had a positive impact on women's reproductive health
outcomes. These success stories, in turn, underscore the critical role that access to
comprehensive sexual education, reproductive healthcare services, and economic opportunities
play in fostering gender equality. In this comprehensive examination of reproductive rights,
gender equality, and human rights in India, we aim to unravel the complexities, challenges, and
opportunities that lie within this nexus. By addressing these issues head-on, we seek to
contribute to the ongoing dialogue and actions aimed at advancing the cause of gender equality
and human rights, ensuring that every individual in India can exercise their reproductive rights
and lead lives free from discrimination, and full of dignity. Reproductive rights play a significant
role in the context of gender equality and human rights in India, as they are intertwined with
various social, cultural, and legal factors. India has made progress in recognizing reproductive
rights as an essential component of human rights and gender equality, but challenges persist.
Reproductive rights are closely linked to gender equality in India. Historically, the country has
faced issues such as son preference, female infanticide, and gender-based violence. Ensuring
women have the right to make decisions about their reproductive health is crucial for addressing
these imbalances. By having control over when and how they have children, women can pursue
education, careers, and other opportunities, promoting gender equality. Access to family
planning services and contraceptives is a vital component of reproductive rights. In India,
programs like the National Family Planning Program aim to provide contraceptive options to
couples. Ensuring that these services are accessible and available to all, regardless of gender,
location, or socio-economic status, is essential for gender equality and human rights.
High maternal mortality rates have been a concern in India. Access to reproductive healthcare,
including safe childbirth and prenatal care, is crucial to protecting women's health and rights.
Ensuring that women receive proper care during pregnancy and childbirth is a human rights
imperative. Abortion rights are another critical aspect of reproductive rights. In India, the Medical
Termination of Pregnancy Act allows for legal abortion under specific circumstances, which is
essential for women's autonomy and health. However, barriers to access, such as social stigma
and lack of healthcare facilities, still exist and can disproportionately affect women's rights,
especially in rural areas. India faces challenges related to child marriage and teenage
pregnancy, particularly in rural areas. These issues can have severe consequences for girls'
education, health, and overall well-being. Addressing child marriage and early pregnancies is
crucial for ensuring that girls have the opportunity to make choices about their reproductive
health and future. Comprehensive sexual and reproductive health education is essential for
empowering individuals to make informed choices about their bodies and relationships.
Providing this education can help reduce gender-based violence and promote gender equality.
Despite legal protections and government programs, numerous challenges and inequalities
persist in India. Issues like female foeticide, gender-based violence, limited access to
healthcare, and lack of awareness about reproductive rights still pose significant obstacles to
achieving gender equality and upholding human rights. It's essential to recognize that gender
equality and reproductive rights intersect with other forms of discrimination and inequality,
including caste, class, religion, and ethnicity. Women from marginalized communities may face
compounded challenges in accessing reproductive rights and health services. Efforts are
ongoing in India to address these issues, with NGOs, women's rights organizations, and
government initiatives working to promote reproductive rights, gender equality, and human
rights. The progress made in these areas is a crucial step toward ensuring that all individuals in
India can exercise their reproductive rights, thereby advancing both gender equality and human
rights. Reproductive rights refer to a set of fundamental human rights that are related to an
individual's ability to make decisions about their own reproductive health and well-being. These
rights encompass a range of issues related to sexual and reproductive health, and they are
grounded in the principles of autonomy, dignity, and equality. The scope and importance of
reproductive rights are significant, as they impact individual well-being, gender equality, and
public health.
Shirin Heidari & Claudia García Moreno, Gender-Based Violence: A Barrier to Sexual and
Reproductive Health and Rights, 24 Reprod. Health Matters 1 (2016).

2. BODY

Across the globe, the women's movement has led individual and group efforts to combat
patriarchal control over reproduction at all levels. However, women's organizations in developing
countries have argued that the discussion surrounding women's reproductive rights needs to
take into consideration the reality that reproduction is only one facet of a woman's physiology
1
and life and cannot be seen in a vacuum. Because we live in societies where political,
economic, cultural, and social factors interact to affect women's health and shape perceptions of
sexuality, reproduction, fertility, and infertility, they contend that our understanding of patriarchy
must take into account far more complex realities. The Indian
2
1. viewpoint on reproductive rights has also needed to consider Reproductive rights rest on
the recognition of the basic right of all couples and individuals to decide freely and responsibly
the number, spacing, and timing of their children and to have the information to do so, as well as
the right to attain the highest standard of sexual and reproductive health," according to the
World Health Organization's definition of reproductive rights. They also include everyone's
freedom to choose their own reproductive path without facing prejudice, violence, or
compulsion. Every day, issues associated to pregnancy and childbirth claim the lives of 800
women. About 222 million women in developing nations wish to avoid getting pregnant, but they
are not utilizing modern methods of contraception, which leads to 20 million unsafe abortions
that carry a risk to life and 80 million unintended pregnancies. Among girls under 18, one in
three are married but not In India, reproductive rights, gender equality, and privacy are
important legal and social problems that interact in different ways within the nation's legal
system. Following is a breakdown of these concerns and how they interact with India's legal
system: India’s Reproductive Rights: The right to make choices regarding one's own family
6
planning and reproductive health is known as reproductive rights. The Medical Termination of
Pregnancy Act, 1971, and the Right to Education Act, 2009, are the main pieces of legislation in
India that regulate reproductive rights. These laws deal with family planning, contraception, and
abortion-related matters. In India, gender equality: India's legal perspective on gender equality,
privacy, and reproductive rights has developed over time as a result of numerous court rulings
and constitutional interpretations. The 1950 Indian Constitution contains a number of
fundamental rights that are essential to comprehending the legal viewpoint on gender equality,
privacy, and reproductive rights. Rights Reproductive: Reproductive rights cover a wide range of
topics, such as the freedom to choose one's own reproductive path and healthcare provider, as
well as the right to use family planning. Reproductive rights have been recognized in India by a
number of laws and regulations, including: The MTP Act of 1971 (Medical Termination of
Pregnancy): This law protected women's reproductive rights and their autonomy over their own
bodies by legalizing abortion under specific guidelines. The 1961 Maternity Benefit Act:
5
2. “Justice K.S. Putt swamy (Retd.) vs Union of India, 2017” In this landmark case, the
Supreme Court declared the right to privacy as a fundamental right under the Indian
Constitution, affirming that it is intrinsic to the right to life and personal liberty.
[i]
Navtej Singh Johar vs Union of India, 2018: The Supreme Court, in this case, decriminalized
consensual same-sex relationships, affirming the right to privacy and personal autonomy,
include Reproductive rights and gender equality are essential to social justice and human rights
because of their strong relationship. Ensuring everyone has access to reproductive rights
depends on gender equality, which is the equitable treatment of all genders in all domains of life,
including social, economic, and political ones. Here's where these two ideas come together:
Access to Reproductive Health care: Gender equality guarantees equal access to reproductive
health care for people of all genders. This covers contraception, family planning, sexual
education, and healthcare for mothers. Women and other oppressed genders could encounter
prejudice and obstacles in obtaining these services in the absence of gender equality. Autonomy
and Decision-Making: Gender equality acknowledges that people ought to have the freedom to
3
make choices regarding their own bodies, regardless of their gender.. The termination of
pregnancy was termed to be a murder of the fetus. But due to the change in time and technology,
nowadays this right has been legally sanctioned by most of the nations after the famous decision
4
of “Roe Vs Wade” 410 U.S. 113 (1973) by the US Supreme Court But the oppositions are still
1
present and people do believe that it should be legally prohibited. This is a landmark United
States Supreme Court decision establishing that most laws against abortion violate a
constitutional right to privacy, thus overturning all state laws outlawing or restricting abortion
1
that were inconsistent with the decision. June Roe, the plaintiff wanted to terminate her
pregnancy because she contended that it was a result of rape. Relying on the current state of
medical knowledge, the decision established a system of trimesters that attempted to balance the
state's legitimate interests with the individual's constitutional rights. The Court ruled that the
state cannot restrict a woman's right to an abortion during the first trimester, the state can
regulate the abortion procedure during the second trimester "in ways that are reasonably related
to maternal health," and in the third trimester, demarcating the viability of the fetus, a state can
choose to restrict or even to proscribe abortion as it sees fit. In response to Roe v. Wade, several
states enacted laws limiting abortion, including laws requiring parental consent for minors to
obtain abortions, parental notification laws, spousal consent laws, spousal notification laws, laws
requiring abortions to be performed in hospitals but not clinics, laws barring state funding for
abortions, laws banning most very late term abortions. The Supreme Court struck down several
state restrictions on abortions in a long series of cases stretching from the mid-1970s to the late
1980s

[i](2017) 10 SCC 1, AIR 2017 SCC 4161

Ii 2018 SC 4321, 2018 10 SCC 1
410 U.S. 113 (1973)

1
CONCLUSION

In conclusion, reproductive rights are a fundamental aspect of gender equality and privacy.
Protecting these rights enables individuals, particularly women, to have greater control over
their lives and bodies, contributing to a more equitable and just society. It's important to
continue advocating for these rights and ensuring their protection through legislation and social
awareness.
 Similarity Report ID: oid:19654:45377691

16% Overall Similarity

Top sources found in the following databases:
16% Internet database 2% Publications database
Crossref database Crossref Posted Content database
14% Submitted Works database

TOP SOURCES
The sources with the highest number of matches within the submission. Overlapping sources will not be
displayed.

pdfcoffee.com
1 10%
Internet

freeessayssamples.com
2 2%
Internet

sites.google.com
3 2%
Internet

Shri Guru Gobind Singhji Institute of Engineering and Technology on 20...

4 <1%
Submitted works

Indian Institute of Management, Nagpur on 2023-04-06

5 <1%
Submitted works

nluo.ac.in
6 <1%
Internet

Sources overview