Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Beyond The Rainbow Final Report
Beyond The Rainbow Final Report
CREDITS
INTRODUCTION
Lead authors: Devon Esper, Zoe Bowen-Jones (Wavemaker)
Co-authors: David Adamson (The&Partnership), Claire McAlpine (EssenceMediacom)
Contributing writers: Emma Franklin-Wright, Liam Earl,
In 1981, vodka brand Absolut made Fears about negative reactions may Louise Vernon (Hill+Knowlton)
the bold decision to place an hold back brands from beginning Survey design and data collection: Michael Liddle, Ramona Daniel (Choreograph)
advert in The Advocate, an LGBTQ+ their journeys to getting things Commentators: Jamie June Hill (VMLY&R), John Beardsworth (EssenceMediacom),
magazine published in the United right, which in turn could mean that Brett Peters (TikTok), Shoshana Goldberg (HRC), Adrien Gaubert (myGwork),
States. Showing support for LGBTQ+ a more informed and thoughtful era Linda Riley (DIVA magazine), Dan Flecker (Absolut), LJ Louis (WPP),
people then was a move that could of LGBTQ+ marketing takes longer Aaron Carty (UK Black Pride)
hardly be described as ‘brand-safe’, to arrive. Such an era would usher
particularly in an era where existing in a meaningful acknowledgment Design: Gisela Valdera (VMLY&R), Dane Beasley, Sean Casserly, Lauren Meehan,
prejudices were starting to include of LGBTQ+ audiences, where Roland Morin, David Jørgensen (Hogarth)
the social stigma of HIV and Aids brands accept that to keep up with Communications: Kevin Walther, Alana Spellman, Taylor Carr, Craig Beyerle (BCW),
infections. developing attitudes to sexuality Alex Davis-Isaac, Martina Suess (WPP), Marc Snitzer (CMI)
Today, the situation is very different. and gender identity, they need
to make the effort to understand
Every June, as Pride month gets LGBTQ+ communities, cultures and
underway, there is a slew of related lifestyles – and not just for Pride
campaigns from brands seeking month campaigns.
to engage with LGBTQ+ people
and our allies. However, such In Beyond The Rainbow, WPP
progressive steps from marketers Unite explores the current state of
are sometimes made amid concerns LGBTQ+ marketing and attempts
about possible backlash from the to answer the question of how its
intended audience, which could future may develop.
include accusations of ‘rainbow-
washing’ or ‘virtue-signalling’.
A NOTE ON LANGUAGE
Language around LGBTQ+ identities identify as both heterosexual
is complex and ever-evolving. and cisgender. We had extensive
We have consulted our partners and discussions about the use of the
expert resources to make sure we word ‘queer’ while creating this
use inclusive language throughout report and recognise that it has long
this report. In addition, we been used as a slur against LGBTQ+
recognise that not everyone will be people. In recent years, there has
familiar with all the words or phrases been a concerted effort in our
used, so there is a glossary of key communities to reclaim ‘queer’ to
terms at the end. refer to us in a celebratory way and,
Throughout this report we use in this report produced by a team of
the catch-all terms ‘LGBTQ+’ and queer people, the word should only
‘queer’. In doing so, we are referring be interpreted as such.
to everyone who doesn’t exclusively
A NOTE ON
INTERSECTIONALITY
There is no one way to be queer. people because marketing
Queerness spans gender, fundamentals are based on the
OUR OBJECTIVE
race, income level, those who power of collective reach. With
live with a disability, family any audience study, it’s important
arrangements, religion, age to have an umbrella label to help
We have created Beyond The gay, bisexual, or something else and other factors. The variety overall comprehension. In this
Rainbow with the aim of equipping other than straight.2 That’s more of identities and lived report, we will look at the LGBTQ+
our people, clients and industry than double the population average experiences is vast and critical to audience at large. However, it’s
with insights which will enable them of 9%. Interestingly, when asked individual expression. important to recognise that
to connect and communicate with if they’re explicitly heterosexual, we’re not talking about a
LGBTQ+ people on a meaningful less than half of young people This is a particular challenge for
marketers. Our industry ‘groups’ homogenous group.
level. Our hope is to help develop agreed.3 In a generation’s time,
a more inclusive future for LGBTQ+ audiences could represent
LGBTQ+ marketing. a significantly higher proportion of
Many studies have shown that the general population. We are no
people are increasingly likely longer a niche minority.
to openly identify as LGBTQ+. With these shifts in demographics,
Over time, fewer people are it is critical that marketers of
defining themselves as ‘straight’ any variety have a thorough
or ‘cisgender’,1 while younger understanding of their audiences.
generations are more likely to This report is designed to raise the
identify as LGBTQ+. In the UK, US collective understanding of LGBTQ+
and Canada, our survey found that identities and how they engage with 1
Gallup poll, US, 2012-2021; ONS annual population survey, UK, 2014-2020
22% of 18-24s identify as lesbian, brands and media. 2
Choreograph Audience Origin study, UK, US, Canada, 2022
3
IPSOS, LGBT+ Pride 2021 Global Survey
3,500 RESPONSES
FROM LGBTQ+
PEOPLE ACROSS
THE US, UK
AND CANADA
METHODOLOGY
Beyond The Rainbow is the result of skewing the results by being influenced
a mixed-method survey. WPP Unite too heavily by a larger sample size of white,
partnered with Choreograph, WPP’s gay, cisgender men – a recurring problem
global data company, on research that WPP Unite has identified with previous
design and recruitment. surveys of LGBTQ+ people. These partnerships
To boost the LGBTQ+ sample, and ensured we had robust sample sizes of groups
to ensure the intersectionality of underrepresented in existing research.
the community was captured, the Through this approach, we spoke to
team also partnered with UK Black 3,500 LGBTQ+ people across the US, UK
Pride, DIVA magazine, the HRC and Canada. To understand perceptions
and myGwork, who shared the among a broader audience, we also
survey with their audiences. The spoke to a comparative sample of
aim of this approach was to avoid 4,000 non-LGBTQ+ people.
WHAT WE
LEARNED
The following pages focus on the highlights from our
survey results, with expert commentary from across
the industry. The report is in three sections.
01. IDENTITY
This section is designed to help readers understand how
people see themselves and how, according to our sample,
that plays out in the world around them.
The future is fluid: 74% of LGBTQ+ people and 61% of non-LGBTQ+
people think that sexuality will become more fluid in the future
More than half of LGBTQ+ people are still not completely out
at work: Only 40% are completely open about their sexuality with
colleagues, while 50% are open about their gender identity
THE FUTURE
IS FLUID
02. MEDIA JUST 38% OF THOSE
As a space for LGBTQ+ audiences to explore their identities –
and for non-LGBTQ+ people to learn more – the media, in all WHO CONSUME QUEER
its forms, has been vital and has also increased our visibility. MEDIA ARE SATISFIED
WITH THE WAY LGBTQ+
This section looks at its role today and how it might evolve in
the future, according to our sample.
Queer media is not just for queer audiences: Almost all (9 out of
10) LGBTQ+ people seek out specific queer media; interestingly,
PEOPLE ARE REPRESENTED
60% of non-LGBTQ+ people also seek it out
22%
16%
01. IDENTITY
10%
9% 9%
8%
7% 7%
6%
5%
AND BOUNDARIES
In the three markets we studied This shift towards inclusivity
When it comes to gender, there acceptance and understanding of
is a clear shift away from binary gender among younger people is
(the US, UK and Canada) there appears to be allowing people to
thinking among the younger reflected in their own identities:
is a general recognition among define their sexuality more freely.
generation. 57% of 18-34s agree 3.6% of 18-24s identify as ‘trans’,
both LGBTQ+ and non-LGBTQ+ Majorities in both groups agree that
that there are more than two ‘non-binary’, or something other than
respondents that their societies sexuality will become more fluid in
genders and are 46% more likely ‘cisgender’. That is 4.2 times higher
are more inclusive of LGBTQ+ the future (74% of LGBTQ+ people
than over-35s to feel that way. As than observed across the general
people than in the past (83% of and 61% of non-LGBTQ+). That
we see with sexuality, this increased population aged over 18.4
LGBTQ+ people and 78% of feeling is stronger among younger
non-LGBTQ+ agree). generations, with 18-34s being 27%
more likely to agree than those aged
over 35. Gender: % of people who identify as something other than 'cisgender'
(includes 'transgender', 'non-binary' or 'other')
Queer 3% 2%
18-24s ARE 2.5 TIMES
Other 1% 1% 18-34
MORE LIKELY TO IDENTIFY
AS LGBTQ+ THAN THE
35+
53%
55%
50%
47%
38%
7
Data about openness in the workplace is based on the working population only
It appears that those who fall into a ‘gay’ or ‘lesbian’ are more likely to There could be many factors behind drawn through this study alone, but
‘binary’ sexuality or gender identity be open at work than ‘bisexual’, this, including types of job and levels the relationship between income and
group are more likely to be open ‘pansexual’, ‘asexual’ or of seniority. Conclusions cannot be openness warrants further research.
about it in the workplace than ‘queer’ people. % completely open about their sexuality or gender identity at work by income level
those who don’t. Given that young Despite a recognition among most
people are, as the previous section respondents that sexuality will
put it, ‘breaking down binaries’ become more fluid in future, those 47%
around gender and sexuality, it whose sexuality doesn’t fit within 40%
might appear that age is a driving the binary appear to face nuanced 34%
factor. However, among both barriers to presenting as such in
younger (18-34s) and older (35+) the workplace.
groups, those who identify as
High income Medium income Low income
% completely open about their sexuality at work
57%
ADRIEN GAUBERT (HE/HIM),
55%
CO-FOUNDER & CMO, MYGWORK (UK)
32%
"We at myGwork are not surprised So organisations today need to go
29% by these findings. LGBTQ+ above and beyond performative
18-34 discrimination is still rife in the measures to show that they are
35+
workplace. Our own recent survey serious about creating a welcoming
indicated that the majority of and inclusive environment where
Gay/Lesbian Bisexual, Pansexual, Asexual or Queer
LGBTQ+ graduates entering the LGBTQ+ professionals can be
THOSE ON A LOWER
workplace would return to the authentic and out at work without
closet if their colleagues weren’t fear of discrimination. Role models,
02. MEDIA
people. In fact, regardless of age, non-LGBTQ+ people seeking out
gender, race, income, religion, queer media among the over-65s.
disability status or education, the For young people, queer media
vast majority of LGBTQ+ people reaches almost everyone, regardless
seek out queer content. However,
TECHNOLOGY FACILITATES
of sexuality and gender identity;
among non-LGBTQ+ people, the among older age groups, queer
generational differences are stark.
LGBTQ+ EXPLORATION
media predominately reaches
Among 18-24s, 85% of non-LGBTQ+ LGBTQ+ people. As our findings in
people seek out queer media – a the previous section demonstrate,
(9 out of 10) LGBTQ+ people seek appeal of queer media and its role 18-24 25-34 35-44 45-54 55-64 65+
out queer media.10 Interestingly, 60% in the everyday life of allies.
of non-LGBTQ+ people also seek
9
Stonewall School Report 2017
"Queer media” or “queer content” refers to stories about LGBTQ+ people (fictional/non-fictional) and content created or presented
10
40% 38%
On the whole, while media touchpoints like radio and print. 28%
23% 23% 22%
behaviour among LGBTQ+ people As the identity section of this
17% 16%
reflects that of the general report has highlighted, the LGBTQ+ 13%
population, as a group they audience is significantly younger
Social TV Movies/ Online LGBTQ+ Music Queer Magazines Newspapers Podcasts Video Radio
are more likely to use digital than the population at large. media films videos publications influencers games
Daily reach and index of each media type There are some clear generational landscape at large, as it is reflective
% of LGBTQ+ adults (16+) who use each media type daily or more, differences in the responses, with of the way different age groups
indexed against the generation population of adults (16+) younger people more inclined to consume media. While it is useful
50 100 150 look to online videos, music, queer to understand the scale of these
influencers and video games than touchpoints within queer media,
Video games 42% the over-35s, who are more likely to it is also important to know that
Music
streaming 59% go to magazines and newspapers. the picture is very nuanced.
Short
online videos 63% This is broadly in line with the media
Podcasts 23%
Radio 40% % of queer media consumers who seek out queer content on each touchpoint
Newspapers 28%
65%
54% 22%
was a record number of LGBTQ+
characters on TV between
June 2021 and May 2022.12
seek out queer content look to queer influencers
While the LGBTQ+ media Key audiences:
advocacy group’s research Gay women/lesbians (71%
on social media
also highlighted the shortfalls movies, 66% TV) and gay men
Social media has given a and missed opportunities (61% movies, 63% TV)
that still exist, there is now a
platform to LGBTQ+ people Key audiences
and enabled connection, broader range of role models on Examples:
(social media generally): mainstream TV and in movies. Heartstopper, Gentleman
education and a sense of Under-35s (64%), bisexual
community. When respondents As queer media continues to Jack, Love Simon, Moonlight,
women (66%) and evolve, film and TV will continue
were asked to give examples Sex Education, Euphoria
lesbians (67%) to play a key role in normalising
of queer content they search for
on social media, they focused on and celebrating different
Key audiences LGBTQ+ identities.
groups and influencers. Queer (queer influencers):
influencers are particularly
LGBTQ+ people of colour
important because people
(29%), LGBTQ+ people living
can look up to and follow
those who represent their with a disability (35%) LGBTQ+ PUBLICATIONS
lived experiences. That can Examples:
36%
be incredibly validating for
Jojo Siwa, Jonathan Van Ness, seek out queer content from
marginalised groups.
Aaron Philip, Munroe Bergdorf LGBTQ+ publications
39%
seek out queer reputation for representing Examples:
content from and engaging with LGBTQ+ DIVA, Gay Times, Pink News,
online videos people. They understand and The Advocate, Attitude, Xtra,
know how to communicate Out, Queerty, The Lesbian and
As with social media, video- Key audiences:
with LGBTQ+ audiences and, Gay Review, Autostraddle,
sharing services like YouTube LGBTQ+ people of colour (49%)
as queer media becomes Equality (published by
have given a voice to LGBTQ+
Examples: increasingly mainstream, the Human Rights
creators, hosting content about
Hey Qween!, Rose and Rosie, will play an increasingly Campaign Foundation)
almost anything you could ever
think of! Whether it’s comedy, Tyler & Todd, Jeffree Star, UNHhhh important role.
video diaries, educational
LGBTQ+ resources or how-to
videos, there is almost limitless
content to explore.
12
GLAAD, Where We Are On TV, 2021-22
MUSIC VIDEO GAMES
PODCASTS
RADIO
16% seek out queer content
12%
on podcasts
From history and politics to
pop culture and dating, there
seek out queer content
is an ever-increasing number
Key audiences: on the radio Key audiences:
of queer podcasts to educate
and entertain. Interestingly, Non-binary (30%), Radio takes on a queer lens Trans people (19%)
the format is particularly trans people (21%) through both LGBTQ+-specific
stations and DJs who identify as
Examples:
popular with trans and non- Examples: Gaydio, Pride Radio, Proud
binary people, many of whom Gayish, Daddy Squared, Race LGBTQ+. In fact, radio stations
FM, current and former BBC
when responding to our Chaser, A Gay and a NonGay, are some of the largest queer
Radio 1 DJs Adele Roberts,
survey talked about turning to We Can Do Hard Things media brands out there and
Nick Grimshaw and Scott Mills,
podcasts to understand their listeners tend to be particularly
Trans Radio UK, The Stephanie
own gender identity. captive audiences.
Miller Show
THE OVERALL QUALITY
% who want to see more queer media
AND QUANTITY OF
QUEER MEDIA NEEDS
80% 80%
76%
65% 65%
IMPROVEMENT
61%
56%
41%
ARE REPRESENTED IN MEDIA There is clearly work to be done in improving both the
quality and quantity of LGBTQ+ media.
Despite a widespread desire for 41% of non-LGBTQ+ people want
queer media and an explosion to see more LGBTQ+ content. This JOHN BEARDSWORTH LINDA RILEY
of available LGBTQ+ content in varies significantly across identity
recent decades, fewer than half of groups, with trans and non-binary
(HE/HIM), (SHE/HER),
people who consume it are satisfied people, lesbians and LGBTQ+ PARTNER, ESSENCEMEDIACOM EDITOR, DIVA MAGAZINE
with the way LGBTQ+ people are people of colour the most likely
represented in media. What’s more, to want more content. “Queer-specific/-owned media “It’s great to see that LGBTQIA+
two-thirds of LGBTQ+ people and platforms are often discounted representation in the media is on the
when a brief calls for reach. But rise but, all too often, brands default
we see with this data, particularly to the gay male market. What about
% satisfied by the way LGBTQ+ people are represented in media within younger demographics, the the lesbians, bisexual women, trans
lines between straight and LGBTQ+ and non-binary people, and those
audiences continue to be blurred who identify as queer or asexual?
54% and/or questioned. This only increases More diversity and intersectionality
44%
the relevancy and appeal of queer in LGBTQIA+ media representation
40%
38% 37%
platforms’ audiences at a time when is a huge opportunity. Our research
36%
34% 31% we’ve seen them grow considerably. shows that 87% of DIVA readers are
To deliver authentic and relevant more likely to buy from a company
campaigns at scale, it’s essential which actively reaches out to their
we start with the organisations communities. LGBTQIA+ women
Trans & Non-LGBTQ+ Bisexual Total Gay men Asexual Lesbians/ Pansexual who understand and know how to and non-binary people are an
Non-binary LGBTQ+ Gay women
communicate with queer audiences.” increasingly visible and economically
powerful demographic. If you aren’t
including queer representation in
your advertising, you’re missing out.”
PEOPLE WANT TO SEE A NOTHING ABOUT US
MORE DIVERSE RANGE OF WITHOUT US: PEOPLE
LGBTQ+ CHARACTERS WANT QUEER TEAMS
We asked people how they think
representation could be improved
83% of LGBTQ+ people and
80% of non-LGBTQ+ people think
BEHIND QUEER CONTENT
and found very similar results representation would be improved It’s not just about on-screen casting and storylines, it’s
between LGBTQ+ and non-LGBTQ+ by having a more diverse range also about the teams creating the content. 79% of LGBTQ+
people. In the same way that queer of LGBTQ+ characters. This scores
media isn’t just for LGBTQ+ people, higher than those who think simply
people (and 75% of non) want to see more content
neither are the improvements and having more LGBTQ+ characters is created by LGBTQ+ people.
evolutions people want to see. enough, which suggests that casting
needs to be thoughtful
and representative.
“It is important to make
Ways to improve LGBTQ+ representation in media sure that creators who are
% who agree LGBTQ+ representation in media would be improved in the following ways minorities are also making
media that is important to
them and media that they
83%
just want to make.”
80% 80% 79% 79%
76% 75% 75%
A more diverse range of More content which highlights More LGBTQ+-specific storylines More LGBTQ+
LGBTQ+ characters/people LGBTQ+ issues people/characters featured
That’s why queer teams are So, the next time you are starting
so important when telling to make anything that features the
queer stories. LGBTQIA+ community, ask yourself,
‘Is this truly authentic?’ – and if
When WPP Unite set out to create you don’t know, then look at the
the All Our Pride campaign for team around you. Lived experience
London Pride’s 50th anniversary, isn’t essential, but it does go
we did it with the ambition of a long way."
making it an entirely queer-
led campaign. Every strategist,
creative, cast member, runner,
make-up artist, producer, writer,
Recall of LGBTQ+ brand activity
55%
49%
03. COMMUNICATIONS
47%
45%
42% 41%
28% 26%
25%
PRIDE DOMINATES
18% LGBTQ+
Non-
LGBTQ+
LGBTQ+ ADVERTISING
A brand changing its A brand running An advert featuring A brand raising A brand raising money for
logo to the rainbow flag a campaign for LGBTQ+ character(s) awareness of issues and an LGBTQ+ charity
colours during Pride month legislation impacting
Pride month LGBTQ+ people
THINKING BEYOND
THE RAINBOW
When asked to name an example of a specific brand which
had changed its logo to the rainbow flag colours during Pride
month, there were no common answers, and some respondents
expressed cynicism at the number of brands doing so.
“They change
their logos back
“So many brands
2 OUT OF 3 PEOPLE
WANT TO SEE MORE
change their logos on
as soon as Pride social media. Almost all
major brands do at
ADVERTISING REFLECTING
month is over.”
this point.”
LGBTQ+ PEOPLE
Quotes from Beyond The Rainbow survey respondents
Of course, every brand’s future they’d like to see more of in the
approach to LGBTQ+ marketing will future. Comparing these sets of
be unique to its own requirements. results, it’s clear there is a mismatch
It needs to be informed by, among between the activities that LGBTQ+
many other factors, what they’re people want to see and what
offering, who they’re offering it to, companies are actually doing. This
and where they’re offering it. highlights an opportunity for brands
To provide a general guide, after to drive greater distinction and
asking people about the types of relevance by moving beyond an
LGBTQ+ advertising they’d seen annual focus on Pride towards more
in the past, we asked them what ongoing positive social impact.
Types of ads seen in the past vs. what respondents would like to see in future
among LGBTQ+ people
55% 52%
49% 47% 47% 46%
35%
28% 28% 26%
Past
Future
A brand changing its A brand running An advert featuring A brand raising A brand raising money for
logo to the rainbow flag a campaign for LGBTQ+ character(s) awareness of issues and an LGBTQ+ charity
colours during Pride Pride month legislation impacting
AWARENESS
OF ISSUES
AFFECTING
LGBTQ+
PEOPLE
According to Kantar Monitor, 68% of debate, but addressing social justice
consumers expect brands to be clear issues can drive distinctiveness
about their values, with Millennials and relevance if it is handled
and Gen Z having the highest with authenticity off the back of
expectations of all age groups.15 established values and a clear role
Whether a consumer would disregard for a brand.
price, quality and distribution to buy Two ways in which this can be done
into a product or service purely on are by speaking out and storytelling.
social justice issues alone is subject to
CHANNEL 4 MARKING A GLOBAL MOMENT
THROUGH AN LGBTQ+ LENS
UK TV station Channel 4 released its cheeky, colourful, in-your-face
the song and video Gay Mountain in good-luck message to all athletes
2014 to mark the start of the Winter (LGBTQ+ and non) on the opening
Olympics in Sochi, Russia. Channel 4 night of the Games as a response
has a long history of provoking to Russian laws which restrict the
debate, representing lesser-heard rights of LGBTQ+ people.
voices and challenging the status
quo through its content, so it aired
15
Kantar Monitor, 2021
AIRBNB EXPLORING ISSUES
AND REINFORCING LONG-TERM
BRAND COMMITMENTS
Safety when travelling is an issue
for many LGBTQ+ people. Airbnb
has consistently communicated its
belief that LGBTQ+ people should
not only be treated with dignity
and respect, but be welcomed and
celebrated. Its initiatives have included
the long-running #HostWithPride
campaign with stories about LGBTQ+
travellers, the brand throwing its
weight behind marriage equality in
Australia with the Until We All Belong
campaign, being a founding member
of the Human Rights Campaign
Global Business Coalition in the US, BOTH TINDER AND FORD TAKING A CAMPAIGNING
and developing the financing and APPROACH TO LGBTQ+ COMMUNICATIONS
production of the documentary film
Gay Chorus Deep South in response to Other examples of brands addressing started as a social clapback against
a wave of discriminatory anti-LGBTQ+ LGBTQ+ issues head-on include a homophobic YouTube comment
laws in the southern states of the US. Tinder partnering with the HRC but quickly became a mission-based
(2022) to call on the US government beacon of allyship, challenging toxic
to lift the ban that prevents men who stereotypes in order to redefine
have sex with men from donating 'tough' and drive out discrimination
blood. Ford’s Very Gay Raptor within car culture.
STORYTELLING
Examples of brands driving empathy for LGBTQ+ people
and the issues they face by crafting it into the narrative
of campaigns.
A person’s name is their greatest its universal welcome of asking a
connection to their own individuality customer for their name, writing it
and personality. For trans and non- on their cup and calling it out
binary people, their chosen names when ready. Gillette’s First Shave
which align with their gender (2019) shared the moment when a
identity carry a deeper meaning. young trans man is taught how to
Starbucks’ What’s Your Name? shave by his father. His emotions
campaign (2019) brought this to life are the focus of the story, and the
in a sensitive, accessible way by campaign helps viewers to feel the
showing the emotional knockbacks anticipation and excitement that so
experienced by young trans man many transitioning men feel during
James and his daily experience of a significant step in their journey,
being addressed by his dead name, while associating Gillette with the
‘Jemma’. The campaign came with father figure, providing guidance,
a clear role for Starbucks through wisdom and unconditional support.
This is where LGBTQ+ portrayal can appearances could be categorised
come across as mere box-ticking, in four general areas: incidental
because characters have been (where LGBTQ+ characters appear
deliberately created to ‘look gay’ briefly in the narrative alongside
and be noticed for it quickly. a sequence of other characters),
This is one of the reasons why essential (where LGBTQ+
deeper and more nuanced portrayals characters drive the narrative),
of LGBTQ+ characters tend to be normalisation (where the experience
found in the realm of brand-building of LGBTQ+ characters is presented
advertising, where there is more as no different to anyone else)
FEATURING
scope for emotion and storytelling. and representation (where the
characters’ unique LGBTQ+
In analysing the portrayal of LGBTQ+ experiences are the key focus).
characters within campaigns, their
LGBTQ+
CHARACTERS
Most LGBTQ+ people (69%) want to see more LGBTQ+
people featured in advertising, but when brands
do feature LGBTQ+ people, 59% think it comes across
as tokenistic (this figure is higher among trans/non-binary
respondents at 70%, and 67% among LGBTQ+ people
of colour).
This well-intended, but potentially is a question of how deep to go in
insincere portrayal of LGBTQ+ people portraying the lives of the people
is something that can cause some (LGBTQ+ or non) in whose kitchen
creative anxiety when developing the fridge is located before that
a campaign, with the creative becomes a distraction to the
conversation often boiling down product messages the ad is
to how to signify that a character trying to land.
is LGBTQ+ without making their When LGBTQ+ people feature in
sexuality or relationship the entire advertising where the role of all
focus of the work. characters is more likely to be
In forms of advertising that are more contextual, portraying them tends
product- and service-focused, the to default to quick reads that
role of all characters (non-LGBTQ+ will establish to the viewer that
or otherwise) is more likely to be they are not heterosexual, such
contextual and less of an ingredient as hand-holding, kissing, or overt
for driving narrative. As an example, gender-swapping in recognisable
if the objective of a 30-second TV heteronormative situations
spot is to sell a fridge, then there (such as two men raising a baby).
INCIDENTAL REPRESENTATION INCIDENTAL NORMALISATION
Examples of incidental Examples of incidental
representation include Nike’s normalisation include Honey Maid’s
The Land Of Football (2021), where This Is Wholesome (2014) and Chase
a footballer kisses his partner on Bank’s Banking With Chase Feels
the pitch, and Virgin Atlantic’s See Good (2021). Another example can
the World Differently (2022), where
an array of characters, including a Incidental be found in Corteva Agriscience's
The Heart Of The Farm series (2021),
glittering flight attendant, features where one episode focuses on
proudly to the soundtrack of the the working life of a farm that just
gay anthem I Am What I Am. Virgin happens to be owned by a gay
Atlantic's campaign was further couple. While the story touches
supported by a policy change on their life together, its focus is
which allows staff to choose the on their work growing food, like so
uniform that best aligns with their many other farms across the US.
gender identity.
Representation
Norm
alisation
ESSENTIAL REPRESENTATION ESSENTIAL NORMALISATION
Examples of essential Examples of essential normalisation
representation include Diesel’s include British Gas’ Here To Solve
Francesca (2020), where Diesel (2020) Maltesers’ Accountant
is a constant in the wardrobe of a (2018) and Beagle Street’s First
young woman during her transition, Night (2021). In these examples, the
Renault’s French Exchange (2019), narratives are built around LGBTQ+
which follows the love story of characters but focus on everyday
a lesbian couple and the role of aspects of life that could be
Renault in keeping them together, experienced by anyone and where
and Posten’s When Harry Met the brand has a role, such as fixing
Santa (2021), where Santa uses the
Norwegian postal service Posten to E s s e n tial a leak, sharing chocolate while
talking about dating struggles,
give himself a Christmas Eve off so and buying insurance.
he can enjoy it with his boyfriend
Harry. In each example, the uniquely
LGBTQ+ experience is what drives
the narrative.
SUPPORTING
LGBTQ+
CHARITIES
Aligning a brand with a charity the ambition of driving long-term
Also in the UK, the English Premier
League’s support of Stonewall’s
Rainbow Laces campaign is an
ongoing long-term partnership to
pledged a US$100,000 donation to
the charity and launched a social
media campaign with the hashtag
#TakeAMinute, where it handed its
or organisation can come under change for LGBTQ+ people of promote allyship in football (soccer) social profile over to voices across
scrutiny if the activity is seen as colour in the UK. The brand set through fundraising, education and the LGBTQ+ community.
short-termist. Apple and (RED) is an out to do this by giving its backing
drawing attention to the need to
example of a long-term partnership to UK Black Pride’s ‘We Will Be
stop homophobia and make the
which has remained consistent over Heard’ survey which aimed to
15 years, with US$270 million in sales increase understanding of the lived game welcoming to everyone.
from the brand’s exclusive (RED) line experiences of LGBTQ+ people However, there are plenty of
of products going to support critical of colour in the UK, distributing examples of brands supporting
work in combating HIV and Aids. community grants to organisations charities over shorter periods of
Partnering with UK Black Pride, working to support LGBTQ+ people time (such as Pride month) and
NYX Cosmetics launched the of colour, and showcasing diverse bringing charity initiatives to the
Proudly Pro-You campaign with LGBTQ+ talent within the marketing. heart of their communications for a
limited period of fundraising time.
This is particularly prevalent
among fashion and beauty brands
which often create specific
Pride-themed SKUs.
As an example of this, watch and
accessory brand Fossil launched
a capsule collection of Pride-
themed watches and straps in the
US, UK and Canada, with 100%
of the proceeds going to The
Trevor Project (the world’s largest
suicide-prevention charity for
LGBTQ+ people). Going beyond
the launch of the collection, Fossil
THINKING
BEYOND THE
RAINBOW
ALL YEAR
ROUND P&G
P&G established the role of Global LGBTQ+ Equality
To make LGBTQ+ marketing really work, brands need to Program Leader in 2021, focusing on ensuring that
think strategically about the long term. 75% of LGBTQ+ LGBTQ+ audiences are accurately reflected by the
people and 51% of non-LGBTQ+ people tell us they’d feel largest advertiser in the world and strategically
more positively about a brand which supports LGBTQ+ catered for as a core consumer group rather than
people throughout the whole year. just ‘bolted on’. In addition to this, P&G launched
Here are three prominent examples of brands taking The Visibility Project in partnership with GLAAD to
this approach on board and planning for it. drive and sustain LGBTQ+ inclusion in marketing
and advertising.
MASTERCARD SAVAGE X FENTY
Mastercard’s True Name scheme had the credit card Savage X Fenty, the gender and size-inclusive
company overhauling its policy to allow trans and lingerie brand founded by entrepreneur and music
non-binary people have a credit card showing their icon Rihanna, partners with LGBTQ+ creators,
chosen name rather than the name issued on their artists and musicians to promote its ranges and
birth certificate. gives sizable donations to LGBTQ+ charities
such as GLAAD and the HRC.
CONCLUSIONS
Beyond The Rainbow goes beyond what has been
surfaced in this report. For WPP Unite, this study
is a snapshot into LGBTQ+ identities, media and
communications to equip members of our community,
our clients and our allies to positively and meaningfully
influence the future of LGBTQ+ marketing.
Here is a summary of the predictions and advice laid out
in this report to help you start thinking about how to
navigate LGBTQ+ marketing successfully.
Audiences will continue to get queerer and more fluid. Reflect that
in the way you represent and engage with them.
LGBTQ+ media will become an established part of
mainstream media. As a key part of the media ecosystem, ensure
that LGBTQ+ content, channels and platforms also become
an established part of your media planning.
Brands will continue to have an impact on attitudes in society
at large. Take the time to understand attitudes today and consider
the role you want to play in influencing them.
Technological developments will impact the way people can
explore their own identities. Consider the role you have in
facilitating this exploration.
Brands at Pride will be challenged on what they do during the
rest of the year. Join a collective effort to reinvent Pride by making
your related activity a celebration of what you do all year round to
support the LGBTQ+ community.
The future of LGBTQ+ marketing will be more informed and
relevance will be more crucial than ever. In your campaigns,
find an angle which is genuinely relevant to your brand. In your
decision-making, be conscious of normalising or representing
LGBTQ+ issues if you’re doing it through narratives where LGBTQ+
visibility is essential or incidental.
The most successful brands will foster a truly inclusive space
for LGBTQ+ employees. Ensure that you understand how your
workplace fares today and implement a long-term strategy to
improve DE&I tomorrow.
GLOSSARY
Partially sourced from the HRC’s glossary of terms.
Agender: Not having a gender – being genderless or gender-neutral. LGBTQ+: As used throughout this report, an acronym for ‘Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender
Asexual: Often referred to as ‘ace’, asexual is a complete or partial lack of sexual attraction and Queer/Questioning’. This acronym can also be expanded to LGBTQIA+, to include the
or lack of interest in sexual activity with others. Asexuality exists on a spectrum and asexual above, plus ‘Intersex' and 'Asexual/Agender’. In both acronyms, the ‘+’ symbol recognises the
people may experience no, little or conditional sexual attraction. limitless sexual orientations and gender identities used by queer people.
Bisexual: A person emotionally, romantically, or sexually attracted to more than one sex, Non-binary: An adjective describing a person who does not identify exclusively as a man or
gender or gender identity, though not necessarily simultaneously, in the same way or to the a woman (see also agender). Non-binary people may identify as being both a woman and a
same degree. See also pansexual. man, somewhere in between, or as falling completely outside these categories. While some
also identify as transgender (see below), not all non-binary people do so. ‘Non-binary’ can
Cisgender: Describes a person whose gender identity aligns with that generally associated also be used as an umbrella term to encompass identities such as ‘agender’, ‘bigender’,
with the sex assigned to them at birth. ‘genderqueer’, ‘gender-fluid’, and others.
Gay: A person who is emotionally, romantically, or sexually attracted to members of the same Pansexual: Someone who has the potential for emotional, romantic, or sexual attraction to
gender (see also homosexual). people of any gender (though not necessarily simultaneously) in the same way or to the
Gender binary: Where gender is classified in two strict categories of ‘male’ or ‘female’ and same degree. Sometimes used interchangeably with bisexual (see above).
gender identity (see below) is expected to align with the sex assigned at birth, while gender Queer: Often used to express a spectrum of identities and orientations that are counter to
expressions and roles fit traditional expectations. the mainstream. ‘Queer’ can be a catch-all to include many people, including those who do
Gender identity: A person’s innermost concept of the self as ‘female’, ‘male’, both or neither not identify as exclusively straight and/or people who have non-binary or gender-expansive
– how individuals perceive themselves and what they call themselves. One’s gender identity identities (see non-binary). This word has historically been used as a slur, but is increasingly
can be the same or different from their sex assigned at birth. being reclaimed by many parts of the LGBTQ+ movement.
Gender non-conforming: A broad term referring to people who do not behave in a way that Rainbow-washing: The act of using the colours of the rainbow flag and/or imagery in logos,
conforms to the traditional expectations of their gender, or whose gender expression does advertising, apparel, accessories, landmarks, etc. to indicate support for LGBTQ+ equality
not fit neatly into a category. While many also identify as transgender (see below), not all and earn consumer credibility, but with a minimum of effort or a meaningful result.
gender non-conforming people do so. Sexual/Gender fluidity: Where one’s sexuality (see below) or gender identity (see above)
Heterosexual: A person who is emotionally, romantically, or sexually attracted to members of isn’t permanently fixed.
the opposite sex (see also straight). Sexual orientation: An inherent or immutable enduring emotional, romantic, or sexual
Homosexual: A person who is emotionally, romantically, or sexually attracted to members of attraction to other people. An individual’s sexuality is independent of their gender identity.
the same gender (see also gay, lesbian and queer). Straight: A person who is emotionally, romantically or sexually attracted to members of the
Intersectionality: The acknowledgement that everyone has their own unique experiences of opposite sex (see also heterosexual).
discrimination and oppression, and the need to consider everything and anything that can Transgender/Trans: An umbrella term for people whose gender identity (see above) and/
marginalise people, which may include aspects of gender, race, class, sexual orientation, or expression is different from cultural expectations based on the sex they were assigned at
physical ability, etc. birth. Being transgender does not imply any specific sexual orientation; transgender people
Lesbian: A woman who is emotionally, romantically, or sexually attracted to other women. may identify as straight, gay, lesbian, bisexual, etc.
Women and non-binary (see below) people may use this term to describe themselves. Virtue-signalling: The action or practice of publicly expressing opinions or sentiments
intended to demonstrate one’s good character or the moral correctness of one’s position on
a particular issue.
ABOUT THE AUTHORS
ZOE BOWEN-JONES, (SHE/HER), DEVON ESPER, (HE/HIM),
SENIOR INSIGHTS DIRECTOR, WAVEMAKER GLOBAL, STRATEGY MANAGER, WAVEMAKER USA,
COMMITTEE MEMBER, WPP UNITE (UK) COMMITTEE MEMBER, WPP UNITE (NORTH AMERICA)
CONTACT
If you’re interested in learning more about Beyond The
Rainbow or want to discuss our findings further,
email us at unite@wpp.com
Image sources:
Channel 4 – Gay Mountain Corteva Agriscience – The Heart Of The Farm: Ogilvy (WPP)
Airbnb – Gay Chorus Deep South Diesel – Francesca: Publicis Italy
Airbnb – Until We All Belong Renault – French Exchange: Publicis Poke
Ford – Very Gay Raptor: VMLY&R and H+K (WPP) Posten – When Harry Met Santa: POL, Oslo
Starbucks – What’s Your Name?: Iris L’Oréal – Pro-Tales: EssenceMediacom (WPP)
Gillette – First Shave: Grey (WPP) Fossil – Take a Minute: M/Six (WPP)
Virgin Atlantic – See the World Differently: Lucky Generals HRC – Reality Flag: WPP Unite
British Gas – Here To Solve: The&Partnership (WPP) Pride in London – #AllOurPride: WPP Unite
Nike – The Land of Football: W+K Amsterdam Photo by Emli Bendixen
Beagle Street – First Night: Creature