Revision Day -

Question -3 - Debate analysis - ( 12 marks )

Title: "The Generational Showdown: Wisdom vs. Future"

Host: Welcome, dear listeners, to "Generations Unplugged," where we explore the
clash of perspectives between Carla and Evy on whether the needs of the young or
the old should take precedence. Let's dive into this lively debate!
Segment 1: Wisdom Reigns
Carla: Greetings, everyone! In my culture, elders are the backbone of our families.
Their wisdom is unparalleled, and it's only fair that we repay the debt we owe them.
They've cared for us, guided us, and now, it's our turn.
My grandparents care for my baby sister when I am at school and my parents are at work.
Now that more women go out to work to bring in enough money for the family, the
contribution of the elderly family members is even more important than before. My
grandparents help to pay for my education.
I think the needs of old people should be the priority.They're the unsung heroes,
supporting us as we navigate the challenges of modern life.
Host: Wise words, Carla! The importance of respecting our elders is a universal
sentiment. But let's switch gears and hear Evy's take on the matter.
Segment 2: Youth Unleashed
Evy: Hey there, folks! I hear Carla's perspective, but let's talk about reality. Many of
our elders had it easier in their time – free education, secure jobs, and generous
pensions.
Today's youth face unemployment, skyrocketing education costs, and housing
nightmares. Young people today are not so lucky. There is much youth unemployment
caused by the world financial crisis and the slow pace of economic growth. In most countries
education is now expensive. Many young people cannot afford to pay for somewhere to live.
According to the World Bank in 2015, in some parts of the world young people are the most
likely to suffer from poverty. A recent research study of armed conflict shows how in some
places young people become victims of warfare. Professor Singh uses many statistics to
describe how they suffer high casualty rates, lose parents and are likely to become orphans
and refugees. Young people are not old enough to care for themselves. As a young person
myself, I believe that our needs should come first. After all, we are the future!
We're the future, and investing in us means investing in a better tomorrow.
Host: Strong points, Evy! The challenges faced by the youth are indeed significant.
Now, let's explore potential solutions in our next segment.
Segment 3: Bridging the Gap
Host: Both Carla and Evy present compelling arguments, but is there a middle
ground? Can we bridge the generational gap and find common ground that benefits
everyone?
Carla: Absolutely! It's about mutual respect and understanding. We can create
programs that leverage the wisdom of the elderly while providing support and
opportunities for the young.
Evy: I agree, Carla. Collaboration is key. Let's invest in education and job
opportunities for the youth while ensuring our elders receive the care and respect
they deserve.
Host: Fantastic suggestions! It seems like there's room for compromise and
collaboration. Dear listeners, what are your thoughts? Join the conversation using
our hashtag #GenerationsUnplugged.
In conclusion, "Generations Unplugged" encourages dialogue, understanding, and
finding common ground in this dynamic debate. Stay tuned for more
thought-provoking discussions on the clash of perspectives in our ever-evolving
world!

(a) Host: Carla, you argued that the elderly should be the priority because of their
wisdom and the reciprocal nature of caregiving.Identify Carla’s statement whether it
is a Fact or Opinion.Does it provide concrete data or examples to support it? (3)

(c) Which argument is more convincing, Carla’s or Evy’s?(6)

You should consider the following points while stating your answer -
1. Use of examples
2. Use of data/ statistics
3. Suggestions given

(b)Host: Evy, you mentioned that many elders had secure jobs and generous
pensions.Identify Evy’s statement whether it is a Fact or Opinion.Does it provide
concrete data or examples to support it? (3)