You are on page 1of 6

Clinical Simulation in Nursing (2021) 55, 37-42

Short communication

Using Social Media and Snowball Sampling as an


Alternative Recruitment Strategy for Research ✩
Kim Leighton, PhD, RN, CHSE, CHSOS, ANEF, FSSH, FAAN a ,∗,
Suzan Kardong-Edgren, PhD, RN, ANEF, CHSE, FSSH, FAAN b,
Tonya Schneidereith, PhD, CRNP, PPCNP-BC, CPNP-AC, CNE, CHSE-A, ANEF,
FAAN c, Colette Foisy-Doll, MSN, RN, CHSE, ANEF d
a
Itqan Clinical Simulation and Innovation Center, Hamad Medical Corporation, Doha, Qatar
b
MGH Institute of Health Professions, Boston, MA, USA
c
University of Maryland School of Nursing, Baltimore, MD, USA
d
MacEwan University Faculty of Nursing, Edmonton, AB Canada

Keywords Abstract The COVID-19 pandemic demanded rapid change in health care education, moving many stu-
snowball sampling; dents to online learning. It is important to examine how this shift affected both student perceptions
social media; of learning and achievement of learning outcomes. Snowball sampling strategy was used to reach and
LinkedIn; recruit nursing students, who had shifted to online learning during the pandemic, to participate in a
Twitter; research study survey. This paper outlines the process of snowball sampling using social media, explores
survey response rate; the relationship between social media posts and survey completion, describes the strategy’s challenges
simulation; and benefits, and provides recommendations to those who may consider using this novel sampling
methodology.
undergraduate nursing;
screen-based Cite this article:
simulation; Leighton, K., Kardong-Edgren, S., Schneidereith, T., & Foisy-Doll, C. (2021, Month). Using Social Me-
clinical dia and Snowball Sampling as an Alternative Recruitment Strategy for Research. Clinical Simulation in
Nursing, 55, 37-42. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecns.2021.03.006.
© 2021 International Nursing Association for Clinical Simulation and Learning. Published by
Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.

Introduction changes were often made with few resources, including the
time and support necessary to teach in alternative environ-
The COVID-19 pandemic demanded a swift change to ments. Outcomes related to these altered teaching strate-
all facets of healthcare education, including the deliv- gies needed to be studied so that educators could determine
ery of didactic material, simulation, traditional clinical, which of their new teaching methods should be retained
and psychomotor and non-technical skills training. These for future use and which should be discarded. Data were
needed to drive these decisions; however, the pandemic
✩ This research did not receive any specific grant from funding agencies quarantine challenged the ability of many researchers to
in the public, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors. reach their target populations. This paper outlines how
∗ Corresponding author. kleighton@hamad.qa (K. Leighton). snowball sampling was used to complete a research study
1876-1399/© 2021 International Nursing Association for Clinical Simulation and Learning. Published by Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecns.2021.03.006
Clinical Simulation in Nursing 38

on distance learning and describes the benefits and chal- Sampling Strategy
lenges of using this social media sampling method.
Reaching the target population was challenging as most
students were learning from home. A novel approach to
Background subject recruitment was used, incorporating snowball sam-
pling into social media. This snowball sampling method
On March 11, 2020, the World Health Organization and study was approved by the university’s Research Ethics
(WHO) announced the global health crisis of COVID-19 Board. Snowball sampling is a recognized and viable
and declared it a method of recruiting study participants not easily acces-
worldwide pandemic sible or known to the researcher (Marcus et al., 2017;
Key Points (WHO, 2020). Many ed-
• Social media was an
Naderifar, Goli, & Ghaljaie, 2017; Reagan et al., 2019;
ucators were forced to Wohl et al., 2017). Briefly, it is a common sampling
effective and efficient move courses and expe- method in qualitative research where the researcher does
way to recruit study riential learning activities not directly recruit participants but contacts others who
participants. entirely online. Guidance
• Snowball sampling is
then connect them to research participants (Marcus et al.,
came rapidly from or- 2017; Parker, Scott, & Geddes, 2019). As the researchers
a viable method of re- ganizations such as the could not access students in a classroom, or within a col-
cruiting study partici- American Association lege or similar location, they were unable to easily identify
pants. for Colleges of Nursing
• Social
their potential participants to recruit and needed to rely on
media sites (AACN, March 2020) and social media to find the participants through snowball sam-
provide analytic the Canadian Association pling.
data that can help of Schools of Nursing Researchers used snowball nonprobability convenience
researchers track en- (CASN, Mar 2020); how- sampling by initially connecting with professionals or
gagement with their ever, the logistics of groups on social media platforms (e.g., LinkedIn and
posts. moving online were re- Facebook student nurse groups) that most closely aligned
ported to be challenging. with the target population. First steps involved identify-
For simulation educators, there was a tremendous shar- ing social media sites that catered to nursing students,
ing of resources. Simulation leaders met regularly online to nursing educators, and simulationists. Twenty-eight sites
converse about how to keep learners safe and healthy. Ven- from LinkedIn and Facebook were identified (13 student
dors freely distributed scenarios and associated documenta- sites; 15 educator/simulationist sites). Of 13 student site
tion. Although the internet abounded with examples of the owners contacted, only one posted the study recruitment
collaborative nature of these efforts, the impact on learn- information. The researchers then requested permission
ing outcomes was unclear. Additionally, it was important to to post on the fifteen educator and simulationist sites,
determine the students’ perceptions of how well their expe- with seven site owners posting recruitment information via
riential learning needs were met through the screen-based blogs, LinkedIn, Twitter, Instagram, and websites. The re-
simulation (SBS) environment, defined as taking place on searchers also emailed colleagues to post recruitment in-
a computer screen where a keyboard, mouse, or other in- formation on their personal, school, or business social me-
put device is used by a learner to interact with graphi- dia sites. Additionally, each researcher posted to their per-
cal images and text. Feedback and assessment are possible sonal social media sites (Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn) to
because actions and decisions can be tracked. The SBS ask readers to forward the research opportunity to students
environment does not necessarily require an instructor’s in an effort to reach more potential participants. While
presence (Lioce et al., 2020). impossible to know how many people were reached, or
if they were reached by another student, faculty, or ran-
dom chance, these combined accounts had over 28,000
Educational Research during COVID-19 members or followers. Postings included wording designed
to prompt nursing students to share the study information
The research team set out to assess how well undergraduate with peers, such as:
nursing students’ learning needs were met through use of . . . ‘share a research opportunity with pre-licensure
the SBS environment, compared to the traditional clinical nursing students worldwide’. . . ‘we are using a snowball
(TC) environment and face-to-face simulation (F2FS). This sampling strategy through social media sites to reach [nurs-
study used an updated version (CLECS 2.0) of the Clin- ing students]’. . . ‘We know these are challenging times
ical Learning Environment Comparison Survey (CLECS; and we appreciate any assistance that you can offer to help
Leighton, 2015) that added a SBS environment response us reach students’. . . ‘help connect us to nursing students
section. Revision and psychometric analysis of the CLECS and graduates’. . . ‘send nursing students to the link’. . .
2.0 fall outside the scope of this manuscript. ‘retweet for nursing students.’

pp 37–42 • Clinical Simulation in Nursing • Volume 55


Clinical Simulation in Nursing 39

Table 1 Data Collection at Start & End of Study


First 15 Days Number Last 15 Days Number Total Number (100%) During Data
(Percentage) (Percentage) Collection Period

Survey Responses 126 (61%) 48 (23%) 208 (100%)



174 usable surveys for data analysis
LinkedIn (LI) Posts 8 posts (26%) 8 posts (26%) 31 posts (100%)
4697 views (49%) 704 views (7%) 9561 views
66 shares (88%) 0 shares (0%) 75 shares
66 reactions (34%) 13 reactions (7%) 196 reactions
12 comments (57%) 0 comments (0%) 21 comments
Twitter (T) Posts 4 tweets (17%) 5 tweets (21%) 23 tweets (100%)
2144 impressions (33%) 2094 impressions (32%) 6540 impressions
76 engagements (35%) 78 engagements (35%) 220 engagements
14 retweets (36%) 12 retweets (31%) 39 retweets
0 replies (0%) 1 reply (50%) 2 replies
12 likes (32%) 13 likes (34%) 38 likes
21 URL clicks (81%) 4 URL clicks (15%) 26 URL clicks
20 detail expands (24%) 34 detail expands (40%) 84 detail expands
LI: Reactions = expressions that make it easier to participate and communicate (e.g., Like, Celebrate; LinkedIn reactions, 2020).
T: Impressions = “number of times users saw the Tweet on Twitter”; Engagements = “total number of times a user has interacted with a Tweet” (Twitter
Analytics, 2020).

When recruiting via snowball sampling, it is crucial companies/vendors, government entities, and organizations
to keep the snowball ‘rolling.’ Each researcher commit- (Table 2). Facebook posts were not analyzed due to a lack
ted to reposting, retweeting, and sharing their own and of analytics collection by the platform.
others’ posts on a planned bi or tri weekly basis over
the recruitment phase of the study. This was done us-
ing hashtags (#) to promote content categorization and
Discussion
At Signs (@) to maximize reposting and facilitate com-
munication (Hunt, 2015), in efforts to reach the right
Data were analyzed for two points in time–the first 15
population. Data collection began April 26th and ended
days (April 26-May 12, 2020) and the last 15 days of data
June 30, 2020. Researchers tracked dates of LinkedIn data
collection (June 16-30, 2020). These data were analyzed
(postings, views, shares, reactions, comments) and Twitter
against the total response data for the study. Eighty-four
data (tweets, impressions, engagements, retweets, replies,
percent of the CLECS 2.0 survey responses were tendered
likes, URL clicks, and detail expands); one researcher
at the beginning and end of data collection. Researchers’
collated overall data. Additionally, survey responses were
social media posts were evenly distributed at both assess-
tracked and aligned to postings.
ment points.
On LinkedIn, views and responses were high, with the
majority of shares occurring during the first 15 days result-
Findings ing in almost half of the total views. Shares in LinkedIn
decreased toward the end of the study. Twitter retweets and
Overall, 208 people accessed the survey via Qualtrics engagement metrics were almost equally distributed at the
(Provo, UT) link, with 174 usable responses. Data col- start and end of data collection, except for a decrease in
lection was brisk during the first and last 15 days of the URL clicks and an increase in detail expands. These find-
study (Table 1), with 84% of the total responses occurring ings correlated with decreased survey responses over the
in these two periods. Respondents were from 9 countries, last 15 days, as the URL clicks led to survey information
with participants from 8 countries responding in the first posted on a website. Detail expands may have increased
15 days. as viewers checked to see if new information was posted
The researchers’ LinkedIn posts numbered the same (Table 1).
during both periods (8); however, the total views decreased Demographics of those who viewed posts in LinkedIn
over each period. Researchers tracked viewers, employ- were analyzed. As the researchers have academic, clini-
ers, and locations of those who viewed or responded to cal, company/vendor, governmental, and organizational ties
posts using LinkedIn analytics function. Comparable data in their employment history, it is not surprising that the
was unavailable for Twitter. LinkedIn post viewers hailed posts attracted views from those sectors. Responses show
from seven countries and represented academic, clinical, the potential power of a snowball strategy to reach those

pp 37–42 • Clinical Simulation in Nursing • Volume 55


Clinical Simulation in Nursing 40

Table 2 Demographics of LinkedIn Viewers


General Type of Business Type of Organization Title of Viewers∗

Academic Colleges Arts Professional


Community Colleges Career Counselor
Technical Colleges Community Development Specialist
Universities Education Administrator
Fellow
Human Resources Specialist
IT Consultant
IT Support Specialist
Laboratory Scientist
Operations Specialist
Program Manager, Research
School Teacher
Student
University Professor
Clinical Ambulance Service Customer Service Specialist
Health Systems Dietician
Home Health Care Medical Assistant
Hospitals Nurse
Companies & Vendors Construction Business Owner
Design Business Strategist
Publishing Consultant
Simulation Contract Worker
Telecommunications Executive Director
Workforce Solutions Founder
Logistics Specialist
Mechanic & Maintenance Tradesperson
Product Development Engineer
Product Manager
Salesperson, Medical
Technology Manager
Government Armed Forces Corporate Trainer
National Health
Organizations Medical
Nursing
Simulation
Surgical
Location of Respondents United States (22 states, District of Columbia), Canada,
Australia, Belgium, Turkey, India, United Kingdom
∗ Titles are defined by LI; not all responses were aligned with a title.

who might not otherwise learn about a study. However, it der revision) using the CLECS required 9 Institutional Re-
is impossible to know which respondents were attracted view Board (IRB) approvals and 9 months of data col-
to the study by which platform and whether they learned lection with a resulting sample of 159. This is an 8%
about the study from a peer, educator, or random oppor- lower response rate, took 7 months longer, and required
tunity. Future research into this sampling strategy should 8 additional IRB approvals than this comparable study us-
include questions to help determine how respondents were ing snowball sampling. This strategy overcame the need to
reached. have site coordinators, thereby reducing staff/faculty time
There are benefits and challenges associated with snow- as well as potential deviation from the study protocol. De-
ball sampling. While researchers can access a sample that creasing study time and personnel involvement may lead
is unknown or difficult to reach, the downside is an inabil- to cost savings. Researcher relationships with study par-
ity to determine sampling error and make generalizations ticipants is a known potential bias when conducting re-
that findings are representative of the studied population search on site; therefore, snowball sampling through so-
(Sharma, 2017). However, this strategy may help recruit cial media widens the sample to those unknown to the
more participants. A recent multisite study (manuscript un- researchers.

pp 37–42 • Clinical Simulation in Nursing • Volume 55


Clinical Simulation in Nursing 41

Snowball sampling through social media may introduce Conflicts of interest


sampling bias toward characteristics of those who have an
active online presence. Eighty-one percent of the US popu- None.
lation have smartphones, increasing access to the Internet,
but people earning under $30,000 annually (Silver, 2019)
and living in rural locations (Wheeler, 2020) have less ac-
cess. Worldwide, almost half the population does not have References
Internet (UNESCO, 2019). Nursing students can fall into
American Association of Colleges of Nursing (AACN). (2020). Con-
these categories, thereby potentially limiting representation siderations for COVID-19 preparedness and response in U.S. schools
in the sample. The researchers were also challenged by of nursing. Retrieved 4 Oct 2020 from https://www.aacnnursing.org/
lack of response from social media sites catering to nursing News- Information/COVID- 19/AACN- Recommendations.
students as this led to use of social media sites designed Canadian Association of Schools of Nursing (CASN). (2020).
for faculty. Nursing education during the COVID-19 pandemic. Retrieved
4 Oct 2020 from https:// www.casn.ca/ wp-content/ uploads/ 2020/ 03/
COVID- 19- POSITION- STATEMENT.pdf.
Hunt, C. (2015). Understanding and using # tags and @ tags. So-
cial Media Today. Retrieved 4 Oct 2020 from https://www.
Recommendations socialmediatoday.com/ social-networks/ courtney-hunt/ 2015-07-06/
understanding- and- using- tags- and- tags.
In hindsight, the researchers could have learned more about Leighton, K. (2015). Development of the clinical learning environment
how social media works before starting the snowball sam- comparison survey. Clinical Simulation in Nursing, 11(1), 44-51. https:
pling strategy. For example, researchers were inexperi- // doi.org/ 10.1016/ j.ecns.2014.11.002.
LinkedIn reactions (2020). Use LinkedIn reactions Retrieved 4
enced with Twitter and would have benefitted from a better Oct 2020 from https:// www.linkedin.com/ help/ linkedin/ answer/ 101466/
understanding of how hashtags are used. Analytics support- use- linkedin- reactions?lang=en.
ing LinkedIn and Twitter provided detailed feedback on en- Lioce, L. (Ed.), Lopreiato, J. (Founding Ed.), Downing, D., Change, T.P.,
gagement with posts; however, there were different types Robertson, J.M., Anderson, M., Diaz, D.A., & Spain, A.E. (Assoc Eds.)
of data, making direct comparisons challenging. Recom- and the Terminology and Concepts Working Group (2020). Health-
care Simulation Dictionary Second Edition. Rockville, MD: Agency
mendations include using site analytics of successful posts for Healthcare Research and Quality. AHRQ Publication No. 20-0019.
early-on to create future content or designs. doi:10.23970/simulationv2.
Maintaining enthusiasm and creating interest in each Marcus, B., Weigelt, O., Hergert, J., Gurt, J., & Gelléri, P. (2017). The use
post was challenging. Researchers posted recruitment in- of snowball sampling for multi source organizational research: Some
formation, then retweeted/reposted each other, in addi- cause for concern. Personnel Psychology, 70(3), 635-673. https://doi.
org/ 10.1111/ peps.12169.
tion to reposting others’ comments or posts on our study. Naderifar, M., Goli, H., & Ghaljaie, F. (2017). Snowball sampling: A
Each time, the researchers included hashtags and At Signs purposeful method of sampling in qualitative research. Strides in De-
geared toward the student nurse. Analytics showed that velopment of Medical Education, 14(3), Article 367670. https://doi.org/
the contacts were similar amongst the researchers and may 10.5812/sdme.67670.
have resulted in viewer fatigue. Our team suggests dispers- Parker, C., Scott, S., & Geddes, A. (2019). Snowball sampling. Sage
research methods foundations. London, UK: Sage Publications. https:
ing messages throughout the two platforms at irregular in- // doi.org/ 10.4135/ 9781526421036831710.
tervals, rather than all at once. The data showed sustained Reagan, L., Nowlin, S. Y., Birdsall, S. B., Gabbay, J., Vorderstrasse, A.,
interest on the Twitter platform; research into platform ef- Johnson, C., & Melkus, G. D’E. (2019). Integrative review of recruit-
fectiveness is warranted. There are products available (e.g., ment of research participants through Facebook. Nursing Research,
Hootsuite) to facilitate a planned, strategic approach to 68(6), 423-432. https:// doi.org/ 10.1097/ NNR.0000000000000385.
Sharma, G. (2017). Pros and cons of different sampling techniques. In-
posting. ternational Journal of Applied Research, 3(7), 749-752 No doi.
Silver, L. (2019). Smartphone ownership is growing rapidly around the
world, but not always equally. Pew Research Center: Global Attitudes
& Trends. Retrieved 4 Oct 2020 from https://www.pewresearch.
Conclusion org/ global/ 2019/ 02/ 05/ smartphone- ownership- is- growing- rapidly-
around- the- world- but- not- always- equally/.
This exploration of data collected using snowball sam- Twitter Analytics (2020). Tweet activity. Retrieved 4 Oct 2020 from https:
//analytics.twitter.com.
pling via social media demonstrated that this method is
United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UN-
an effective and efficient way to recruit study participants. ESCO). (2019). New report on global broadband access underscores
When compared to the authors’ previous experience, snow- urgent need to reach the half of the world is still unconnected.
ball sampling made possible an increased sample size and UNESCO. Retrieved 16 Oct 2020 from https:// en.unesco.org/ news/
decreased time to completion, as well as elimination of new- report- global- broadband- access- underscores- urgent- need- reach-
half- world- still- unconnected.
burdensome IRB applications. Recommendations include
Wheeler, T. (2020). 5 steps to get the internet to all Amer-
a deeper dive into the workings of social media and avail- icans. Brookings: Center for Technology Innovation. Re-
able analytics before embarking on a study using social trieved 16 Oct 2020 from https:// www.brookings.edu/ research/
media sites for snowball sampling. 5- steps- to- get- the- internet- to- all- americans/.

pp 37–42 • Clinical Simulation in Nursing • Volume 55


Clinical Simulation in Nursing 42

Wohl, A. R., Ludwig-Barron, N., Dierst-Davies, R., Kulkarni, S., Ben- World Health Organization (WHO) (2020). WHO characterizes COVID-
detson, J., Jordan, W., & Perez, M. (2017). Project engage: Snow- 10 as a pandemic Retrieved 4 Oct 2020 from https://www.who.
ball sampling and direct recruitment to identify and link hard-to-reach int/ emergencies/ diseases/ novel- coronavirus- 2019/events- as- they-
HIV-infected persons who are out of care. Journal of Acquired Im- happen.
mune Deficiency Syndromes, 75(2), 190-197. https:// doi.org/ 10.1097/
QAI000000000000312.

pp 37–42 • Clinical Simulation in Nursing • Volume 55

You might also like