Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Readers of the Bulletin may be surprised to see this special gravate the conditions that breed conflict, thus increasing
issue on human population growth. While it may appear the chances that nuclear weapons will be used. They in-
to he an ahrupt departure from the Bulletin's usual themes clude:
— international conflict and the threat of nuclear war— • destruction and dispersion of the one-time bonanza
the population issue has considerable relevance to those of "capital" (fossil fuels, rich soils, other species, and so
themes. Rapid population growth, rising competition for forth) that humanity inherited;
resources, and increasing environmental deterioration are • environmental deterioration, including the decay of the
intertwined factors in the human predicament that feed the systems that provide civilization with the "income" resour-
political tensions and conflicts of the late twentieth century. ces that are the only alternative to consuming our capital
The following article outlines the dimensions of that pre- stock;
dicament and sets the context. Then, Kingsley Davis pro- • the widening gap between rich and poor nations and
vides a historical overview of the global demographic situa- related patterns of migration;
tion. The connections between population growth and • the persistence of economic inequality within nations;
international conflict are described by Nazli Choucri. Frank • the rise of ethnic and religious separatism;
and Susan Mott focus on the population situation in Africa, • persisting high levels of hunger and unemployment;
a continent that includes many of the poorest and hungriest and
nations in the world as well as the most rapidly expanding • the relatively slow and geographically spotty progress
populations. Lee-Jay Cho examines Asia, the region where in ending racism, sexism, and religious prejudice.
more than half the world's people reside and whose largest All those negative trends are interrelated, and interwoven
country, China, has had the greatest recent success in brak- with them is one of the most basic causes of the human
ing population growth. Loy Bilderback discusses interna- predicament —unprecedented continued growth in human
tional migration, the third variable —along with birth and numbers in an already overpopulated world. When the two
death — in the study of population, and Carl Djerassi grap- of us were born in the early 1930s, only two billion people
ples with the controversy surrounding abortion and birth existed; by 1987, five billion will.
control. Finally, Herman Daly proposes an alternative eco- This year the population will grow by more than 84 mil-
nomic model based on sustainability and renewable re- lion people —a record number—and each year in the im-
sources rather than growth. mediate future will see a new record increment. A great deal
of attention has been paid to a small decrease in the global
by Paul R. Ehrlich and Anne H. Ehrlich growth rate since the early 1960s, a drop from about 2.2
percent annual natural increase to around 1.7 percent. But
7 ,
VY
b *
f
English writer C.P Snow saw that when the number of people using a the problems of an expanding, ever more complex, global society. From
service grows, the number of sen/Ice problems grows at an even faster rate, 1930 to 1976 the number ot people on earth doubled from two billion to four
proportional to the number of possible connections between users. The billion-and the number of possible connections quadrupled. Based on
diagram above illustrates this principle. For example, when the number of current growth rates, ttie population could be expected to double again to
nodes doubles, from four to eight, the number of connections between eight billion by 2020, bringing another quadrupling of possible connections
them more than quadruples. This law of connections helps explain many of -and of Snow's "service difficulties."
Informational graphics in population articles: Michael Yanoff
April 1986
14
If today's population were of constant size, it still would already born. Today there are over 30 million Mexicans
have to run continually, like the Red Queen, to stay in place. under the age of 15.
Technology would have to be constantly improved to com-
pensate for depleted supplies of fuels, declining quality of i N THE FACE of all these factors, why is the population
ores, and deterioration of soils, and to protect people from component so often ignored in discussions of the human
the environmental consequences of using both old and new predicament? One possible reason is evolutionary. Evolu-
technologies. But today's population is growing. Each addi- tionary success has meant, and means today, outbreeding
tional person, on average, must be cared for by using lower- your friends and neighbors.
quality resources that must be transported further, and by Animal populations have often increased in size to the
food grown on more marginal land. Supplying the addi- point where they exceeded the carrying capacity of their
tional energy needed for these tasks creates both economic environments, which, in turn, led to catastrophic popula-
and environmental problems. tion declines or extinctions. Homo sapiens is the first of
Although population growth rates are highest in poor billions of species that has developed the ability both to
countries, overpopulation and continuing population detect the relation of its population size to carrying capa-
growth in rich countries are the prime threat to global city and, through birth control, to adjust its numbers to
resources and environmental systems, simply because the fit within that capacity.
average individual in rich nations has a large impact on
Yet, problems of overpopulation were rarely present or
resources and environment. One ofthe best available mea-
perceived over most of the millions of years that human
sures of that impact is a nation's per capita use of commer-
beings were evolving into the most successful of the great
cially produced energy. In the United States, the average
apes. Throughout our evolutionary history, the emphasis
person uses the commercial energy equivalent of about
has been on successful reproduction. People therefore have
10.,000 kilograms of coal annually. In contrast, an average
great difficulty facing the fact that either humanity must
South American uses about 1,000 kilograms, an Asian
consciously halt population growth and then gradually
about 600, and an African about 425. By this measure,
reduce its numbers, or nature will end the explosion of
the birth of an average baby in the United States will be
human numbers with a catastrophic population crash. De-
about 200 times as disastrous for the world as the birth
creasing the death rate goes with the evolutionary grain,
of an average Bangladeshi, who will consume the commer-
and in the past century our species has been extraordinarily
cial equivalent of some 45 kilograms of coal annually.
successful at it. Avoiding disaster by humanely causing a
This does not mean that population growth in poor na- compensating decline in the birth rate, unfortunately for
tions is harmless. But, as a great oversimplification, one humanity, goes against long-evolved prejudices.
can say that population growth in less developed countries
primarily harms those countries, while that in industrialized A second evolutionary reason is that the human nervous
nations harms the world as a whole. Consider what it system developed little capacity to detect gradual trends in
means for poor countries such as Bangladesh or Kenya to the environment —trends that only created significant
double their populations in 25 and 17 years, respectively, changes after decades or centuries. Over most of our his-
as they are currently doing. If those nations are to main- tory, our ancestors did not need to respond adaptively to
tain their present standards of living, low as they are, they such changes, but to sudden or rapid alterations in their
will have to duplicate every amenity for the support of hu- environments. So our nervous systems evolved a high capa-
man beings in that time period. Among other things, that city to detect the sudden appearance of tigers and the crack
means doubling their food production, their supply of of falling trees and a low capacity to respond to growth
teachers, doctors, engineers, and scientists, and the capaci- in human numbers, nuclear arms, or environmental damage
ty of housing, hospitals, road and rail systems, and manu- from acid rains.
facturing plants. It would be a daunting task for a rich The inability of peopie to register change over long
nation such as the United States, with abundant capital, periods often leads them to ignore history, to believe that
incredibly rich soils, good supplies of most other resources, the world has not and will not change. It allows economists
fine transport and communications systems, vast industrial to think that there have always been and always will be high
capacity, and a largely educated and literate population. rates of economic growth. Even those who admit that there
Most poor nations have none of these things. must be ultimate limits to growth struggle to keep their
Indeed, even without further growth, most less developed world constant by assuming, against all the evidence, that
countries face massive problems in the near future just be- those limits are so far in the future that they can be safely
cause of their age structures. In Mexico, for instance, about ignored.
half of the labor force is unemployed or underemployed. There is no longer any substitute for analysis; the world
That is bad enough, but in the next 15 years Mexico will can no longer afford to believe such myths as that economic
have to find jobs for perhaps 10 million people if the un- growth can be infinite, contraception is immoral, and more
employment rate is not to increase, and 20 million people nuclear weapons will prevent nuclear war. All the educa-
if the number of unemployed is not to rise. Those numbers tional mechanisms that society can deploy must be focused
are not based on future population growth, but on people on teaching people to understand the physical and biologi-
April 1986
16
ca! constraints on human activities, to recognize and deal different aspects of a general problem of social organiza-
with long-term trends, and to perceive the connections be- tion. But while that global enlightenment is awaited, action
tween various aspects of the human predicament. Then must be taken to end both the arms race and the baby race,
everyone will recognize that problems as seemingly discon- for either is likely to result in the premature deaths of bil-
nected as Star ^X^lrs and the population bomb are simply lions of human beings. D
April 1986
18
Gross Military
Annual national share
Reputation, population product of state Life Adult
1980 growth per capita budget expectancy illiteracy Abortion
(millions) (percent)^ (1980 USS) (percentP (men/women)^ (percentP restrictions^
Spain 38.0 0.7 5,640 10.1 70/76 8 1
Sweden 8.3 0.1 14.870 6,8 73/79
fi S n
AJ.U
fi 17 4^0 99 1 7n/7fi u
n
Turi<ey 45.5 2.1 1,540 19.1 60/62 40
1 InitpH [ KinoHnm U,E,J
U r Q
W 1 IK^U M F P^^HI^JI 1 1
56.0 09 q 110 fiR/74
USSR 265.0 0.9 4,155 48.3 64/74 0.2
Yugoslavia 22.5 0.8 2,790 20.8 65/70 17
Middle East
Cyprus 0.6 1.4 3,740 7.8 72/75 24 ?
Iran 40 1 98 7Q7 7fi 11
/u Ll
Iraq 13.5 3.5 2,254 54/57 Li
76
Israel 4.0 1.9 5,160 34.2 72/76 12 H.E.J
Jordan 3.4 3.6 1,620 23.4 62/66 32
Kuwait 1.5 6.8 20,900 14.1 66/72 40 U
1phannn 97 04 ft^/fi7 1 j
^. / LJ
fim^ n
OQ
sn 6 920 44
' 1*1
0.\j 4fi/4R
'-rU/MO
7
09 4^ ?7 790 90 1
Saudi Arabia 9.3 4.1 12,600 26.7 47/49 75 u
Syria 9.3 n/a 1,570 35.4 63/65 60 Li
United Arab Emirates 1.1 7.2 24,660 41.4 n/a 44 ?
Yemen, North 7.3 2.3d 460 30.0 39/40 91 U
Yemen, South 2.0 2.3d 460 45.7 43/45 73 7
North America
Canada 94 9 19 11 400 7 ft 7om
/\Ji 1 1
H
n
Mexioo 71.2 2.7 2,250 2.4 17
United States 229.8 0.9 12,820 24.9 70/78 1
Oceania
Australia 14.9 1.5 11,080 9.1 71/78 H,E,S
Fiji 0.6 1.9 2,000 3.0 70/73 21 ?
MtHW 7oa la nH 1 n 7 7nn Aa CQI-7C
t-i p 1
i .U n,c,j
Papua New Guinea 31 2.1 840 3.5 50/50 68 H
South America
Argentina 28.2 1.6 2,560 12.8 65/71 7 H,J
Rnlivia 57 Q Q
fiflO •^7 M1
o/
Brazil 120.5 2.3 2,220 9.3 58/61 U,J
24
Chiie 11.3 1.7 2,560 9.8 61/68 11 y
Colombia 26.4 n/a 1,360 10.3 61/64 19 u
Ecuador 8.6 3.5 1,180 10.2 60/62 26 U,J
Guyana 0.8 2.0 720 5.9 67/72 8 7
Paraguay 3.1 3.1 1,630 11.4 62/65 20 Li
Peru 17.0 2.7 1,170 24.4 55/58 28 U
Uruguay 2.9 0.7 2,820 9.9 66/73 6 U,J,S
Venezuela 15.4 3.0 4,220 5,0 65/70 u
The following low-populated countries are not included in the table: Antigua vwman's health; E: permitted on eugenic grounds (fetal birth defects); J:
and Barbuda, Bahamas, Bahrain, Barbados, Belize, Bermuda, Brunei. Cape permitted on juridical grounds {pregnancies resulting from rape or incest);
Verde, Comoros, Dominica, Equatorial Guinea, French Guiana, Greenland, S: permitted on social or sociai-medical grounds (woman's age, marital and
Grenada, Guadeloupe, Iceland, Kiribati, Luxembourg, Macao. Maldives. economic status, size of family); ?: information not available. Countries without
Malta. Martinique, ^ n t a Lucia, St. Vincent and the Grenadines, Sao Tom6 listings provide legal abortion on demand, although restrictions are often
and Principe, Seychelles, Surinam, Western Samoa. placed on second- or third-trimester abortions.
3 n/a: information unavailable. •^Separate listing not available.
^ : negligible amount, or information unavailable.
c Key to national restrictions on abortion: I: Illegal {no exceptions, although Sources: 1982 Statistical Yearbook. 33rd edition (New \brk: United Na-
abortions to save woman's life may be authorized under general principles tions, 1985); Christopher Tietze. Induced Abortion: A WDrld View. 4th edition
of criminal law); Li: permitted only if woman's life would be endangered (New York: The Fbpulation Council, 1981); Ftete Ayrton, Tom Engelhardt, and
by full-term pregnancy; H: permitted if the pregnancy will endanger the Vron Ware, eds., Wfer/d View (New York: Pantheon, 1984).