You are on page 1of 67

ADAMSON UNIVERSITY i

Assessment of Cashless Transaction Using QR Scan on Food Stalls along the


University Belt

A Thesis

Presented to the Faculty of the

College of Business Administration

Adamson University

Manila

In Partial Fulfillment
Of the Requirements for the Degree
BACHELOR OF SCIENCE IN BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION
MAJOR IN FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT

Presented by:
John A.
Marie P.
James G.
Abdellah
Alonzo T.

May 2023

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY iii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

We would like to express our gratitude and acknowledgment to the following

people who have helped, guided and inspired us in making this research possible.

To our teacher and adviser, Prof. Annedrei Maurizze Barcarse, MBA . , who

assisted and guided us from start to finish, taught us the step-by-step procedure to

make this research possible.

We are also grateful to our panelists Dr. Emily Baluyot, Dr. Jose Mari Lee,

and Prof. Paul Belleza, MBA for sharing their knowledge by checking our works,

marking our errors, giving more suggestions that help improve our study and setting

everything right for our work to be acceptable.

We would also like to acknowledge our families for their untiring support,

most especially financially, for being our inspiration, and for their unwavering

encouragement and guidance throughout the study.

Lastly, to our Almighty Father in Heaven who is the source of all wisdom,

strength, patience, and understanding, and for the guidance throughout the study for

it would not be possible without him.

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY iv
DEDICATION

The success of this study is dedicated to the following people who helped us and

made it all possible to complete this study:

First of all, our Almighty God in Heaven who became the source of all the

knowledge and wisdom and the endless guide physically and spiritually to finish this study.

To our beloved parents who have always been there for us from the start. They have

given us their trust and determination to finish this study. Without their support, financially

and emotionally, this project would not have been made possible.

And to ourselves, for the patience and trust that we show to ourselves that we can

finish this study. All the sleepless nights we have gone through, all the money we spent

and the efforts we put in the process of this study. Finally, we are one step closer to PICC

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY vi
Table of Contents

TITLE PAGE i

APPROVAL SHEET ii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT iii
DEDICATION iv
ABSTRACT v
TABLE OF CONTENTS iv
LIST OF TABLES vii
LIST OF FIGURES viii
LIST OF APPENDICES ix

CHAPTER PAGE
1. INTRODUCTION 1
1.1 Background of Study 1
1.2 Statement of the Problem 6
1.3 Hypothesis 7
1.4 Scopes and Limitations 7
1.5 Significance of Study 8
1.6 Review of Related Literature 9
1.7 Definition of Terms 24
1.8 Theoretical Framework 26
1.9 Conceptual Framework 28
CHAPTER
2. METHODOLOGY 29
2.1 Research Design 29
2.2 Data Management 30
2.2.1 Data According to Source 30

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY vii
2.2.2 Data According to Methods 31
2.3 Sampling Design 32
2.3.1 Sample Population 32
2.3.2 Respondents 32
2.3.3 Research Instrument 32
2.3.4 Control Procedure 32
2.4 Statistical Treatment 33
2.5 Decision Criteria 33
2.6 Ethical Consideration 34
2.6.1 Conflict of Interest 35
2.6.2 Privacy and Confidentiality 35
2.6.3 Informed Consent Process 35
2.6.4 Vulnerability 36
2.6.5 Recruitment 36
2.6.6 Assent 36
2.6.7 Risks 36
2.6.8 Benefits 36
2.6.9 Incentives or Compensation 37
2.6.10 Community Consideration 37
2.6.11 Collaborative Study of Reference 37
CHAPTER
3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 38
3.1 Presentation, Analysis, and Interpretation of Data 39
3.2 Summary of Findings 53
3.3 Conclusions 56
3.4 Recommendations 58
REFERENCES 60

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY viii
LIST OF TABLES
Table 1.0 Frequency and Percentage Distribution of the 39
Respondents in terms of Age
Table 1.1 Frequency and Percentage Distribution of the 40
Respondents in terms of Sex
Table 1.2 Frequency and Percentage Distribution of the 40
Respondents in terms of Occupation
Table 1.3 Frequency and Percentage Distribution of the 41
Respondents in terms of Educational Background
Table 2.0 Weighted Mean: Perception of the respondents 41
towards the affect of capability for a food stall to run a full
transactions in terms of Performance Expectancy
Table 2.1Weighted Mean: Perception of the respondents 42
towards the effect of capability for a food stall to run a full
transactions in terms of Effort Expectancy
Table 2.2 Weighted Mean: Perception of the respondents 43
towards the affect of capability for a food stall to run a full
transactions in terms of Social Influence
Table 2.3 Weighted Mean: Perception of the respondents 44
towards the affect of capability for a food stall to run a full
transactions in terms of Risk
Table 2.4 Weighted Mean: Perception of the respondents 45
towards the affect of capability for a food stall to run a full
transactions in terms of Trust

Table 3.0 One- Way ANOVA: Difference between the 46


Evaluation of the Respondents on the Effect of
capability for A Food stall to run a full cashless
transaction and Age
Table 3.1 One- Sample T-Test: Difference between the 48
Evaluation of the Respondents on the Effect of
capability for A Food stall to run a full cashless
transaction and Educational Background
Table 3.2 One- Sample T-Test: Difference between the 50
Evaluation of the Respondents on the Effect of
capability for A Food stall to run a full cashless
transaction and Gender

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY ix

Table 3.3 One- Way ANOVA: Difference between the 51


Evaluation of the Respondents on the Effect of
capability for A Food stall to run a full cashless
transaction and Educational Background

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 1 Unified Theory of Acceptance and Use of 26
Technology
Figure 2 Conceptual Framework 27

LIST OF APPENDICES
Appendix A 65
Research Instrument 65
Questionnaires 66
Appendix B 70
Validation Letter 71
Appendix C 72
Informed Consent Form 72
Curriculum Vitae 77
Reliability Test 87
Statistician 89

Certification 90

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
INTRODUCTION

Background of the Study

The QR codes were invented in Japan, they are expected to be more popular in Asia

than in the rest of the world. East Asia had the highest QR code usage (15%) in 2019,

according to the previously mentioned global QR code usage statistics. China is widely

considered to have the highest rate of QR code adoption.

They have used a QR code payment method in everything from renting portable

chargers to paying for groceries since they developed it in 2011. The total payment

transactions made using QR codes in 2017 were also recorded at $550 billion. This

increased 15 times in three years, reaching $1.5 trillion in the fourth quarter of 2019. While

the Japanese were already in the process of updating. Since 2002, they have been using QR

codes in their coupons by scanning them with their phones and incorporating QR code

scanners into their smartphone cameras. Additionally, these QR codes are popular in other

Asian countries. QR codes are used by 40% of Indians, 27% of Vietnamese, and 23% of

Thai consumers. (Qr Tiger, 2022)

In recent years, we have witnessed a growing trend in cashless transactions as well

as products and services sold exclusively in this way. According to Fabris (2019) Cashless

societies and technological innovation have become increasingly popular around the world.

Having a cashless transaction in an economy does not necessarily mean shortage of cash,

rather it indicates a culture of people settling transactions digitally. In a modern economy,

money moves electronically, hence, the spread of digital payment culture along with the

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
expansion of infrastructure facilities is needed to achieve the goal of business. (Ramya,

Sivasakthi, & Nandhini, 2017)

In the year 2021 starts the adoption of cashless society, according to Lucas (2021),

Filipinos are increasingly using the so called QR or “Quick reaction” code when paying

for purchases and transferring money from one person to another and also Governor

Benjamin Diokno of the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas cited that in February 2021 the QR

Ph person to person payments increased by 22 percent and 26 percent respectively.

According to Megan (2021), that in Uptown Bonifacio it introduced a new way of dining,

Scan to Dine, which is a QR-based, centralized menu that can be accessed with a single tap

on the diner's smartphone. Customers simply need to use their phone's camera to scan the

QR code located on the top of the dining tables located on The Deck (4th level) of Uptown

Mall.

The increase of quick responses of QR code mobile payment users heralds the

coming of a Cashless Society to the point that the people are forced to adopt the QR code

mobile payment which many stores nowadays have like Sari-sari store, fish ball stand,

etc… (Tu et al, 2021) Consumers in the Philippines are changing cash to E-money in

order to avoid physical touch due to concerns about getting coronavirus. Based on the

article by Endo (2020) that the use of QR Code applications are less risky than cash

handling, because it is more efficient than physical payments, and is also very transparent.

Pebbles Sy, also stated that In a world where digital is the new normal, financial technology

should be considered the bedrock of digital service.

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
As the pandemic happened, the cashless transactions became a trend in the

Philippines, therefore the researcher decided to conduct this study in view of the fact that

there are not enough resources or study for cashless transactions in the Philippines.

According to Tu et al (2022), the result shows that from 248 respondents revealed the

perceived severity and social influence positively affected the perception of utilitarian and

health benefits of respondents, which in turn influenced the behavioral intention on the use

of QR code mobile payment.

The possibility of making and receiving payment is the key factor for prioritizing

the Digital payment or in other words using QR Code “Scan to pay”. The next advantage

is the security, the QR scan is made secure with varying levels of encryption and data

authentication. Some modes of payments for E-wallet enable the two-factor authentication

(TFA) to add a restriction layer for security and advantage of cashless transactions for food

stalls is that it is convenient for the consumer. There are many benefits of cashless payment

systems like QR codes for the customer for business owners, one of which is customer

satisfaction as the main goal. As business owners who want to expand their business, the

company needs to adjust to the cashless transaction but is not totally fully cashless, but it

can also be included in their mode of payment. According to the study conducted by

Chaveesuk and Piyawat (2021) the study conducted a survey that the majority of

respondents were retail business owners who have been in business for 1 - 5 years and have

a monthly income of less than 20,000 baht.

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
The majority of the entrepreneurs do not have employees and only accept cash

payments. Initial findings show that entrepreneurs in Thailand's eastern region with various

types of businesses have different intentions of using QR Code technology. The number of

times payments are received is smaller than in other firms. It is often used for receiving

cash payments, processing checks, and Accepting bank transfers as payment. Because the

majority of product entrepreneurs are family-owned firms, they are more accustomed to

accepting cash payments than any other way.

The adoption of cashless transactions using QR code scan on food stalls along the

University belt started during the COVID-19 pandemic. The Researchers want to assess

the adaptability of food stalls that use QR code scan to pay. Despite the growing popularity

of cashless transactions and the increasing adoption of QR scan technology in various

industries, there is a lack of comprehensive research focusing specifically on the

assessment of cashless transactions using QR scan on food stalls along the University Belt.

While studies have explored the implementation of cashless payment systems in different

contexts, there is a paucity of research that specifically investigates the demographic profile

of individuals who frequently patronize food stalls within the University Belt area and their

perception of the capability of food stalls to run full cashless transactions.

This study highlights the need to delve into the demographic characteristics of the

target population, including age, gender, occupation, and educational background, to better

understand their preferences, behaviors, and readiness to embrace cashless payment

systems. Additionally, there is a lack of research that systematically examines the

perceptions of these respondents regarding the effect of the capability of food stalls to

conduct full cashless transactions.

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
Factors such as performance expectancy, effort expectancy, social influence, risk,

and trust are crucial in understanding the potential barriers or facilitators that may influence

individuals' willingness to embrace and utilize cashless payment options in the context of

food stalls within the University Belt. The study aims to contribute to the existing literature

on cashless transactions and QR scan technology by providing valuable insights into the

specific demographic profile of staff and business owner of food stall along the University

Belt.

Furthermore, it seeks to explore the perceptions of these individuals regarding the

capability of food stalls to run full cashless transactions, shedding light on factors that may

affect the successful implementation and acceptance of cashless payment systems in this

particular setting.

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
Statement of the Problem

The study aims to answer the following questions in order using QR scan and its effects

on the food stall owners along the university belt.

1. What is the demographic profile of the respondent to be described in terms of:

1.1 Age

1.2 Gender

1.3 Occupation

1.4 Educational Background

2. What is the Perception of the Respondents Towards the Effect of Capability for a

Food Stall to Run a full cashless transaction?

2.1 Performance Expectancy

2.2 Effort Expectancy

2.3 Social Influence

2.4 Risk

2.5 Trust

3. Is there a significant difference between the respondent's demographic profile

and the variable mentioned in SOP 2?

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
Hypothesis

The hypothesis is based on the assessment of the researchers.

Hypothesis have been formulated:

H01: There were no significant differences between the evaluation of the respondents on

the effect of capability of a food stall to run a full cashless transaction when grouped

according to the demographic profile of the respondents.

Scope and Limitations

This study will be conducted in order to determine the different aspects of the

cashless transaction using QR Scan on food stalls along University Belt. The researchers

presumed the effects based on their experience in using cashless transactions, such as

Accessibility, Security, Lack of data, and Ethernet, and not being literate to generate scans

in different Cashless applications. The method to use for the source of data would be a

survey form.

The researchers limit the study to staff and owners of food stalls around Intramuros,

Recto U-BELT, Particularly those who are still using the traditional payment method and

not familiar with using QR code. The sample size in the study is limited to 125

Respondents. In each food stall along the University belt will be the respondents to answer

the survey questions.

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
Significance of Study

The results of this study will benefit the society as a whole. Keeping in mind the major role

that cashless transactions and the use of e-wallets play in our current economy. Since most

establishments are using cashless transactions when it comes to buying things in their

everyday life transactions, the use of e-wallets became popular because it is convenient.

● Students - Students who are using cashless payments are able to keep their money

secure because of having their money converted into online payments. With having

physical money on hand, there are risks of their money being stolen from them. It

also gives off increased efficiency because e-payments in transactions can be done

quickly through online or through applications. It also saves time from both parties.

A study related to QR codes can benefit students by providing them with an

understanding of the use of QR codes in various fields.

Students can learn about the different types of QR codes, their applications, and

how to create and scan QR codes. This knowledge can be useful in various fields,

such as marketing, advertising, and retail. It can also help students in their research

projects and assignments.

● Small Businesses - Also with the students, it saves time from the process of

traditional payments. It can lessen errors such as miscalculations that can lead to

loss to the stall or vice versa. It can increase the security of the business because

there can be no physical money stolen from them. Cashless payments can also offer

great flexibility for the business and also the customers, with the thought of having

to worry about how much money they need to have and count. Small businesses

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
can benefit from a study related to QR codes by gaining knowledge about the use

of QR codes in marketing and advertising. QR codes can be used to provide

customers with additional information about products, services, and promotions.

Small businesses can also use QR codes to collect customer data and feedback. By

understanding how to create and use QR codes effectively, small businesses can

enhance their marketing efforts and customer engagement.

● Future researchers- This study will benefit future researchers for future reference

to their study. Also, they can use this as a basis to rely on information that was

previously gathered from this research and can be used to assess and pinpoint

shortcomings. Because of this, this research works that look into these identified

gaps frequently have their roots in future research studies. A study related to QR

codes can benefit future researchers by providing them with insights into the use of

QR codes in different fields. Researchers can use this information to further explore

the effectiveness of QR codes in marketing, advertising, retail, and other areas. This

can lead to the development of new theories and models related to the use of QR

codes. Future researchers can also use the findings of the study as a basis for further

research on the topic.

Review of Related Literature

The Unified Theory of Acceptance and Use of Technology (UTAUT) is based on

studies of eight research models in information systems adoption study. Venkatesh (2003)

produced a model that consists of Five Variables, Performance expectancy, Effort

Expectancy, Social Influence, Risk, and trust. (Rosli et al., 2020)

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
Education is critical for improving the quality of human capital. Education can lead

to increased economic growth and higher living standards. (Weisbrod, 1964 as cited

Sukanti, 2022) According to certain research, education has a favorable influence on

income. Education is a critical contributor to income. (Mincer, 1974 as cited Sukanti,

2022) The primary components of human capital are knowledge and skills acquired via

schooling. (Schultz, 1961 as cited in Sukanti, 2022) Finding a suitable career without a

formal education is extremely difficult. A surge in education has resulted in a situation of

overeducated workers, with people with a higher academic background working in lower-

skilled positions. This is in contrast to undereducated employees, who have employment

that need more skills and knowledge than their school background provides. Given these

circumstances, the purpose of this research is to determine the impact of the mismatch

between workers' educational backgrounds and occupations on the Indonesian labor

market. (Sukanti, 2022) The number of overeducated workers with the mean approach is

more significant than that of unskilled workers and cleaning staff (26.73

percent). Similarly to overeducated workers, the proportion of undereducated workers is

larger in unskilled workers and cleaning staff (12.99 percent). The biggest mismatch

between educational background and occupation is the same for overeducated and

undereducated employees, which is an intriguing event. This is because the vast

majority These forms of the job require more strength/physical endurance in December

2022 and do not require any specific talents or expertise. This form of labor necessitates

basic skills learned in the first stage of basic education, such as reading, writing, and

mathematics, although these are not essential. As a result, it is possible to explain that this

work can be completed by anyone with any degree of education. (Sukanti, 2022)

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
The integration of QR code technology has influenced numerous aspects of our

lives, including the way occupations and industries handle transactions. Occupations across

different sectors have embraced QR transactions as a means to streamline payment

processes, enhance customer experiences, and improve overall efficiency.

Based on a study (CHAVEESUK, S. ; PIYAWAT, N. 2021), The results indicated that the

respondents with different business operation duration, monthly business income, and the

amount of capital investment had the indifferent intention of using QR code technology

with a statistical significance level of 0.05.

Performance Expectancy

Quick Response (QR) has become well known for its functionality such as it can

be used for information retrieval, connecting to other phones, and most importantly the use

of Scan to pay Qr code.

Performance expectancy was found to be a critical factor in the use of mobile

payment tools, QR codes are provided in the majority of cashier desks. In China, it can be

used easily regardless of the size and the location of these stores as stated in the research

by Chang et al. (2021). Paying using a QR code is one of the mobile banking applications

that eliminates dangers associated with card purchases while also offering greater

convenience than using cash, especially during the Covid-19 pandemic (Ngo and Nguyen,

2020).

A survey was conducted in 2021 on the usage of QR codes scan to pay, 31 percent

of the respondents in the Philippines indicated that they used QR code to make payments

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
in 2021. The 2020 use of QR scan to pay in the Philippines is 26% while in 2021 the result

is 31% when using QR scan to pay (Statista Research Department, 2022).

In an article written by Aineena Hani (2021), the QR program accelerated to

increase digital payments in the Philippines because it recognized the Quick Response

(QR) codes and a broad variety of possible applications. Additionally, QR PH interoperable

said that “They see a lot of potential for these QR payments. We have boarded a lot of

merchants and definitely, coupled with the QR PH interoperable QR PH QR codes, we see

more digital payments”.

QR Ph transactions grow as more banks, businesses adopt standard

(BusinessWorld, 2022), also Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas (BSP) Deputy Governor

Mamerto E.angko Sentral ng Pilipinas (BSP) Deputy Governor Mamerto E. Tangonan

Stated that“ The use of QR Ph payments has been gaining translation as an

alternative to traditional debit and credit card payments given the ease, convenience, and

security of merely scanning the QR code compared to having to bring a card.” “This trend

is expected to continue given that the merchant payments comprise over 70% of the total

monthly retail payments in the country, of which only 23% is digital. Thus, digitalizing

merchant payments is one of our top priorities in order to maximize its huge potential to

further advance digital payments' adoption in the country,” Mr Tangonan added in his

statement. Businesses need to adopt new norms in which money can be the second option

while prioritizing QR code scan to pay in their business.

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
Effort Expectancy

An indicator of how simple a system is to use is called effort expectancy (Ee). User

experience is crucial for providing a gauge of a person's comfort and ease when utilizing

technology. New technological innovations ought to be more user-friendly and beneficial.

However, some technology is challenging to adopt because it is challenging to learn,

unintuitive, overly complex, and constrained. Users and organizations will be at risk of not

utilizing new technology to its full potential in this case.

A model was empirically tested with a sample of 215 consumers of QR code mobile

payment services in China, claims study (Guo, Gao, Yang, & Jing, 2018). The results

suggested that five of seven research hypotheses were significantly supported. The findings

show that consumers' intentions to continue using QR code mobile payment services were

significantly positively directly impacted by performance expectancy, effort expectancy,

and social influence. Perceived danger did not, however, have a detrimental impact on

customers' propensity to utilize QR code mobile payment services on a regular basis. This

article adds to the body of knowledge about ongoing use of mobile payment systems.

Effort expectancy is defined as the degree of ease related to the use of specific

technology. In the context of mobile payment, this factor explains where individuals are

free from effort and easy to understand the use of certain types of mobile payment (Imani,

Anggono, 2020)

Effort expectancy is one of the determinants that influences the intention and usage

of a technology. As defined by the theorists, the degree of ease associated with the usage

of a system determines its utilization. Majority (27%) of the non-users find the process of

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
scanning QR codes difficult. This inhibits them from using the QR code technology. (Nath,

Dr. M, 2020)

Effort expectancy has also been shown to positively influence behavioral intention in the

context of mobile payment in Malaysia (Teo et al., 2015; Ramayah et al., 2017).

Social Influence

Social influence (SI) is the degree to which an individual perceives that important

others believe he or she should use the new system (Le et al., 2020)

The influence of family members, friends, peers or any person important to an

individual cannot be ignored in shaping the individual’s action or belief, and this is also

applicable in the context of technology adoption. This is especially true when the

technology is still in the infancy or introductory stage, in which there are only a few

adopters (Mun et al., 2017).

The COVID-19 pandemic has catalyzed a shift in awareness. It provided the

necessary push for more consumers, individuals, businesses, and the government to use

digital payments when the country implemented health and social-distancing protocols

(Estioko, Mesina, & Masangkay, 2021). In addition, as economic concerns and restrictions

continue to affect consumers worldwide, new buying and consumption patterns and

behaviors have emerged (Nielsen, 2020); as a result, customers shifted to cashless

transactions.

Martins et al. (2014). Found that social influence had an impact on the intention of

online users to adopt Internet services, while Chaouali et al. (2015). Reported that social

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
influence affected the mindset of every individual on the use of new innovative products

through technology services. Social influence (SI) can be derived from the effect of

subjective norms and social factors on behavior and intention to use e‐money in UTAUT.

The digital payments provider is collaborating with the City of Manila to deploy

contactless payments via its PayMaya QR method to the city’s newly-launched cashless

stalls around the Manila City Hall and in Divisoria, the city’s popular bargain shopping

market. The top quick service restaurants in the country like Jollibee, McDonald’s, and

KFC have all adopted PayMaya’s end-to-end digital payments solutions for enterprise

comprising the devices for in-store and drive-thru, PayMaya’s digital payment gateway, as

well as digital invoicing solutions to process online orders. (Devanesan, 2020)

Risk

Smartphones and information communication technology advancement have

played a huge part in our lives. As mobile technology innovation arises, QR codes became

the primary design to have a cashless transaction that can help clients pay their bills at any

time because of the convenience that it can bring to them. But, some of the clients are no

longer thinking, or they are setting aside the threats that can affect their privacy in the long

run. Kumar et al. (2022). In addition, every cashless transaction requires their users to

input their identification cards to have a legitimate identification in the application. It can

be a complete loss of privacy to the user while using the application. That can lead to a risk

of robbery because of exposing too much information in the application. (Fabris 2018).

QR Application became functional for every user of cashless transactions because

of the capability of the Barcode that can be used in different activities and bring

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
convenience to the user of the said application. However, it may cause problems for the

user of the cashless because of giving too much information in every QR Code Application.

They can also be utilized maliciously by cyber hackers.

According to Posey (2022), QR codes became the primary target of cybercriminals

because they are the easiest to access to steal the information of a client. Also, another

problem that QR codes may occur is that they become the main target of phishing attacks.

As stated by Agazzi (2020), Due to the design’s ease of replacement by malicious QR

Codes, fraudsters can quickly replace a trustworthy Qr code to commit cyber fraud.

Nowadays, Technology become a huge part of the financial industry. It becomes

more convenient and easier to use for every one who desires to have a transaction

anywhere. On the other hand, threats and risk also arise because it is very easy to generate

a QR code that can affect the transactions of the clients.

Using QR code in financial transactions has become a trend because of being easy

to transact without experiencing any inconvenience. It becomes less difficult to understand

how to use this kind of transaction. However, clients don't usually see the harmful effect

of the QR code, especially to those who are not literate in using quick response transactions.

As stated in the study of Rudesha (2019), Customers and small retailers are facing high

risk and problems in the application of cashless transactions because of the low literacy

rate in rural areas in different countries. Moreover, the government can reduce this kind of

risk for those people who don’t have enough knowledge in using QR codes, to increase the

public awareness of the advantages and disadvantages of the cashless transactions more

work must be done during the financial literacy campaign. (Rudesha 2019)

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
During the pandemic, the rapid transition of mode of payment has driven the

development of mobile devices and e-commerce to adapt the QR code scan as a payment

system. It becomes popular to the younger generation because of being easy and convenient

to use in every transaction. However, because of the abrupt demand of using QR code, it

may also increase the risk that can affect the consumer's privacy and decision-making.

According to the study of Huang et al. (2021) younger generations differ from other

generations' in terms of the systematic difference in values, preference and behavior

that are not stable. Also, limited attention can exert a negative impact on the consumer's

decision-making. In addition, Privacy risk, another perceived risk that younger generation

can encounter in disregarding the risk that can affect their privacy that can cause fraud and

hacking that potentially compromise the security of the cashless payment system.

Moreover, Namaroot and Jantasri (2022) by using the UTAUT model, perceived risk have

a significant influence on behavioral intention to use the cashless payment system.

Trust

Users of smartphones are expanding quickly. Smartphone users will number 5.22

billion by 2021, growing at a 1.8% annual rate, or 93 million new users (Wardani, 2021).

This is consistent with the rising number of internet users. The number of internet users

has increased to 4.66 billion as of this writing. 7.3% or 316 million more people in 2025

than in 2020. It's no surprise that digital transformation is on the rise given this tendency.

Also expanding.

To provide clients with effective and efficient services, one of mobile payments

and a choice that suppliers have utilizing. QR codes is one method that may be used to

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
deliver effective and efficient services. The use of QR codes for payments is very recent in

Indonesia. Even though they are still quite new, QR codes are already being widely

employed by many mobile payment service providers, as seen by the fact that practically

all of them include QR code-based technology. Additionally, by issuing QRIS, the

government of the Republic of Indonesia encourages the usage of QR code-based payment

technology. Any mobile payment service can be used to access QRIS, a national standard

QR code-based payment service. Although there has been extensive marketing research on

the acceptance of m-payments, there is little literature on the use of QR codes for payments.

Additionally, one technology that speeds up the payment procedure is the QR code (Yan

et al., 2021).

Numerous studies show that trust is a significant predictor of adoption of

technology by individuals (Shao et al. 2019, Gong et al. 2020). The formation of trust in

mobile payment service providers has a positive outlook. Trust in a system's operation has

a positive impact on attitudes. (Sarkar et al. 2020). When deciding whether to use

technology, a person's level of trust is crucial. User’s trust develops when there is past

knowledge and a well-established reputation for a company. However, when it comes to

financial technology, this statement cannot be verified (Merhi et al., 2019). When someone

already holds the view that the technology being utilized provides advantages for users,

performance expectation increases significantly (Khalilzadeh et al., 2017).

Trust is defined as "the belief that a person or organization's integrity, ability, and

benevolence can be trusted." Trust regarding technology is defined as "the level of

confidence a consumer has that the consumed product or service will meet predefined

expectations." Trust can be an important factor when it comes to money, such as mobile

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
payments. According to the findings, 74% of respondents agreed that QR code-based

mobile payments are reliable, 58% agreed that they are safe, 66% agreed that they are

trustworthy, and 68% agreed that the instructions for use are clear and intelligible. The

cumulative mean score of all four questionnaire items is 3.87, which is considered high.

This suggests that respondents believed QR code mobile payment could be trusted (Roslina

Ibrahim, 2020).

The bank will contribute to the development of an integrated payment system. To

ease digital payment transactions in Indonesia, Indonesia adopted a standard QR code

payment, known as QRIS (Quick Response Indonesia Standard) (Saputri, 2020). QRIS is

a non-cash payment system that is deemed more practical and efficient in practice

(Goleman et al., 2018). QRIS is a digital payment instrument that has shown promise since

its inception. It is well known that the demographics of QRIS users, especially students,

are highly diverse. The purpose of this study is to identify Jabodetabek students'

preferences for using QRIS as a digital payment method. The following four characteristics

are used to measure preference or interest in adopting QRIS that occurs in this study:

1)Easiness Characteristic; 2) Usefulness Characteristic; 3) Risk Characteristic; and 4) Trust

Characteristic. (Yudistira Andi Permadi 2021, Angestika Wilandari 2021).

According to the study's findings, 40.3% of respondents prefer to trust and feel safe

when transacting with QRIS. This is consistent with the results of the respondent's

questionnaire on ease qualities. This suggests that respondents who find it simple to interact

with QRIS will feel comfortable and confident in continuing to transact with QRIS in the

future (Yudistira Andi Permadi 2021, Angestika Wilandari 2021). Trust will influence

consumer choice for utilizing QRIS as a payment mechanism (Husna, 2020). By analyzing

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
the results in both studies given above, The researchers can say that the behavioral intention

to use QR code-based mobile payment is affected by trust.

SYNTHESIS OF REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE

Previous and existing studies that provided information, written by different

authors, were significant to the study, "Assessment of Cashless Transaction Using QR scan

on Food stalls along the University belt." The study concluded from different authors

consisted of helpful claims about the behavioral intention in terms of using QR scan and

studies that correlated to the researchers' goal and intention. Based on the study of (Rosli

et al., 2020), Venkatesh (2003) developed a model with five variables: performance

expectancy, effort expectancy, social influence, risk, and trust. The Unified Theory of

Acceptance and Use of Technology (UTAUT) is based on findings from eight research

models in the adoption of information systems.

Chang et al. (2021) found out that performance expectancy is a crucial component

in the adoption of mobile payment tools, and QR codes are available at the majority of

cashier desks. It is simple to utilize in China, regardless of the size or location of these

establishments. According to Statista Research Department (2022), a survey on the use of

QR codes scan to pay was done in 2021, and 31% of respondents in the Philippines said

that they used QR codes to make payments in 2021. In the Philippines, the utilization of

QR scan to pay in 2020 is 26%, while in 2021, the figure is 31%.

Imani, Anggono (2020) explained that the degree of convenience related to the

usage of given technology is defined as effort expectancy. This component indicates where

users are free of effort to easily understand the use of certain types of mobile payment.

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
According to Guo, Gao, Yang, and Jing, (2018), a model was empirically tested with a

sample of 215 consumers of QR code mobile payment services in China. They found out

that performance expectancy, effort expectancy, and social influence all had a strong

positive direct impact on consumers' preferences to continue using QR code mobile

payment services. However, perceived danger had no negative impact on customers'

propensity to use QR code mobile payment services on a regular basis. According to Nath,

Dr. M, (2020), One of the factors influencing technology intention and usage is effort

expectancy. The degree of convenience associated with the use of a system, as defined by

researchers, impacts its utilization. The process of scanning QR codes is difficult for the

majority of non-users (27%). This prevents them from using QR code technology.

Based on Le et al. (2020), social influence is the degree to which an individual

believes that important others believe he or she should use the new system. In addition,

according to Mun et al. (2017), the influence of family members, friends, peers, or another

important person in forming an individual's conduct or belief cannot be ignored, and this

is particularly applicable in the context of technology adoption. This is especially true when

the technology is still in its infancy or early stages, with only a few early users. Martins et

al. (2014), found out that social influence has an effect on online users' intentions to use

Internet services. In contrast to Chaouali et al. (2015), it was reported that social influence

affected every individual's thinking towards the adoption of new innovative products via

technology services. The effect of subjective norms and social factors on behavior and

intention to use e-money in UTAUT can be used to calculate social influence.

According to Posey (2022), QR codes have been the prime target of hackers

because they are the easiest to access in order to steal a client's information. Another issue

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
that QR codes may encounter is that they become the primary focus of phishing assaults.

According to Agazzi (2020), fraudsters can immediately replace a trustworthy QR code to

commit cyber fraud due to the design's simplicity of replacement with harmful QR Codes.

Based on Rudesha's (2019) research, customers and small shops face considerable risk and

challenges while using cashless transactions due to low literacy rates in rural areas in

different countries. Furthermore, the government can limit this type of risk for those who

do not have sufficient understanding in using QR codes; nevertheless, more effort must be

made during the financial literacy program to enhance public awareness of the benefits and

drawbacks of cashless transactions. According to Huang et al.'s (2021) research, younger

generations differ from previous generations in terms of systematic differences in values,

preferences, and behavior that are not stable. In addition, limited attention might have a

negative impact on consumer decision-making. Furthermore, another perceived risk that

the younger generation may face is ignoring the risk that can damage their privacy, which

can lead to fraud and hacking, thus compromising the security of the cashless payment

system. Furthermore, Namaroot and Jantasri (2022) found that perceived risk has a

substantial influence on behavioral intention to employ the cashless payment system when

using the UTAUT model.

Based on the study of Roslina Ibrahim (2020), Trust is defined as "the belief that

a person or organization's integrity, ability, and benevolence can be trusted." Trust in

technology is defined as "the level of confidence a consumer has that the consumed product

or service will meet predefined expectations." According to the results, 74% of respondents

believe QR code-based mobile payments are reliable, 58% believe they are safe, 66%

believe they are trustworthy, and 68% believe the instructions for use are clear and

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
understandable. The total mean score of all four questionnaire items is 3.87, which is

deemed excellent. This indicates that respondents thought QR code mobile payment was

trustworthy. Furthermore, according to the research of Yudistira Andi Permadi (2021) and

Angestika Wulandari (2021), QRIS is a digital payment instrument that has showed

potential from its start. It is commonly understood that the demographics of QRIS users,

particularly students, are extremely diverse. The goal of this study is to determine the

preferences of Jabodetabek students for utilizing QRIS as a digital payment mechanism. In

this study, the following four characteristics are utilized to assess preference or interest in

adopting QRIS: 1)Easiness Characteristic; 2)Usefulness Characteristic; 3)Risk

Characteristic; and 4)Trust Characteristic. According to the results of the study, 40.3% of

respondents prefer to trust and feel safe when doing business with QRIS. This matches the

results of the respondents' questionnaire on easy attributes. This implies that respondents

who find it easy to deal with QRIS will feel at ease and secure in continuing to do business

with QRIS in the future.

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
Definition of Terms

The key terms in the study are given the following operational definitions.

Adaptability - is the capacity of a person to adapt to changes in their environment. Changes

in your job goals have a direct impact on your ability to remain adaptable.

Accessibility- is the activity of making as many people as possible understand, value, and

use information, activities, and/or settings.

Cashless Transactions- In cashless transactions, payments are accepted without the use

of cash. It is used to provide easy access to online information about digital cameras on

smartphones and tablets.

Convenience - It is a state of being able to proceed with something with little effort or less

difficulty. Anything that saves or makes work easier contributes to ease and comfort..

Digital Payment - A monetary transaction between two individuals, corporations, or

governments using a digital payment mechanism.

Efficiency - the capacity to do a task with minimal or no waste, energy, or effort is the

frequently quantifiable capacity to avoid wasting resources when performing something or

when achieving a desired goal.

E-Wallet - A type of electronic card used for online transactions via computers and

smartphones. It is used in the same way as a credit card or debit card. To make payments,

an e-wallet must be linked to the person's bank account.

Food Stalls - A temporary structure where food is prepared and sold to the general public.

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
Quick Response (QR) - it is used to provide easy access to online information about digital

cameras on smartphones and tablets. The code is basically a barcode on steroids. Barcodes

carry information horizontally, while QR codes carry information both horizontally and

vertically.

University Belt - Contains of universities, institutions, and locals, other Filipinos, and

some international students attend the universities in this district.

Scan to pay - The user may scan the QR code and pay the merchant without entering any

merchant account information. The merchant will have the bank's QR code, which may be

scanned by clients of the same bank to make payments.

Two Way Authentication - often known as dual-factor authentication, is a security

procedure in which users submit two separate authentication factors to validate themselves

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
Theoretical Framework

Theoretical background

The use of the theory that the researchers found will be used to explain the Cashless

transaction Using QR scan on Food Stalls along the University belt. These include the

universal technology adoption and use theory (UTAUT) (Venkatesh & Davis, 2000)

Figure 1. Unified theory of Acceptance and Use of Technology (Venkatesh, 2003)

The Unified Theory of acceptance and Use of Technology (UTAUT) model explored the

behavioral intentions and usage of mobile payment from the prospective purchase of

intentions of the consumers. By the extended Unified Theory of Acceptance and Use of

technology model with the addition of Performance Expectancy, Effort Expectancy, Social

Influence, Perceived Risk and Trust. The Unified Theory of Technology Acceptance and

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
Use (UTAUT) model. The purpose of UTAUT is to describe the user's intentions of use

and subsequent use behavior. This theory states that the key components of achievement

expectations, effort expectations, social impacts, and supportive conditions are direct

determinants of use intentions and behaviors (Venkatesh et al.…, 2003).

Conceptual Framework

Figure 2. Conceptual Framework

Figure 2. The flow will start at the demographic profile of the respondent, such as age,

gender, occupation, and educational background, which is our dependent variable as

provided in the figure. The second flow will focus on the perception of food stall owners

towards cashless transactions and will answer the following questions based on

Performance Expectancy, Effort Expectancy, Social Influence, Risk, and Trust, which will

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
be the independent variables. Lastly, the third flow will be the basis for improving cashless

transactions.

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
METHODOLOGY

Introduction

The quantitative methodological approach was considered to be used for this


research. The questionnaire, which was used as the research instrument. The details of the
research procedure were described as follows.

2.1 Research Design

This research study assesses the Cashless Transaction Using QR scans on Food stalls along
the University belt. The researchers used a Descriptive-Quantitative research method in
conducting this research.

According to Bahndari (2020), A quantitative research is a collection of measurable


data and the application of statistical, mathematical, or computer methods that can be used
to gather data from the qualified and potential respondents of the research. Also,
quantitative research uses methods such as; sending out questionnaires, surveys, and polls
to collect information from existing and potential customers in the future.

There are many different quantitative research techniques that can be used to gather
data. But for our study, we chose a survey research method. The survey method uses
statistically precise the number of the population and questionnaire design methods to
measure demographic data.

The survey was conducted using a survey questionnaire using Google Forms. The
following questions in the survey questionnaire examine the respondent's Perception of the
Respondents Towards the Effect of the Capability for a Food Stall to run a full cashless
transaction with regard to five significant variables. These are as follows: a. Performance
Expectancy b. Effort Expectancy c. Social Influence d. Risk e. trust. Using Four point scale
and a multiple choice survey will be used by the researchers to gauge respondents'
sentiments regarding online transactions on a scale of 1 to 4. The respondents assign the

Strongly Agree 1.00 - 1.75

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
Agree 1.76 - 2.50

Disagree 2.51 - 3.25

Strongly 3.26 - 4.00


Disagree

2.2 Data Management

2.2.1 Data According to Source

Prior to engaging in any off-campus study, the researchers must first obtain at
Adamson University all the forms, such as endorsement and authorization, that will be
needed to conduct a study. The researchers started to prepare the Google forms that focus
on the assessment of using cashless transactions along the university belt. The
questionnaire is formulated based on real-life situations in the use of QR code scan to pay
payments in their food stall/s.

The researchers began collecting data by conducting surveys throughout the


research area, which includes the City of Manila. In order to collect 125 food stall owners
and staff members who are qualified to respond to the survey, the researchers mostly
conduct surveys in the Central Station, Taft Avenue, Quiapo, and Recto University belt.

The researchers ask pre-question individuals, such as, "Are you a staff or owner of
this food stall?" to make sure they are competent to respond to the survey. Data was
collected via a survey questionnaire distributed using an easy-to-use chat app, a QR code
that could be scanned using a phone camera, and a Google Form. Additionally,
respondents were initially asked for their permission. All information and data gathered
from the respondents will be added to Microsoft Excel to save the data, and all personally
identifiable information will be handled in complete confidence.

2.2.2 Data According to Methods


The method used in this research is a quantitative, non-experimental method.

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
The researcher used quantitative methods because quantitative methods emphasize

objective measurements and the statistical data collected through pools or questionnaires

or surveys that will be answered by the respondents and the research will show the

statistical analysis of data. According to PR Newswire (2022), a globally recognized

research, ratings, and reviews platform, recently published a new research report titled

"Scenario Planning - Objectives, Benefits, and Methods of Application." It attempts to

identify and analyze scenario planning's objectives, benefits, types, application methods,

and challenges. The study intends to investigate a variety of possible future probabilities

in order to assist organizations in making more informed strategic decisions and improving

their scenario-planning initiatives. The researchers cannot control the variables or the

subjects, they use a non-experimental method. According to Adam, R. (2022), there are no

variables that the observer can directly control in a non-experimental study. Instead,

researchers must easily filter through established context to arrive at their own

interpretation of the events. While the use of non-experimental research is limited, there

are a few key areas where a researcher may find this type of methodology useful.

Correlation design is used to show the relationship between the two variables, the

demographic profile of the respondents, and the assessment of Cashless Transaction Using

QR scans on Food stalls along the University belt. According to Cherry (2022), a

correlational study is a type of research design wherein the relationships between two

variables are examined. Correlational studies are non-experimental, which means that no

variables are manipulated or controlled by the researcher.

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
2.3 Sampling Design

2.3.1. Sample Population

Using a Raosoft sample size calculator with a margin error of 5%, a confidence
level of 95%, 50% of response distribution, and with a total population of 184. The total
sample size is 125 Food stalls along the university belt. The researcher of this study seeks
to gather data from the 125 Food stalls along Central Station, Taft Avenue, Quiapo, and
Recto University belt. The researcher used the Purposive sampling technique to gather
information from selected individuals, who have the characteristics that can help the
researchers to achieve the study’s objective.

2.3.2Respondents
The respondents are the business owners and staff of food stalls along the
University Belt. However, one hundred twenty-five (125) individuals will be the
researcher's target respondents of the study.

2.3.3 Research Instruments

The survey questionnaire that will be utilized in this study will be divided into
three (3) sections, the first of which is the socio-demographic profile of the respondents.
This tool will be used to gather the respondent's Educational background and a question
regarding whether they are utilizing a QR code or a cashless payment as a new method of
payment.

2.3.4 Control Procedure

The researchers did a self-created questionnaire that was pre-testing outside the
sample size to which is equal to thirty (30) to ensure the reliability of the self-made
questionnaires. This was later on tested by their statistician through a Reliability test. Using
Cronbach's Alpha, the result of the test made by the statistician resulted in a 94% reliability
rate, which means that the survey created is therefore reliable enough to be distributed to
other respondents.

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
2.4 Statistical Treatment

The purpose of this study is to determine which method of payment is preferred by


employees and business owners. The researcher will begin their analysis after gathering
the necessary data. Based on the self-made survey questionnaire responses of the selected
respondents, the researcher will use formulas and computations to determine the means.

The statistical method that the researcher used to analyze, organize, and interpret
the collected data.

Frequency Counting and Percentage - This is used to establish the respondent's


demographic profile and responses.

Mean Weighted - This statistical method will determine whether employees


and business owners prefer cashless or traditional payment.

One Sample T-test- This test is used to determine if there is a difference between
a group and the population.

ANOVA test - This test is used to see if the test results are significantly different.
It will display the preferred method of payment for both business owners and staff. The
ANOVA Test will also determine the significant difference between the demographic
profile and the variable.

Cronbach's Alpha- To determine the accuracy of the survey to be used in the


study, the researchers will use Cronbach's alpha for the pre-test. This is done to ensure that
all the questions on the questionnaire are clear and understandable to the respondents.

2.5. Decision Criteria

The researcher will use a 0.05 level of significance in order to evaluate the result,
which will be one of the basis for whether to accept or reject the null hypothesis.

2.6 Ethical Consideration

The researcher will tackle the possible hazard or harm concerning the respondents
or participants of the research and will enlist ethical consideration and ethical issues so that

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
the respondents will be safe and away from harm. According to Bryman and Bell (2007),
there are ten ethical considerations that are important in dissertations. The 10 ethical
considerations are listed below:

1. Research participants should not be subjected to harm in any ways whatsoever.


2. Respect for the dignity of research participants should be prioritized.
3. Full consent should be obtained from the participants prior to the study.
4. The protection of the privacy of research participants has to be ensured.
5. An adequate level of confidentiality of the research data should be ensured.
6. The anonymity of individuals and organizations participating in the research has to
be ensured.
7. Any deception or exaggeration about the aims and objectives of the research must
be avoided.
8. Affiliations in any form, sources of funding, as well as any possible conflicts of
interest, have to be declared.
9. Any type of communication in relation to the research should be done with honesty
and transparency.
10. Any type of misleading information, as well as representation of primary data
findings in a biased way, must be avoided.

The researcher will also address the following Ethical issue:

1. Voluntary participant- The respondents have the ability to choose in or out of the
study at any point in time.
2. Informed consent - The respondents know the purpose, benefits, risks, and funding
behind the study before they agree or decline to join.
3. Confidentiality- Only the researchers know the participants and the information
will be hidden from everyone else. The researchers will anonymize personally
identifiable data so that the data will not be linked to other research or other people's
hands.
4. Potential for harm - The researchers will ensure that Physical, social, psychological,
and other types of harm are kept to an absolute minimum.

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
5. Results communication- The researchers will ensure that the work is free of
plagiarism or research misconduct, and the result will accurately represent the
researcher's results.

2.6.1 Conflict of Interests

The researcher will accept a paid consulting position with a company interested in
our research. Using students to perform services for a company in which you have a
financial interest; signing a book for which you receive royalties as the required text for a
course; and accepting a research contract with a restrictive publication schedule.

2.6.2 Privacy and Confidentiality

The researchers are aware to maintain the confidentiality of all the information they
have collected from the respondents and to prevent its release. All information will be kept
confidential during the study, and the respondents have given their consent for the
researcher to use their real names in the research report. As a result, we guarantee that
respecting the respondents' autonomy and overall well-being is necessary for protecting
their privacy.

2.6.3 Informed Consent Process

Each respondent will be asked politely if they are willing to take part in the research
and answer the survey. The researchers will ask the respondent to sign the consent form if
they are interested in participating. The purpose of the study will be fully explained by the
researchers.

2.6.4 Vulnerability

The respondents of the research are those who are Male and Female of legal age,
which are 18–59 years of age. The main focus is also the Vendors and Owners of food
stalls around U-belt, which can be any of marital status along with any educational level
of attainment. There will be staff and business owners of the same demographic profile
that is included in the main focus of the survey.

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
2.6.5 Recruitment

In this study, the researchers will use the total population in choosing the respondents.
Only followed the survey’s instructions. These are participants who are capable of
answering all the survey questionnaires. The researchers will search around to the given
place and look for food stalls that are capable of being a respondent to the study. The
questionnaire will be given to the participants by using a QR code. They will be given a
QR code that will take them to the Google form survey.

2.6.6 Assent

The respondents of the study are the owners and employees who are in ages 18
years old up to 59 years old. It has food stalls and consumers along the university belt.

2.6.7 Risks

The respondents won't be put at risk throughout the research's execution, and their
private information won't be shared or used for any illegal purposes. Respondents will also
be required to give their approval before they can take part in the study. While in the
researchers, the risk is that the respondents might give false information while answering
the survey.

2.6.8 Benefits

The purpose of the research is to increase the researcher's understanding of their


subject of study, learn more about their subject of study, and learn more about the research
process itself. The side of the responders, they might have a forum to share their thoughts
and expectations regarding their experiences with cashless transactions as a new form of
payment. The study will reveal the insights of the staff at the food stalls who are using
cashless transactions as a mode of payment.

2.6.9 Incentives or Compensation

The respondents did not get any money in exchange for their participation.

2.6.10 Community Consideration

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
After the research was conducted, some of the respondents still recommend a
traditional way in paying their transactions instead of using cashless transactions or to be
specific using QR code scan. The reason why is that some of the respondents can’t easily
adapt with the changes regarding digital payment, with the reason that there are levels to
the amount of adaptation and understanding to changes that people have, which can affect
their sense of technological literacy. Speaking of technological literacy, there are some
who are tech-savvy that are ahead of some who can easily adapt to changes when it
comes to it, specifically like cashless or Qr transactions.

2.6.11 Collaborative Study of Reference

The participants in the research are the College of Business Administration students
majoring in Financial Management who are enrolled at Adamson University and taking the
course Financial Research 1.

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

Introduction
This section contains the Table, Presentation, Analysis, and interpretation of data
along with the summary of the findings, conclusions, and recommendations.

In the research, several statistical methods will be employed to analyze the data that
is encoded in the table. Every table was formulated with different statistical techniques to
explain the information gathered. Starting off with Frequency counting and percentage
which will be utilized to establish the demographic profile and responses of the
respondents. The mean weighted approach will help determine whether employees and
business owners have a preference for cashless or traditional payment methods. The one-
sample t-test will assess if there are any significant differences between a group and the
population. Additionally, the ANOVA test will be employed to examine if there are
significant variations in the test results, displaying the preferred payment method for both
business owners and staff. Moreover, the ANOVA test will evaluate the significant
difference between the demographic profile and the variable. To ensure the accuracy of the
survey, Cronbach's alpha will be used in the pre-test to ascertain the clarity and
understandability of the questionnaire for the respondents.

A research findings revealed a positive correlation between performance


expectancy and consumer acceptance of cashless payment among UMK's staff. The
correlation coefficient between the two variables was found to be 0.724. Furthermore,
through coefficient regression analysis, it was determined that performance expectancy had
the fourth highest beta value of 0.167. These results indicate the significance of
performance expectancy in influencing the acceptance of cashless payment among UMK's
staff (Bin Razali, Salehhudin, Lee, & Binti Moktar, 2023).

The findings regarding the habitual factor indicated that small entrepreneurs
exhibited the highest level of familiarity with using PromptPay for business transactions.
They were followed by individuals who had experience with Internet Banking and were
skilled in using QR codes to make purchases. Lastly, they had experience with Rabbit Line
Pay for buying goods and services, with mean values of 3.88, 3.69, 3.53, and 3.27,

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
respectively. (S. CHAVEESUA N. PIYAWAT 2021) Similarly, according to a study
conducted by Raza et al. in 2019, it was discovered that the adoption of QR codes by
consumers for routine and frequent habits has an impact on both behavioral intention and
actual usage (Raza et al., 2019, pp. 1-5).

The findings related to the price value factor indicated that entrepreneurs perceived
the cost of using QR Code technology to be more reasonable compared to other payment
systems. They believed that QR Code technology offered cost-effectiveness and helped
save money on cash management. Additionally, the entrepreneurs found the price of using
QR Code technology to be suitable for their budget. The mean values for these perceptions
were 3.94, 3.88, 3.64, and 3.57, respectively. (S. CHAVEESUA N. PIYAWAT 2021)

3.1 Presentation, Analysis, and Interpretation of Data

The researcher conducted a survey along Central Station, Taft Avenue, Quiapo, and
Recto University belt. The researcher uses Frequency and Percentage Distribution,
weighted mean, One-way ANOVA, and One-sample T-test in order to Present, analyze,
and interpret the data.

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
Table 1.0 exhibits the frequency and percentage distribution of the respondents in
terms of age. Based on the table, the minority of the respondents in this study were ages 53
years old to 59 years old with 0.80% of total sample respondent, the majority of the
respondents were ages 18 years old to 24 years old with 43 or 34.40% of the total
respondents.

Table 1.1 exhibits the frequency and percentage distribution of the respondents in
terms of sex. Based on the table, the minority of the respondents in this study were female
with 51 or 40.80% of total sample respondent, the majority of the respondents were male
with 74 or 59.20% of the total respondents.

Table 1.2 exhibits the frequency and percentage distribution of the respondents in
terms of occupation. Based on the table, a minority of the respondents in this study were
business owners with 58 or 46.40% of total sample respondent, the majority of the
respondents were staff with 67 or 53.60% of the total respondents.

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY

Table 1.3 exhibits the frequency and percentage distribution of the respondents in terms of
educational background. Based on the table, a minority of the respondents in this study
were elementary graduates with 1.60% of total sample respondent, the majority of the
respondents were college graduates with 58 or 46.40% of the total respondents.

Table 2.0 presents the weighted mean of the respondents towards the effect of the
capability for a food stall to run a full cashless transaction in terms of performance

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
expectancy. It was exposed from the table that the weighted response of the respondents
was in agreement with 2.05 weighted mean. It explains that most of the respondents agree
that the listed situation above were common things on the perception of the effect of the
capability for a food stall to run a full cashless transaction in terms of performance
expectancy. The situation that had the highest response was all food stalls needing to adopt
a QR Code scan to pay. While the situation that has the least number of responses was the
rise of QR code scan to pay, hinder the respondent’s food stall ability to generate profit.

Table 2.1 presents the weighted mean of the respondents towards the effect of the
capability for a food stall to run a full cashless transaction in terms of effort expectancy. It
was exposed from the table that the weighted response of the respondents was in agreement
with 1.82 weighted mean. It explains that most of the respondents agree that the listed
situation above were common things on the perception of the effect of the capability for a
food stall to run a full cashless transaction in terms of effort expectancy. The situation that
had the highest response was the respondents agreeing that cashless payment was much
more convenient. While the situation that has the least number of responses was the
experience of errors when doing cashless transactions.

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY

Table 2.2 presents the weighted mean of the respondents towards the effect of the
capability for a food stall to run a full cashless transaction in terms of social influence. It
was exposed from the table that the weighted response of the respondents agreed with 1.70
weighted mean. It explains that most of the respondents agree that the listed situation above
were common things on the perception of the effect of the capability for a food stall to run
a full cashless transaction in terms of social influence. The situation that had the highest
response was the respondents agreeing that there are possibilities to have a full cashless
transaction due to influence of other business owners. While the situation that has the least
number of responses was the cashless transactions affect the consumer on new buying and
consumption methods.

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY

Table 2.3 presents the weighted mean of the respondents towards the effect of the
capability for a food stall to run a full cashless transaction in terms of risk. It was exposed
from the table that the weighted response of the respondents was in agreement with 2.05
weighted mean. It explains that most of the respondents agree that the listed situation above
were common things on the perception of the effect of the capability for a food stall to run
a full cashless transaction in terms of risk. The situation that has the highest response was
the QR code scan can be prone to security and malicious attack (Phishing, Trojan, data
theft, etc.). While the situation that has the least number of responses was users of cashless
transactions experiencing message and advertisement spam after using cashless
transactions.

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY

Table 2.4 presents the weighted mean of the respondents towards the effect of the
capability for a food stall to run a full cashless transaction in terms of trust. It was exposed
from the table that the weighted response of the respondents was agreed with 1.76 weighted
mean. It explains that most of the respondents agree that the listed situation above were
common things on the perception of the effect of the capability for a food stall to run a full
cashless transaction in terms of trust. The situation that has the highest response was the
trusting matter in the respondent’s decision to use a cashless transaction and playing a
significant role in the adoption of the technology. While the situation that has the least
number of responses was the trust arises when there was prior experience and a proven
good company reputation.

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY

Table 3.0 presents the significant difference between the assessment of the
respondents on the effect of capability for a food stall to run a full cashless transaction
when grouped according to their age. Based on the table, the respondents on the effect of
capability for a food stall to run a full cashless transaction against according to the age of
the respondents was not statistically significant because the p-value was higher than the
level of significance which was 0.05, therefore, accept null hypothesis.

With regards to age, all age groups except those above 50 years old exhibit concern
regarding performance expectancy. However, it is important to note that the results may be
biased, as only 9.6% of the respondents in this study were above 50 years old. Younger
users of cashless payment methods appear to be more influenced by social factors, as
indicated by the significant coefficient (B = 0.370). The younger generation often tends to
be influenced by external factors as they have less experience and a desire to conform to
societal norms. On the other hand, the influence of effort expectancy, facilitating
conditions, and trust is more significant for older users of cashless payment methods. Older
individuals generally require more effort and assistance to embrace new technologies. They
are typically less adept with technology compared to the younger generation and may take

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
longer to learn new things. Moreover, older people tend to be more risk-averse and are less
willing to experiment with unfamiliar concepts. (Zhi Goh Nguyen 2022)

Table 3.1 presents the significant difference between the assessment of the
respondents on the effect of capability for a food stall to run a full cashless transaction

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
when grouped according to their educational background using one sample t-test. It was
exposed from the table that the effect of capability for a food stall to run a full cashless
transaction and sex has a significant difference due to the lower value of level of
significance which was 0.05, therefore rejecting the null hypothesis.

This implies that most of the respondents have the same extent of assessment on
the effect of capability for a food stall to run a full cashless transaction when grouped
according to sex.

Based on the study findings, the F value for overall cashless transactions is 23.108
with a significant value of 0.000, which is less than the 5% level of significance. This
indicates that there is a significant difference in cashless transactions across various
education levels. Therefore, the null hypothesis 1 is accepted even at a 5% or 1% level of
significance. (Kumar 2020)

Upon analyzing the table, it is evident that education levels have a statistically
significant impact on all components, except for one component, namely "Visit bank for
fund transfer" (IMPS/NEFT/RIGS). The F value for this component is 1.823 with a
significant value of 0.141, which is greater than the 5% level of significance. (Kumar 2020)

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY

Table 3.2 presents the significant difference between the assessment of the
respondents on the effect of capability for a food stall to run a full cashless transaction
when grouped according to their Gender using one sample t-test. It was exposed from the
table that the impact of the ability for a food stall to run a full cashless transaction and
occupation has a significant difference due to the lower value of level of significance which
was 0.05, therefore rejecting the null hypothesis.

This implies that most of the respondents have the same extent of assessment on
the effect of capability for a food stall to run a full cashless transaction when grouped
according to occupation.

The results presented in a study indicate that neither facilitating conditions nor
social influence were found to be statistically significant for both males and females, as
their corresponding p-values were greater than 0.05. However, gender did not moderate the
relationship between performance expectancy and effort expectancy, which was found to

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
be significant for both groups. It is noteworthy that males showed a greater perception of
performance expectancy (B = 0.713) and effort expectancy (B = 0.265) compared to
females when it came to using cashless payment methods. Additionally, the moderation
effect of gender was found to be important in the context of trust, as only females were
found to have a significant relationship. (Zhi Goh Nguyen 2022)

Table 3.3 presents the significant difference between the assessment of the
respondents on the effect of capability for a food stall to run a full cashless transaction
when grouped according to their education background. Based on the table, the respondents
on the effect of capability for a food stall to run a full cashless transaction against according
to the educational background of the respondents was not statistically significant because

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
the p-value was higher than the level of significance which was 0.05, therefore, accept null
hypothesis.

Regarding education level, the moderation effect exhibits varying directions.


Performance expectancy (PE) is not influenced by education level, as it remains significant
across all education levels. However, the effect of education level is more pronounced for
effort expectancy (EE), specifically in the case of higher education. The interaction
between effort expectancy and degree level (EE * Degree) has a significant coefficient (B
= 0.329). Trust is also more influential for individuals with higher education levels,
particularly those with education levels higher than STPM/Pre-U, where a significant
relationship is observed. It is important to note that the results of this study can be
generalized to the bachelor's degree group, as 54% of the respondents in the study possess
a degree level education.

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
3.2 Summary of Findings
This chapter presents the summary of findings, conclusions and derived from the
findings and recommendation based on the findings and conclusions of the finding.

Respondents Demographic Profile


A. Age of the respondents

The finding showed the frequency and percentage distribution of the respondents
in terms of age. The table indicates that a minority of the respondents were between the
ages of 53 to 59, with only 0.80% of the total sample respondents falling within this age
group. On the other hand, the majority of the respondents were between the ages of 18 to
24, with 43 or 34.40% of the total respondents being in this age group. Overall, the data
suggests that the majority of the respondents in this study were younger adults, with a
relatively small representation of older adults.

B. Gender of the respondents

The finding showed the distribution of respondents based on their sex. A total of
125 respondents participated in the study, of which 74 (59.20%) were male and 51
(40.80%) were female. This indicates that the majority of the respondents were male, while
the minority were female.

C. Occupation of the respondents

The finding showed the distribution of respondents in terms of their occupation. The data
reveals that a small proportion of the respondents were business owners, constituting only
46.40% of the total sample, while the majority of respondents were staff, accounting for
53.60% of the total respondents. Based on the findings, the majority of staff are co-owners
and family members managing the food stalls. It helps the business to lessen their salary
expenses, since they run the food stalls so that owners won't pay for their labor or pay it
less compared to paying an actual staff or workers. Also, working with family members
can provide a helpful environment because you already trust the individuals you work with.

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
D. Educational Background of the respondents

The finding showed the distribution of respondents according to their educational


background. A small proportion of the respondents, specifically 1.60% of the total sample,
had an elementary education. On the other hand, most of the respondents, specifically 58
or 46.40% of the total sample, were college graduates on vocational courses. A vocational
degree is a credential granted by an academic institution to students who have fulfilled
degree requirements for a particular subject or trade. Vocational degrees differ from
standard degree programs such as bachelor's and master's degrees. The former takes less
time than the latter and allows students to immediately begin working in the area or trade.

● The findings display the respondents' overall mean of 2.05 on their responses on
the impact of a food stall's capacity to conduct a complete cashless transaction in
terms of performance expectancy. QR code scan to pay in eliminating dangers
associated with card purchases garnered the highest mean of 1.97. Overall, the
variable performance expectancy gathered agreed interpretation.
● The findings display the respondents' overall mean of 1.82 on their responses on
the impact of a food stall's capacity to conduct a complete cashless transaction in
terms of effort expectancy. Experience errors when doing cashless transactions
garnered the highest mean of 2.03. Overall, the variable effort expectancy
gathered an agreed interpretation.
● The findings display the respondents' overall mean of 1.70 on their responses on
the impact of a food stall's capacity to conduct a complete cashless transaction in
terms of social influence. Affecting the consumer on new buying and
consumption methods garnered the highest mean of 1.93. Overall, the variable
social influence gathered strongly agreed interpretation.
● The findings display the respondents' overall mean of 2.05 on their responses on
the impact of a food stall's capacity to conduct a complete cashless transaction in
terms of risk. Experiencing message and advertisement spam using cashless
transactions garnered the highest mean of 2.12. Overall, the variable risk gathered
agreed interpretation.

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
● The findings display the respondents' overall mean of 1.76 on their responses on
the impact of a food stall's capacity to conduct a complete cashless transaction in
terms of trust. Arises when there is prior experience and proven good company
reputation garnered, the highest mean of 1.85. Overall, the variable trust gathered
agreed interpretation.
● Using the one-sample t-test, respondents when group according to their educational
background of performance expectancy that gained a p-value of 0.57; effort
expectancy gained a p-value of 0.55; social influence gained a p-value of 0.89; risk
gained a p-value of 0.08; trust gained a p-value of 0.72. Therefore, reject null
hypothesis.
● Using the one-sample t-test, respondents when group according to their occupation
of performance expectancy that gained a p-value of 0.00; effort expectancy gained
a p-value of 0.00; social influence gained a p-value of 0.00; risk gained a p-value
of 0.00; trust gained a p-value of 0.00. Therefore, reject null hypothesis.
● Using the one-way ANOVA, respondents when group according to their
educational background of performance expectancy that gained a p-value of 0.00;
effort expectancy gained a p-value of 0.00; social influence gained a p-value of
0.00; risk gained a p-value of 0.00; trust gained a p-value of 0.00. Therefore, accept
null hypothesis.

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
3.3 Conclusions

Based on the findings of the study, the following conclusions are made:

1. The majority of survey respondents, according to the researchers' demographic


findings, are college graduates who work mostly at food stalls. The researchers also
note that the majority of respondents are between the ages of 18 years old to 24
years old.
2. The variable affects the capability for a food stall to run a full cashless transaction.
Using weighted mean the overall perception on performance Expectancy is 2.05,
Effort expectancy is 1.82, Social influence is 1.70, Risk is 2.05, and the overall
perception on trust is 1.76. Therefore, the result shows that the result has a positive
on capability of food stalls to run a full cashless transaction.
3. When respondents are grouped according to age. P-value exceeding 0.05, there
were no significant differences in terms of age. The Performance Expectancy has a
p-value of 0.54, Effort Expectancy has a p-value of 0.49, Social influence has a p-
value of 0.81, Risk has a p-value of 0.23, and trust age range has a p-value of 0.97.
Therefore, accepting the null hypothesis.
4. When respondents are grouped according to gender, Using One-sample T-test the
mean difference of Performance Expectancy is 0.10, Effort Expectancy is 0.01,
Social Influence is 0.09, Risk is 0.17, and lastly Trust has a mean of 0.05. Therefore,
rejecting the null hypothesis.
5. When respondents are group according to their occupation, Using One- Sample T
test result shows that performance expectancy that gained a p-value of 0.00; effort
expectancy gained a p-value of 0.00; social influence gained a p-value of 0.00; risk
gained a p-value of 0.00; trust gained a p-value of 0.00. The impact of capability
for a food stall to run a full cashless transaction and occupation, has a significant
difference due to the lower value of level of significance, which was 0.05.
Therefore reject the null hypothesis.
6. When respondents are grouped according to their educational background ., using
One-Way ANOVA to identify the significant difference in terms of educational
background, P-value exceeding 0.05, the Effect of capability for a Food stall to run

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
a full cashless transaction, Performance expectancy is 0.00, Effort Expectancy is
0.00, Social Influence is 0.00, Risk is 0.00, and mean of trust is 0.00. Therefore,
accepting the null hypothesis.

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
3.4 Recommendations

Based on the findings of the study, the researchers recommend the following actions:

For Small Business Owners. Based on the result, it shows that 43 respondents or
34.40% are 18-24 years old while 67 respondents or 53.60% were staff, and 58 respondents
,or 46.40% are college graduates. Based on the study's overall outcome, Social Influence
has the lowest mean of 1.70. A lot of respondents agree that there was a chance that a
complete cashless transaction may occur because of the influence of other business owners.
Hence, they must tighten their security measures in every cashless transaction done by its
customer correspondingly the situation that has the highest response was the QR code scan
can be prone to security and malicious attack.

Business owners may promote the use of QR cashless transactions in general to


their customers as age and educational background accepted the null hypothesis signifying
that performance expectancy, effort expectancy, social influence, risk, and trust have no
significant differences in their evaluation of QR’s capability. Additionally, Owners should
explain to employees who have just completed primary school the fundamental functions
and advantages of the e-wallet programs.

Furthermore, gender rejected the null hypothesis, therefore signifying that there is
a difference in the evaluation of QR’s capability for females and the variables performance
expectancy, effort expectancy, social influence, risk, and trust. Result shows that male are
more frequent in using QR code platform. While female is less active in using QR code
payment for food stalls. Therefore, it is recommended that female staff and business owner
the researcher recommend that the female staff and business owner must attend either
online or face to face seminar about QR code payments through social media platform such
as Facebook group (Philippine Business/ startup/ SME seminar, business seminar for
entrepreneurs, and start up business network) specifically, what are the benefit of adopting
cashless transaction using QR code scan to pay in their business.

For Future Researchers. The future researcher can examine the concerns related
to security, privacy, fraud, and unauthorized access that consumers may have when using

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION


ADAMSON UNIVERSITY
QR-based payment systems. This can involve conducting surveys, interviews, or
experimental studies to understand the specific risk perceptions and their influence on
consumers' adoption behavior. The future researcher can delve deeper into the potential
vulnerabilities, risks, and challenges that may arise when implementing QR-based payment
systems in food stalls. Future researchers may study medium to large-scale businesses’ use
of QR cashless transactions to cover all types of businesses and its effect on their financial
statement.

COLLEGE OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION

You might also like