21/09/2020

CONCEPTS ON
EARTHQUAKE RESISTANT
DESIGN
Earthquake Engineering and Plastic Design
Prepared by: KSDYee Engr. Katherine Shayne D. Yee, CE, RMP, ME-1
What happens to the buildings during an
earthquake?
◦ If the ground moves rapidly back and
forth, then the foundations of the building
are forced to follow these movements.
◦ The upper part would remain where it is
because of its mass of inertia.
◦ A resonance phenomena will incur and
cause large internal force.
◦ This frequently results in plastic
deformation of the structure and
substantial damage with local failures
and in extreme cases, collapse.
Prepared by: KSDYee
 21/09/2020
General Concepts in Earthquake Resistant Design
◦ Resist minor earthquake without damage
◦ Resist moderate earthquake without structural damage, but
possibly experience some non-structural damage
◦ Resist major earthquake without collapse, but possibly with some
structural as well as nonstructural damage.
Prepared by: KSDYee
To become Earthquake Resistant,
◦ Strength – the structure must have the ability to carry or resist the
earthquake forces without failure.
◦ Ductility – the structure must have the ability to deform past the
elastic range without failure to dissipate the energy induced by
the earthquake.
Prepared by: KSDYee
 21/09/2020
SEISMIC CONCEPTUAL DESIGN
101
Reference: Seismic Conceptual Design of Buildings – Basic Principles for
engineers, architects, building owners, and authorities.
Prepared by: KSDYee
BP1: The architect and the engineer
collaborate from the outset.
Prepared by: KSDYee
 21/09/2020
BP1: The architect and the engineer
collaborate from the outset.
◦ How to maintain a CLOSE COLLABORATION BETWEEN THE
ARCHITECT AND CIVIL ENGINEER?
Prepared by: KSDYee
BP 2: Follow the seismic provisions of the
Codes!
◦ Enforcing building
code requirements
makes it possible to
significantly reduce
the seismic
vulnerability of
buildings with no
significant additional
costs while improving
their resistance
against collapse.
Prepared by: KSDYee
 21/09/2020
BP3: Avoid Soft-storey ground floors
◦ In a soft storey building configuration, the columns are damaged by
CYCLIC DISPLACEMENTS between the moving soil and the upper part
of the building. A collapse is often inevitable
Prepared by: KSDYee
BP3: Avoid Soft-storey ground floors
This sway mechanism in the ground floor of the building
under construction almost provoked a collapse.
Prepared by: KSDYee
 21/09/2020
This multi-storey
building has just
escaped collapse
from an
earthquake
Prepared by: KSDYee
And this is the remains of the left A resistant column with well detailed
edge ground floor column stabilizing confining reinforcement
Prepared by: KSDYee
 21/09/2020
BP4: Avoid Soft-Storey Upper floors
◦ If lateral bracing is weakened or omitted, or if the horizontal resistance
is strongly reduced above a certain floor.
Prepared by: KSDYee
In this office building,
an upper storey failed.
The top of the building
has collapsed onto the
floor below.
Prepared by: KSDYee
 21/09/2020
BP5: Avoid Asymmetric Bracing!
If the center of resistance and the center of mass do not
coincide, eccentricity and twisting occurs.
Prepared by: KSDYee
Why should we must avoid asymmetric
bracing?
◦ Asymmetric Bracing leads to unbalance distribution
of stiffness or mass w/c can also lead to eccentricity
and torsion in the structure.
◦ Dynamically a building is more efficient if the center
of mass and the center of resistance coincides.
◦ This can be achieved with a symmetric
arrangement of the lateral bracing elements.
Prepared by: KSDYee
 21/09/2020
Prepared by: KSDYee
Prepared by: KSDYee
 21/09/2020
BP6: Avoid Bracing Offsets
◦ Offset disturbs the direct flow of forces,
weakened the resistance and reduce
the ductility of the bracing.
◦ They cause LARGE additional forces and
DEFORMATION in their other structural
elements.
Prepared by: KSDYee
BP7: Discontinuities in stiffness and resistance cause
problems
Modifications of cross sections of bracing systems over the height of a
building cause discontinuities and lead to sudden variations in the
stiffness and resistance of the building.
Prepared by: KSDYee
 21/09/2020
A seismic resistant structure always has
seismic resisting parts!
Prepared by: KSDYee
Even a Special Moment Frame System is
Seismic Resisting frame
Prepared by: KSDYee
 21/09/2020
Causes of Discontinuities of Frames:
A. Floating Columns - when a column coming from top
of the building is discontinued at a lower level, usually
at the ground storey.
B. Set-back Columns - when a column coming from top
of the building is moved away from its original line,
again usually at the ground storey.
C. Lack of Grid in Moment Frame – common discontinuity
of load path in the horizontal direction (in plan).
Prepared by: KSDYee
A. Floating
Columns
Prepared by: KSDYee
 21/09/2020
B. Setback Column
Prepared by: KSDYee
C. Lack of Grid in Moment Frames
Prepared by: KSDYee
 21/09/2020
Causes of Discontinuities of Structural Walls
(Shear Walls):
◦ Structural Wall Openings
Prepared by: KSDYee
Causes of Discontinuities of Structural Walls
(Shear Walls):
◦ B. Discontinuing structural walls in upper storey:
Prepared by: KSDYee
 21/09/2020
Causes of Discontinuities of Structural Walls
(Shear Walls):
◦ B. Discontinuing structural walls in upper storey:
Prepared by: KSDYee
Causes of Discontinuities of Structural Walls
(Shear Walls):
C. Discontinuing structural walls in lower storey:
Prepared by: KSDYee
 21/09/2020
BP8: Two slender reinforced concrete
structural walls in each principal direction
In a zone of moderate seismicity,
in most cases two slender and
capacity designed ductile walls
in each major direction are
sufficient.
Walls should be placed
symmetrically with respect to the
center of mass and as close as
possible to the edges of the
building.
Prepared by: KSDYee
◦ This skeleton structure has reinforced concrete structural wall in transverse direction at
two building corners. Prepared by: KSDYee
 21/09/2020
BP9: Avoid mixed systems with columns and
structural masonry walls.
◦ The columns in combination with the
slabs or beams form frames, which has
smaller horizontal stiffness than the
masonry walls.
◦ The earthquake actions are carried to
a large extent by masonry walls.
◦ When masonry walls fail due to the
seismic actions or deflections, they can
no longer carry the gravity loads, which
usually lead to total collapse of the
building.
Prepared by: KSDYee
BP10: Avoid bracing of frames with
masonry infills.
◦ The frame structure is relatively
flexible and somewhat ductile, while
reinforced masonry is very stiff and
fragile and may explode under
effect of only small deformations.
◦ At the beginning of an earthquake
the masonry carries most of the
earth-quake actions but as the
shaking intensifies the masonry fails
due to shear or sliding.
Prepared by: KSDYee
 21/09/2020
BP11: Brace masonry buildings with reinforced
concrete structural walls
Masonry structures are good material for
gravity load but has no resistance to
seismic excitations.
Therefore, a possible solution consists of
bracing unreinforced masonry buildings
with reinforced concrete structural walls.
Prepared by: KSDYee
Prepared by: KSDYee
 21/09/2020
BP12: Reinforce structural masonry walls to
resist horizontal actions
◦ Possible alternative to BP11
for making masonry
structures more suitable for
seismic actions is to
reinforce some long
masonry walls and thus
stiffen them in the
longitudinal direction.
Prepared by: KSDYee
BP13: In skeleton structures, separate non-structural
masonry walls by joints.
◦ In flexible skeleton structures, It can
be beneficial to separate non-
structural partition walls from the
structure by soft joints.
◦ The joints run along the columns,
structural walls, and slabs, or beams
and must be filled by a very flexible
soundproof material. (e.g. soft
rubber)
Prepared by: KSDYee
 21/09/2020
BP14: Avoid short columns
◦ The diagonal cracks and shear failures
in the short columns of a multi-storey car
park in California almost caused
collapse.
Prepared by: KSDYee
BP15: Avoid partially infilled frames
◦ The infill of parapet walls into a
frame structure without the
addition of joints can cause short
column phenomena. (see BP14).
Prepared by: KSDYee
 21/09/2020
BP16: Separate adjacent buildings by joints
◦ Pounding and hammering of adjacent
buildings can cause substantial
damage, if not collapse.
◦ This implies the following:
◦ The joints must have a certain min. width
◦ The joints must be empty (no contact joints)
Prepared by: KSDYee
BP17: Favor compact plan configurations
◦ In this L shaped building, the
stiffnesses of the two wings,
respective to each principal
direction are very different.
◦ The two wings will tend to
oscillate very differently but also
hinder each other.
◦ This tend to large additional
stresses, particularly at the
corners of the floor slabs and at
the end of each wing.
Prepared by: KSDYee
 21/09/2020
BP18: Use the slabs to tie in the elements
and distribute the forces
◦ In multi-storey buildings, the
floor slabs must be nearly rigid
diaphragms.
◦ They must be properly
connected to all the gravity
load bearing elements to act
as section shape preservers.
◦ Slabs ensure that all the
vertical elements contribute to
the lateral resistance.
Prepared by: KSDYee
BP19: Use transverse reinforcement with
135 degree hooks and spaced at s ≤ 5d in
structural walls and columns
◦ Within the cyclically stressed
plastic zones of reinforced
concrete structural walls and
columns, the concrete cover
spalls when the elastic limit of
the reinforcement is exceeded.
◦ It is necessary to stabilize the
vertical bars against buckling
and to confine the concrete to
allow greater compressive
strains.
Prepared by: KSDYee
 21/09/2020
BP20: Use transverse reinforcement with
135 degree hooks and spaced at s ≤ 5d in
structural walls and columns
In this column, the
hoops or ties were
too widely spaced
and insufficiently
anchored with only
90° hooks.
Prepared by: KSDYee
BP21: Assess the potential for soil liquefaction
◦ Certain sandy or silty soil saturated with water can display a sufficient
static load-bearing capacity. However, when vibrated, such during an
earthquake, they suddenly behave like a liquid.
Prepared by: KSDYee
 21/09/2020
BP21: Design the structure properly and
construct accordingly
Prepared by: KSDYee
BP22: Design Foundation per Column
Prepared by: KSDYee
 21/09/2020
Other Earthquake Resistant
Techniques:
◦ Base Isolation Devices – Separate buildings from ground by some
rubber devices
◦ Seismic Dampers – introduced in buildings – absorb the energy
produced by seismic waves.
Prepared by: KSDYee
Base Isolation Devices
As the earthquake shakes
the soil laterally, the
foundation moves with the
soil and seismic waves are
transferred throughout the
structure over time as the
seismic waves travels up to
the structure.
The base isolator reduced
the stiffness of the building
and thereby, lower its natural
frequency.
Prepared by: KSDYee
 21/09/2020
Seismic Dampers
◦ Seismic Dampers are used
in place of structural
elements, like diagonal
braces, for controlling
seismic damage in
structures. It partly absorbs
the seismic energy and
reduces the motion of
buildings.
Prepared by: KSDYee
Tuned mass dampers stabilize against violent Tuned
motion caused by harmonic vibration. Mass Dampers
A tuned mass damper (TMD) consists of a mass (m),
a spring (k), and a damping device (c), which
dissipates the energy created by the motion of the
mass.
An external force is applied to a system, such as
wind pushing on a skyscraper, there has to be an
acceleration. Consequently, the people in the
skyscraper would feel this acceleration. In order to
make the occupants of the building feel more
comfortable, tuned mass dampers are placed in
structures where the horizontal deflections from the
wind's force are felt the greatest, effectively
making the building stand relativelyPrepared
still.by: KSDYee
 21/09/2020
Components of a Tuned Mass Damper
◦ Spring
◦ Oscillating Mass
◦ Viscodamper
Prepared by: KSDYee
Types of Dampers
◦ Viscous Damper
◦ Friction Damper
◦ Yielding Damper
Prepared by: KSDYee
 21/09/2020
Prepared by: KSDYee
MOST EARTHQUAKE-
RESISTANT
STRUCTURES
Prepared by: KSDYee
 21/09/2020
TAIPEI 101
◦ Taipei 101 uses a massive internal
damper to control swaying and minimize
the possibility of structural damage or
failure, making it a very earthquake
resistant building.
◦ The goal of such a damper isn’t to
prevent swaying in general, but to
instead attempt to control this
movement.
◦ During an earthquake or high winds, the
pendulum counteracts the building’s
movements
Prepared by: KSDYee
SHANGHAI TOWER
◦ Shanghai is located in a seismically
active area and the site of the tower is
composed primarily of soft, clay-heavy
soil. To boost the foundation and make it
more of an earthquake proof building,
engineers incorporated 980 piles — some
nearly 300 feet deep — secured within
2.15 million cubic feet of reinforced
concrete.
◦ As the building sways, the inertia of the
weight counters this movement. For
optimal counterbalancing, a series of
shock absorbers keep the pendulum
from swinging too far or too quickly.
Prepared by: KSDYee
 21/09/2020
SHANGHAI TOWER
◦ Shanghai is located in a seismically
active area and the site of the tower is
composed primarily of soft, clay-heavy
soil. To boost the foundation and make it
more of an earthquake proof building,
engineers incorporated 980 piles — some
nearly 300 feet deep — secured within
2.15 million cubic feet of reinforced
concrete.
◦ As the building sways, the inertia of the
weight counters this movement. For
optimal counterbalancing, a series of
shock absorbers keep the pendulum
from swinging too far or too quickly.
Prepared by: KSDYee