You are on page 1of 13

Hydrometallurgy 108 (2011) 33–45

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Hydrometallurgy
j o u r n a l h o m e p a g e : w w w. e l s ev i e r. c o m / l o c a t e / h yd r o m e t

Bauxite residue issues: I. Current management, disposal and storage practices


G. Power, M. Gräfe, C. Klauber ⁎
CSIRO Process Science and Engineering (Parker CRC), Light Metals National Research Flagship, PO Box 7229, Karawara WA 6152, Australia

a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t

Article history: Bauxite residue has been continuously produced since the inception of the alumina/aluminium industry in the
Received 19 August 2010 late nineteenth century. The global inventory of bauxite residue reached an estimated 2.7 billion tonnes in 2007
Received in revised form 1 February 2011 increasing at 120 million tonnes per annum. This growth highlights the urgency to develop and implement
Accepted 14 February 2011
improved means of storage and remediation, and to pursue large-volume utilization options of residue as an
Available online 24 February 2011
industrial by-product. This review looks at current management practices for disposal and amendment, and how
Keywords:
each unit process influences residue properties. Since 1980 the trend has been away from lagoon-type
Red mud impoundments towards “dry” stacking; this reduces the potential for leakage, reduces the physical footprint and
Bauxite residue improves recoveries of soda and alumina. Associated technical developments in residue neutralization are
Bayer process solids considered with possible future practices in residue disposal and how that might best integrate with future
Global residue inventory utilization. For example, hyperbaric steam filtration is an emerging technology that could discharge residue as a
BRDA engineering dry, granular material of low soda content. Such properties are beneficial to long term storage and remediation,
Dry-stacking but importantly also to future utilization. Although residue has a number of characteristics of environmental
Lagooning
concern, the most immediate and apparent barrier to remediation and utilization (improved sustainability) is its
Residue utilization
high alkalinity and sodicity. The sustained alkalinity is the result of complex solid-state and solution phase
BRaDD
Marine disposal interactions while its sodicity arises from the use of caustic soda (NaOH) for digestion. This is the first in a series of
four related reviews examining bauxite residue issues in detail.
Crown Copyright © 2011 Published by Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

1. Introduction identify the technologies or practices for either the alternative use of
bauxite residues and/or improved storage practices.
Bauxite residue and its appropriate management is of increasing
environmental concern. As the global demand for aluminium metal
continues in transportation, packaging and construction, from the 2. Overview of bauxite residue management
fabrication of fuselages and car parts to disposable containers and
various consumer durables, the legacy of nearly 120 years of alumina 2.1. History and future of bauxite residue
extraction from bauxite ore is manifested as an estimated 2.7 billion -
tonnes (Bt) of hazardous material commonly referred to either as red In order to appreciate the trends in both awareness and
mud or bauxite residue. This amount is currently increasing by perceptions of residue, the evolution of technologies, management
approximately 120 million tonnes per annum (Mtpa). Storage locations systems and the regulatory situation, it is worthwhile examining the
vary from purpose built, well-engineered containment areas through to history of the alumina industry and the inevitable growth in the world
simply utilizing natural landscape depressions and the bottom of the residue inventory and how it has been managed.
ocean (marine disposal). Despite the long-standing recognition of In 1885, Karl Josef Bayer moved from Brno (Czech Republic, then
bauxite residue as a problem, it has never been satisfactorily resolved. In Austro-Hungarian Empire) to St. Petersburg, where he joined the
order to understand why this has arisen and to seek possible solutions Tentelev Chemical Plant to work on the dying of cotton fabrics using
for better management, it is very useful to consider all aspects of pure aluminium hydroxide, which was a rare and expensive raw
production, chemistry, residue value and barriers to utilization. This is material. By 1887 he had discovered that aluminum hydroxide could
the first in a series of four reviews examining issues pertinent to bauxite be precipitated in crystalline form from a cold sodium aluminate
residue and its environmental impact (see also Klauber et al., 2011; (NaAl(OH)4) solution, if a seed of aluminium hydroxide was used. On
Gräfe et al., 2011; Gräfe and Klauber, 2011). Ultimately, the aim is to July 17, 1887, the Imperial Patent Office of Germany issued patent
number 43977 “Verfahren zur Darstellung von Thonerdehydrat und
Alkalialuminat”.1 Shortly after, he discovered that the required NaAl
(OH)4 solution could be prepared by heating bauxite under pressure
⁎ Corresponding author. Tel.: + 61 8 9334 8060; fax: + 61 8 9334 8001.
1
E-mail address: craig.klauber@csiro.au (C. Klauber). Process for synthesis of aluminium oxide hydrate (gibbsite) and alkali aluminate.

0304-386X/$ – see front matter. Crown Copyright © 2011 Published by Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.hydromet.2011.02.006
34 G. Power et al. / Hydrometallurgy 108 (2011) 33–45

3000
2008) and for dust and other losses in the conversion of the oxide to
140 Global residue production and inventory
the metal. Bauxite residue tonnage was then estimated by applying an
2500
residue production rate (Mtpa)

120 annual residue production overall ratio of 1.5 to the alumina production (Hamada, 1986). Factors
such as bauxite grade, alumina extraction efficiency and caustic losses

cumulative residue (Mt)


cumulative inventory
100 2000 will vary between refinery operations so a world average ratio value
of 1.5 should only be regarded as approximate.
80
1500
60
2.2. Need for a cohesive residue database: Development of BRaDD
1000
40 It appears to have been in the early 1980s, when the bauxite residue
inventory was approaching the 1 Bt level, that bauxite residue became
500
20 recognized as an issue of increasing environmental importance to the
future of the industry. In 1981, the United Nations Environmental
0 0
1900 1920 1940 1960 1980 2000 Programme (UNEP) and the United Nations Industrial Development
year Organization (UNIDO) jointly sponsored a workshop in Paris to examine
the environmental aspects of alumina production. Overviews of the
Fig. 1. Global production rate and cumulative inventory of bauxite residue.
workshop, “Environmental Aspects of Alumina Production”, are
available as a UNEP pamphlet (United Nations Industrial Development
in concentrated caustic soda (NaOH) solution, a process that he Organisation, 1985), and in a conference paper by (Hamada, 1986).
patented shortly after (Patent number 65604 issued by the German In 1986, The University of the West Indies and The Jamaica Bauxite
Imperial Patent Office 31 January 1892). Bayer's two patents formed Institute conducted the first conference and workshop on bauxite
that basis of the industrial process of extracting and synthesizing tailings in Kingston (Jamaica) co-sponsored by UNIDO and the
gibbsite that now bears his name (Habashi, 1988).2 International Research Development Centre (IRDC) and major
The potential for the Bayer process to provide alumina as feedstock producers of alumina and aluminium (Wagh and Desai, 1986). A
for the newly invented process for manufacturing aluminium metal subsequent bauxite tailings workshop was held in Perth (Australia)
was quickly realized. By 1892 Bayer plants had been established in 1992 under the sponsorship of the Australian bauxite and alumina
England, France, Italy and Germany for this purpose. Between 1893 producers (Glenister, 1992).
and 1910 two further Bayer plants were built in France and the Other useful sources of publications relating to bauxite residue
Pittsburgh Reduction Company (later Alcoa) built the first Bayer plant storage and disposal have been conference proceedings of the annual
in the USA at East St. Louis (Illinois). In the ensuing 30 years, more Light Metals conferences of The Minerals, Metals and Materials
plants were built in the USA, Germany, Great Britain, Japan and the Society (TMS), the Alumina Quality Workshop held every 3 years in
Soviet Union. Of these early plants, only the plant at Gardanne Australia, and the International Committee for the Study of Bauxite,
(France) is still operating today. Alumina & Aluminium (ICSOBA). In the general academic literature
From these beginnings the aluminium industry grew rapidly. From (journal and conference proceedings) only a small number of
6800 tonnes in 1900 the global production rate of aluminium metal publications relating to bauxite residues and storage issues have
reached 1 Mtpa in 1940. The global inventory of bauxite residue at appeared. From the first publication in 1977 to date, there are about
that time can be estimated to have been approximately 22 Mt, 90 papers (excluding pre-1990 conference proceedings and patents)
associated with production facilities that were small by today's and CSA's Aluminium Industry Abstracts lists 220 publications since
standards. The available literature up to that time makes little 1968 including patents, peer-reviewed journal articles, other articles
mention of bauxite residue, other than to account for dealing with it and conference proceedings.
as part of the cost of production. It appears that neither the industry, Surveys of the accessible literature on residue revealed that the
public nor governments viewed bauxite residue as an issue of social or various data domains placed a severe limitation on the ability to
environmental importance. collect, systematize and interrogate information on residue. A number
Technology development and economies of scale have driven the of key features are apparent:
development of increasingly larger production facilities. By the 1980s,
1 Mtpa was the size of new plants being built in Australia and Brazil, 1. Relevant information is scattered over many public domain sources:
with plants in Spain and Ireland expanding beyond 1 Mtpa in the early journals, conference proceedings, patents, company reports, securi-
1990s. Today Alunorte (Barcarena, Brazil) is targeting a production of ties and exchange commission reports, newspaper articles, PhD and
6 Mtpa. By 1985 residue was being produced at a rate of approxi- MSc theses, and other miscellaneous sources. Much of the informa-
mately 48.5 Mtpa and the global inventory of residue neared the 1 Bt tion is not peer-reviewed, but is essential to construct an under-
mark. In 2007 the annual production of residue was an estimated standing of residue management.
120 Mtpa and the global inventory had risen to over 2.6 Bt. Thus it 2. Each source of information provides only a limited amount of
took approximately 90 years to generate the first billion tonnes of relevant data, and the data type is not consistent across publications.
residue, but only approximately 15 years to produce the second. 3. The relevant information is published in a variety of languages,
These figures suggest that 3 Bt will be exceeded between 2010 and principally Chinese, English, French, German, Portuguese, Russian
2015. Our estimates of the growth in the inventory and rate of and Spanish.
production of bauxite residue from 1900 to 2007 are shown in Fig. 1 4. The nature and scope of the information is owner and/or refinery
and are based on alumina and aluminum metal production. specific and not consistent in either form or content.
Where alumina production data is not directly available, the 5. Each refinery has unique operating details with respect to bauxite
annual production values have been inferred by applying a factor of 2 residue technologies, management and engineering practices.
to the production values for aluminium metal. This factor is calculated 6. The operating details of each refinery may or may not change in
from the stoichiometric ratio of 1.9 plus an additional 0.1 to allow for any given year.
alumina being produced for non-metallurgical uses (0.08, Roskill,
That is, for every refinery, a multifactorial data set propagates over
2
The dates suggested by Habashi (1988) are incorrect as can be evidenced from the time, which must then be combined over all refineries in order to
original patents. The correct dates are presented here. provide a true reflection of technology, storage practices, engineering,
G. Power et al. / Hydrometallurgy 108 (2011) 33–45 35

science, utilization options and chemistry relevant to bauxite residue. simplest method, the residue slurry from the washing circuit is
The absence of a means of collecting and managing information disposed directly into the sea, usually via a pipeline that takes the
on bauxite residue is a key impediment to elucidate knowledge slurry well offshore for discharge into the deep ocean. For lagooning
gaps about bauxite residue. This prompted the creation of an on-line the residue slurry from the washing circuit is pumped into land-based
database that would contain details on refinery practices on bauxite ponds. Such ponds may be formed within natural depressions using
residue storage, disposal, and technologies gathered from a wide dams and other earthworks to ensure secure containment. More
range of sources with an aim to provide a comprehensive resource recently the emphasis has been on dry disposal, namely “dry” stacking
through which data could be compared and analyzed in a variety of and dry cake disposal. “Dry” stacking is a misnomer as the residue is
ways. The database, known as the Bauxite, Residue and Disposal actually not dry at time of discharge. Each method has advantages and
Database (BRaDD), is publicly available to interested parties at no cost disadvantages that are summarized in Table 3.
(see Gräfe et al., 2009, 2010). BRaDD has been an essential enabling The main factors determining the choice of disposal method for
tool for the collation and interpretation of information required for a given refinery are local rainfall and topography and the land
this and the subsequent reviews in this series. It is hoped that later availability in the context of the grade and mineralogy of the bauxite
versions of BRaDD, with data input from the industry, will provide and the size of the refinery (which together determine the rate of
invaluable support to the development of a global strategy for the residue production) and of course legislative requirements. Secondary
future of bauxite residue management. factors that can influence choice are the economics of trucking versus
pumping to the BRDA. French and Japanese practices have historically
2.3. Bauxite residue production process: red side favoured disposal at sea as the best option on economic and
environmental grounds. North American practice has favoured land-
The success of the Bayer process is demonstrated by the fact that, based disposal in lagoons, even for refineries on the seaboard.
despite enormous technological advances and the need to process a The 1970s saw a major expansion of the alumina industry in
wide range of ore types, the basic chemistry and operational steps of a response to growth in primary aluminium production, resulting in a
modern Bayer plant are fundamentally the same as originally rapid growth in the production rate and global inventory of bauxite
described in Bayer's patents. In combination with the Hall–Héroult residue (Fig. 1) that in turn led to the construction of new refineries
process for smelting alumina to metal, it remains the only viable throughout the world. In particular, increasingly large refineries were
process for the production of the metal, a situation that is highly built in the major laterite regions of first Australia and then South
unusual, if not unique, in the history of metallurgical processes. The America. The distribution and timing of refineries are shown in Fig. 3.
chemical and physical nature of bauxite residue is determined by the Apart from a number of refineries that we have been unable to locate
nature of the bauxite and the effect that the Bayer process has on it.
Hence it is relevant to consider the main aspects of a modern Bayer
plant that affect residue properties.
The half of the Bayer plant that affects the properties of the residue
produced includes a series of unit processes that start with bauxite and
finish with bauxite residue; this is often referred to as the “red side”. A
contemporary Bayer plant's red side generally includes the unit
processes of bauxite milling, pre-desilication, digestion, clarification,
and counter-current decantation (CCD) washing (thickener series). A
further thickening and/or filtration step prior to residue discharge
(usually to a bauxite residue disposal area or BRDA) follows these unit
processes. A schematic of these basic steps is shown in Fig. 2. Each unit
process influences the chemical composition of the residues, as well as
their physical and mineralogical attributes and the way they behave
subsequently in the BRDA.
Bauxite residue management begins at the point of separation of the
green liquor from the solids remaining after digestion. This is usually
achieved in a thickener (also known as a settler) which separates
residues from saturated sodium aluminate (NaAl(OH)4) solutions. After
the green liquor has been separated, the residue underflow is transferred
to the counter-current decantation (CCD) washer trains where the
residues are washed in several stages in raked thickeners (settler-
washers) to recover NaOH and NaAl(OH)4 from the remaining entrained
liquor and from the solids that slowly release these constituents into
solution. After washing in the CCD train, the residue is usually filtered or
treated in a final thickener to increase the solids content prior to being
transported to the BRDA. Filtration is used in some plants currently, but
the majority of plants use thickeners for this purpose. The thickener may
typically be either a deep cone thickener (Alcan) or a superthickener
(Alcoa). The most important influences of each process in relation to
bauxite residue are summarized in Tables 1 and 2.

3. Storage practices, engineering and science


Fig. 2. Schematic of a general Bayer process “red side”, highlighting those processes
3.1. Development of disposal methods affecting the disposal and storage of bauxite residues. The right arrows for the counter-
current wash train (e.g. 1–5) indicate the flow of wash water opposite to the flow of
residue. The final residue preparation stage may be a deep cone type thickener (5),
Prior to the 1970s, there were only two disposal methods in superthickener (e.g. 6) or a filter. Some refineries practice a variety of pre-disposal
general use, marine discharge and lagooning. Marine discharge is the neutralization amendments.
36 G. Power et al. / Hydrometallurgy 108 (2011) 33–45

Table 1
Bayer plant unit processes affecting bauxite residue characteristics relevant to disposal and storage.

Plant process Effects relevant to disposal and storage

Bauxite milling • Sets the effective particle size distribution and specific surface area of bauxite particles for digestion
• Particle size and surface area are key factors in determining physical properties
(e.g. Settling rates, mud rheology) and chemical properties (e.g. Adsorption of flocculants, organics and
metal ions, dissolution rates of minerals and precipitates)
Pre-desilication • Introduces sodium alumino-silicates (desilication products or DSP) to the residue
Digestion • High temperature, high pressure environment which alters the elemental and mineralogical make-up
of the original bauxite particles into bauxite residues
• Nature of the bauxite dictates temperature, pressure and NaOH concentrations (see Table 2)
• Introduces large amounts NaOH to the solids increasing their ph, alkali and Na+ content
• Al is solubilized and removed from the solid phase
• Mineral transformation reactions occur: less stable minerals dissolve and re-precipitate; other minerals
undergo solid-state dehydration reactions which convert them to more stable mineral phases
Settling • Conducted in high volume raked settlers
• Slurry is mixed with chemical additives to promote settling and to clarify the overflow liquor
• Bauxite residue is separated from the green liquor
Washing • Conducted in high volume raked washers
• Flocculants added to achieve required underflow densities
• Recovery of NaOH and NaAl(OH)4 in the remaining liquor of the residues to be returned to the main
Bayer process liquor
• Underflow of the last washer is optimized according to the disposal method
Final thickening or filtration • Increases solids density to meet storage or disposal requirements
• Further flocculant or filtration aid added
• Additional washing

in China, we believe this distribution map accurately accounts for the marine disposal regarded as a last resort where suitable land disposal
majority of global alumina production. This rapid expansion coincided is not available” (United Nations Industrial Development Organisation,
with increasing environmental awareness. Regulation in the devel- 1985). This appears to reflect the opinion of the majority of companies
oped world from the 1970s onwards led to the development of new involved in alumina refining. There has been a shift away from direct
approaches to residue management. marine or river disposal as noted in Table 4. To our knowledge no new
Table 4 shows residue disposal methods used for 17 refineries for refineries were built after 1970 that employ marine disposal. Presently
which information could be found for each of the years nominated. only 2–3% of global alumina production results in marine disposal of
These 17 refineries accounted for 44% of the 76 million tonnes of residue.
alumina produced globally in 2007 (U.S. Geologic Survey, 2008). Residue from the Gramercy plant in Louisiana was disposed into
Noteworthy is the consistent trend away from marine disposal to the Mississippi River until 1974, at which time a transition was made to
land-based disposal, and from wet to “dry” disposal methods. In 1965, lagooning. The operating company (Kaiser) voluntarily removed
one third of the refineries considered were disposing of residue by residue from the river and relocated it to land-based lagoons. Effort
marine dumping, and the other two thirds were impounding it in was also directed towards dewatering and treating the residue to enable
lagoons. In the 1970s research into alternatives led to the develop- the creation of useful products in order to limit the requirements for
ment of “dry” stacking methods. The subsequent increase in the additional area for residue disposal (Kirkpatrick, 1996).
number of plants using “dry” stacking, and the conversion of a number Plants in Japan are restricted in relation to land area available for
of refineries from wet to dry disposal, reflects its emergence as the disposal of residues, and so have historically marine discharged.
favoured option for residue disposal (Banerjee, 2003; Cooling, 1989) Responses to find beneficial uses for residue (e.g. as a supplement to
and certainly the preferred practice in the construction of new cement manufacture) have proved insufficient. Other approaches to
refineries. By 1985 43% of the refineries were using “dry” stacking, minimize residue have been to maximize the imported bauxite grade
growing to 70% by 2007. As noted in Table 3 it has the particular and to directly import smelter feed “hydrate” (International Maritime
advantages of reducing the land area required for residue storage, Organization, 2005). Japan made a commitment in 2005 to the
minimizing the potential for liquor release to the surrounding International Maritime Organization that disposal of bauxite residue
environment and also maximizing the recovery of liquor (and to the sea would be discontinued by 2015. The country reported that
entrained value) to the refinery. One serious drawback however is in the previous 5 years residue had been disposed to the sea at two
the increased risk of fugitive dust requiring mitigation methods. locations at a total rate of 1.0 Mtpa. Environmental impact assess-
ments at both sites concluded no impact on water quality and marine
3.2. Marine disposal organisms in the water column in the region of sedimentation but some
differences in the nature of the seabed between the dumping sites and
The 1981 UNEP/UNIDO workshop concluded that “disposal control sites, i.e. only limited impact was reportedly observed. It was
[of bauxite residue] into rivers has been strongly discouraged and intended that further monitoring campaigns would be carried out every
2 to 3 years (International Maritime Organization, 2005).
The plants at Gardanne in France and Viotia in Greece that still use
Table 2 marine dumping are actively pursuing alternatives (Martinet-Catalot
Bayer digest variables.
et al., 2002). Dauvin (2010) summarizes the most recent impact
Hudson (1987).
assessments for the Cassidaigne canyon. It is noteworthy that as of
Main Al mineral Gibbsite Boehmite 2010 only 0.18 Mt (dry weight) will be discharged at Gardanne and
Al(OH)3 γ-AlOOH they (along with Japan) will cease all marine discharge by 2015. A
Temperature (°C) 104–145 200–232 study of the discharge from the Viotia plant into the Gulf of Corinth
Pressure (atm) 1.0–3.0 6.0 showed that an extensive deposit has been formed close to the point
NaOH (M) 8.9–3.6 5.0–3.6
of discharge from a pipeline at a depth of 100 m. The residue also
G. Power et al. / Hydrometallurgy 108 (2011) 33–45 37

Table 3
Summary of the advantages and disadvantages of the four residue disposal methods.

Advantages Disadvantages

Marine disposal
No land required for storage Covering of sea-bed and destruction of associated ecosystem
No closure and rehabilitation of storage areas Potential for release of toxic metals to marine environment
No impacts associated with land-based storage (dusting, contamination Increased turbidity of seawater due to dispersion of original residue and the
of surface and ground waters, and leaching of toxic metals) formation of colloidal magnesium and aluminium compounds
Lower capital and operating costs than for land-based disposal methods Unknown effects on ecosystems and food chains
No additional thickening or filtration of the slurry prior to disposal Increasing community/regulatory pressure to discontinue the practice
Does not return impurities to the Bayer plant liquor Loss of soda and alumina values with entrained liquor

Lagooning (low wt% solids)


Lowest capital cost land-based disposal method Provision of substantial areas of land
No additional thickening or filtration of the slurry prior to disposal Long term planning and funds for closure and rehabilitation
Dust potential minimized by maintaining a supernatant liquor layer Loss of soda and alumina values with entrained liquor
Does not return impurities to the Bayer plant liquor If not neutralized:
Poorly compacted highly alkaline residue and highly alkaline lake
Range of hazards (risk of contact of humans and wildlife with caustic liquor and
residue, and contamination of surface and ground waters)
Costly engineering to prevent catastrophic failure of impoundments
Difficult to close and rehabilitate because of large amounts of caustic liquor —
possibility of an indefinite legacy

“Dry” stacking (48–55 wt.% solids)


Land area required for storage is minimized Sufficient areas of land for storage
Structures required for secure containment are minimized Planning and funds allocation for long-term closure
Soda and alumina values in the liquor are returned to the Bayer plant Additional stage of thickening or filtration prior to discharge.
Potential for leakage to groundwater is minimized Liquor impurities are returned to the Bayer plant (process impacts)
Risk of surface water contamination is lowered by smaller area of open “Dry” stack surfaces are subject to fugitive dust lift-off and mitigation processes
contaminated water and returning runoff to the Bayer plant may be required (e.g. sprinklers)
Rapid de-liquoring assists area management, including rehabilitation Difficult to achieve in areas of high rainfall and low net evaporation
Hazards associated with open caustic lakes are minimized Significant compaction density hinders the establishment of vegetation
Recovery of solids for alternative uses is facilitated

Dry cake disposal (N 65 wt.% solids)


Land area required for storage is minimized Provision of sufficient areas of land for storage
Collapse risk of a raised mound or impoundment is minimized Long term planning and funds for closure and rehabilitation
Soda and alumina values in the liquor are returned to the Bayer plant Installation and operation of a filtration plant capable of handling entire
which reduces the need for washing stages residue production
Low leakage risk to groundwater due to the low pore volume Liquor impurities are returned to the Bayer plant (process impacts)
Environmental and safety hazards associated with the presence of open Surfaces are subject to dust lift-off so that mitigation processes may be required
caustic lakes are avoided
Residue can be recovered by standard earthmoving equipment
Rehabilitation and closure are facilitated by the ability to landscape the
deposit and by its low alkali content

extends over the sloping shelf of the sea floor and into an abyssal plain to mixing with seawater or by the addition of mineral acids (e.g.
a depth of 860 m at distances of up to 17 km from the point of discharge. sulphuric acid).
The main mechanism of transport of the residue from the shelf to the Lagooning is the simplest land-based disposal method, but due to the
abyss was found to be by gravitational flow triggered by seismic events, low solids content is also the most dependent on good engineering
which are common in the region (Varnavas et al., 1986). practice for the residue containment. The increased risk with low solids
containment is tragically demonstrated by the impoundment wall
3.3. Lagooning collapse at the Ajka Timföldgyár alumina refinery in October 2010
(Enserink, 2010). Effective low solids in an impoundment area can also
The residue slurry from the washing circuit is pumped into land- arise from high rainfall events.
based impoundments. In the absence of suitable natural topography,
ponds may exist as fully fabricated structures, generally excavated 3.4. “Dry” stacking
into the existing land. In either case, best practice is to line the ponds
with sealants to minimize liquor leakage to the underlying ground “Dry” stacking is a significantly different disposal concept and could
and ground water. The linings vary in relation to both the materials more generically be termed thickened tailings disposal (TTD). Unlike
used and the complexity of the construction. The simplest is a single lagooning residue at a low solids level, the residue slurry from the washing
layer of compacted clay which separates the residue from the original circuit is thickened to a paste (in the initial range of approximately 48 to
soil or rock of the storage area, but the integrity of such layers cannot 55% solids) prior to discharge. The paste is thixotropic, and so is amenable
generally be guaranteed (Thomas et al., 2002). Additional security can to pumping and pipeline transport. Upon discharge from the pipe it
be achieved by the use of multiple layers featuring impermeable will flow down a slope without segregating or settling to form layers of
plastic or geo-membrane materials to form a seal between the residue uniform thickness at an angle of repose in a range of 2° to 6° (in non-
and the supporting clay or other layer beneath. Minimizing the freezing conditions). The residue deposit is built into a stack by
hydrostatic pressure by removing liquor by decanting and in some discharging the paste progressively in thin layers that are allowed to
cases by also under-draining the deposit further contributes to the dewater and air-dry before being overlain with the next layer. Upon
reliability of the seal (Cooling, 1989). Storage problems can be further standing, the paste consolidates (with liquor decant) to a density of 62 to
mitigated by neutralizing the slurry prior to discharge, for example by 65% solids, with a final dry density around 70% and an accompanying
38 G. Power et al. / Hydrometallurgy 108 (2011) 33–45

Fig. 3. World map showing the distribution of alumina refineries based on establishment date (before or after 1970), closed or unknown.

increase in shear strength. Shear strengths of 20 kPa or more may be imately 5°). The deposition schedule was managed to optimize
reached (Nikraz et al., 2007). The consolidation occurs as the solids settle surface drying while minimizing dusting potential. It was found that:
and liquor is removed by a combination of decantation and surface
evaporation. Modern designs also include under-draining to facilitate the • The residue consolidates to about 62–67% solids, enabling it to be
consolidation process. The process is designed such that the dried paste traversed by machinery minimizing the requirements of the
becomes substantially self-supporting so that it can be safely stacked to containment dykes
considerable heights within containment bunds, minimizing the physical • Degree of fluid decant was minimal, and rainwater could be
footprint of the disposal area (Cooling, 1989). As with lagooning the collected and either discharged to the environment or returned to
hazards associated with alkalinity may be reduced by neutralization but the Bayer plant according to purity
any changes to paste rheology need to be considered. • Material compacts on standing to become highly impermeable
Methods for disposing of residue with prior de-liquoring were (permeability in the order of 10−9 cm/s), removing the necessity to
pioneered in Germany with a view to minimizing the land required line the disposal area to prevent seepage of impurities into the
for disposal and maximizing the return of soda and alumina to the underlying soil and ground water
refinery. The term “dry stacking” appears to have been first used to
describe the process developed at the Ludwigshafen plant in the A similar system was developed and implemented by Alcan at the
1970s (Anon, 1982; Pohland et al., 1981; Pohland and Tielens, 1983, Arvida plant in Canada (Paradis, 1992, 1993; Robinsky, 1982). In this
1986). Residue slurry from the washing stage was filtered on drum case special thickeners were developed to produce a residue of
filters that discharged a cake at about 55% solids by weight. The cake sufficient solids density to behave as a non-segregating slurry. This led
was fluidized by mechanical agitation for pumping to the drying area to the development of the Alcan Deep Cone Thickener, a new
where it formed a mound with a shallow angle of repose (approx- technology for producing densities of over 50% solids suitable for

Table 4
Storage practices at 17 refineries (representing 44% of global alumina production in 2007) for which information is available over the period 1965–2007.

Startup date Refinery 1965 1975 1985 2007

1959 Kirkvine Lagoon Lagoon Lagoon Lagoon


1963 Kwinana Lagoon Lagoon “Dry” stack “Dry” stack
1965 Aluminium de Grece Sea disposal Sea disposal Sea disposal Sea disposal
1967 Queensland Alumina Ltd Lagoon Lagoon Lagoon
1972 Alcoa Alumino S.A. Lagoon Lagoon “Dry” stack
1972 Gove Alumina Lagoon Lagoon “Dry” stack
1972 Pinjarra Lagoon “Dry” stack “Dry” stack
1973 VAW Stade Unknown “Dry” stack “Dry” stack
1973 Eurallumina Lagoon Lagoon Lagoon
1980 San Ciprian “Dry” stack “Dry” stack
1983 Aughinish “Dry” stack “Dry” stack
1983 CVG Bauxilum Lagoon Lagoon
1984 Worlsey Alumina “Dry” stack “Dry” stack
1984 Wagerup Lagoon “Dry” stack
1987 Dhamanjodi “Dry” stack
1995 Alunorte Barcarena “Dry” stack
2005 Yarwun “Dry” stack
G. Power et al. / Hydrometallurgy 108 (2011) 33–45 39

the production of thickened tailings without the need for filtration and transport design, and for spreading behaviour and slope formation
(Peloquin and Simard, 2002). In 1996 Alcan entered into a license prediction are yield stress and viscosity as a function of solids content
agreement with EIMCO for the further development and marketing of and the shear and compression history of the material (Green and Boger,
Deep Cone thickeners. According to EIMCO (now FLSmidth Minerals) 1997; Sofra and Boger, 2002). The particle size distribution is also
there are over 50 Alcan Deep Cone thickeners now operating in important (Doucet, 1999) as is the nature and rates of the chemical
alumina plants, and the technology has been deployed to other additives (in particular flocculants and flowability aids).
industries including copper and lead/zinc processing (Emmett and These principles have also been successfully applied at the MOTIM
Klepper, 1991; Emmett et al., 1992). Thickener performance issues are plant in Hungary, where the residue is filtered on vacuum drum filters
reviewed by Farrow et al. (2000). to 50% solids, fluidized by high-intensity stirring, and then pumped to
The National Aluminium Company (NALCO) plant at Orissa, India, the residue storage area where it is stacked in layers to dry. After
applied the Alcan technology (Banerjee, 2003; Das et al., 2003) to drying times between 80 days (summer) and 160 days (winter), the
replace the original wet disposal method and they simply refer to it as solids content rises to around 65%, at which point the material can be
TTD. The system was installed as part of a major plant expansion from mechanically spread using conventional earth-moving machines
0.8 to 1.575 Mtpa. The existing wet disposal method would not have (Solymar et al., 2002).
been capable of supporting the projected residue production over the Alcoa determined that underflow densities in the region of 50 wt%
ensuing 20 plus years, because of limitations on the availability of solids were sufficient as the starting point for a “dry” stacking system
suitable land area and environmental concerns associated with wet provided with underdrainage for efficient de-liquoring (Cooling, 1989)
disposal. The alternative of dry cake disposal was also considered, but of the deposited residue and return of the recovered liquor to the Bayer
was rejected, primarily on grounds of capital and operating costs. plant. The required solids density was achieved in a specially designed,
Concerns related to the safety and environmental aspects of trucking large diameter (90 m) thickener (a “superthickener”) and associated
the material in hilly terrain were also cited (Banerjee, 2003). In rake system developed in collaboration with EIMCO (Marunczyn and
addition to the “dry” stacking advantages outlined in Table 3, the TTD Laros, 1992, 1993). As the raking loads would exceed the capability of
system was seen to have additional advantages in relation to wet any centre-drive design, a peripheral traction drive was employed
storage of reduced earthquake and erosion risks and lower energy (Emmett and Klepper, 1991). Between 1985 and 1992, Alcoa imple-
consumption and pipeline requirements. mented at its Western Australian refineries a stacking system in which
The rheological properties of bauxite residues vary widely residue is deposited into rectangular cells on a rotational basis to assist
between plants and successful “dry” stacking requires an understand- drying and reduce the land area. It was found that final densities
ing of the rheology (Farrow et al., 2000; Sofra and Boger, 2002) as of ~ 70 wt.% solids are achievable, although the time required was not
slurries are thixotropic and their flowability increases with the reported (Cooling and Glenister, 1992). A schematic of this system is
amount and manner of mixing energy applied (Pashias and Boger, shown in Fig. 4. At 70 wt.% the shear strength of the stack is N 30 kPa (i.e.
1996). For example, slurry that has been allowed to settle to 50% high structural integrity) and not only is the storage volume
solids will be firm and seemingly un-pumpable, but if sufficient requirement reported to be about 60% of that required for lagooning,
mixing energy is introduced, the viscosity is decreased as the pore but greater impoundment heights are more easily constructed. Further
liquids create a network enabling the slurry to be pumped. Without under-drainage may be introduced progressively as the stack is built.
sustained energy input it will slowly revert back to a firm condition. Some mechanical ploughing of the surface is required to optimize drying
These flow behaviour changes occur without the solids density of the rates, and water sprinklers are used on an as needs basis to mitigate
material changing. The key rheological parameters for slurry thickening fugitive dust lift-off. Fig. 5 shows a satellite image of the Pinjarra residue

Fig. 4. Schematic of Alcoa dry-stacking method for bauxite residue disposal.


Redrawn from Alcoa (2005a).
40 G. Power et al. / Hydrometallurgy 108 (2011) 33–45

Fig. 5. Google Earth™ image of Pinjarra refinery and residue area in 2006. Captions inferred from Pinjarra long term residue management plan (Alcoa, 2005b). GOOGLE is a
trademark of Google Inc.

area (the labeling of the areas is according to the Pinjarra long term residue to fully de-liquor the cake. By using pressure filtration it is
residue plan (Alcoa, 2005b). This residue management has since been possible to achieve differential pressures in the order of 6 bar which is
deployed to other operations including those in Suriname, Spain, and Pt sufficient to fully de-liquor. The non-thixotropic nature of this cake is
Comfort Texas (Alcoa, 2001). It should be noted that the storage volume fundamental to the success of the process. It means that the cake can be
advantage over lagooning may be operationally relevant for a time, but readily discharged from the filter by air blow-back or mechanical means,
the final compaction of the solids in a lagooned impoundment would be and can then be transported to the disposal area by truck or conveyor
similar to dry disposal. Issues such as yield stress values and where it can be stacked with a minimum of additional treatment in
permeabilities at a given weight% solids must also be considered in relatively simple containment facilities (Kainuma et al., 1979; Oeberg
the context of residue particle size distributions, shape and mineralogy. and Steinlechner, 1996; Steinlechner et al., 1996).
For example, Jamaican residues settle to considerably lower% solids than Recent trials of BOKELA hyperbaric filtration technology have been
other residues (Roach et al., 2001) but exhibit similar viscosities, leading successfully demonstrated using a Bokela Hi-Bar® at the pilot plant
to the conclusion that comparisons of residue behaviour should be made scale at the Aluminiumoxid Stade (Germany) plant (Bott et al., 2002).
on a volume/volume basis and not% solids. This trial demonstrates the possibility of a marked improvement in the
removal of fluids and salts from bauxite residue in which solids contents
3.5. Dry cake disposal of N 75% can be achieved with the application of steam in the filter. This
filtration method produces soda contents as low as 3 g/kg as compared
Dry cake disposal refers to the practice of mechanically removing to 6 to 12 g/kg by vacuum filtration. The resulting cake is described as
as much water as possible from the residue to produce a dry cake with “extremely dry and well washed … with a crumbly, sandy-like and non-
a solid's content of N 65 wt% prior to disposal. The special case of dry sticky consistency and a low soda content” (Bott et al., 2002). Similar
cake disposal is not always specified as such in available information results were also achieved by Maschinenfabrik Andritz at the CVG plant
and “dry” stacking tends to be used to encompass both high wt% solids in Venezuela (Oeberg and Steinlechner, 1996).
methods. The dry cake is not pumpable, so is generally moved to the Producing a residue with these characteristics greatly simplifies
disposal area by conveyors or trucks. There is no significant further handling and storage requirements, reduces the potential for environ-
de-liquoring once the residue has been delivered to the storage area mental impact, and broadens the options for rehabilitation and/or reuse
and these factors distinguish it from “dry” stacking. Similarly to the of the material. A number of these advantages were previously
other methods, any hazards associated with entrained alkalinity can demonstrated by Nippon Light Metals at their Tomakomai works
be further reduced by washing or neutralizing the cake on the filters. (Kainuma et al., 1979). Given that the technology has been demon-
Filtration on vacuum drum filters followed by dry cake disposal has strated at a plant scale, the challenge is to develop it as an economically
been applied successfully in practice, for example at the Hindalco attractive alternative to current methods, and then to deploy it to
plant at Renukoot (Shah and Gararia, 1995). existing and future plants.
It is not possible to achieve a dry cake by means of thickening alone,
and so a filtration stage is required. Vacuum filtration is not generally 3.6. Bauxite residue amendment
satisfactory for this purpose, as it is limited in the available pressure drop
across the filter cake to b 0.75 bar (Oeberg and Steinlechner, 1996). This Except for dry cake disposal bauxite residue is discharged as a slurry
is insufficient to overcome the capillary resistance inside the pores of the or paste whose high alkalinity (pH N 11) and high sodium content
G. Power et al. / Hydrometallurgy 108 (2011) 33–45 41

favours particle dispersion. In addition, the solids in the slurry contain a liquor, which is the solution produced by the digestion process, also
high proportion of fine, silt- to clay-sized particles. The combination of contains Na+ ions in high concentration. As a result, the liquor becomes
these chemical and physical factors creates significant difficulties in the unstable with respect to a range of sodium alumino-silicates, in
handling, storage and remediation or utilization of bauxite residue. For particular sodalite3 and/or cancrinite.4 These sodium alumino-silicate
long-term storage or utilization of the residue, it may be necessary to solids that form during pre-desilication and pre-digestion are collec-
release liquor to the surrounding environment. This will generally tively referred to as “desilication products” or DSPs because they remove
require it to be neutralized in some way and diluted prior to discharge. silica, sodium and hydroxide ions from solution by incorporation. DSP is
The pore fluids remaining in the stack will generally also need to be a form of solid alkalinity, stable while the solution is alkaline, but
diluted and/or neutralized. Solid alkalinity can also have a profound decomposing in neutral to acid solutions, releasing sodium, hydroxide,
effect on attempts to neutralize the pore water and is a major factor to be aluminate and silicate ions into solution. In this way the DSPs act as
considered in any evaluation of possible future storage or utilization significant solid alkaline pH buffers.
scenarios. The need to amend bauxite residue grew with the rapid A number of side reactions can occur between the added lime and
growth of industry output and increasing levels of environmental the aluminate ions in the Bayer solution. The exact reactions and the
awareness and regulation. nature of the products depend on conditions, but the general
Although significant general progress has been made with the reactions may be illustrated by the formation of hydrated calcium
advent of “dry” stacking, it is reasonable to conclude that pressure aluminate and aluminate carbonate as follows (Rosenberg et al.,
filtration, washing and at least partial pH neutralization would remain 2004):
essential to any long term disposal solution. However, pressure filtration
in particular is costly and its implementation without regulatory − −
3CaðOHÞ2 þ 2½AlðOHÞ4  þ nH2 O→Ca3 Al2 ðOHÞ12 :nH2 OðsÞ þ 4OH
incentive is unlikely. The key to successful amendment is the complex
chemistry, this is treated in detail in part three of this review series − 2− −
4CaðOHÞ2 þ 2½AlðOHÞ4  þ CO3 þ nH2 O→½Ca2 AlðOHÞ6 2 :CO3 :nH2 OðsÞ þ 4OH
(Gräfe et al., 2011).

Alkaline solids can also be formed with other anions such as


3.6.1. Alkalinity of bauxite residue
phosphate, zincate and titanate, and with other cations such as
The object of the digestion step of the Bayer process is to dissolve
magnesium and potassium.
aluminium-containing minerals while minimizing the dissolution of
Both the quantity and forms of alkalinity must be taken into
other mineral phases. This is achieved in a strongly alkaline solution at
account in any process for neutralizing the residue. For example, the
temperatures above 100 °C (mostly in the range 145 to 250 °C), so
amount of carbonate in solution determines the buffering capacity of
that minerals such as gibbsite (Al(OH)3) and boehmite (γ-AlO(OH))
the solution above pH 10. In the region of neutral pH additional
are dissolved to produce [Al(OH)4]− (aluminate) ions in solution,
buffering is provided by (solid) aluminium hydroxides, and if
according to the following reactions:
significant carbonate is present, also by sodium alumino-carbonates,
− − in particular dawsonite (NaAl(OH)2CO3).
AlðOHÞ3ðsÞ þ OH ⇔½AlðOHÞ4 ðaqÞ

− −
γ  AlOðOHÞðsÞ þ OH þ H2 O⇔½AlðOHÞ4 ðaqÞ 3.6.2. Seawater remediation
Apart from direct marine disposal, such as has been practiced at
The bauxite residue is then separated from the main liquor stream Gardanne since the very early days of the industry (Martinet-Catalot
and washed to recover soda and alumina. The resulting residue et al., 2002), the first example of onshore remediation of residue by
contains pore water that is considerably more dilute (by a factor of at mixing with seawater appears to be at the Queensland Alumina refinery.
least 10) than the main Bayer plant liquor, but is nevertheless highly In this case seawater was used as a transport fluid for pumping it to
alkaline. If this residual solution is then neutralized, aluminium disposal lagoons in order to conserve fresh water (Hanahan, 2004).
hydroxides will re-precipitate. The nature of the precipitates depends Remediation by neutralization was a consequence, but not the primary
on the method and conditions of precipitation, but will generally aim of seawater use.
include Al(OH)3 and/or AlOOH. By adding seawater, hydroxide, carbonate and aluminate ions are
The chemistry of the residue slurry is thus determined by the removed from solution by reaction with Mg2+ and Ca2+ ions to form
interactions between the bauxite and the plant liquor during digestion, alkaline solids, in particular hydrotalcite (Mg6Al2(CO3)(OH)16·4(H2O))
followed by the changes that occur after the bulk solids are separated and calcite (CaCO3). This buffers the solution in the range of pH 8 to 9.
from the digest liquor and progressively washed (usually CCD) to It has been shown that the phosphate adsorption capacity of the
remove sodium hydroxide, aluminate and carbonate. During the solids is substantially increased by seawater neutralization (Hanahan,
washing process various chemicals are added, most notably flocculants 2004), and that the solids have a high trapping capacity for trace
to settle the residue and clarify the solution for return to the Bayer liquor metals (McConchie et al., 2002). These features are useful in relation
circuit, and lime to remove carbonate ions from the liquor by to revegetation of bauxite residue areas, and for creating various re-
precipitation of CaCO3 and replacement of carbonate by hydroxide use products (Tillotson, 2006).
ions in solution, in a process called “causticization”, nominally: Seawater is also used to neutralize the decant liquor from ponding
operations prior to discharge. Neutralization by simply mixing the
2− −
CaO þ CO3 þ H2 O→CaCO3ðsÞ þ 2OH decant liquor with seawater results in the formation of white colloidal
precipitates which have the potential to produce contamination
This produces pH buffers in the form of calcium carbonate, tricalcium downstream of the discharge point (Baseden and Grey, 1976). At the
aluminate (TCA, stoichiometric formula Ca3Al2(OH)12) and calcium- Gove refinery, hydrotalcite, calcium carbonate and calcium oxalate
aluminate carbonate (hydrocalumite, stoichiometric formula Ca4Al2 were identified as the main components of such precipitates along
(OH)12.CO3.6H2O). with trace amounts of other salts (Anderson et al., 2008).
Apart from the intended solubilization of aluminium species, there Further research led Alcan Gove to develop a seawater treatment
are a number of other reactions that occur during and prior to digestion. method for decant water to meet stringent standards of purity for
One of the most important is the solubilization of phyllosilicate minerals
(clays), e.g. kaolinite Al4Si4O10(OH)8. The dissolution of these minerals 3
Na6[Al6Si6O24]·[2NaOH,Na2SO4]·nH2O.
results in aluminate and silicate ions in solution. The digester discharge 4
Na6[Al6Si6O24]·2[CaCO3]·nH2O.
42 G. Power et al. / Hydrometallurgy 108 (2011) 33–45

discharge to the environment (Haggard and Smith, 2002). The purity leachate from a non-carbonated drying bed was consistently greater
parameters of particular interest are pH, turbidity and trace metals. In than 13. On the basis of these trials, full scale residue carbonation
addition to meeting the designated water quality criteria, ecological capability was implemented at the Kwinana refinery in 2000 (Cooling
toxicity testing was done to provide additional confirmation that the et al., 2002).
treated water was safe for discharge to the marine environment. It was Prior to neutralization, residue slurries are highly alkaline. The pH
found that a two-stage treatment was required in order to meet the of the slurry is generally in the region of 13, equivalent to an OH−
design performance requirements, particularly in relation to vanadium concentration of 0.1 M. Introducing CO2 to the solution causes rapid
levels. The first stage of the process is the mixing of the decant water neutralization according to the following reaction:
with a six-fold excess of heated seawater (waste cooling water from the
− −
plant evaporators) to form the hydroxide precipitates. The resulting CO2ðgÞ þ OH →HCO3 ðaqÞ
suspension is then mixed with residue slurry and treated with
flocculants in a thickener to produce a clarified overflow stream for This reaction causes the pH to drop rapidly until buffering by the
discharge. Continuous flow (bench scale) trials confirmed that the carbonate/bicarbonate equilibrium becomes apparent below a pH of
required performance parameters can be met with this design, which 10. At that pH solid hydroxides begin to form, creating additional
has been proposed for implementation at Gove (Anderson et al., 2008). buffering as they equilibrate with the ions in solution.
Successful implementation of this technology would be a significant The Alcoa trials demonstrated that it was possible to achieve a pH
milestone in the development of seawater neutralization technology. It as low as 8.5 by reacting residue slurry with CO2 under pressure
would be the first use of a Deep Cone thickener as a mixer to produce (Cooling et al., 2002). However, after the CO2 overpressure was
overflow water suitable for direct discharge and would eliminate the removed, the pH would slowly rise until a final pH of about 10.5 was
need of a labyrinthine discharge channel required to provide residence reached. This rise was explained by those authors and by Smith et al.
time necessary for formation and sedimentation of precipitates. (2003) as being due to the dissolution of alkaline solid phases that
become soluble in this pH range, for example TCA. As noted, TCA is
3.6.3. Mineral acid remediation present in bauxite residue as a result of the use of lime in the Bayer
There are few examples in the literature of neutralization of bauxite process for control of carbonate levels in the liquor (Rosenberg et al.,
residue by mineral acids and whilst addressed in general terms by 2004) and as an aid to settling and filtration (Whittington, 1996).
McConchie et al. (2002), no examples are given. The authors point out Dissolution of TCA results in the release of OH− ions to the solution,
that large quantities of acid would need to be available at low cost, thus raising the pH. This is accompanied by the formation of new solid
opining that this is unlikely to be the case for alumina refineries phases, including calcium carbonate (calcite), sodium aluminium
generally. It is also noted that residue neutralized by mineral acid hydroxyl-carbonate (dawsonite) and aluminum hydroxide (gibbsite),
contains no residual (solid) alkalinity, and so would not be useful as a possibly according to the following equations:
starting material for the range of applications envisaged by those
authors. In addition it does not improve the physical properties of the − þ
Ca3 Al2 ðOHÞ12 þ 3HCO3 ðaqÞ þ 4Na →3CaCO3 þ 2AlðOHÞ3 þ 3H2 O
material, both of which occur if either seawater or carbon dioxide is used
þ −
for neutralization. þ4Na þ 3OH
It has been reported that sulphuric acid is used as a supplementary − þ
neutralizing agent at the Yarwun refinery (Queensland, Australia) due 2Ca3 Al2 ðOHÞ12 þ 10HCO3 ðaqÞ þ 4Na →6CaCO3 þ 4NaAlðOHÞ2 CO3
to (pipeline) limitations in seawater supply (Sturt, 2008). The −
þ10H2 O þ 6OH
performance of sulphuric acid was assessed in terms of its ability to
reduce the level of aluminate in the discharge liquor. It was found that
Due to the buffering effects of these reactions, the pH can be expected
the mineral acid was significantly less effective in removing aluminate
to stabilize in the region of 10.5. These observations are consistent with
from solution because it relies on the precipitation of aluminium
recent work by Khaitan et al. (2009a), who also observed that the
hydroxide, whereas if seawater is used the solid phase formed is
amount of TCA present is a major factor in determining the carbon
hydrotalcite which is less soluble at the target pH of 8.5.
sequestration capacity of a bauxite residue (Khaitan et al., 2009b).
No references were found in the open literature concerning the
Alcoa found that carbonation of residue affects the physical prop-
neutralization of bauxite residue decant waters with mineral acids in
erties of the material as well as its chemical composition. Carbonated
a specific refinery context. Such a practice would be expected for some
residue dries more rapidly than uncarbonated residue, possibly because
refineries in order to meet discharge license requirements. This would
of the elimination of surface crusting and improved cracking behaviour
result in the formation of colloidal and/or gelatinous precipitates
that provides more effective surface area for evaporation. It was also
(primarily aluminium hydroxides and hydroxy-carbonates) requiring
found that the mechanical strength of the residue was enhanced by
a clarification process prior to discharge.
carbonation. The combination of these effects results in a significant
reduction in the drying time required to reach a target minimum
3.6.4. Carbon dioxide remediation
strength to ensure long-term stability, which in turn reduces the
A process for reacting bauxite residue with gaseous carbon dioxide
required cycle time for drying and improves the utilization of the
was piloted by Alcan for the Saramenha Ouro Preto refinery in Brazil
residue drying area. Some of the perceived benefits of carbonation of
in 1983 (Versiani, 1983). The concept has since been developed by
residue have been summarized (Cooling et al., 2002) as:
Alcoa as a means of reducing the pH of the slurry prior to “dry”
stacking (Cooling et al., 2002). Extensive laboratory and pilot-scale • Reduces risk to containment seal material (clay or synthetic) and
testing was carried out by Alcoa between 1991 and 1996. This was therefore reduced risk of groundwater contamination
followed by small-scale field trials in which several mixing devices • Improves quality of drainage water
were tested. Carbonated residue was deposited in layers so that its • Provides a sink for greenhouse gasses
longer term behaviour could be studied in a “dry” stacking operation. • Reduces risk of future classification of the residue as a hazardous waste
The optimum rate of CO2 addition was found to be 25 kg CO2 per m3 of • Facilitates development of productive uses for the residue in the future
residue slurry, at a slurry density of 48% solids. It was demonstrated
that a pH of 9 could be achieved in the carbonated residue. The pH of CO2 supply is a key issue to be considered in relation to carbonation
the leachate collected from the under-drainage system remained of residue. The carbonation technology applied at Kwinana requires
steady at around 10.5 over an extended period, while the pH of the concentrated CO2 as the raw material to be mixed with the residue
G. Power et al. / Hydrometallurgy 108 (2011) 33–45 43

slurry. The Kwinana alumina plant is located within an industrial accurately gauge the volume and nature of current residue output,
complex that includes an ammonia plant which produces pure CO2 as a let alone the very substantial legacy material in impoundment. Very
by-product, this is supplied to the residue area by a dedicated pipeline little useful information is in the public domain. We have established
(Cooling et al., 2002). Such examples of industrial synergy are rare, so an online database framework to try and address this problem — the
alternatives need to be considered if carbonation is to be applied more Bauxite, Residue and Disposal Database (BRaDD). BRaDD has been an
generally. One alternative is to extract CO2 from flue gasses associated essential enabling tool for the collation and interpretation of
with the alumina refinery. The level of CO2 in such flue gasses is information required for this and the associated three reviews in
generally in the order of 10%, so a concentration process in which it is the series. With further programming refinements, and with data
separated from the other gasses (mainly nitrogen) is needed. The input from the industry, BRaDD should be an invaluable tool in the
current best technologies for capturing and concentrating CO2 from flue development of a global strategy for the future of bauxite residue
gasses are based on amine scrubbing (Simmonds et al., 2003). This management.
requires the installation of a significant additional operation to an Prior to 1980, most of the inventory of bauxite residue was held in
already complex alumina plant, and carries the potential for amine lagoon-type impoundments. This storage method has a number of
emissions. A promising amine-free alternative is based on carbonation disadvantages, in particular the large areas of land required and the
of residue liquor by contacting it with flue gasses in a high-efficiency potential for leakage of caustic liquors to the environment. Since 1980
scrubber. The carbonated solution is then recirculated with residue the trend has been towards “dry” stacking in bunded areas that are
solids to carbonate the overall residue (Guilfoyle et al., 2005). lined with a variety of natural and synthetic barrier materials.
Improved methods for thickening and washing of the residues prior
3.6.5. Sulphur dioxide remediation to storage, and recovery of decant water during storage, have been
The reaction of SO2 with residue has been developed as a means of developed to increase the recovery of valuable soda and alumina to
scrubbing SO2 from flue gasses. The technology utilizes the reaction of the Bayer process plants and to also minimize the potential for
SO2 with the sodium alumino-silicates in the residue to produce leakage to the surrounding environment.
sulphites that can be removed by oxidation by air (Yamada et al., The current trend in residue storage practice is towards increasing
1979a,b). The process was patented by the Sumitomo Aluminium use of “dry” stacking as the preferred technology, and further research
Smelting Co (Yamada et al., 1979b), and has been used at a number of to optimize this technology is appropriate. Hyperbaric steam filtration
sites, including the Eurallumina plant (Sardinia, Italy; Fois et al., is an emerging technology that produces a dry, granular residue of low
2007). The process is aimed at the removal of SO2 from gas streams soda content. Such properties are beneficial to long term storage,
and the amount of residue neutralized is minor in relation to the total remediation, and utilization. Support for the development and
of amount of residue produced. Reaction of bauxite residue with SO2 is implementation of hyperbaric filtration as a potential breakthrough
therefore an example of a beneficial use for bauxite residue, but it technology is warranted.
does not appear to be a potential treatment for large quantities of A range of methods has been employed to neutralize both residue
residue. Although not believed to be in use it is worth noting that a and decant waters. The most established methods to date involve
process using SO2 to recover soda and alumina values form residue either mixing with seawater to precipitate hydroxide, carbonate
has been patented (Cresswell et al., 1987). and aluminate ions with magnesium and calcium, or with carbon
dioxide to produce calcium carbonate and calcium alumino-carbonates.
4. Conclusions Neutralization with mineral acids is less successful due to the
influence of solid hydroxides in the residue and the deleterious effects
Bauxite residue has been continuously produced since the that this method of neutralization has on the physical properties of
inception of the alumina/aluminium industry in the late nineteenth the residue.
century. We have estimated that the global inventory of bauxite The most important barrier to remediation, utilization and long
residue reached 1 billion tonnes in 1985, 93 years since the estab- term sustainability of bauxite residue management is its high
lishment of the first Bayer process plant. This inventory grew to 2 Bt alkalinity and sodicity. The alkalinity of bauxite residue is a result of
by 2000, a doubling time of only 15 years. The inventory was almost complex solid-state and solution phase interactions. A better
2.7 Bt by 2007, growing at 120 million tonnes per annum. The understanding of these interactions is required to support progress
prospect of an ever decreasing doubling time, and an inventory of 4 in the development of sustainable bauxite residue management and
Bt possibly before 2015, highlights the urgency of the need to develop re-use options, so ongoing research on the chemistry and technology
and implement improved means of storage and remediation, and to of residue neutralization is required. Based on this review of bauxite
pursue large-volume utilization options. Despite the size of the management practices a set of knowledge gaps and research priorities
industry and the residue problem, it is surprisingly difficult to are summarized in Table 5.

Table 5
Summary of the key knowledge gaps concerning management, disposal and storage practices for bauxite residue and areas of suggested research.

Knowledge gap Research project

Economic technology to reduce the alkali and soda levels of bauxite residue. Development of alternate processes, e.g. economically viable hyperbaric steam filtration.
Understanding the residue fundamentals of solid alkalinity and surface equilibria; Fundamental residue chemistry investigations of ion exchange, leaching and
ion exchange, leaching and neutralization. neutralization.
Detailed worldwide bauxite residue inventory knowledge (historical and current); Release of key residue information from industry practitioners into public domain
production, characteristics and disposal/storage practice. forums, e.g. BRaDD database.
Is dry disposal the best technical answer to residue disposal? Investigation of the relative long-term environmental impact risks of “dry” stacking,
dry cake disposal, seawater and carbonation methods.
BRDA closure technology that improves on simple capping and re-vegetation. Technology to reduce alkali and soda levels within existing BRDA locations.
Quantification and validation of carbon sequestration potential of Fully understanding long term CO2 equilibria as a function of residue composition and the
residue carbonation role of direct carbonation compared to natural absorption processes with time.
Methods for direct carbonation of residue by stack gas carbon dioxide. Development of methods for direct carbonation of residue by stack gas carbon dioxide.
44 G. Power et al. / Hydrometallurgy 108 (2011) 33–45

Acknowledgements Habashi, F., 1988. A hundred years of the Bayer Process for alumina production. In:
Boxall, L.G. (Ed.), Light Metals. TMS, Phoenix, pp. 3–11.
Haggard, N., Smith, H.D., 2002. Supernatant liquor neutralisation with seawater and Bayer
This project received funding from the Australian Government as tailings mud via deep cone thickener. In: Chandrashekar, S. (Ed.), Proceedings of the
part of the Asia-Pacific Partnership on Clean Development and 6th International Alumina Quality Workshop. AQW Inc., Brisbane, pp. 174–179.
Hamada, T., 1986. Environmental management of bauxite residue — A review. In:
Climate. The views expressed herein are not necessarily the views Wagh, A.S., Desai, P. (Eds.), Proceedings of the International Conference on Bauxite
of the Commonwealth, and the Commonwealth does not accept Tailings. The Jamaica Bauxite Institute, The University of the West Indies, Kingston,
responsibility for any information or advice contained herein. The Jamaica, pp. 109–117.
Hanahan, C., 2004. Dissolution of hydroxide minerals in the 1 M sodium acetate, pH 5,
support of the CSIRO Light Metals National Research Flagship and the extracting solution in sequential extraction schemes. Environ. Geol. 45 (6),
Parker CRC for Integrated Hydrometallurgy Solutions (established and 864–868.
supported under the Australian Government's Cooperative Research Hudson, L.K., 1987. Alumina production. Crit. Rep. Appl. Chem. 20, 11–46 (Prod. Alum.
Alumina).
Centres Program) is gratefully acknowledged. The authors gratefully
International Maritime Organization, 2005. Report of the twenty-eighth meeting of the
acknowledge Dave Pang for the development of the BRaDD interface. scientific group. Scientific Group Meeting — 28th Meeting. IMO, London, UK, p. 54.
Kainuma, A., Takahashi, M., Higuchi, T., Itoh, D., 1979. Utilization of filter
pressed bauxite residue. In: Peterson, W.S. (Ed.), Light Metals. TMS, New Orleans,
References pp. 107–127.
Khaitan, S., Dzombak, D.A., Lowry, G.V., 2009. Chemistry of the acid neutralization
Alcoa, 2001. Lessening the Impact of Bauxite Residue. Alcoa Inc.. http://www.alcoa. capacity of bauxite residues. Environ. Eng. Sci. 26 (00), 1–9.
com/global/en/environment/initiatives/dry_stacking.asp?initCountry=0. Khaitan, S., Dzombak, D.A. and Lowry, G.V., (2009). Mechanisms of neutralization of
Alcoa, 2005b. Pinjarra Refinery Long Term Residue Management Strategy. Sinclair bauxite residue by carbon dioxide. J. Environ. Eng.-ASCE. 135 (6):433-438.
Knight Merz, Perth. pp 1–1 and 13–14. Kirkpatrick, D.B., 1996. Red mud product development. In: Hale, W. (Ed.), Light Metals.
Alcoa, 2005a. Kwinana Refinery Long Term Residue Management Strategy. Sinclair TMS, Anaheim, pp. 75–80.
Knight Merz, Perth 4, 4. Klauber, C., Gräfe, M. and Power, G., to be published. Bauxite residue issues: II. Options for
Anderson, J., Smith, M., Zeiba, M., Clegg, R., Peloquin, G., Vellacott, S., 2008. residue utilization. Hydrometallurgy (2011), doi:10.1016/j.hydromet.2011.02.007.
Implementing seawater neutralisation at Gove. In: Armstrong, L. (Ed.), 8th Martinet-Catalot, V., Lamerant, J.-M., Tilmant, G., Bacou, M.-S., Ambrost, J.P., 2002.
International Alumina Quality Workshop. AQW Inc., Darwin, pp. 301–306. Bauxaline: a new product for various applications of Bayer process red mud. In:
Anon, 1982. Thixotropic Sludge Deposition esp. Red Mud: Giulini Chem GmbH. Schneider, W. (Ed.), Light Metals. TMS, Columbus, pp. 125–131.
Banerjee, S.K., 2003. Conversion of conventional wet disposal of red mud into thickened Marunczyn, M., Laros, T.J., 1992. Bauxite residue disposal at Alcoa of Australia using the
tailing disposal (TTD) at NALCO Alumina Refinery, Damanjodi. In: Crepeau, P.N. Eimco hi-density thickener. International Bauxite Tailings Workshop. Allied
(Ed.), Light Metals. TMS, Vancouver, pp. 125–132. Colloids (Australia), Perth, Western Australia, p. 32.
Baseden, S., Grey, D., 1976. Environmental study of the disposal of red mud waste. Marunczyn, M., Laros, T.J., 1993. Bauxite residue disposal at Alcoa of Australia using hi-
Marine Pollut. Bull. 7 (1), 4–7. density thickener. In: Leung, W.W.-F. (Ed.), Advances in Filtration and Separation
Bott, R., Langeloh, T., Hahn, J., 2002. Dry bauxite residue by hi-barR steam pressure Technology: System Approach to Separation and Filtration Process Equipment.
filtration. In: Chadrashekar, S. (Ed.), Proceedings of the 6th International Alumina American Filtrations & Separations Society, Chicago, pp. 180–188.
Quality Workshop. AQW Inc., Brisbane, pp. 24–32. McConchie, D., Clark, M., Davies-McConchie, F., 2002. New strategies for the
Cooling, D.J., 1989. Developments in the disposal of residue from the alumina refining management of bauxite refinery residues (red mud). In: Chandrashekar, S. (Ed.),
industry. In: Campbell, P.G. (Ed.), Light Metals. TMS, Halifax, pp. 49–54. Proceedings of the 6th International Alumina Quality Workshop. AQW Inc.,
Cooling, D.J., Glenister, D.J., 1992. Practical aspects of dry residue disposal. Light Metals. Brisbane, pp. 327–332.
TMS, pp. 25–31. Nikraz, H.R., Bodley, A.J., Cooling, D.J., Kong, P.Y.L., Soomro, M., 2007. Comparison of
Cooling, D.J., Hay, P.S., Guilfoyle, L., 2002. Carbonation of bauxite residue. In: physical properties between treated and untreated bauxite residue mud. J. Mat. Civ.
Chandrashekar, S. (Ed.), Proceedings of the 6th International Alumina Quality Eng. 19 (1), 2–9.
Workshop. AQW Inc., Brisbane, pp. 185–190. Oeberg, N.C.R., Steinlechner, E.H., 1996. Red mud and sands handling: new thoughts on
Cresswell, P.J., Grayson, I.L., Smith, A.H., 1987. Recovery of Sodium Aluminate from an old problem. In: Hale, W. (Ed.), Light Metals. TMS, Anaheim, pp. 67–73.
Bayer Process Red Mud. . US-4668485. Paradis, R.D., 1992. Disposal of Red Mud Using Wet Stacking Technology. International
Das, P., Roy, D., Brahma, R., 2003. Experience with thickened disposal of red mud. In: Bauxite Tailings Workshop, Perth, Western Australia. pp. 179.
Crepeau, P.N. (Ed.), Light Metals. TMS, Vancouver, pp. 133–135. Paradis, R.D., 1993. Application of Alcan's deep thickener technology for thickening and
Dauvin, J.-C., 2010. Towards an impact assessment of bauxite red mud waste on the clarifying. In: Leung, W.W.-F. (Ed.), Advances in Filtration and Separation
knowledge of the structure and functions of bathyal ecosystems: the example of Technology: System Approach to Separation and Filtration Process Equipment.
the Cassidaigne canyon (north-western Mediterranean Sea). Mar. Pollut. Bull. 60 American Filtration & Separations Society, Chicago, pp. 176–179.
(2), 197–206. Pashias, N., Boger, D.V., 1996. The importance of rheology in optimising a disposal
Doucet, J., 1999. Effect of sand addition on the rheological properties of red mud strategy for bauxite residue. Proceedings of the 4th International Alumina Quality
slurries. Proceedings of the 5th International Alumina Quality Workshop. AQW Inc., Workshop. AQW Inc., Darwin, pp. 507–515.
Bunbury, pp. 478–488. Peloquin, G., Simard, G., 2002. Improved thickener for red mud. In: Chandrashekar, S. (Ed.),
Emmett, R.C., Klepper, R.P., 1991. High density red mud thickeners. In: Rooy, E.L. (Ed.), Proceedings of the 6th International Alumina Quality Workshop. AQW Inc., Brisbane,
Light Metals. TMS, New Orleans, pp. 229–233. pp. 40–45.
Emmett, R.C., Laros, T.J., Paulson, K.A., 1992. Recent developments in solid liquid Pohland, H.H., Tielens, A.J., 1983. A new bayer liquor purification process. In: Adkins, E.M.
separation technology in the alumina industry. In: Cutshall, E.R. (Ed.), Light Metals. (Ed.), Light Metals. TMS, Atlanta, pp. 211–222.
TMS, San Diego, pp. 87–90. Pohland, H.H., Tielens, A.J., 1986. Design and operation of non-decanting red mud ponds
Enserink, M., 2010. After red mud flood, scientists try to halt wave of fear and rumors. in Ludwigshafen, West Germany. In: Wagh, A.S., Desai, P. (Eds.), Bauxite Tailings
Science 330, 432–433 (22 October). International Conference. The Jamaica Bauxite Institute, The University of the West
Farrow, J.B., Fawell, P.D., Johnston, R.R.M., Nguyen, T.B., Rudman, M., Simic, K., Swift, J.D., Indies, Kingston, Jamaica, p. 87.
2000. Recent developments in techniques and methodologies for improving Pohland, H., Haerter, M., Bayer, G., 1981. Thixotropic Mud, esp. Red Mud, Disposal — By
thickener performance. Chem. Eng. J. 80 (Sp. Iss. 1–3), 149–155. Mechanically Liquefying and Transferring to Dump with Embankment Contg.
Fois, E., Lallai, A., Mura, G., 2007. Sulfur dioxide absorption in a bubbling reactor with Cation-Exchange Material: Giulini Chem Gmbh (Giul).
suspensions of Bayer red mud. Industr. Eng. Chem. Res. 46 (21), 6770–6776. Roach, G.I.D., Jamieson, E., Pearson, N., Yu, A.B., 2001. Effect of particle characteristics on
Glenister, D.J. (Ed.), 1992. Conference Proceedings of an International Bauxite Tailings the solids density of Bayer mud slurries. In: Anjier, J.L. (Ed.), Light Metals. TMS, New
Workshop. Allied Colloids Pty Ltd., Perth. Orleans, pp. 51–58.
Gräfe, M. and Klauber, C., to be published. Bauxite residue issues: IV. Old obstacles and Robinsky, E.I., 1982. Thickened tailings disposal in any topography. In: Andersen, J.E.
new pathways for in situ residue bioremediation. Hydrometallurgy (2011), (Ed.), Light Metals. TMS, Dallas, pp. 239–248.
doi:10.1016/j.hydromet.2011.02.005. Rosenberg, S.P., Wilson, D.J., Heath, C.A., 2004. Processes for the Causticisation of Bayer
Gräfe, M., Power, G., Klauber, C., 2009. The Asia-Pacific partnership: an important new Liquors in an Alumina Refinery. Worsley Alumina Pty Ltd.. US 6676910 B1.
initiative for a sustainable alumina industry. In: Bearne, G. (Ed.), Light Metals. TMS, Roskill, 2008. The Economics of Bauxite & Alumina, 7th Ed. Roskill Information Services
San Francisco, pp. 5–10. Ltd, London, UK, p. 48.
Gräfe, M., Klauber, C., Pang, D., 2010. BRaDD: Bauxite Residue and Disposal Database. . Shah, R.P., Gararia, S.N., 1995. Upgradation of alumina refinery at Hindalco, Renukoot
http://www.csiro.au/products/Bauxite-residue-database.html. (India). In: Evans, J. (Ed.), Light Metals. TMS, Las Vegas, pp. 25–29.
Gräfe, M., Power, G. and Klauber, C., to be published. Bauxite residue issues: III. Simmonds, M., Hurst, P., Wilkinson, M.B., Reddy, S., Khambaty, S., 2003. Amine based
Alkalinity and associated chemistry. Hydrometallurgy (2011), doi:10.1016/j. CO2 capture from gas turbine. In: Klara, S. (Ed.), Second Annual Conference on
hydromet.2011.02.004. Carbon Sequestration. USDOE, Alexandria, VA, pp. 1–10.
Green, M., Boger, D., 1997. Yielding of suspensions in compression. Industr. Eng. Chem. Smith, P.G., Pennifold, R.M., Davies, M.G., Jamieson, E.J., 2003. Reactions of carbon
Res. 36 (11), 4984–4992. dioxide with tri-calcium aluminate. In: Young, C., et al. (Ed.), Fifth International
Guilfoyle, L., Hay, P., Cooling, D., 2005. Use of flue gas for carbonation of bauxite residue. Symposium on Hydrometallurgy. TMS, Vancouver, pp. 1705–1715.
In: McKinnon, A. (Ed.), Proceedings of the 7th International Alumina Quality Sofra, F., Boger, D., 2002. Environmental rheology for waste minimisation in the
Workshop. AQW Inc., Perth, pp. 218–220. minerals industry. Chem. Eng. J. 86 (3), 319–330.
G. Power et al. / Hydrometallurgy 108 (2011) 33–45 45

Solymar, K., Ferenczi, T., Papanastassiou, D., 2002. Digestion alternatives of the Greek Varnavas, S., Ferentinos, G., Collins, M., 1986. Dispersion of bauxitic red mud in the Gulf-
diasporic bauxite. In: Schneider, W. (Ed.), Light Metals. TMS, Seattle, pp. 75–81. of-Corinth, Greece. Mar. Geol. 70 (3–4), 211–222.
Steinlechner, E., Oeberg, N., Kern, R., 1996. Red mud, a challenge for filtration. Versiani, F., 1983. Neutralization of red mud by boiler stack gases. In: Adkins, E.M. (Ed.),
Proceedings of the 4th International Alumina Quality Workshop. AQW Inc., Darwin, Light Metals. TMS, Atlanta, pp. 337–343.
pp. 251–261. Wagh, A.S., Desai, P. (Eds.), 1986. Proceedings of an International Conference on Bauxite
Sturt, A., 2008. Effect on aluminium solubility when acid is used to neutralise residue. Tailings. The Jamaica Bauxite Institute, The University of the West Indies, Kingston,
In: Armstrong, L. (Ed.), Proceedings of the 8th International Alumina Quality Jamaica.
Workshop. AQW Inc., Darwin, pp. 93–95. Whittington, B., 1996. The chemistry of CaO and Ca(OH)2 relating to the Bayer process.
Thomas, G.A., Allen, D.G., Wyrwoll, K.-H., Cooling, D., Glenister, D., 2002. Capacity of clay Hydrometallurgy 43 (1–3), 13–35.
seals to retain residue leachate. In: Chandrashekar, S. (Ed.), Proceedings of the 6th Yamada, K., Fukunaga, T., Harato, T., 1979a. Process of SO2 removal from waste gas by
International Alumina Quality Workshop. AQW Inc., Brisbane, pp. 233–239. red mud. In: Peterson, W.S. (Ed.), 108th AIME Annual Meeting. : Light Metals. The
Tillotson, S., 2006. Phosphate removal: an alternative to chemical dosing. Filtr. Sep. 43 Metallurgical Society of AIME, New Orleans, Louisiana, pp. 67–79.
(5), 10–12. Yamada, K., Harato, T., Shiozaki, Y., 1979b. Removing Sulphur Oxide(s) from Exhaust
U.S. Geological Survey, 2008. Bauxite and alumina statistics and information. In: Kelly, Gas with Red Mud Slurry — Giving Efficient Removal and Use of Soda Values
D.T., Matos, G.R. (Eds.), Historical Statistics for Mineral and Material Commodities without Scaling. Sumitomo Aluminium Smelting: Sumitomo Chem Ind Kk.
in the United States. FR2418019-A1.
United Nations Industrial Development Organization, 1985. Environmental Aspects of
Alumina Production. UNEP, Nairobi.

You might also like