Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Radiohead
Victoria Malawey
Macalaster College
However you try to describe it, Radiohead makes sense almost im-
mediately—musically, despite complex time signatures, and emo-
tionally, even though the words are often obscure and drenched in
sound.
—George A. Reisch, “Is Radiohead the Pink Floyd of
the Twenty-First Century?”
I
ncorporating popular music in ear-training and music theory classes
is sensible and advantageous. It allows us to supplement tradition-
al examples from the canon, resulting in greater musical diversity,
which keeps classes from becoming predictable and curricula from be-
coming static. In addition, it brings out similarities in musical structure
among seemingly diverse styles. Finally, bringing “real music” into aural
skills training gets away from (or at least can supplement) the atomistic,
non-contextual drilling lamented by some ear-training experts.1
English band Radiohead has been recording high-quality music
for decades, offering eight full-length albums from which to choose
examples appropriate for class. Guy Capuzzo points out that several
Radiohead songs incorporate a number of desirable musical features,
worthy of our study—including, but not limited to, modal mixture and
harmonic structures guided by voice-leading connections by common
tone.2 Many of Radiohead’s songs conform to these and other prin-
1
Gary Karpinski argues for using aural skills training with “real music” as
opposed to instructor-created materials, and furthermore advocates for greater
contextual skills (dictation and sight singing) as opposed to “atomistic skills
such as identifying and singing intervals and chord qualities and inversions”
(“Lessons from the Past: Music Theory Pedagogy and the Future,” Music Theory
Online 6, no. 3 (2000), ¶ 5.4–5.5).
2
Guy Capuzzo, “Neo-Riemannian Theory and the Analysis of Pop-Rock
Music,” Music Theory Spectrum 26, no. 2 (Fall 2004): 186.
28 Indiana Theory Review Vol. 30 No. 2
ciples of common practice Western tonal music. In addition, much
of Radiohead’s music is at once widely accessible yet also surprising-
ly complex in terms of its harmonic content, metric structure, lyrical
content, and voice leading, making their songs ideal for classroom use.
Furthermore, scholars are already analyzing some of Radiohead’s songs
compellingly in scholarly monographs and journal articles (many rel-
evant sources are cited along with the appropriate songs in the course of
this article), which work well as follow-up reading assignments to com-
plement ear-training exercises done in class. In addition, Radiohead’s
songs are readily available for free streaming online via services such
as Rdio (www.rdio.com), Grooveshark (grooveshark.com), and Spotify
(www.spotify.com). This essay seeks to summarize Radiohead examples
appropriate for ear-training activities and to argue for the inclusion of
Radiohead’s music in teaching aural skills and music theory.
This study is a contribution to a small, but useful body of work
by others who have sought out pedagogical examples from popular
music. In an article published in 1990, Justin London offers an analysis
that relates harmonic content with the meaning of the lyrics in Bruce
Springsteen’s “One Step Up” from his 1987 album Tunnel of Love, which
can be used in theory and ear-training classes.3 He argues that examples
from popular music are advantageous because “they provide a means
of connecting what is taught in class with students’ ‘real world’ musical
experiences.”4 E. Michael Harrington presents numerous songs popular
in the late 1980s and early ’90s that use common chord progressions,
extended tertian chords, modulation schemes unique to rock music, and
composite meters, showing the variety of applications such music has
in teaching theory.5 More recently, Stuart Folse analyzes Shania Twain’s
“You’re Still the One” and The Eagles’ “New Kid in Town,” and argues
that incorporating pop music in musicianship classes not only reflects
the changing focuses of academic institutions (growing numbers of pro-
grams in jazz and commercial music) but also takes advantage of stu-
dents’ familiarity with pop songs.6 Similarly, Pandel Collaros identifies
3
Justin London, “‘One Step Up’: A Lesson from Pop Music,” Journal of
Music Theory Pedagogy 4, no. 1 (Spring 1990): 111–14.
4
Ibid., 111.
5
E. Michael Harrington, “Rock Music as a Resource in Harmonic,
Melodic and Metric Dictation,” College Music Symposium 31 (1991): 27–35.
6
Stuart Folse, “Popular Music as a Pedagogical Resource for Musicianship:
Contextual Listening, Prolongations, Mediant Relationships, and Musical
Form,” Journal of Music Theory Pedagogy 18 (2004): 65–79.
Malawey, Ear Training with the Music of Radiohead 29
pedagogical examples from the Beatles’ repertoire.7 My study differs
somewhat from the work done by all of these authors because I am
focused primarily on generating aural skills activities (as opposed to
“written” analysis activities), although a few examples for the aural anal-
ysis of form and voice leading are included.
The examples offered in this essay are designed for a variety of
undergraduate levels. Activities such as identification of intervals, scale
type, and meter (simple vs. compound) are appropriate for beginners in
fundamentals classes. As students learn about diatonic harmony, they
can take advantage of continued interval identification, chord quality
identification, and melodic dictation. As students advance into chro-
matic harmony, ample chord function identification and longer aural
analysis activities will challenge them. And finally, there are several ac-
tivities that can enhance the study of post-tonal theory, such as scale
identification (octatonic scales) and meter identification (composite
meters).
In what follows, I will describe different types of ear-training ac-
tivities appropriate for this repertory, highlight several representative
examples, and suggest ways the activities cultivate essential aural skills. I
will demonstrate the benefits of using large-scale aural analysis exercis-
es with Radiohead’s “Exit Music (for a Film),” “You and Whose Army?”
“A Wolf at the Door,” “Stop Whispering,” “High and Dry,” “I Might Be
Wrong,” and “A Punch Up at a Wedding.” Finally, I will suggest pos-
sibilities for sequencing these activities within a multi-semester music
theory curriculum.
Interval Identification
7
Pandel Collaros, “The Music of the Beatles in Undergraduate Music
Theory Instruction,” Indiana Theory Review 21 (Fall–Spring 2000): 53–78.
8
This and all of the songs presented in this essay may be streamed online
for free through Rdio (www.rdio.com), Grooveshark (grooveshark.com), or
Spotify (www.spotify.com).
30 Indiana Theory Review Vol. 30 No. 2
Figure 1. Examples for Interval Identification.
Song /Album Time Intervals
In Limbo introduction M2
Kid A
The National Anthem introduction M3 vs. m3,
Kid A M2
How to Disappear Completely 4:38–4:53 m3
Kid A
You and Whose Army? 2:01 m3
Amnesiac
Morning Bell/Amnesiac 0:00 and 0:11 m3, P1
Amnesiac
Prove Yourself 0:15, 0:21 m3, P5
Pablo Honey (and 0:26)
Dollars & Cents 4:15–4:40 M3 vs. m3
Amnesiac
Like Spinning Plates 2:33–2:39 P4
Amnesiac
2+2=5 0:42–0:49 P4, P5
Hail to the Thief
Fake Plastic Trees 0:16 P4, P8
The Bends
Just 0:44–0:55 Tritone
The Bends
Lurgee 0:55 P5
Pablo Honey
Ripcord 0:42–0:50 P5, P1
Pablo Honey
Feral 0:00–0:27 P5, P1
The King of Limbs
Sit Down, Stand Up throughout; “sit down” at 0:34, m6, m2,
Hail to the Thief c.f. “the raindrops” at 3:03 P4/P5
Nice Dream 0:22–0:40 m6
The Bends
Vegetable 0:19 M6
Pablo Honey
High and Dry 1:09–1:25 M6
The Bends
My Iron Lung 0:54–1:00 M6
The Bends
Karma Police 2:37–3:36 M6
OK Computer
Let Down 2:28–2:48 M7
OK Computer
Bulletproof 1:44–2:06 P8
The Bends
Malawey, Ear Training with the Music of Radiohead 31
Questions
What melodic interval is prominent in this passage?
What melodic interval occurs on “(re)lease me”? What melodic interval occurs on the first
statement of “morning bell”?
What are the various melodic intervals sung on the lyrics “off dead”?
What is the descending melodic interval sung on “self (you) do” and “self (just) you”?
What two melodic intervals occur in the song’s recurring three-note motive? At 0:34, what
melodic interval is sung on "sit down"? How does this contrast with harmonic intervals at 3:03?
What is the ascending melodic interval that occurs on “brother” and “protect me”?
What ascending melodic interval is sung on “me high” and “me dry”?
9
Sasha Frere-Jones, “Fine Tuning,” New Yorker 82, no. 19 (26 June 2006):
86–7.
10
Brad Osborn, “Understanding Through-Composition in Post-Rock,
Math-Metal, and other Post-Millennial Rock Genres,” Music Theory Online 17,
no. 3 (October 2011)
http://www.mtosmt.org/issues/mto.11.17.3/mto.11.17.3.osborn.html, ¶ 33.
11
Frank Samarotto, “The Trope of Expectancy/Infinity in the Music of
the Beatles and Others,” presented at the 35th Annual Meeting for the Society
for Music Theory (New Orleans, La., 2 November 2012).
Malawey, Ear Training with the Music of Radiohead 33
drops” to create a sense of “infinity” in the closing section (3:03–4:20)
of the song. As students identify intervals in this song, they can relate
them to this particular trope, or perhaps devise their own tropes based
on how they experience changing states in the song.
Instrumental riffs are also useful for identifying prominent inter-
vals. Dai Griffiths identifies “The National Anthem” as one of three “os-
tinato songs” appearing on Kid A and Amnesiac.12 As students listen to
this song, they can be asked to identify three distinct melodic intervals
used in the bass guitar riff, which are M3 (F # to D), m3 (F n to D), and
M2 (E to D). Marianne Tatom Letts describes the riff as a “collaps-
ing of intervals” that “underscores the claustrophobic feel of the lyrics,”
which deal with themes of alienation and despair.13 Because the riff is
repeated many times, students will have multiple chances to internalize
the series of intervals. Furthermore, since the intervals (m3, M2, m2) all
share the same bottom note (D), which acts as a common tone among
them, students may more easily compare the sound of these smaller
intervals, which beginning students sometimes mistake for each other.
Other examples using instrumental cues shown in Figure 1 include
“Dollars & Cents,” “How to Disappear Completely,” “In Limbo,”
“Feral,” “Sit Down, Stand Up,” and “Let Down,” all of which rely on
repetition to allow students to more easily extrapolate and identify the
given intervals contextually.
Scale type identification can be useful from the novice level (in
which students identify differences among major and the three minor
scales) to more advanced levels (in which students identify modal and
octatonic scales). Examples for scale type identification appear in Figure
2. All of the examples are largely unembellished or pure, which make
them especially useful for ear training. In Figure 2, I have classified each
example into one of three primary types, which may affect the level
of difficulty of the activity: songs that use (1) a general key collection
12
Dai Griffiths, “Public Schoolboy Music: Debating Radiohead,” in
The Music and Art of Radiohead, ed. Joseph Tate (Burlington, Vermont and
Aldershot, England: Ashgate, 2005), 164.
13
Marianne Tatom Letts, Radiohead and the Resistant Concept Album:
How to Disappear Completely (Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 2010),
66.
34 Indiana Theory Review Vol. 30 No. 2
without explicit presentation of a sequential scale or scale fragment; (2)
prominent stepwise scale fragment(s), as well as a general unordered
diatonic collection; and (3) prominent stepwise scale fragments or a
complete scale exclusively.
Just as repetition can make for easier contextual identification of
intervals, it can also be an asset for aural scale identification. “I Might
Be Wrong” (0:17–3:49) uses a repeating riff that emphasizes 1̂ and 3̂,
which define the mode as minor. “Stop Whispering” features a de-
scending fragment of the major scale (1̂–7̂–6̂ –5̂), which is stated twice
at the beginning of the verses. Similarly, the vocal line of the verses
of “I Can’t” states major scale fragments 6̂ –7̂ – 1̂ and 6̂ –5̂–4̂ –3̂ –2̂ twice.
“Thinking About You” emphasizes the stepwise gesture 1̂ –2̂ – 3̂, which
recurs throughout the song’s melody and defines the mode as major.
“There There” gradually introduces the general minor collection with
repeated emphasis on tonic anchors 1̂, 3̂, and 5̂. “I Will” provides an
interesting example of melodic minor. Once students are able to infer
tonic as C # and the overall mode as minor in “I Will,” they may listen
to the vocal part beginning at 1:26, which repeats an ascending step-
wise gesture that uses the raised forms of 6̂ and 7̂, the defining features
of melodic minor. All of these are effective examples, particularly for
beginning students, because they emphasize tonal anchors (1̂ , 3̂ , and/or
5̂) that define the mode as major or minor through repetition.
Repetition of scalar fragments also makes for effective identifica-
tion of modes other than major and minor. For example, “Morning Mr.
Magpie” (0:00–2:04) repeats the mixolydian scalar fragment 5̂–6̂–7̂– 5̂
in the guitar while the lead vocal emphasizes 1̂ and 5̂. In “A Punch Up at
a Wedding,” E is established as tonic through repetition and emphasis
in the bass part, and in the passage beginning at 1:16, Yorke sings an as-
cending stepwise fragment of E dorian (4̂ –5̂ –6̂ –7̂ – 1̂) on “nothing’s ever
good enough for you” and “you’ve come here just to start a fight.” Other
songs reveal modal properties more gradually. “Hunting Bears,” a short
instrumental track from Amnesiac, demonstrates a gradual presentation
of D dorian—at first, emphasizing 4̂, 5̂, 7̂, and 1̂ of the scale, at 0:35 in-
troducing 3̂, and finally at 1:33 articulating the characteristic raised 6̂ to
confirm the mode as dorian. Similarly, the modal content of “Separator”
appears gradually: at the beginning of the song, repeating B bs establish
tonic, Yorke’s melody reaches D (3̂) at 0:27, and soon after at 0:32 Yorke
sings A b (b 7̂ ), which defines the mode as mixolydian.
Other examples reveal their modal properties primarily through
harmonic content. “Lucky,” “15 Step,” and “Lotus Flower,” all examples
in the dorian mode, feature the major subdominant (IV) and minor
Malawey, Ear Training with the Music of Radiohead 35
Figure 2 . Examples for Scale Type Identification
Song /Album Time Scale Type Classification
Stop Whispering 0:15, 1:19 major (1̂ 7̂ 6̂ 5̂ repeated at Type 2
Pablo Honey beginning of each verse)
Thinking About You throughout major (emphasizes 1̂ 2̂ 3̂) Type 2
Pablo Honey
I Can’t 0:17–0:36 major (6̂ 7̂ 1̂, 6̂ 5̂ 4̂ 3̂ 2̂ at Type 2
Pablo Honey beginning of verses)
I Might Be Wrong 0:17–3:49 minor (emphasizes minor Type 1
Amnesiac tonic triad)
There There 0:00–1:15 natural minor Type 1
Hail to the Thief
I Will 1:26 melodic minor (1̂ 5̂ 6̂ 7̂ 1̂ Type 2
Hail to the Thief sung on “eyes, eyes, eyes”)
15 Step 0:41–1:38 dorian Type 1
In Rainbows
Lucky 1:10 dorian Type 1
OK Computer
Hunting Bears throughout dorian Type 1
Amnesiac
A Punch Up at a Wedding 1:16–1:51 dorian (fragment: 4̂ 5̂ 6̂ 7̂ 1̂) Type 2
Hail to the Thief
Lotus Flower 0:58–2:00, dorian Type 1
The King of Limbs 2:32–3:20
Morning Mr. Magpie 0:00–2:04 mixolydian Type 2
The King of Limbs
Give Up the Ghost throughout mixolydian Type 1
The King of Limbs
Separator 0:00–2:57 mixolydian Type 1
The King of Limbs
tonic (i) chords prominently, which are hallmarks of their modal iden-
tity. Likewise, “Give Up the Ghost” alternates D major (I) and C major
(bVII), a typical mixolydian chord structure in rock music.
36 Indiana Theory Review Vol. 30 No. 2
Very few rock bands use the octatonic scale, and consequently
Radiohead’s use of the scale within the genre of rock is exceptional. The
most explicit and unambiguous use of the octatonic scale can be found
in “Just,” which scholar Paul Lansky describes as “complex, pushing tra-
ditional tonal functional relations to the edge of a cliff.”14 Because of
its straightforward presentation, “Just” functions well alongside more
standard examples from the twentieth-century canon for the introduc-
tion of the octatonic scale in post-tonal theory classes. “These Are My
Twisted Words” (0:08–1:04) repeats a descending stepwise octatonic
fragment (G–F # –E–E b–D b–C) over a static C major harmony. The
song as a whole is tonal because it has a clear pitch center (C), but
its tertian-based harmonies reflect some aspects of the octatonic scale,
such as extensive mode mixture (play with E and E b, both pitches in
the OCT01 collection), use of D b (b2̂) in the repeating bass guitar riff,
and occasional appearances of the D major triad at 2:05, 2:50, 3:10, and
4:26, which subtly hearkens back to the F # from the OCT01 collection.
In addition, octatonic subsets in “The National Anthem” and
“Morning Mr. Magpie” result from the use of mode mixture within an
otherwise tonal context. Osborn identifies such an octatonic passage
in the ondes Martenot melody in “The National Anthem” at 1:57.15
Hearing a tonic of D, the melody eerily hovers around 5̂ (A), embel-
lished by b 6̂ (B b), 4̂ (G), and # 3̂ (F # ) to create a subset of the octatonic
collection. A vocal melody using a similar octatonic subset occurs in
“Morning Mr. Magpie” (2:04–2:14) with a tonic of C.
Meter Identification
14
Paul Lansky, “My Radiohead Adventure,” in The Music and Art of
Radiohead, ed. Joseph Tate, 168–76 (Burlington, Vermont and Aldershot,
England: Ashgate, 2005), 171.
15
Brad Osborn, “Kid Algebra: Radiohead’s Euclidean and Maximally
Even Grooves,” presented at the 35th Annual Meeting for the Society for
Music Theory (New Orleans, La., 2 November 2012).
16
Letts characterizes the meter in “How to Disappear Completely” as
somewhat ambiguous. She writes, “The bass line presents a ‘two against three’
Malawey, Ear Training with the Music of Radiohead 37
Figure 3. Examples for Meter Identification
Song /Album Time Meter Type
Paranoid Android 0:00–2:09, simple quadruple
OK Computer 3:36–5:40
I Might Be Wrong throughout simple quadruple
Amnesiac
Nice Dream throughout compound quadruple
The Bends
Sulk throughout compound quadruple
The Bends
Subterranean Homesick Alien throughout compound quadruple
OK Computer
How to Disappear Completely throughout compound quadruple
Kid A
Morning Bell throughout composite (in 5)
Kid A
Everything In Its Right Place throughout composite (in 5)
Kid A
15 Step throughout composite (in 5)
In Rainbows
These Are My Twisted Words 1:42 composite (in 5)
(single)
Paranoid Android 2:09, 3:16 composite (in 7)
OK Computer
2+2=5 0:00–1:22 composite (in 7)
Hail to the Theif
feel (dotted quarter notes that can be heard in 6/8 rather than in 3/4 meter of
the vocal line) against the ‘fast three’ feel (3/4) of the guitar’s rhythmic pattern,
which also contribute to the feeling of being out of time” (Resistant Concept
Album, 75). I do not hear this song as being “out of time”; on the contrary, I hear
it as a fairly clear example of compound meter. This type of texture, with 2:3
cross rhythms within an overarching compound meter, seems to be common
in popular music spanning various genres. Examples of this phenomenon
include Duncan Sheik’s “Hymn” (2006), Audrye Sessions’ “Awake” (2009),
Atlas Sound’s “Criminals” (2009), Kelly Clarkson’s “Breakaway” (2004), Dave
Matthews’ “Stay or Leave” (2003), John Mayer’s “Daughters” (2003), Namoli
Brennet’s “Boy in a Dress” (2002), and Sinead Lohan’s “No Mermaid” (1998),
to name a few.
38 Indiana Theory Review Vol. 30 No. 2
Biographer James Doheny comments on the metric differences between
the two versions of “Morning Bell”:
Not only does the Kid A version of “Morning Bell” feature a local com-
posite meter of 3+2, but what is even more compelling about this song
is how larger levels of meter are similarly asymmetrical. Nested, hierar-
chical levels of composite meter, which mirror each other, are unique to
Radiohead. The hypermeter, as articulated through repeating harmonic
patterns, is also 3+2 in this song. There are three repetitions of a two-bar
oscillation of A minor and C # minor followed by two repetitions of
another 2-bar oscillation of G major and D major. Figure 4 illustrates
the song’s asymmetrical hypermeter as articulated by harmony as it
occurs in its first iteration (0:08–0:29); this harmonic structure is re-
peated throughout the song.
• 3 2 •
• 0:08 0:10 0:12 0:14 0:17 0:19 0:21 0:23 0:25 0:27 •
Am C # m Am C # m Am C # m GM DM GM DM
17
James Doheny, Radiohead Back to Save the Universe: The Stories Behind
Every Song (New York: Thunder’s Mouth Press, 2002), 124.
18
Letts, Resistant Concept Album, 147.
Malawey, Ear Training with the Music of Radiohead 39
timbre, and dynamics. The version that appeared on Amnesiac is best
characterized as a slow simple quadruple.
Chord Identification
19
Jon Pareles, “Recordings,” review of Radiohead Amnesiac, Rolling Stone
no. 871 (21 June 2001): 74–77.
40 Indiana Theory Review Vol. 30 No. 2
Figure 5. Examples for Chord Quality Identification
Song /Album Time Chord Quality
Faust Arp 0:02 and 0:11 minor and parallel major
In Rainbows (Bm, BM)
Dollars & Cents 4:15–4:40 major and parallel minor
Amnesiac (BM, Bm)
You 0:00 Mm7 (E7)
Pablo Honey
Bullet Proof . . . I Wish I Was 0:14 mm7 (Am7),
The Bends MM7 (CM7)
Sail to the Moon 0:00 MM7 (AM7)
Hail to the Thief
20
Nadine Hubbs, “The Imagination of Pop-Rock Criticism,” in Expression
in Pop-Rock Music: Critical and Analytical Essays, 2nd ed., ed. Walter Everett,
(New York and London: Routledge, 2008), 226.
21
George A. Reisch, “Is Radiohead the Pink Floyd of the Twenty-First
Century?” in Radiohead and Philosophy: Fitter Happier More Deductive, ed.
Brandon W. Forbes and George A. Reisch (Chicago and LaSalle, Ill.: Open
Court, 2009), 7.
42 Indiana Theory Review Vol. 30 No. 2
“No Surprises” and other songs by Radiohead—with themes ranging
from a critique of political and economic societal structures, self-re-
flection and self-awareness, to themes of isolation, alienation, love, and
loss—may resonate with some traditional college-age students (18–22
years old), just as they are coming of age, experiencing a period of self-
discovery, and developing social awareness.
Music by other rock bands sometimes uses borrowed predominant
chords, but very few rock songs feature linear chromatic chords most
often associated with late nineteenth-century Romantic art music, such
as the augmented sixth and Neapolitan, which are present in several of
Radiohead’s songs. Thus Radiohead’s music provides instructors with
a unique opportunity to explore such chromatic chords in the genre of
mainstream rock music. “A Wolf at the Door” features the Neapolitan
sixth chord in D minor. This example is effective because the N6 is
situated in between tonic and dominant harmony, and the chords are
arpeggiated so students can latch onto individual scale degrees, such as
b2, which marks the N6. The Neapolitan is also featured at the end of
“Subterranean Homesick Alien.” The harmonic syntax in this excerpt is
unusual (I–v–N–V), but the last three chords of the progression provide
harmonic support for a loosely constructed sequence in the lead guitar
melody, transcribed in Example 1. This chromatic sequence preserves
rhythm and general melodic contour. Although the minor dominant
triad is atypical, the motion from the Neapolitan to the major dominant
triad is normative. The inflection of Neapolitan harmony in this song
might be seen as a nod to the otherworldly, which relates loosely to the
“aliens [that] hover” in the song’s lyrics.
& 68 n œ . œ œ œ bœ bœ œ bœ
œ. œ ˙. ˙.
GM: v N V
22
In either interpretation, the second chord (B major) provides consonant
support for a passing F-sharp (from G to E) in Yorke’s lead vocal melody in
the verses.
23
Alex Ross, “The Searchers: Radiohead’s Unquiet Revolution,” New
Yorker (20 and 27 August 2001): 112–23.
24
Doheny, Back to Save the Universe,18. He argues also that the repeat-
ing progression “provides a steady platform on which the drama of the song is
played out by its other constituent elements: lyrics, melody, intonation, perfor-
mance, dynamics and orchestration, etc.” (15). Doheny describes this progres-
sion further as a “passacaglia—the chord pattern itself with those major/minor
chord shifts, overlapping of lyrical and musical phrases to dramatic effect, etc.”
(18).
25
Capuzzo, “Neo-Riemannian Theory,” 186–7.
44 Indiana Theory Review Vol. 30 No. 2
the chords and their relationship to meanings of the lyrics. Capuzzo
argues that the repeating chord progression “creat[es] a musical analog
to the song’s obsessive lyrics” and further identifies an ascending chro-
matic line (5̂– # 5̂– 6̂ or D–D # –E) “that ‘creeps’ up” and then retreats back
down by step to b 6̂ (E b ) to invoke “self-pity” implied by the lyrics.26
Melodic Dictation
26
Ibid., 186.
27
Potter, “Successful Dictation Strategies,” 66.
Malawey, Ear Training with the Music of Radiohead 45
Answer Key:
## j j j j j œ. Œ. ‰ j j œ œ. Œ. ‰ œ œ œ œ œ. Œ. Œ
Cadence: HC
8 œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ Jœ
V # 12 œ œ œ J J J J
They love me like I was a brother They pro-tect me Listen to me
# # # 12
Cadence: ___
& # 8 Œ.
#œ.
You'll
##
Answer Key: Cadence: HC
& # # 12
8 Œ. œ j ˙. œ. œ œ œ ˙. Ó.
#œ. œ. œ. œ. #œ. œ. œ. œ. œ. œ. œ
You'll go to hell for what your dir-ty mind is think - - - ing
V 44 œ œ
Rows I
KEY: ___
j œ œ œ œ œ œ œ œ ‰ œj œ œ œ œ œ œ œ
Answer Key:
V 44 œ œ œ œ ‰ œ œ œ œ
Rows of houses all bear-ing down on me I can feel their blue hands touch-ing me
KEY: Am
4
&b 4 ˙
Lyrics: I go forwards, you go backwards
And somewhere we will meet
Answer Key:
& b 44 ˙ ˙ ˙ ˙ ˙ ˙ ˙ œ ‰œ
j ˙ ˙ ˙ ˙ w ˙.
Œ
I go for-wards, you go back - wards and some-where we will meet
46 Indiana Theory Review Vol. 30 No. 2
Example 6. Melodic Dictation, “Optimistic,” 0:00–0:26
#
& # 44 ..
# 4
Answer Key:
& # 4˙ œ . œj ˙ Ó n˙ œ . # œj ˙ Ó ..
#
& 68 n œ .
Cadence: ___
#
Answer Key:
& 68 n œ .
Cadence: HC
œ œ œ bœ œ. bœ œ bœ
œ ˙. ˙.
As with any dictation activity, the instructor can adjust the amount
of given information from class to class, or even individual to individual
within a single class, depending on ability level. Karpinski encourages
the practice of giving students only the tonic and the beat unit before
beginning a dictation so that they have to determine the meter, mode,
starting pitch, and other essential musical information.28 All of the tem-
plates above may be modified to give as much or little musical informa-
tion as desired.
Karpinski offers a formula for generating the number of hearings
appropriate for melodic dictation based on the number of memorable
chunks the melody contains: “To calculate an appropriate number of
playings for a dictation, divide the number of chunks it contains by the
limit of the listener’s short term memory (in chunks) and add one extra
playing.”29 Following this model, Figure 7 suggests the number of hear-
ings appropriate for each example.
28
Karpsinki, Aural Skills Acquisition, 99.
29
Ibid.
Malawey, Ear Training with the Music of Radiohead 47
Figure 7. Suggested Number of Hearings for Melodic Dictations
Number of Number of
Chunks / 2 Hearings
Example 2 3/2 +1= 2 or 3
Example 3 4/2 +1= 3
Example 4 4/2 +1= 3
Example 5 3/2 +1= 2 or 3
Example 6 2/2 +1= 2
Example 7 3/2 +1= 2 or 3
Aural Analysis
30
London describes “applied ear-training” as a pedagogical activity where
students notate recorded music by ear and identify prominent harmonic pro-
gressions (“One Step Up,” 114n3).
31
See, for example, Hubbs, 215–37; Letts; and Osborn, “Understanding
Through-Composition,” ¶ 33–35.
48 Indiana Theory Review Vol. 30 No. 2
Aural analysis allows students at various skill levels to be challenged
through multiple, layered tasks involving different musical parameters.
In this type of exercise, all students need not complete all tasks, but
those looking for additional challenges will not be disappointed. This
type of exercise is also flexible; instructors can cater questions to suit
the topic at hand or whatever problem areas students need to practice
most. The ultimate goal of any ear-training program is to have students
successfully convert sound into notation and notation into sound, to
draw explicit connections between what we teach in music theory and
how we train their ears, or between what Michael Rogers calls “Mind
Training” and “Ear Training.”32 Aural analysis makes explicit these con-
nections.
For this activity, students are given a worksheet, such as the one
shown in Example 8, which asks questions about an excerpt of “Exit
Music (for a Film).” Students may be given a number of different things
to complete as they listen to the example. First, they may transcribe
the pitches and rhythm of the vocal line (lyrics are provided so that
students can follow along). Second, they may notate the bass line and
determine the key and harmonic function of the chords in the passage.
Third, students may answer additional questions about the passage
regarding melodic sequence, chromatic chord function, and different
harmonizations of scale-degree 5̂. When I have used this example in
classes previously, sometimes I give students a choice as to what they
should focus on first, and other times I instruct them specifically as to
what to focus on (melodic dictation in some cases, harmonic function
in others). Because this activity is more involved than a simple melodic
or harmonic dictation, it may require more than four hearings or addi-
tional time between hearings to complete a set of given tasks. Adapting
Karpinski’s model for determining the number of hearings based on
the number of chunks, it would be reasonable to play this example 5 or
6 times.33
32
Michael R. Rogers, Teaching Approaches to Music Theory: An Overview
of Pedagogical Philosophies (Carbondale and Edwardsville: Southern Illinois
University Press, 1984), 8.
33
Ibid., 99. This excerpt can be divided into 9 discernable chunks.
Following Karpinski’s formula: (9 / 2) + 1 = 5.5, five or six hearings would be
appropriate.
Malawey, Ear Training with the Music of Radiohead 49
Example 8. Aural Analysis, “Exit Music (for a Film),” 2:50–3:50
Worksheet:
Given the pre-formatted staff, provide the following upon listening to the
excerpt several times:
• Pitches, with correct rhythm, of the vocal line (lyrics are given below to
help you follow along)
• The bass notes, written in whole notes, on the bottom staff
• The implied key of the passage
• Roman numerals beneath the staff, summarizing the harmonic functions
you hear
• Corresponding lead-sheet symbols above the staff
Lyrics:
“You can laugh a spineless laugh
we hope your rules and wisdom will choke you
Now we are one in everlasting peace
we hope that you choke/ that you choke”
Dictation Answer:
34
Hubbs, “Imagination of Pop-Rock Criticism,” 226–9.
Malawey, Ear Training with the Music of Radiohead 51
A and B both) the vocal melody had traced a stepwise descent, that
of section C is characterized at the surface by large leaps downward
and upward. But just beyond the surface, this vocal line too can be
seen as a stepwise ascent, only now proceeding on two distinct levels
that descend in parallel sixths. It is, in other words, a polyphonic
(or compound) melody: a single line implying two distinct voices.35
The song lyrics are particularly dark and invoke ideas of lovers
secretly escaping (“today we escape”), codependence (“I can’t do this
alone” and “now we are one”), and murder (“we hope that you choke”).
The lyrics of the first half of the bridge section address the lovers’
unnamed antagonist (“You can laugh a spineless laugh; we hope your
wisdom and rules choke you”), which corresponds with the melodic se-
quence that implies compound melody. Hubbs argues that as the lyrics
shift (“now we are one in everlasting peace”), the coming together of
the voices implied by compound melody musically depicts the theme of
coming together in the lyrics.36
As shown in mm. 8–12 in the Example 8 Answer Key, Yorke’s
vocal melody lingers on F # 4, which functions as the climatic apex of the
song, and this pitch is re-harmonized in five different ways (over F # 7 in
m. 8, B minor in m. 9, F # major in m. 10, D major in m. 11, and Eadd9
as a suspension in m. 12). Instructors could also emphasize the un-
derlying voice-leading structure, a descending 5-line that occurs in the
last half of this excerpt (a possible voice-leading reduction is given in
Example 9). In fact, the entire song can be read as a descending 5-line
as Yorke emphasizes 5̂ (F # 3) at the beginning of the song.
35
Ibid., 228.
36
Ibid.
52 Indiana Theory Review Vol. 30 No. 2
The worksheet and answer key for aural analysis of “You and Whose
Army?” appears in Example 10. Music critic David Fricke describes
this song as “begin[ning] as a bleak piano prayer, like John Lennon’s
‘Imagine’ via Nina Simone, then erupt[ing] with eccentric radiance—all
in a little more than three minutes.”37 The worksheet for this song offers
several questions regarding meter, sequence, interval identification, and
chromatic harmony. This song is particularly engaging because texture,
instrumentation, form, and harmony interact in interesting ways. If we
attend primarily to instrumentation and texture, the song can be parsed
into two large sections: 0:00–1:48 marked by Yorke’s intimate vocals,
closely miked, and accompanied by gentle, sustained backing vocals and
a sparse guitar accompaniment. This first section features a circle-of-
fifths sequence and as Letts points out, an unusually ambiguous to-
nality (in her words, “although the progression here sounds stable, it
has no one tonic upon which to rest”).38 At 1:48 through the end of
the song, the drums and piano are added for a fuller texture as Yorke’s
vocals become more robust. This section features striking contrast in
terms of harmony: C # emerges as a clear tonic, which is reinforced by
its emphasis in Yorke’s vocals and the repeating four-chord progression
(open fifth chord on C # [I] – E [bIII] – F # [IV] – C # [I]). Yorke’s vocal
melody emphasizes the m3 between C # and E n (b 3̂) particularly on “we
ride tonight,” and interacts with the harmony articulated in the piano
and guitar for a hybrid modal pitch collection (combining C # dorian
and mixolydian).
As a follow-up activity to the worksheet for “You and Whose
Army?” the instructor might assign Letts’ brief, but detailed analysis
of how this song fits in the overall scheme of Amnesiac and how voice,
instrumentation, harmony, and form relate to the song’s political im-
plications.39 Letts argues that Yorke’s singing mimics the vocal style of
WWII ballads and suggests that it “evokes the rise of global brands at
the end of WWII,” which in turn gave way to “consumer capitalism as
the way of the world.” She further identifies a contradiction between
the anti-consumerism sentiments evoked in this song and Radiohead’s
participation within the music business; in her words, “the band simul-
taneously decries the capitalist culture and thrives within it.”40
37
David Fricke, “Radiohead Warm Up; With a New Disc, the Band
Shows Its Intimate Side ‘(Amnesiac),’ Rolling Stone no. 869 (24 May 2001): 21.
38
Letts, Resistant Concept Album, 137.
39
Ibid., 137–40.
40
Ibid., 138.
Malawey, Ear Training with the Music of Radiohead 53
Example 10. Aural Analysis, “You and Whose Army?”
Worksheet:
While listening to this song, answer the following questions.
5. How are the scale degrees 1- b7-6-5 (sung on “ghost horses”) harmo-
4. What melodic interval do we hear on the text, “we ride tonight”? m3
progression: I- bIII-IV-I
nized near the end? Represent the progression with a Roman numeral
chromatic? bIII
7. Assuming that this passage is in a major key, which of these chords is
The worksheet and answer key for “A Wolf at the Door” appears
in Example 11. The excerpt conforms to conventions found in common
practice classical music, and as such it uses the N6 as a chromatic pre-
dominant and emphasizes linear connections, such as V42 resolving to I6.
It is somewhat unusual to encounter the N6 in the genre of rock, and
perhaps even more unusual to encounter it with voice-leading proce-
dures associated with common-practice harmony, which makes this a
compelling example. In addition, the arpeggiated texture of this passage
and its slow harmonic rhythm make it ideal for classroom use. After the
instrumental introduction which comprises this aural analysis activity,
Yorke delivers the lyrics of this song at a frenetic pace, which creates
textural tension as his delivery is juxtaposed with the slower moving
compound meter and harmonic rhythm articulated by the accompany-
ing rock instruments.
54 Indiana Theory Review Vol. 30 No. 2
Example 11. Aural Analysis, “A Wolf at the Door,” 0:00–0:16
Worksheet:
Transcribe as much as possible of the first sixteen seconds of this song (0:00–
0:16). Provide the key, time signature, and measure lines. Be sure to notate
both the arpeggiated chordal parts as well as the bass, which begins in m. 3.
After completing the transcription, provide a Roman numeral analysis of the
implied harmonies beneath the staff and answers the questions that follow.
Dictation Answer:
Malawey, Ear Training with the Music of Radiohead 55
Example 12. Aural Analysis, “High and Dry”
Worksheet:
While listening to this song, answer the following questions.
1. On what words does Thom Yorke sing the highest note(s) of the song?
“High” and “Dry”
2. What scale degree occurs on the melodic apex? Scale degree 3
3. What mode best characterizes this song? Major
4. What type of meter best characterizes this song? Simple quadruple
5. What are the scale degrees of the repeating bass line in the verses?
2̂–4̂–1̂
6. What kind of cadential motion is implied by the last two scale degrees
of this repeating bass line? Plagal
Worksheet:
Given the pre-formatted staff, provide a time signature and notate the
pitches, with correct rhythm, of the vocal line upon listening to the excerpt
several times. The vocal part begins after a fifteen-second introduction.
Lyrics are given below to help you follow along.
Lyrics:
“And the wise man say I don’t want to hear your voice
And the thin man say I don’t want to hear your voice
And they’re cursing me, and they won’t let me be
There’s nothing to say, and there’s nothing to do
Stop whispering, start shouting / Stop whispering, start shouting”
56 Indiana Theory Review Vol. 30 No. 2
Example 13. (continued)
Dictation Answer:
The worksheet for “High and Dry” (Example 12) is appropriate for
students still learning the basics. It emphasizes identification of scale-
degree function, mode, and meter within a diatonic context and does
not require any transcription. Its melodic apex on 3̂ occurs aptly when
Yorke sings the words from the song’s title, “high” and “dry.” The apex is
an appropriate word painting of “high,” whose higher frequency (G # 4)
is further emphasized by its approach of an ascending M6, as well as
Yorke’s beautiful tenor falsetto. Repetition in this song also gives begin-
ning students ample opportunity to process and identify its repeating
bass line (2̂ – 4̂ –1̂) and the plagal harmonic motion associated with it.
“Stop Whispering” is entirely diatonic, and its worksheet
(Example 13) focuses on aspects of melodic dictation, meter identi-
fication, and harmony. The extended length of the dictation on this
Malawey, Ear Training with the Music of Radiohead 57
Example 14. Aural Analysis, “I Might Be Wrong”
Worksheet:
While listening to this song, answer the following questions.
41
Letts, Resistant Concept Album, 140–43.
58 Indiana Theory Review Vol. 30 No. 2
Example 15. Aural Analysis, “A Punch Up at a Wedding”
Worksheet:
While listening to this song, answer the following questions.
Bonus Question: Considering the overall mode of this song (named in ques-
0:45? #3̂
tion #1), what chromatic scale degree do we hear in the vocals in 0:39–
G # and F n
Assuming E is tonic, name the pitches of these chromatic notes:
This first stage of ear training is concerned with the accurate per-
ception and labeling of individual events: the quality of an interval,
inversions of a chord, etc. The other stage involves the comprehen-
sion of musical relationships and for teaching purposes implies—
almost demands—a holistic approach.43
42
Rogers, Teaching Approaches, 146.
43
Ibid., 101.
60
Fig. 3, Fig. 5,
Ex. 10 (#1–4);
Diatonic Ear Training Fig. 1, all Fig. 2, all simple & major, Exx. 2–5
Exx. 12–15
compound minor, Mm7
Figure 8. Model for Sequencing
15 (#5)
harmony and modulation) & ninth chords
Fig. 3,
Post-Tonal/20th- and 21st- Ex. 15
Fig. 1, all Fig. 2, modes composite
Century Ear Training (modal)
meters
Malawey, Ear Training with the Music of Radiohead 61
In these terms, “first-stage” activities include identification of
intervals, scale type/mode, and chord quality, as given in Figures 1, 2
and 4. These activities are generally more appropriate for beginners
in rudiments and diatonic harmony classes. “Second-stage” activi-
ties include meter identification, chromatic chord function identifi-
cation, melodic dictation, and aural analysis, found in Figures 3 and
5 and Examples 2–15. These activities generally work best at higher
levels (chromatic harmony and beyond). Even with this broad classi-
fication in mind, however, the “first-stage” activities I have listed blur
this bipartite distinction because all of the activities are contextual.
Conclusion
Their music talks to you, in a real way. It can take you down a quiet
street before it drops a beautiful musical bomb on you. It can build
to where you think the whole thing will crumble beneath its own
weight—and then Thom Yorke will sing some melody that just
cuts your heart out of your chest. There’s a point on the album
Kid A where I start feeling claustrophobic, stuck in a barbed-wire
44
Two recently published texts with a wealth of interesting examples
include Gary Karpinski, Manual for Ear Training and Sight Singing (New York
and London: W. W. Norton & Co., 2007); and Joel Phillips et al., The Musician’s
Guide to Aural Skills: Ear Training and Composition, 2nd ed., vol. 2 (New York
and London: W. W. Norton & Co., 2011).
62 Indiana Theory Review Vol. 30 No. 2
jungle—and then I suddenly fall out and I’m sitting by a pool with
birds singing. Radiohead can do all of these things in a moment,
and it drives me fucking crazy.45
Bibliography
Doheny, James. Radiohead Back to Save the Universe: The Stories Behind Every
Song. New York: Thunder’s Mouth Press, 2002.
Frere-Jones, Sasha. “Fine Tuning.” New Yorker 82, no. 19 (26 June 2006): 86–7.
Fricke, David. “Radiohead Warm Up; With a New Disc, the Band Shows Its
Intimate Side ‘(Amnesiac).’” Rolling Stone no. 869 (24 May 2001): 21.
45
Dave Matthews, “The Immortals-73: Radiohead” Rolling Stone, no. 972
(21 April 2005): 80.
Malawey, Ear Training with the Music of Radiohead 63
Hubbs, Nadine. “The Imagination of Pop-Rock Criticism.” In Expression in
Pop-Rock Music: Critical and Analytical Essays, 2nd ed. Edited by Walter
Everett, 215–37. New York and London: Routledge, 2008.
———. “Lessons from the Past: Music Theory Pedagogy and the Future.” Music
Theory Online 6, no. 3 (2000). http://www.mtosmt.org/issues/mto.00.6.3/
mto.00.6.3.karpinski_frames.html. Accessed 27 February 2012.
———. Manual for Ear Training and Sight Singing. New York and London:
W. W. Norton & Co., 2007.
Lansky, Paul. “My Radiohead Adventure.” In The Music and Art of Radiohead.
Edited by Joseph Tate, 168–76. Burlington, Vermont and Aldershot,
England: Ashgate, 2005.
Letts, Marianne Tatom. Radiohead and the Resistant Concept Album: How to
Disappear Completely. Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 2010.
London, Justin. “‘One Step Up’: A Lesson from Pop Music.” Journal of Music
Theory Pedagogy 4, no. 1 (Spring 1990): 111–14.
Matthews, Dave. “The Immortals-73: Radiohead.” Rolling Stone, no. 972 (21
April 2005): 80.
———. “With Radiohead and Alone, a Sweet Malaise.” New York Times (2 July
2006): section 2, column 2, 1.
Phillips, Joel, Paul Murphy, Elizabeth West Marvin, and Jane Piper
Clendinning. The Musician’s Guide to Aural Skills: Ear Training and
Composition, 2nd ed., vol. 2. New York and London: W. W. Norton &
Co., 2011.
64 Indiana Theory Review Vol. 30 No. 2
Potter, Gary. “Identifying Successful Dictation Strategies.” Journal of Music
Theory Pedagogy 4 (1990): 63–71.
Reisch, George A. “Is Radiohead the Pink Floyd of the Twenty-First Century?”
In Radiohead and Philosophy: Fitter Happier More Deductive. Edited by
Brandon W. Forbes and George A. Reisch, 3–14. Popular Culture and
Philosophy, vol. 38, series ed. George A. Reisch. Chicago and LaSalle, Ill.:
Open Court, 2009.
Ross, Alex. “The Searchers: Radiohead’s Unquiet Revolution.” New Yorker (20
and 27 August 2001): 112–23.
Discography
———. Hail to the Thief. Capitol Records 7243 5 84543 2 1. CD. 2003.
Copyright © 2012 by Indiana University. All rights reserved. Content compilation copyright © 2019
by Répertoire International de Littérature Musicale (RILM). All rights reserved.
RILM Abstracts of Music Literature with Full Text contains electronic versions of previously
published journals reproduced with permission. The RILM collection is owned and managed by
Répertoire International de Littérature Musicale (RILM), 365 Fifth Avenue, New York NY 10016,
USA.
As a RILM user, you may print, download, or send articles for individual use as authorized under
the terms and conditions of this site, as well as under fair use as defined by U.S. and international
copyright law. No content may be otherwise copied or posted without the copyright holders’
express written permission.
To view the entire list of journals included within the RILM Abstracts of Music Literature with Full
Text collection, please visit http://rilm.org/fulltext/.