Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Department of Philosophy
ASSIGNMENT
Conditions for the Affirmation of a Modern African Philosophical Thought by Marcien Towa
and
Tradition and Destiny: Horizons of an African Philosophical Hermeneutics by Okonda Okolo
Lecturer
Nairobi, Kenya
This paper delves into the conditions necessary for the affirmation of modern African
philosophical thought as outlined by Marcien Towa. It examines the obstacles, methodological
conditions, and institutional/material requirements crucial for the development and recognition of
African philosophical discourse. Furthermore, it explores the interconnectedness of reading and
text within the framework of African philosophical hermeneutics, as articulated by Okonda Okolo.
The discussion underscores the importance of critical engagement with Western philosophy, the
valorization of indigenous knowledge systems, and the promotion of interdisciplinary
collaboration in advancing African philosophical thought. Additionally, it emphasizes the dynamic
nature of interpretation, highlighting the role of the reader's worldview and ethical considerations
in shaping interpretive practices. Through a critical analysis, this paper aims to shed light on the
significance of African philosophy in fostering intellectual diversity and addressing socio-political
challenges on the continent which culminates in the proffering of a critique.
ii
Table of Contents
Abstract........................................................................................................................................................ ii
Table of Contents ....................................................................................................................................... iii
Introduction ................................................................................................................................................. 1
1.0 Conditions for the Affirmation of a Modern African Philosophical Thought by Marcien Towa . 1
1.1 Obstacles to Overcome for the Affirmation of Modern African Philosophical Thought by
Marcien Towa.......................................................................................................................................... 2
1.1.1 Colonial Legacy and Eurocentrism .......................................................................................... 2
1.1.2 Intellectual Dependency and Mimicry ..................................................................................... 2
1.1.3 Linguistic and Epistemological Challenges ............................................................................. 3
1.1.4 Social and Economic Constraints ............................................................................................. 3
1.2 Methodological Conditions for the Affirmation of Modern African Philosophical Thought by
Marcien Towa.......................................................................................................................................... 3
1.2.1 Critical Engagement with Western Philosophy ...................................................................... 4
1.2.2 Recovery and Valorization of Indigenous Knowledge Systems ............................................. 4
1.2.3 Contextualization and Application to Concrete Realities ...................................................... 4
1.2.4 Promotion of Interdisciplinary Collaboration......................................................................... 5
1.3 Institutional and Material Conditions for the Affirmation of Modern African Philosophical
Thought by Marcien Towa ..................................................................................................................... 5
1.3.1 Development of Academic Institutions and Research Centers .............................................. 5
1.3.2 Support for Scholarly Publications and Journals ................................................................... 6
1.3.3 Investment in Research Infrastructure and Resources .......................................................... 6
1.3.4 Promotion of Intellectual Freedom and Academic Autonomy .............................................. 7
2.0 Tradition and Destiny: Horizons of an African Philosophical Hermeneutics by Okonda Okolo .. 7
2.1 Any theory of reading presupposes a theory of the text and vice versa ....................................... 7
2.1.1 Interconnectedness of Reading and Text ................................................................................. 7
2.1.2 African Philosophical Hermeneutics ........................................................................................ 8
2.1.3 Implications for Interpretive Practice ...................................................................................... 8
2.1.4 Contribution to Philosophical Discourse ................................................................................. 9
2.2 Any reading (interpreting) presupposes some kind of “retake” ................................................... 9
2.2.1 The Concept of "Retake" in Reading....................................................................................... 9
2.2.2 Contextualization and Reinterpretation ................................................................................ 10
2.2.3 Dialogical Engagement with Texts ......................................................................................... 10
2.2.4 Implications for Interpretive Practice .................................................................................... 10
iii
2.3 Any Reading and Any Retaking Involves a Decision that Starts from the Reading and
Retaking Subject’s Vision of the World.............................................................................................. 11
2.3.1 Interpretive Subjectivity.......................................................................................................... 11
2.3.2 Worldview and Interpretive Frameworks ............................................................................. 12
2.3.3 Ethical and Political Dimensions ................................................................................................ 12
2.3.4 Implications for Interpretive Practice .................................................................................... 12
3.0 Critique of Conditions for the Affirmation of a Modern African Philosophical Thought by
Marcien Towa and Tradition and Destiny: Horizons of an African Philosophical Hermeneutics by
Okonda Okolo ........................................................................................................................................... 13
Conclusion ................................................................................................................................................. 15
Bibliography .............................................................................................................................................. 16
I. Books .............................................................................................................................................. 16
II. Journal Article ............................................................................................................................... 16
iv
Introduction
African philosophical thought has long been marginalized within the global philosophical canon,
overshadowed by dominant Western paradigms. Marcien Towa and Okonda Okolo offer valuable
insights into the conditions necessary for the affirmation and development of African philosophical
discourse. Towa identifies colonial legacies, intellectual dependency, linguistic challenges, and
interpretation, and the reader's worldview. This paper critically examines these perspectives,
offering a nuanced understanding of the challenges and opportunities facing modern African
philosophical thought.
1.0 Conditions for the Affirmation of a Modern African Philosophical Thought by Marcien
Towa
iii. The institutional and material conditions that need to be fulfilled in order to insure the
1
Tsenay Serequeberhan, African Philosophy: The Essential Readings (New York: Paragon House, 2001), 20.
1
1.1 Obstacles to Overcome for the Affirmation of Modern African Philosophical Thought by
Marcien Towa
Marcien Towa highlighted the enduring impact of colonialism on African philosophical thought.
Colonial education systems often denigrated indigenous African knowledge systems, promoting
African philosophy, with Western philosophical traditions often serving as the normative standard
against which African thought is judged. Towa argued that overcoming Eurocentrism is essential
Towa identified intellectual dependency and mimicry as significant obstacles to the development
intellectual autonomy and creativity. He urged African philosophers to engage critically with both
original insights.5
2
Marcien Towa, Black Religion and Philosophy (Chicago: Third World Press, 1987), 18.
3
Marcien Towa, African Philosophy: Philosophy of the South (Dakar: New African Editions, 1992), 45.
4
Marcien Towa, For an Ethics of African Responsibility (Yaoundé: Cle Editions, 2001), 33.
5
Marcien Towa, The Ethics of Freedom (Yaoundé: Clé Editions, 2010), 19.
2
1.1.3 Linguistic and Epistemological Challenges
Linguistic diversity poses challenges to the affirmation of modern African philosophical thought.
European languages dominate academic discourse in Africa, limiting access to indigenous African
languages and knowledge systems. Towa emphasized the importance of linguistic diversity and
the need to valorize African languages as vehicles for philosophical expression.6 Epistemological
challenges also arise from the tension between Western and indigenous African ways of knowing.
Western epistemologies often prioritize abstract rationality and empirical observation, whereas
African epistemologies may emphasize oral traditions, communal wisdom, and spiritual insights.7
Socio-economic constraints, such as poverty, inequality, and political instability, present obstacles
to the development of African philosophy. Limited resources, institutional barriers, and political
repression can impede philosophical inquiry and academic freedom.8 Towa argued that addressing
social and economic constraints requires broader societal transformations and the democratization
of knowledge production. African philosophers should actively engage with social justice issues
6
Marcien Towa, Ethics and Politics in Africa: Essay on African Political Philosophy (Yaoundé: Clé Editions, 1997),
14.
7
Marcien Towa, African Philosophy in Dialogue (Yaoundé: Clé Editions, 2005), 56.
8
Marcien Towa, "Conditions for the Affirmation of a Modern African Philosophical Thought," Presence Africaine,
Vol. 77 (1971):160.
9
Marcien Towa, The African Philosophy: Myth and Reality (Johannesburg: New Africa Books, 1980), 45.
3
1.2.1 Critical Engagement with Western Philosophy
Marcien Towa emphasized the importance of critically engaging with Western philosophical
thought. Rather than uncritically adopting Western frameworks, African philosophers should
subject them to rigorous scrutiny and adaptation to African contexts.10 Towa argued for a
dialogical approach to philosophy that involves both critique and appropriation of Western ideas.
This approach allows African philosophers to draw upon the insights of Western thought while
indigenous African knowledge systems. African philosophy should not be confined to Western-
style academic discourse but should encompass the rich diversity of indigenous African
philosophies, oral traditions, and cultural practices.12 Towa advocated for an interdisciplinary
approach to African philosophy that incorporates insights from anthropology, history, literature,
and other fields. This approach allows African philosophers to access and interpret indigenous
knowledge systems in ways that are meaningful and relevant to contemporary African contexts.13
Towa stressed the importance of contextualizing philosophical inquiry and applying it to concrete
social, political, and economic realities. African philosophy should not remain abstract or detached
from lived experiences but should address pressing issues such as colonialism, globalization,
10
Towa, Black Religion and Philosophy, 33.
11
Towa, African Philosophy, 48.
12
Towa, For an Ethics of African Responsibility, 25.
13
Towa, The Ethics of Freedom, 9.
4
development, and identity.14 Contextualization requires African philosophers to ground their
theoretical reflections in empirical research and engage with the lived experiences of ordinary
Africans. This approach fosters a deeper understanding of the social and cultural dynamics shaping
methodological condition for the affirmation of modern African philosophical thought. African
philosophers should work closely with scholars from other disciplines, as well as with practitioners
fosters cross-fertilization of ideas, fosters innovation, and enhances the relevance of African
philosophy to broader intellectual and practical concerns. By breaking down disciplinary silos,
African philosophers can contribute more effectively to the advancement of knowledge and social
transformation.17
1.3 Institutional and Material Conditions for the Affirmation of Modern African
Marcien Towa stressed the importance of establishing and strengthening academic institutions and
research centers dedicated to African philosophy. These institutions provide spaces for rigorous
14
Towa, Ethics and Politics in Africa, 17.
15
Towa, African Philosophy in Dialogue, 44.
16
Towa, "Conditions for the Affirmation of a Modern African Philosophical Thought," 163.
17
Towa, The African Philosophy, 27.
5
community.18 Academic institutions play a crucial role in training future generations of African
philosophers, scholars, and educators. By offering courses, seminars, and research opportunities
Towa emphasized the need for support for scholarly publications and journals dedicated to African
philosophy. Publishing outlets provide platforms for African philosophers to share their research,
engage in dialogue with colleagues, and contribute to the global conversation in philosophy.20
Institutional support for scholarly publications helps to ensure the visibility and impact of African
philosophical thought within academic circles. By promoting dissemination and exchange of ideas,
Adequate investment in research infrastructure and resources is essential for the affirmation of
modern African philosophical thought. This includes funding for libraries, archives, digital
databases, and other research facilities that support scholarly inquiry and knowledge production.22
Access to research resources enables African philosophers to conduct empirical research, access
primary sources, and engage in comparative analysis. Investment in research infrastructure helps
to overcome barriers to knowledge production and fosters a culture of intellectual curiosity and
exploration.23
18
Towa, Black Religion and Philosophy, 19.
19
Towa, African Philosophy, 39.
20
Towa, For an Ethics of African Responsibility, 42.
21
Towa, The Ethics of Freedom, 22.
22
Towa, Ethics and Politics in Africa, 18.
23
Towa, African Philosophy in Dialogue, 11.
6
1.3.4 Promotion of Intellectual Freedom and Academic Autonomy
Towa highlighted the importance of promoting intellectual freedom and academic autonomy as
institutional conditions for the affirmation of African philosophy. Academic institutions should
uphold principles of academic freedom, free inquiry, and open debate, allowing scholars to pursue
their research interests without fear of censorship or reprisal.24 Intellectual freedom is essential for
Okolo 26
2.1 Any theory of reading presupposes a theory of the text and vice versa
Okonda Okolo posits that any theory of reading presupposes a corresponding theory of the text,
and vice versa. In other words, the act of reading is intimately intertwined with the nature and
characteristics of the text being read. He argues that understanding the text requires an appreciation
of the reader's interpretive framework and the context in which the text is situated.27 Conversely,
theories of the text are shaped by the methods and approaches employed in reading and
24
Towa, "Conditions for the Affirmation of a Modern African Philosophical Thought," 164.
25
Towa, The African Philosophy, 34.
26
Serequeberhan, African Philosophy, 19.
27
Oritsegbubemi Okolo, Tradition and Destiny: Horizons of an African Philosophical Hermeneutics (Oxford: African
Books Collective, Oxford, 2018), 45.
7
interpretation. The way in which a text is understood and interpreted influences our understanding
of its meaning, significance, and cultural context. Therefore, theories of reading and theories of
the text are mutually constitutive, each informing and shaping the other.28
Within the framework of African philosophical hermeneutics, Okolo explores how theories of
reading and theories of the text intersect and interact. He contends that African philosophical
traditions offer unique perspectives on the nature of texts and the processes of interpretation,
emphasizing the importance of context, dialogue, and communal engagement in reading.29 Okolo
draws on indigenous African epistemologies and interpretive practices to inform his hermeneutic
approach. He explores how oral traditions, storytelling, and communal rituals shape the production
and reception of texts within African societies. By integrating these insights into contemporary
philosophical discourse, Okolo seeks to enrich our understanding of reading and interpretation.30
Okolo's exploration of the interplay between theories of reading and theories of the text has
significant implications for interpretive practice. He argues that readers must be mindful of their
interpretive frameworks and biases when engaging with texts, recognizing that interpretation is a
dynamic and context-dependent process.31 Additionally, Okolo suggests that theories of the text
should be flexible and adaptable, capable of accommodating diverse interpretive approaches and
perspectives. Rather than imposing fixed meanings or interpretations, theories of the text should
28
Okolo, Tradition and Destiny, 26.
29
Okolo, Tradition and Destiny, 53.
30
Okolo, Tradition and Destiny, 22.
31
Okolo, Tradition and Destiny, 18.
32
Okolo, Tradition and Destiny, 10.
8
2.1.4 Contribution to Philosophical Discourse
"Tradition and Destiny" contributes to broader philosophical discourse by shedding light on the
intricate relationship between reading, interpretation, and textuality. Okolo's work challenges
reading and theories of the text, Okolo invites scholars to rethink their approaches to textual
analysis and engage more deeply with the cultural, social, and historical contexts that shape textual
production and reception. His work opens up new avenues for interdisciplinary dialogue and
Okolo argues that the process of reading or interpreting a text involves a continuous cycle of
engagement and reinterpretation, which he refers to as a "retake." This concept suggests that every
reading of a text is not merely a passive reception of information, but an active process of
engagement that involves revisiting, reinterpreting, and re-contextualizing the text.35 The notion
of "retake" implies that reading is not a static or linear process, but rather a dynamic and iterative
one. Each reading represents a new perspective or angle through which the text is approached,
33
Okolo, Tradition and Destiny, 6.
34
Okolo, Tradition and Destiny, 25.
35
Okolo, Tradition and Destiny, 18.
36
Okolo, Tradition and Destiny, 8.
9
2.2.2 Contextualization and Reinterpretation
Within the framework of African philosophical hermeneutics, Okolo emphasizes the importance
of contextualization and reinterpretation in the process of reading. He contends that readers must
continually "retake" the text by situating it within its cultural, historical, and ideological context,
and by reassessing its meaning in light of new insights and perspectives.37 This approach to reading
acknowledges the dynamic nature of texts and the plurality of meanings that they can evoke. By
embracing the concept of "retake," readers are encouraged to adopt a critical and reflexive stance
towards texts, recognizing that interpretations are not fixed or definitive, but contingent upon the
Okolo's concept of "retake" underscores the dialogical nature of reading, wherein the reader enters
into a dynamic exchange with the text. Rather than passively consuming information, readers
actively engage with the text, posing questions, making connections, and generating new insights
through the process of interpretation.39 This dialogical engagement with texts reflects Okolo's
embracing the concept of "retake," readers are invited to participate in ongoing conversations with
texts, authors, and other readers, enriching their understanding and appreciation of the text.40
Okolo's concept of "retake" has important implications for interpretive practice, particularly within
the context of African philosophical hermeneutics. It challenges readers to adopt a reflexive and
37
Okolo, Tradition and Destiny, 13.
38
Okolo, Tradition and Destiny, 16.
39
Okolo, Tradition and Destiny, 7.
40
Okolo, Tradition and Destiny, 24.
10
critical approach to reading, acknowledging their own biases, assumptions, and limitations in the
approach texts with humility and openness, recognizing that interpretations are always provisional
and subject to revision. This approach to reading fosters a spirit of intellectual curiosity,
exploration, and dialogue, enriching the reader's engagement with texts and contributing to the
advancement of knowledge.42
2.3 Any Reading and Any Retaking Involves a Decision that Starts from the Reading and
Okolo highlights the inherent subjectivity of reading and retaking, emphasizing that every
interpretation is shaped by the reader's unique perspective, experiences, and worldview. He argues
that readers do not approach texts as neutral or objective observers but as situated individuals
whose interpretations are influenced by their cultural, social, and ideological context.43 This
awareness in the process of reading and retaking. Readers must be conscious of their own biases,
assumptions, and values, recognizing that their interpretations are not universal truths but situated
41
Okolo, Tradition and Destiny, 19.
42
Okolo, Tradition and Destiny, 10.
43
Okolo, Tradition and Destiny, 19.
44
Okolo, Tradition and Destiny, 25.
11
2.3.2 Worldview and Interpretive Frameworks
Okolo contends that readers' decisions in reading and retaking are guided by their vision of the
world, which encompasses their beliefs, values, and epistemological commitments. This
worldview serves as the lens through which readers interpret and make sense of texts, shaping their
understanding and interpretation.45 Different readers may approach the same text with distinct
interpretive frameworks based on their worldview. For example, readers from diverse cultural
backgrounds may interpret a text differently based on their cultural norms, values, and traditions.
Similarly, readers with different philosophical or ideological perspectives may offer contrasting
Okolo suggests that readers' decisions in reading and retaking texts have ethical and political
dimensions, as they reflect underlying power dynamics and ideological struggles. The act of
interpretation is not merely a cognitive exercise but a morally and politically charged endeavor
that can reinforce or challenge existing power structures.47 Readers' decisions in reading and
retaking texts may reflect their positionality within broader systems of oppression, privilege, and
marginalization. Okolo encourages readers to critically examine the ethical implications of their
interpretations, interrogating the social, political, and ethical consequences of their decisions.48
Okolo's exploration of the relationship between reading, retaking, and the reader's vision of the
world has important implications for interpretive practice. It calls attention to the need for self-
45
Okolo, Tradition and Destiny, 14.
46
Okolo, Tradition and Destiny, 17.
47
Okolo, Tradition and Destiny, 22.
48
Okolo, Tradition and Destiny, 35.
12
reflection, critical consciousness, and ethical responsibility in the process of interpretation.49 By
acknowledging the subjective nature of interpretation and the influence of readers' worldviews,
interpreters can adopt a more nuanced and self-aware approach to reading and retaking texts. This
approach fosters dialogue, empathy, and understanding across diverse perspectives, enriching the
3.0 Critique of Conditions for the Affirmation of a Modern African Philosophical Thought
Towa's analysis of the obstacles to the affirmation of African philosophy provides a comprehensive
overview of the structural barriers and ideological biases that hinder its development. However,
while his emphasis on critical engagement with Western philosophy is essential, it is essential to
avoid perpetuating a dichotomy between Western and African thought. Instead, a more nuanced
approach that recognizes the interconnectedness of philosophical traditions would enrich the
discourse. Additionally, Towa's focus on institutional and material conditions highlights the need
for investment in academic infrastructure and intellectual freedom, yet it overlooks the grassroots
efforts and community-based initiatives crucial for the democratization of knowledge production.
Okolo's exploration of African philosophical hermeneutics offers valuable insights into the
dynamic nature of interpretation and the role of the reader's subjectivity. However, his framework
could benefit from further elaboration on the ethical implications of interpretation and the power
dynamics inherent in the production and reception of texts. Additionally, while Okolo emphasizes
49
Okolo, Tradition and Destiny, 13.
50
Okolo, Tradition and Destiny, 30.
13
the importance of contextualization and reinterpretation, more attention to the specific
methodologies and practices employed in African hermeneutics would enrich his analysis.
14
Conclusion
The affirmation of modern African philosophical thought requires a multi-faceted approach that
Towa's emphasis on critical engagement with Western philosophy and Okolo's exploration of
and ethical reflexivity, African philosophers can contribute to a more inclusive and equitable
philosophical traditions are essential for addressing pressing socio-political challenges and
15
Bibliography
I. Books
Towa, Marcien. "Conditions for the Affirmation of a Modern African Philosophical Thought."
Presence Africaine, Vol. 77 (1971):159-175.
16