Professional Documents
Culture Documents
0143051A1
(19) United States
(12) Patent Application Publication (10) Pub. No.: US 2004/0143051A1
LOu et al. (43) Pub. Date: Jul. 22, 2004
(54) UNSATURATED POLYESTER RESIN Publication Classification
COMPOSITIONS WITH IMPROVED
PROCESSING AND STORAGE STABILITY (51) Int. Cl. ................................................... C08K 3/28
(76) Inventors: Jianfeng Lou, Wayne, PA (US); Daniel (52) U.S. Cl. .............................................................. 524/429
Alford JR., Pottstown, PA (US)
Correspondence Address: (57) ABSTRACT
Gilbert W. Rudman
ATOFINA Chemicals, Inc.
26th Floor The present invention relates to a finished resin composition
2000 Market Street containing (a) an unsaturated polyester, b) a polymerizable
Philadelphia, PA 19103 (US) monomer, (c) a promoter System, and (d) a composite
Stabilizer, wherein the composite Stabilizer is a hydroxy
(21) Appl. No.: 10/722,872 lamine oxide and aromatic antioxidant and, optionally, a
(22) Filed: Nov. 26, 2003 hydroxylamine and is present at 0.001-0.5 parts per 100
parts of the finished UPE resin. The stabilizing system
Related U.S. Application Data improves processing Stability by preventing gel-particle
formation, improved Storage Stability of the curing compo
(60) Provisional application No. 60/441,813, filed on Jan. Sitions by inhibiting formation of overhead popcorn and
22, 2003. Suppressing drifts of resin Viscosity and gel time.
US 2004/0143051A1 Jul. 22, 2004
UNSATURATED POLYESTER RESIN monomer Solution is too thick or gelatinous to pour into
COMPOSITIONS WITH IMPROVED PROCESSING molds. The same UPE resin in the reactive monomer Solu
AND STORAGE STABILITY tion Such as Styrene is more fluid thus allowing one to pour
the UPE resin into a mold.
REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONS
0011. The reactive monomer solution may be susceptible
0001) This application claims the benefit of U.S. Provi to Spontaneous polymerization when hot UPE resin is added.
sional Application Serial No. 60/441,813, filed Jan. 22, For example, Styrene may spontaneously form polystyrene if
2003. the Styrene is not Stabilized. Typically, commercial Styrene is
stabilized with dialkylcatechols to slow or completely
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION inhibit polystyrene formation.
0012. With current technology, phenolic compounds such
0002) 1. Field of the Invention as hydroquinone (HQ), 4-tert-butylcatechol (TBC) and 2,6-
0003. This invention relates to unsaturated polyester di-tert-butyl-4-methylphenol (BHT) are used as stabilizers
resin compositions containing a hydroxylamine oxide and, in the finished resin compositions to ensure their shelf-life
optionally, a hydroxylamine and an aromatic antioxidant, stability.
wherein the addition of the hydroxyl amine oxide and the 0013 However, such phenolic stabilizers do not provide
optional components results in an improvement in proceSS Vapor-phase popcorn inhibition during Storage of the UPE
ing Stability and composition, inhibition of an accumulation resin and often lead to Viscosity and gel time drifts. AS Such,
of undesired overhead polymers, and a decrease in the drift the storage stability of finished UPE resins, especially those
of resin Viscosity and gel time. based on dicyclopentadiene (DCPD)-containing UPE resins,
0004 2. Prior Art presents a great challenge to UPE producers.
0005. In the unsaturated polyester resin (UPE) industry, 0014. Also, phenolic stabilized monomer Solutions do not
UPE end users make various finished products such as adequately inhibit Spontaneous polymerization of the mono
marbles and gel coats by curing finished resin compositions mer Solution. For example, when the hot UPE resin is poured
that contain UPE, cross-linking monomer, promoter and into the monomer Solution, the temperature of the monomer
stabilizer. Solution may rise from about room temperature to greater
than 70° C. This elevated temperature increases the propen
0006 UPE resins are generally made by an esterification sity for monomer polymerization resulting in un-wanted
reaction in a heated vessel. Saturated dibasic acids Such as
phthalic anhydride, isophthalic acid, adipic acid or tereph gel-type particles in the UPE-monomer Solution.
thalic acid or unsaturated dibasic acids Such as maleic 0015 There exist numerous publications aiming to
anyhydride or fumaric acid are reacted with glycols during improve the resin stability by the use of various stabilizers
the esterification reaction. Hydrocarbon modifierS Such as in UPE curing formulations.
dicyclopentadiene (DCPD) and other platicizers may be 0016 May, C. A.; U.S. Pat. No. 3,408,422, 1968 (Shell
added during the esterification reaction to impart desired Oil) discloses hydroxy-containing unsaturated polyester
properties to the final UPE resin. compositions with hydroxylamine compound as Stabilizer.
0007. The esterification reaction is usually done at Such unsaturated polyester is prepared from a glycidyl
elevated temperatures, from 50° C. to greater than 250 C. polyether of polyhydric phenol and an unsaturated carboxy
Such high processing temperatures are necessary to ensure lic acid. The hydroxylamine compound is preferably a
the esterified product remains molten or gel-like as to make dialkylhydroxylamine and is preferably used together with a
it easy to pour from the reaction vessel into another pro phenolic compound. These compositions are disclosed as
cessing vessel. Stabilizing against premature gelation, gel-particles, during
Storage.
0008. It is common practice to use an esterification
catalyst. Such catalysts produce free radicals that are nec 0017 Baker, J. G.; Yerty, O. M.; U.S. Pat. No. 3,775,513,
essary during the reaction. Catalysts for the esterification 1973 (PPG Industries) discloses an unsaturated polyester
reaction include oxidants Such as benzoyl peroxide, tertiary composition comprising 2,4-dinitrophenol as Stabilizer. The
butyl hydroperoxide, ditertiary butyl peroxide, and hydro dinitrophenol stabilizer is used either by itself or together
gen peroxide among others. with quinones or hydroquinones. These compositions are
disclosed as exhibiting improved Storage Stability.
0009 Processing times for the esterification reaction may
be long, often greater than ten hours. For example, UPE 0018 Jackson, R.J.; U.S. Pat. No. 4,293,672, 1981 (Shell
resins formulated using maleic acid and polypropylene Oil) discloses an improved process of esterifying Saturated
glycol require from ten to fourteen hours at temperatures epoxy resins with ethylenically unsaturated monocarboxylic
from 150-250 C. UPE resins formulated using isophthalic acids. Such a process involves prereacting the epoxy com
acid may require processing times in excess of twenty-three pound with a hydroxylamine compound, which reduces
hours at temperatures from 180° C. to 230° C. premature gelation during the Subsequent esterification reac
tion.
0010. Once the esterification reaction is completed, the
unsaturated polyester resin is transferred to a Solution con 0.019 Jackson, R.J.; U.S. Pat. No. 4,301.261, 1981 (Shell
taining reactive monomerS Such as Styrene, methyl meth Oil) discloses an improved process of esterifying Saturated
acrylate or vinyl toluene. The reactive monomer Solution is epoxy resins with ethylenically unsaturated monocarboxylic
necessary to allow for easy processing of the UPE resin. For acids. Such a process involves prereacting the epoxy com
example, the UPE resin in the absence of the reactive pound with a trialkylphosphite, which reduces premature
US 2004/0143051A1 Jul. 22, 2004
gelation during the Subsequent esterification reaction. The 0029. The objective of this invention is to develop a
preferred trialkylphosphite is triethylphosphite. Stabilized curing formulation that contains, but is not limited
0020 Jackson, R.J.; U.S. Pat. No. 4,303,576, 1981 (Shell to, a DCPD-containing UPE resin, a polymerizable mono
Oil) provides an improved process for preparing stabilized mer, a promoter System, and a composite Stabilizer. The
polyester compositions. The composition comprises an composition of this invention would exhibit improved pro
unsaturated polyester prepared from polyepoxide and unsat cessing and Storage Stability with Substantially reduced
urated monocarboxylic acid with an organic phosphine as gel-particle formation, inhibited overhead polymer forma
catalyst, an amine-based Stabilizer Such as pp'-dioctyldiphe tion and little gel time drift.
nylamine, and, optionally, a cross-linking monomer Such as SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
Styrene. The disclosed composition is disclosed to have
improved Storage Stability. 0030 The present invention discloses a finished resin
0021 Jackson, R.J.; U.S. Pat. No. 4,303,579, 1981 (Shell composition containing,
Oil) describes a stable vinyl ester composition that exhibits 0031) a. an unsaturated polyester
improved color Stability. The composition comprises a vinyl
ester prepared from polyepoxide and unsaturated monocar 0032) b. optionally dicyclopentadiene,
boxylic acid and a Stabilizer based on hydroquinone and 0033) c. a polymerizable monomer,
Sterically hindered phenol.
0034) d. a promoter System, and
0022) Messick V. B.; U.S. Pat. No. 4,336,359, 1982 (Dow
Chemical) discloses the use of nitric acid to improve the 0035) e. a composite Stabilizer;
Storage Stability of vinyl ester resins or unsaturated polyes 0036 wherein the composite stabilizer is a hydroxy
ters without deteriorating their curability. The nitric acid is lamine oxide and optionally a hydroxylamine and an aro
used by itself or in combination with phenothiazine. matic antioxidant and is present at 0.001-0.5 parts per 100
0023 Messick V. B.; U.S. Pat. No. 4,407,991, 1983 (Dow parts of the finished UPE resin.
Chemical) describes the use of Oxalic acid to improve the
Storage Stability of vinyl ester resins or unsaturated polyes DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE
ters without deteriorating their curability. The Oxalic acid is INVENTION
used, optionally, in combination with phenothiazine and 0037. In the present invention, a stabilizing system to
4-chloro-2-nitrophenol. improve the processing and Storage Stability of curing com
0024 Matsukawa, K.; Hayashiya, T.; Yamamoto, D.; EP positions based on unsaturated polyester resins or dicyclo
Patent # 0,761,737, 1997 (Nippon Shokubai) describes a pentadiene (DCPD)-containing unsaturated polyesters
Stabilized resin composition which does not produce gel (UPE) is disclosed.
during Storage and has good Viscosity Stability and little gel
time drift. The composition contains at least a dicyclopen 0038. The stabilizing system is based on hydroxylamine
tadiene (DCPD)-type unsaturated polyester resin, a cross oxide and, optionally, a hydroxylamine and aromatic anti
linking monomer, a phenothiazine derivative, an anion oxidants. It provides improved processing and Storage Sta
producing compound, and, optionally, a phosphorous ester. bility during the thinning of the UPE or UPE-DCPD resins
and overhead protection So that undesired polymer is not
0.025 Typically, resin formulators use multiple stabilizers formed in monomer Solution or in the overhead Space of the
to exploit Synergies. These Stabilizers impart to the unsat Storage container.
urated polyester resin formulations reduced gelation and gel
time drift. 0039 The resin composition of the present invention
exhibits improved processing and Storage Stability with
0026. In addition, efforts have been directed at reducing inhibited gel-particles formation in the UPE-monomer solu
premature gelation during the esterification reaction where a tion and inhibited formation of overhead popcorn (polymer
hydroxylamine or a trialkylphosphite compound is incorpo ized monomer) and Suppressed drifts of resin Viscosity and
rated into the chemical Structure of the reactant. gel time.
0027. The use of hydroxylamines to reduce gelation has 0040. In addition, the disclosed stabilizer gives less gel
focused on unsaturated polyester resins that are hydroxy time and Viscosity drifts during Storage of pre-promoted
Substituted and are prepared from polyepoxides and unsat DCPC-type UPE resin compositions than do traditional
urated carboxylic acids. In these applications, the hydroxy Stabilizers, and it imparts to the curing formulation high
lamine compound is pre-reacted with polyepoxides to Stability in the absence of air (oxygen) during resin Storage.
reduce gel formation during the Subsequent esterification
reaction, and it is used together with a phenolic Stabilizer in 0041. In the best way known of practicing the present
the pre-promoted curing formulation to improve Storage invention, the UPE resin or DCPD-containing UPE resin in
stability. the molten state is blended with styrene that is pre-stabilized
0028. In particular, for curing formulations based on by aromatic antioxidants and a hydroxylamine oxide and
DCPD-containing UPE resins, cobalt soaps are often used in optionally a hydroxylamine.
the formulation to facilitate the breakdown of peroxide 0042. The operating temperature at the blend tank is
catalyst. The pre-promoted UPE resins, though stabilized by controlled below 70° C. So that heat-induced evaporation
aromatic antioxidants Such as phenols, quinones and phe and monomer polymerization could be minimized. The
nothiazines, exhibit poor Storage Stability-undesired poly resulting base resin contains 10-40% styrene and is Stabi
mer formation in overhead Space and drift of gel time during lized by 10-500 parts-per-million (ppm) of an alkyl
Storage. hydroxylamine oxide and alkyl hydroxylamine and 10-500
US 2004/0143051A1 Jul. 22, 2004
ppm of aromatic antioxidants Such as hindered phenols, 0051. The hydroxylamine compound has the general for
quinones and phenothiazines or combinations thereof. mula:
benzoquinone (20 ppm). The styrene Solution was cooled 2. The resin composition of claim 1, wherein the promoter
using an ethylene glycol cooled blanket and maintained at a System comprises at least a metallic compound as primary
temperature of less than 70° C. during the addition of the hot promoter and at least an organic amine as co-promoter.
UPE resin. To this inhibited styrene solution was added 100 3. The resin composition of claim 1, wherein the com
ppm of TEAO, 100 ppm of DEHA or 90 ppm DEHA/10 ppm posite Stabilizer is based on an alkyl hydroxylamine oxide,
TEAO.
optionally an alkyl hydroxylamine and an aromatic antioxi
0075) This molten UPE resin is then let down into a kettle dant and is present at 0.001-0.5 parts per 100 parts of the
containing inhibited styrene to thin the UPE resin to a finished UPE resin.
desired Viscosity. 4. The resin composition of claim 3, wherein the alkyl
0076 Samples of the thinned UPE resin were then hydroxylamine oxide is an (C-C) alkyl hydroxylamine
applied to Leneta paper and a draw down bar was used to oxide compound.
form a 1 mil coating of the formulated UPE resin on the 5. The resin composition of claim 3, wherein the alkyl
Linetta paper. The number of polystyrene particles per hydroxylamine is an (C-C) alkyl hydroxylamine com
square foot formed as a result of pouring the hot UPE resin pound.
into the Styrene was then examined using a black light 6. The resin composition of claim 4, wherein the alkyl
source (UV) to examine the black portion of the Leneta hydroxylamine oxide is triethylamine oxide (TEAO) or
Paper. tributylamine oxide (TBAO) or combinations thereof.
7. The resin composition of claim 5, wherein the alkyl
hydroxylamine is diethyl alkylhydroxylamine (DEHA)
Particle Density dibutylhydroxylamine (DBHA)or N-iso-propylhydroxy
Sample # Description DEHA TEAO (Particles/ft) lamine (NiPHA) or combinations thereof.
12215-30-1 Control 0 ppm 0 ppm 32 8. The resin composition of claim 3, wherein aromatic
12215-114-1 Formulated 0 ppm 100 ppm 16 antioxidant is a hindered phenol, quinone or phenothiazine
12215-32-1 Formulated 100 ppm 0 ppm 8 or combinations thereof.
12215-114-1 Formulated 90 ppm 10 ppm O
9. The resin of claim 1 wherein dicyclopentadiene is
added in the resin mixture.
0077. The combination of TEAO with DEHA completely 10. The resin composition of claim 2 that contains a cobalt
eliminated gel-particle formation in the Styrene. Salt as a primary promoter.
What is claimed is:
11. The composition of claim 2 wherein the amine is
1. A resin composition comprising: dimethyl aniline or diethyl aniline.
12. The resin composition of claim 1 that contains a
a. an unsaturated polyester peroxide catalyst.
b. a polymerizable monomer, 13. The composition of claim 10 that contains a peroxide
catalyst with active oxygen content from 0.05% to 50%.
c. a promoter System, and 14. An article that is produced from the composition of
d. a composite Stabilizer, wherein the composite Stabilizer claim 1 that is a gel-coat, marble or laminate.
is comprised of (i) a hydroxylamine oxide, and (ii)
optionally, a hydroxylamine.