Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Dokumen - Tips - Ieee c571200 A Dga DRM On Tap Changers For Ieee c571200 A Dga
Dokumen - Tips - Ieee c571200 A Dga DRM On Tap Changers For Ieee c571200 A Dga
00 –
DGA / DRM ON TAP-CHANGERS
FOR ROUTINE TESTS
IEEE C57.12.00 – DGA / DRM on Tap Changers for Routine Tests I Rainer Frotscher I 03/11/2014 I page 1 of 14
IEEE C57.12.00
Scope of Tests defined in C57.12.00 (Tap Changers)
Tap-Changer
Section Test Comment
Positions
only with first unit of new
Table 18 (Static) Resistance Measurement Min / N / Max design
IEEE C57.12.00 – DGA / DRM on Tap Changers for Routine Tests I Rainer Frotscher I 03/11/2014 I page 2 of 14
IEEE C57.12.00
Scope of Tests defined in C57.12.00 (Tap Changers)
Tap-Changer
Section Test Comment
Positions
only with first unit of new
Table 18 (Static) Resistance Measurement Min / N / Max design; method has been
voted out (Fall 2013)
Table 18/ Variable supply voltage, no
Ratio Test All
8.3.1. load
IEEE C57.12.00 – DGA / DRM on Tap Changers for Routine Tests I Rainer Frotscher I 03/11/2014 I page 3 of 14
IEEE C57.12.00
Proposal for Additional Tests
IEEE C57.12.00 – DGA / DRM on Tap Changers for Routine Tests I Rainer Frotscher I 03/11/2014 I page 4 of 14
IEEE C57.12.00
Proposal for Additional Tests
IEEE C57.12.00 – DGA / DRM on Tap Changers for Routine Tests I Rainer Frotscher I 03/11/2014 I page 5 of 14
IEEE C57.12.00
DGA on Tap Changers is not recommended for Routine Tests !
– During the test, the oil heats up and produces dissolved gases,
due to heating and/or catalytic effects
ð Gas patterns before and after the test(s) cannot be the same !
– DGA on Tap Changers is meaningful only for vacuum switching LTC types
ð conventional arc-switching LTC types cannot be tested this way
ð IEEE Standard is not generally applicable
– Limit values for DGA are type-specific
ð Different data sets, one for each tap-changer type/family/brand
ð Potential source for misinterpretation !
– Gas generation depends on application parameters
ð ”Normal” values vary with every application
ð Values which are normal for one type may indicate a fault for another type
IEEE C57.12.00 – DGA / DRM on Tap Changers for Routine Tests I Rainer Frotscher I 03/11/2014 I page 6 of 14
IEEE C57.12.00
Tap Changer Population – Big variety of types/models
Vacuum
Switching Technology
Arc
Arc-Breaking-in-Oil
Switching Technology
Reinhausen
OILTAP® V
In-Tank Type
Reinhausen Compartment Type
OILTAP® M
Reinhausen
VACUTAP® VR
Transition
Resistors
Transition
Reactance
IEEE C57.12.00 – DGA / DRM on Tap Changers for Routine Tests I Rainer Frotscher I 03/11/2014 I page 7 of 14
IEEE C57.12.00
DGA on Tap Changers
IEEE C57.12.00 – DGA / DRM on Tap Changers for Routine Tests I Rainer Frotscher I 03/11/2014 I page 8 of 14
IEEE C57.12.00
Winding Resistance Measurement
IEEE C57.12.00 – DGA / DRM on Tap Changers for Routine Tests I Rainer Frotscher I 03/11/2014 I page 9 of 14
IEEE C57.12.00
Dynamic Resistance Measurement (DRM)
IEEE C57.12.00 – DGA / DRM on Tap Changers for Routine Tests I Rainer Frotscher I 03/11/2014 I page 10 of 14
IEEE C57.12.00
Dynamic Resistance Measurement (DRM)
IEEE C57.12.00 – DGA / DRM on Tap Changers for Routine Tests I Rainer Frotscher I 03/11/2014 I page 11 of 14
IEEE C57.12.00
Dynamic Resistance Measurement (DRM)
“Higher”
Source: Raka Levi, “Dynamic Resistance Measurement applied to On-Load Tap Changers”
IEEE C57.12.00 – DGA / DRM on Tap Changers for Routine Tests I Rainer Frotscher I 03/11/2014 I page 12 of 14
IEEE C57.12.00
Dynamic Resistance Measurement (DRM)
IEEE C57.12.00 – DGA / DRM on Tap Changers for Routine Tests I Rainer Frotscher I 03/11/2014 I page 13 of 14
IEEE C57.12.00
Dynamic Resistance Measurement (DRM)
bridging to non-bridging
Start motor drive non-bridging to bridging bridging to non-bridging
IEEE C57.12.00 – DGA / DRM on Tap Changers for Routine Tests I Rainer Frotscher I 03/11/2014 I page 14 of 14