Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • MPE Sterilizer

    Uploaded by

    Chou Chou
    3 views5 pages
    The document contains a table comparing different sterilization methods based on 12 metrics such as investment costs, operational costs, sterilization time, and oil content. It calculates index values for each metric across vertical, continuous, and horizontal+indexer sterilization methods. The horizontal+indexer method has the lowest total index value of 17.4488600537581, indicating it performs best across the metrics. A second table compares oil extraction methods and also calculates a total superiority index, finding clay waterbath and hydrocyclone methods are superior to other options like manual extraction.

    Original Description:

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    XLSX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Report this Document
    The document contains a table comparing different sterilization methods based on 12 metrics such as investment costs, operational costs, sterilization time, and oil content. It calculates index values for each metric across vertical, continuous, and horizontal+indexer sterilization methods. The horizontal+indexer method has the lowest total index value of 17.4488600537581, indicating it performs best across the metrics. A second table compares oil extraction methods and also calculates a total superiority index, finding clay waterbath and hydrocyclone methods are superior to other options like manual extraction.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as XLSX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    3 views5 pages

    MPE Sterilizer

    Uploaded by

    Chou Chou
    The document contains a table comparing different sterilization methods based on 12 metrics such as investment costs, operational costs, sterilization time, and oil content. It calculates index values for each metric across vertical, continuous, and horizontal+indexer sterilization methods. The horizontal+indexer method has the lowest total index value of 17.4488600537581, indicating it performs best across the metrics. A second table compares oil extraction methods and also calculates a total superiority index, finding clay waterbath and hydrocyclone methods are superior to other options like manual extraction.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as XLSX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    of 5

    Indeks Nilai Beban

    No Tolok ukur Tingkat Kepentingan Continues Horizontal +Indexer


    1 Investment Costs 8 1.125 1.019
    2 Operational Costs 6 1.24 1.41
    3 Sterilization time 4 0.4096 0.8145
    4 Oil in Liquor 3 0.0392 0.047
    5 Oil in Emply Bunch 3 0.02 0.04
    6 Oil in Condensates 3 0.1081 0.114
    7 Man Power 6 0.5 1
    8 Steam Consumption 2 1.1429 1.1556
    9 Electricity in Strelizer 3 1.2857 1.4286
    10 Wastes (limbah) 3 0.63 0.5
    11 Working Culture/Habit 5 1.6 1.1
    12 Additional Investment 8 1 1
    ilai Beban Indeks Nilai
    Vertical Continues Horizontal +Indexer Vertical
    1 2.565784514 1.162501366456 1
    1 3.6352150774 7.858047974841 1
    1.2155 0.0281474977 0.440113159805063 2.1828296923
    0.0536 6.023629E-05 0.000103823 0.0001539907
    0.06 0.000008 0.000064 0.000216
    0.131 0.0012632144 0.001481544 0.002248091
    0.75 0.015625 1 0.1779785156
    1.1905 1.30622041 1.33541136 1.41729025
    1.2857 2.1252935868 2.915626825656 2.1252935868
    0.48 0.250047 0.125 0.110592
    1.4 10.48576 1.61051 5.37824
    1.2 1 1 4.29981696
    NPE = 21.413424537 17.4488600537581 17.694659086

    Beban yang paling kecil adalah Horizontal + Indexer Sterilizer


    Indeks Nilai Keunggulan
    Pengambilan
    Clay Waterbath
    No Tolok ukur Tingkat Kepentingan Dengan Tangan
    1 Efficiency 8 0.53 0.6
    2 Moisture content 3 0.094 0.089
    3 Shell/fibre content 3 0.092 0.094
    4 FFA content 3 0.094 0.091
    Indeks Nilai Keunggulan Indeks Nilai
    Separator Pneumatic Pengambilan Separator
    Hydrocyclone Clay Waterbath
    Mekanik Separator Dengan Tangan Mekanik
    0.74 0.9 0.96 0.00622596904 0.01679616 0.08991947402
    0.096 0.097 0.096 0.000830584 0.000704969 0.000884736
    0.096 0.098 0.097 0.000778688 0.000830584 0.000884736
    0.095 0.097 0.096 0.000830584 0.000753571 0.000857375

    Total Keunggulan 0.00866582504 0.019085284 0.09254632102

    Beban yang paling kecil adalah Horizontal + Indexer Sterilizer

    0.00866582504 0.019085284 0.09254632102

    0.00866582504
    0.019085284
    0.09254632102
    0.433233748
    0.72407172398
    ks Nilai
    Pneumatic
    Hydrocyclone
    Separator
    0.43046721 0.721389579
    0.000912673 0.000884736
    0.000941192 0.000912673
    0.000912673 0.000884736

    0.433233748 0.724071724

    0.433233748 0.724071724

    You might also like