Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Nutrition in Thailand
Nutrition in Thailand
DigitalCommons@USU
5-1966
Nutrition in Thailand
Methee Larptavee
Utah State University
Recommended Citation
Larptavee, Methee, "Nutrition in Thailand" (1966). All Graduate Plan B and other Reports. 824.
https://digitalcommons.usu.edu/gradreports/824
by
Methee Larptavee
of
MASTER OF SCIENCE
in
Plan B
1966
ACKNOWLE
DGMENT
I do appreciate Dean Phy lli s R. Snow and Mrs. Grace Smith for
their support, advice, and app ro val of this thesis so it can appear
as it is .
Methee Larptavee
TABLEOF CONTENTS
Page
INTRODUCTION
CONCLUSIONS
AND RECOMMENDATIONS 46
LITERATURECITED 51
APPENDIX 53
LIST OF TABLES
Table Page
Figure Page
10. Mean number of decayed, mi ssi ng, and filled teeth per
person by age - males and females combined 33
Cambodia (Figure 1). It has a long coast line as one strip of land
reaches out into the sea. It has a warm climate with much rain,
espec ially in the south. There are 27 mil lion people in th e area of
200,000 square miles. Rice rank s number one in the Thailand diet.
Since the results covered only a sma ll seg ment of the populat ion, a
number of surveys have since been made which were direct ed toward
eve r made in Thailand was the work of the Interdepartment a l Commi ttee
education in nutrition .
2
Burma
Ardamen Sea
Malaya ~
Figure l. The map of Thai land (Berry, 1962, p. VI).
NUTRITION OF THAI PEOPLE
in 1960 a follow-up survey was made of the people in the first vil -
lage studied.
lation was divided into two gro ups, A and B, group B being relatively
more prosperous than group A. The people were asked to measure their
Every house had a fish pond and raised chickens and ducks, but
three out of five of the eggs from the pou ltr y were sold. Every
family had some type of kitchen garden , including banana trees and
some edible plants. However, much of the garden space was used to
raise seasoning (herbs, etc.) and chili which were the preferred
plants. Swamp cabbage, the green leafy vegetable used most often,
Pou l try , oxen , and oth er flesh foods were us ed occasiona ll y . Foods,
Fruits an d desserts were considered as chi ld re n's snacks and were not
preferred by adults.
during tra nsplan ti ng and harvesting at which times per capita calorie
Since rice was cooked in excess water, and the c ooking water was
changes in the tongue , lip s , skin an d ha ir, and absence of knee and
Bang Chan e l ementary school child r en, both boys and girls, were
not as tall as the urban Thai children of the same age. Moreover,
both sexes and all ages. More than half of them did not eat a regu-
lar lunch .
Of 226 Bang Chan children whose teeth were examined, 68 per cent
school children as compared to six per cent of children six years old
per ce ntages : xerosis of the skin, 15; enlarged liver, 9; hair that
North and North East sections of Thailand were shown to be below the
(1959).
and Ubon and Udorn in the North East. The serious deficiencies, in
and vitamin C. The daily intakes of niacin, iron, iodine, calo .ries,
Tab le 1.
Ubon villages 86 93 15 87 28 27 23 69 26
Udorn villages 81 78 17 78 44 34 22 73 45
Chieng mai
villages 92 95 22 91 56 41 23 73 74
Chieng rai
villages 79 75 17 75 72 38 17 67 46
highly milled glutinous rice. Goiter was also found in this survey.
Dietary su rvey in the Roya l Thai Army, 1955-1956
1955-56. 6905 men aged 21-22 were weighed. Average weight was 55
kg. Food consumption was observed. Total calories per capita aver-
aged 3000 with which 80 per cent of the calories coming from rice.
below the United States standard set by the National Research Council
in 1948.
(1959). The naval personnel were classified into three groups ac-
The survey was made in three periods of four months each, so that each
unit was surveyed at three different times of the year for each daily
tions on rice consumption and method of cooking the rice were made.
half of the total weight of food taken, A poor intake of animal pro-
tein, fat and fruits among some classes of naval personnel was ob-
served.
8
Methods of cookin g the rice for the various groups are shown in
Table 2. The wate r used in cooking the rice was discarded by some
2. Sailors and
Marines:
Fleet person- White, highly Once Open type; excess cook -
nel milled ing water discarded.
Shore person- Moder;,tely Twice Open type; excess cook-
nel milled ing water discarded.
which consumed the rice that had the cooking water discarded (Table
3). The high incidence of beriberi for sailors and marines, as com-
methods.
9
1. Anemia of nutri-
tional origin 1 18 19
3. Cholecystitis - 2 2
4. Glossitis,
Che ilitis 2 32 34
5 . Hypertension - 26 26
6. Stomatitis - 27 27
7. B-complex deficiency - 1 1
8. Scurvy 1 2 _3
Total 9 295 304
The 1957 studies of mother and infant nutrition and health were
toxemia in the mother, and neonatal death of the infant were caused
10
proteins.
the age of seven months, about 85 per cent of these infants were
being fed cooked rice as the main supplement. Other foods such as
eggs, pork, other meat, vegetables and fruits were given but in very
small amounts compared with the amount of rice. When infants were
given supplemental foods, milk intake was reduced. Only 15 per cent
soup. In this study eggs were used by 75 per cent of the people
while animal liver was not used . Bananas and oranges were given
frequently.
status of the population, and availabi l ity of food resources with the
full even during the depression. The foods came from every town and
city. However, the average food intake was somewhat low when compared
11
Urban diets were more nutritious than those of rural areas be-
1957-58 in six different rural parts and one of the most crowded part
It was found that more than 90 per cent of the babies in the
rural area and 66 per cent of the babies in Bangkok were breast fed
rice, fruits and some kind of protein food at a very early age. The
in 100 gm. Egg and lean pork were used as the protein supp l ement.
Bangkok ( urban) 1409 47 42 208 180 7.3 1678 0.82 0.61 10. 2 60
Chiengmai (N) 1851 46 23 365 354 8.4 1368 0 .80 0.80 12.0 87
,...
N
13
boys, 587 of whom were under and 520 of whom were over 15 years of
age; a l so 1282 gir l s with 6 11 under and 671 over 15 years of age.
The 4325 military personnel ave r aged 22 years of age. The l ocation
km f rom a town. For the boys and g irl s in the survey, food intakes
tabulated. Food resources were rice , fish , meat and some vegetables.
Rice was mainl y consumed as milled r eg ular rice and glutinous r ice .
Except for iron and calories, glutinous rice was superior to regular
ric e. Fish were caught along the sea coasts of the Andamen Sea and
the Gulf of Siam, along th e rivers, lakes, canals, and from fish
tables were not in the regular daily menu. Fruits were often us ed for
raw and half cooked but among the military, foods were well cooked .
Rain, wells, and canal wat e r were us ed in the areas where a supply of
running water was not available. Large a luminum tanks (for civi li ans)
and cement tanks (for militar y) were general ly used to coll ec t rain
that of the military, perhaps b eca use the civilian groups in c lud ed
14
people of all ages, from one year to old age. The findings of the
(Berry, 1962, p. 35) reported that Ramalin gaswami found the incidence
rapid death or the child made a rapid recovery. The loss of deep
associated with beriberi. One per cent of the subjects showed this
civilians. The mean intake was 0.24 mg per 1000 calories for the
3). Angular lesions at the corners of the mouth were observed among
both civilian and military groups in every area studied, the higher
Ubol and Chiengmai. Among the military, angular lesions were more
compared to the incidence for a ll older men (one per cent). Among
per cent for both males and females 5 to 9 years of age (Table 6).
16
efi- I Accept-
cient •Low able High- 1. Chiengmai
2. Udorn
No. of Subjects 3. Ubol
1 --- --, 96 4. Lopburi
2 127 5. Bangkok
3 123
4 60 6. Sattaheep
7 107 7. Songkh l a
513
i===J Civilian
(ZZZZZJ Military
~ !'-,,'-r+-rr~~ LO.
21"-7''-+-,,<..,,,_,,.-,,.....,,_.,'-r'+-.,,_.,~
l l'-,<'-,L--,L-,,,_,,.'-,''-,1-~
7 912
I
Deficient I Low Acceptab l e
I I
: No . of Subject~
~ f--~~~~~~~~~--' 96 1. Chiengma i
127 2. Udorn
123
i 1---~----'-- 60 3. Ubo l
71--------I 107 4.
5.
Lopburi
Bangkok
513
6. Sattaheep
7. Songkhla
r:::==:::=J
Civilian
cz::::z::z::a
Milit ary
9 12
Males 3.0 12 . 2 10 . 7 6. 3 2, 3
Females, lactating 4. 2
well with th e dietary and biochemical findings, nor was any exp lan a-
tion readily apparent for the higher incidence in the 5 to 9 year old
children. However, children of this age group had the highest ribo-
median excretion for the civi li an grou p was 30 mcg per gm which was
day for both the military and civ ilian groups (Figure 4) , However,
infectious diseases will cause anemia even when iron intake is high.
19
D L A
e o c1
fr: Cl High
i I el
c I I pl
i I It 1
e l Ia
1
n I I bl 1. Chiengmai
I 111 2. Udorn
I
e 3. Ubol
1 96 4. Lopburi
2 127 5. Bangkok
3 123
6. Sat taheep
1 189 7. Songkhla
Total 513
~~~~!Civilian
1
2
3
4
5
6 361
7
Tota
0 9 18 27 36 45 54 63 72 81 90 99
Mean hemoglobin v a lues for the military were fairly good with a
values with their mean being 11 . 6 gm (Figure 5). More civilians than
military showed signs of anemia; 22 per cent had hemoglobins below ten
hookworm, and liver flukes were all observed with appreciable fre-
quencies . Many subjects were infested with more than one parasite .
Less than ten per cent of either group was completely free of
glo delineated a "goiter belt" during his studies from 1933 to 1951
goiter were 58, 58, 21, and 15 per cent among people in Chiengmai,
deficient subjects .
35 I
Deficient Low I Acceptab l e High ---,.
I
I
30 I
25 t==t Civilian
ther e were one and th r ee per cent visib l e goiter and 13 and 20 per
force, one per cent visible goiter and eight per cent invisib le
goiter; in the navy, two per cent visib l e go i ter and 14 per cent
Tab l e 7. Regardless of the age group, Chiengmai and Ubol areas had
goiter but the younger children did not show this high frequency .
having goiters.
Songkh l a 81 0 90 0 94 0 116 2
Lopburi 41 2 33 6 34 12 58 43
data in Table 8.
131 127
Table 8. 1 uptake and 1 excretion among the Thai militarya
131
Mean 1
Site No. of Mean and No. of Mean and uptake for
Province area subiects S.D. subiects S.D. this grouo
Udorn 15 59:: 7 . 2 -- -- --
Washington, D.C. -- -- 15 180:'.57. 7 --
aBerry, 1962, p. 49.
131
The mean uptakes of 1 for both civilian and military subjects
in Songkhla and Bangkok were lower than in the Chiengmai areas which
131 131
had the highest mean uptake of 1 The normal mean for 1 uptake
127
should fall within the range of 30 to 45 per cent. Excretion of 1
by all groups of the Thai military was much lower than was found for
subjects in Washington, D.C . The reason for the low urinary iodine
values was not clear . There was evidence that goiter was mor e preva-
lent in females than in males . There was also evidence that iodine
24
"acc e ptabl e " l eve ls, that is, in excess of one gram per kg in eve ry
gro up studied, for both the military and civilian subjects . Bio -
che mi cal ana l ysis for serum a lbumin for each of both group s atta in ed
see med satisfa ctory. However, a lar ge proportion of the total prot e in
int ake was of vegetab l e origin, principally rice. During the sur vey
it was found that, among both mi li tary and civi l ian groups, an ave r age
angular l es ion s, and ocular l es ions assoc i ated with v it amin A defi-
ciency were found among the lower socio-economic group. The ass ocia-
tion between kwashiorkor a nd xer ophth a lmia had been empha s i zed by
oth e r workers.
vitamin A intake among both military and civilian group s was in the
"de fici e nc y " and "lo w" ranges res pect i ve l y (Figure 6), th e mea n
25
1
?
J
Deficient I
I
!
Low
' ~8
!Acceptab l e : High
I No. o~ Subjects
19
I
- 1.
2.
Chiengrnai
Udorn
4 l' u I I
3. Ubol
7 23 1 4. Lopburi
Total I 93 j I 5. Songkhla
l 6. Sattaheep
I
I I 7. Songkh l a
I
I I I c=:=:=Jci vilian
l 1T7 7777A 527
I e2:.Z.Z..21Military
2 1777 777'! lll7I I I
i ,,
7.,.
7 77771
/////
156 I I
838
5 7 777'"71 l 495
6 1 /// ///
I 361
I I
]// ////J
I 912 I l
-, -7 77711 4402
Total 17T7 I
I
I
I
I I
I I I
I I
I I
I I
I
I I
I
1000
!
2000 3000
I
I
4000
.
l
5000 6000
calculated serum vitamin A and serum carotene values showed that al-
most all groups fell into the "acceptable" range. Very few subjects
were in the very high or very low ranges. There was a gradual rise
A total of eight cases of Bitof ' s spots was seen in all age
groups among the civilians, six of which were in the moslem village
although the survey did not find it. The January-June 1960 Semi-
developed.
vitamin C intakes were in the ranges of low and acceptable (Figure 7).
The mean serum values for vitamin C in the various locations were
10 to 18 per cent of the civilian men and women over 15 years of age.
27
Def i- : I
cient
I
Low I Acceptable High ---->-
I
No. cit Subjects
l I 96 l. Chiengmai
2 I I 127 2. Udorn
3 I I 123
4 60 3. Ubol
7 I
I 107 4. Lopburi
I
Total I 513 5. Bangkok
I 6. Sattaheep
I
I 7. Songkhla
I
I
I I
1
j
4
/////////!
///////..11
//////
'./////////Al
I
I 1m
527
R38
Civilian
V 7 77 %Military
5 I/ / / / / / / / / / / / 495
6 //////I 361
7 //////////1 912
Total ///////// 4402
I I I
I
I I
I I I
I I I
I I
I I I
I I
I I
I I I 1
10 20 }O do 50
1
60
Age (years)
0-4 5-9 10-14 15-44 45+
Males:
Serum vitamin C, mg/100 ml 0.46 0.86 0.94 0. 70 0.68
Percentage with low values 14 .3 -- -- 1. 9 5.3
Females:
Serum vitamin C, mg/100 ml 0.58 0.82 1.03 0.85 0.63
Percentage with low values 22.2 -- 5.0 -- --
aBerry, 1962.
Fewer cases were found in the younger age groups. For the military
prevalent among the older civilian gro ups, 30 to 58 per cent, than
intake figures which included those for children were 266-278 mg per
among all army units combined was 1,422 mg per man per day, and among
all civilian groups combined was 658 mg per person per day.
Fat and cholesterol. Average fat intake was low among both
civilian and military groups (Figure 8). However, there was wide
variation from family to family, and from area to area. The mean
cholesterol level was 128 mg per 100 ml of serum for 24 children less
than 15 years of age, and 132 mg for 38 adult civilians. Only one
child had cholesterol values which exceeded 200 mg. This was a girl
Salt intake and blood pressure. Sea salt intake was considered
salt was 9 gm per person per day for civilian, and 18 gm per person
per day for military. This might be due to the preferenc e of high
seaso nings and the use of much salted fish by the Thai people.
The mean blood pressure among the military for all groups com-
bined based on 880 subjects was 117 and 74 mm of mercury for the
No. of Subjects
1 1. Chiengmai
2 2. Udorn
3 3. Ubol
4 4. Lopburi
7 107
5. Bangkok
Total 513
6. Sattaheep
7. songkhla
1
2
r:::=:==:=J
Civilian
3 I/// ,1 Military
4
5 495
6
7
Total
0 10 20 30 40 50 60
provided a mean of 118 and 73, with a range of mean systolic pres-
Then the values were 142/81 mm for men and 134/82 mm for women.
0.80 ppm. Fluoride in urine samples ranged from 0.78 to 2.92 ppm.
Thus fluoride intake was not from water alone. Dental fluorosis was
low in the south but high in the north where dental decay and the
dental decay and DMF number (Figure 10) . By age 33, 50 per cent of
the civilian males were affected and 45 per cent of the females.
Only 20 per cent of the military of this age group had developed
among the military was considered to be the result of the oral hy-
The number of decayed, missing and filled teeth per person was
extremely low compared with the levels in the United States. These
low DMF levels (below two) were constant until after 40 years of age
when there was a sharp rise due to the loss of teeth caused by
periodontal disease.
32
100
/
""' 90 I
"'"
U) I
I
·~
///
-0
..... 80
"'
'-'
c I I
0
,//
-0
0
·~ 70
"0."
·~";,
'-'
<.J
60
I
I
//
I
""
'-'
U)
//'
"
-0
50
..c:
'-'
·~
:,
I
//
I
----
U)
/I
c 40
0
U)
Civilian males
""
0. I I t--- __ _.
.... Civilian fema l es
0 30
I
I
'
I
"Oil Military males
~
c
"
<.J
""
20 //
I/
0. / I
10 j
_/j'
0
5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60
Age in yea rs
24
22
20 Th a il a nd
"o ,a o Ba l t imo r e , Md ., U. S . A.
...
<I) 18
<11
a.
...
<11
a. 16
,;=;
<11
<11 14
"
.,:,
<11
.-<
....
.-<
4..;
12
.,:,
""' 10
"°
....
"
<I)
<I)
8
·g
.,:,
Q) 6
>,
"'
u
Q)
.,:,
4..;
4
o
...
Q)
.D 2
z
9
Age in yea r s
In 1960 Bang Chan village was revisited by Hauck and the 1960
They found that the food consumed was somewhat lik e that observed in
was cooked in excess water, and the cooking water was usually dis-
carded. Fish was the food next in abundance. The highest intake of
protein occurred in the post-harvest season, when the fish ponds were
drained. Nearly all the families raised chicke ns and some raised
were much more commonly grown than vegetab l es and fruits. Swamp cab -
bage, the green leafy vegetable used most often, grew wild in the
cana l s.
Over 90 per cent of children ate snacks which usually were des-
lactating, and for infant feeding, were much lik e those in 1952.
Only some women omitted some kinds of food. During the postpartum
rest period most women ate a very strict diet which made them prone
tion most women ate the family diet. Breast feeding for most infants
was continued into the second year. Half of the infants had been
weaned by 18 months and nine-tenths of them by the time they were two
35
The signs observed among Bang Chan people were generally those
vitamin A. These were the same as those found in the 1952 survey.
However, there was neither beriberi nor loss of ankle jerk or knee
males were lower than the average found in the general Thailand
survey of 1952 . Total serum protein and serum hemoglobin values were
hypochromic anemia was also found in the Bang Chan follow-up study.
adults. This condition began at a very early age and rapidly pro-
OF THE THAIS
Then the United States infants showed somewhat better growth than the
Thai infants.
11) continued to be lower than that for United States males (Berry,
The Thai people are relatively small in sta tur e compared with
American people rises steadily until the age of 60 and 70. These dif-
Of the liv e births 50 per cent of the Thai were dead by age 15 years
Table 10 . Data on ave r age weight and height of Thai and American
infants 8
Thai American
Age in Weight Height Weight Height
months kg cm kg cm
12 8 . 76 73.3 9.5 74 . l
60
55
50
45
40
35
30
00
c.., 25
-"00
..,
~ 20
15
10
l 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
Age (years)
Figure 11. Average weight of Thai male children compared with those
of United States (Berry, 1962, p. 16).
39
65
60
55
so
~ 45
:=,
..,
_,::
-~
~
40 0 0 u .s.
:,:
Thai
35
30
15 25 35 45 55 65 75
Age (years)
45
"
.,.
4...
.....
4...
0 40
...
"'
"
;,,
.., 35
....
"'
,.
4...
00
30
.,.
c:
...
::>
25 0 -----<O
"' U.S.A. - 1958
"'
.c
µ
"' 20
"'"
.....
µ
µ
"'
0
4...
0
µ
c:
"u
...
"
0..
12
Age (month s)
NEEDEDCALORIES,PROTEIN, MINERALS,
ANDVITAMINS
to the Thai people and their food values as obtained from food tables
of Chatfie l d (1954), Watts and Merrill (1963), and Wenkam and Miller
easiest way the average housewife can be assured of giving her family
a good diet is to use the Basic Four Food Groups (Page and Phipard,
1957). The use of the minimum number of servings listed for each of
the food groups forms a foundation for a good diet . Workers in other
countries have adapted this plan using foods common to their locali-
lar chart is used with native foods in Hawaii. Such a guide provides
Small fish of several kinds often are the best source of calcium .
curd (tofu) are the next best sources . These foods form group l in
Figure 14 . This group also would provide protein and the B-vitamins .
In the second group high quality protein, iron, and the B-vita-
mins are provided . This group is for muscle bui l ding, blood building
for children, and for adolescents. Fish, pork, chicken, ducks , and
43
1. 2.
small fish fish
crustaceans poultry, eggs
crabs meat - liver, kidney,
mullusks heart, etc .
shrimp peanuts, cashew nuts
soybean curd gree n cow peas
green mustard pigeon peas
dry sesame seeds soybean, broad bean
okra dry mung bean seeds
mung beans green lima beans
mollasses dry hyacinth bean
seaweeds seeds
milk : cow, goat other nuts
4. 3.
vita-rice or par- spinach cauliflower
boiled white rice swamp cabbage taro l eaves
coconut turnips cararnbola
enriched bread or ripe tomato pummelo
whole cereal bread squash cabbage
sweet corn pumpkin sorrel
sweet potatoes
-=-=-=-="'----'--"--""'-'c..=.:'-"''--'::.:.:."-'"""---"'
a~nd~ 1 gree n onions
carrots ~G~r~o~u~p'--"'--':.::.;~:c::.:""-~
mangoes
guava
Figur e 14. Food for health in Thailand. Eat foods from each group
daily.
44
eggs are the best anim a l sources in Thailand. Beef is used also.
Liver, heart, and kidneys are especia ll y rich and should be used .
Other foods that may be used for protein are dry mature seeds of
beans (dry mature seeds), broad beans, cashew nuts, and lima beans
(immature).
shou l d supp l y over half the vitamin A and all of the vitamin C
The use of three to four servings per week of dark green leafy
carrots, white mustard, snap beans, lim a beans, broad beans, spin -
ach, swamp cabbage, sweet potatoes, tanger ines, ripe tomatoes, and
squash.
vitamin C sho uld be eaten every day. Vegetab les and fruits high in
is needed. Parboiled rice and enriched rice under the name "Vita-
The people should be taught to cook rice with just enough water so
age, size, sex, and activity as we ll as the amount of starchy and high
be exp l ained on the back of the "Food for Health" Chart (Figure 14).
CONCLUSIONS
ANDRECOMMENDATIONS
ferent fami li es, makes it hard to surrnnarize and draw conclusions con -
data for each of the surveys made by the Thai public health officers
and by the American survey team were obtained from military person-
nel, from different areas of Bangkok, and from farmers and people in
of nutrients.
2. Calorie intake from carbohydrate and fat sources was ade qu ate.
Education must be emphasized to see that these foods carry more than
rice other than highly polished white rice must be encouraged. Calo-
day for the civilians, and 59 gm to 150 gm per man per day for the
47
albumin levels are low and globulin levels high. This is because
animal sources. Too often rice protein is the main protein source.
couraged. Poultry and eggs are available but are often sold by the
farmers who raise them. Excess heat should be avoided in the cooking
ment of ways of processing or using more kinds of fish from the sea
4. Calcium intake is 675 mg per man per day for the military .
The civilian intake is not quite so clear with the mean intake of
266 mg per person per day, and with considerable differences among
communities.
Small fish when eaten whole are the best source of calcium in
Thailand.
tions are improved, raw vegetables and other raw foods could then be
safely eaten.
person per day for civilians and 1800 IU per man per day for military
turnips, swamp cabbage, and mangoes are good sources of vitamin A and
are plentiful.
for civilians and 0.64 mg per 1000 calories for the military. The
rich foods cooked in a small quantity of water and until just done
should be stressed.
civilian groups. Children five to nine years of age had the highest
day in every location observed. Infants Oto four years of age have
the lowest vitamin C serum level. The serum levels of the military
encouraged.
tension has not been established. It is found that death rate from
disease is doubted.
tion in nutrition and work in the field of public health are needed
50
body would make the "Food for Health" chart more useful. Foods
native to each area of the country that can be used in each food
Recormnended a ll owance,
me n, 70 kg, U.S. 1963 2900 70 800 10 5000 1. 2 1. 7 19 70
Animal resources
Meat
Beef, medium 217 14.9 9 1. 8 30 0.05 0 . 13 3. 1 0
Veal, medium 146 15.l 9 1.8 20 0.11 0 . 20 5.0 0
Pork, medium 396 10.4 6 1. 2 0 0 . 36 0.10 2.4 0
Buffa l o, carcass-lean 80 12.8 7 1. 9 0 0.05 0.11 3 .0 0
Poultry
Chick en, dressed, not
drawn 122 12.3 7 0.9 250 0.06 0.10 4.9 0
Duck s, dressed , not
drawn 205 10 8 1.1 540 0.05 0.12 3.5 0
~
Hen-in she ll 144 11 44 2. 2 890 0.09 0. 27 0.1 0
Duck-in she ll 164 11. 3 so 2 .4 1040 0. 13 0.26 0.1 0
Fish and she llfi sh
All unspecified-fillet 132 18.8 31 1.0 so 0 . 06 0 . 15 2.5 0
All unspecifi ed-round 62 8.8 15 0. 5 20 0.03 0.07 1. 2 0
Fish 1 medium cured
Larg e f i sh , bone not
eaten 178 27 54 1. 6 70 0 . 07 0.24 3.0 0
Sma ll fish , bone eaten 261 40 1600 2.4 100 0.1 0.36 4.4 0
Canned fish in oi l 314 22 44 1. 3 110 0.06 0.20 2.6 0
Crustac e ans, cann e d 92 17 . 5 108 1.8 0 0 . 02 0.09 1.4 0 ,,_
u,
·~
Vitamin C
Table 11. Continued
v,
00
Table 11 . Continued
"'
Table 11. Continued
by
Methee Larptavee
of
MASTEROF SCIENCE
in
Plan B
Approved:
UTAHSTATE UNIVERSITY
Logan, Utah
1966
TABLEOF CONTENTS
Page
INTRODUCTION
.
REVIEWOF LITERATURE
INTERNATIONAL
SUPPLIES OF AVAILABLEPROTEIN 20
CONCLUSION
ANDRECOMMENDATION 29
SUMMARY 32
LITERATURECITED 33
LIST OF TABLES
Table Page
Figure Page
plied from local foods which fit the prevailing cultural and religious
few years medical science has made much progress and has lowered
death rates . In those countries where the birth rate is high and
maternal and child health. Poor diet often leads to nutritional dis-
eases.
REVIEWOF LITERATURE
ing (a) 7 per cent wheat protein and (b) 18 per cent mixed protein to
feed rats during gestation and lactation . It was found that the 7
per cent wheat diet severely affected the quantity of milk produced
mortality. Pups born to rats receiving the 18 per cent mixed protein
diet but suckled by mothers receiving the 7 per cent wheat protein
diet showed very high mortality and l ow weaning weight. Among those
born to mothers receiving the per cent wheat protein diet but
suckled by rats receiving the 18 per cent mixed protein diet, the
mortality was less and the weaning weight higher than in those of the
above group. The highest weaning weight was shown in rats born to
and suckled by mothers r eceiving the 18 per cent mixed protein diet.
found that in the offspring of all three strains, the low-protein diet
ing, reduction in the size of the molars, delay in third molar erup-
onine to the low protein diet throughout the reproduction cycle led
wean ing. These might be due to low dietary intake, poor absorption,
normal. There was some impa irm ent of protein absorption but greater
women were taller and generally healthier, and had lar ger and healthi-
perinatal mortality rate . For lower weight gains there was a higher
pregnancy, giving a total of some 950 gm, was needed for the formation
4
of new maternal tissues, foetal growth and maintenance, and for the
the last two trimesters was thus 5 gm to which 20 per cent should be
gm of reference protein per day owing to the fact that human milk
contains 1.2 gm of protein per 100 ml and most women secreted 850 to
1200 ml of milk daily. Thus, the upper limit of daily protein output
Fat storage during 10, 20, 30, and 40 weeks of pregnancy was
weight by average healthy well-fed Scottish women for the same peri-
ods of pregnancy, 10, 2Q, 30, and 40 weeks was 650, 4000, 8500, and
12,500 gm.
the WHOExpert Committee (1965, p,. 22) cited the information that
Illsley and Kincaid in the United Kingdom, and O'Brien and Shelton in
sional men were tall (165 cm or more) while only 26 per cent of the
5
Placenta 2 16 60 100
Liquid 0 0.5 2 3
Breasts 9 36 72 81
wives of semi - ski lled and unskilled men were this tall . Similar find-
ings were observed in the United States. Short women among the
1965, p. 23) had babies about eight per cent lighter on the average
then tall women and underweight women had babies eight per cent
Tall and heavy women had babies about 14 per cent heavi er than short
between ethnic groups are inf lu enced by genetic differ ences. Just
how much may he due to enviro nmental or to genetic diff erences is not
c l ear.
6
Weight-for-
heightb
Mean birth
weight of
all infants 3101 3228 3373 3241
awHO Report No. 302, 1965, p. 22.
b"Underweight" was in the lowest 25 per cent of the distribution
of weight according to height.
"Overweight" was in the upper quartile.
"Average" consisted of the remaining 50 per cent.
economic gradient. The rates are low where the standard of living is
high and high where the standard of living is low. There are excep-
begins to increase.
The relation between lo w birth weight and mortality rate at the be-
1000 20 90 22 68 32 87.5
All under
2500 403 14 .1 1480 7. 7 2271 9. 1
mittee ( 1965) in Table 4. They have also summarized and reported the
Austra l ia, United States, Israel , and Egypt) the prot ei n intake was
Tab l e 4.
In India and New Guinea, protein intake was only one - fifth to
co
Table 5. Summary of r epo rted diets of pregnant womena
Tri - Protein
Country mester Year Subjects Calories gm
New Guinea
(Chimbu) In poor condition 1490 19
(Ajamaroe) 1958 In poor circumstances 1450 31
(Waropen) In poor circumstances 1170 15
United States, Great Britain, Norway, India, and Holland with Japan
and Central America being only slightly lower. Canada and South
verting the actual weight into the age in months to which it cor -
weight per day was satisfactory for gain in weight in severely mal-
seed oil and cane sugar, maintaining the same relative proportion of
out edema, the protein intake was increased by substituting milk and
desired gain in weight at least 125 kcal per kg body weight per day
was needed. Increases in calories above 150 kcal per kg did not
Developmental
quotient % Intake in kcal per kg per day
75 100 125 - 130 150 175
( - wt.age x 100) Average weight gain in gm per day
age
10 - 29 -14 10 22 29 39
30 - 49 -14 11 30 39 -
50 or more 5 19 34 55 -
30 or above for the 125 kcal per kg or for lower developmenta l quo-
tients the calorie intake had to be 175 kcal per kg per day (Table
did not meet the minimum requirement for many infants. However, at
The effects of protein from both anima l and vegetable origin are
fact that this difference was not evident at the higher levels of
pr otein mixtu r e was utilized more efficie n tly when additional ca l ories
wer e provided.
12
Table 7. Effect of protein intake and nut ritio nal state on weight
gai n at different l eve ls of ca loric intakea
Developmental
quotient
Protein In take in kcal per kg per dav
wt.age x 100) int ake 75 100 125- 130 150 17 5
(=
age gm/kg/day Average wei ght gain in gm per day
30-4 9 Vegetable
o r mixed 2.0 or le ss - - 26 39 -
Cow 1 s milk
2 . 0 or l ess - 26 11 33 43 -
Cow ' s mi lk ove r 2 .0 3 - 33 37 -
50 or more Vege tab l e
or mi xed 2 . 0 or less 10 21 37 55 -
Cow' s milk2.0 or less 1 17 32 - -
Cow's milk over 2 . 0 - - 23 - -
<Gr aham~ .§!l. , 1963, p . 253.
13
acid for infants. Weight gain and nitrogen retention were depressed
nutrition of the NRC Food and Nutrition Board (1964) stated that:
diseases.
infancy were based on the fact that growth of human brain at time of
birth was largely dependent upon protein synthesis. The rate of gain
in brain weight should range from one to two mg per minute when pro-
life.
14
acid patterns of human's milk, hen's egg, and cow's milk from the FAQ
1957 FAQ
Amino acid
provisional
oat tern Cow's milk
gm of amino acid/100
Human milk
gm protein
I Hen's eo:o:
Hen's egg and human milk were completely utilized by the body
them was 100. Other protein sources were lower in NPU value, since
their amino acid patterns differed in some degree thus reducing their
amino acid patterns and lower NPU va lu e than animal proteins. The
sary for the feeding of a child aged 2-3 years if the full growth
larly with diets based mainly on such foods as cassava, where the NPU
was as low as 50-60. The NPU values for some proteins are given in
Table 10.
then more slowly through chi ldh ood and adolescence. At Oto three
yea r s of age it is 2.3 gm protein per kg; at three to six months , 1.8
gm; at six to nine months, 1.5 gm; and at nine to twelve months, 1.2
0.81 gm. The average requirements for protein for children by age
group and by quality of protein (NPU) are shown in Table 11. These
tion . If va lues are calcu l ated for 20 per cent below these figures ,
Limiting amino
acid based on
Food egg pattern NPU
Milk (cow's) sb 75
Egg -- 100
Beef muscle s 80
Pork tenderloin s 84
Fish Tryptophan 83
Rice Lysine 57
Ground nut s 48
Soy flour s 56
Cotton seed s 66
Navy bean s 47
Peas s 44
Sweet potato s 72
Children (yrs)
l-3b 0.88 0.98 1.10 1. 25 1.46 1. 76
4-6 0.81 0.90 1. 01 1.16 1. 34 1.62
7-9 o. 77 0.86 0.96 1.10 1. 28 1. 54
10-12 0. 72 0.80 0.90 1.03 1. 20 1.44
Adol esce nt s
13-15 0.70 0. 78 0.88 1.00 1.16 1.40
16-19 0.64 0. 71 0.80 0.92 1.06 1.28
.....
.._,
18
occur in all but a very few individuals (2.5 per cent). A level 20
per cent above the average is li kely to cover the requirements of all
Council for protein for children in the United States are converted
into gm per kg per day (Table 12), the values can be compared direct-
quality has an NPU valu e of 70 and are much more generous than re-
quirements given for the poor quality protein (NPU = 50). Most
of parasitism and might even have more parasites under the same
Protein imper kg
Age Minimurna Recommended u
years requirement allowance
Boys 9-12 1. 3 1. 82
12-15 1. l 1. 67
15-18 0.9 1. 39
tries in Far East Asia have had from 43 to 58 gm available per person
daily protein intake of the pregnant woman. In Middle East Asia four
In Africa and the Near East, two countries reported that avail-
able protein per person was less than the amount recommended for the
of the protein that comes from animal sources is also high (25 to 56
gm).
high intakes of animal protein. The Latin Ameri can countries showed
great variation with some low, as in Columbia and Peru, and some high,
adequate supplies of animal protein. The re ve rse was also true with
quality and the use of plant protein in human feedings. The imper-
which is lower in vegetable than in animal foods due to the fact that
than with animal protein; and processing methods, parti c ul arly tern-
hydrolysis.
that are known are: a trypsin inhibitor present in legumes and soy-
which reacts with lysine during processing and exerts a toxic effec t
to some animals.
have kwashiorkor and marasmus. Genera ll y, such mixtures are made from
aginous seeds and products, nuts, palm kernels, leaf and algae pro-
in the body. The following data show the effect of how suitable
follows: whole ground sorghum (or other cereals) 28, gro und corn 28
(or 56 per ce~t of other cereals), cottonseed flour 38, torula yeast
cent l eve ls, are shown in Figure 1. At low levels of protein intake
the animal protein produced a higher growth rate, but at the higher
level of intake the growth rate was simi lar for both groups of rats.
Growth rate in rats when skim milk replaced half of the mixture was
nearly as high as that when skim milk alone was us ed to supplement the
cells, white cells, and heamoglobin were simi lar at the same levels
of protein intake.
below two gm per kg per day, which is considered insufficient for the
diet.
recov ery when milk alone was used. However, the return of serum pro-
teins to normal values was s lower when vegetable mixtures only were
given.
flour 50, sesame flour (full fat) 35, cottonseed flour 9, torula
200
20 per cent protein
in diet
180
160
140
cent
in diet
120
§, 100
'-'
.c
....
00
0)
:,
80
0)
00
"'
...
0)
~ 60
40 mixture no. 9
20
a----- casein (vitamin free)
0 14 21 28 0 14 21 28
Days Days
Figure 1. Growth of rats fed INCAP vege table mixture 9, skim milk,
and casein (Bressani and Behar, 1964, p . 195).
26
2.4 -3.8 gm protein per kg per day was used. It was also eff ective
per cent chickpea, 65 per cent peanut f l ou r and 10 per cent sesame
meal.
60:15:25, and contai n ing about 11 per cent protein; (2) Panshtik
atta, a mixture o f whole wheat flour wi th pea nut flour and some
tapioc a; (3) Nutro or protein rich bis cuits, made from a 2:3 blend
of peanut a nd wheat f l our and co ntai nin g sugar , salt, l eave ning,
vitamins, and about 17 per cent protein; (4) s oyb ea n products such as
tion and a soybean milk mixture used as a n infant food; (5) blends
peanuts with soybeans; peanut f lour fortified with c a lcium and v ita-
mins; peanut flour with sk im milk powder ; and peanut flour with soy -
sesam e and coco nut meals, for tified with lysine, methionine, and
of 3:1; (8) Bengal gram (chickpea) wi t h banana and Bengal gram with
were used as s uppl ements to the rural diets (Bressani and Behar,
196 4).
prot ei n) , corn meal, sugar, and some dry milk. The mixture was about
cept ed.
ground nut flou r 4, sorghum flou r 20, whea t flour 10, millet flour
17 , white bean f lour 10, ye ast 2, Caco 1, and Vit amin A 4,500 I.U.
3
The mixture conta in s 27 . 8 per cent protein and has a good pattern of
la yer of the whea t kernel and processed defatted soybean mea l, was
animal proteins.
were for blend I, 2.70 and for b l end II, 3.34 . These compared with
28
2.14 for soy proteins and 3.08 for milk prot e ins. Fortification of
incr ease in PER to 3 .30 and 3.49 respective ly. Soybean and skim milk
powder fortifi ed with DL-meth ionin e gave PERs of 3.07 and 3.78.
prot e in food based on fortified bl e nds of gro und nut, Bengal gram ,
and sesa me f lour, and of ground nut, soybean and sesame flour. A
by pre-schoo l childr e n.
in PER va lu e when both ground nut f l our and skim milk powder were
r eplaced by soy flour in th e b l end of wheat f lour, gro und nut, and
brou ght a signif ic ant incr ease in PER value . A bl e nd of 60:40 wheat
and soy flours fortified with methionine gave a PER value near l y
an adequate amount for maternal hea l th and for the normal growth
and ph ysica l and ment al deve l opment of fet us, infant, and child bo th
for present gro wth and for lat er l ife . Since protein values d epe nd
seven to nine months of pregn a ncy and 40 gm per day during lactation
are r ecormnended.
per d ay. An addition of 27 gm per day during the one to five months
The infant and child are in the ages of the high e st growth rate
Proteins of human milk and of hen's egg have about the same
amino acid patterns which ar e somewhat lower in many amino acids than
100. Though cow's milk ha s lower biological and NPU values, its
below :
For children aged mor e than one year old, protein of NPU lower
than 100 and lower concentration than milk can be fed , fortified with
per 0.45 kg body weight per day (we i ght 27 lb needs 32 gm protein).
31
Children aged three t o nin e years need about l gm protein per 0.45 kg
The use of low cost, high quality pr o tein from vegetable mix-
for maternal and child health than for the normal woman and child.
Probl ems of providing ade quate protein foods are mostly found in
deve l op in g countr i es in the areas whe r e socio -econ omical l eve ls are
and lactation.
LITERATURECITED
Bressani, R., and M. Behar. 1964. The use of plant protein foods in
preventing malnutrition. Proceedings of the Sixth Internationai
Congress of Nutrition. E & S Livingstone LTD, London. p. 181-
204.
F.A.O. 1959b. Report of the Nutrition Committee for the Middle East,
1958. F,A,O , Nutrition meeting report series no. 24:1-50.