Professional Documents
Culture Documents
To cite this article: Ross Snyder (1958) VI A Theology for Youth, Religious Education:
The official journal of the Religious Education Association, 53:5, 439-466, DOI:
10.1080/0034408580530508
Taylor & Francis makes every effort to ensure the accuracy of all the information
(the “Content”) contained in the publications on our platform. However, Taylor
& Francis, our agents, and our licensors make no representations or warranties
whatsoever as to the accuracy, completeness, or suitability for any purpose of the
Content. Any opinions and views expressed in this publication are the opinions and
views of the authors, and are not the views of or endorsed by Taylor & Francis. The
accuracy of the Content should not be relied upon and should be independently
verified with primary sources of information. Taylor and Francis shall not be liable
for any losses, actions, claims, proceedings, demands, costs, expenses, damages,
and other liabilities whatsoever or howsoever caused arising directly or indirectly in
connection with, in relation to or arising out of the use of the Content.
This article may be used for research, teaching, and private study purposes. Any
substantial or systematic reproduction, redistribution, reselling, loan, sub-licensing,
systematic supply, or distribution in any form to anyone is expressly forbidden.
Terms & Conditions of access and use can be found at http://www.tandfonline.com/
page/terms-and-conditions
Downloaded by [New York University] at 10:46 16 February 2015
VI
youth — the underlying needs of young who had raped ten women in our area of
people for a theology, the types of content the town was finally caught when he left
which a theology for them must develop, an article of clothing behind in the home
and the mode of a theology for young peo- of his last victim — a young mother.
ple. I will illustrate these from some of the What is one to say about "A Theology
recent aliveness within myself in work with for Adolescence?" Or "A Theology for a
teenagers, but I am most concerned to set Civilization in which Adolescents must
out a framework within which the leaders Live?"
of the church and seminaries can — each
from his own point of view — develop a Or is there any point in fooling around
serviceable theology for the young people with theology at all? The public knows
of his church. that we call in policemen, social workers,
You are probably wondering — and so psychiatrists, to handle these "acting-out"
am I — whether there is such a thing as adolescents? What they need is healing
a theology for youth. And even if there personal relations, identification with a pow-
were, wouldn't every up-and-coming ado- erful but fair man, and structures of au-
lescent prefer to get the one for adults, thority which they cannot violate with im-
since it is the adult world in which finally punity. Who would be so foolish as to
he must find home? While no one would suggest that we hire experts to teach them
maintain that there are two forms of the theology? If we did, which of them would
Christian religion, no one who is aware of listen? And is the difference between
the kairos nature of developmental tasks some young people we know (who in many
would ignore recognizing that at particular ways are the finest adolescents the world
times in life, a particular focus and availa- has ever known) and the complusively hos-
bility of Christian resources is required. And tile and sex-obsessed adolescents largely that
to this degree, there is a theology for youth. the superior group has been taught the
Biblical story and the sick group has not
I. UNDERLYING NEED FOR THEOLOGY
been? This would be difficult to document
As I began to put this paper into form, in many cases.
the newspaper carried the headlines "644 Yet back of everything — and in the
teen-age trouble-makers expelled from New long run — man lives in a world of mean-
York high schools." On other pages of ings — not just a world of social impact.
the same newspaper were reports of the (Even if it be the social reality of "money,
appointment of lawyers to defend the ado- a car, a girl, and sex whenever you want
lescent gang that in cold aesthetic delight it.") A human being is that form of life
had beaten, stabbed and killed a boy who which senses significance — and when he
couldn't run because he was crippled from cannot sense significance he becomes rest-
polio; the police in Chicago were after the less. As Exupery wrote in 1939 —
439
440 RELIGIOUS EDUCATION
There are two hundred million men in "our way of life," or in the values of a com-
Europe whose existence has no meaning and mercial civilization with which Americans
who yearn to come alive. . . . Once it was
believed that to bring these creatures to man- are saturated every three to five minutes via
hood, it was enough to feed them, clothe television and radio.
them, and look to their everyday needs; but Should young people put their trust in
we see now that the result has been to turn the adults around them? Our keener young
out pettyshopkeepers, village politicians, hol-
low-technicians devoid of an inner life. people do not feel that the world achieved
by the present adults merits much trust in
Meanings and felt significances are the the wisdom, intentions, and world of mean-
fullness out of which the distinctively hu- ings with which present adults live. As a
man within us lives. Yet meanings and junior high school girl said to her mother
significance arise only through affiliation; after listening to a news broadcast, "Gee,
through a sensing of the nature and direc- Mother, if this is the kind of world your
Downloaded by [New York University] at 10:46 16 February 2015
tional thrust of a "field of life" in which generation is leaving us, I guess my genera-
our life is rootedly a participative knowl- tion has to get smart real fast."
edge of some history-making which we ac-
cept as not alien to our own realization. So increasingly young people try to find
In brief, when there is no trust, there can- an object of trust in each other. They go
not be meaning. "steady," maybe for a couple of months.
But there is an unsureness about how much
So in any life—including the adolescent's they can trust each other. Physical inti-
— basic trust is the critical "present or not macies and even sex relations are no indi-
present" that determines the quality of that cation of respect or even friendship. These
life. Trust in Life itself; trust that there is acts have lost any character as a language
a core of humanity within one's self and the which expresses meaning.
other. As the fabulous Dr. Spock has re-
marked concerning what makes a good par- Freud has enabled us to deepen our mis-
ent, "You have to — somehow or other — trust of everyone, and of ourselves. Now
at least believe in the human species." everyone is an amateur psychoanalyst,
Basic trust is not easily come by. And watching for the undeclared and sinful mo-
probably has fled the channels of the hu- tives within other people, pointing out the
man heart in our moment of history in- infected, self-concerned nature of the think-
stead of flowing in. ing even of those nearest and dearest: chil-
dren and spouse. And finally it dawns upon
For World War is the name of the past,
us that we mistrust ourselves also. We also
present, and future of the twentieth cen-
are being carried along by hidden forces we
tury. And we are on our own. Increasing
do not know about. So why not surrender
numbers of men doubt that God will inter-
to them and enjoy it? Or surrender to the
fere in the course of history on the side of
nearest monolithic view supported by au-
the freedom loving in the manner that the
thority?
Bible reports he did in the exodus from
Egypt — by ordering natural catastrophes. Basic mistrust is a present infection with-
Since the Lisbon earthquake and the re- in Western man, and with considerable fu-
sulting discussion, the learned world believes ture ahead of it. It is an acid eating away
that this is not the way God participates the bonds that bind men together in the
in the world process. bundle of life, and therefore preparing the
Further we know that we must resist the way for George Orwell's nightmare world.
hidden persuaders. Some, at least, are aware The mistrust is not just of each other, but
of the horror which follows when a people of existence itself, a mistrust that Life (and
are sold a pseudo-trust in that which cannot therefore my life) can have any meaning
be trusted ultimately. Among these would or significance; that Life is any more than
be listed trust in a fierce nationalism, in the turmoil of colliding wild charges of
political leaders who make an idolatry of energy, the rubbing of skin upon skin, re-
A THEOLOGY FOR YOUTH 441
curring chemical hungers satiated in such a enable him to see more, sense more vividly
way that status hungers are also fed. hidden potentiality and significance, under-
Stated positively, basic trust is a funda- stand better the uncommon meanings of the
mental component of healthy life. common things of life "in situation" — than
To summarize, this section of the paper he could without it. Theology must come
has asserted that there are two back-lying down from the heights and wrestle with
resources (in addition to human relations) the human situation until a "blessing" has
out of which adolescents and adults live — been wrung from the situation, and possibly
our wealth of meanings and sensings of both the situation and the theology are trans-
significance, and our wealth of basic trust formed in the process. (For I personally be-
or mistrust. lieve that contemporary experience is also
II. TYPES OF CONTENT I N A
data for constructing theologies, and that
THEOLOGY FOR YOUTH
every generation of Christians has responsi-
bility for clarifying and putting into com-
Downloaded by [New York University] at 10:46 16 February 2015
These two needs for resource provide the pelling form their own moments of en-
basis for the second section of the paper counter — else we live as parasites upon
which deals with the necessary content of a the thought and experience of other genera-
theology for youth. Two types of content tions.)
are needed.
One type of content will be the best re- Some of these experiences are the insolu-
ports we can make to adolescents of a ble problems of personal life, such as the
Reality which is encountered wherever you cry of Antigone down through the centuries,
are and whoever you are; with which we "I was not born to share in hatred, but to
must come to terms, which we cannot vio- share in love," for this is the cry of our
late with impunity or push around. A Real- best young people today. We are presently
ity that is empowering and instinct with experimenting with recording on tape fif-
creativeness. To be estranged from this God teen minute portions from such accounts as
is to become less than personal. To this Bonhoeffer's letters from prison (Prisoner
content, we will return later in the paper. for God) and the Exuperey's Flight to
A second necessary section of a theology Arras as a means of enabling young people
for adolescents will deal with the concrete- to think about how they see their moment
ness of life. It will help young people to in history and who they are in it. I wish
acquire meanings out of which they can live. very much that we also had available the
We call this "situational theologizing," re- inner experience of Negroes in integrated
ferring by that phrase to a number of high schools. A chapter in We of Nagasaki
things. in which an adolescent girl tells her four
year story, beginning with the bombing,
To do situational theologizing is, first of
requires all the theological resources that
all, to take the major experiences of ado-
can be summoned when you start asking
lescents and adults in today's world and ask,
"What does this experience mean? How
"How does our Christian faith interpret
is it to be interpreted by this girl?" Situa-
each of these experiences? How does it
tional theologizing also involves tackling
help us to penetrate the layers of existence
(with considerable profit) the depth mean-
that are here? What does this experience
ing of quite common things such as of
mean?"
owning a car for an adolescent boy, or of
Back of this process are two convictions clothes and a dance for a girl.
(1) that until a person can use his "knowl-
edege," he has not really learned it, (2) that Out of such a process, carried on over
Christian revelation is not revelation for a a period of time, an adolescent has an in-
person until with its help he sees deeply ternal world of meanings with which to
into the situations of his own life and the handle and digest what happens to him.
events of his social order. To make good This richness of meanings is also a reservoir
its claim to an adolescent, his religion must of potential sensitivity which makes him a
442 RELIGIOUS EDUCATION
person of substance and religious culture. shriveled, or have been so misused by propa-
Further, it is by analogies of experience that gandists that their glory and evocative power
the adolescent (as well as everybody else) has been lost.
does most of his decision thinking. There is a tremendous need today for a
A second form of life theologizing fo- Protestant image of marriage; one which is
cuses on an imaginative, experiential and not primarily a set of negative commands,
intellectual grasp of the major processes yet makes sense of creative fidelity and of
necessary for personal life. Such a full per- the enterprise of raising (not merely hav-
ception ef anything I call an image. If I ing) children. If I were working in a local
were working with high school juniors and church I would make much of the great
seniors, I would put on a hard-hitting edu- image of the Christian church found in the
cational program hoping to evoke potent last few verses of the second chapter of
images of such processes of personal exist- Ephesians —
ence as —
Downloaded by [New York University] at 10:46 16 February 2015
Which therefore no other can finally con- This type of content takes three forms:
trol or make. descriptions of encounter, a drama which
A person is that form of life we live with, organizes history, a story of personal life
instead of alongside.
Also that form of life which lives •within which binds the episodes together and gives
meanings and with a conscience. destiny.
Finally, a person is Mystery and a Holy. Ideally, we all hope for the moving event
Along with this image of the personal, hoped for by the poet Rilke,
we can place some of the existential grasp First you must find God somewhere, ex-
of what human existence (not "just exist- perience him as infinitely, prodigiously,
ing") is. stupendously, present.
Human existence is courage that alternates This would seem to be another state-
with cowardice, faith which includes doubt,
belonging and estrangement, good and evil. ment of Tillich's "ecstasy"; an experience
of divine power overcoming chaos; destruc-
Downloaded by [New York University] at 10:46 16 February 2015
viduating out the desirable from that which E. In the mode of vocation and
is to dissolve. celebration as well as the mode of
despair and foregiveness; of creation
Christian theology for adolescents will
as well as redemption.
have to speak, in understandable but not
purely sentimental terms, of acceptance and Sometimes it seems that God is merely
promise; of a creativeness within which our a useful instrument for need-driven man.
feeble efforts are enveloped and fed, of a God is not of worth and grandeur in and
love which "bears all things" which we of himself, but only as he functions for us
are, but from within the situation and as a free and instantaneous therapist.
with us is a moving toward love and wis- A theology for young people will con-
dom. tain some of the "high hardness" of a doc-
trine of vocation that may give even junior
At present "acceptance" is the word we high's some sense of a destiny other than
all glibly use. Acceptance does not mean
Downloaded by [New York University] at 10:46 16 February 2015
Financial Support
The Religious Education Association and its journal, RELIGIOUS EDUCA-
TION, like every other American institution, has been affected by economic
changes and the reduced value of the dollar over the past ten years. There has
been no increase in national dues of R.E.A. members since 1950. The Board of
Directors, at the meetings of May 12,1958, decided that it was imperative to in-
crease the minimal professional dues from $5.00 to $7.50 in order to meet the
increased cost of all services and to maintain the expanding work of the Asso-
ciation. This new rate took effect on September 1, 1958.
Of course the journal is one important aspect of the work of the Association,
but other members are sponsoring and conducting research and are fulfilling
other services which are included within the budget of the Association. Many
members, over the years, have voluntarily paid annual dues of from $10.00 to
$25.00 as contributing or supporting members. Also, many friends of the Asso-
ciation have annually sent in $50.00, $100.00, $250.00 or more, as "sustaining" or
"donor members. Even with the minimum dues increased to $7.50, the Associa-
tion needs the support of these more generous, and sometimes, sacrifical, sup-
porters if the program of the Association is to be maintained at its present level
and if new opportunities are to be met.