Professional Documents
Culture Documents
F.S.Sakkarnaikar
Course Outline
of
Interpretation of Statutes
For
BA/BCom/BSc/BBA/BSW, LLB
Semester:IV
Faculty:
Dr. Fakkiresh S.Sakkarnaikar
Assistant Professor of Law
Gujarat National Law University
Email: fsakkarnaikar@gnlu.ac.in
Mob: 8128650849
Page 1 of 15
Semester: IV Course: IoS Faculty:
F.S.Sakkarnaikar
Page 2 of 15
Semester: IV Course: IoS Faculty:
F.S.Sakkarnaikar
The importance of this subject within the framework of legal studies cannot be over-
emphasized. The courts have to administer justice according to law. The chief source
of law is legislation. The other sources are precedents and customs. Every source of
law finds its expression in a language. A language is the property of the people and
not that of law, though some words may acquire special legal meaning and may
become a part of the legal terminology. But by far a great bulk of the words used in a
legal draft belongs to the ordinary language. What meaning is to be given to a word
used in a legislation, custom or precedent or in a private deed or will? Even the
dictionary does not give the clear-cut meaning of a word. It gives many alternative
meanings applicable in different contexts and for different purposes so that no clear
field for the application of a word becomes identified. So long as expansion of
meaning takes place uniformly, the law will develop along healthy lines.
But if one judge takes the narrow view and the other the broad view, the law will
mean different things for different persons and soon there will be race for window
shopping for justice. Hence, it is necessary that there should be some rules of
interpretation to ensure just and uniform decisions. Such rules are called the rules of
interpretation. They are the subject-matter of this brief work of introductory nature.
The rules of interpretation are drawn from the general scope and intention of the
instrument or legislation, from the nature of the transaction or the circumstances,
from the legal rights of the parties’ independent of the instrument or law in question,
and from many other relevant particulars.
Salmond says that “judicial decisions have the force of law is legally ultimate and un-
derived. These ultimate principles are the grund norms or basic rules of recognition
of the legal system.”
In the process of interpretation, several aids are used. They may be statutory or
nonstatutory. Statutory aids may be illustrated by the General Clauses Act, 1897 and
by specific definitions contained in individuals Acts whereas non-statutory aids is
illustrated by common law rules of interpretation (including certain presumptions
relating to interpretation) and also by case-laws relating to the interpretation of
statutes.
Lord Denning in Seaford Court Estates Ltd. v. Asher, “English Knowledge is not an
instrument of mathematical precision… It would certainly save the judges from the
trouble if the acts of parliament were drafted with divine precision and perfect clarity.
In the absence of it, when a defect appears, a judge cannot simply fold hand and
blame the draftsman…”
No. of Sessions
Module No. Modules
(Classes)
IV.2.1 Introduction 07
IV.2.2 Canons of Interpretation 10
IV.2.3 Internal Parts/aids to Interpretation and 10
Construction
IV.2.4 External Parts/aids to Interpretation and 10
Construction
IV.2.5 Subsidiary Rules 05
IV.2.6 Operation of Statutes 04
IV.2.7 Statutes affecting the Crown or the State 03
IV.2.8 Fiscal and Taxing Statutes 02
IV.2.9 Interpretation of Judgments 02
IV.2.10 Interpretation of Constitution 02
IV.2.11 Interpretation of Documents, Deeds and Wills 02
Page 4 of 15
Semester: IV Course: IoS Faculty:
F.S.Sakkarnaikar
IV.2.12 Penal and Remedial Statutes 02
Total = 60
What is a Statute?
The duties of a Judge and a Legislature
Judicial activism and Judicial restraint
Optima est lex minimum relinquit arbitrio judicis, optimus judex qui
minimum sibi
Salus populi supreme lex (Roman Twelve Tables)
Difference between Making law and Creating law
Difference between Interpretation and Construction
Jaimini’s Mimamsa Rules of Interpretation
Humbert Wolfe’s view on statutes
Cases
State of U.P. v. Jeet S. Bhist (2007) 6 SCC 586
U.P. Bhoodan yagna Samiti v. Brij Kishore (1988)4 SCC 274
Bhatia International v. Bulk Trading S.A (2002) 4 SCC 105
Ratanchand Hirachand v. Askar Nawaz Jung – (dead) by L.Rs
(1991) 3 SCC 67
Beni Prasad v. Hardai Bibi (1892) ILR 14 All 67 (FB).
Cases
Literal Rule:
Ramavatar Buddaiprasad etc v. Asstt. S.T.Officer, Akola AIR 1961
SC 1325
M.V. Joshi v. M.U. Shimpi AIR 1961 SC 1494
The Queen v. Charles Arthur Hill Heaten Ellis (1844) 6Q.B. 499
Ranjit Udeshi v. State of Maharasthra AIR 1965 SC 881
Municipal Board v. State Transport Authority,Rajasthan AIR 1965
SC 458
Ramji v. State of Bihar AIR 1963 SC 1088
M/S Motipur Zamindary Co. Pvt. Ltd v. State of Bihar AIR 1962 SC
860
Maqbool Hussain v. State of Bombay AIR 1953 SC 325
S.A. Venkataraman v. U.O.I. AIR 1954 SC 375
Shriram v. State of Maharasthra AIR 1961 SC 674
Golden Rule
Karnail Singh v. Moinder Kaur AIR 2003 P & H 135
State of U.P. v. Synthetics & Chemical Limited AIR 1980 SC 614
Page 6 of 15
Semester: IV Course: IoS Faculty:
F.S.Sakkarnaikar
Lee v. Knapp (1967) 2 Q.B. 442
Mischief Rule:-
Long Title
Preamble and preamble of the Constitution
Headings
Marginal notes
Punctuations
Illustrations
Definition sections
Proviso
Explanation
Schedules
Transitional provision
Surplusage
Cases
R.v. Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs
(1994) 1 All ER 457
In re,Kerala Education Bill,1957 AIR 1958 SC 956
Bishwamber Singh v. State of Orissa AIR 1954 SC 139
Sardar Inder Singh v. State of Rajasthan AIR 1957 SC 510
Kesavananda v. State of Kerala AIR 1973 SC 1461
Page 7 of 15
Semester: IV Course: IoS Faculty:
F.S.Sakkarnaikar
Karnataka Power Transmission Corp v. Ashok Iron Works
Ltd. (2009) 3 SCC 240
Emperor v. Sadashiv AIR 1947 PC 82
Mohammad Shabir v. State of Maharashtra AIR 1979 SC 564
Parliamentary History
Historical facts and surrounding circumstances
Later social, political and economic developments and scientific
Inventions
Reference to other statutes
Effect of usage and practice
Dictionaries
Use of foreign decisions etc.
International Conventions
Websites
Cases
B. Prabhakar Rao and Others v. State of A.P. and others AIR
1986 SC 120
District Mining Officer and Others v. Tata Iron Steel Co. (2001)7
SCC 358
K.P.Varghese v. Income Tax Officer Eranakulam AIR 1981 SC
1922
Pepper v. Hart (1993) 1 ALLER 42 HL
State of Travancore Cochin and Others v. Bombay Co.Ltd AIR
1952 SC 366
Aswini Kumar Ghose and another v. Arbinda Bose AIR 1952 SC
369
State of Mysore v. R.V. Bidop AIR 1973 SC 2555
Fagu Shaw etc. v. The State of W.B. AIR 1974 SC 613
S.R.Chaudhuri v. State of Punjab and Others (2001)7 SCC 126
K.S.Paripornan v. State of Kerala and Others AIR 1995 SC 1012
R.Y.Prabhoo (Dr.) v. P.K.Kunte (1995) 7 SCALE 1
P.V. Narasimha Rao v. State AIR 1998 SC 2120
Sushil Rani v. CIT and another (2002)2 SCC 697
Page 8 of 15
Semester: IV Course: IoS Faculty:
F.S.Sakkarnaikar
Devadoss (dead) by L.Rs v. Veer Makali Amman Koil Anthalur
AIR 1998 SC 750
National Grindlays Bank v. Municipal Corporation Greater
Bombay AIR 1969 SC 1048
Supreme Court Advocates on Record Association v. Union of
India AIR 1994 SC 268
Forasol v. ONGC, AIR 1984 SC 241
General Electric Co. v. Renusagar Power Co., (1987) 4 SCC 137
Mohanlal Tripathi v.Distt. Magistrate Rail Bareilly and others,
(1992) 4 SCC 80
Dental Council of India v. Hariprakash, (2001) 8 SCC 61
S.P. Gupta v. Union of India, AIR 1982 SC 149
S.P. Jain v. Krishan Mohan Gupta and others AIR 1987 SC 222
J.K. Cotton Spinning & Wvg Mills Ltd. v. Union of India, AIR
1988 SC 191
P.N. Krishanlal v. Govt. of Kerala (1995) 2 SCC 187
Visakha v. State of Rajasthan AIR 1997 SC 3011
Cases
Bhogilai Chunnilal Pandya v. State of Bombay AIR 1959 SC
356
Chairman IVP v. Pure Industrial Cocke and Chemicals Ltd
(2007) 8 SCC 705
In re Article 143 of the Constitution of India AIR 1965 SC 745
Page 9 of 15
Semester: IV Course: IoS Faculty:
F.S.Sakkarnaikar
Links Advertisers and business promoters v. Commr., corp of
the city of Banglore AIR 1977 SC 1646
Bank of India v. Ketan Parekh AIR 2008 SC 2361
Retrospective operation
o Statutes regulating contracts and transfers
o Statutes regulating succession
o Statutes of limitation
o Statutes regulating appeals
o Statutes affecting finality of orders
Relevant considerations relating to operation
o Presumption that legislation is territorial
o Operation as to foreigners
o Regard to International agreements/conventions/treaties
o Acts passed to give effect to international treaties and
conventions
o Operation as to crimes
o International crimes
o Legislation under the Government of India Act,1935
Cases
J. Mitra and Co Pvt Ltd. v. Assistant Controller of Patents and
Designs AIR 2009 SC 405
Virendra Singh Hooda v. State of Haryana AIR 2005 SC 137
Mohm. Akram Ansari v. Chief Election Officer (2008) 2 SCC
95
Kuwait Minister of Public v. Sir Frederick Snow and Partner
(1984) 1 All ER 733
Cherotte Sugathan v. Cherotte Bharati AIR 2008 SC 1467
New India Insurance Co.Ltd v. Shanti Mishra AIR 1976 SC
237
Cases
Director of R and D v. Corporation of Calcutta AIR 1960 SC
1355
Bombay Province v. Bombay Municipal Corp. 1947 PC 34
State of U.P. v. Radhey Shyam Rai (2009) 5 SCC 577
Cases
Page 11 of 15
Semester: IV Course: IoS Faculty:
F.S.Sakkarnaikar
Cases
R v. Charges Ltd (2009) 2 All ER 645 (HL)
ESI Corp. v. HMT Ltd (2008) 3 SCC 35
Page 12 of 15
Semester: IV Course: IoS Faculty:
F.S.Sakkarnaikar
Kailash Chand v. Dharam Dass (2005) 5 SCC 375
Ajit Singh v. Jit Ram AIR 2009 SC 199
Prescribed Readings
5. Edgar S.G.G. Craies on Statute Law (6th edition Sweet and Maxwell
1963)
Recommended Readings
Page 13 of 15
Semester: IV Course: IoS Faculty:
F.S.Sakkarnaikar
3. Eskridge, William N. Legislation and Statutory Interpretation, (2nd
edn.,
Foundation Press, 2006)
The methodology for study and research of this subject would be covering,
class room lectures, seminars, group discussions, teacher and student
interaction and open discussion.
Evaluation: Marks
Continuous Evaluation……………………………… 20
Mid-Semester Examination--------------------------------- 30
End-Semester Examination………………………… 50
--------------------------------------------------------
Total 100
Page 14 of 15
Semester: IV Course: IoS Faculty:
F.S.Sakkarnaikar
Page 15 of 15