Professional Documents
Culture Documents
PERRY L. McCARTY
91
only.
(7) A given species of bacteria mediates only a single reaction.
(8) Cellular yield of organisms is a function of reaction energetics.
(9) Rate of electron transfer in energy yielding reactions is a tem-
perature-dependent constant for all microorganisms.
Several of these assumptions do not have general validity for all bio-
logical reactions but are not felt to limit severely the analysis in the
present context. Assumptions 6 and 7 are certainly not of general use-
fulness but are quite reasonable for methane fermentations. A unique
characteristic of these organisms is that their ability to mediate reactions
is very limited, and several different species are required to bring about
the conversion of a complex substrate to methane gas. The last two as-
sumptions have been found to be reasonably valid for microorganisms
which tend to dominate in natural environments. These assumptions are
basic to the present analysis, and the limitations which result are gov-
erned primarily by limitations in these two assumptions.
With the above constraints, a continuous flow stirred anaerobic re-
actor as illustrated in Figure 1 will be considered to operate under steady-
state conditions (dQ/dt = dnf/dt = dn?/dt = dnf/dt = 0), where
Q is the flow rate in liters per day and nf, nf, and n* represent the num-
a
ber of moles of component Aj per unit time entering the reactor, and leav-
ing the reactor in the gas and aqueous phases, respectively. The system
contains m components A; (f = 1, 2,... . m) interconnected by means of
n biologically mediated reactions B (k = 1, 2,
k n). There are more
components than reactions so that n is less than m. S is the concentration
t
eralized way:
m
0=2>aA { (1)
1=1
tive for products and negative for reactants and equals zero for com-
ponents that do not take part in the reaction.
From the assumptions previously listed, the rate of reaction B de- k
k k
kXS k k k /v0
r
" = K ^ S k
( 2 )
Publication Date: June 1, 1971 | doi: 10.1021/ba-1971-0105.ch006
reaction.
A component enters the reactor in aqueous solution and may leave
the reactor either with the aqueous phase or as a gas. A materials balance
for component A{ for the system will yield the following:
n
nf - nf - nf = £ ( - rV k (3)
fe=i
V is the reactor volume in liters. The designation X is used when
referring to microorganisms. The stoichiometric coefficient v then is xk
v rVxk k = XQ k (4)
or
X = k v rO
xk k c
6 is defined as the cell retention time and for the continuous flow reactor
C
S k =
v k9 l ' r k >
° ( 5 )
Q , n? Q .
Downloaded by NORTH CAROLINA STATE UNIV on November 18, 2011 | http://pubs.acs.org
V Si
Publication Date: June 1, 1971 | doi: 10.1021/ba-1971-0105.ch006
(6)
m
£ V (7)
effluent stream and gas discharge can be determined. This requires that
the stoichiometric coefficients v be known, including the value v for
ik xk
organism synthesis. Also required are the coefficients k and K for each k k
reaction. The method used for selection of appropriate values are dis-
cussed in the following.
Downloaded by NORTH CAROLINA STATE UNIV on November 18, 2011 | http://pubs.acs.org
for energy and synthesis separately and then adding them together. Het-
erotrophic and chemosynthetic autotrophic microorganisms obtain energy
for growth by mediating oxidation-reduction reactions. Such reactions
involve a flow of electrons from electron donors to electron acceptors. A
partial list of half-equations which can be combined in various ways to
yield equations for oxidation-reduction reactions of interest in methane
fermentation are listed in Table I. The last equation contains an em-
pirical molecular formula for bacterial cells (C5H7O2N)
and is useful
in constructing synthesis equations.
electron equivalents of the electron donor converted for energy per elec-
tron equivalent of cells synthesized. Hydrogen fermentation, by contrast,
is mediated by autotrophic organisms which use carbon dioxide, acetate,
or some other carbon source for cell synthesis. In the equation shown in
Table II acetate was assumed to be the carbon source used as found for
this fermentation by Bryant (1). E has the same definition as for hetero-
k
trophic growth.
The stoichiometric coefficient v for each of the over-all reactions in
ik
Table II equals the sum of the coefficients for the energy reaction v ik
e
Vi = Vi +v
k k
c
ik
s
(8)
While the values for E were assumed for the examples listed in Table II,
k
Half-
(1) ^ H 0 2
Downloaded by NORTH CAROLINA STATE UNIV on November 18, 2011 | http://pubs.acs.org
(2) ^ C E U + ^HsO
Publication Date: June 1, 1971 | doi: 10.1021/ba-1971-0105.ch006
(3) ^ C H C O O - + | H 0
3 2
(4) ± C H ( C H ) C O O -
3 2 14 + g H 0 2
(5) ^ C H C H C O O - + ^ H 0
3 2 2
(6) 1 C H C H C H C O O - + ^ H 0
3 2 2 2
(7) ^ C H C H O H + ~ H 0
3 2 2
(8) ^ C H C H N H C O O H + ~ H 0
3 2 2
(9) CH COCOO- + | H 0
1U o
3 2
(10) Jh 2
(11) ^ C H 0 + i H 0
6 1 2 6 2
(12) ^HCOO- + i H 0 2
± C H 0 N + 4
6 7 2 H 0 2
Various Half-Reactions
AG",
kcal per
mole
Reaction electrons
= | 0 + H+ + e-
2 28.345
Downloaded by NORTH CAROLINA STATE UNIV on November 18, 2011 | http://pubs.acs.org
= ^ C 0 + H+ + e-
2 3.907
Publication Date: June 1, 1971 | doi: 10.1021/ba-1971-0105.ch006
= ^ C 0 + | H C 0 - + H+ + e~
2 3 3.061
= ^ C 0 + ^ H C O , - + H+ + e-
2 3.013
= ^ C 0 + ^ H C 0 - + H+ + e-
2 3 3.006
= ^ H C 0 - + ^ C 0 + H+ + e-
3 2 2.917
= ^ C 0 + H+ + e- 2.078
b
2
=
I°
c 2+
h ° ~ 12
HC 3 + NH4+
+ H +
+~ e 2 0 3 1
= I ° 2 + ^ C 0 - + H+ + e~
c H
1.125
5 10 3
= H+ + e- 0.000
= 1 C 0 + H+ + e~
2 -0.350
^ H C 0 - + H+ + e-
3 -1.810
=
I °
C 2 +
4 H C O r +
2^ N H 4 +
+ H +
+ ~
e
change (AG ) for the energy portion of reaction B can be written as:
k k
m
AG = AG ° + RT"£ v
k k ik
e
In a, (9)
i=l
where AG ° is the standard free energy for reaction B as determined
k k
from the values listed in Table I and as illustrated in Table II, and a* is
the activity of component A*. The activity for non-gaseous components
is approximated by S and for gaseous components by pi.
h
Downloaded by NORTH CAROLINA STATE UNIV on November 18, 2011 | http://pubs.acs.org
v AG /e + AG + AG /e
pk
m
ck nk (
ti =k —^ (lUj
eAG
Publication Date: June 1, 1971 | doi: 10.1021/ba-1971-0105.ch006
Synthesis (3)-(13) 20
Over-all 20
Synthesis (3)-(13) 5
Over-all 5
quantity of energy required to convert the carbon source used for syn-
thesis of cells mediating reaction B into an intermediate (assumed to
k
nfc
to reduce the nitrogen source used for cell synthesis into ammonia. AG nk
equals zero if the nitrogen source is ammonia, the usual nitrogen source
in methane fermentations.
Publication Date: June 1, 1971 | doi: 10.1021/ba-1971-0105.ch006
kcal per
electron
Reaction equivalent
I CH3COO- + I H 0 = I HCO3- + I C H
2 4
-0.846
1 [I CH3COO- + A C0 + 1 W = 2
^ C H 0 N + A HC0 - + g
5 7 2 3 H o]
2
-3.91
0.315 H 0 2
k = Dexp(-H /RT)
k a (11)
tween about 9 and 18 kcal/mole, R equals 1.99 kcal mole" degree" , and 1 1
onate, than for aerobic oxidations. Values of 10" moles/liter seem appro-
3
priate for the former and 10" for the latter. K also tends to increase
4
k
HYDROGEN
Downloaded by NORTH CAROLINA STATE UNIV on November 18, 2011 | http://pubs.acs.org
METHANE
Publication Date: June 1, 1971 | doi: 10.1021/ba-1971-0105.ch006
day, while fermentation of the fatty acids formed occurs only at 6 values C
^ C H 0 N + ± C0 + | H 0
6 7 2 2 2 -1.48
^ CH0N + A
6 7 2 N h 4 + + _|_ H C O r 0.85
? CH COO~ + ^ C H + J C 0
3 4 2 -1.00
^ C H 0 N + ™ C0 + i | H 0
6 7 2 5 2 2 1.89
| CH + \ H 0 4 2 -3.91
^ C H 0 N + ^ HCOr + ^ H 0
6 7 2 2
1.94
\ CH COO- + ^ C H + ^ C0
3 4 2 -0.97
^ CH0N + ^
5 7 2 HCOr + ^ H0 2 1.88
\ CH3COO- + \ CH + I C0 4 2
-1.57
^ CH0N + ^ H0
6 7 2 2 1.79
Table III.
Limiting
Substrate
A k Reaction
o o
Downloaded by NORTH CAROLINA STATE UNIV on November 18, 2011 | http://pubs.acs.org
Synthesis: | C H C O O - + ^ C 0 + ^ NH + =
3 2 4
e k
0.6
AG 0
[HCO3-]
ni
10" mole/liter
2
Pressure 1 atm
C H i 0 , C4H6ON, and C15H31COOH considered as molecular formula for
a
6 2 6
Continued
kcal/electron
equivalent
AG*° AG Pk
i C H + | HC0 -
4 3 -0.85
Downloaded by NORTH CAROLINA STATE UNIV on November 18, 2011 | http://pubs.acs.org
^ C H 0 N + A HC0 - + ^ H 0
5 7 2 3 2 1.936
1200
Publication Date: June 1, 1971 | doi: 10.1021/ba-1971-0105.ch006
FATTY ACID
•7
800 - ^ - METHANE x £
10
cell yield coefficients, is also seen from the figure. The effect is different
with different substrates and is a result of their varying interdependencies.
Figure 5 is a summary of the total cellular yields for organisms which
ferment the various substrates. The greatest predicted yield is for the
carbohydrate-fermenting organisms, even though the carbohydrate con-
tent of the influent is only intermediate between proteins and fats. This
is a reflection of the greater energy content of carbohydrates on an elec-
tron equivalent basis. The hydrogen-fermenting organisms are relatively
low in concentration since little hydrogen is formed from the fermenta-
0.12
Downloaded by NORTH CAROLINA STATE UNIV on November 18, 2011 | http://pubs.acs.org
0 2 4 6 8 10 12
Publication Date: June 1, 1971 | doi: 10.1021/ba-1971-0105.ch006
6,
C DAYS
results are quite comparable with those obtained from the continuous feed
300
ACETATE
u / / PROPIONATE + BUTYRATE
LU
S 200
J FATTY ACID
(/)*
< —^
5 PROTEIN
100 ->
f CARBOHYDRATE
1 1 1 1 1
10 12
0C.DAYS
0 2 4 6 8 10 12
0 C , DAYS
Literature Cited