For Lebanon, post war-reconstruction is tricky - The National 12/03/2019 15)39

SUBSCRIBE
23°c

19:26 Isha

Abu Dhabi, UAETuesday 12 March 2019

Business
Economy
Banking
Aviation
Property
Energy
Technology
Travel and Tourism
Comment
Markets
Money

Michael
Karam
Feb
For Lebanon, post war-reconstruction is tricky
7, The process can often be a violent extension of conflict and in Beirut's case has left a central district bereft of
2018 life

Last week, on a flight to Beirut, I bumped into my friend Deen Sharp who used to be a business writer but is
now a brainy, New York-based, PhD student.

He was flying to the Lebanese capital to present a paper on, essentially, how post war-reconstruction is not
always the clean break from conflict many of us imagine, and how the process can often be a violent
extension of that conflict. No surprise, therefore, that Lebanon and Solidere, the controversial real estate
company tasked with rebuilding the Beirut Central District in the mid 1990s after the country’s civil war, and
which still manages the 1.9 million square metre plot of land, is firmly in his doctrinal crosshairs.

Lebanon’s tragic civil conflict was punctuated by endless ceasefires, some came into effect to simply allow
people to go shopping or bury their dead, but others were meant to herald an end to the fighting that
atomised Lebanon’s short-lived reputation as the Paris of the Middle East. And so, intriguingly, Mr Sharpe’s
presentation reminded us that the notion of reconstruction actually began as early as 1977, just two years
after the civil war began and not, as many believe, after the October 1989 Ta’ef Accord, which to all intents
and purposes ended the conflict.

In fact more reconstruction plans were mooted in 1983 – another optimism-filled milestone in the war and
one more time in 1986. In all cases, renewed fighting prevented each initiative from achieving any “grip” and
it was only in 1994, after four years of proper peace, that Solidere was established by the late prime minister
Rafic Hariri, the man whose dream it was to make Beirut a Middle East retail and tourism destination for the
region’s elite. It was the only plan that would reach fruition. Two other development plans – Linord and Elisar
- were also approved by law but were never activated due to what Mr Sharpe says was a “lack of funding and
entanglement in political disputes”.

But when the new Beirut Central District (BCD) opened for business in 2000, it was only after much violent
upheaval and displacement that effectively divided the capital by expropriating land owned by the pre-war
tenants - who reflected a genuine cross section of Lebanese society. They were offered shares in Solidere by
way of compensation but the popular heart of the city had been ripped out in what was effectively a huge
power grab by Hariri, who had entered Lebanese politics via accumulating vast wealth in Saudi Arabia. As Mr
Sharpe put it “the reconstruction was central to [the] accumulation of social power” by one man.

_____________

Read more:

Will McKinsey help Lebanon chalk out a better economic model?

Lebanese crave economic liberation beyond Iran's influence

_____________

And what many people forget is that much of the destruction of the BCD was the result of extensive
demolition rather than fighting. “[Construction company] Oger Liban is accused of destroying many significant
buildings in the downtown area including Souk Al Nouriyeh, Souk Sursuq and parts of Saifi during its 'clear
up' operations,” argues Mr Sharpe.

https://www.thenational.ae/business/for-lebanon-post-war-reconstruction-is-tricky-1.702545 Page 1 of 4
For Lebanon, post war-reconstruction is tricky - The National 12/03/2019 15)39

As our plane sped across the Balkans, he told me that in the early 1990s there had been an active group of
Lebanese who had created alternatives to Hariri’s Horizon 2000 master plan. Some of these
recommendations were incorporated into what became the Solidere project, but Hariri – always the corrupter,
but never corrupt – co-opted many of those that opposed his buccaneering way of doing things and gave
them top jobs in Solidere. He also, in typical Hariri fashion, allegedly bought every copy of Bayreuth:
Construire L'Avenir, Reconstruire Le Passe? a series of essays that outlined an alternative vision to that of
Solidere.

Hariri was murdered in 2006 and the political schism that grew out of his death contributed to what I firmly
believe is the failure of the Solidere project. The BCD was rebuilt at a cost of approximately $11 billion but
Lebanon’s fragile political framework ensured that the area has been tarred with the brush of the Hariri family
name, while, as landlord, Solidere has done virtually nothing meaningful to foster a spirit of openness with
the people of Beirut and everything to prioritise the bottom line without realising that you can’t have one
without the other.

I live in the BCD when I’m in Beirut. The shops, offices and apartment buildings are largely empty and there
are very few pedestrians. Those who live in the area emerge from underground car parks in smoked-glass
4x4s to go to work or the gym.

In 2001, it was the hottest patch of real estate in town. I also know this because I worked from Cushman &
Wakefield’s Beirut office and the retail units in the BCD were our bread and butter. There was to be the
“Souks”, a much bigger development than that which stands today. There was to be a department store as
an “anchor” (indeed French department store chain Galeries Lafayette was interested in taking the space),
while Rues Foche and Allenby were allocated the luxury brands. The Souks opened 10 years late in 2010
due to a political dispute and the momentum was lost as retailers found other locations. It nonetheless has
around 200 shops but the bustling retail life just isn’t there.

In fact, according to “Main Streets Across the World 2016/2017”, a research publication by Cushman &
Wakefield, Lebanon's most expensive retail location is Hamra Street, ranking 44th globally. In second place
was Verdun, last year’s top spot, followed by Kaslik Street in third. Back in 2001, commercial rents in Hamra,
admittedly Beirut’s only genuine high street, were around 30 per cent that of the BCD.

Nemesis may be slow, but it is sure.

Updated: February 7, 2018 05:39 PM

RELATED

UAE
Iraq's displaced have been forgotten, says top UNHCR official

https://www.thenational.ae/business/for-lebanon-post-war-reconstruction-is-tricky-1.702545 Page 2 of 4
For Lebanon, post war-reconstruction is tricky - The National 12/03/2019 15)39

MENA
Yemen peace process at risk of failure say UN permanent members

GOVERNMENT
Zayed National Museum and Guggenheim projects 'active' in Abu Dhabi

https://www.thenational.ae/business/for-lebanon-post-war-reconstruction-is-tricky-1.702545 Page 3 of 4
For Lebanon, post war-reconstruction is tricky - The National 12/03/2019 15)39

FILM
Disney's Aladdin: 5 takeaways from the brand new trailer

AFRICA
UN investigators say 890 'horrific' ethnic killings could be war crimes

https://www.thenational.ae/business/for-lebanon-post-war-reconstruction-is-tricky-1.702545 Page 4 of 4