Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Patient Assessment: Effective Consultation and History Taking
Patient Assessment: Effective Consultation and History Taking
net/publication/23566482
Article in Nursing standard: official newspaper of the Royal College of Nursing · October 2008
DOI: 10.7748/ns2008.10.23.4.50.c6677 · Source: PubMed
CITATIONS READS
25 89,861
1 author:
Gerri Kaufman
The University of York
28 PUBLICATIONS 336 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by Gerri Kaufman on 22 April 2016.
learning zone
CONTINUING PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT
Page 58 Page 59 Page 60
Patient consultation Respiratory assessment Guidelines on how to
multiple choice practice profile by write a practice profile
questionnaire Noreen Macfarlane
Patient assessment:effective
consultation and history taking
NS462 Kaufman G (2008) Patient assessment: effective consultation and history taking. Nursing
Standard. 23, 4, 50-56. Date of acceptance: August 1 2008.
FIGURE 1
The Calgary-Cambridge consultation guide (Adapted from Kurtz et al 2003)
3. Physical examination
areas contain skills that are used continuously skills and the ability to perform effectively and
throughout the consultation. This article explores impartially in the consultation.
the following sections of the guide: In the pre-consultation period the patient’s
notes or records should be checked to raise
Initiating the session. awareness of previous problems or any regular
treatments the patient is having or medication
Gathering information.
the patient is taking (Chafer 2003). Attention
Explanation and planning. should be paid to comfort, privacy and the
creation of a safe environment. The possibility
Closing the session.
of interruptions and being overheard can
discourage or prevent patients from telling their
Initiating the session
story (Clark 1999, While 2002).
Initiating the consultation in the Before the patient arrives in the room the
Calgary-Cambridge guide has unique and practitioner should deal with, or at least
separate objectives that must be completed acknowledge, any negative feelings or stress.
before moving on to the main history-taking or Patients seek healthcare assistance for a variety
information-gathering session. It involves of reasons, including physical, psychological and
preparing for the encounter, establishing social reasons. Consultations can be stressful
a rapport with the patient and identifying and emotionally draining and, in a busy clinical
the reason for the consultation. environment, it is easy to hang on to charged
Chafer (2003) reminds us that a lack of emotions from a previous encounter (Clark 1999).
attention to the pre-consultation period can Starting a consultation in a distracted state of
adversely affect clinical reasoning, perceptual mind can adversely affect performance and result
information required for diagnosis (Epstein et al Presenting problem or difficulty The presenting
2008), therefore history taking is essential to the complaint provides a good starting point for
consultation process. Active listening, which is history taking as it is often considered the
described as the most fundamental patient’s most important concern. It is important
communication skill (Duxbury 1999), is central to to explore sensitively patients’ ideas and concerns
obtaining a comprehensive history. about their symptoms and their expectations
from the consultation to promote patient-centred
Time out 4 consultations (Moulton 2007). Exploring
patients’ ideas about their symptoms involves
Define what active listening asking them what they think the problem is.
means to you. Ask a friend or Their perception is especially important for the
colleague to start telling you what explanation and planning stage of the
he or she did on holiday. Use consultation. If a patient has different ideas from
the skills of active listening to get the practitioner about the cause and management
more information. of the symptoms, constructing an effective
management plan is likely to fail.
Active listening encompasses verbal and The patient’s particular concerns in relation
non-verbal behaviours. Egan (2007) to the symptoms should also be explored. Most
emphasises the non-verbal elements of active patients do not admit their anxieties (Chafer
listening in the SOLER framework, which 2003). Asking patients what they think the
involves sitting Square on to the patient with problem is, encourages them to share their inner
an Open position, Leaning slightly forward feelings. Patients cannot be advised effectively or
with Eye contact in a Relaxed posture. The reassured if the practitioner does not discover
verbal elements of active listening encompass what is really worrying them (Moulton 2007).
appropriate questioning techniques and Finding out what patients think or hope the
summarising and recalling the history back practitioner is going to do is also important. It
to the patient to ensure that nothing is missed. can provide additional clues to the patient’s
Use open questions initially as they cannot be underlying level of concern and provides
answered by a yes or no and they enable patients to information about options to incorporate when
expand their story. For example, ‘Tell me more discussing symptom management.
about your chest pain’ encourages the patient to
tell the practitioner more. In contrast, closed Time out 5
questions such as, ‘Is the chest pain severe?’, which
can be answered yes or no are useful in seeking How might you ask patients directly
specific data that are required to gain a deeper for their ideas, expectations and
understanding of the patient’s problems. concerns? Choose a condition relevant
Summarising the patient’s history and recalling to your clinical area. Ask a colleague to
it back to him or her is important to ensure that play the role of a patient with this condition
the practitioner has the correct information. and try out phrases to discover his or her ideas,
Summarising should not be a passive activity but concerns and expectations.
a dynamic process in which the practitioner and
patient construct a shared overview of the When taking a history, encourage patients to
problem. Summarising gives the patient an describe their symptoms in the most expansive
opportunity to clarify details, make corrections manner. Several frameworks have been developed
and add further contributions (Moulton 2007). to help with the process. The mnemonic PQRST
Asking the patient if there is anything else gives (Zator Estes 2002) is most useful in gathering
him or her a final opportunity to add any information about symptoms:
additional information (Lloyd and Craig 2007).
P = Provocation and palliation.
When talking to patients it is easy to be
side-tracked or omit important questions, Q = Quality.
therefore it is helpful to use a history-taking
R = Region and radiation.
framework which gathers information in an
orderly way. The patient’s presenting problem S = Severity.
or difficulty, medical history, current health,
T = Timing.
family history and psychosocial history should
be explored, and a review of systems – focused Provocation and palliation When taking a history,
questions about the health of all body systems – explore what causes or exacerbates the patient’s
undertaken. This review is a way of checking symptoms and if anything relieves them. This
that key information has not been missed information can provide important clues to help
during history taking (Clark 1999). with diagnostic decision making. For example,
References
Chafer A (2003) Communication Nurse Practitioners: Clinical Skills Journal. 324, 7353, 1567-1569. Effective and Intuitive Consulting
Skills Manual. February-July 2003. and Professional Issues. Second Style. MTP Press, Lancaster.
Kurtz S, Silverman J, Benson J,
www.easterngp.co.uk/pages/resour edition. Butterworth-Heinemann,
Draper J (2003) Marrying content Silverman J, Kurtz S, Draper J
ces/documents/reskl_Manual0cm0 Oxford, 319-329.
and process in clinical method (2004) Skills for Communicating
203.pdf?PHPSESSID=ceadf362cd
Duxbury J (1999) Therapeutic teaching: enhancing the with Patients. Second edition.
0b668b4ce9165e3ac1c310 (Last
communication and the nurse Calgary-Cambridge guides. Radcliffe Publishing, Abingdon.
accessed: September 18 2008.)
practitioner. In Walsh M, Crumbie A, Academic Medicine. 78, 8, 802-809.
Simpson M, Buckman R, Stewart
Clark C (1999) Taking a history. In Reveley S (Eds) Nurse Practitioners:
Lloyd H, Craig S (2007) A guide M et al (1991) Doctor-patient
Walsh M, Crumbie A, Reveley S (Eds) Clinical Skills and Professional
to taking a patient’s history. Nursing communication: the Toronto
Nurse Practitioners: Clinical Skills Issues. Butterworth-Heinemann,
Standard. 22, 13, 42-48. consensus statement. British Medical
and Professional Issues. Oxford, 249-259.
Journal. 303, 6814, 1385-1387.
Butterworth-Heinemann, Oxford, 12-23. Moulton L (2007) The Naked
Egan G (2007) The Skilled Helper.
Consultation: A Practical Guide to While A (2002) Practical skills:
Crumbie A (2005a) Problem- BrooksCole/Thomson Learning,
Primary Care Consultation Skills. prescribing consultation in practice.
solving. In Walsh M (Ed) Nurse Belmont, California.
Radcliffe Publishing, Abingdon. British Journal of Community
Practitioners: Clinical Skills and
Epstein O, Perkin GD, Cookson J Nursing. 7, 9, 469-473.
Professional Issues. Second edition. Munson E (2007) Applying the
et al (2008) Clinical Examination.
Butterworth-Heinemann, Oxford, Calgary-Cambridge model. Practice Zator Estes ME (2002) Health
Fourth edition. Mosby, Edinburgh.
3-13. Nursing. 18, 9, 464-468. Assessment and Physical
Gask L, Usherwood T (2002) ABC Examination. Second edition.
Crumbie A (2005b) The patient as Neighbour R (1987) The Inner
of psychological medicine. The Delmar Learning, Clifton Park,
partner in care. In Walsh M (Ed) Consultation: How to Develop an
consultation. British Medical New York.