Title: Mastering the Art of Crafting a Thesis: Navigating the Complexities of Research Paper on

DNA Evidence

Embarking on the journey of writing a thesis, especially one centered around the intricate realm of
DNA evidence, is a formidable task. It requires a meticulous blend of research, critical analysis, and
coherent presentation to unveil meaningful insights and contribute to the existing body of
knowledge. Yet, the path to crafting a compelling research paper on DNA evidence is laden with
challenges that can easily overwhelm even the most seasoned scholars.

One of the primary hurdles lies in navigating the vast landscape of existing literature and studies
related to DNA evidence. With the exponential growth of research in this field, sifting through the
plethora of information to identify gaps, contradictions, and areas ripe for exploration demands both
time and expertise. Moreover, ensuring the credibility and relevance of the selected sources adds
another layer of complexity to the process.

Beyond the realm of literature review, the formulation of a clear and coherent research question or
hypothesis is paramount. Given the multifaceted nature of DNA evidence and its implications across
various disciplines, defining a focused and impactful research inquiry requires careful deliberation
and refinement. Without a well-defined research question, the thesis risks losing direction and failing
to make a meaningful contribution to the academic discourse.

Furthermore, the process of data collection and analysis poses significant challenges, particularly in
the context of DNA evidence. From obtaining access to relevant datasets and samples to employing
rigorous methodologies for analysis, each step demands meticulous attention to detail and adherence
to ethical standards. Moreover, interpreting complex genetic data and drawing valid conclusions
necessitates a strong foundation in both genetics and statistical analysis.

As the culmination of months or even years of rigorous research and analysis, the writing phase of
the thesis presents its own set of challenges. From structuring the paper in a logical and coherent
manner to articulating complex concepts with clarity and precision, every word carries the weight of
scholarly rigor and academic integrity. Moreover, adhering to the formatting and citation guidelines
prescribed by academic institutions adds another layer of complexity to the writing process.

Amidst the myriad challenges associated with writing a thesis on DNA evidence, seeking expert
assistance can provide invaluable support and guidance. At ⇒ BuyPapers.club ⇔, we understand
the complexities inherent in crafting a compelling research paper and offer tailored solutions to meet
your specific needs. Our team of experienced writers and researchers possesses the expertise and
dedication to assist you at every stage of the thesis-writing process, from formulating research
questions to polishing the final draft.

With our commitment to excellence and client satisfaction, ⇒ BuyPapers.club ⇔ stands as your
trusted partner in navigating the complexities of writing a thesis on DNA evidence. Let us help you
transform your research aspirations into tangible academic achievements.
A negative microscopic examine may not show any spermatozoa due to the low concentration of
sperm produced naturally by the male (oligospermic), the male being vasectomized, penetration by
the male without ejaculation, and digital penetration. Sperm cell staining can help in determining in
case the stain is the outcome of vaginal drainage. The number of cells transferred to touched objects
is highly variable, and often results in less than 300 picograms of DNA. The committee comments on
statements in the original book that proved controversial or that have been misapplied in the courts.
This is 100% legal. You may not submit downloaded papers as your own, that is cheating. Also you.
Therefore, forensic evidence is paramount, to show that the real blood level concentration, that it
exceeded the limit. The quality of justice will be increased by full use of DNA typing. The genes are
arranged in linear order along the chromosome. The more detailed a showing the court requests as to
precisely what issues in the case necessitate expert assistance, the less likely it is that a defense
counsel unsophisticated about DNA testing will be able to satisfy the court. And as always when big
datasets are gathered new mining procedures based on correlation became feasible. LR indicates how
many times more probable it would be to. For example, if torturing a terrorist who knows the
location of a bomb planted to kill a million people is the only way to avert the tragedy, then torture
might be justified. The Cobey court was impressed by the absence of expert testimony contradicting
that in favor of admissibility. To provide the trier of fact—a judge or jury, for example—with
information for weighing the two possibilities, it has been traditional to us statistics from population
genetics to estimate the fraction of people in the population who have the particular combination of
DNA patterns. Draw and label the structure of a simplified single nucleotide, including sugar,
phosphate and base. 2. Complete the table below to. Other research on blood-type evidence has
produced similar results (Faigman and Baglioni 1988; Thompson and Schumann 1987). See other
similar resources ?0.00 4.60 14 reviews Download Save for later Not quite what you were looking
for. It is still unclear whether this provision will cause experts to provide more detailed written
documentation than they previously furnished. This is because most of the Y-chromosome found in
males doesn’t change with each new generation which brings into account the likelihood of paternal
lineages during Y-STR analysis. Mapping our genes—the genome projects: how big, how fast.
Court-appointed experts could also provide information about the composition of databases and the
scientific literature dealing with specific issues. A brief argument to the contrary is made in
Thompson (1993). Professional forecasters, physicians, science writers, students, and soldiers show
high variability in translating verbal probability expressions to numerical expressions (Mosteller and
Youtz 1990; Wallsten and Budesco 1990). Inasmuch as the purpose of our report is to determine
what aspects of the procedures used in connection with forensic DNA testing are scientifically valid,
we attempt no such policy judgment. Some knowledge of the scientific background behind DNA
extraction is needed to do this. The DNA is placed into a gel (such as agarose), then an electrical
charge is applied into the gel, with positive at the bottom and negative at the top. The structure has
two long polymers of a simple unit called nucleotides. Presentations that suggest to a judge or jury
that DNA typing is infallible are rarely justified and should be avoided. Since Rachel’s census
records indicated a birth in Indiana and Benjamin’s indicated a birth in Ohio, I decided to explore
records of Indiana and Ohio for Benjamin Cox. Are ceiling frequencies sufficiently valid or accepted
in the scientific community to be admissible.
The DNA evidence should not be admissible if the proper procedures were not followed. Thus, the
combination of those factors severely limits the power of conventional forensic serological
examinations as an individual identifier. The newest cases involve attacks on the procedures for
ensuring the accuracy of such analyses and questions about the quantitative interpretation of genetic
typing. In this experiment, a goal is to extract the DNA from a fruit sample. For instance, a body of a
person killed and buried for many years can still yield better results when used in carrying out DNA
evidence. Advances in DNA technology have revolutionized forensic science since its introduction in
the mid 1980s. Among the issues raised is the validity of the assumptions that (1) except for identical
twins, each person's DNA is unique, (2) the technique used allows one to determine whether two
DNA samples show the same patterns at particular loci, and (3) the statistical methods used and the
available population databanks allow one to assess the probability that two DNA samples from
different persons would by chance have the same patterns at the loci studied. Mapping our
genes—the genome projects: how big, how fast. Thus, a few experts have testified on this posterior
probability in court. 99. In a civil case, however, if the results of a DNA analysis are not conclusive,
it will usually be possible to obtain new samples for study. The Virginia law provides for testing of
all convicted felons. Rachel married Hickman Monroe Shults on 4 July 1848 in Navarro County,
Texas. Those matters are better left to the experts and to the lawyers on summation. The author
outlines a PCR experiment geared towards identifying the specific components of the meat
products. For example, data sheets and other materials obtained from experts who are not designated
to testify should be available freely without the need for separate motions, because such materials
are important for the evaluation of the scientific evidence in the case of DNA typing. At the same
time, some courts, expressing concern over the impact of DNA evidence on jurors, have grafted a
procedural safeguard onto the general-acceptance standard. Quantitation using PCR (polymerase
chain reactions) has shown to be extremely sensitive in detecting human specific DNA quantities and
inhibitors. (Ginart et al. 2016) This test can detect DNA to the picogram level and provides forensic
scientists with data to determine further action. In this case my cousin matches share specific DNA
segments with me and that shared DNA came from a common ancestor. In late 1994, one of the
authors of that report, and an early advocate of the ceiling procedure, expressed his belief that the
committee intended to offer ceiling frequencies as a supplement rather than as a necessary substitute
for estimates derived from data on the population or subpopulation of interest (Lander and Budowle
1994). Thus, extraction has to be done in place that physically isolated from the place where
amplification will be performed. (rasskazat podrobnee). Touched surfaces that have been revealed
using fingerprinting methodologies are usually those surfaces on which fingerprints are sought as the
priority, rather than surfaces where DNA will be sampled. Electrophoretic patterns are diagrammed
below. A. Diallelic RFLP system resulting from single nucleotide change as diagrammed in Figure
1-2. Some VNTR polymorphisms have a small number of alleles, and the patterns of RFs that
represent each of the alleles at a given locus can be readily distinguished. The electrophoresis
apparatus creates an electrical field with positive and negative poles at the ends of the gel. This
volume offers recommendations for handling DNA samples, performing calculations, and other
aspects of using DNA as a forensic tool—modifying some recommendations presented in the 1992
volume. See Weinstein, Rule 702 of the Federal Rules of Evidence is sound; it should be amended
(138 F.R.D. 1991) (discussing 7'wo Bulls ). In Andrews v. State, 25 a Florida court of appeals (the
first higher-level state court to consider DNA evidence) determined that the relevance approach was
applicable under the Florida evidence code that tracks the federal rules. These have traditionally been
held to include prohibitions against enslavement, torture, gratuitous infliction of harm on human
beings, and modes of exploitation that use humans as merely a means (usually without their
knowledge or consent) to serve the ends of others. 6 To hold that such actions or practices are
intrinsically wrong is not to claim that they can never be justified. Before making use of evidence
derived from scientific advances, courts must scrutinize the proposed testimony to determine its
suitability for use at trial, and controversy within the scientific community often is regarded as
grounds for the exclusion of the scientific evidence. Those cases focused less on the laboratory
methods for characterizing and matching DNA and more on the statistical methods for interpreting
the significance of similarities in DNA samples.
However, It has been used since 1970s for making copies(amplifying) of DNA when DNA is not
enough for creating profiling. CRISPR interference limits horizontal gene transfer in staphylococci
by targeting DNA. The Castro court stated that the focus of the Frye test as applied to DNA typing
(or any other novel scientific evidence of similar complexity) must include its application to the
particular case. Sign up for email notifications and we'll let you know about new publications in your
areas of interest when they're released. Particularly in regard to DNA typing, the manner in which
probabilities should be calculated requires great care. Complexities arise with DNA typing, because
the full typing process rests on theories and findings that pertain to various scientific fields. In
anthropology, whole genome studies of ancient individuals have also been used to answer questions
regarding the peopling of the Americas. We use cookies to create the best experience for you. DNA
is used in a crime scene to identify the perpetrator of the crime. Such free exchange of information,
including access to databanks and to samples of evidence DNA, should apply to defense and
prosecution experts in both criminal and civil cases. LR indicates how many times more probable it
would be to. Some VNTR polymorphisms have a small number of alleles, and the patterns of RFs
that represent each of the alleles at a given locus can be readily distinguished. This is done breaking
down the proteins and other cellular material, yet not the DNA itself. The tools of DNA typing
include restriction enzymes, electrophoresis, probes, and the polymerase chain reaction. 11, 12, 13.
The more LR exceeds 1, the greater the probative value of the data in supporting hypothesis S (see
Lempert 1977). Some of the component subpopulations might have allele frequencies quite different
from the mean values of the whole population. The appellate court was informed that outside experts
had twice verified the laboratory's procedures and results. Vuichard et al. (2011) propose that the
initial lysis of the samples may have a large impact on the amount of male DNA that is recovered and
ultimately extracted. The committee considers how laboratory errors (particularly false matches) can
arise, how errors might be reduced, and how to take into account the fact that the error rate can never
be reduced to zero. Register for a free account to start saving and receiving special member only
perks. This can be done through the extraction of genomic DNA from a small tissue sample like
feathers, blood, or any other tissue of a species and then the CHD1 genes are amplified using PCR.
The committee believes that the expenditures are warranted by the advantages to be expected.
Recently, this volume was brought to worldwide attention in the murder trial of celebrity O. J.
Simpson. The Evaluation of Forensic DNA Evidence reports on developments in population genetics
and statistics since the original volume was published. After being convicted of rape, in part on the
basis of DNA typing evidence, the defendant appealed, arguing that there was no general agreement
concerning test methods, use of control samples, or the need for a testing laboratory to meet external
performance standards. Starting with People v Castro, 144 Misc. 2d 956, 545 N.Y.S. 2d 985 (Sup.
Ct. 1989), a minority of courts have treated an inquiry into a laboratory's conforming in a particular
case to a generally accepted protocol as an essential part of a pretrial hearing under Frye. 41. It is to
be expected that the frequencies of the various alleles for the DNA polymorphisms also show
differences among populations. In this paper, we propose a framework and algorithm for seamless
integration of both systems from the Bayesian perspective. Electrophoresis, typically performed on
agarose or acrylamide gels, results in large fragments at one end and small fragments at the other; the
small fragments migrate farthest in the electric field. Amplification of a variable number of tandem
repeats (VNTR) locus (pMCT118) by the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and its application to
forensic science. J For Sci. 35:1196-1200, 1990. Although some courts have ordered liberal discovery
with regard to DNA testing, 5 other courts have taken a more restrictive approach. 6 In jurisdictions
that interpret their discovery rules as applying only to written reports, the defense cannot obtain
discovery of laboratory records if the DNA examiner fails to submit a written report or to
incorporate a matter into a report, even if the examiner makes an oral report. 7 Our recommendation
that all aspects of DNA testing be fully.
In the absence of specific objections to laboratory procedures, a court may rely on evidence of
accreditation and certifications, a history of adequacy of testing by the laboratory, and other
assurances of careful practice. The prosecution relied on a Bayesian analysis of this type in State v
Klindt, 389 N.W.2d 670 (Iowa 1986), a gruesome chainsaw-murder case decided before the
emergence of DNA testing. The small amount of research on reactions to probabilistic evidence
suggests that methods of presentation may strongly affect reactions to DNA evidence. Conversely,
autosomal STR analysis is preferred when the microscopic examination for spermatozoa is positive.
When the swabbing method is utilized, the surface of the item is usually rubbed with a wet cotton
swab, followed by a dry cotton swab in an effort to collect possible skin cells. A human has 50,000-
100,000 genes, each occurring in every nucleated body cell. The method, as described in the 1992
report, includes many refinements, and ambiguities or variations in the details have led to the
presentation of markedly different values by prosecutors and defendants as the ceiling frequency. 71
We believe that combing. VNTRs are a leading form of variation used currently in forensic DNA
typing. As with frequencies and match probabilities, prejudice might exist. When the sample has
been collected, and there is a enough DNA present to complete the profile, the DNA must be
processed. The scientist must be able to separate DNA from the unwanted substances of the cell
gently enough so that the DNA is not broken up. Prior DNA analysis and methods of extraction are
vital in order to establish an identifiable profile. DNA evidence, like other scientific and statistical
evidence, can pose special problems of jury comprehension. If such evidence is to be useful in court,
scientifically acceptable procedures must permit the reliable measurement and comparison of physical
features. To obtain the best experience, we recommend you use a more up to date browser or turn off
compatibility mode in Internet Explorer. In addition, the court concluded that the laboratory's
population-frequency databank could not provide an accurate estimate of the likelihood that the
defendant was the source of the DNA. The defendant did not challenge the principles of DNA
typing or the general qualifications of the state's five experts. It is accurate to characterize the
estimate obtained with those methods as match probabilities if it is established or assumed that the
laboratory correctly characterized the human DNA in the samples and that the samples came from
reported sources. There are several actions that could trigger this block including submitting a certain
word or phrase, a SQL command or malformed data. Reasonable estimates of allele frequencies in
major population groups can be obtained from standard references, and many quantitatively literate
experts could use the appropriate formulas in Chapters 4 and 5 to compute the relevant profile
frequencies or probabilities. There is no need for a general moratorium on the use of the results of
DNA typing either in investigation or in the courts. The Institute acts under the responsibility given
to the National Academy of Sciences by its congressional charter to be an advisor to the federal
government and, upon its own initiative, to identify issues of medical care, research, and education.
Insertion or deletion of nucleotides between two cleavage sites also changes RF lengths. The ASO
probe is mixed with dissociated strands of PCR reaction product under such conditions that the ASO
and the PCR product strands hybridize if there is perfect sequence complementarity, but do not if
there are mismatches in sequence. Presentations that suggest to a judge or jury that DNA typing is
infallible are rarely justified and should be avoided. First, blood is one of the main sources of DNA
evidence. As the DNA moves through the gel, a laser excites the tags and a picture is made of the
pattern of bands that represent the lengths of the STR. In some circumstances, the constitution
requires that indigent defendants be provided with funds to retain suitable experts. Bonded to each
sugar is 4 different types of molecules called bases. Isolated DNA from a tissue of a plant, animal,
microbe or a human is therefore very useful since it provide much information about the individual,
its characters and genetic background.
In that context, we review some of the rapidly growing number of cases involving admissibility. In
addition, some jurisdictions have adopted special statutes that provide for the admissibility of genetic
testing in general or of DNA analyses in particular in criminal or civil cases. 12 If a timely objection
is raised, the judge must determine whether the applicable standard has been met. A considerable
degree of discretion and control by the courts in these cases is recommended. When two variable
sites, each on a different chromosome, are examined, the inheritance at one site is independent of
that at the other; i.e., which paternal allele is inherited at site 1 bears no relation to which paternal
allele is inherited at site 2. Are ceiling frequencies sufficiently valid or accepted in the scientific
community to be admissible. As in criminal cases, laboratories and other interested parties must treat
evidence according to established protocols. Castro, 4 in which a New York trial court concluded
that the theory underlying DNA typing is generally accepted by scientists in genetics and related
fields, that forensic DNA typing has also been accepted and is reliable, but that the technique as
applied in the particular case was so flawed that evidence of a match was inadmissible (although
evidence of an exclusion was admissible). For example, could a vegetarian panda have predictable
genetic differences from a meat-eating polar bear? 'To test this hypothesis, we picked simple groups
of parasites to use as a model system. Unlike your scenario, though, is that I cannot place Benjamin
or any of his family in the same areas as the matches locations. It is autonomous in its administration
and in the selection of its members, sharing with the National Academy of Sciences the responsibility
for advising the federal government. There is clearly a need to conduct further studies on the issue.
The main biological molecule of target for forensic analysis is deoxyribonucleic acid ( dna ), which is
present in all cells of all organisms. Biological evidences at the scene of the crime thus serve as
essential resources for dna that could be employed in the forensic analysis of a criminal case. We will
also be discussing some background information on the subject. Study co-author Emily Seward, a
doctoral candidate in Oxford's Department of Plant Sciences, said: 'It has been unclear why very
closely related organisms can look so different in their genetic makeup. Advances in DNA
technology in the 1970s paved the way for the detection of variation (polymorphism) in specific
DNA sequences and shifted the study of human variation from the protein products of DNA to
DNA itself. The script used to quantify pegRNA scaffold insertion is provided as Supplementary
Note 4. Landrum, M. et al. ClinVar: public archive of interpretations of clinically relevant variants.
Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1983. Thus, the combination of those factors
severely limits the power of conventional forensic serological examinations as an individual
identifier. Chapters 3-5. OTA-BA-438. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1990.
First try the technique on yourself, then ask a friend or family member to let you learn by using his
or her fingerprints. We performed more than edits in human cells, including targeted insertions,
deletions, and all 12 types of point mutation, without requiring double-strand breaks or donor DNA
templates. Learn how your comment data is processed. Follow Us. However, it has to be a meeting
of the two families somehow at some point since a match that high has to be real. Gregorio et al.
(2019) discussed the practice of completely saturating the SAP so that the free-water immersing the
sanitary product exceeds the absorbance capacity of the hydrogel, thus promoting the release of
biological material. I can honestly say before doing this report I had no idea really what DNA was.
Some state statutes use them to create a presumption of paternity (Kaye 1990a,b,c). Any reservations
about inadequacies or errors should be promptly revealed, and failure to do that should be dealt with
seriously. Similar tests conducted by FBI to determine correctness of the tests of FSA showed a
mismatch between the dna in the examined underwear of the victim and that of Bloodsworth
(McNamara, 2009). Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Also, you can type in a page number and press Enter to go directly to that page in the book.
Generally, to be admissible the scientific evidence must have probative value. As a response, this
study was initiated in January 1990. This Kiwi - buffer mixture was then incubated at 600 C for 15
min. Indigent criminal defendants might have a constitutional due-process right to have an expert
witness paid for by the government. The lengths at which this science can evolve are endless. In this
adjudication, the accreditation and certification status of the laboratory performing the analysis
should be taken into account. Marietta Toal, Administrative Secretary, served the committee well in
logistics and the preparation of the report. In fact, new developments should present less difficulty
than has been posed by present DNA typing technology, because much of the theory will have
already been tested and accepted by the courts. DNA profiling is the only way through which
scientists can be able to stain of a given blood mixture. When VNTR profiling is done with due care,
the results are highly reproducible, and comparisons at four or more loci are almost certain to
exclude the innocent. Some courts have held that an expert must be provided, 49 and others have
found no such need. 50. However, the practice has met with much less favor in criminal cases where
the experts failed to disclose that they had used an ad hoc prior probability of one-half. 100 The
expert-prior-odds approach has been criticized as requiring a jury to defer to an expert's choice of
the prior odds, even though the scientist's special knowledge and skill extend merely to the
production of the likelihood ratio for the scientific evidence (Kaye 1993). The court concluded that
the DNA typing evidence offered by the plaintiff was clearly helpful to the jury. The author outlines
a PCR experiment geared towards identifying the specific components of the meat products. I did
this original research several years ago and the timeline analysis revealed several opportunities for
further research. Also, you can type in a page number and press Enter to go directly to that page in
the book. A special register of scientific experts can be maintained for ready access. I also thank
Della Malone, my secretary, for her help throughout. The genes are arranged in linear order along the
chromosome. The committee was to address the general applicability and appropriateness of the use
of DNA technology in forensic science, the need for standards in data collection and analysis, the
need for advances in technology, management of DNA typing data, and legal, societal, and ethical
issues surrounding DNA typing. Not all samples need to be amplified, but if one needs to be
amplified it will be done before moving to the Genetic Analyzer and genotyping. In this experiment,
a goal is to extract the DNA from a fruit sample. Law enforcement officials submitted blood samples
from victim and suspect and vaginal swabs from victim. The first case work was performed in
December 1988. We have an extensive amount of paper research (every bit of paper available in
Bladen, present-day Sampson, Duplin, Robeson Counties, NC. ) Thank you for your time. We must
explore, among other questions, the permissible purposes of such banks, how to minimize invasion of
legitimate privacy interests, and how to determine the appropriate response when such interests are
violated 40 (see also Chapters 5 and 7 ). Therefore, a critical step in accepting the use of DNA
technology in criminal trials is establishing safeguards and seeking to prevent abuses. The court
should encourage the use of charts, written reports, and duplicates of materials that are relied on by
the experts, so that the jury can be as well educated as possible in the evaluation of DNA typing
evidence. Similar wide variation is observed with genes for blood groups A and O. Eight of the state
appellate courts upheld trial courts' decisions to admit; the other two approved the scientific theory
underlying DNA typing, but one excluded the work of a particular laboratory because of process
unreliability, and one found that there was.