Professional Documents
Culture Documents
DOI: 10.1111/hae.14561
SUPPLEMENT ARTICLE
1
Division of Thrombosis and Haemostasis,
Department of Haematology, University Abstract
Medical Centre Groningen, University of
Rare bleeding disorders result in significant morbidity but are globally underdiag-
Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands
2 nosed. Advances in genomic testing and specialist laboratory assays have greatly
Radboud University Medical Center,
Hemophilia Treatment Centre, increased the diagnostic armamentarium. This has resulted in the discovery of new
Nijmegen-Eindhoven-Maastricht, Nijmegen,
genetic causes for rare diseases and a better understanding of the underlying molec-
The Netherlands
3
Enzyre, Nijmegen, The Netherlands
ular pathology.
4
Haemophilia Centre and Thrombosis Unit,
KEYWORDS
Royal Free London NHS Foundation Trust,
London, UK blood coagulation disorders, blood platelet disorders, hemorrhagic disorders, whole exome
sequencing, whole genome sequencing
Correspondence
Keith Gomez, Haemophilia Centre and
Thrombosis Unit, Royal Free London NHS
Foundation Trust, Pond Street, London NW3
2QG, UK.
Email: k.gomez@ucl.ac.uk
Haemophilia. 2022;28(Suppl. 4):119–124. wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/hae © 2022 John Wiley & Sons Ltd. 119
13652516, 2022, S4, Downloaded from https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/hae.14561 by Algeria Hinari NPL, Wiley Online Library on [31/03/2024]. See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License
120 MEIJER ET AL .
does not necessarily mean that there is no real suspicion of a bleeding for at least 10 years, and no treatment with clotting factors or desmo-
disorder: a single very suspect bleeding event in a young patient with pressin is documented. His daughter, who presented for preconception
no further challenges maybe a valid indication for haemostatic evalua- advice, has a normal factor VIII level and no bleeding symptoms. She
tion. However, it could also indicate that the threshold for referral was undergoes genetic analysis specifically for haemophilia A, which does
too low. not identify any potentially pathogenic variants in the F8 gene.
Overall, that is without exclusion based on the review of bleeding
symptoms, tertiary centres using advanced haemostatic testing reach
a final diagnosis of a defined bleeding disorder in 30%-50% of those 2.2 Case 2
referred.2-4
In the absence of a diagnosis, no disease-specific treatment can be Ms B, 18 years old, was referred from a community hospital with
prescribed. For mild bleeding disorders, this might be less of a problem mild thrombocytopaenia, diagnosed when she presented with bleed-
than expected. Two retrospective cohorts described the outcome of a ing after dental extraction. She uses oral contraceptives for heavy men-
standard regime of tranexamic acid and/or desmopressin in patients strual bleeding and tonsillectomy as a toddler was complicated by
with unexplained bleeding. In the first, with 53 low-risk surgical pro- bleeding immediately after the procedure. She is otherwise healthy.
cedures, 16 high risk and 13 deliveries, this was associated with the Except for a possible mild bleeding tendency in her mother, there
absence of bleeding in 75/82.5 In the second cohort, 70 out of 78 pro- was nothing remarkable in the family history. Platelet count was
cedures (including minor and major surgery, and deliveries) had good 93 × 109 /L, MPV reported as ‘not measurable’, with an excess of imma-
haemostatic outcome.6 Of course, tranexamic acid is often also used ture platelets. Light transmission aggregometry was confused by the
for minor interventions and menorrhagia in patients with a specific intermittent, ill-documented use of non-steroidal anti-inflammatory
diagnosis of a mild bleeding disorder. drugs, but seemed decreased with adrenaline and collagen.
Failing to identify the molecular cause of a heritable thrombocy-
topaenia often leads to a misdiagnosis of immune thrombocytopae-
nia and results in unnecessary immunosuppressive therapy or even 2.3 Case 3
splenectomy. In the contemporary McMaster thrombocytopaenia reg-
ister, five out of 295 patients with an initial diagnosis of ITP were reclas- Ms N, 26 years old, was referred for investigation of a bleeding his-
sified as having inherited thrombocytopaenia during follow-up.7 This tory because she wished to start a family. Her major complaints were
demonstrates the importance of obtaining a family history and enquir- severe menorrhagia that persisted despite the commencement of the
ing after syndromic features prior to making a diagnosis of ITP. To date, oral contraceptive pill and necessitated iron supplementation. In con-
and reflecting the recent introduction of widespread genetic testing, no junction with other episodes of unexplained bleeding, her BAT score
systematically collected data are available on how often genetic diag- was 9. Her father had recurrent epistaxis, whereas her mother and sis-
nosis leads to a change in treatment plan. ter had no bleeding symptoms. Previously, her bleeding time was pro-
When no specific diagnosis can be made, it is difficult to discuss longed and clotting screen revealed a prolonged PT and APTT. Fac-
prognosis: How big is the risk that certain procedures are complicated tor assays showed an isolated mild factor II deficiency, and borderline
by bleeding? A recent study reported that, in 90 patients with bleed- results in the von Willebrand factor assays.
ing of unknown cause, higher bleeding scores were associated with an
increased risk of future bleeding.8 However, the size of the effect was
too small for useful prediction on an individual level. Uncertainty of 3 PHENOTYPIC LABORATORY ANALYSIS
bleeding risk can lead to avoidance of procedures. For instance, neu-
raxial analgesia might be denied to women in childbirth. Lastly, a defini- A thorough laboratory analysis to diagnose the patients’ anomaly
tive molecular diagnosis makes screening of family members more requires a detailed analysis of the haemostatic system (Figure 1). As
accurate. This is especially important if family members have not had this is an interaction between vessel wall, platelets, coagulation and
haemostatic challenges and need to undergo major procedures. fibrinolysis, an in-depth analysis can be laborious, time-consuming and
In this review, we will introduce some hypothetical case scenarios, expensive.
explore the laboratory and genomic options for diagnosis and subse- Theoretically, the best approach is to have sensitive screening
quently discuss how this might be applied in these cases. assays for each compartment. Apart from vessel wall abnormali-
ties that cannot be covered with laboratory assays, easy-to-perform
screening assays only exist for platelet number and coagulation factor
2 CASE SCENARIOS deficiencies other than von Willebrand disease. Prothrombin time (PT),
activated partial thromboplastin time (APTT) and thrombin time (TT)
2.1 Case 1 are typical coagulation screening assays.
A positive result in one of the screening assays streamlines identi-
Mr A, 56 years old, was diagnosed with mild haemophilia A in the fication of the patient’s anomaly as it directs confirmatory assays. The
1990s. He has not been seen in the Haemophilia Treatment Centre analysis is hampered in cases where screening assays are completely
13652516, 2022, S4, Downloaded from https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/hae.14561 by Algeria Hinari NPL, Wiley Online Library on [31/03/2024]. See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License
MEIJER ET AL . 121
responsible for rare bleeding disorders. This is well demonstrated by be a relatively benign disorder characterized by thrombocytopaenia
the fact that the EAHAD VWF database has approximately half the and relatively little other pathology. It is now clear that the same
number of unique variants listed compared with F8, despite von Wille- causative variants in MYH9 are also seen in the more serious conditions
brand disease being 10 times more common. Essentially, it has simply Epstein, Fechtner or Sebastian syndrome in association with presenile
been too expensive and laborious to support routine sequencing of cataracts, hearing loss and renal failure.16 These eponymous names
rare disorders using standard sequencing techniques that analyse part implying distinct conditions no longer reflect the genotype-phenotype
of a single gene at a time. relationship with these genes. The single overarching term, MYH9-
The Human Genome Project completed in 2003 required the devel- related thrombocytopaenia, better reflects our current understanding
opment of techniques that allowed the quick analysis of vast sequences that the spectrum of disease encompasses all these clinical features.
of DNA in parallel.10 These techniques are collectively referred to as While NGS has enabled access to genes for which testing was not
‘high-throughput’ or ‘next-generation’ sequencing. They have provided previously feasible in a clinical setting, the efficiency of simultaneous
access to the whole genome, which in the case of humans is 3 billion multigene testing does come with some disadvantages. Incidental find-
base pairs. Costs have plummeted and now we can analyse the whole ings are an obvious example. Currently, the available platforms can be
genome, and all of the 20 000 or so protein-coding genes that it con- divided into those that offer whole-genome testing and those that offer
tains, for less than the price of a single gene analysis 10 years ago. gene panels which group together all the genes that are of relevance for
Alongside these new techniques, we have seen the development of a particular field. The genomics scientific subcommittee of the Inter-
bioinformatic tools to process the vast amount of data generated. Fil- national Society on Thrombosis and Haemostasis maintains a list of
tering of variants against the allele frequencies listed in large genomic genes that are considered to be proven to cause haemostatic disease
databases of apparently normal individuals, in silico analysis of their at https://www.isth.org/page/GinTh_GeneLists. As of February 2020,
effect on gene structure and protein function and use of algorithms to there are 101 genes in this list of which 22 are coagulation factor genes,
collate this evidence are part of the several layers of analysis required 11 are thrombotic and 68 cause platelet abnormalities. A gene panel
to determine whether a variant is pathogenic or not. However, filter- for clinical use in the field of haemostasis would be expected to contain
ing using allele frequency can exclude some common pathogenic vari- all these genes with the option for revision as new genes are added to
ants. This can be mitigated by the use of ‘whitelists’. These advances this list. The likelihood of an incidental finding is relatively low with a
had allowed several projects in different countries that have focused gene panel. This was demonstrated in the ThromboGenomics project
on investigating the genetic basis of rare bleeding disorders.11-14 There which investigated nearly 2400 patients with haemostatic disease and
have been several benefits: patients with rare heritable bleeding dis- resulted in only 6 incidental findings that were considered reportable
orders can now receive a genetic diagnosis as easily as patients with under current guidance.11 With whole-genome analysis that poten-
haemophilia, our understanding of the molecular basis of rare disease tially gives access to an estimated 20 000 genes, the potential for inci-
and phenotypic effects is rapidly increasing and many new genes that dental findings is obviously much greater. The handling of potentially
cause bleeding disorders have been discovered. pathogenic variants in genes unrelated to the field of interest requires
If we take the example of Hermansky-Pudlak syndrome, then prior extensive interaction between different clinical disciplines and is dif-
to the advent of NGS there were only two genes with a proven link to ficult to implement in current clinical services. It is unclear whether
the disease. Few patients could access genetic diagnosis and all were patients receive a net benefit from these findings, and this raises impor-
considered to be at risk of serious sequelae such as pulmonary fibrosis tant ethical considerations.17 For the moment, clinical services are
and granulomatous colitis. We now have at least 10 causative genes, largely based on gene panels with whole-genome analysis mostly used
and only three are associated with pulmonary fibrosis. Increasing use in research.
of genetic diagnosis has allowed lung screening to be restricted only to Finally, it is important to be aware of the limitations of any diagnos-
those patients that need it. tic tool. The chance of finding a potentially pathogenic variant depends
Accurate genotyping of rare disorders has allowed better mapping on the type of haemostatic disorder under investigation. In the Throm-
of non-haemostatic clinical features. For genes encoding transcription boGenomics study, 67% of patients with mostly rare coagulation fac-
factors such as RUNX1, ETV6 and GATA1, this has led to a better under- tor deficiencies had a pathogenic or potentially pathogenic variant. For
standing of the risk of developing leukaemia.15 In other haematological patients with heritable disorders of platelet number and/or function,
stem cell disorders, identification of the molecular aetiology has led to the diagnosis rate was rather lower at 38% because the genetic basis of
the development of specific molecular therapies, such as the introduc- these disorders is much less well-characterized. Often, there is simply
tion of tyrosine kinase inhibitors following on from the characteriza- insufficient knowledge of the effects of variation in a specific gene to be
tion of the BCR-ABL oncogene. At the moment, identification of these confident of predicting pathogenicity. Co-segregation studies may help
variants does not improve clinical outcomes, but we can confidently in large pedigrees with clearly defined laboratory assays for a specific
expect that specific molecular therapies will become available for those phenotype. Where this is not feasible, it is expected that the accumu-
at risk of malignancy due to the variants in the above genes. lation of ‘big data’ through international collaborative databases will
In some cases, the accurate association of phenotype with geno- facilitate curation. NGS remains primarily a sequencing tool that has
type has resulted in a revaluation of the clinical features of well- a very high accuracy for single nucleotide changes. Copy number vari-
characterized conditions. May-Hegglin anomaly was considered to ants may also be detected with comparative analysis of read depth,
13652516, 2022, S4, Downloaded from https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/hae.14561 by Algeria Hinari NPL, Wiley Online Library on [31/03/2024]. See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License
MEIJER ET AL . 123
but complex rearrangements are not detected. An important exam- be utilized earlier in the diagnostic pathway. In contrast with assays
ple is the intron 22 inversion in F8, which is the commonest cause of such as platelet aggregometry, which require the patient to attend a
haemophilia A, and is undetectable by current NGS techniques. We also specialist centre for a fresh blood sample, samples for genomic testing
have to be mindful that pseudogenes and repetitive elements can lead can be taken remotely, perhaps even non-invasively with saliva sam-
to misleading results and coverage of the non-coding space is of inad- ples, and sent by ordinary post to the testing laboratory. However,
equate quality for many genes. All these factors need to be considered except for a few well-characterized variants that have been reported
when interpreting negative reports. often enough that pathogenicity classification is automatic, interpre-
tation still requires correlation with laboratory assays to establish
the genotype-phenotype relationship. The laboratory assays described
5 DISCUSSION above are unlikely to become redundant any time soon.
Genetic diagnosis can also have drawbacks, especially in the diag-
5.1 Case 1, continued nosis of platelet disorders with unanticipated clinical features. This
is illustrated by the second case, where the patient did not make an
Current genetic testing strategies fail to identify the causative vari- explicit choice to know about her increased risk of renal disease. How-
ant in about 5% of cases of non-severe haemophilia A. Non-paternity, ever, for MYH9 disease, the diagnosis gives opportunities for preventa-
mosaicism and an alternative diagnosis are also possible explanations tive action (ie follow-up of renal function, initiation of angiotensin inhi-
for the absence of a variant in a daughter expected to be an obli- bition). This is not always the case.
gate carrier. In this case, genetic testing of the index revealed homozy- Inherited platelet disorders can be subdivided into three groups,
gosity for a variant previously reported in two families with type 2N based on their additional features: ‘affecting only platelets’, ‘with
von Willebrand disease. Subsequently, further genetic analysis on his a syndromic phenotype’ and ‘with increased risk of haematological
daughter showed her to be heterozygous for the same variant. malignancies’.18 For this third group, the consequences of genetic test-
ing can be profound.19 It would be desirable to allow patients to make
an informed choice as to which genes are tested, thereby controlling
5.2 Case 2, continued to some extent the possibility of unexpected findings. However, this
requires in-depth knowledge of testing strategy at the time of the
In Ms B, the application of an NGS panel focused on primary haemosta- request and may not be possible depending on how the NGS platform is
sis showed heterozygosity for a previously reported variant in the set-up. This has wider ethical implications when the rights and wishes
MYH9 gene. On further questioning, the family history was negative for of relatives are considered. Testing of multiple members of a pedi-
renal disease, cataract or hearing loss. Additional testing revealed pro- gree can infer genotype in untested relatives whether or not they have
teinuria with intact renal function in the patient, and she was referred agreed to testing. The ISTH scientific subcommittee for genomics in
to a nephrologist. thrombosis is currently preparing guidance on the ethical implications
of genomic testing for platelet disorders.
In conclusion, NGS has greatly improved our ability to provide
5.3 Case 3, continued a definitive diagnosis in patients with a heritable platelet disor-
der. In patients with other rare bleeding disorders that were previ-
Genomic panel testing revealed heterozygosity for a nonsense vari- ously diagnosed phenotypically (ie coagulation deficiencies other than
ant in VWF that was classed as pathogenic, and heterozygosity for a haemophilia A or haemophilia B), advanced genetic testing provides
likely pathogenic variant in F2. The introduction of a premature stop confirmation, better understanding of the molecular pathology and the
codon in one VWF allele would explain the borderline levels of this fac- opportunity for prenatal testing. Additionally, NGS may streamline the
tor and would be expected to result in type 3 disease in the homozy- diagnostic process, replacing part of the traditional haemostatic work-
gous state. Similarly, the missense variant in one F2 allele is consistent up.
with the mild reduction in factor II levels. In isolation, neither of these
variants would be expected to result in significant bleeding symptoms, ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
but it may be that the combination of both could result in the pheno- KG was a chief investigator in the ThromboGenomics study. WvH is the
type described. chief scientific officer of Enzyre.
For many patients, the developments discussed in this paper have
led to improved diagnostics, within some cases access to specific ther- DISCLOSURES
apy or diagnostic possibilities for family members. A comprehensive The authors stated that they had no interests which might be perceived
list of outcomes after extensive investigations is given in the EHA Con- as posing a conflict or bias.
sensus Report.1 In our first case, the correct diagnosis of type 2N von
Willebrand disease led to a modified treatment plan for the index case ORCID
and appropriate counselling of his daughter. As the cost of genomic Karina Meijer https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9447-0465
testing falls and access increases, it has been suggested that it could Keith Gomez https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8934-0700
13652516, 2022, S4, Downloaded from https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/hae.14561 by Algeria Hinari NPL, Wiley Online Library on [31/03/2024]. See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License
124 MEIJER ET AL .