Professional Documents
Culture Documents
http://www.elsevier.com/locate/apenergy
Abstract
Integration of natural ventilation and daylighting in a single installation would make both
technologies more attractive. One method for the integration is the use of concentric light pipe
and ventilation stack. By constructing the light pipe using dichroic materials, the infrared part
of the solar radiation is allowed to be transmitted to the stack but the visible light is guided by
the light pipe into a room. The heat gain to the interior can be reduced and the thermal stack
eect strengthened. Work presented here involved the experimental and computational eva-
luation of dichroic materials for enhancing both natural stack ventilation and daylighting.
The transmittance of a dichroic light pipe was found to be similar to that of a light pipe with a
95% specular re¯ectance. The infra-red radiation transmitted through the dichroic material
into a passive stack was found to enhance the natural ventilation ¯ow by up to 14%. The
eect is greater in summer than in winter, which is highly desirable as there is often a lack of
driving force for natural stack ventilation in summer. # 1999 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights
reserved.
1. Introduction
0306-2619/99/$ - see front matter # 1999 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
PII: S0306-2619(99)00014-8
254 A.A. Elmualim et al. / Applied Energy 62 (1999) 253±266
Tests were carried out in a specially constructed room with black internal surfaces
to obtain the characteristics of the dichroic material in terms of infra-red and visible
light transmittances and specular re¯ectances for visible light, as detailed below.
The dichroic material for testing was obtained from Sycamore Glass Components,
USA. The material has a nominal re¯ectance of 90% between the wavelengths of
420 and 630 nm and a nominal transmittance of 85% on average between the
wavelengths of 750 and 1200 nm. The 750±1200 nm band carries most infra-red
energy in the solar radiation [13]. The substrate is Boro¯oat, a borosilicate glass that
can handle heat. The high cost of the dichroic material currently purchased from
Sycamore precludes the construction and testing of actual light pipes lined with the
material. However, recent advances in material and manufacturing technologies
indicated that dichroic materials' cost would soon be dramatically reduced to allow
large-scale applications in buildings.
The light source used for the tests was manufactured by General Electric (GE)
lighting. The lamp is Halogen TAL 100 mm with an integrated metal re¯ector and
constant colour coatings providing consistent light quality and high intensity. The
power of the lamp was 50 W and the beam had a peak intensity of 55,000 cd and
beam spread of 4 . The colour temperature of the lamp is 3000 K and with a rated
average life of 3500 h. The environmental chamber within which the optical experi-
ments were carried out is a wooden structure measuring 333 m, with a single
door and no other openings. The walls, door, ¯oor and ceiling were covered in a
black matt paper to reduce the amount of secondary re¯ection, which may aect
readings, but only to a negligible amount. The test rig was on a platform inside
the chamber and the equipment was operated from outside the chamber without
the presence of the researcher inside the chamber. This also reduced the amount
of unwanted secondary re¯ection. All experiments on the dichroic material were
carried out under these strict conditions to ensure that accurate results were
obtained.
The tests for the dichroic study were performed on a platform situated at the
centre of the environmental chamber. Fig. 2 shows the schematic layout of the
typical arrangement for the measurement of transmitted infra-red and visible light
256 A.A. Elmualim et al. / Applied Energy 62 (1999) 253±266
Fig. 2. Experimental set-up for the measurement of transmitted infra-red and visible light of a dichroic
material disk.
through a dichroic-coated glass disk. Steel rods and clamps were used to ®x a 0.5 m
long black tube horizontally on a table covered with matt black paper. The position
and the horizontal levelling of the tube were checked regularly with a spirit level.
The light source was placed at one end of the narrow black tube and the dichroic
disk positioned on a spectrometer at the other end of the tube. The spectrometer
allowed accurate adjustment and measurement of the angle between the dichroic
disk and the light beam. The irradiance of infra-red and illuminance of visible light
were measured both before and after the dichroic disk is positioned in place [Fig.
3(a) and (b) respectively]. These data were then used to calculate transmittance
values.
The tube was coated on the inside and the outside with a matt black paint to
ensure that the light rays meeting the dichroic disk are very close to being parallel.
This allowed the accurate determination and adjustment of the incidence angle used
in the tests. It was anticipated that, as the experiment continues, the tube would get
hot due to the radiated heat from the lamp which may cause errors in the infra-red
measurements. The lamp operating time and the corresponding extent of this eect
were monitored and the information was then used to plan the test procedures.
Measurements were taken during a short period of a few seconds between cooling
intervals of about 15 min to control the temperature of the tube and to prevent the
tube from heating up. This eliminated the error due to the radiated energy from the
tube. The instrumentation was controlled and measurements undertaken from outside
the chamber. The photometer used was a Hanger Universal Photometer/Radiometer
model S3 ®tted with sensors for the measurements of visible light illuminance and a
special detector for the measurement of infra-red irradiance. It incorporated silicon-
diode photocells with approximately the spectral sensitivity of the human eye (CIE).
It was capable of measuring illuminance in the range 0.01±200,000 lux. It has an
accuracy of 3% and a virtually perfect cosine correction curve. The photometer
was connected to a remote photocell via a ¯exible lead, making it easier to obtain
readings without blocking incident radiation reaching the photocell. The infra-red
remote sensor (SD7) had a spectral response to wavelength in the range of 700±1150
nm. It had an absolute sensitivity of 2 nA/W/m2, with an accuracy of 3%.
Tests to determine the visible-light specular re¯ectance of the dichroic disk were
carried out in overcast-sky conditions. Prior to each test, a luminance range check
was carried out to ensure that the overcast-sky condition was present at the time of
the test. The overcast condition is assumed to occur when the average horizon
luminance does not exceed half the luminance of the zenith. The tests were carried
out in a large room, with large windows open to the outside, using the technique of
Fontoynont and Berrutto [14]. A piece of matt white paper (0.20.3 m) is attached
to the window glass. The dichroic disk is positioned on the ¯oor at a distance from
the sheet of paper to allow light from the paper to strike the disk surface at a
required angle of incidence on the disk to be established. The specular re¯ectance at
a speci®c incidence-angle was determined by measuring the luminance ``Lr'' of the
image of the paper re¯ected o the dichroic disk and the luminance from the paper,
``Ls''. The ratio (Lr/Ls) of the two values is the specular re¯ectance of the dichroic
disk at the speci®c angle-of-incidence. The test was repeated for a range of incidence
angles of 10 to 80 at 10 intervals.
The eect of dichroic material on the enhancement of the stack ¯ow was analysed
using a computer program, which was based on an MS Excel spreadsheet. Compu-
tational experimentation was carried out on a room, which had a light pipe with a
diameter of 0.3 m located in the centre of the ceiling. The basic room used in the
analysis was a cubic enclosure 333 m, although rooms of other dimensions were
also included in the analysis. The light pipe was placed inside another pipe, with a
diameter of 0.36 m. A natural-ventilation stack was formed between the two con-
centric pipes. The wall of the light pipe was constructed from a dichroic material,
which re¯ected the visible light down the pipe to the occupied spaces, while allowing
the infra-red component of the solar radiation to be transmitted through to the
natural-ventilation stack. An inlet area of 0.09 m2 was assumed along with typical
discharge coecients of 0.6 for the air inlet and 0.5 for the stack outlet. Throughout
this analysis, external and internal temperatures were assumed to be 18 and 22 C
respectively for summer, and 0 and 16 C respectively for winter. The solar infra-red
irradiance (I) transmitted through the light pipe into the stack can be calculated
using:
258 A.A. Elmualim et al. / Applied Energy 62 (1999) 253±266
I PT% Sin
Q ID2pipe =4
where Dpipe is the diameter of the light pipe. The temperature of the stack, based on
the heat input and the room temperature, can be calculated using:
Td Q=Vf Cp Ti
where is air density, Cp is the speci®c heat of air, Ti is the temperature of the room
and Vf is the volume ¯ow rate of the air through the stack. Vf was obtained using:
Vf VI=3600
where V is the volume of the room and I is the air exchange rate of the room. I was
obtained using I 3600 Qo =V, where Qo is the ventilation ¯ow rate when there is no
infra-red heat input into the stack, i.e. the temperature of the stack is the tempera-
ture of the room. The ventilation ¯ow rate of the air can now be calculated [15]:
v
u2g T H T h
u D d
Q1 CD1 A1 u
t 1
Te 1 2
k
where CD1 is the discharge coecient of the air inlet, A1 is the cross-sectional area of
the air inlet, g is the gravitational acceleration, H is the distance from the air inlet to
the base of the light pipe, h is the pipe length, Te is the external temperature, TD is
the dierence between the internal and external temperatures and Td is the dier-
ence between the temperature in the stack and that in the room. The loss coecient
k, is given as:
where A2 is the cross-section area of the stack, and CD2 is the discharge coecient of
the stack. The ventilation ¯ow rate in the dichroic stack was calculated and com-
pared with that in a stack which had identical dimensions but was without dichroic
walls. The relative increase in air-¯ow rate was then calculated.
A.A. Elmualim et al. / Applied Energy 62 (1999) 253±266 259
The results of transmittance of the dichroic material for infra-red are shown in
Table 1 and Fig. 4. The transmittance was about 76% for incidence angles ranging
from zero to 50 , peaking at 30 to reach 76.4%. It then decreased with increasing
incidence angle giving a value of 66.2% at an incidence angle of 60 , 23.2% at 70 ,
1.3% at 80 and reaching zero at 90 . The transmittance of the visible light on the
other hand is minimal at all incidence angles. The maximum level was 5% at the
incidence angle of 70 and its value did not exceed 4.4% in the range of zero to 60 .
These results demonstrate the characteristics of the dichroic material to transmit a
large portion of the infra-red radiation, but relatively little visible light. The infra-
red transmittance of the dichroic material was best within the range of incidence
angles of zero to 60 , which is almost exactly the range of solar altitudes experienced
in most European countries. So the dichroic material tested is most suitable for appli-
cation in Europe and other parts of the world with similar latitudes. Compared with a
conventional light pipe, a dichroic light pipe would remove virtually all infra-red
Table 1
Transmittance of dichroic glass for both visible light and infra-red
0 75.20 0.50
10 75.00 0.60
20 74.70 0.70
30 76.40 1.00
40 76.10 1.90
50 74.80 4.40
60 66.20 4.00
70 23.20 5.00
80 1.30 1.60
90 0 0
radiation in daylight transmitted through light pipes. The cooling load would be
reduced and thermal comfort in occupied spaces would be greatly improved in
summer months. This eect is negligible in winter due to the limited overall solar
radiation available.
Fig. 5 shows the eect on stack ¯ow enhancement of varying the length of the
stack/light pipe and keeping all other variables constant. The summer values were
based on a solar altitude of 50 and winter values on 20 . It can be seen from the
graph, that as the pipe length increases from 0.5 to 3.5 m the ventilation ¯ow rate
increases for both summer and winter conditions and the rate of increase follows a
logarithmic trend. The increases are also much higher in summer than in winter due
to the greater amount of infra-red radiation.
Fig. 6 shows the eect on stack ¯ow enhancement of varying the diameter of the
light pipe and keeping all other variables constant except the diameter of the stack,
Fig. 5. Eect of dichroic material on ventilation rate for various stack/light pipe lengths.
Fig. 6. Eect of dichroic material on ventilation rate for various light pipe diameters.
A.A. Elmualim et al. / Applied Energy 62 (1999) 253±266 261
which was adjusted to maintain a constant stack width of 3 cm. The summer values
were based on a solar altitude of 50 and winter values on 20 . It can be seen from
the graph that, as the diameter of the light pipe increases from 0.1 to 0.8 m, the
increase of ventilation ¯ow rate also increases at a linear rate for both summer and
winter conditions due to the greater amounts of infra-red radiation received by lar-
ger pipes. Again, this eect is much higher in summer than in winter.
Fig. 7 shows the eect on stack ¯ow enhancement of varying the diameter of the
light pipe and keeping all other variables constant except the diameter of the stack,
which was adjusted to maintain a constant stack cross-sectional area of 0.275 m2.
The summer values were based on a solar altitude of 50 and winter values on 20 . It
can be seen from the graph that, as the diameter of the light pipe increases from 0.1
to 0.8 m, the increase of ventilation ¯ow rate also increases at a linear rate for both
summer and winter conditions due to the greater infra-red radiations received by
larger pipes. The eect on the enhancement of ventilation ¯ow rate is much higher in
summer than in winter.
The eect of passive stack width can be seen in Fig. 8. The summer values were
based on a solar altitude of 50 and winter values on 20 . It can be seen from the
graph that, as the stack diameter is increased from 0.32 to 0.46 m (hence the passive
stack width is increased from 1 to 8 cm), the enhancement to ventilation ¯ow rate
reduced, following an exponential trend for both summer and winter conditions.
Variation of the room ¯oor area does not have any eect on ventilation ¯ow rate,
as the stack pressure, infra-red radiation received and other parameters related to
stack ¯ow are independent of the room ¯oor area. The eect of varying the room
height can be seen in Fig. 9. The summer values were based on a solar altitude of 50
and winter values on 20 . It can be seen from the graph that, as the height of the
room is increased, the rate of increase in ventilation ¯ow rate reduced, following
exponential trends for both summer and winter conditions.
The eect of various solar altitude angles during the summer and winter seasons is
shown in Fig. 10. The eect on stack ¯ow enhancement increases considerably with
Fig. 7. Eect of dichroic material on ventilation rate for various light pipe diameters while maintaining
constant stack cross-sectional area.
262 A.A. Elmualim et al. / Applied Energy 62 (1999) 253±266
Fig. 8. Eect of dichroic material on ventilation rate for various stack diameters.
Fig. 9. Eect of dichroic material on ventilation rate for various room heights.
Fig. 10. Eect of dichroic material on ventilation rate for various solar altitude angles in summer and
winter.
A.A. Elmualim et al. / Applied Energy 62 (1999) 253±266 263
the increase of the solar altitude angle in the range of zero to 60 , which is the range
of solar altitude angles prevailing in most European countries. The rate of increase
in ventilation ¯ow rate reaches its highest value at an altitude angle of 60 . However,
the rate of increase in ventilation ¯ow rate drops as the solar altitude angle increases
from 60 to 90% reaching zero at 90 . The eect of various solar altitude angles on
the enhancement of ¯ow rate in the winter season follows a similar pattern as in
summer. However, the eect in winter is negligible.
Fig. 11 shows the measured specular re¯ectance of visible light of the dichroic
material. The highest re¯ectance of 98% occurred at an incidence angle of 30 and
its value was 92% at 20, 50, 60 and 70 . The specular re¯ectance was 93% at 80 ,
89% at 40 and 78% at an incidence angle of 10 . The results for the visible-light
transmittance and specular re¯ectance obtained from experiments were used to
obtain the amount absorbed, noting that the sum of the ratios for re¯ection,
absorption and transmission is unity. The results are shown in Table 2. The data
Table 2
The visible light characteristics of the dichroic glass
demonstrate the minimal amount of visible light transmitted through the dichroic
disk and the high eciency of the material to re¯ect visible light.
4. Conclusions
Tests of the dichroic material have been carried out to investigate its suitability
for application in integrated light pipes/natural ventilation stacks. The infra-red
Fig. 12. Transmittance of dichroic light pipe compared to conventional light pipes with identical dimen-
sions; an aspect ratio of 6 and various re¯ectances.
A.A. Elmualim et al. / Applied Energy 62 (1999) 253±266 265
Acknowledgements
The authors would like to acknowledge the ®nancial support of the EU under its
JOULE programme.
References
[1] Littlefair PJ. Innovative daylighting systems. IP 22/89, Building Research Establishment. Depart-
ment of Environment, 1989.
[2] Switzer G. Three advanced daylighting technologies for oces. Energy 1993;18(2):107±14.
[3] Littlefair PJ, Aizlewood ME, Birtles AB. The performance of innovative daylighting systems.
Renewable Energy 1994;5(5±8):920±34.
[4] Edmonds IR, Moore GI, Smith GB, Swift PD. Daylighting enhancement with light pipes coupled to
laser-cut light de¯ecting panels. Lighting Research and Technology 1995;27(1):27±35.
[5] Bouchet B, Fontoynont M. Daylighting of underground spaces: design rules. Energy and Buildings
1996;23(3):293±8.
[6] McCluney R. Color-rendering of daylight from water-®lled light pipes. Solar Energy Materials
1990;21(2±3):191±206.
[7] Rogora A, Palermo G. New component for daylighting. Renewable Energy 1994;5(5±8):974±6.
[8] Swift PD, Smith GB. Cylindrical mirror light pipes. Solar Energy Materials and Solar Cells
1995;36(2):159±68.
266 A.A. Elmualim et al. / Applied Energy 62 (1999) 253±266
[9] Mulder M. To capture the sun and sky. Lighting Futures 1996;1(4):1±6.
[10] Shao L, Riat SB, Hicks W, Yohannes I. A study of performance of light pipes under cloudy and
sunny conditions in the UK. The 4th European Conference on Energy-Ecient Lighting, Copenha-
gen, Denmark, 1997.
[11] Liberman J. Light Ð medicine of the future. Bear and Company Publishing, 1991.
[12] Pritchard DC. Lighting. 5th ed London, UK: Longman Scienti®c and Technical, 1995.
[13] Hecht E. Optics. 3rd ed. New York: Addison Wesley Longman, Inc, 1998.
[14] Fontoynont M, Berrutto V. Daylighting performance of buildings: monitoring procedure. Proceed-
ings of the 4th European conference on energy-ecient lighting, volume 2. Copenhagen, 19±21
November 1997.
[15] Etheridge D, Sandberg M. Building Ventilation: theory and measurements. Essex: John Wiley and
Son, 1996.