Some say that when young people commit serious crimes, they should be punished like adults.

To what extent do
you agree or disagree?

AGREE

In contemporary society, the issue of how to address serious crimes committed by young individuals has sparked
considerable debate. While some argue for leniency and rehabilitation, others advocate for treating young offenders
with the same severity as adult criminals. This essay contends that when young people commit serious crimes, they
should be subject to adult punishment.

Firstly, treating young offenders as adults sends a clear message about the gravity of their actions. Regardless of age,
individuals must understand the consequences of engaging in criminal behavior. Allowing leniency based solely on age
undermines the principle of accountability and diminishes the severity of the crime. By subjecting young offenders to
adult punishment, society reaffirms its commitment to justice and ensures that individuals are held responsible for
their actions.

Moreover, adult punishment serves as a deterrent against future criminal behavior among young individuals. The fear
of facing severe consequences acts as a powerful deterrent, dissuading young people from engaging in criminal
activities. If young offenders believe they will escape serious punishment due to their age, they may be emboldened to
commit further crimes.

Furthermore, treating young offenders as adults acknowledges the impact of their actions on victims and society as a
whole. Serious crimes, such as violent assaults or homicides, inflict profound harm and suffering on victims and their
families. Failing to hold young offenders fully accountable for their actions perpetuates a sense of injustice and
undermines public trust in the legal system. By subjecting young offenders to adult punishment, society acknowledges
the seriousness of the harm caused and seeks to provide justice for victims.

In conclusion, I strongly agree that upholding the principle of adult punishment for serious crimes committed by young
individuals is essential for maintaining a just and orderly society.

DISAGREE

The question of how to address serious crimes committed by young individuals is a complex and nuanced issue that
demands careful consideration. While some argue for treating young offenders like adult, this essay contends that
such an approach is fundamentally flawed and counterproductive.

Firstly, it is crucial to recognize the developmental differences between adolescents and adults. Adolescents are in a
period of rapid cognitive, emotional, and social development, characterized by impulsivity, susceptibility to peer
influence, and limited foresight. These developmental factors can significantly influence their decision-making
processes and may contribute to juvenile delinquency. Therefore, treating young offenders as adults fails to
acknowledge the mitigating factors associated with their age and developmental stage.

Moreover, subjecting young offenders to adult punishment disregards the principles of proportionality and fairness in
the criminal justice system. Punishments designed for adults may be excessively harsh and disproportionate when
applied to young offenders, considering their age, maturity level, and capacity for rehabilitation. The imposition of
adult sentences on young individuals can result in lifelong consequences, including stigmatization, limited educational
and employment opportunities. Such outcomes undermine the principles of fairness and rehabilitation central to a just
and humane society.

Furthermore, research has consistently demonstrated the efficacy of rehabilitative approaches in addressing juvenile
delinquency. Indeed, rehabilitation programs tailored to the specific needs of young offenders. To illustrate,
education, counseling, vocational training, and family support, have been shown to promote successful reintegration
into society, facilitate positive behavioral change and prevent future criminal behavior.
In conclusion, I believe that the proposition that young people should be punished like adults when they commit
serious crimes is misguided and unjust. It is recommended that investing in rehabilitation and support services, society
can help young offenders realize their potential for positive change and contribute to a safer and more equitable
future.