Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2024
THE
CARBON
CAPTURE
BLUEPRINT
Navigating the Lifecycle of Carbon
Capture Projects in North America
Table of Contents
Chapter 1: Introduction 03
Chapter 4: Overcoming 16
Challenges
02
Chapter 1: Introduction
What is CCUS and its role in achieving net-zero emissions?
CCUS refers to a suite of technologies that enable the mitigation of carbon dioxide
(CO2) emissions from significant point sources such as power plants, refineries, and
other industrial facilities or the removal of existing CO2 from the atmosphere.
CCUS can play four critical roles in the transition to net zero:
These roles are evident in the IEA Sustainable Development Scenario, in which
global CO2 emissions from the energy sector fall to zero on a net basis by 2070
worldwide.
02
03
Historical Evolution of CCUS
Phase 1: Originating from MIT in 1989, the academic community probed the
potential environmental impacts of CO2 storage—whether underground, on land,
or at sea. Discussions evolved from identifying storage risks to strategies for
mitigating these concerns, focusing on the role of CCUS in large-scale emission
reduction and its cost-effectiveness.
Phase 2. The second phase shifted towards strategies for the broader adoption of
CCUS, emphasizing economic benefits, life cycle assessment, investment
strategies, and social acceptability. The goal was to integrate CCUS into diverse
financial models to alleviate the funding challenges of such projects, aiming at
achieving emission reduction targets.
Now, we are moving into the next phase of CCUS to operationalize and scale
projects across industries. This journey from feasibility to scientific advancement
underscores the multifaceted approach needed to make CCUS a cornerstone to
achieving Net Zero goals.
04
Untapped Opportunities:
With more than $3 billion invested in carbon capture in 2022 and a projected sixfold
increase in global capture capacity by 2030 to 279 million tons of CO2 per year, the
CCUS sector is on the brink of a transformative leap.
14000
12000
Million metric tons of CO2
10000
8000
6000
4000
2000
0
Today 2050 Net-Zero Total Potential Market
Legislative Support: The Inflation Reduction Act in the US, which increased tax
credits for CCUS by 70%, exemplifies the kind of legislative support that can
catalyze the sector. Such incentives are crucial for making CCUS viable across
various industries, including petrochemicals, steel, cement, and power generation.
Direct Air Capture (DAC) Growth: The DAC sector has seen significant
investment, with venture capitalists pouring over $1 billion into the technology in
2022 alone. The Inflation Reduction Act's passage has spurred ambitious projects,
indicating DAC's growing role in achieving net-zero goals.
Despite the optimistic outlook, several challenges persist that could hinder the
sector's growth and its contribution to net-zero targets:
06
This Guide Will Help Readers Learn
07
Chapter 2: Initial Planning
and Feasibility Analysis
Understanding the viability of a Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS) project is
foundational to its success.
The industry is set for a 50% growth spurt since the last iteration of BNEF’s market
outlook, to reach 420 million metric tons per annum by 2035.
This chapter guides you through the essential steps of conducting a comprehensive
feasibility analysis, ensuring your project is technically sound and economically viable.
Characterizing Emissions
Objective and Methods: The journey begins with a deep dive into emission sources.
Accurate characterization, including assessing emission volumes, gas compositions, and
the conditions under which they're emitted, lays the groundwork for the entire CCS
process.
08
Reservoir Engineering Considerations: Understanding the nuances of potential
storage sites, from field sizes to overall storage capacity, is essential. This knowledge
ensures that sites are capable of meeting the project’s long-term storage needs.
Cost Analysis: A detailed look at the costs associated with CO2 transportation is vital
for budgeting and economic feasibility. This analysis helps balance logistical needs
with financial realities.
As of 2023, over 200 CO2 injection wells have been permitted by the EPA in the United
States, demonstrating the regulatory pathway for CCS projects. (Source: U.S.
Environmental Protection Agency).
Monetization Strategies: Exploring revenue streams, such as the 45Q tax credit, this
part of the chapter discusses how to make CCS projects financially sustainable and
attractive to investors.
The Inflation Reduction Act of 2022 increased the 45Q tax credit for carbon capture
and storage projects from $50 to $85 per ton of CO2, significantly improving project
economics. (Source: U.S. Congress)
As technology progresses through higher TRL levels, it becomes closer to being ready
for practical application, deployment, or commercialization.
10
The figure above shows TRL and CRI mapped more broadly across R&D,
demonstration, and deployment. As a buyer or investor in the technology, this
framework will help answer key questions, such as:
What is the risk for the project if the technology is not yet pilot-scale?
What testing should be considered for technologies below 7 TRL?
How can we collaborate with the technology provider to improve readiness?
How does this technology compare to the landscape for CO2 capture solutions?
What due diligence is needed before engaging in CO2 utilization solutions?
11
Optimizing CCUS Viability with Technical Analysis
Technical analysis is pivotal in Carbon Capture, Utilization, and Storage (CCUS),
ensuring that every technological factor, from operational costs to IP concerns, is
aligned with commercial viability and environmental mandates.
It validates critical project elements such as CO2 purity for diverse applications, the
project's environmental impact, and the scalability of technology.
These analyses are essential in providing the operational assurances needed for long-
term investment decisions, reinforcing the project's market credibility.
12
Chapter 3: Navigating the
Regulatory Landscape
This chapter highlights the different steps to gain Class VI regulatory approval
at a high level. The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) in the United
States, along with the states that have regulatory primacy, has the authority to
approve CO2 injection wells.
13
Permitting and Approval
Operators of Class VI wells must obtain permits from the EPA or an authorized
state agency before injecting CO2 into the subsurface. The permitting process
involves submitting detailed applications that demonstrate compliance with
regulatory requirements, including well construction standards, monitoring
and reporting requirements, and plans for site characterization and risk
assessment.
Site Characterization
Before injecting CO2, operators must conduct thorough site characterization
to assess geologic suitability and potential risks associated with the injection
activity. This includes evaluating factors such as the depth, porosity,
permeability, and sealing integrity of the injection zone, the presence of nearby
drinking water sources, and potential migration pathways.
Modeling Approach
Screening Insights
•Technical screening Screening
(geology, fluids) Models
•Injection rates Mechanistic Studies
•First order economic •Understand key geological &
screen reservoir performance drivers
•Identify additional data needs
Mechanistic •Select key injection intervals
Models •Explore improvement strategy
and opportunities
Field Development
Models
14
Monitoring and Reporting
Once injection operations commence, operators must implement
comprehensive monitoring programs to track the movement and fate of
injected CO2, detect any leakage or migration into underground sources of
drinking water, and assess the effectiveness of containment measures.
Operators are also required to submit regular reports to the EPA or state
regulatory agencies documenting injection activities, monitoring results, and
any corrective actions taken.
The image above shows various techniques to monitor the CO2 plume with
sensors, seismic, injection wells, geochemical data, or satellite imagery. The
approved Class VI and Class II monitoring plans utilize multiple methods of
monitoring to ensure
15
Chapter 4: Overcoming
Challenges
Navigating the complexities of Carbon Capture, Utilization, and Storage (CCUS) projects is no simple
task. Industry leaders and developers face many challenges, from securing funding to integrating
advanced technologies, each with the potential to derail even the most well-conceived plans.
Let’s outline a course through these turbulent waters, providing strategic responses rooted in real-
world experience and data-driven insights. By acknowledging these obstacles and equipping
ourselves with robust strategies, we can address current issues and fortify our projects against
future uncertainties, setting the stage for successful CCUS implementation.
Supply Chain Establish robust supply chain networks and secure long-
and Availability of term agreements with suppliers. Diversify supply sources
Materials to mitigate risks associated with material shortages.
16
Challenges Strategic Responses
Monitoring,
Reporting, and Develop robust MRV protocols and engage third-party
Verification auditors to ensure compliance. Utilize digital tools and
(MRV) platforms for accurate and transparent reporting.
Compliance
Fluctuating
Maintain an adaptive business model that can respond to
Policy and
policy changes. Engage in policy advocacy to support
Incentive
stable and supportive regulatory environments.
Landscapes
Pro tip: If you think you are facing a unique challenge, always look for case
studies and study how they overcome it!
17
Chapter 5: Case Studies
1. BKV's Project Barnett Zero
Challenges: High CO2 emissions from natural gas production, complex regulatory landscape,
and the high cost and time-consuming nature of traditional CCS project development.
Market Conditions: Increasing demand for sustainable energy solutions amidst growing
environmental regulations.
Technological State: Limited application of innovative monitoring and tracing technologies in
CCS projects.
18
Regulatory Strategy: Swift acquisition of a Class II permit by leveraging Texas's regulatory primacy,
streamlining the project's approval process.
Market Impact: Establishment of a scalable and economically viable model for CCS projects,
supported by enhanced 45Q tax incentives.
Key Takeaways:
Strategic Regulatory Navigation: BKV's approach to regulatory engagement, opting for a Class II
permit with Class VI specifications, significantly expedited project timelines.
Advanced Monitoring Techniques: The application of unique tracer technology and comprehensive
data logging provided unparalleled understanding and management of CO2 sequestration.
Scalability and Replication: Project Barnett Zero's success serves as a blueprint for future CCS
projects, demonstrating the viability of rapid development and close-to-source sequestration
strategies.
Economic and Environmental Synergy: Enhanced 45Q tax credits and innovative project design
align financial incentives with substantial environmental benefits, setting a precedent for future
CCS initiatives.
Conclusion:
BKV's Project Barnett Zero showcases a breakthrough in CCS project development and regulatory
approval and illuminates a path forward for the industry.
Through strategic planning, innovative technology application, and adaptive regulatory engagement,
BKV has laid the groundwork for accelerating the adoption of CCS solutions—turning challenges into
opportunities for sustainable growth.
This case study explores the transformative journey of BD3 and emphasizes the role of supportive
policies like the CCUS investment tax credit in fostering CCS projects.
19
Before the Project:
Before the CCS initiative, BD3 was a conventional coal-fired power unit.
The pressing need to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and transition to cleaner energy sources
prompted SaskPower to explore CCS technologies to extend the aging facility's life while
significantly reducing its carbon footprint.
Project Execution:
The upgrade of BD3 included the installation of a carbon capture facility capable of capturing
approximately 1 Mtpa of CO2.
This CO2 is primarily used for enhanced oil recovery (EOR) and partly for geological storage at
the Aquistore Project.
The initiative demonstrates the feasibility of CCS technology in reducing emissions from coal-
fired power generation and provides a blueprint for similar projects worldwide.
The project contributes to cleaner energy production and supports economic growth by
generating high-quality jobs and fostering economic partnerships, particularly with Indigenous
groups.
20
Project Execution: Lessons Learned and Policy Impact
Supportive Policies: The Government of Canada's proposed regulations for a CCUS investment
tax credit (CCUS-ITC) have been pivotal. By covering up to 50% of the capital cost of CO2 capture
projects (and higher for direct air capture), the policy significantly enhances the economic
viability of CCS projects.
Labour Provisions: The CCUS-ITC includes provisions to support fair labor practices, requiring
prevailing wage payments and a minimum percentage of work to be performed by apprentices.
This approach supports job creation and ensures a skilled workforce for the burgeoning CCS
industry.
Integrated Operations: BD3's success underlines the importance of an integrated full-chain CCS
approach, from capture and transportation to utilization and storage. This comprehensive
strategy is crucial for demonstrating the operational feasibility and environmental benefits of
CCS.
Economic and Environmental Benefits: Beyond reducing emissions, BD3 showcases how CCS
projects can transform CO2 from a waste product into a commodity, creating new revenue
streams through EOR and other uses. This model presents a compelling case for the commercial
viability of CCS technologies.
Key Takeaways:
The Boundary Dam 3 CCS project is a testament to the critical role of supportive government
policies in accelerating the deployment of CCS technologies.
The CCUS-ITC, with its strong focus on job creation and fair labor practices, not only incentivizes CCS
projects but also ensures they contribute positively to the economy and the environment.
BD3's journey from a conventional coal-fired unit to a pioneering CCS facility illustrates CCS's
potential to play a central role in global decarbonization efforts, providing valuable insights for
future projects across heavy-emitting industries.
As Canada aims to triple its national CCS capacity by 2030 and achieve net-zero emissions by 2050,
BD3 stands as a model for integrating policy support, technological innovation, and economic
incentives to advance CCS technologies.
Conclusion:
The Boundary Dam 3 CCS project exemplifies how forward-thinking policies and innovative
technologies can converge to address the pressing challenge of cleaner energy.
BD3 serves as a global model, offering stakeholders a clear view of how CCS projects can be
effectively implemented, their advantages, and their growth potential. It is leading the charge
towards a more sustainable and cleaner tomorrow.
21
Chapter 5: The Future of
Carbon Capture
Just a few years ago, CCUS was a developing concept with only a few pilot
projects to demonstrate the value. With nearly 200 projects announced across
North America, multiple industries are working towards making CCUS a reality.
Studies from the US Department of Energy along with other academic studies
suggest that reaching U.S. energy transition goals will require capturing and
storing 400 to 1,800 million tonnes (MT) of carbon dioxide (CO2 ) annually by
2050. Similarly, Canada aims to capture and store 15 million tons of CO2 by 2030.
In the near term, spanning through 2030, industries with high-purity CO2
streams such as ethanol, natural gas processing, and hydrogen production offer
the most favorable project economics. For instance, there are 20+ ethanol CCUS
projects expected to be operational in 2025.
From 2030 to 2050, project economics must improve for low-purity CO2 stream,
common in power plants, petrochemicals, steel, and cement. Demonstration
projects from the present through 2030 will play a crucial role in supporting cost
reductions, primarily through experiential learning and the standardization of
project development frameworks. Technology and infrastructure expansion are
required to capture, transport, and store the low-purity CO2 streams.
22
Common themes as the industry evolves:
1. Strategic Partnerships for Innovation: For clean energy leaders and CCUS
developers, forming strategic partnerships with technology providers, research
institutions, and government bodies is crucial for driving innovation and reducing
costs.
This evolving policy environment can significantly impact project viability and
investment decisions.
Advances in AI and machine learning for process optimization and new materials
for CO2 capture can offer competitive advantages.
23
6. Net-Zero Commitments Driving Demand: As more organizations commit to
achieving net-zero emissions by 2050, the demand for CCUS technologies and carbon
credits is expected to surge.
This presents a significant opportunity for CCUS facility developers and organizations
with carbon credits to position themselves as essential partners in global
decarbonization efforts.
8. Emerging Markets for CCUS: Identifying and entering emerging markets with high
carbon capture potential, such as Southeast Asia and Africa, can offer new growth
opportunities. These regions are increasingly focusing on reducing emissions and need
advanced CCUS technologies and expertise.
10. Leveraging Carbon Credits for Sustainable Growth: For organizations with carbon
credits, leveraging these assets through strategic sales or investments in sustainability
projects can support environmental goals while providing economic benefits.
Innovative approaches to using carbon credits, such as funding reforestation or
renewable energy projects, can enhance an organization's sustainability profile.
24
What’s next?
Let’s Connect on Linkedin
Tell me your thoughts on the blueprint. I would love to learn what you are working
on and see how I can help.
Workshops
We recently hosted one of the biggest energy leaders workshops in Houston, Texas,
attended by 60+ energy leaders!
We are hosting the next one soon! We will share the details in our newsletter or on
LinkedIn.
25
4. Carbon Capture and Storage Association (CCSA):
Based in the UK, CCSA promotes the commercial deployment of carbon capture and
storage (CCS) technology.
5. CO2CRC Limited:
An Australian research organization that has been pioneering advances in carbon
capture and storage.
6. European Technology Platform for Zero Emission Fossil Fuel Power Plants (ZEP):
A coalition of stakeholders united in their support for CO2 capture and storage as a key
technology for combating climate change.
12. McKinsey & Company provide great quarterly insights on industrial decarbonization.
13. Net Zero Tracker: Tracks the net zero pledges across countries, regions, cities, and
companies. (We used this at Decarbonfuse as inspiration for our industrials company
database)
14. S&P Global: Offers market news and analyses specifically related to energy markets,
including CCS.
15. BloombergNEF: A leading source for investment analysis of the CCS market,
investment trends, and economic implications of various decarbonization strategies.
26
20 Essential CCUS Acronyms ⚡
▶️CCUS - Carbon Capture, Utilization, and Storage
▶️BECCS - Bioenergy with Carbon Capture and Storage
▶️DAC - Direct Air Capture
▶️EOR - Enhanced Oil Recovery
▶️CCS - Carbon Capture and Storage
▶️CCU - Carbon Capture and Utilization
▶️CDR - Carbon Dioxide Removal
▶️NET - Negative Emissions Technology
▶️LCA - Life Cycle Assessment
▶️PC - Post-combustion Capture
▶️PCC - Pre-combustion Capture
▶️OCC - Oxy-fuel Combustion Capture
▶️MVA - Monitoring, Verification, and Accounting
▶️MRV - Monitoring, Reporting, and Verification
▶️GtCO2 - Gigatonnes of Carbon Dioxide
▶️MtCO2 - Megatonnes of Carbon Dioxide
▶️SMR - Steam Methane Reforming
▶️ATR - Autothermal Reforming
▶️PSA - Pressure Swing Adsorption
▶️TNS - Transportation and Storage
References
1. IEA Website
2. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2325426222000390
3. BKV Website
4. Boundary Dam Website
5. https://about.bnef.com/blog/global-carbon-capture-capacity-due-to-rise-
sixfold-by-2030/
6. Canadian CCS Projects Report, 2022
7. U.S. Carbon Capture and Storage Market Forecast, 2023-2032
8. Ecosystem Marketplace, 2020
27
END
28