Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2nd edition
Robert P. Reiser
University of California, San Francisco, CA
Larry W. Thompson
Stanford University, Stanford, CA
Sheri L. Johnson
University of California, Berkeley, CA
Trisha Suppes
Stanford University, Stanford, CA
About the Authors
Robert P. Reiser, PhD, is a cognitive behavioral therapist
in private practice focusing on treatment of individuals and
families with serious mental illness and a Fellow of the
Academy of Cognitive Therapy. He supervises graduate
clinicians in training and provides workshops, consultation,
and technical assistance with a goal of improving treatment
of bipolar disorder and schizophrenia in community mental
health settings. Dr. Reiser currently works as a consultant
with the Felton Institute in San Francisco providing
supervision and training for clinicians and case managers
using cognitive behavioural therapy for psychosis (CBT-P),
and supervises medical residents at the University of
California, San Francisco in the Department of Psychiatry.
Associate Editors
Larry Beutler, PhD, Professor, Palo Alto University /
Pacific Graduate School of Psychology, Palo Alto, CA
Kenneth E. Freedland, PhD, Professor of Psychiatry and
Psychology, Washington University School of Medicine, St.
Louis, MO
Linda C. Sobell , PhD, ABPP, Professor, Center for
Psychological Studies, Nova Southeastern University, Ft.
Lauderdale, FL
David A. Wolfe , PhD, RBC Chair in Children’s Mental Health,
Centre for Addiction and Mental Health, University of
Toronto, ON
C2016-906771-8
PUBLISHING OFFICES
USA: Hogrefe Publishing Corporation, 7 Bulfinch Place, Suite 202,
Boston, MA 02114
Phone (866) 823-4726, Fax (617) 354-6875; E-mail
customerservice@hogrefe.com
EUROPE: Hogrefe Publishing GmbH, Merkelstr. 3, 37085 Göttingen, Germany
Phone +49 551 99950-0, Fax +49 551 99950-111; E-mail
publishing@hogrefe.com
SALES & DISTRIBUTION
USA: Hogrefe Publishing, Customer Services Department, 30 Amberwood
Parkway, Ashland, OH 44805
Phone (800) 228-3749, Fax (419) 281-6883; E-mail
customerservice@hogrefe.com
UK: Hogrefe Publishing, c/o Marston Book Services Ltd., 160 Eastern
Ave., Milton Park, Abingdon, OX14 4SB, UK
Phone +44 1235 465577, Fax +44 1235 465556; E-mail
direct.orders@marston.co.uk
EUROPE: Hogrefe Publishing, Merkelstr. 3, 37085 Göttingen, Germany
Phone +49 551 99950-0, Fax +49 551 99950-111; E-mail
publishing@hogrefe.com
OTHER OFFICES
CANADA: Hogrefe Publishing, 660 Eglinton Ave. East, Suite 119-514,
Toronto, Ontario, M4G 2K2
SWITZERLAND: Hogrefe Publishing, Länggass-Strasse 76, CH-3000 Bern 9
Copyright Information
The e-book, including all its individual chapters, is
protected under international copyright law. The unauthorized
use or distribution of copyrighted or proprietary content is
illegal and could subject the purchaser to substantial
damages. The user agrees to recognize and uphold the
copyright.
License Agreement
The purchaser is granted a single, nontransferable license
for the personal use of the e-book and all related files.
Making copies or printouts and storing a backup copy of the
e-book on another device is permitted for private, personal
use only.
Other than as stated in this License Agreement, you may not
copy, print, modify, remove, delete, augment, add to,
publish, transmit, sell, resell, create derivative works
from, or in any way exploit any of the e-book’s content, in
whole or in part, and you may not aid or permit others to do
so. You shall not: (1) rent, assign, timeshare, distribute,
or transfer all or part of the e-book or any rights granted
by this License Agreement to any other person; (2) duplicate
the e-book, except for reasonable backup copies; (3) remove
any proprietary or copyright notices, digital watermarks,
labels, or other marks from the e-book or its contents; (4)
transfer or sublicense title to the e-book to any other
party.
These conditions are also applicable to any audio or other
files belonging to the e-book. Should the print edition of
this book include electronic supplementary material then all
this material (e.g., audio, video, pdf files) is also
available in the e-book edition.
Cover image based on photo © KatarzynaBialasiewicz –
iStock.com
Format: EPUB
ISBN 978-0-88937-410-2 (print) • ISBN 978-1-61676-410-4 (PDF)
• ISBN 978-1-61334-410-1 (EPUB)
http://doi.org/10.1027/00410-000
Citability: This EPUB includes page numbering between two
vertical lines (Example: |1|) that corresponds to the page
numbering of the print and PDF ebook versions of the title.
|v| Preface
In the 10 years since our first edition, interest has
continued to grow in the psychosocial treatment of bipolar
disorder. A number of new randomized clinical trials have
been completed. In the preface of our first edition we noted
that, despite the substantial evidence supporting several
psychological treatment approaches for bipolar disorder,
these treatments were often not used by practitioners.
Unfortunately, even with better treatment resources
available, a wide gap remains between effective evidence-
based treatments and the actual standard of care delivered in
the community. The present state of affairs remains
consistent with the picture presented in the National
Institute of Mental Health (NIMH) white paper on research in
mood disorders more than 10 years ago, which summarized that
only about 10% of the treatments for depression (a far more
common mood disorder) meet the standard guidelines for
evidence-based care. This need not be the case. There is a
wealth of research and treatment information available, and
we aim to make this readily accessible to the individual
practitioner. We seek to provide updated practical guidance
for an evidence-based treatment of bipolar disorder while
trying to avoid an overly narrow or complex approach. We have
also attempted to address important problems likely to be
encountered with the more challenging patients often seen in
treatment settings such as community mental health clinics.
We aim to provide the practitioner with an evidence-based,
comprehensive, integrated approach to the treatment of
bipolar disorder that is practical, easily accessible, and
can be readily applied in clinical practice.
Robert P. Reiser
Larry W. Thompson
Sheri L. Johnson
Trisha Suppes
Contents
Preface
Assumptions for Use of this Book
Acknowledgments
1 Description
1.1 Terminology
1.2 Definition
1.2.1 Additional Considerations in the Classification and Diagnosis of
Bipolar Disorders
1.3 Epidemiology
2.2 Psychoeducation
4 Treatment
4.1 Biological Approaches to Treatment
4.8 Summary
5 Further Reading
6 References
Activity Schedule
Self-Help Resources
Books
Websites
Self-Help Organizations With Local Chapters
1
Description
|1|
1.1 Terminology
Bipolar disorder (BD), previously known as manic depressive
illness, is a mood disorder defined by manic symptoms of
varying severity. Most people with BD will also experience
depressive symptoms. Manic symptoms may involve changes in
energy, impulsivity, behavior, and cognition. BD is usually
characterized by an episodic course throughout the lifetime,
resulting in significant impairment in social, interpersonal,
and occupational functioning.
1.2 Definition
Table 1 presents the criteria for a manic episode or a
hypomanic episode as described in the DSM-5. Increased
activity or energy was added as a cardinal symptom in DSM-5,
in part because this may be more reliably reported than mood
states.
Table 1 DSM-5 Criteria for Manic and Hypomanic Episodes (Adapted from
APA, 2013)
A. Abnormally and persistently elevated, expansive, or irritable mood and
increased activity or energy
B. During this period, three or more (four if mood is only irritable) of the
following changes from usual behavior are present to a significant degree and
persistent:
1. Increased self-esteem
2. Little need for sleep (e.g., feels rested after 3 hours of sleep)
3. More talkative than usual or pressure to keep talking
4. Flight of ideas or subjective experience of racing thoughts
5. Distractibility (attention overly drawn to irrelevant stimuli)
6. Increased goal-directed activity (either socially, at work or
school, or sexually) or psychomotor agitation
7. Excessive involvement in activities with potential painful
consequences (e.g., reckless spending, sexual indiscretions, or
unwise investments)
C. The episode is not caused by the direct effects of a substance (e.g., drug of
abuse, an antidepressant medication, or other treatment) or medical condition
(e.g., hyperthyroidism), unless symptoms persist after the effects of the
somatic agent are no longer present
D. Symptoms are present most of the day, nearly every day
Table 2 DSM-5 Criteria for a Major Depressive Episode (Adapted from APA,
2013)
1. Sad or depressed
2. Decreased interest or pleasure
3. Psychomotor slowing
4. Fatigue or decreased energy
5. Feelings of extreme worthlessness or guilt
6. Recurrent thoughts of death or suicidal ideation, plan, or attempt
1.3 Epidemiology
As noted above, bipolar spectrum disorders are more common
than BD I. The World Health Organization World Mental Health
Survey Initiative is the largest available study on the
prevalence of BD. In this representative sample of 61,392
adults in 11 countries, the lifetime prevalence was estimated
to be 0.6% for BD I, 0.4% for BD II, and 1.4% for
subthreshold BD. There is debate about how common these
subthreshold variants are, with some arguing that variants of
BD other than BD I and II may affect 2–4% or more of people
depending on definitions and sample (Regeer et al., 2004). In
the US, higher prevalence estimates have been observed: 1.0%
for BD I, 1.1% for BD II, and 2.4% for subthreshold BD
(Merikangas et al., 2007). Relatively little is known about
whether these cross-national differences are genuine. It is
important to consider that culture influences stigma,
acceptance of mental health problems, and comfort discussing
symptoms. Cross-national variation in the prevalence of
bipolar disorder has also been tied to fish oil consumption
(Noaghiul & Hibbeln, 2003), as well as cultural emphasis on
individualistic striving (Johnson & Johnson, 2014a). In
contrast to unipolar depression, which affects nearly twice
as many women as men, men and women are equally likely to
suffer from BD I, though the ratios suggest more women than
men are diagnosed with BD II. Among those diagnosed with BD,
however, overall women experience more episodes of depression
than do men and so may be more likely to seek treatment.
Mood symptoms developed while the patient was exposed to substances. The
symptoms remit when the physiologic effects of the substance(s) are not
present.
The substances are capable of producing mood symptoms. Substances that
commonly trigger mood changes include alcohol, amphetamines, cocaine,
hallucinogens, other psychedelics, inhalants, phencyclidine, sedatives,
hypnotics, anxiolytics, and antidepressants.
Substances and medications may elicit many manic symptoms including elevated,
irritable or expansive mood, altered activity, impulsive decisions, diminished
sleep, or depressive symptoms, including depressed mood, diminished interest
or pleasure in activities, guilt, or suicidal feelings.
Mood symptoms may develop during intoxication, during initiation or
discontinuation of a substance, or within one month of withdrawal from a
substance.
Screen for past or current manic and hypomanic symptoms in depressed patients.
Ask about shifts in energy as well as mood.
Carefully assess history of lifetime episodes.
Use multiple interviews and include family members/significant others whenever
possible.
Review family history of mania, hypomania, or mood instability in first degree
relatives.
Review hospitalization history.
Always assess suicidality, given high risks.
Use a Life Chart to review timing of episodes, hospitalizations, major life
events, and medication changes.
Request medical records for hospitalizations and extended outpatient
treatment.
There are several diagnostic procedures that can be used to
assess the diagnosis and severity of BD, setting the stage
for treatment success. There is no definitive laboratory test
to confirm the diagnosis of BD. Rather DSM-5 diagnosis is
based on the presence of hypomanic or manic symptoms. Family
history, as well as previous treatment response, may be
weighted in making a diagnosis (Goodwin & Jamison, 2007).
Given the complexity of mood fluctuations, single interviews
with patients are often not reliable in establishing a
diagnosis, |14| and ideally you will develop a perspective
over several interviews with the patient and other
informants. In the course of therapy, patients can also
complete a daily mood chart. See Appendix 5: Mood Chart
Adapted from Basco and Rush (2007) that tracks mood and
related symptoms to help deepen understanding of mood
fluctuations. We recap goals of a good assessment in Table 5.
Clinical Vignette 1
Identifying Periods of Manic Symptoms
Therapist: Have you ever had any periods where you have needed
considerably less sleep than usual for days in a row?
Patient: Needed or wanted?
Therapist: No, it’s more like you haven’t felt tired and you didn’t
feel you needed the sleep.
Patient: Not recently, but within the last several months – yes.
Therapist: For more than a week at a stretch?
Patient: It was about a week. I just wasn’t sleeping very much.
Therapist: Did you feel rested?
Patient: No, I was having a lot of trouble sleeping at that time.
[Not consistent with mania]
Therapist: OK. Have there been times when you were very energetic or
active or were taking on lots of new goals?
Patient: No.
Therapist: Have you had times when your mood was higher or more
irritable than normal for 4 days at a time?
Patient: No.
Disorder
Here we focus on the background for effectively explaining BD
within a therapeutic framework, using models that have
received strong research support. We begin with a discussion
of the biological basis of BD. We then provide an overview of
the model and rationale for the following treatment
approaches:
Psychoeducation
Interpersonal and social rhythm treatment
Family-based treatment
Cognitive-behavioral treatment
2.2 Psychoeducation
Psychoeducation encompasses many strategies with a goal of
illness management. Psychoeducation is designed to provide
information about the nature and causes of psychiatric
disorders, and to give a clear rationale for seeking and
remaining in treatment (including medication). Most
psychoeducation approaches begin by promoting an
understanding of BD as a recurrent illness that will require
ongoing treatment. Helping clients understand medication side
effects, and ways to reduce these, can be extremely helpful.
The main rationale is that improving adherence with
treatment, especially medication, and assisting patients in
the management of potentially stressful situations can
ameliorate the course of future episodes by helping the
patient identify protective strategies and reduce high-risk
behaviors.
Help patients recognize the relationship between mood and life events.
Help patients manage stressful life events.
Stabilize social rhythms.
Address medication nonadherence.
Provide an opportunity for the patient to grieve over losses due to the
illness.
Address interpersonal difficulties, role transitions, and deficits in social
skills.
Provide psychoeducation.
Emphasize importance of regular daily routine and sleep-wake cycles.
Help patients learn to identify early warning signs and symptoms (prodromes).
Foster skills for coping with prodromes.
Teach problem-solving skills to manage stress.
Provide 6–9 months of intervention and at least 16 sessions of individual
structured psychotherapy.
Indications
This chapter provides advice on treatment indications – that
is, how to determine the most appropriate treatment. After
describing basic issues, we include a decision tree for
evaluating the best treatment options/settings, and specific
advice for addressing common presentations.
Has the patient agreed to take a mood stabilizer, receives current psychiatric
care, and is treatment adherent?
Is there a pattern of recent instability, hospitalizations, or emergency room
visits suggesting that standard outpatient treatment will not be sufficient
for the patient to remain stable?
Does the patient have a stable living situation?
Does the patient have sufficient social support available?
Does the patient present an acute suicide risk that cannot be managed in
outpatient care?
Will the patient be able to comply with the requirements of outpatient
treatment in terms of attending for regularly scheduled appointments?
Is the patient sufficiently motivated to commit to a course of outpatient
treatment?
3. Environmental factors
a) Interpersonal, family, and social stressors
b) Interpersonal, family, and social resources
c) Job, career, school-related problems
d) Goals and aspirations
4. Treatment factors
a) Family/significant other engagement
b) Degree of medication adherence
c) Degree of acceptance/denial of illness
d) Degree of overall readiness and engagement in treatment
e) Willingness to accept help in therapeutic relationship
f) Ability to manage without structured, supervised living situation
Several weeks into the treatment program, Bill began to experience increasing
signs of activation and complained about stressors he associated with selling
his house and feeling pressure from his girlfriend to complete tasks related
to their impending move. After missing group for a week, Bill returned and
reported that he had had a “mixed manic episode” this past week in which he
began to experience unusual thoughts (“My desktop files are organized in an
especially significant way”; “I’m part of a grand plan”; “I have a true
understanding of my life”) and a sense of being very buoyed up and restless.
His mood graph indicated a sharp spike into the +4 to +5 range, indicating
“very manic” or severe hypomania/mania.
Bill was able to communicate with his girlfriend and call his doctor, with
the result that he received some additional medication and did not cycle into
a full manic episode that required hospitalization. This was the first such
episode that Bill had been able to avoid ending up in the hospital in a
severe psychotic state.
|32| When we reviewed the different outcome for this episode, it appeared
that Bill had implemented a few “small” but highly important changes, as he
noted in his diary: “This time it was different, I didn’t hide the
episode.” He was able to let his girlfriend know about the changes in his
thinking instead of being secretive, and he called his doctor for the first
time before being hospitalized. This case illustrates how careful monitoring
and small, specific behavioral changes that are incorporated into a coping
plan can significantly affect the outcome of a bipolar episode.
Note. (a)
Side effect concerns with these agents include weight gain, metabolic
syndrome, and extra pyramidal symptoms (EPS). Side effects warrant vigilance and
close monitoring on the part of the clinician.
|37| Table 16 Recent Guidelines for Management of Bipolar Depression (Adapted
from Ostacher et al., 2016)
Note. (a)
Tolerability limitations include sedation and weight gain. (b) Efficacy
limitations include negative randomized controlled trials but positive meta-
analyses. (c) Consideration merited due to clinical need, despite even greater
efficacy/tolerability limitations than Level 1 and 2 treatments. (d) There is
inadequate information (including negative trials) to recommend adjunctive
antidepressants, aripiprazole, ziprasidone, and levetiracetam.
Note. (a)
Side effect concerns with these agents include weight gain, metabolic
syndrome, and extra pyramidal symptoms (EPS). Side effects warrant vigilance and
close monitoring on the part of the clinician. (b) Longer-term efficacy data
limited for divalproex monotherapy, carbamazepine (drug interaction risk),
antidepressants, electroconvulsive therapy (inconvenience/expense).
Clinical Vignette 3
Setting Treatment Goals (Second Session)
Therapist: So today one of my goals is to talk a little more about what
you’d like to get out of this. Last week we talked about a
few goals for you – getting some improvement in your
depressed mood and energy level – and those are really
important goals.
Patient: Yeah, inertia is also a bit of a problem
|46| Therapist:Ok, let’s start by having you make a sort of “problems
list,” and this will become our agenda for your therapy
and we’ll try to make sure we stay close to your goals. Of
course, they can change over time too. But this will give us
a way of tracking our progress. What should we start with
(for your problem list)?
Patient: It would be so nice to be able to go back to school next
semester and be able to make it to all my classes and
actually complete the work.
Therapist: [handing patient a pad of paper] You can actually write
these down as we go for your own benefit.
Therapist: So would your first goal be to return for the fall semester?
Patient: Eventually, I would like to change my major and get a degree
in engineering.
Therapist: And that’s a really important personal goal?
Patient: Yes, but right now I’m not up for it.
Therapist: What’s interfering with achieving this goal, because that
should be on our problem list?
Patient: If I could actually make it to all my classes and do all the
work – I stopped going to classes I really loved and lost
interest in them.
[Patient and therapist spend some time discussing the importance of this goal
in terms of personal and family values before going on to the next problem,
which happened to be skipping her medication.]
Trouble Shooting
In our experience as supervisors, we see that several
components involved in conducting a structured therapy
session as described above are particularly difficult for
professionals who are beginning to use this type of therapy.
The first problem encountered by therapists who are used to
working in an unstructured approach is developing an agenda
quickly to guide the remainder of the session. Therapists
often start a session by asking a general question (“How
have you been doing over the last week?”). We prefer using
an approach that inquires more specifically about mood
related symptoms and other problems that the patient would
like to address so that we can quickly focus on problem
solving and other skills that might help the patient. To
reduce the time spent checking in, the therapist can signpost
important issues by asking: “Would you like to put this on
today’s agenda?”
Clinical Vignette 5
Learning To Use the Thought Record in a Group
Treatment Setting
Therapist: This would be a good time to see how the thought record
works. Does anyone recall a situation where they became
upset that they would be willing to share?
Frieda, a 35-year-old single female who lives with her parents, agreed to
share an upsetting event with the group. The therapist used an easel to write
down Frieda’s comments so that the whole group could observe how the thought
record can be used.
|57| Frieda: Ok, this is one where I didn’t lash out, but I got so
depressed.
Therapist: What was the event? Let’s write that down here. Why don’t
you write them down, too, Frieda in your blank thought
record?
Frieda: Ok. Well I made a new friend and I expected that she’d call
me and she did not call.
Therapist: Ok. [Therapist writes verbatim what the patient says]
Frieda: So then my thoughts were that she doesn’t like me.
Therapist: Ok, “She doesn’t like me.”
Frieda: And I’m too old and boring.
Therapist: “I’m too old and boring.” Thank you for sharing this with
us.
Frieda: She’s mad at me.
Therapist: Ok. Any other thoughts?
Frieda: She doesn’t want to hang out with me.
Therapist: Ok.
Frieda: I’m too fat. I’m a depressing person. And I still live at
home with my mom and dad.
Therapist: Ok. [Still writing]
Frieda: [spontaneously] Boy, I get strange thoughts.
Therapist: What was it like writing down these thoughts?
Frieda: Oh, it was weird, because I don’t know where these thoughts
come from. It doesn’t even make sense. It doesn’t have
anything to do with the event.
Therapist: That’s a wonderful example. You’ve just said something
important, which is these are kind of automatic thoughts
that come into your mind without any prompting, and you may
not even be aware of them and they may have little to do
with the event.
Group Member: But to us it does.
Therapist:
Ok, it feels like it does. So then if we looked at your
feelings [goes to next column]: now, if you look you had a
series of thoughts, and I wonder if there were some that
were particularly painful or upsetting.
Frieda: I started to hurt.
Therapist: Was there a particular thought that was connected with the
hurt?
Frieda: Well, that’s got me. Well, the worst was that I was still
living at home.
Therapist: Ok, what was the feeling that you had?
Frieda: Oh, that I was incompetent.
Therapist: Well, that’s kind of a thought. Let’s put that over here
in the thought column. What feeling did you have?
Frieda: Shame.
Therapist: Ok, so you had a whole series of thoughts. Let’s talk more
about how those affected your mood.
Frieda: It made me more depressed.
Therapist: Any particular thoughts that made you depressed?
Frieda: Well the main one is that I’m still living at home.
Therapist: Sounds like this was an interesting experience for you to
look at these thoughts after writing them down. Sounds like
you felt it wasn’t clear how this event caused all of these
thoughts.
Frieda: Yeah, and the funny thing was that the reason she didn’t
call was that she was depressed herself.
Therapist: How did you find out? Did you try to reach her?
Frieda: Yeah, I wrote to her and asked, “Are you mad at me?”
|58| Therapist:So can we look at some of the thoughts that Frieda had here
and see if we can find any thinking errors?
Group Member: To me shame is the basic thing. You’re not valuable.
Therapist: Let’s look at our list of thinking errors. What would that
be if we looked at our list?
Group Member: One thing is that there is a lot generalizing about yourself
from one event and it’s not based on a lot of evidence.
Therapist: Let’s start with the first, “She doesn’t like me”. Is
there a thinking error there?
Frieda: Well, one thing is, I can’t tell what people think.
Group Member: That’s right. When I go out and I see people looking at me
and I begin to imagine all sorts of things they are
thinking. But I really can’t tell what they’re thinking
and I forget that.
Therapist: That’s right. Then let’s look at the next thought, “I’m
old and boring”. Is there a thinking error? How would that
fit?
Group Member: Kind of labeling.
Therapist: Yeah, what else?
Group Member: Making an assumption, right? Jumping to a conclusion.
Therapist: What about taking it personally. How would you apply that?
Group Member: As you go through the day people look at you and you wonder
what they’re thinking and you don’t know, so we read our
own concerns into it.
Frieda: Right!
Clinical Vignette 6
Hopelessness and Worries About My Self, My Future,
and My Illness
Patient: I have a lot of fear about my future and having what I
consider to be a good life…I just feel like I have a
capacity where I could be doing something…you know, I mean
I guess it’s really important for me to have a purpose and
that I have the potential to do something that would be
meaningful, but then I feel like I am also restricted by
this [illness] and it might not happen [sounding very
tearful]. I might fail to follow through because of
something emotional that might come up.
Therapist: So you’re really hoping you can do something important,
have an important purpose, but you’re worried that your
illness might restrict you from having a really important
meaningful life.
Patient: Yeah, something could come up related to my illness. And
then I could get off track. I feel like I have already been
sidetracked by this illness for the last couple years.
|60| Therapist:There’s a worry that you might get side-tracked again…get
up on the horse but get knocked off.
Patient: I mean I guess it’s good because I am learning to be more
tenacious about what I want.
Therapist: Being tenacious is a wonderful quality.
Patient: But it’s so humiliating and I feel so embarrassed [crying]
Therapist: This is really tough stuff…
Patient: Yeah, this worry is about my future, feeling like my life is
not going to turn out OK.
Therapist: So we are addressing a real core worry, so it’s powerful,
because if we can get a handle on this it’s going to make a
big difference for you if you can develop some confidence…
[Patient and therapist agree to do a role play where the therapist voices
some of the patient’s doubts and sees if the patient can come up with any
countering responses]
Therapist: (in role): So I’m hoping I could have some important
purpose in my life and do something really meaningful, but
I’m afraid that this won’t happen for me because of this
illness I won’t be able to have the kind of like I want to
have.
Patient: (tearing up): Well Sally, you are having a lot of good
people helping you through this…you have your mom and two
really good doctors and you’re getting the right
combination of medication and you are going to come to a
point when you are going to recognize if you are getting
into a depression or manic episode. (sounding increasingly
tearful and sad here) and you’re going to know how to deal
with it once it comes up…if you just keep having people
around you who are supportive, you are going to figure out a
way to cope with this. In a healthy way so your life can
have meaning…
Therapist: Can I interrupt? It seems like you started out saying the
right things but you sounded really sad and worried.
Patient: I think I wanted to start crying right away but had to hold
it back.
Therapist: Am I being too intense here, is this too difficult?
Patient: No.
Therapist: We are really addressing the core issue of worry about
yourself and worry about your future. Would it be OK to do
this role play one more time and write down the most helpful
countering thoughts for you to address your worry? We want
to help you not get so caught up in the worry anxiety cycle.
Patient: Yeah, worry can make me not want to do anything, not try
’cause I’m scared.
Therapist: So worry can be counterproductive.
[Therapist reflects on the worry – giving up cycle and gives some examples
of how the patient might adopt a more reassuring or compassionate tone]
Therapist: You’ve been through some really difficult things so it’s
understandable that you would be so worried.
Patient: It’s really good to hear this
[They reengage in a second role play with the goal of incorporating more
acceptance of the worry.]
Patient: (in role): Well, Sally, I think your worry is really valid
because you’ve had some serious problems.
[Sally repeats some of the main points above in a slightly more confident
manner, but sounding quite a bit less worried].
|61| Therapist:Now you have added a part about acknowledging the worry, do
you think that was helpful?
Patient: Yeah, I think if I say to myself but don’t acknowledge it
(the worry), it feels like all these things are true but
you’re not hearing what I’m feeling.
Thoughts He remembers me
He’s wondering how I am now
He saw me when I was really depressed
Feelings Fearful
Ashamed
Shame
Clinical Vignette 7
I Called My Mother Names
When depressed, Frederick often ruminated about bad behavior during past
manic episodes. He was particularly upset by an incident in which he had been
very rude to his mother during an irritable manic phase shortly before her
death. Bill often replayed this and other incidents in his head over and over
again, becoming progressively more depressed, ashamed, and guilty. During
these periods he would isolate himself and withdraw socially, which further
contributed to his depression.
His ongoing guilt was addressed in a group therapy intervention in which
Frederick discussed shameful acts. The therapist asked Frederick to write
down the most distressing thoughts: (see Table 20). Frederick was able to
review some of the unhelpful behaviors (isolation, withdrawal, attempts to
avoid these painful thoughts) that resulted in increased distress and
depression and develop more helpful responses (contacting others). As a
result of this exercise, he was also able to develop a more compassionate
view of his illness and a more motivating helpful view of what he could do to
stay stable.
Group Members agreed that they had little difficulty thinking of some
symptoms, and during the conversation many were able to add symptoms that
they had forgot to include.
Therapist: Ok, now we want to start thinking about what are the
earliest possible indicators that you’re getting depressed
or starting into a manic stage.
Group Member: I have depression all the time it seems.
Therapist: Ok, let’s start by finding out what makes depression worse.
What are things that make your depression worse? [Therapist
writes items on the white board.] If any of these apply to
you and you don’t have them on your list, it’s a good idea
to write them down.
Group Member: Not enough sleep.
Group continues to list items while therapist writes them on the white board.
List included: ruminating on stressful situations, sense of urgency,
uncontrollable sense of pressure, having trouble prioritizing things, having
people tell me what I can and can’t do, not taking medication on schedule,
having weird thoughts, trying to get things done and people or something gets
in the way, getting irritable.
Therapist: Okay. These are pretty good lists of things that make
depression and mania worse. We want to keep working on the
idea of finding out what are the earliest possible signs
that we’re sliding into a deeper depression or into a manic
state. Paying attention to these things on the list may help
us begin to spot changes in ourselves earlier than we have
before. For our home practice this week does anyone have a
good idea about how we can do this?
Group Member: Well one thing is if we keep trying to add things to our
lists, maybe we can spot more things that get to us early
on, and we can notice how that’s affecting us.
Group Member: Also if we think about the level of these different things.
Maybe some start off real gradual and we don’t notice it.
Maybe if we tried to see if that’s the case. Like what am I
doing or experiencing before I notice that I’m starting to
have sleep problems.
Therapist: Well those are good suggestions. Any others?
Group Member: Maybe there are things that occur before the things that we
notice. I think it would be helpful to look for things like
that.
Therapist: Okay. Our assignment for next week will be to continue
looking for items to put on our list, and keep thinking
about what might be happening even before or just as our
mood is starting |73| to change significantly. Going back
to our symptom list, the features we’ve listed here are
pretty obvious and we have little difficulty in identifying
them. However, in many of us there may be early subtle signs
that we and others don’t see right away. So what we want to
do is to see if we identify signs that occur very early,
even before we see these more obvious symptoms. We can use
the handout I gave you to list what we think are early,
middle, and late symptoms for us and bring this in next
week. Oh, and also we want to keep monitoring our mood. So
for next week we’ll have our mood graphs to hand in, and
we’ll have our list of early middle and late signs started
so that we can finish it during our session.
Vulnerabilities:
Isolation
Trying to do everything on my own
Visions of sainthood
Romance woes
Immersion in foreign cultures?
Emotional detachment
Self-isolation
Feeling inexplicably frustrated by everything
Dwelling on loneliness
The “gray cloud” mood
Warning Signs:
Clinical Vignette 9
Why Are You Sleeping So Much? Are You OK?
Andrea, a bright and high-achieving 21-year-old college student, returned to
live at home after a serious period of depression followed by a manic episode
in her first year at college. During her manic episode Andrea had engaged in
a number of behaviors that were frightening and disturbing both to her and to
her family. As a result, her mother was particularly concerned and attempted
to closely monitor changes in her behavior, including any significant changes
in sleep and wake cycles and other behavioral changes associated with the
onset of hypomania and mania. In mother’s view, there would be realistically
disastrous consequences for failing to identify signs of instability that
might indicate the emergence of new symptoms. Unfortunately, this sometimes
resulted in a high level of conflict between mother and daughter. Whenever
Andrea felt criticized by her mother, she tended to experience episodes of
depression that were destabilizing and interfered with her functioning at
college.
During a conjoint family therapy session, Andrea reported that she had become
severely dejected and depressed because she felt that her mother thought she
was a “lazy” person. This resulted in her staying in bed throughout the day
and missing several of her scheduled activities, and feeling significantly
more depressed. In the thought record summarized in Table 29, the therapist
attempted to illustrate the “downward spiral” into depression that occurred
in the context of concerns expressed by the mother which were experienced by
the daughter as both critical and intrusive.
The therapist attempted to help Andrea develop countering thoughts that would
assist her in feeling less criticized and disrupt some of her negative self-
labeling, and pointed out her tendency to sabotage herself by missing classes
and other important activities when she felt criticized. This resulted in a
serious “downward spiral,” in which minor criticisms were perceived as
major threats to self-esteem and precipitated further withdrawal, isolation,
and self-blaming. The final outcome was that what might have started out as a
relatively minor setback became a much more serious depressive episode that
interfered with daily functioning and threatened important longer-term goals.
Table 28 Thought Record: “I’m a Lazy Person Staying in Bed All Day”
Situation I’m trying to nap and mom says, “Get up, you’ve been
watching TV all day.”
Thoughts I’m lazy
I don’t care about my future
I’m less of a person (95%)
I’m not motivated
I’m not good enough (99%)
If mom thinks I’m lazy then I must be lazy (90%)
I am bad person
Whatever my mom says about me is true.
My thoughts and feelings are not valid.
Feelings Dejected
Depressed
Irritable
Annoyed
Sensitive
[Anxious]
Clinical Vignette 11
Combating Demoralization and Hopelessness
Tanya, a 22-year-old Asian-American woman, began therapy during a severe
depression in which she often felt “numb,” immobilized, “robotic,”
“muddle-headed,” and would stay in bed for several days at a time.”
Although very bright and with an advanced degree in engineering, she was
reduced to doing project-oriented consulting and felt that her last project
had been an abysmal failure. She assumed that she was viewed as grossly
incompetent and would never be offered another consulting project. Tanya was
assigned The Feeling Good Handbook by David Burns (see Self-help Resources in
Appendix 10). After several sessions, Tanya agreed to schedule several
pleasant events that involved increasing her social contacts.
When she returned for the next session, Tanya reported that she had been
unable to follow through on the assignment and reported feeling increasingly
depressed. We discussed her difficulty following through on these assignments
and developed a Thought Record).
Tanya reported feeling very apathetic, numb, doubtful and hopeless in
conjunction with these thoughts. After identifying some of the cognitive
distortions associated with these thoughts (e.g. “I’ll be too robotic”,
“I’ll be disappointed anyway, so why bother”, “I’ll never do well at
this”), Tanya slowly developed more rational responses (e.g. “Even so,
it’s better than doing nothing.”, “Maybe I will be |82| disappointed, but
I might not be 100% disappointed”, “Making some attempt will be better than
staying in bed.”) It took time for Tanya to come up with alternative ways of
thinking. Even though it is often time-consuming for severely depressed
patients to complete this type of exercise, it is important to let patients,
rather than therapists, to develop the alternate responses.
At the end of the exercise, Tanya felt more hopeful and less anxious about
homework, and renewed her commitment to the the tasks the next week.
It should be noted that for patients like Tanya who are severely depressed,
one exercise is unlikely to have a lasting impact and multiple efforts will
need to be made over time to address hopelessness and demoralization. In
fact, after 2–3 weeks of feeling significantly better, Tanya returned to
therapy after a 2 week break unable to do her homework and feeling very
hopeless again. She began the session with the statement, “I feel like I
took a nosedive,” and she rated her mood as –3 on a +5 to –5 scale. She
had not followed through on homework and had the following thoughts:
“I don’t really care anymore about making an effort, because it won’t make
a difference.”
“I want to crawl in a hole and not deal with the world right now.”
“I’m frustrated that I made an improvement and slid back.”
“When I make progress, there’s always some glitch; something bad happens.”
These thoughts left her feeling numb, blank, and hopeless. She noticed
several thinking errors, including “emotional reasoning” (“I feel like it
won’t make a difference, therefore, it won’t make a difference”),
predicting the future, overgeneralization, magnifying problems, and
minimizing positives (“When I make progress, something bad always
happens”). With some effort she was able to come up with several countering
thoughts:
“I am feeling more hopeful about my therapy.”
“Things don’t always stay bad; I have felt better in the past.”
“Even if I do slide back, I’m getting help and have good support systems.”
At the end of this exercise the patient felt somewhat less hopeless and rated
her mood as a –1 or –2 on the +5 to –5 scale. This may seem to be only
modest progress, but in an additive fashion these small steps help the
patient move forward.
4.4.2 The Role of Self-Help and Support Groups
For maintenance of gains long-term, self-help support groups
can be extremely helpful. Many patients we have treated who
have been most successful have developed strong support
systems, in part through organized self-help groups. Active
participation in self-help groups reflects the same active
self-management efforts that are a key to long-term illness
management and recovery. There are a number of well-organized
and dedicated organizations (see Appendix 10: Self-Help
Resources) that offer education and support for individuals
with serious mental health problems and for their families.
These groups provide extremely helpful education, social
support, and help to destigmatize the illness in ways that
are not available to the professional therapist.
Clinical Vignette 12
Helping Patients Assess Risk of Hypomania
A 32-year-old Asian-American woman comes to group session 4 of a specialty BD
treatment group, indicating that she had only 3 hours of sleep last night.
She denies that she is at risk of becoming manic, despite feedback from other
group members, and in fact insists that this sleep loss is helpful in
combating depression. However, she does agree to participate in an exercise
reviewing the evidence that she might be becoming manic.
Therapist: So you’re telling me that there was such a pressure to do
things that you couldn’t sleep? Is that right? Did I
mishear you?
Patient: Yeah, that’s right.
Therapist: But you’re saying you’re not worried about becoming manic
or hypomanic?
Other Patient: When I lose that much sleep I become irritable and
hypomanic, but I feel like I can write a whole book.
Patient: Yeah, you discover all these talents. By pulling an “all
nighter” last week, I changed my body chemistry.
Therapist: This seems really important. Could we look at the evidence
that this is just a normal mood range for you or something
more?
Patient: Well, I’m a bit irritable. [Evidence of hypomania]
|89| Therapist:Okay, [going to board and writing] could we look at the
evidence for “I’m not hypomanic” versus the evidence for
“I am hypomanic.” Are you willing to work with me here?
Patient: Okay.
Therapist: Let’s look at the evidence that you’re really okay –
you’re not getting into trouble-hypomania.
Patient: I’m a little irritable.
Therapist: That’s probably on the side of hypomania. Right?
Patient: But, I’m not going on shopping sprees.
Therapist: Let’s look at all the evidence that you’re okay. What
else?
Patient: Well, I did go on a shopping spree, but I returned half the
stuff.
Therapist: I’m a little confused. Maybe we should put the shopping
spree on one side [Manic] and the returns on the other [not
manic]? [Laughter from group members]
Patient: I also feel more positive and optimistic. I realize now the
obsessive thoughts I had (when depressed) were unfounded.
Therapist: So all these are pretty much evidence that you’re feeling
better, right? Are these all reflections of your normal mood
state? Is this how you usually feel – optimistic and
positive all the time? So these are signs of normal mood for
you?
Patient: Well, my speech is a bit rapid.
Therapist: So, where is the evidence that you might be getting
hypomanic?
Patient: Irritability is a sign, right?
Therapist: And, I guess, shopping sprees, although you returned half
the stuff and that’s on the “evidence against” side.
Patient: I’m feeling more social too.
Therapist: What else should be on the list? What about you’re sleeping
4 hours a night?
Patient: Yes.
Therapist: So is this a balanced picture? How do you weigh the evidence
at this point?
Patient: Is there anything between normal and hypomania?
Therapist: Sure. Let’s put the question this way: Are you 100% sure
that you are in a normal mood state and there’s no
possibility that you’re getting hypomanic?
Patient: I’m 100% convinced I’m somewhere between normal and
hypomanic.
Table 30 Interview Style With the Hypomanic/Manic Patient
Dos Don’ts
Sit quietly Sit too close
Avoid any rapid movements Sit away from the door
Keep personal space Argue or debate
Use Socratic questioning Challenge or confront the patient
Use a calm tone of voice Blame or shame
Speak slowly Lecture
Use open-ended questions Tell the patient what to do
Engage patient in a collaborative fashion Be the expert on mania
Encourage “sitting and talking”
4.7.2
Suicide Risk Assessment and Management
|90|
Clinical Vignette 13
Behavioral Tailoring for Medication Adherence
Therapist: Are there any other problems that we want to make sure we
address?
Patient: Yes. One consistent problem for me has been keeping up with
actually taking my medication. When I’m at home I’m fine,
but then back at school I stop taking it after about a
month. I don’t know why.
Therapist: Do you say to yourself that I’m going to stop, or do you
just find yourself not remembering?
Patient: I forget OK. I can’t figure out what’s going on
Therapist: And what’s the difference between home and school in terms
of taking your medication?
Patient: I guess I kind of planted in my head the idea that if Mom
asks me I need to say “Yes.”
Therapist: Do you depend on reminders from other people?
Patient: I guess it’s a kind of mental trick that I had better take
it in case Mom asks – she knows I have had trouble at
school.
Therapist: So, when no one asks you, that’s when you run into trouble?
Patient: Yes. I really don’t have any idea why or how that ends up
happening, it just happens.
Therapist: So you don’t seem to be doing on purpose, you just seem to
lapse suddenly.
Patient: Yes, suddenly I’ve been off my medications weeks and
feeling horribly depressed and not attending classes. I’m a
wreck.
Therapist: So its sounds important that this not happen again. It seems
like when you’re at home you have a cueing system that
eventually comes in and says, “Oh, by the way, did you take
your medicine?” and you’re using that to cue yourself –
problem is you don’t have that same cueing system in
college.
|94| Patient: What I could do is use a calendar and make a specific mark
each day signifying I took the pills.
Therapist: Ok, so you could mark your calendar. That’s a good
suggestion because when you check your calendar you’ll know
where you stand, particularly if you’re checking your
calendar all the time anyway for other things you’ve
scheduled. Maybe we could assign this as homework over the
next week for you to keep a daily calendar on medication. I
think I warned you I might give homework.
Patient: Well, it’s my idea anyway – so this assignment is my
fault!
Therapist: So you accept responsibility for this one, since you
developed yourself.
4.8 Summary
Clinicians working with patients with BD are likely to
confront a number of clinical challenges, including suicide
risk, problems with treatment adherence, and co-occurring
substance use disorders. We have outlined strategies that
target each of these problems. To be successful, clinicians
need to be willing to be flexible in their treatment approach
and to incorporate specialized interventions into evidence-
based treatment.
5
Further Reading
|97|
Cella, D., Riley, W., Stone, A., Rothrock, N., Reeve, B.,
Yount, S., …PROMIS Cooperative Group. (2010). The Patient-
Reported Outcomes Measurement Information System (PROMIS)
developed and tested its first wave of adult self-reported
health outcome item banks: 2005–2008. Journal of Clinical
Epidemiology, 63, 1179–1194.
Even, C., Richard, H., Thuile, J., Friedman, S., & Rouillon,
F. (2007). Characteristics of voluntary participants versus
nonparticipants in a psychoeducation program for euthymic
patients with bipolar disorder. Journal of Nervous and Mental
Disease, 195, 262–265. Crossref
Lam, D. H., Hayward, P., Watkins, E. R., Wright, K., & Sham,
P. (2005). Relapse prevention in patients with bipolar
disorder: Cognitive therapy outcome after 2 years. American
Journal of Psychiatry, 162, 324–329. Crossref
Lam, D. H., Jones, S. H., Hayward, P., & Bright, J. (2010).
Cognitive therapy for bipolar disorder: A therapist’s guide
to concepts, methods, and practice (2nd ed.). Chichester, NY:
Wiley. Crossref
Merikangas, K. R., Jin, R., He, J. P., Kessler, R., Lee, S.,
Sampson, N., …Zarkov, Z. (2011). Prevalence and correlates
of bipolar spectrum disorder in the World Mental Health
Survey Initiative. Archives of General Psychiatry, 68, 241–
251. Crossref
Meyer, T. D., & Hautzinger, M. (2012). Cognitive behaviour
therapy and supportive therapy for bipolar disorders: Relapse
rates for treatment period and 2-year follow-up.
Psychological Medicine, 42, 1429–1439. Crossref
Moreno, C., Laje, G., Blanco, C., Jiang, H., Schmidt, A. B.,
& Olfson, M. (2007). National trends in the outpatient
diagnosis and treatment of bipolar disorder in youth.
Archives of General Psychiatry, 64, 1032–1039. Crossref
Padmos, R., Van Baal, G., Vonk, R., Wijkhuijs, A., Kahn, R.,
Nolen, W., & Drexhage, H. (2009). Genetic and environmental
influences on pro-inflammatory monocytes in bipolar disorder.
Archives of General Psychiatry, 66, 957–965. Crossref
Perry, A., Tarrier, N., Morriss, R., McCarthy, E., & Limb, K.
(1999). Randomised controlled trial of efficacy of teaching
patients with bipolar disorder to identify early symptoms of
relapse and obtain treatment. British Medical Journal, 318,
149–153. Crossref
Scott, J., Colom, F., Popova, E., Benabarre, A., Cruz, N.,
Valenti, M., … Vieta, E. (2009). Long-term mental health
resource utilization and cost of care following group
psychoeducation or unstructured group support for bipolar
disorders: A cost-benefit analysis. The Journal of Clinical
Psychiatry, 70, 378–386.
Scott, J., Garland, A., & Moorhead, S. (2001). A pilot study
of cognitive therapy in bipolar disorders. Psychological
Medicine, 31, 459–467. Crossref
Sekar, A., Bialas, A., de Rivera, H., Davis, A., Hammond, T.,
Kamitaki, N., … Genovese, G. (2016). Schizophrenia risk from
complex variation of complement component 4. Nature, 530
, 177
–183. Crossref
Suppes, T., Silva, R., Cucchiaro, J., Mao, Y., Targum, S.,
Streicher, C., … Loebel, A. (2016). Lurasidone for the
treatment of major depressive disorder with mixed features: A
randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study. American
Journal of Psychiatry, 173, 400–407.
Zaretsky, A., Lancee, W., Miller, C., Harris, A., & Parikh,
S. V. (2008). Is cognitive-behavioural therapy more effective
than psychoeducation in bipolar disorder? Canadian Journal of
Psychiatry, 53, 441–448.
Zimmermann, P., Brückl, T., Nocon, A., Pfister, H., Lieb, R.,
Wittchen, H.-U., … Angst, J. (2009). Heterogeneity of DSM-IV
major depressive disorder as a consequence of subthreshold
bipolarity. Archives of General Psychiatry, 66, 1341–1352.
Websites
http://www.dbsalliance.org/: Website for the Depressive and
Bipolar Support Alliance (DBSA)
http://www.nimh.nih.gov/health/topics/bipolar-
disorder/index.shtml: Website for National Institutes of
Health