You are on page 1of 97

Chapter 2: Part 1

Determination of Interest Rates


1. Overview of Interest rates

2. Determination of Interest Rates


Contents
3. Economic forces that affect
Interest rates

4. Forecasting Interest rates


1. Overview of Interest rates
1. Overview of Interest rates

○ What does interest mean?


□ Interest is the price demanded by the lender from
the borrower for the use of borrowed money
□ a fee paid by the borrower to the lender on borrowed
cash as a compensation for forgoing the opportunity
of earning income from other investments that could
have been made with the loaned cash.
□ "opportunity cost’ or "rent of money" – from the
lenders’ perspective

4
1. Overview of Interest rates

○ Why do lenders charge interest rates on loans?


□ Compensation for inflation
□ Compensation for default risk – the chance that
the borrower will not pay back the loan
□ Compensation for the opportunity cost of
waiting to spend your money

5
1. Overview of Interest rates

○ Interest rate? the rate at which interest (or


‘opportunity cost’) accumulates over a period of time.
□ The longer the period for which money is borrowed,
the larger is the interest (or the opportunity cost).
□ The amount lent is called the principal.
□ Interest rate is typically expressed as percentage of
the principal and in annualized terms.
□ From a borrower’s perspective: interest rate is the
cost of capital - the cost that a borrower has to incur
to have access to funds.
Question: How to measure interest rate?

6
1. Overview of Interest rates

○ How to measure Interest rate?

□ Q: (1) A one-year, $1000 face value coupon bond with a


selling price of $1200, coupon rate of 10%. Calculate the
Rate of return of this bond
c = 10%

Yield = (1200-1000)/1000 x 100 = 2%

C + Pt +1 - Pt C Pt +1 - Pt
r= = +
Pt Pt Pt
7
1. Overview of Interest rates

○ How to measure Interest rate?

Interest rate = Interest payment / Principal

Interest rate and Rate of Return ?


Rate of Return
= [Initial value / (Current value−Initial value)]×100

C + Pt +1 - Pt C Pt +1 - Pt
r= = +
Pt Pt Pt
8
1. Overview of Interest rates

Present Value

A dollar paid to you one year from now is less valuable


than a dollar paid to you today

○ Why?
□ A dollar deposited today can earn interest and
become $1 x (1+i) one year from today.

9
1. Overview of Interest rates

Discounting the Future


Let i = .10
In one year $100 X (1+ 0.10) = $110
In two years $110 X (1 + 0.10) = $121
or 100 X (1 + 0.10) 2
In three years $121 X (1 + 0.10) = $133
or 100 X (1 + 0.10)3
In n years
$100 X (1 + i ) n
10
1. Overview of Interest rates

Simple Present Value

PV = today's (present) value


CF = future cash flow (payment)
i = the interest rate
CF
PV = n
(1 + i)
11
1. Overview of Interest rates

Timeline
Cannot directly compare payments scheduled in
different points in the timeline

$100 $100 $100 $100

Year 0 1 2 n

PV 100 100/(1+i) 100/(1+i)2 100/(1+i)n


12
1. Overview of Interest rates

Terms

13
1. Overview of Interest rates

Four Types of Credit Market Instruments

○ Simple Loan
○ Fixed Payment Loan
○ Coupon Bond
○ Discount Bond

14
1. Overview of Interest rates

Yield to Maturity: The interest rate that equates the present


value of cash flow payments received from a debt instrument
with its value today
□ Q: (1) a three-year, $1,000 face value coupon bond
with a price of $1,050 and a coupon rate of 8% or (2) a
two-year, $1,000 face value coupon bond with a price
of $980 and a coupon rate of 6%?

15
1. Overview of Interest rates

Four Types of Credit Market Instruments


○ Simple Loan
If Pete borrows $100 from his sister and next year she wants $110
back from him, what is the yield to maturity on this loan?

110 = 100 x (1+i)

16
1. Overview of Interest rates

Four Types of Credit Market Instruments


○ Simple Loan
PV = amount borrowed = $100
CF = cash flow in one year = $110
n = number of years = 1
$110
$100 =
(1 + i )1
(1 + i ) $100 = $110
$110
(1 + i ) =
$100
i = 0.10 = 10%
For simple loans, the simple interest rate equals the
yield to maturity
17
1. Overview of Interest rates

Four Types of Credit Market Instruments


○ Fixed payment loan
The lender provides the borrower with an amount of funds that the borrower must
repay by making the same payment, consisting of part of the principal and
interest, every period (such as a month) for a set number of years.

Installment loans (such as auto loans) and mortgages are frequently of the fixed-
payment type.

Example: if you borrow $1,000, a fixed payment loan might require you to pay
$126 every year for 25 years.

18
1. Overview of Interest rates

Four Types of Credit Market Instruments


○ Fixed payment loan
The same cash flow payment every period throughout
the life of the loan
LV = loan value
FP = fixed yearly payment
n = number of years until maturity
FP FP FP FP
LV = + 2
+ 3
+ ...+
1 + i (1 + i ) (1 + i ) (1 + i ) n
19
1. Overview of Interest rates

Four Types of Credit Market Instruments


○ Fixed payment loan
Example: if you borrow $1,000, a fixed payment loan might require you to pay
$126 every year for 25 years.

126 126 126


1000 = + + ..... +
1+ i *
(1 + i )
* 2
(1 + i * ) 25

20
1. Overview of Interest rates

Four Types of Credit Market Instruments


○ Coupon Bond
Using the same strategy used for the fixed-payment loan:
P = price of coupon bond
C = yearly coupon payment
F = face value of the bond
n = years to maturity date
C C C C F
P= + + + . . . + +
1+i (1+i ) 2 (1+i )3 (1+i ) n (1+i ) n
21
1. Overview of Interest rates

Four Types of Credit Market Instruments


○ Coupon Bond
Example: Find the price of a 10% coupon bond with a face value of $1,000, a
12.25% yield to maturity, and eight years to maturity.

PV = 100/0.1225 x (1-1/(1.1225)^8) + 1000/ (1.1225)^8 = 852.55

22
1. Overview of Interest rates

Four Types of Credit Market Instruments


○ Coupon Bond

Table 1 Yields to Maturity on a 10%-Coupon-Rate Bond Maturing in Ten Years


(Face Value = $1,000)
23
1. Overview of Interest rates

Four Types of Credit Market Instruments


○ Coupon Bond

□ When the coupon bond is priced at its face value, the yield
to maturity equals the coupon rate
□ The price of a coupon bond and the yield to maturity are
negatively related
□ The yield to maturity is greater than the coupon rate when
the bond price is below its face value
24
1. Overview of Interest rates

○ Consol or Perpetuity
□ A bond with no maturity date that does not repay principal but
pays fixed coupon payments forever
P = C / ic
Pc = price of the consol
C = yearly interest payment
ic = yield to maturity of the consol
can rewrite above equation as this : ic = C / Pc
For coupon bonds, this equation gives the current yield, an easy
to calculate approximation to the yield to maturity
25
1. Overview of Interest rates

Four Types of Credit Market Instruments


○ Consol or Perpetuity
Example: What is the yield to maturity on a bond that has a price of $2,000
and pays $100 of interest annually, forever?
ic = 100/2000 = 5%

26
1. Overview of Interest rates

Four Types of Credit Market Instruments


○ Discount Bond
For any one year discount bond
F-P
i=
P
F = Face value of the discount bond
P = current price of the discount bond
The yield to maturity equals the increase
in price over the year divided by the initial price.
As with a coupon bond, the yield to maturity is
negatively related to the current bond price.
27
1. Overview of Interest rates

Four Types of Credit Market Instruments


○ Discount Bond
Example: What is the yield to maturity on a one-year, $1,000 Treasury bill
with a current price of $900?
(1000-900)/9000

28
1. Overview of Interest rates
Exercise
For each of the following situations, write the equation that you would use to
calculate the yield to maturity. You do not have to solve the equations for i;
just write the appropriate equation.
a. A simple loan for $500,000 that requires a. payment of $700,000 in four
years. PV = FV/ (1+i)^n => 500,000 = 700,000/ (1+i)^4

b. A discount bond with a price of $9,000, which has a face value of $10,000
and matures in one year. i = FV - PV) / PV = 10,000-9,000)/9,000

c. A corporate bond with a face value of $1,000, a price of $975, a coupon rate
of 10%, and a maturity of five years. PV = C/(1+i) +... +C/(1+i)^n + FV/(1+i)^n => 975 = 100/(1+i) +...+ 100/(1+i)^5 + 1000/(1+i)^5
d. A student loan of $2,500, which requires payments of $315 per year for 25
years. The payments start in two years. FV = A/(1+i) +...A/(1+i)^n => 2,500 = 315/(1+i) +...+ 315/(1+i)^25

29
1. Overview of Interest rates
Rate of Return
The payments to the owner plus the change in value
expressed as a fraction of the purchase price
C P -P
RET = + t+1 t
Pt Pt
RET = return from holding the bond from time t to time t + 1
Pt = price of bond at time t
Pt+1 = price of the bond at time t + 1
C = coupon payment
C
= current yield = ic
Pt
Pt+1 - Pt
= rate of capital gain = g
Pt
30
1. Overview of Interest rates
Rate of Return and Interest rates

○ The return equals the yield to maturity only if the holding


period equals the time to maturity

○ A rise in interest rates is associated with a fall in bond prices,


resulting in a capital loss if time to maturity is longer than the
holding period
○ The more distant a bondʼs maturity, the greater the size of the
percentage price change associated with an interest-rate
change

31
1. Overview of Interest rates
Rate of Return and Interest rates

○ The more distant a bond’s maturity, the lower the rate of


return the occurs as a result of an increase in the
interest rate
○ Even if a bond has a substantial initial interest rate, its
return can be negative if interest rates rise

32
1. Overview of Interest rates
Rate of Return and Interest rates

○ The more distant a bond’s maturity, the lower the rate of


return the occurs as a result of an increase in the
interest rate
○ Even if a bond has a substantial initial interest rate, its
return can be negative if interest rates rise

33
1. Overview of Interest rates
Rate of Return and Interest rates

34
1. Overview of Interest rates
Interest-rate Risk

○ Prices and returns for long-term bonds are more volatile


than those for shorter-term bonds
○ There is no interest-rate risk for any bond whose time to
maturity matches the holding period

35
1. Overview of Interest rates
Real and Nominal Interest rates

○ Nominal interest rate makes no allowance for inflation


○ Real interest rate is adjusted for changes in price level,
so it more accurately reflects the cost of borrowing
○ Ex ante real interest rate is adjusted for expected
changes in the price level
○ Ex post real interest rate is adjusted for actual changes
in the price level

36
1. Overview of Interest rates
Exercises

1. Would a dollar tomorrow be worth more to you today when the


interest rate is 20% or when it is 10%? No because we know PV = FV/(1+i)^n => So PV and i is inversely
proportional => 10% will be worth more

2. You have just won $20 million in the state lottery, which
promises to pay you $1 million (tax free) every year for the next
20 years. Have you really won $20 million? FV = 1/(1+i) +.. 1/ (1+i)^20 < 20 million
3. If the interest rate is 10%, what is the present value of a
security that pays you $1,100 next year, $1,210 the year after, and
$1,331 the year after that? PV = 1,100/1.1 + 1,210/1.1^2 + 1,331/1.1^3 = 3000

37
1. Overview of Interest rates
Exercises

4. If the security in Problem 3 sold for $3,500, is the yield to


maturity greater or less than 10%? Why? 3500-3000/3000 = 16.67% >10%

5. Write down the formula that is used to calculate the yield to


maturity on a 20-year 10% coupon bond with $1,000 face value
c = 10%*1000 = 100

that sells for $2,000. PV = PV coupon + PV Par = 100/i (1-1/(1+i)^20) + 1000/(1+i)^20

6. What is the yield to maturity on a $1,000-face-value discount


bond maturing in one year that sells for $800?
i = (1000-800)/800 = 25%

38
1. Overview of Interest rates
Exercises
7. What is the yield to maturity on a simple loan for $1 million
that requires a repayment of $2 million in five years’ time?
8. To pay for college, you have just taken out a $1,000
government loan that makes you pay $126 per year for 25 years.
However, you don’t have to start making these payments until
you graduate from college two years from now. Why is the yield to
maturity necessarily less than 12%, the yield to maturity on a
normal $1,000 fixed-payment loan in which you pay $126 per
year for 25 years?

39
7. PV = FV / (1+i)^n => 1 = 2/(1+i)^5 => i = 14.87%

8. 1000 = 126/i * (1-1/(1+i)^25 = 11.83%

This is the case because the first payment due begins at a future date.

2. Determination of Interest rates


2.1. Bond Market Model
2.2. Loanable Funds Model
2.3. Liquidity Preference Framework
2. Determination of Interest rates
Determining the Quantity Demanded of an Asset

○ Wealth—the total resources owned by the individual,


including all assets

○ Expected Return—the return expected over the next period on


one asset relative to alternative assets

○ Risk—the degree of uncertainty associated with the return on


one asset relative to alternative assets
○ Liquidity—the ease and speed with which an asset can be
turned into cash relative to alternative assets

41
2. Determination of Interest rates

increase because

increase

decrease

increase

theory of portfolio choice, which tells us how much of an asset people will want to hold in their portfolios

42
2. Determination of Interest rates

43
2.1 Determination of Interest rates
Supply and Demand for Bonds

44
2.1 Determination of Interest rates

○ Wealth—in an expansion with growing wealth, the Shifts in the Demand for Bonds
demand curve for bonds shifts to the right
○ Expected Returns—higher expected interest rates
in the future lower the expected return for long-
term bonds, shifting the demand curve to the left
○ Expected Inflation—an increase in the expected
rate of inflations lowers the expected return for
bonds, causing the demand curve to shift to the left

○ Risk—an increase in the riskiness of bonds causes


the demand curve to shift to the left
○ Liquidity—increased liquidity of bonds results in
the demand curve shifting right
45
2.1 Determination of Interest rates

Shifts in the Supply of Bonds


○ Expected profitability of investment
opportunities—in an expansion, the supply
curve shifts to the right
○ Business taxes – an increase in taxes shifts the
supply curve for bonds to the right
○ Expected inflation—an increase in expected
inflation shifts the supply curve for bonds to the
right
○ Government budget—increased budget deficits
shift the supply curve to the right

46
2.1 Determination of Interest rates
Supply and Demand for Bonds

• At lower prices (higher interest rates), ceteris


paribus, the quantity demanded of bonds is
higher—an inverse relationship
• At lower prices (higher interest rates), ceteris
paribus, the quantity supplied of bonds is lower—a
positive relationship

47
2.1 Determination of Interest rates
A Change in Expected Inflation

48
2.1 Determination of Interest rates
A Change in Expected Inflation

49
2.1 Determination of Interest rates
A Business Cycle Expansion

50
2.1 Determination of Interest rates
A Business Cycle Expansion

51
2.2. Loanable Funds Model
2.2. Loanable Funds Model

Loanable funds theory suggests that the market


interest rate is determined by the factors that affect
the supply of and demand for loanable funds
□ Can be used to explain movements in the
general level of interest rates of a particular
country
□ Can be used to explain why interest rates among
debt securities of a given country vary
53
2.2. Loanable Funds Model

Demand and supply of Demand and supply of


Bonds approach Loanable funds approach
Good? Bonds The use of Funds
Buyer? Investor (lender) who The firm (borrower) raising
buys a bond funds
Seller? Firm (borrower) who Investor (lender) supplying
issues a bond funds
Price? The bond price The interest rate

54
2.2. Loanable Funds Model
Demand for loanable funds

55
2.2. Loanable Funds Model
Demand for loanable funds

Determination Demand for I/r


funds
Expected Inflation

Expected profitability

Government budget
deficits

56
2.2. Loanable Funds Model

○ Business demand for loanable funds


□ Businesses demand loanable funds to invest in fixed
assets and short-term assets
□ Businesses evaluate projects using net present value
(NPV):
n
CFt
NPV = -INV +
t =1
å
(1 + k ) t

Ø Projects with a positive NPV are accepted


□ There is an inverse relationship between interest
rates and business demand for loanable funds
57
2.2. Loanable Funds Model

○ Government demand for loanable funds


□ Governments demand funds when planned
expenditures are not covered by incoming
revenues
Ø Municipalities issue municipal bonds
Ø The federal government issues Treasury
securities and federal agency securities
□ Government demand for loanable funds is
interest-inelastic

58
2.2. Loanable Funds Model

○ Aggregate demand for loanable funds


□ The sum of the quantities demanded by the
separate sectors at any given interest rate is the
aggregate demand for loanable funds

59
2.2. Loanable Funds Model

Dh Db

Household Demand Business Demand


60
2.2. Loanable Funds Model

Dg Dm

Federal Government Demand Municipal Government Demand

61
2.2. Loanable Funds Model

Df

Foreign Demand

62
2.2. Loanable Funds Model

DA

Aggregate Demand

63
2.2. Loanable Funds Model

○ Supply of loanable funds


□ Funds are provided to financial markets by
○ Households (net suppliers of funds)
○ Government units and businesses (net borrowers
of funds)
□ Suppliers of loanable funds supply more funds at
higher interest rates

64
2.2. Loanable Funds Model
Supply of loanable funds

65
2.2. Loanable Funds Model
Supply of loanable funds
Determination Supply of I/r
Funds
Income

Risk of Fund

Return of Fund

Liquidity

66
2.2. Loanable Funds Model

○ Supply of loanable funds


□ Foreign households, governments, and corporations
supply funds by purchasing Treasury securities
○ Foreign households have a high savings rate
□ The supply is influenced by monetary policy implemented
by the Federal Reserve System
○ The Fed controls the amount of reserves held by
depository institutions
67
2.2. Loanable Funds Model

○ Supply of loanable funds


□ The supply curve can shift in response to
economic conditions
○ Households would save more funds during a
strong economy

68
2.2. Loanable Funds Model

SA

Aggregate Supply

69
2.2. Loanable Funds Model

○ Equilibrium interest rate - algebraic


□ The aggregate demand can be written as
DA = Dh + Db + Dg + Dm + Df

□ The aggregate supply can be written as

SA = Sh + Sb + Sg + Sm + S f

70
2.2. Loanable Funds Model

SA

DA

Equilibrium Interest Rate - Graphic

71
2.2. Loanable Funds Model
International Capital Market

72
2.2. Loanable Funds Model
Large Open Economy

73
2.3. Liquidity Preference Framework
Supply and Demand in the market for Money
○ Keynes’s analysis is his assumption that people use two main categories of
assets to store their wealth:
□ Money
□ Bonds

LIQUIDITY PREFERENCE FRAMEWORK

Analyse the changes in Income, Price Level, Money Supply

Demand and Supply of Bonds

Analyse the changes in Expected Inflation

74
2.3. Liquidity Preference Framework
Supply and Demand in the market for Money

75
2.3. Liquidity Preference Framework
Supply and Demand in the market for Money

76
2.3. Liquidity Preference Framework
Supply and Demand in the market for Money

77
2.3. Liquidity Preference Framework
Supply and Demand in the market for Money

The increase of … Change in Change in interest


Demand/Supply at rate
each IR

Income Demand é

Price Level Demand é

Money Supply Supply ê

78
2.3. Liquidity Preference Framework
Money and Interest Rates
Liquidity Effect: An increase in the money supply (everything else remaining
equal) lowers interest rates

1. Income Effect: The income effect of an increase in the money supply is a rise
in interest rates in response to the higher level of income.

2. Price-Level Effect: The price-level effect from an increase in the money


supply is a rise in interest rates in response to the rise in price level.

3. Expected-Inflation Effect: The expected-inflation effect of an increase in the


money supply is a rise in interest rates in response to the rise in the expected
inflation rate.
79
2.3. Liquidity Preference Framework
Money and Interest Rates

80
2.3. Liquidity Preference Framework
Money and Interest Rates

81
3. Economic Forces That
Affect Interest Rates
3. Economic Forces That Affect Interest Rates

○ Economic growth
□ Shifts the demand schedule outward (to the
right)
□ There is no obvious impact on the supply
schedule
Ø Supply could increase if income increases as
a result of the expansion
□ The combined effect is an increase in the
equilibrium interest rate

83
3. Economic Forces That Affect Interest Rates

Loanable Funds Theory

SA

i2

DA2
DA

Impact of Economic Expansion

84
3. Economic Forces That Affect Interest Rates

○ Inflation
□ Shifts the supply schedule inward (to the left)
○ Households increase consumption now if
inflation is expected to increase
□ Shifts the demand schedule outward (to the
right)
○ Households and businesses borrow more to
purchase products before prices rise
85
3. Economic Forces That Affect Interest Rates

Loanable Funds Theory

SA2 SA

i2

DA2

DA

Impact of Expected Increase in Inflation

86
3. Economic Forces That Affect Interest Rates

○ Fisher effect
□ Nominal interest payments compensate savers
for:
○ Reduced purchasing power
○ A premium for forgoing present consumption
□ The relationship between interest rates and
expected inflation is often referred to as the
Fisher effect

87
3. Economic Forces That Affect Interest Rates

○ Fisher effect
□ Fisher effect equation:

i = E (INF ) + i R
□ The difference between the nominal interest
rate and the expected inflation rate is the real
interest rate:
i R = i - E (INF )
88
3. Economic Forces That Affect Interest Rates

○ Money supply
□ If the Fed increases the money supply, the supply
of loanable funds increases
Ø If inflationary expectations are affected, the
demand for loanable funds may also increase
□ If the Fed reduces the money supply, the supply
of loanable funds decreases
□ During 2001, the Fed increased the growth of the
money supply several times

89
3. Economic Forces That Affect Interest Rates

○ Money supply
□ September 11
○ Firms cut back on expansion plans
○ Households cut back on borrowing plans
○ The demand of loanable funds declined
□ The weak economy in 2001–2002
○ Reduced demand for loanable funds
○ The Fed increased the money supply growth
○ Interest rates reached very low levels
90
3. Economic Forces That Affect Interest Rates

○ Budget deficit
□ A high deficit means a high demand for loanable funds by
the government
Ø Shifts the demand schedule outward (to the right)
Ø Interest rates increase
□ The government may be willing to pay whatever is
necessary to borrow funds, but the private sector may not
Ø Crowding-out effect
□ The supply schedule may shift outward if the government
creates more jobs by spending more funds than it collects
from the public

91
3. Economic Forces That Affect Interest Rates

○ Foreign flows of funds


□ The interest rate for a currency is determined by the
demand for and supply of that currency
Ø Impacted by the economic forces that affect the
equilibrium interest rate in a given country, such
as: (1) Economic growth; (2) Inflation
□ Shifts in the flows of funds between countries cause
adjustments in the supply of funds available in each
country

92
3. Economic Forces That Affect Interest Rates

○ Explaining the variation in interest rates over time


□ Late 1970s: high interest rates as a result of strong
economy and inflationary expectations
□ Early 1980s: recession led to a decline in interest rates
□ Late 1980s: interest rates increased in response to a strong
economy
□ Early 1990s: interest rates declined as a result of a weak
economy
□ 1994: interest rates increased as economic growth
increased
○ Drifted lower for next several years despite strong
economic growth, partly due to the U.S. budget
surplus
93
4. Forecasting Interest Rates
4. Forecasting Interest Rates

○ It is difficult to predict the precise change in the


interest rate due to a particular event
□ Being able to assess the direction of supply or
demand schedule shifts can help in
understanding why rates changed

95
4. Forecasting Interest Rates

○ To forecast future interest rates, the net demand


for funds (ND) should be forecast:

ND = DA - S A
[
= Dh + Db + Dg + Dm + Df ]
- [S h + Sb + Sg + Sm +S ]
f

96
4. Forecasting Interest Rates

○ A positive disequilibrium in ND will be corrected by


an increase in interest rates
○ A negative disequilibrium in ND will be corrected
by a decrease in interest rates

97

You might also like