Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
Implantable biomaterials often trigger a variety of adverse responses. Because polydimethyl siloxane surfaces have good hemo- and
bio-compatibility, it is generally believed that surface biocompatibility may be improved by modifying biomaterial surfaces with
silicone-like properties. For this, we developed a series of polycaprolactone}polydimethylsiloxane}polycaprolactone (PDMS}PCL)
copolymers. By mixing the substrate material*polyvinyl chloride*with low concentrations (1.2 and 2.4%) of the PDMS}PCL
copolymer, we generated materials with silicone-like surface properties as re#ected by increased surface silicon content and surface
contact angles. We assessed the biocompatibility of these surfaces in vitro and found that the addition of PDMS}PCL signi"cantly
reduced the percentages of surface-&denatured' "brinogen, a critical element of genesis of many adverse responses to implanted
biomaterials. Indeed, using an animal implantation model, we "nd that PDMS}PCL-blended materials triggered signi"cantly weaker
in#ammatory responses than did polyvinyl chloride, the substrate control. The results from these experiments suggest that the use of
PDMS}PCL additives (2.4%) in polymer blends is a useful means of camou#aging the substrate surface properties and improving the
biocompatibility of biomaterials. 1999 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved
0142-9612/99/$ - see front matter 1999 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
PII: S 0 1 4 2 - 9 6 1 2 ( 9 9 ) 0 0 0 3 4 - 4
1366 L. Tang et al. / Biomaterials 20 (1999) 1365}1370
dominated by the low-surface energy siloxane. Thus, a molecular weight of 6500 D. The PDMS}PCL copoly-
even at very low levels of bulk siloxane content (0.5}5.0% mer was compounded at 1.2 and 2.4% (w/w) with a medi-
by weight), the resultant blends display completely sili- cal grade polyvinyl chloride to generate test tubing and
cone-like surface properties [27, 28]. However, due to the "lms using a twin screw extruder and THF solution
lack of covalent linkage, pure PDMS does not stay on casting, respectively. All experimental results are com-
surfaces over a long period of time. An e!ective way pared with control PVC and polydimethyl siloxane "lm
of achieving stable surface modi"cation in such blends (Dow Corning Corp., Midland, Michigan).
is through the use of siloxane-containing block copoly-
mers. In these systems the organic component of the 2.2. Sample preparation
siloxane copolymer provides miscibility with the base
polymer while siloxane segments migrate to the air-poly- Except for rheological studies, disks of 1.2-cm diameter
mer interface. Therefore, in essence, these organic seg- were cut from test surfaces. These disks were sonicated
ments act as &anchoring groups' for the siloxane blocks three times (5 min each time) in 70% ethanol, with
and thereby provide &permanent' surface modi"cation. frequent changes of ethanol, to remove dust and to
Because of a wide choice of organic blocks, various types sterilize the surfaces. Before use, the disks were hy-
of siloxane copolymers have been designed and syn- drated by immersion in sterile, pyrogen-free saline for at
thesized to achieve optimum compatibility with the base least 1 h.
resin utilized [24, 27, 28, 30].
One of the earliest studies of surface-modifying addi- 2.3. Rheological measurement
tive-containing copolymers was reported by Zisman et al.
[31] in 1967. Since then many PDMS-based surface It is well known that additives in the polymer com-
modifying additive-containing copolymers have been pound may change not only the physical and chemical
synthesized and shown to e!ectively modify material properties of the material, but also the parameters
surfaces with silicone-like surface properties [24, 27, 28, needed to process the materials. The most common indi-
30, 32]. However, to the best of our knowledge, the cator used to assess these changes is the rheological
biocompatibility of these silicone-like surfaces has not properties of the material. A Kayness Dynasty IV Capil-
been evaluated. By measuring surface-mediated protein lary Rheometer was used to evaluate changes in shear
adsorption in vitro and in#ammatory responses in vivo, viscosity under various shear rates as described earlier
we attempted to assess the biocompatibility of polyvinyl [33}36]. The results were then compared with control
chloride (PVC) blended with di!erent concentrations (1.2 PVC tubing.
and 2.4%) of siloxane-containing block copolymers.
PVC was selected as the substrate because it is widely 2.4. Contact angle measurement
used in the medical device industry, often in application
requiring direct blood and tissue contact. A commercial- The wettability of the samples was evaluated using
ly available triblock copolymer of polycaprolactone} water contact angle measurements. A computer-video
polydimethylsiloxane}polycaprolactone was chosen to processed goniometer, VCA-2500 (Advanced Surface
produce silicone-like surfaces. Tech., Billerica, MA), was used to take these measure-
ments. A sessile drop of DI water was dispensed onto the
"lm and its image was captured by a video camera and
2. Materials and methods displayed on a computer monitor. The contact angle of
the water drop was then determined using computer
2.1. Materials software.
I-human "brinogen was obtained from ICN Bio- 2.5. X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS or ESCA)
medical Inc. (Costa Mesa, CA). Sodium dodecyl sulfate
(SDS), horseradish peroxidase, guaiacol (O-methoxy- XPS measurements were carried out in an SSX-100
phenol), hydrogen peroxide (30% solution), eserine spectrometer (Surface Science Instruments, Mountain
(physostigmine), O-nitrophenyl butyrate, dimethyl silo- View, CA) using a monochromatic AlKa X-ray source,
xane, tetrahydrofurane (THF) and Triton X-100 (octyl a detection system with a 303 solid angle acceptance and
phenoxy polyethoxyethanol) were purchased from Sigma a hemispherical analyzer as published earlier [37].
Chemical Co. (St. Louis, MO). A 5 eV #oodgun was applied to compensate for the
Surface-modifying additive PDMS was obtained from surface charging of polymer samples. The X-ray spot size
Goldschmidt Chemical Co. (Hopewell, VA) and used as (area analyzed) on the sample surfaces was approxi-
received. It is a hydroxy-terminated polycaprolactone} mately 1 mm in diameter. A standard 553 take-o! angle
polydimethylsiloxane}polycaprolactone (Tegomer (the angle between the surface normal and the axis of
hereafter abbreviated as PDMS}PCL) copolymer with the analyzer lens) was used for surface scans. Surface
L. Tang et al. / Biomaterials 20 (1999) 1365}1370 1367
compositions determined from XPS spectra were used to 3. Results and discussion
examine the existence of the siloxane component.
3.1. Surface characterization of PDMS}PCL blended
2.6. Measurement of adsorbed and *denatured+ materials
xbrinogen
Earlier and our preliminary studies have established
The amounts of spontaneously adsorbed and &de- that, by blending a small percentage (1}3%) of PDMS-
natured' "brinogen on di!erent surfaces were determined copolymer with polyvinyl chloride, the resulting materials
radiometrically. For this, the samples were incubated display silicone-like surface properties [24]. However,
with I-human "brinogen ("nal concentration the compatibility of the PDMS-copolymer-modi"ed sur-
20 lg/ml) for 4 h at 373C, on a rotary shaker set at 50 faces has not been evaluated. In the present studies,
rounds per minute (RPM). The samples then were thor- PDMS}PCL block copolymer was employed as the sur-
oughly rinsed with phosphate-bu!ered saline (PBS, face modifying additive for biomaterials. After blended
50 mM, pH 7.4) and half were incubated with 1% SDS for polyvinyl chloride with di!erent weight percentages (1.2
1 h (also shaken at 50 RPM) in order to remove elutable and 2.4%) of PDMS}PCL, the change of surface func-
(non-denatured) "brinogen [38]. Ratios between the sur- tionality and properties was determined by ESCA, con-
face-associated radioactivity on disks rinsed with 1% tact angle and shear viscosity measurements. As shown in
SDS vs. PBS were taken as a measure of the percentages Table 1, by comparing these data with those obtained
of surface-denatured "brinogen [39, 40]. from pure PVC and PDMS, we observed that the addi-
tion of PDMS}PCL copolymer at both 1.2 and 2.4%
generates silicone-like surfaces on PVC. Speci"cally, the
2.7. Experimentation and measurements of host responses addition of PDMS}PCL signi"cantly increased the sili-
con and oxygen contents on biomaterial surfaces. Obvi-
As an in vivo model for assessing biomaterial-me- ously, PDMS, but not PVC, surfaces have silicon. On the
diated in#ammatory responses, di!erent samples were other hand, the disappearance of substrate atomic com-
implanted intraperitoneally in Swiss Webster mice (male, ponents, such as chloride, indicated that the modi"ed
20 g body weight) (Taconic Farms, Inc., Germantown, surfaces are sheltered under PDMS. In addition, the
NY) as described earlier [41}43]. Explantation was per- supplement of PDMS}PCL compound resulted in an
formed at 16 h after implantation (earlier found to be the increase of hydrophobicities from 87 to 1003 and 1063 for
approximate time of maximal phagocyte accumulation). 1.2 and 2.4% PDMS}PCL, respectively. The increase of
After careful removal from the peritoneal cavity, ex- contact angle after adding PDMS}PCL compound fur-
planted disks were gently washed with PBS. The adher- ther supported the idea that PDMS segments, which are
ent cells were then lysed by incubating the disks with 0.6 m highly hydrophobic, have migrated onto the surfaces.
of 1% (v/v) Triton X-100 for 1 h (to release cytosolic and For manufacturing purposes, we also have tested
granular contents of adherent cells). The numbers of whether the addition of PDMS}PCL copolymer changes
adherent phagocytes were then estimated by determining the melting viscosity of substrate polymer. Knowledge of
enzyme activities (myeloperoxidase [MPO] for the #ow properties of the polymer melts is very impor-
neutrophils and nonspeci"c esterase [NSE] for macro- tant in determining whether it is capable of withstanding
phages/monocytes [M ]) to re#ect the extent of the manufacturing process, such as extrusion and injec-
biomaterial-mediated in#ammatory responses [41, 42]. tion molding. Knowledge of the melt #ow properties
Previous control experiments showed that surface-asso- allows accurate optimization of the process operating
ciated enzyme activities are reliable indicators of the
numbers of adherent phagocytes [41, 42]. We have
previously determined that the MPO activity of mouse
peripheral neutrophils and the NSE activity of mouse Table 1
peritoneal resident macrophages are &23 and &11 nU/ ESCA surface analyses and contact angle measurements of PVC,
PDMS}PCL-added PVC, and PDMS
cells, respectively [41]. Experimental values shown in all
graphs represent the results of single implantation experi- Test surface Atomic percentages Contact
ments using "ve animals per group. All such experiments angle
were repeated at least three times to ensure the reproduc- Si Cl C O
ibility of our results.
PVC 0 22.52 70.21 7.27 87$4
PVC#1.2% 9.71 5.03 63.60 21.63 100$3
2.8. Statistical analysis PDMS}PCL
PVC#2.4% 9.26 0.34 66.90 23.50 106$10
PDMS}PCL
Signi"cance of di!erences among variously coated sur- PDMS 27.07 0.00 45.06 27.87 118$2
faces was assessed using two-tailed Student's t test.
1368 L. Tang et al. / Biomaterials 20 (1999) 1365}1370
4. Conclusions
Acknowledgements
[13] Gristina AG. Biomaterial-centered infection: microbial adhesion [36] Rauwendaal C. Polymer extrusion. Munich: Carl Hanser Verlag,
versus tissue integration. Science 1987;237:1588}95. 1986.
[14] Lew DP. Physiopathology of foreign body infections. Eur J Can- [37] Sheu MS, Hudson DM, Loh IH. Biomaterial surface modi"ca-
cer Clin Oncol 1989;25:1379}82. tion using plasma gas discharge processes. In: Wise DL, Trantolo
[15] Dekker A, Reitsma K, Beugeling T, Bantjes A, Feijen J, van Aken DL, Altobelli DE, Yaszemski MJ, Gresser JD, Schwartz ER,
WG. Adhesion of endothelial cells and adsorption of serum pro- editors. Vol. 1, Part A: Materials. New York: Marcel Dekker,
teins on gas plasma-treated polytetra#uoroethylene. Biomaterials 1996:865}94.
1991;12:130}8. [38] Ratner BD, Castner DG, Horbett TA, Lenk TJ, Lewis KB,
[16] Ko TM, Lon JC, Cooper SL. Surface characterization and plate- Rapoza RJ. Biomolecules and surfaces. J Vasc Sci Tech 1990;8:
let adhesion studies of plasma-sulphonated polyethylene. Bio- 2306}16.
materials 1993;14:657}64. [39] Bohnert JL, Horbett TA. Changes in adsorbed "brinogen and
[17] Ko TM, Cooper SL. Surface properties and platelet adhesion albumin interactions with polymers indicated by decreases in
characteristics of acrylic acid and allylamine plasma-treated poly- detergent elutability. J Colloid Interface Sci 1986;111:363}77.
ethylene. J Appl Polym Sci 1993;47:1601}19. [40] Chinn JA, Posso SE, Horbett TA, Ratner BD. Postadsorptive
[18] Sano S, Kato K, Ikada Y. Introduction of functional groups onto transitions in "brinogen adsorbed to polyurethanes: changes in
the surface of polyethylene for protein immobilization. Bio- antibody binding, and sodium dodecyl sulfate elutability. J Bio-
materials 1993;14:817}22. med Mater Res 1992;26:757}78.
[19] Lee JH, Park JW, Lee HB. Cell adhesion and growth on polymer [41] Tang L, Eaton JW. Fibrin(ogen) mediates acute in#ammatory
surfaces with hydroxyl groups prepared by water vapor plasma responses to biomaterials. J Exp Med 1993;178:2147}56.
treatment. Biomaterials 1991;12:443}8. [42] Tang L, Lucas AH, Eaton JW. In#ammatory responses to Dac-
[20] Lee JH, Jung HW, Kang IK, Lee HB. Cell behavior on polymer ron: role of surface adsorbed IgG. J Lab Clin Med 1993;122:
surfaces with di!erent functional groups. Biomaterials 292}300.
1994;15:705}11. [43] Tang L, Ugarova TP, Plow EF, Eaton JW. Molecular determi-
[21] Lyman DJ, Metcalf LC, Albo D Jr, Richards KF, Lamb J. The nants of acute in#ammatory responses to biomaterials. J Clin
e!ect of chemical structure and surface properties of synthetic Invest 1996;97:1329}34.
polymers on the coagulation of blood. III. In vivo adsorption of [44] Pitt WG, Park K, Cooper SL. Sequential protein adsorption and
proteins on polymer surfaces. Trans ASAIO 1974;20:474}9. thrombus deposition on polymeric biomaterials. J Colloid Inter-
[22] Brash JL. Hydrophobic polymer surfaces and their interactions face Sci 1986;111:343}62.
with blood. Ann NY Acad Sci 1977;283:356}71. [45] Anderson JM, Bon"eld TL, Ziats NP. Protein adsorption and
[23] Leininger RI, Falb RD, Grode GA. Blood-compatible plastics. cellular adhesion and activation on biomedical polymers. Int
Ann NY Acad Sci 1968;146:11}20. J Artif Organs 1990;13:375}82.
[24] Yilgor I, Steckle WP Jr, Yilgor E, Freelin RG, Ri%e JS. Novel [46] Sevastianov VL. Role of protein adsorption in blood compatibil-
triblock siloxane characterization, and their use as surface ity of polymer. CRC Crit Rev Biocompat 1988;4:109}54.
modifying additives. J Polym Sci Part A: Polym Chem 1989;27: [47] Roohk HV, Nakamura M, Hill RL, Hung EK, Bartlett RH.
3673}90. A thrombogenic index for blood contact materials. Trans ASAIO
[25] Noll W. Chemistry and technology of silicons. New York: Aca- 1977;23:152}61.
demic Press, 1968. [48] Whicher SJ, Brash JL. Platelet-foreign surface interactions: re-
[26] Noshay A, McGrath AE. Block copolymer: overview and critical lease of granule constituents from adherent platelets. J Biomed
survey. New York: Academic Press, 1977. Mater Res 1978;12:181}90.
[27] Lelah MD, Cooper SL. Polyurethane in Medicine. Boca Raton: [49] Horbett TA, Cheng CM, Ratner BD, Ho!man AS, Hanson SR.
CRC Press, 1986. The kinetics of baboon "brinogen adsorption to polymers:
[28] Kawakami Y, Yamashita Y. Ring-opening polymerization. In: In vitro and in vivo studies. J Biomed Mater Res 1986;20:739}72.
McGrath JE, editor, ACS symposium series No. 286, Washington [50] Tang L, Wu Y-L, Timmons RB. Biomaterial surface properties
DC: American Chemical Society, Washington, 1985 [Chapter 19]. a!ecting both protein adsorption and host tissue responses. J Bio-
[29] Voronkov MG, Mileshkevich VP, Yuzhelevskii YA. The siloxane med Materials Res 1998;42:156}63.
bond. New York: Consultants Bureau, 1978. [51] Freyria AM, Chignier E, Guidollet J, Louisot P. Peritoneal mac-
[30] Yilgor I, McGrath JE. Advances in polymer science: polysiloxane rophage response: an in vivo model for the study of synthetic
copolymers/anionic polymerization. Berlin: Springer, 1988:1}86. materials. Biomaterials 1991;12:111}8.
[31] Zisman WA, Jarvis NL, Fox RB. Vinyl polymers modi"ed with [52] Merhi Y, Roy R, Guidoin R, Hebert J, Mourad W, Benslimane S.
#uoro esters. US Patent 3356632, 1967. Cellular reactions to polyester arterial prostheses impregnated
[32] Kumaki T, Sisido M, Imanishi Y. Antithrobogenicity and oxygen with cross-linked albumin; In vivo studies in mice. Biomaterials
permeability of block and graft copolymers of polydimethyl- 1989;10:56}8.
siloxane and poly(a-amino acid). J Biomed Mater Res 1985;19: [53] Uenoyama K, Kanagawa R, Tamura M, Matoba M, Enomoto Y,
785}811. Ohmi S. Experimental intraocular lens implantation in the rabbit
[33] Walters K. Rheometry: industrial applications. Chichester, Eng- eye and in the mouse peritoneal space. Part 1. Cellular compo-
land: Research Studies Press, 1980. nents observed on the implanted lens surface. J Cataract Refract
[34] Van Wazer JR, Lycons JW, Kim KY, Colwell RE. Viscosity and Surg 1988;14:187}91.
#ow measurement: a laboratory handbook of rheology. New [54] Christenson L, Aebischer P, McMillan P, Galletti PM. Tissue
York: Interscience, 1963. reaction to intraperitoneal polymer implants, species di!erence
[35] Dealy JM. Rheometers for Molten Plastics. New York: Van and e!ects of corticoids and doxorubicin. J Biomed Mater Res
Norstrand Reinhold, 1982. 1989;23:705}18.