You are on page 1of 5

616917

research-article2015
Sports Health: A Multidisciplinary Approach OnlineFirst, published on November 11, 2015 as doi:10.1177/1941738115616917
SPHXXX10.1177/1941738115616917Li et alSports Health

vol. XX • no. X SPORTS HEALTH

[ Athletic Training ]

Wearable Performance Devices


in Sports Medicine
Ryan T. Li, MD,† Scott R. Kling, MD,† Michael J. Salata, MD,† Sean A. Cupp, MD,†
Joseph Sheehan, ATC, CSCS,† and James E. Voos, MD*†

Context: Wearable performance devices and sensors are becoming more readily available to the general population and
athletic teams. Advances in technology have allowed individual endurance athletes, sports teams, and physicians to monitor
functional movements, workloads, and biometric markers to maximize performance and minimize injury. Movement sensors
include pedometers, accelerometers/gyroscopes, and global positioning satellite (GPS) devices. Physiologic sensors include
heart rate monitors, sleep monitors, temperature sensors, and integrated sensors. The purpose of this review is to familiarize
health care professionals and team physicians with the various available types of wearable sensors, discuss their current
utilization, and present future applications in sports medicine.
Evidence Acquisition: Data were obtained from peer-reviewed literature through a search of the PubMed database.
Included studies searched development, outcomes, and validation of wearable performance devices such as GPS,
accelerometers, and physiologic monitors in sports.
Study Design: Clinical review.
Level of Evidence: Level 4.
Results: Wearable sensors provide a method of monitoring real-time physiologic and movement parameters during training
and competitive sports. These parameters can be used to detect position-specific patterns in movement, design more
efficient sports-specific training programs for performance optimization, and screen for potential causes of injury. More
recent advances in movement sensors have improved accuracy in detecting high-acceleration movements during competitive
sports.
Conclusion: Wearable devices are valuable instruments for the improvement of sports performance. Evidence for use of
these devices in professional sports is still limited. Future developments are needed to establish training protocols using data
from wearable devices.
Keywords: wearable devices; GPS; accelerometers; sensors; sports performance

T
here is a growing trend in the athletic and health care accelerometers have been incorporated into personal devices to
environment to monitor human physiologic function and be used in a variety of applications (Table 1). These
performance during real-time activities. Recently, portable applications are diverse and range from ambulatory monitoring
and wearable sports devices incorporating sensor technology in the elderly population for falls, development of exercise
have benefited from increased media and commercial exposure programs to combat childhood obesity, and monitoring of
as effective tools to assess physical activity in the general military personnel on the battlefield.3,21,22,26,35,46,55
population. This has been driven by the increased availability, Athletes present a growing niche for the use of wearable
lower cost, and advancements of personal computing devices sensor technology. Advances in technology have allowed
such as smart phones and digital watches. Pedometers, heart individual endurance athletes, sports teams, and physicians to
rate monitors, portable electrocardiogram monitors, and monitor player movements,33 workloads,41,58 and biometric

From the †Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, University Hospitals Case Medical Center, Cleveland, Ohio
*Address correspondence to James E. Voos, MD, Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, University Hospitals Case Medical Center, 11100 Euclid Avenue, Cleveland, OH 44106
(email: james.voos@uhhospitals.org).
The following authors declared potential conflicts of interest: Michael J. Salata, MD, is a paid consultant for Smith & Nephew Endoscopy and James E. Voos, MD, is a paid
consultant for Stryker.
DOI: 10.1177/1941738115616917
© 2015 The Author(s)

1
Downloaded from sph.sagepub.com at UNIV CALIFORNIA SANTA BARBARA on November 24, 2015
Li et al Mon • Mon 2015

Table 1. Wearable devices used in sports medicine

Wearable Device Functional Mechanism


Movement sensors
Pedometer “Step” recorded each instance the vertical acceleration of a spring-loaded lever arm exceeds
the force sensitivity threshold
Accelerometer/gyroscope Acceleration causes deflection of a seismic mass between 2 electrodes, causing a change in
capacitance
GPS Signal transmissions from multiple orbiting satellites are acquired by a ground-based receiver;
the relative delay is used to calculate the speed and position of the receiver
Physiologic sensors
Heart rate monitor 1. Electrical activity from the heart recorded by electrodes in a chest strap
2. Peripheral pulse detected by optical-sensing technology in a wristband
Temperature monitor 1. Ingestible capsule transmits readings to external data log system
2. Armband measures skin convective heat flux in temperature
Integrated sensors Multimodal platforms that incorporate components of movement and physiologic sensors

GPS, global positioning satellite.

markers13,44 in attempts to maximize performance and minimize ambulatory setting, the application is unproven in competitive
injury. Monitoring these variables may allow for the sports. Pedometers have limited use in quantifying athletic
identification of biomechanical fatigue and early intervention in movements because of their inability to perceive changes of
an attempt to prevent injury during training and competitive direction and are poor indicators of energy expenditure.7,57
matches. Monitoring may also facilitate the development of
improved training regimens to optimize athlete performance. Accelerometers/Gyroscopes
The purpose of this review article is to familiarize health care Accelerometers and gyroscopes have demonstrated promise in
professionals and team physicians with the various available the realm of personal fitness by giving the user access to
types of wearable sensors, discuss their current utilization, and advanced performance data and the ability to quantifiably alter
present future applications in sports medicine. Knowledge of exercise programs. These devices are composed of 2
these devices is important in counseling patients in the safe components: a mechanical movement-sensing device and a
employment of these devices and potential limitations microchip that interprets signals from the mechanical device.
Technological progress and the development of
Movement Sensors microelectromechanical systems (MEMS) devices have allowed
multiple transducers to be packaged together, giving a single
Pedometers sensor the ability to perceive movement in multiple
Pedometers are the simplest and arguably the most commonly dimensions.40,51
used form of movement sensor. A “step” is recorded each time An additional benefit of accelerometers is the ability to
the vertical acceleration of the lever arm exceeds the force estimate energy expenditure by integrating vertical acceleration
sensitivity threshold of the pedometer.6 Many fitness over time.19,32 Energy expenditure is a crucial parameter for
recommendations and corporate health programs are based on assessing the intensity of a training regimen. Accelerometer-
achieving a recommended number of daily steps.5,56 Adherence based energy estimation in elite Australian football players was
to step counts is more likely to correlate with an increased comparable with more time-intensive video analysis.60
likelihood in meeting age-appropriate physical activity Because of their low-cost design and portability, accelerometry
guidelines.30 Pedometers have also demonstrated utility in has driven the development of portable wristband devices that
pediatric and obese populations to promote active have seen a significant rise in personal fitness in recent years.
lifestyles.29,34,50 These findings show that pedometers may have Devices such as the FitBit (FitBit Inc; www.fitbit.com), Jawbone
some value as a first-line tool in tracking levels of fitness. Up (Jawbone; jawbone.com/up), Nike Fuelband (Nike; www
While pedometers have been shown to have acceptable .nike.com/us/en_us/c/nikeplus-fuel), and Microsoft Band
reliability and validity for step-count monitoring in the (Microsoft; www.microsoft.com/microsoft-band/en-us) provide

2
Downloaded from sph.sagepub.com at UNIV CALIFORNIA SANTA BARBARA on November 24, 2015
vol. XX • no. X SPORTS HEALTH

data on a number of physiologic and movement parameters systems that have been shown to produce reliable
such as heart rate, caloric expenditure, sleep tracking, and steps measurements of movement.23,47,48 The validity and reliability of
that are then relayed wirelessly to a personal user account. GPS systems for court-based sports with shorter travel distance
Accelerometers generate more accurate analyses of athletic and greater intensities is still unproven.10
movements with higher sampling rates and more accurate
measurements.11,20,31,36,37 A series of studies in swimming have Physiologic Sensors
concluded that triaxial accelerometers are valuable in assessing Heart Rate Monitoring
stroke mechanics to optimize performance.5,8 Similar
accelerometer-based systems have been used to perform Sensors that determine physiologic response to changes in
time-motion analysis for rowing, tennis, and golf.1,16,45 competition and training are also crucial in promoting improved
Accelerometer data have been used during Australian football performance and decreased injury. Heart rate is a useful
matches to show positional differences in physical demands indicator of physiological adaptation and intensity of effort.
between positions and varying levels of competition.4 Standard heart rate monitors comprise a transducer worn
around the chest that transmits to a wireless wrist display.
Global Positioning Satellite Newer heart rate monitors have been developed using optical
sensor devices, such as a wrist band or smart phone, that detect
Global positioning satellite (GPS) devices are an alternative to
heart rate directly from the wrist or fingertip. While arguably
accelerometers in measuring positional data in athletics. GPS
more cumbersome, there are data to suggest the chest strap
devices require signal transmission from multiple GPS satellites
devices are still more accurate at higher heart rates and less
orbiting the earth. Signals from the satellites, each with
susceptible to motion artifact.54 Newer commercially available
on-board atomic clocks, are acquired from GPS receivers that
synchronize the signals to determine the speed and position of heart rate monitors such as those produced by Polar Electro
the receiver.12 The performance of GPS devices is improved, (Polar Electro Inc; www.polar.com/us-en) and Suunto (Suunto;
www.suunto.com) are also capable of measuring heart rate
particularly in the team sport setting, by employing a stationary
variability, which has been shown to be an important indicator
ground-based reference receiver in addition to wearable
of fitness.
receivers to refine timing errors from each satellite, with
Heart rate monitors are often used as important tools for the
accuracy up to 1 meter.43
measurement of exercise intensity. There is a linear relationship
GPS has been used to monitor the speed and position of
between heart rate and VO2 over a large range of submaximal
athletes in football, orienteering, cross-country skiing, and field
intensities.53 Consequently, VO2 and energy expenditure may be
hockey.17,27,28 The most well-documented use of GPS in
extrapolated from heart rate. Because of this relationship,
professional sports has been with Australian football and
portable heart rate monitors have become the most common
rugby.14,15,24,33,41,49,59
method of estimating exercise intensity. Heart rate monitors
Devices such as the Vivofit and Vivoactive (Garmin; www
have also been used in conjunction with kinematic analysis to
.garmin.com/vivofit), Polar M400 (Polar Electro Inc; www
determine physiologic response and metabolic demand
.polarm400.com), and Surge (FitBit Inc; www.fitbit.com/surge)
experienced during competition in a number of sports,
have incorporated GPS technology in wearable devices for
including basketball, rugby, and soccer.26,38
individual users. These devices are capable of displaying data
such as mileage, steps, pace, caloric expenditure, altitude, and
speed to the user in real time. In addition, data are then Temperature/Heat Flux Sensors
tabulated in software programs to allow the user to track their Monitoring of core body temperature is important in conditions
performance. where hyperthermia is a concern, such as high temperature/
GPS has also been used to modify training regimens to humidity climates and indoor facilities without air conditioning.
improve athlete performance.33 GPS devices have been used to There is additional concern for abnormal core temperature
collect both training and match time-motion data on 10 changes during an athlete’s initial acclimation to sporting
midfielders from an Australian Football League team. The study activity. Accurate monitoring of core body temperature has
classified different drills into 3 groups based on training presented a significant challenge in sports medicine. Core
intensity, as measured by the distance traveled in certain temperature can be assessed during athletic activities.44 External
velocity ranges. Additionally, higher intensity drills using the temperatures have been shown to be an unreliable proxy for
entire field more closely resembled competitive match play.33 core body temperature.18,42 Newer commercial temperature
GPS systems have been used to correlate fitness tests and sensors have circumvented this fact using a telemetric core
on-field performance, as well as determining energy temperature sensor relying on an ingestible capsule that
requirements for specific player positions.41,59 transmits data systems using radiofrequency.39,52 Designs for
Several commercially available GPS systems for sports temperature sensors all suffer from separate limitations. Cold
medicine have been introduced to the market with the ability to water and food ingestion affect the validity and reliability of
monitor an entire team. Catapult (Catapult; www.catapultsports. ingestible sensors.52 Armbands and skin-based dermal
com) and GPSports (GPSports; gpsports.com) are examples of temperature sensors may cause skin irritation and have poor

3
Downloaded from sph.sagepub.com at UNIV CALIFORNIA SANTA BARBARA on November 24, 2015
Li et al Mon • Mon 2015

reliability when assessing temperature and estimating energy 12. El-Rabbany A. Introduction to GPS: The Global Positioning System. London,
England: Artech House; 2002.
expenditure in high-intensity exercise.9 13. Foster CD, Twist C, Lamb KL, Nicholas CW. Heart rate responses to small-sided
games among elite junior rugby league players. J Strength Cond Res. 2010;24:
Integrated Sensors 906-911.
14. Ganio MS, Brown CM, Casa DJ, et al. Validity and reliability of devices that
Multimodal integrated sensors have been developed for use in assess body temperature during indoor exercise in the heat. J Athl Train.
team and individual fitness activities. The manufacturers 2009;44:124-135.
Catapult and Zephyr incorporate GPS technology with a 15. Gabbett TJ. GPS analysis of elite women’s field hockey training and competition.
J Strength Cond Res. 2010;24:1321-1324.
number of variable sensing elements to obtain physiologic and 16. Gabbett TJ. Influence of the opposing team on the physical demands of elite
movement profiles in athletes.2,48,58 The Catapult device is a rugby league match play. J Strength Cond Res. 2013;27:1629-1635.
small sensor placed most commonly between the shoulder 17. Gabbett TJ, Seibold AJ. Relationship between tests of physical qualities, team
selection, and physical match performance in semiprofessional rugby league
blades and can be secured onto a jersey or protective gear. The players. J Strength Cond Res. 2013;27:3259-3265.
Zephyr devices incorporate a respiratory rate monitor in 18. Ganio MS, Brown CM, Casa DJ, et al. Validity and reliability of devices that
addition to an electrocardiogram monitor.25 The Zehphyr assess body temperature during indoor exercise in the heat. J Athl Train.
2009;44:124-135.
BioPatch is designed as a wireless device that attaches to 19. Gusmer RJ, Bosch TA, Watkins AN, Ostrem JD, Dengel DR. Comparison of FitBit
disposable electrocardiography electrodes and provides Ultra to Actigraph GT1M for assessment of physical activity in young adults
continuous monitoring. While relatively small, the Zephyr during treadmill walking. Open Sports Med J. 2014;8:11-15.
20. Hartmann A, Luzi S, Murer K, de Bie RA, de Bruin ED. Concurrent validity of a
device requires a strap applied around the chest and over the trunk tri-axial accelerometer system for gait analysis in older adults. Gait Posture.
shoulder, which can be cumbersome when safety gear such as 2009;29:444-448.
shoulder pads are worn over the top. The straps are required 21. Helmrich SP, Ragland DR, Leung RW, Paffenbarger RS Jr. Physical activity and
reduced occurrence of non-insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus. N Engl J Med.
for accurate measures of respiration and heart rate. 1991;325:147-152.
22. Hu FB, Sigal RJ, Rich-Edwards JW, et al. Walking compared with vigorous
Conclusion physical activity and risk of type 2 diabetes in women: a prospective study.
JAMA. 1999;282:1433-1439.
The development of wearable sensor technology has had a 23. Johnston RJ, Watsford ML, Kelly SJ, Pine MJ, Spurrs RW. The validity and
reliability of 5-Hz global positioning system units to measure team sport
significant impact on athlete monitoring in sports medicine. movement demands. J Strength Cond Res. 2012;26:758-765.
Wearable sensors provide physicians, coaches, and training staff 24. Johnston RJ, Watsford ML, Pine MJ, Spurrs RW, Murphy A, Pruyn EC. Movement
with a method of monitoring real-time physiologic and demands and match performance in professional Australian football. Int J Sports
Med. 2012;33:89-93.
movement parameters during training and competitive sports. 25. Johnstone JA, Ford PA, Hughes G, Watson T, Garrett AT. Bioharness multivariable
These parameters can be used to detect position-specific monitoring device: part I: validity. J Sports Sci Med. 2012;11:400-408.
patterns in movement, design more efficient sports-specific 26. Kohl HW 3rd. Physical activity and cardiovascular disease: evidence for a dose
response. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2001;33(suppl):S472-S483.
training programs for performance optimization, and screen for 27. Larsson P. Global positioning system and sport-specific testing. Sports Med.
potential causes of injury, such as concussion and fatigue. 2003;33:1093-1101.
28. Larsson P, Henriksson-Larsén K. Combined metabolic gas analyser and dGPS
analysis of performance in cross-country skiing. J Sports Sci. 2005;23:861-870.
References 29. Laurson KR, Eisenmann JC, Welk GJ, Wickel EE, Gentile DA, Walsh DA.
Evaluation of youth pedometer determined physical activity guidelines using
1. Ahmadi A, Rowlands D, James DA. Towards a wearable device for skill receiver operator characteristic curves. Prev Med. 2008;46:419-424.
assessment and skill acquisition of a tennis player during the first serve. Sports 30. Le Masurier GC, Sidman CL, Corbin CB. Accumulating 10,000 steps: does this
Technol. 2009;2:129-136. meet current physical activity guidelines? Res Q Exerc Sport. 2003;74:389-394.
2. Akenhead R, French D, Thompson KG, Hayes PR. The acceleration dependent 31. Lee JA, Cho SH, Lee JW, Lee KH, Yang HK. Wearable accelerometer system for
validity and reliability of 10Hz GPS. J Sci Med Sport. 2014;17:562-566. measuring the temporal parameters of gait. Conf Proc IEEE Eng Med Biol Soc.
3. Bandodkar AJ, Wang J. Non-invasive wearable electrochemical sensors: a review. 2007;2007:483-486.
Trends Biotechnol. 2014;32:363-371. 32. Lee JM, Kim Y, Welk GJ. Validity of consumer-based physical activity monitors.
4. Boyd LJ, Ball K, Aughey RJ. Quantifying external load in Australian football Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2014;46:1840-1848.
matches and training using accelerometers. Int J Sports Physiol Perform. 33. Loader J, Williams MD, Lorenzen C, Kemp J. Classifying training drills based on
2013;8:44-51. movement demands in Australian football. Int J Sports Sci Coach. 2012;7:57-68.
5. Callaway A, Cobb JE, Jones I. A comparison of video and accelerometer based 34. Lubans DR, Morgan PJ, Callister R, Collins CE. Effects of integrating pedometers,
approaches applied to performance monitoring in swimming. Int J Sports Sci parental materials, and E-mail support within an extracurricular school sport
Coach. 2009;4:139-153. intervention. J Adolesc Health. 2009;44:176-183.
6. Chen KY, Janz KF, Zhu W, Brychta RJ. Redefining the roles of sensors in objective 35. Macera CA, Hootman JM, Sniezek JE. Major public health benefits of physical
physical activity monitoring. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2012;44(suppl 1):S13-S23. activity. Arthritis Rheum. 2003;49:122-128.
7. Crouter SE, Schneider PL, Karabulut M, Bassett DR Jr. Validity of 10 electronic 36. Maffiuletti NA, Gorelick M, Kramers-de Quervain I, et al. Concurrent validity and
pedometers for measuring steps, distance, and energy cost. Med Sci Sports Exerc. intrasession reliability of the IDEEA accelerometry system for the quantification
2003;35:1455-1460. of spatiotemporal gait parameters. Gait Posture. 2008;27:160-163.
8. Davey N, Anderson M, James DA. Validation trial of an accelerometer-based 37. Mathie MJ, Basilakis J, Celler BG. A system for monitoring posture and physical
sensor platform for swimming. Sports Technol. 2008;1:202-207. activity using accelerometers. Conf Proc IEEE Eng Med Biol Soc. 2001;2001:
9. Drenowatz C, Eisenmann JC. Validation of the SenseWear Armband at high 3654-3657.
intensity exercise. Eur J Appl Physiol. 2011;111:883-887. 38. Matthew D, Delextrat A. Heart rate, blood lactate concentration, and time–
10. Duffield R, Reid M, Baker J, Spratford W. Accuracy and reliability of GPS devices motion analysis of female basketball players during competition. J Sports Sci.
for measurement of movement patterns in confined spaces for court-based 2009;27:813-821.
sports. J Sci Med Sport. 2010;13:523-525. 39. McKenzie JE, Osgood DW. Validation of a new telemetric core temperature
11. Eisenmann JC, Strath SJ, Shadrick D, Rigsby P, Hirsch N, Jacobson L. Validity monitor. J Therm Biol. 2004;29:605-611.
of uniaxial accelerometry during activities of daily living in children. Eur J Appl 40. Mineta T, Kobayashi S, Watanabe Y, et al. Three-axis capacitive accelerometer
Physiol. 2004;91:259-263. with uniform axial sensitivities. J Micromech Microeng. 1996;6:431.

4
Downloaded from sph.sagepub.com at UNIV CALIFORNIA SANTA BARBARA on November 24, 2015
vol. XX • no. X SPORTS HEALTH

41. Mooney MG, Hunter JR, O’Brien BJ, Berry HT, Young WB. Reliability and 51. Scheeper P, Gulløv JO, Kofoed LM. A piezoelectric triaxial accelerometer.
validity of a novel intermittent peak running speed test for Australian football. J Micromech Microeng. 1996;6:131-133.
J Strength Cond Res. 2011;25:973-979. 52. Sparling PB, Snow TK, Millard-Stafford ML. Monitoring core temperature during
42. Moran DS, Mendal L. Core temperature measurement. Sports Med. 2002;32: exercise: ingestible sensor vs. rectal thermistor. Aviat Space Environ Med.
879-885. 1993;64:760-763.
43. Morgan-Owen GJ, Johnston GT. Differential GPS positioning. Electr Commun 53. Strath SJ, Swartz AM, Bassett DR Jr, O’Brien WL, King GA, Ainsworth BE.
Eng J. 1995;7:11-21. Evaluation of heart rate as a method for assessing moderate intensity physical
44. Noonan B, Bancroft RW, Dines JS, Bedi A. Heat- and cold-induced injuries in activity. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2000;32(suppl):S465-S470.
athletes: evaluation and management. J Am Acad Orthop Surg. 2012;20:744-754. 54. Terbizan DJ, Dolezal BA, Albano C. Validity of seven commercially available
45. Ohgi Y, Baba T, Sakaguchi I. Measurement of deceleration of golfer’s sway and heart rate monitors. Meas Phys Educ Exerc Sci. 2002;6:243-247.
uncock timing in driver swing motion. Impact Technol Sport. 2005:349-354. 55. Troiano RP, Berrigan D, Dodd KW, Mâsse LC, Tilert T, McDowell M. Physical
46. Pate RR, Freedson PS, Sallis JF, et al. Compliance with physical activity activity in the United States measured by accelerometer. Med Sci Sports Exerc.
guidelines: prevalence in a population of children and youth. Ann Epidemiol. 2008;40:181-188.
2002;12:303-308. 56. Tudor-Locke C. Taking steps toward increased physical activity: using
47. Petersen C, Pyne D, Portus M, Dawson B. Validity and reliability of GPS units pedometers to measure and motivate. President’s Council on Physical Fitness
to monitor cricket-specific movement patterns. Int J Sports Physiol Perform. and Sports Research Digest. 2002;3:1-8.
2009;4:381-393. 57. Tudor-Locke C, Sisson SB, Lee SM, Craig CL, Plotnikoff RC, Bauman A.
48. Portas MD, Harley JA, Barnes CA, Rush CJ. The validity and reliability of 1-Hz Evaluation of quality of commercial pedometers. Can J Public Health.
and 5-Hz global positioning systems for linear, multidirectional, and soccer- 2006;97(suppl 1):S10-5-S10-6.
specific activities. Int J Sports Physiol Perform. 2010;5:448-458. 58. Varley MC, Fairweather IH, Aughey RJ. Validity and reliability of GPS for
49. Rampinini E, Impellizzeri FM, Castagna C, Coutts AJ, Wisløff U. Technical measuring instantaneous velocity during acceleration, deceleration, and constant
performance during soccer matches of the Italian Serie A league: effect of fatigue motion. J Sports Sci. 2012;30:121-127.
and competitive level. J Sci Med Sport. 2009;12:227-233. 59. Wisbey B, Montgomery PG, Pyne DB, Rattray B. Quantifying movement
50. Rowlands AV, Eston RG, Ingledew DK. Relationship between activity levels, demands of AFL football using GPS tracking. J Sci Med Sport. 2010;13:531-536.
aerobic fitness, and body fat in 8- to 10-yr-old children. J Appl Physiol. 60. Wixted AJ, Thiel DV, Hahn AG, Gore CJ, Pyne DB, James DA. Measurement of
1999;86:1428-1435. energy expenditure in elite athletes. IEEE Sens J. 2007;7:481-488.

For reprints and permission queries, please visit SAGE’s Web site at http://www.sagepub.com/journalsPermissions.nav.

5
Downloaded from sph.sagepub.com at UNIV CALIFORNIA SANTA BARBARA on November 24, 2015

You might also like