0DLVRQQHXYH /DURVH

7KH$XWKHQWLFLW\RI3URSKHWLFᏬDG°WK$3VHXGR3UREOHP
$XWKRU V :DHO%+DOODT
6RXUFH6WXGLD,VODPLFD1R  SS
3XEOLVKHGE\0DLVRQQHXYH /DURVH
6WDEOH85/KWWSZZZMVWRURUJVWDEOH
$FFHVVHG87&

5()(5(1&(6
/LQNHGUHIHUHQFHVDUHDYDLODEOHRQ-6725IRUWKLVDUWLFOH
KWWSZZZMVWRURUJVWDEOH"VHT  FLG SGIUHIHUHQFHUHIHUHQFHVBWDEBFRQWHQWV

<RXPD\QHHGWRORJLQWR-6725WRDFFHVVWKHOLQNHGUHIHUHQFHV

Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp

JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content
in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship.
For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.

0DLVRQQHXYH /DURVHis collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to 6WXGLD,VODPLFD

http://www.jstor.org

This content downloaded from 128.59.222.12 on Thu, 26 Mar 2015 01:38:32 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
6WXGLD,VODPLFD

RI3URSKHWLF+DGLWK
7KH$XWKHQWLFLW\
D3VHXGRSUREOHP

,

7KHPRVWFHQWUDOSUREOHPDVVRFLDWHGZLWK3URSKHWLFKDGLWKKDV
XQGRXEWHGO\ EHHQWKHLU DXWKHQWLFLW\7KLVLVVXHRFFXSLHG0XVOLPVSH
VLQFHWKHHDUO\
FLDOLVWV FODVVLFDOSHULRGDQGKDVFRQWLQXHG WRFRPPDQG
WKHLQWHQVHDWWHQWLRQ RIZHVWHUQVFKRODUVVLQFHWKHPLGGOHRIWKHODVW
FHQWXU\ *XVWDY :HLOZDVRQHRIWKHILUVW LIQRWWKHILUVWWRVXJJHVWDV
HDUO\DVWKDWDVXEVWDQWLDO EXONRIWKHKDGLWKVKRXOGEHUHJDUGHG
DV VSXULRXV  ,Q $OR\V6SUHQJHULQHIIHFW DUJXHGWKHVDPH
SRLQW %XWLWZ DV,JQD] *ROG]LKHU ZKR LQDXJXUDWHG WKHFULWLFDO
VWXG\
RIWKHKDGLWK VDXWKHQWLFLW\ &RQFHUQHG Z LWK WKHHDUO\HYROXWLRQ RI,VOD
PLFGRJPDDQGWKHRORJ\ *ROG]LKHU FRQFOXGHGWKDW WKHJUHDW PDMRULW\RI
WKH3URSKHWLF KDGLWKFRQVWLWXWH HYLGHQFHQRWRIWKH3URSKHW VWLPHWR
ZKLFKWKH\ FODLPWREHORQJ EXWUDWKHURIPXFKODWHU SHULRGV *ROG]L
KHU VFULWLFDO WR
DSSURDFK KDGLWK Z DVWDNHQIXUWKHU LQGHHGUHILQHG
DQG
E\-RVHSK 6FKDFKW ZKRLQVLVWHG WKDWLQVRIDU DVOHJDOKDGLWKDUHFRQFHU
QHGWKH\ PXVW EHDVVXPHGILFWLWLRXV XQWLO
WKHFRQWUDU\ LVSURYHQ 
$QHDUOLHU YHUVLRQRIWKLVSDSHUZDVSUHVHQWHG DWDFRQIHUHQFH RQKDGLWKKHOGDWWKH6FKRRORI
2ULHQWDO DQG$IULFDQ6WXGLHV RI/RQGRQ0DUFK,VKRXOGOLNHWRWKDQN
8QLYHUVLW\ WKHSDU
WLFLSDQWVZKRFRPPHQWHG RQP\ SUHVHQWDWLRQQRWDEO\04DVLP=DPDQ/DZUHQFH &RQUDGDQG+DUDOG
0RW]NL
 *HVFKLFKWH GHU&KDOLSKHQYROV0DQQKHLP )ULHGULFK%DVVHUPDQQ  ,,II
 'DV/HEHQXQGGLH/HEUHGHV0RKDPPDGYROV%HUOLQ 1LFKRODLVFKH 9HUODJVEXFKKDQGOXQJ
LGHP2QWKH2ULJLQRI:ULWLQJ
 ,,,O[[YLLFLY 'RZQ+LVWRULFDO UHFRUGVDPRQJWKH0XVXO
PDQV-RXUQDORIWKH$VLDWLF6RFLHW\ RIWKH%HQJDO  
 0XVOLP6WXGLHV HG606WHUQ
WUDQV&5%DUEHU YROV/RQGRQ*HRUJH$OOHQ
DQG606WHUQ
DQG8QZLQ ,,IIII)RUDVXPPDU\ RI*ROG]LKHU V VHH-DPHV
SRVLWLRQ 5REVRQ0XV
OLP7UDGLWLRQ7KH4XHVWLRQRI$XWKHQWLFLW\ 0HPRLUVDQG3URFHHGLQJV 0DQFKHVWHU /LWHUDU\DQG3KL
ORVRSKLFDO6RFLHW\   DWII
  7KH2ULJLQVRI0XKDPPDGDQ-XULVSUXGHQFH2[IRUG&ODUHQGRQ 3UHVV 



This content downloaded from 128.59.222.12 on Thu, 26 Mar 2015 01:38:32 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
 :$(/% +$//$4

6LQFH6FKDFKWSXEOLVKHGKLVPRQXPHQWDO ZRUNLQVFKRODUO\
GLV
FRXUVHRQWKLVPDWWHU 7KUHHFDPSVRIVFKRODUVPD\EH
KDVSUROLIHUDWHG
RQHDWWHPSWLQJ
LGHQWLILHG WRUHFRQILUP KLVFRQFOXVLRQVDQGDWWLPHV
JRLQJEH\RQGWKHPDQRWKHU HQGHDYRXULQJ WRUHIXWH
WKHPDQGDWKLUG
VHHNLQJWRFUHDWHDPLGGOH
SHUKDSVV\QWKHVL]HG SRVLWLRQEHWZHHQWKH
WZR$PRQJRWKHUV -RKQ:DQVEURXJK  DQG0LFKDHO&RRN 
ILUVW
EHORQJWRWKHILUVW
FDPSZKLOH1DELD$EERWW(6H]JLQ&  0$]DPL 
*UHJRU 6FKRHOHU  DQG
-RKDQQ )XLFN  EHORQJWR V
WKH HFRQG+DUDOG
0RW]NL   '6DQWLOODQD   *+-X\QEROO )D]OXU5DKPDQ   DQG
-DPHV5REVRQ   WDNHWKHPLGGOHSRVLWLRQ

'HVSLWHVLJQLILFDQW LQWKHPHWKRGRORJLHV
GLIIHUHQFHV DQGDVVXPSWLRQV
RIWKHVHVFKRODUVHYHQZLWKLQRQHDQGWKHVDPHFDPSDQGGHVSLWHWKH
IDFWWKDWQRWDOORIWKHPGHDOWZLWKWKHSUREOHPRIDXWKHQWLFLW\
IRULWV
RZQVDNH  WKH\DOOVKDUHRQHIXQGDPHQWDO DVVXPSWLRQ WKDW
QDPHO\
 6HHQEHORZ
 4XUDQLF6WXGLHV6RXUFHVDQG0HWKRGVRI6FULSWXUDO ,QWHUSUHWDWLRQ 2[IRUG2[IRUG 8QLYHU
3UHVV 
VLW\
 (DUO\0XVOLP'RJPD$6RXUFH&ULWLFDO 6WXG\&DPEULGJH &DPEULGJH 8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV 
 6WXGLHVLQ$UDELF/LWHUDU\ 3DS\UL,,4XU GQLF&RPPHQWDU\ DQG7UDGLWLRQ&KLFDJR7KH8QL
YHUVLW\RI&KLFDJR3UHVV II
  *HVFKLFKWHGHVDUDELVFKHQ6FKULIWWXPV %DQG,4XU GQZLVVHQVFKDIWHQ +DGLWK*HVFKLFKWH
)LTEK
'RJPDWLN 0\VWLN ELVFD+ /HLGHQ(-  II
%ULOO
 2Q6FKDFKW V2ULJLQV RI0XKDPPDGDQ-XULVSUXGHQFH5L\DGK .LQJ6DXG8QLYHUVLW\  
LGHP6WXGLHVLQ+DGLWK0HWKRGRORJ\ DQG/LWHUDWXUH5HSU,QGLDQDSROLV $PHULFDQ 7UXVW3XEOLFD
WLRQV 
  'LH)UDJHGHUVFKULIWOLFKHQ RGHUPLLQGOLFKHQ 8EHUOHLIHUXQJ GHU:LVVHQVFKDIWHQ LPIULLKHQ
,VODP'HU,VODP  LGHP:HLWHUHV ]XU)UDJHGHUVFKULIWOLFKHQ RGHUPLLQGOLFKHQ
2EHUOLHIHUXQJ GHU:LVVHQVFKDIWHQ LP,VODP 'HU,VODP  LGHP0LLQOLFKH 7KRUDXQG
+DGLWK 8EHUOLHIHUXQJ6FKUHLEHUERW 5HGDNWLRQ 'HU,VODP  LGHP6FKUHLEHQ XQG
9HUEIIHQWOLFKHQ=X9HUZHQGXQJ XQG)XQNWLRQ GHU6FKULIW LQGHQHUVWHQLVODPLVFKHQ -DKUKXQGHUWHQ
'HU,VODP  
  'LH5ROOHGHV7UDGLWLRQDOLVPXV LP,VODP=HLWVFKULIW GHU'HXWVFKHQ0RUJHQOGQGLVFKHQ
   )RUDVXPPDU\
*HVHOOVFKDIW RI)LLFN V
SRVLWLRQ VHH5REVRQ0XVOLP 7UDGLWLRQ 
 'LH$QIGQJH GHULVODPLVFKHQ -XULVSUXGHQ] ,EKUH(QWZLFNOXQJ LQ0HNNDELV]XU0LWWHGHV

-DKUKXQGHUWV 6WXWWJDUW )UDQ] 6WHLQHU LGHP4XRYDGLV+DGLWK)RUVFKXQJ (LQHNULWLVFKH
8QWHUVXFKXQJ YRQ*+$ -X\QEROO 1IIL W KHPDZOGRI,EQ8PDUDQGKLVSRVLWLRQLQ0XVOLP +DGLWK
/LWHUDWXUH'HU
 ,VODP  LGHP7KH0XVDQQDIRI $EGDO5D]]$T DODQLQLDVD6RXUFH
RI$XWKHQWLF$KGGLWK RIWKH)LUVW&HQWXU\ $+-RXUQDORI1HDU(DVWHUQ6WXGLHV   
LGHP'HU)LTKGHV=XKUL 'LH4XHOOHQSUREOHPDWLN 'HU,VODP   
 )RU6DQWLOODQD VSRVLWLRQ VHH5REVRQ0XVOLP 7UDGLWLRQ
  0XVOLP7UDGLWLRQ 6WXGLHVLQ&KURQRORJ\ 3URYHQDQFHDQG $XWKRUVKLSRI(DUO\+DGLWK
&DPEULGJH &DPEULGJH 8QLYHUVLW\ 3UHVV 
 ,VODP &KLFDJRDQG/RQGRQ8QLYHUVLW\ RI&KLFDJR3UHVV IILGHP,VODPLF0HWKR
GRORJ\LQ+LVWRU\.DUDFKL&HQWUDO ,QVWLWXWHRI,VODPLF5HVHDUFK  
 0XVOLP 7UDGLWLRQ LGHP7UDGLWLRQ ,QYHVWLJDWLRQ DQG&ODVVLILFDWLRQ
0XVOLP:RUOG
  LGHP7KHLVQGGLQ0XVOLP 7UDGLWLRQ7UDQVDFWLRQVRIWKH*ODVJRZ8QLYHUVLW\
2ULHQWDO6RFLHW\  
 $GPLWWHGO\ DQXPEHU RIKLVWRULDQV VXEMHFWHGKDGLWKWRWKHVDPHKLVWRULRJUDSKLFDO DSSDUDWXV
WKH\DSSOLHGWRRWKHU W\SHVRIKLVWRULFDOQDUUDWLYH WKXVFLUFXPYHQWLQJ WKHLVVXHRIDXWKHQWLFLW\DOWRJH
WKHU LQ
$OWKRXJK SUDFWLFDO WHUPV WKHLUDSSURDFK LVWKH WKH
GHVLGHUDWXP SUREOHP UHPDLQVWKHRUHWLFDOO\
DQGHSLVWHPRORJLFDOO\ XQVROYHG



This content downloaded from 128.59.222.12 on Thu, 26 Mar 2015 01:38:32 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
 7+($87+(17,&,7<
2)3523+(7,& $36(8'2352%/(0
+$',7+

WKHHDUO\DQGPHGLHYDO 0XVOLP VFKRODUVHVSRXVHGWKHYLHZWKDW WKH3UR

SKHWLFKDGLWKOLWHUDWXUH LVVXEVWDQWLDOO\
JHQXLQHDQGWKDWGHVSLWHWKH
UHODWLYHO\ODUJHVFDOHIRUJHU\ WKDW
WRRNSODFHLQWKHHDUO\SHULRGWKHOLWH
UDWXUHDWOHDVWDVLWFDPHWREHFRQVWLWXWHG LQWKHVL[VRFDOOHG FDQRQLFDO
FROOHFWLRQVKDVEHHQVXFFHVVIXOO\ VDOYDJHGDQGILQDOO\ SURYHQWREH
DXWKHQWLF ,WLVRQO\DJDLQVWWKLV
EDFNGURS RIWUDGLWLRQDO
UHOLJLRXVDVVXPS
WLRQVWKDW WKHPRGHUQ FRQWURYHUV\ FDQ PDNH DQ\VHQVH)RULIWKHPDLQV
WUHDP WUDGLWLRQDO VFKRODUVKLS ZDVSHUFHLYHG QRWWRKDYHPDGHFODLPVIRU
WKHDXWKHQWLFLW\ RIKDGLWKWKHUHZRXOGEHOLWWOH LIDQ\WKLQJ WRDUJXH
DJDLQVW,QIDFW LIWKHVHZHUHQRWWKHSHUFHLYHGWUDGLWLRQDO FODLPVWKHUH
ZRXOGKDYHEHHQQRFRQWURYHUV\ WREHJLQZLWKVLQFHWKHLVVXHZRXOG
LQQRZD\SRVHDSUREOHP
2QHZRXOGH[SHFWWKDW EHIRUHDQ\LQNKDGEHHQVSLOWLQFRPPHQWLQJ
RQWKHSUREOHPRIDXWKHQWLFLW\ LWZRXOG KDYHEHHQ DIXQGDPHQWDO
UHTXLUHPHQW ILUVW WRGHILQHWKHWUDGLWLRQDO 0XVOLPSRVLWLRQZLWKUHJDUG
WRWKLVVSHFLILF TXHVWLRQ ,I
P DLQVWUHDP 0XVOLP VFKRODUVKLS FRQVLGHUHG
WKHKDGLWKOLWHUDWXUH WREHDWUXHUHSUHVHQWDWLRQ RIWKHDFWXDOZRUGVRI
WKH3URSKHW WKHQE\ZKDWHSLVWHPRORJLFDO \DUGVWLFNGLGWKH\PHDVXUH
WKHYHUDFLW\ RIWKDWOLWHUDWXUH" )XUWKHUPRUH ZHVKRXOGKDYHDVNHG
EHIRUH*ROG]LKHU 6FKDFKWDQGWKHLUOLNHEHJDQWRH[SHQGVRPXFK
VFKRODUO\ LQ
HQHUJ\ WUHDWLQJ WKHPDWWHU KRZWKHWUDGLWLRQDO 0XVOLPFUL
IRU
WHULD WKH
MXGJLQJ DXWKHQWLFLW\ RI
W KH
K DGLWE ZLWK
WDOO\ RU
P RUH
LPSRU
WDQWO\
HSLVWHPRORJLFDOO\ GLIIHU
IURP RXUPRGHUQFULWLFDO DQGVFKRODUO\
FULWHULD,QWKLVVKRUW ,DUJXHWKDW
HVVD\ WKHVFKRODUO\
RXWSXWFRQFHUQHG
ZLWKDXWKHQWLFLW\ VLQFH:HLOUDLVHGWKHLVVXHDFHQWXU\ DQGDKDOIDJRLV
ODUJHO\LI
Q RWWRWDOO\
SRLQWOHVV

,KDYHQRQHZHYLGHQFHWRDGGWRWKHPDVVLYHUHSHUWRLUH RIH[LVWLQJ
PDWHULDODQGQRWKLQJ LQP\PHWKRGRORJ\ KHUHLVXQFRQYHQWLRQDO ,Q
,VKDOOLQVRIDU
IDFW DVDQDXWKRU FDQPLQLPL]H WKHGLYLGHEHWZHHQKLV
VRXUFHVDQGKLVUHDGHUOHWWKHWUDGLWLRQDO
SRVLWLRQVSHDNIRU 2QFH
LWVHOI
WKDWSRVLWLRQLVFODULILHG
DQGGHILQHG ZHZLOOEHDEOHWRFRQFOXGHWKDW
WUDGLWLRQDO
0XVOLP VFKRODUVKDYHDOUHDG\VROYHGWKHSUREOHPIRU XVDQG
WKDWZHKDYHQHHGOHVVO\ H[SHQGHGPXFKVFKRODUO\ HIIRUWEHFDXVHZH
KDYHQRWOLVWHQHG WRZKDWWKHVHVFKRODUV
FDUHIXOO\ KDYHIRUVRORQJEHHQ
XV
WHOOLQJ

 7KHVHFRQGDU\ OLWHUDWXUHGHDOLQJZLWKWKHSUREOHPRIDXWKHQWLFLW\ LVPDVVLYH

DQGWKHFRQWUL
EXWRUVWRWKHGHEDWHPHQWLRQHG LQQQDUHRQO\DPRQJWKHPRVWREYLRXV,QWKHZHVWWKHUHDUH
RWKHUV
VHYHUDO ZKRZURWHRQWKHSUREOHP ZRUOGWKHOLVWRIFRQWULEXWRUV
LQWKH0XVOLP WRWKLVVXEMHFW
DQGFULWLFV  FDQQRWEHH[KDXVWHG
RIWKH2ULHQWDOLVWVILQGLQJV 2QDGGLWLRQDO FRQWULEXWRUVWRWKHGHEDWH
VHH-DPHV5REVRQ+DGLWK(QF\FORSHGLDRI,VODP1HZ(GLWLRQ ,,, /HLGHQ(-  
%ULOO



This content downloaded from 128.59.222.12 on Thu, 26 Mar 2015 01:38:32 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
 :$(/
%+$//$4

,,

7KHHYLGHQFHRIP\DUJXPHQW LVGHULYHG IURP DIDPLOLDUILHOGRI,VOD

PLFWUDGLWLRQDO GLVFRXUVHD ILHOGWKDWKDVHVFDSHG WKHDWWHQWLRQ RI
PRGHUQ KDGLWKVFKRODUVKLS 7KLVLVOHJDOPHWKRGRORJ\ SURSHUO\ NQRZQ
DV DOILTK,QWKLVPHWKRGRORJ\ 3URSKHWLF KDGLWKLVWUHDWHGIURP D
XVO RISHUVSHFWLYHV
QXPEHU EXWZKDW FRQFHUQV XVKHUH LVWKHSHUVSHFWLYH
RIHSLVWHPRORJ\ ZKLFKVHHNVWRRUGHU WKHW\SHV RIKDGLWKRQDVSHFWUXP
WKDWUDQJHV IURP WKHGXELRXVWRWKHFHUWDLQ E\ZD\RIWKHFHQWUDO FDWH
JRU\RIWKHSUREDEOH6HWWLQJ IRUREYLRXVUHDVRQVWKHGXELRXVDVLGH
OHJDOPHWKRGRORJ\ DFNQRZOHGJHV WZRFDWHJRULHV NEDEDUDOZGDKLG RU
WKHDAKGG DQGWKH
 PXWDZDWLU  %HFDXVHRIWKHPRGDOLWLHV WKURXJK
ZKLFKWKH\ DUHWUDQVPLWWHG WKHFRQWHQWV RIWKHIRUPHU DUHNQRZQRQO\
ZLWKSUREDELOLW\ WKHODWWHUZLWKFHUWDLQW\  
,QWKHIROORZLQJ SDUDJUDSKV ZHVKDOOGHILQHWKHWZRFDWHJRULHVLQ
WHUPV RIHSLVWHPRORJ\ ,WLVDFXULRVLW\RIOHJDOPHWKRGRORJ\ DFXULR
ZKRVHH[SODQDWLRQ
VLW\ LVLUUHOHYDQW WKDW
KHUH WKHGKGGLVGHILQHG
LQ
WHUPVRIWKHPXWDZGWLU WKDW
LVWKHDKLGGFDQEHLGHQWLILHGDQGNQRZQ
RQO\LQWHUPVRIZKDWWKHPXWDZDWLULVQRW  ,IWKLVLVWKHFDVHWKHQ
ZKDWLVWKHPXWDZDWLU" 7KHFRPPRQ DQGLQGHHGLQGLVSXWDEOHGHILQL
WLRQRIWKLV RIKDGLWKLVWKDW
W\SH LWLVDQ\UHSRUWWKDW
UHDFKHVXVWKURXJK
WH[WXDOO\LGHQWLFDO  FKDQQHOVRIWUDQVPLVVLRQ ZKLFKDUHVXIILFLHQWO\
QXPHURXV DVWRSUHFOXGHDQ\SRVVLELOLW\ RIFROODERUDWLRQ
RQDIRUJHU\
7KHSHUVRQVZKRZLWQHVVHGWKH3URSKHWVD\LQJ RUGRLQJDSDUWLFXODU
RUPHUHO\
WKLQJ DQDFWRUHYHQW
DSSURYLQJ KDGWRKDYH
WDFLWO\ EHHQVXUH
RIZKDWWKH\REVHUYHGDQGWKHLUNQRZOHGJHRIZKDWWKH\ZLWQHVVHG
PXVW
KDYHEHHQEDVHGRQVHQVRU\ PDKVDV   )RUWKH
SHUFHSWLRQ

 2QHMXULVW IRULQVWDQFHVWDWHG WKHPDWWHULQXQHTXLYRFDOWHUPV 5HSRUWV DUHHLWKHUWDZGWXU

RUG2LDG7KHUHLVQRWKLUGFDWHJRU\ DODNKEGULPPGWDZGWXU DZ LGDG,W ODKXPG 6HH
$KPDGE4LVLPDO $EELGLDO6KDUOW DO.DELU DOG DO:DUDTDIW WKGWOLWKD
HG6D\\LG$EGDO $]L]DQG $EG
$OOLK5DEL YROV0DGLQD" 0X DVVDVDW 4XUWXED  ,,$QRWKHU MXULVWQRWHGWKDWWKHUHLV
QRPLGGOHFDWHJRU\ EHWZHHQWKHWZR6HH0XKDPPDG $PLQ$PLU %LGLVK$K 7D\VLU 6KDUKO
DOG.LWGEDO7DKULU YROV0HFFD'$U DO%L] ,,, DO7DKULU
  $OLE$PU ,EQDO4DVVLUDO0XTDGGLPDIWDO8VDOHG0XKDPPDG %HLUXW'LU
DO*KDUE  
DO,VOLPL 6XOD\PPQL
 0XKDPPDG E $OLDO7DKLQDZL .DVKVKGI,VWLOGOGW DO)XQILQYROV &DOFXWWD:1/HHGV 
3UHVV ,,
 0HDQLQJ WKDWDOOLQVWDQFHVRIWUDQVPLVVLRQPXVW EHLGHQWLFDOLQWKHLU
ODQJXDJHODI +HQFHWKH
QDPHDOWDZGWXU DOODIWL ZKLFKLVJLYHQWRWKLVW\SHRIKDGLWKLQRUGHUWRGLVWLQJXLVK LWIURPDOWDZG
WXUDOPDQDZL WREHGLVFXVVHGEHORZ 
 6KLK$E DO'LQDO4DULIL6KDUKO7DQTLK HG7LKD $EG
DO)XVOIL O,NKWLVGU DO8\WLO
DO0DKVDOILE
6D G &DLUR0DNWDEDW
DO5D ILI DO.XOOL\\$WDO$]KDUL\\D 0XKDPPDG DO+XVD\QDO)DUU$ 
DO
%DJKG$GL DO 8GGD IW8VaUO DO)LTEHG$KPDGDO0XELUDNL  YROV %HLUXW0X DVVDVDWDO5LVLOD
 ,,,:%+DOODT2Q,QGXFWLYH &RUURERUDWLRQ 3UREDELOLW\DQG&HUWDLQW\ LQ6XQQL
/HJDO7KRXJKW LQ1LFKRODV+HHUHG,VODPLF/DZ XULVSUXGHQFH 6WXGLHVLQ+RQRURI)DUEDW-
=LDGHE 6HDWWOHDQG/RQGRQ8QLYHUVLW\ DQG
RI:DVKLQJWRQ 3UHVV II
%HUQDUG :HLVV.QRZOHGJH
RIWKH3DVW7KH7KHRU\ RI7DZGQWXU $FFRUGLQJ WR*KD]LOL  II



This content downloaded from 128.59.222.12 on Thu, 26 Mar 2015 01:38:32 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
 2)3523+(7,&+$',7+$36(8'2352%/(0
7+($87+(17,&,7<

KDGLWKWRDWWDLQ
WKHOHYHORIFHUWDLQW\
WKHVHFRQGLWLRQV PXVW
REWDLQDWDOO
IURP
VWDJHVRIWUDQVPLVVLRQ WLHUWRWKHODVW 
WKHILUVW
$JUHDW RI0XVOLP
PDMRULW\ WKHRUHWLFLDQV
OHJDO HVSRXVHG
WKHYLHZWKDW
WKHPXWDZDWLU
\LHOGVQHFHVVDU\ XVDOL\\DQ
RULPPHGLDWH 
NQRZOHGJH
ZKHUHDV
GDUWUW  DPLQRULW\ WKDW
WKRXJKW WKHLQIRUPDWLRQ
FRQWDLQHG
LQ
FDQEHNQRZQ
VXFKUHSRUWV PHGLDWH
WKURXJK RUDFTXLUHG
NQRZOHGJH
PXNWDVDERUQD]DUL    ,QFRQWUDGLVWLQFWLRQ
WRPHGLDWHNQRZOHGJH
ZKHUH
E\GHILQLWLRQ
LQIHUHQFH
LVWKHPHDQV
RILWVDFTXLVLWLRQ
QHFHVVDU\
NQRZOHGJH LVQHLWKHULQIHUUHGQRUGRHVLWDOORZIRUDQ\PHQWDO
RULQWHO
OHFWXDOUHIOHFWLRQ
,WLVGLUHFWO\
LPSRVHGXSRQ WKHLQWHOOHFW
ZLWKRXWDQ\
DZDUHQHVVRIWKHSURFHVVWKURXJK ZKLFKNQRZOHGJHREWDLQHGLQWKH
 DSHUVRQ
PLQG :KHQ KHDUV
DKDGLWK
QDUUDWHG
E\RQHWUDQVPLWWHU
KH
LVSUHVXPHGWRKDYHJDLQHGRQO\SUREDEOHNQRZOHGJHRILWVFRQWHQWV
DQGWKXVRILWVDXWKHQWLFLW\
7RUHDFKFRQFOXVLYH WKHKDGLWK
NQRZOHGJH
EHKHDUG
PXVW E\WKLV DVXIILFLHQW
SHUVRQ RIWLPHV
QXPEHU DQGHDFK
WLPHLWPXVWEHQDUUDWHGE\DGLIIHUHQWWUDQVPLWWHU
)RXURUIHZHULQV
VXFKDKDGLWKZHUHGHHPHGLQVXIILFLHQW
WDQFHVRIKHDULQJ WRFRQVWLWXWH
DWDZGWXU VLQFHWKHMXULVWV
WUDQVPLVVLRQ WKHTGDGL
DUJXHG LQDFRXUWRI
ODZPXVWGHOLEHUDWH
RQWKHWHVWLPRQ\RIIRXUZLWQHVVHVDVZHOODVLQYHV
WKHLU
WLJDWH PRUDO
UHFWLWXGHEHIRUH
 KHUHQGHUVKLVYHUGLFW
7KLVSURFHVV
RIGHOLEHUDWLRQ
DQGUHIOHFWLRQSUHFOXGHV WKH RILPPHGLDWH
SRVVLELOLW\
NQRZOHGJHREWDLQLQJEHLWLQWKHFDVHRIFRXUWURRP ZLWQHVVHVRURI
KDGLWKWUDQVPLVVLRQ 

6RPHVFKRODUV IL[HGWKHPLQLPXP QXPEHU RIWUDQVPLVVLRQV \LHOGLQJ

WDZDWXUDWILYH
ZKLOHRWKHUVVHWWKHPYDULDEO\
DWRU
HDFKQXPEHUEHLQJMXVWLILHG E\D 4XUDQLFYHUVHRUVRPH UHOLJLRXV
DFFRXQW  7KHLQDELOLW\
WRGHWHUPLQHRQUDWLRQDO
JURXQGV WKHPLQL
PXPQXPEHU RIWUDQVPLVVLRQV OHG0XVOLP
UHTXLUHG EDFNWRWKH
MXULVWV

 4DULIL 6KDUOL0XKDPPDG DO,]PLUL

0LU GWDO8VOILIOVKDUK0LUTGWDO:XVDO YROV
,VWDQEXO QS ,,:HLVV.QRZOHGJH RIWKH3DVW
  $EELGL DO6EDUK DO.DEWIU,,$EL%DNU $KPDG ,EQ6DKODO6DUDNKVL
DO0XKDUUDUIL 8VDO
DO)LTK HG6DOLKE 8ZD\GDYROV%HLUXW 'LUDO.XWXE DO ,OPL\\D
  ,I
  :%+DOODT$+LVWRU\RI,VODPLF/HJDO7KHRULHV&DPEULGJH &DPEULGJH 8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
 II 7KHLPPHGLDWH NQRZOHGJH ZKLFKWKHWDZGWXUHQJHQGHUV LQWKHLQWHOOHFW
HOLPLQDWHVDQ\
SRVVLELOLW\ RILQIHUHQFH EHFDXVHWKHPDKVLWV WKHRULJLQDO3URSKHWLF HYHQWGHHGVZRUGVWDFLWDSSUR
YDOHWF SHUFHLYHGE\WKHVHQVHVDUHGLUHFWO\ FRQQHFWHGZLWKWKHFRPSUHKHQVLRQ DQGVHQVHSHUFHS
WLRQRIWKHKHDUHU 7KXVZKHQRQHKHDUVDPXWDZGWLU QXPEHU RILGHQWLFDOKDGILWKVWUDQVPLWWHGWKH
NQRZOHGJHWKDWDFFXPXODWHV WKHUHIURP LVVDLGWRFDUU\ZLWKLWWKHDFWXDORULJLQDO H[SHULHQFHDVLILW
ZHUHWKHGLUHFW H[SHULHQFHRIWKHKHDUHUKLPVHOI 6HH$EIL ,VKLTDO6KLUL]LDO7DEVLUDIL8VWDO)LTK
HG0+DVDQ+D\WIL 'DPDVFXV'LUDO)LNU  
 $EIL %DNU DO%ITLOOLQL
7DPKLG HG5-
0F&DUWK\ %HLUXW /LEUDULHRULHQWDOH 4DULIL
6KDUK)DUU  8GGD,,,6D\I DO'LQDOL$PLGLDOOKNGP IW84\ODO$KNGP YROV &DLUR

D W
0DWED  $OL6XED\K ,
 $PLGL ,KNGP ,,PLPDO+DUDPD\Q DO-XZD\QLDO%XUKGQ HG $EGDO$]LP'LEYROV
&DLUR'LUDO$QV$U   ,)DUU  8GGD,,,



This content downloaded from 128.59.222.12 on Thu, 26 Mar 2015 01:38:32 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
 :$(/
%+$//$4

LQWHOOHFWRIWKHKHDUHU
DVWKHSRLQWRIUHIHUHQFH
IRUPHDVXULQJ WKHQXP
EHURIKDGLWKV WRFRQFOXVLYH
OHDGLQJ LPPHGLDWHNQRZOHGJH ,WWXUQV
RXW
WKDWLWLVWKHPRPHQW DWZKLFKDSHUVRQUHDOL]HVWKDWKHLVFRPSOHWHO\
RIWKH
FHUWDLQ RIDUHSRUWHG
FRQWHQWV ZKLFK
KDGLWK GHWHUPLQHV
WKH
QXP
EHURIWUDQVPLVVLRQV
UHTXLUHGIRU
WKDW LQVWDQFH
SDUWLFXODU RIWUDQVPLV
VLRQQRWWKHRWKHUZD\URXQGWKHQXPEHU PD\EHGHFLGHGRQO\ZKHQ
LPPHGLDWH DQGFRQFOXVLYH NQRZOHGJH KDVEHHQUHDFKHG 
1RZWKHNKDEDUDOGKDGG LVVLPSO\GHILQHG
DVDQ\KDGLWKZKLFKIDOOV
VKRUWRIPHHWLQJWKHUHTXLUHPHQWV RIWKHPXWDZGWLU  ,WPD\EHVROL
WKURXJKRXW
WDU\ DOOWLHUV
RILWVWUDQVPLVVLRQ
EXWLWPD\EHJLQDVDQLGKGG
DQGODWHU
DFTXLUHDGGHGFKDQQHOV RIWUDQVPLVVLRQ,IWKHWRWDOQXPEHU
RI
FKDQQHOV DWDQ\
EHFRPHV WLHU IRXU
WKUHH RUHYHQILYH
DQGFRQWLQXHV
WR
EH WUDQVPLWWHGWKURXJK DQ\SDUWLFXODU QXPEHURIFKDQQHOVWKHQLW
EHFRPHVNQRZQDV RQWKHRWKHUKDQGWKHFKDQQHOV
  ,I
PXOWLSO\IXUWKHUVRDVWRUHDFK
PXVWDILG DWDZGWXUQXPEHU WKHQLWEHFRPHV
NQRZQDVPDVKKEU   $QXPEHU RIVFKRODUVHVSRXVHGWKHYLHZWKDW
WKHPDVKKEAUDQGWKHPXVWDILG DUHLGHQWLFDOLQWKHVHQVHWKDWWKH\DUH
WZRLQWHUFKDQJHDEOH QDPHVIRUDQ\KDGLWKWKDWEHJLQVDVDQDKGGDQG
ODWHUDFTXLUHVDGGHGFKDQQHOVRIWUDQVPLVVLRQ   6RPH +,DQDILWHV
DUJXHGWKDWWKHPDVKKXAU \LHOGVDFTXLUHGNQRZOHGJH EXWWKHJHQHUDO
YLHZVHHPVWRKDYHEHHQWKDW VLQFHDOOWKHVHW\SHV RULJLQDWHG DVGKGGV
WKH\HQJHQGHURQO\SUREDEOHNQRZOHGJH  ,QDQ\HYHQW QRKDGLWKRI
WKHKGGFDWHJRU\ FDQE\LWVHOIUHDFKWKHOHYHORIWDZDWXUKRZHYHU
PDQ\ FKDQQHOVRIWUDQVPLVVLRQLWPD\ODWHU DFTXLUH

3UREDEO\VRPHWLPHGXULQJ WKHIRXUWKWHQWK
FHQWXU\EXWFHUWDLQO\ QRW
EHIRUHWKHPLGGOHRIWKHWKLUGQLQWK
DQHZFDWHJRU\RIKDGLWKZDV
LQWURGXFHG
7KLVFDWHJRU\DFTXLUHGWKHQDPHDOWDZGWXU DOPD QDZL
DQGZHKDYHHYHU\
UHDVRQWREHOLHYHWKDW
LWZDVFUHDWHGLQRUGHUWRVROYH
ZKDWZDVFRQVLGHUHGWREHDIRUPLGDEOH
SUREOHP UHJDUGLQJ LVVXHRI
WKH

 )DUU  8GGD,,,4DULIL 6KDUK 0XZDIIDTDO'LQ ,EQ4XGLPD5DZaGDW DO1G]LUZD

-XQQDWDO0XQGLU HG6D\I
DO'LQDO.LWLE%HLUXW 'LUDO.LWLE
DO $
 UDEL
  )DNKUDO'LQ
DO5L]L/XEDEDO,VKEUGW&DLUR0DWED DWDO6DLGD 
,WLVWREHQRWHGWKDWWKHGHWHUPLQDWLRQ RIWKHPXWDZDWLU ZDVQRWLQUHDOLW\
DVVXEMHFWLYH DPDW
WHUDVOHJDOWKHRU\ PDNHVWREH7KHFRPPXQLW\ RIMXULVWV
DQGWUDGLWLRQLVWVGLGDJUHHLQWKHJUHDW
PDMR
ULW\RIFDVHVRQZKLFKKDGLWKVZHUHPXWDZDWLUDQGZKLFKZHUHQRW
 7DKDQDZL .DVKVKGI,,
  $EELGLDO6KDUKW DO.DELU ,,
 7KHMXULVWV GLIIHUHG
RQWKHGHWDLOVRIVXFKFODVVLILFDWLRQV6HH$PLU %LGLVKLK7D\VLU,,,,W
LVWREHQRWHGWKDW VRPHKDGLWKV RIWKHPDVKKEEU W\SHDUHFRQVLGHUHG VSXULRXVE\WKHWUDGLWLRQLVWV
,EQ
REVHUYHVWKDW
DO6DODLK WKHUHDUHKDGLWKVRIWKLVW\SHWKDWDUHDWWULEXWHG WRWKH0HVVHQJHU RI*RGDQG
FLUFXODWH LQWKHPDUNHWSODFH EXWZKLFKDUHILFWLWLRXV ZDKXQGNDDOKGLWKPDVKEKWUD WDGWOUXDQ
5DVWO$OOGK ILDODVZGTOD\VDODEGK DVL 6HHKLV0XTDGGLPDW,EQDO6DOGKZD0DKDVLQDOO,VWLOGK HG
$ LVKD$EGDO5DKPLQ &DLUR'DUDO0D$ULI
  
  $EEGLG DO6KDUKDO.DELU ,,
 $PLU %LGLVKLK7D\VLF,,,



This content downloaded from 128.59.222.12 on Thu, 26 Mar 2015 01:38:32 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
 7+( $87+(17,&,7< 2) +$',7+ $36(8'2352%/(0
)3523+(7,&

WKHDXWKRULWDWLYHQHVV RIFRQVHQVXVKXMML\\DW PD   'HVSLWHWKH

DOLP
OLPLWHG XVHRIWKLVW\SH RIWDZDWXULWEHFDPHQRQHWKHOHVV DZLGHO\UHFR
JQL]HGFDWHJRU\ VWDQGLQJ RQHTXDOIRRWLQJ ZLWKWKHUHJXODU PXWDZGWLU
WHFKQLFDOO\ NQRZQ DVWDZDWXU ODI]L  DQGWKH 7KLVODWWHU W\SH
HQJHQGHUV LQWHUPV RIWKH3UREDELOLW\ 7KHRU\LQPDWKHPDWLFV
KD(G DGHJUHH
RISUREDELOLW\ LQH[FHVVRI FHUWDLQW\ EHLQJ 1RZZKHQWZR
DKDGLKDGLWKVUHOD\HGE\GLIIHUHQW WUDQVPLWWHUV VXSSRUWD SDUWLFXODU
SRLQWRUWKHPH PD QD  WKHLUSUREDELOLW\ WRJHWKHU LQFUHDVHV,IZH
DVVXPHWKDW WZRGKDGLKDGLWKV SRVVHVV LQ FRPPRQ D JLYHQWKHPH DQG
WKHSUREDELOLW\ RIHDFKKDGLWKEHLQJWUXHLVVD\WKHQWKHDJJUH
JDWHSUREDELOLW\ RIWKHLU EHLQJWUXHLVLQFUHDVHGWRDGHJUHHKLJKHU WKDQ
EXWVWLOOVLJQLILFDQWO\ ORZHUWKDQ:KHQDJUHDWHU QXPEHURI
VXFKKDGLWKV DOOEHLQJWH[WXDOO\ GLIIHUHQW DQGDOOKDYLQJLQGHSHQGHQW
FKDQQHOVRIWUDQVPLVVLRQ SRVVHVV LQFRPPRQWKHVDPH WKHPHWKH
NQRZOHGJHRIWKLVWKHPHLQFUHDVHVXQWLOLWILQDOO\ OHDGVWRD GHJUHH
ZKHUHLWEHFRPHVERWKLPPHGLDWH DQGFRQFOXVLYH 
1RZEHIRUH GLVFXVVLQJ WKHHSLVWHPLF YDOXHRIWKHWKUHHW\SHVRXWOL
QHGKHUHZHVKDOOGRZHOOWRDVVHVVRXURZQHSLVWHPLFFULWHULD IRU
DFFHSWLQJKLVWRULFDO QDUUDWLYH VLQFHDIWHU DOOWKHLVVXHDWVWDNHLVZKH
WKHURUQRWZHFDQWDNHWKHKDGLWKOLWHUDWXUH WREHDWUXHUHSUHVHQWDWLRQ
RIZKDWWKH3URSKHW KDGDFWXDOO\ VDLGRUGRQH:HKDYHDOUHDG\ VDLGWKDW
LIZKDW:HLO*ROG]LKHU 6FKDFKWDQGWKHLULONKDYHDUJXHGDJDLQVWWKH
KDGLWK VDXWKHQWLFLW\ LVWRPDNHDQ\VHQVHLWPXVWEHWDNHQIRU JUDQWHG
WKDWZKDWWKH\KDYHDVVXPHG0XVOLP VFKRODUVWRVD\LVWKDWWKHKDGLWK
LVDXWKHQWLFQDPHO\ WKDW DVDZKROHLWUHSUHVHQWV ZKDWWKH3URSKHW VDLG
RUGLGZLWKFHUWDLQW\ ,WLVLQFRQFHLYDEOH WKDWWKHVH2ULHQWDOLVWV ZRXOG
KDYHPDGHVXFKGUDVWLF DVVHUWLRQV KDGWKH\ XQGHUVWRRG WUDGLWLRQDO 0XV
OLPVFKRODUVWRDVVHUWWKHYHUDFLW\ RIWKHKDGLWKPHUHO\ LQSUREDELOLVWLF
WHUPV ,IRU
RQHGRQRWEHOLHYHWKDW *ROG]LKHU IRU
LQVWDQFH ZRXOGKDYH
UDLVHGVXFKDIXVV RYHUWKHUHOLDELOLW\ RIWKHKDGWKE DVDKLVWRULFDO VRXUFH
KDGKHXQGHUVWRRGWKHWUDGLWLRQDO VFKRODUVWRDFNQRZOHGJHWKDWWKH
KDGLWK V YHUDFLW\ FDQQRW EHNQRZQDSRGLFWLFDOO\ DQGWKDW LWVDXWKHQWLFLW\
FDQEHDVVHUWHG RQO\LQSUREDELOLVWLF WHUPV
,QPRVWLQVWDQFHV LQYROYLQJ WKHVWXG\ RILQGLYLGXDO KDGLWKVWKHWRWDO
QXPEHULQJ LQWKHWHQVRIWKRXVDQGV LW  LVIUHTXHQWO\ GLIILFXOW WRHVWDEOLVK
WKDWDSDUWLFXODU KDGLWKUHSUHVHQWV DODWHU IDEULFDWLRQ %XWLIZHDUHDEOH
WRFDVWVHULRXV RUHYHQVRPHGRXEWDERXWDKDGLWK VDXWKHQWLFLW\ WKHQ
DVFDUHIXOKLVWRULDQV ZKLFK,KRSHZHDUHZHVKRXOGHLWKHU GLVPLVV
LWHQWLUHO\RULILWLVRQO\PLOGO\ SUREOHPDWLF XVHLWLQDFLUFXPVFULEHG

 2QWKLVVHH:DHO%+DOODT7KH$XWKRULWDWLYHQHVV RI6XQQL&RQVHQVXV
,QWHUQDWLRQDO -RXU
QDORI0LGGOHHDVW6WXGLHV  
,ONGP,$ELa
  NPLGL DO:DOLG
E.KDODI DO+LMGMHG
DO0LQKDMIL7DUWLE
DO%LML DO
$EG
0DMLG7XUNL3DULV3DXO*HXWKQHU +DOODT,QGXFWLYH II
&RUURERUDWLRQ



This content downloaded from 128.59.222.12 on Thu, 26 Mar 2015 01:38:32 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
 :$(/% +$//$4

PDQQHU ZLWKWKHIXOO NQRZOHGJH DQGDZDUHQHVV WKDWLWFDQQRWFRQVWLWXWH

DUHOLDEOH VRXUFH,QHLWKHU FDVH LW
L VQRWWREHWUXVWHG :HWUXVW RQO\D
KLVWRULFDO QDUUDWLYH WKDWZHEHOLHYHZLWKDVVXUDQFHWRKDYHRULJLQDWHG
ZLWKWKHHYHQWLWVHOI DQGHYHQWKHQ ZHPXVW JXDUGDJDLQVW LGHRORJLFDO
ELDVHVDVZHOODVDYDULHW\ RIRWKHU SRWHQWLDO SUREOHPV
,QWHUPV RIWKH3UREDELOLW\ 7KHRU\ DQ\QDUUDWLYH WKDWZHWKLQN WREH
HTXDO WRRU OHVV LVWREH LPPHGLDWHO\ GLVPLVVHG &RPSDUH WKLVIRU
LQVWDQFH ZLWKWKHFDVHRIDKXPDQELUWK ZKHUHWKHSUREDELOLW\ RIWKH
LQIDQW EHLQJDJLUO LVVLQFHWKHUHPDLQLQJ LVDVVLJQHGWRWKHSUR
EDELOLW\ RILWVEHLQJD ER\,IWKHSUREDELOLW\ RID KDGLWKEHLQJWUXH
DXWKHQWLF LVRQO\PDUJLQDOO\ KLJKHUE\RUHYHQPRGHUDWHO\
PRUH WKDQWKHSUREDELOLW\ RIDFHUWDLQ QHZERUQEHLQJDJLUORUIRU WKDW
PDWWHU DER\ WKHQVXUHO\ ZHKDYHOLWWOH LI
UHDVRQ DQ\ WRWUXVW VXFK D
KDGLWK DVDFUHGLEOH KLVWRULFDO GDWXP
,QWKLVFRQWH[W ERWKWKHDKDG DQGWKHWDZGWXUDOPDQDZOIDLOWR
VXUYLYH EH\RQGWKHWHVWRISUREDELOLW\ 7KHGKGGLVDGPLWWHGO\ ]DQQL
PHDQLQJWKDWLWHQJHQGHUV LQWKHLQWHOOHFW DSUREDELOLW\ LQWKHRUGHURI
RUKLJKHU EXWQHYHU HYHQLQWKHPRVWRSWLPLVWLF RIFLUFXPVWDQFHV
FHUWDLQW\ ,WLV
ZLWK W KLVLQP LQGWKDW WKH0 XVOLPMXULVWVDQGWUDGLWLRQLVWV
UHDGLO\ DFNQRZOHGJHG WKDWWKHGKGGLVVXEMHFWWRPHQGDFLW\ DQGHUURU
IRUSUREDELOLW\ LWVHOILVE\GHILQLWLRQ OLDEOHWRIDOVLILFDWLRQ ,IWKH
LVQRWWREHWUXVWHG DVDKLVWRULFDO " 
VRXUFHWKHQDOWDZDWXUDO
PD QDZWLVWREHWUHDWHG
KDG SUHFLVHO\ LQWKHVDPHPDQQHU IRUWKLVW\SHRI
WDZDWXULVQRWKLQJ PRUHWKDQDFROOHFWLRQRIKDGLWKVRIWKHGKGGW\SH
,QIDFWLWLVSUHFLVHO\RQWKHVHJURXQGVWKDWD QXPEHURIVFKRODUV
GHQLHGWKHPXWDZGWLU ODIaLWKHVWDWXV RIFHUWDLQW\DOWKRXJK WKLVWDZ
WXUZDVXQLYHUVDOO\ DFNQRZOHGJHGDVEHLQJHSLVWHPLFDOO\ VXSHULRUWR
WKH PD QDZO W\SH   )RURXU SXUSRVHV WKHQ  DQG QRWWKRVH RI
PHGLHYDO0XVOLPVFKRODUVZKRDVVRFLDWHGWKLVFRQFHSWRIWDZGWXU
ZLWKPHWDSK\VLFDO DQGWKHRORJLFDOSRVWXODWHV LIWKHSDUWLFXODUVDUH
GXELRXVWKHQWKHZKROHLVHTXDOO\VR,QGXHFRXUVHZHVKDOOVHHWKDW
LQDQ\HYHQWQRKDGLWKVRIWKHPD  QDZIW\SHH[FHSW IRURQH  FDQ

 1DMPDO'LQ 6XOD\PLQ DO72IL

6KDUOL0XNKWDVDUDO5DZGDHG $EG$OOLKDO7XUNL YROV%HL
UXW0X DVVDVDW  
DO5LVLOD ,, NKDEDUDOZG,KLG \DKOWDPLO DONDGKLE $EIL$PU
,EQDO6DOLK6L\MGQDW6DKWK 0XVOLPPLQDO,NKOGO ZDO*KDODW HG0XZDIIDT $EGDO4$GLU %HLUXW'LU
DO*KDUE DO,VO,PL
   DO]DQQTDG\XNKWL ,EQDO4DVVLU 0XTDGGLPD NKDEDUDO
ZGKLGMGL]D DOD\KLDOQDVNKZDOJKDODW ZDOVDKZZDONDGKLE $EIL$O DO6DUDNKVL 8VLO %HLUXW
'LUDO.LWLE DO$UDEL
 DOGKLG-G@ILKL LKWLPGOZDVKXEEKD
 6DUDNKVL 0XKODUUDU ,II
 :KLFKKDVWKHFRPPRQWKHPHP\ FRPPXQLW\ VKDOOQHYHUDJUHHXSRQDQHUURU 6HH+DOODT
2QWKH$XWKRULWDWLYHQHVV RI6XQQL &RQVHQVXV II
,VKRXOGQRWHWKDW WKLV
KDGIWK ZDVQRWDGPLWWHG
DVFDSDEOHRIHQJHQGHULQJ
E\DOOMXULVWV )DNKU
FHUWDLQW\ DO'LQDO5L]LDQG7ILIL
IRU UHMHFWHGLW
LQVWDQFH
DVOHVVWKDQDQDSRGLFWLFVRXUFHDQGWKXVLQFDSDEOHRIMXVWLI\LQJ FRQVHQVXV6HHKLVDO0DKVDOI,OP
DO8VLOYROV%HLUXW 'LUDO.XWXE DO,OPL\\D ,,6HHDOVR:%+DOODT/DZDQG /HJDO
7KHRU\ LQ&ODVVLFDODQG0HGLHYDO,VODP $OGHUVKRW 9DULRUXP  DGGHQGXPWR9,,,



This content downloaded from 128.59.222.12 on Thu, 26 Mar 2015 01:38:32 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
 7+($87+(17,&,7<
2)3523+(7,&+$',7+$36(8'2352%/(0

DVVXPLQJWKDWWKHUHZDVPRUHWKDQRQHLQ
EHVDLGWRKDYHVXUYLYHG
H[LVWHQFH 

,,,

:KDWUHPDLQV WKHQLVWKHPXWDZDWLURIWKHODI]LNLQG ZKLFKLVSUR

GXFWLYH RILPPHGLDWH DQGWKXVFHUWDLQ NQRZOHGJH +RZHYHU EHIRUH ZH
DGGUHVVWKLVFDWHJRU\ ZHRXJKWWRORRNDWDQRWKHU VSKHUH RIW UDGLWLRQDO
0XVOLPGLVFRXUVHJHQHUDWHG QRWE\WKHMXULVWV DQGOHJDOWKHRUHWLFLDQV
EXWE\WKHWUDGLWLRQLVWV PXKDGGLWKIWQWKHPVHOYHV
 WKHKDGLWKH[SHUWV
SDUH[FHOOHQFH
:KLOHWKHOLQJXLVWLF DQGHSLVWHPRORJLFDO VWXG\RIKDGLWKZDVRQHRI
QXPHURXV WKDW
VXEMHFWV SUHRFFXSLHG OHJDO WKH WKHRUHWLFLDQV WKHWUDGLWLR
QLVWV P
 DLQEXVLQHVVZDVE\GHILQLWLRQ H[FOXVLYHO\ WKDWRIWKHKDGLWK
7KLVLQRWKHU ZRUGVZDVWKHLU VSHFLDOW\%XWWKLVVKDUHGLQWHUHVW LQWKH
KDGLWKZDVYLUWXDOO\ WKHRQO\FRPPRQGHQRPLQDWRU EHWZHHQWKHWZR
JURXSV 7KHOHJDOWKHRUHWLFLDQV ZHUHLQWKHILQDO DQDO\VLVLQWHUHVWHG LQ
WKHKDGLWK DVSDUWRIWKHLUHSLVWHPRORJLFDO HQWHUSULVH ZKLFK Z DVXVADODO
ILTE:KDWFRQFHUQHG WKHP LQWKHHQGZDVWKHHYDOXDWLRQ RIWKLV VRXUFH
DPRQJPDQ\ RWKHUWKHRUHWLFDO HOHPHQWV LQWHUPV RIWKHGHJUHHWRZKLFK
ODZDVFRQFHLYHGE\PDQLVLGHQWLFDO RUGLIIHUHQW IURP WKDWORGJHGLQWKH
PLQGRI*RG7KHKLJKHUWKHSUREDELOLW\ WKDWD SDUWLFXODU KDGLWKRQ
ZKLFKDUXOLQJ LVEDVHG ZDVDXWKHQWLF WKHFORVHUWKHMXULVW FDPHWRWKH
+LJKHU 7UXWKRIWKH/DZDVLWSHUWDLQHG WRWKDW SDUWLFXODU UXOLQJ,WZDVSUH
FLVHO\LQWKLVHSLVWHPLF HYDOXDWLRQ WKDWWKHLQWHUHVW RIWKHOHJDOWKHRUHWL
FLDQOD\$QGLWLVSUHFLVHO\KHUHWKDWWKHLQWHUHVW RIWKHWKHRUHWLFLDQV FRLQ
FLGHVZLWKWKDWRIPRGHPVFKRODUV%RWKJURXSVDUHLQWHUHVWHG LQWKH
DXWKHQWLFLW\DQGYHUDFLW\ RIKDGLWK IURP DQHSLVWHPRORJLFDO SHUVSHFWLYH
GHVSLWHWKHGLIIHULQJ DSSURDFKHV WKH\DGRSWLQWKHLU DVVHVVPHQWV 
7KHLQWHUHVW RIWKHWUDGLWLRQLVWV RQWKHRWKHUKDQGOD\HOVHZKHUH
7UXHWKH\ ZHUHLQWHUHVWHG LQWKHYHUDFLW\ RIWKHKDGLWKEXWIURP DQHQWL
UHO\GLIIHUHQW YDQWDJHSRLQW7KH\VWXGLHGKDGLWKLQVRIDU DVLWOHDGVWR
ZKDWWKH\FDOOHG DPDO   WKDWZKLFKLVEDVHGRQSUREDELOLW\ EXW

 :LWK WKHH[FHSWLRQRIWKHKDGLWKSHUWDLQLQJWRWKHDXWKRULWDWLYHQHVV RIFRQVHQVXV,NQRZRI

QRRWKHU 6HHSUHYLRXV QRWH
  :RUNV RQKDGLWKFRQVWDQWO\ PDNHUHIHUHQFH WRWKHGLVWLQFWO\
GLIIHUHQW FDWHJRULHVDQGWHUPV
XVHGE\WKHMXULVWV DQGOHJDOWKHRUHWLFLDQV/HVVRIWHQEXWIUHTXHQWO\HQRXJKWKHWKHRUHWLFLDQV PDNH
WKHVDPHUHIHUHQFH WRWKHWUDGLWLRQLVWV
  6HH $EGDO5DKP$Q ,EQ.KDOGILQ0XTDGGLPD %HLUXW'LU,K\$DO7XUaWK
 DO $UDEL QG 
ZKRDUJXHVWKDW WKHKDGWWKFRQVWLWXWLQJWKHEXONRIWKHVL[FDQRQLFDOFROOHFWLRQV
LVWKDWZKLFKIXO
ILOVWKHUHTXLUHPHQW RI DPDO 8QGHQLDEO\ WKHFRQVLGHUDWLRQ RI DPDO ZDVDOVRLPSRUWDQW IURPWKH
OHJDOSHUVSHFWLYH EXWWKHWUDGLWLRQLVWV
ODLGPRUHVWUHVVRQLWWKDQGLGWKHOHJDOWKHRUHWLFLDQVZKRZHUH
LQWHUHVWHG PRUHLQWKHHSLVWHPRORJLFDOVLGHRIWKHKDGLWK6HH$EELGLDO6KDUK DO.DEIU,,7OIL
6KDUK,,



This content downloaded from 128.59.222.12 on Thu, 26 Mar 2015 01:38:32 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
 %+$//$4
:$(/

ZKLFKLVDOVRQHFHVVDU\ WRFRQVWLWXWH WKHIRXQGDWLRQV RISLRXVUHOLJLRXV

SUDFWLFH  ,QRWKHU ZRUGV XQOLNH WKHOHJDOWKHRUHWLFLDQV WKH\ZHUHE\
QRPHDQVLQWHUHVWHG LQWKHSUREDEOHFHUWDLQ GLFKRWRP\ EXWUDWKHULQ
DQ\3URSKHWLFPDWHULDO WKDWDSSHDUHGWRWKHPWRPHHWWKHPLQLPDO
UHTXLUHPHQWV RIVRXQGQHVV 7KLVLVZK\WKHLU ILUVWDQGIRUHPRVW FDWH
JRU\RIKDGLWK WKH VRXQG FRQVLVWHGRIYDULRXVW\SHVQRWWKH
OHDVWRIZKLFKDUHWKRVH
VDKLK KDGLWKVZKLFKHQJHQGHUPHUHSUREDEL
OLW\ 3UREDEO\ IRUWKHVDPHUHDVRQ WKH\ GLGQRWLQWKHLU FODVVLILFDWLRQ
RIKDGLWK GLVWLQJXLVK DQ\FDWHJRU\ HTXLYDOHQW WRWKH XVD]OLW\SHRIWKH
PXWDZGXWLU ,EQDO6DODVKG R
 QHRI WKH PRVW GLVWLQJXLVKHG
WUDGLWLRQLVWV RIWKHPXWD DNKNKLUALQ   H[SOLFLWO\ VWDWHVWKDW
LQWKHWUD
GLWLRQLVWVGLVFRXUVH
 WKHWD[RQRP\ RIWKHPXWDZDWLULVQRZKHUHWREH
IRXQGDQGWKLVKHVD\VLVGXHWRWKHIDFWWKDWVXFKKDGLWKVGRQRW
FRQVWLWXWH SDUWRIWKHLU ULZD\D 
,WEHDUVVRPHUHLWHUDWLRQ KHUHWKDWDPDMRUFULWHULRQ RIWKHWUDGLWLR
QLVWVDQGWRVRPHH[WHQW RIWKHOHJDOWKHRUHWLFLDQV   ZDVWKHGHVLGH
UDWXP RIDPDO  WKDW LVUHOLJLRXV SUD[LVLQDOOVSKHUHVRIKXPDQOLIH
SUD[LV WKDWL VIRXQGHG XSRQ DUHDVRQDEOH NQRZOHGJHRIWKHGLYLQHO\
RUGDLQHG VRXUFHV&HUWDLQW\ FRQFHUQLQJ WKH GHWDLOVRIKXPDQEHKDYLRXU
ZDVFRQVLGHUHGXQDWWDLQDEOH DQGLIFRQGXFWLQJDQGRUJDQL]LQJ VXFK
EHKDYLRXU ZHUHWRGHSHQGVLJQLILFDQWO\ RUHYHQSDUWO\ RQVXFKDQHSLV
WHPLFFDWHJRU\ WKHUHJXODWLRQ RIKXPDQOLIHZRXOGEHFRPHZHOOQLJK
LPSRVVLEOH )RU DVRQHMXULVW SXWLWFHUWDLQW\ LVDUDULW\
LQPDWWHUVRI
ODZ  DQGODZUHJXODWHV DOOVSKHUHVRIKXPDQFRQGXFW
,IWKHPXWDZDWLUZDVQRWSDUWRIWKHWUDGLWLRQLVWVUHSHUWRLUH  RI
KDGLWK WKHQ ZKDWWKH\ KDQGOHG ZHUHKDGLWKV RIWKH W\SHRUWKRVH
HYHQRIDZHDNHUVRUW 7KHVRXUFHV DVLVZHOONQRZQ PDNHLWTXLWHFOHDU
GKG
WKDWWKHWUDGLWLRQLVWV VHWIRUWK DFODVVLFDOWD[RQRP\ ZKLFKGLVWLQJXLVKHV
EHWZHHQWKUHH PDLQW\SHV WKH VRXQG WKHKDVDQ JRRG DQGWKH
GDLI ZHDN   7KHODVWWZRVDKLK
FDWHJRULHV PD\EHIXUWKHU GLVWLQJXLVKHG

 ,EQDO4DVVGU 0XTDGGLPD
 ,EQDO6DOLK 0XTDGGLPD 1DZDZL7DTULE
 ,EQ.KDOGILQ UHPDUNV WKDW
,EQ ZULWLQJVRQKDGLWKDUHWKHPRVWDXWKRULWDWLYH DPRQJ
WKHODWHU0XVOLP DXWKRUV0XWD DNKNKLUDIQ 6HHKLV
 V 0XTDGGLPD
DO6DOK
  ,EQDO6DOLK0XTDGGLPD
 :KRDUHWREHGLVWLQJXLVKHG KHUHIURP PXIWLVTDGGLVDQGRWKHUPHPEHUV RIWKHOHJDOSURIHV
VLRQWKDW KDGWRGHDOZLWKDQGGLUHFWO\ FRQIURQW WKHUHDOLDRIMXGLFLDOSUDFWLFH
7UXHWKHXOWLPDWH GHV
WLQDWLRQRIXVXODOILTE ZDVODZLQDVRFLDOFRQWH[W EXWLQRUGHU WREHHODERUDWHGDVDWKHRU\ RIODZWKH
XVDLOOHQWLWVHOI
IXQGDPHQWDOO\ DQGVWUXFWXUDOO\ WRHSLVWHPRORJLFDO GLVWLQFWLRQVZKLFKVHHPLQJO\ REVFX
UHGWRVRPHH[WHQW LWVRZQJHQXLQHLQWHUHVW LQWKHVRFLDOUHDOLW\RIWKHODZ
 6HHQDERYH
  $EELGLDO6KDULDO.DELIU ,,72LI 6KDUK,,
6KDUOL
 7ILIL ,,
 7KHFOD LILVOHVVIUHTXHQWO\ NQRZQDVVDTLP6HH,EQDO6DOLK 0XTDGGLPQD II
-DPHV 5RE
VRQ9DULHWLHVRIWKH+DVDQ7UDGLWLRQ -RXUQDORI6HPLWLF6WXGLHV   DW



This content downloaded from 128.59.222.12 on Thu, 26 Mar 2015 01:38:32 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
 2)3523+(7,&+$',7+$,36(8'2352%/(0
7+($87+(17,&,7<

RURWKHUW\SHVPD\EHDGGHGHJKDVDQVDKLK KDVDQJKDULE %H

WKDWDVLWPD\WKHGD IJKDULEDQGRWKHUPRUHLQIHULRU W\SHVGRQRW
FRQFHUQXVIRU WKH\DUHDGPLWWHG E\WKHWUDGLWLRQLVWVWKHPVHOYHV WREH
KLJKO\ SUREOHPDWLF DWEHVWDQGVSXULRXV DWZRUVW 
7KHVDKLKLVGHILQHG DVKDYLQJ EHHQWUDQVPLWWHG LQDQXQLQWHUUXSWHG
PDQQHUE\SHUVRQVDOO RIZKRPIURPWKHILUVW WLHUWRWKHODVWDUH
NQRZQIRUWKHLUMXVW FKDUDFWHU XGDO  DQG H[FHOOHQW PHPRU\
GDEW    :HKDYHDOUHDG\ VDLGWKDWQRWDOOKDGLWKVRIWKLVW\SHDUHRI
WKHVDPHTXDOLW\ RUVWUHQJWK $WOHDVWKDOIDGR]HQVXEW\SHV ZHUHGLV
WLQJXLVKHG GHSHQGLQJRQKRZ WKH\ZHUHFODVVLILHGDQGWUHDWHGE\
%XNKDUL DQG0XVOLP WKHDXWKRUV RIWKHWZR6LKGFK  7KHKDVDQRQ
WKHRWKHUKDQGLVDKDGLWKWUDQVPLWWHG E\SHUVRQVZKRVHFKDUDFWHU LV
NQRZQWREHQHLWKHU MXVWQRUQHIDULRXV  7KLVW\SH LWV
GHVSLWH SRWHQ
WLDOVKRUWFRPLQJV PD\EHDFWHGXSRQ \DVOXKOLO DPDOELEL EXWFDQ
QRWEHVDLGWRUHSUHVHQW DQ\WKLQJ PRUHWKDQPHUHSUREDELOLW\  
,WDSSHDUVWKDWDIWHUWKHILIWKHOHYHQWK FHQWXU\ WKHHSLVWHPLF YDOXHRI
WKHVDKLKEHFDPHDPLOGO\ FRQWURYHUVLDO PDWWHU DPRQJ WKH WUDGLWLRQLVWV
 WKHLULQWHUHVWEHLQJ HVVHQWLDOO\QRQHSLVWHPRORJLFDO1DZDZL
G D QG,EQDO6DOLOK VHHPWRKDYHVSHDUKHDGHG WKHWZRRSSR
VLQJFDPSDLJQV 1DZDZLXQHTXLYRFDOO\ VWDWHV WKDWWKHVDKL]K PHDQVMXVW
DQGGRHVQRWPHDQWKDWLWLVFHUWDLQ +HYHKHPHQWO\
WKDWVDKL]K
DUJXHGWKDW WKHPDMRULW\ RI0XVOLP VFKRODUVDQGOHDGLQJDXWKRULWLHVDO
PXKDTTLTDQ ZDODNWKDU]aQ  KHOGWKDWXQOHVVWKH VDKLKLV RIWKH
PXWDZGWLU FDWHJRU\ LW
VKDOO UHPDLQ SUREDEOH DQGFDQQHYHU DWWDLQ WKH
OHYHORIFHUWDLQW\ 2QWKHRWKHUKDQG%XOTLQLG DOVR
HQOLVWVWKHDXWKRULW\RIDQXPEHU RIVFKRODUV
RQKLVVLGHDQGEDVLQJKLP
VHOIRQ,EQDO6DOLK
DUJXHV WKDW WKRVH KDGLWKV RIWKH W\SH RQZKLFK
%XNK:UL DQG0XVOLP DJUHHG OHDG WRDFTXLUHGFHUWDLQVDKK
NQRZOHGJH\DTLQL
QD]DUW   7KLVNQRZOHGJH ,EQDO6DODKPDLQWDLQV LVGXHWRWKHIDFW
WKDW WKHFRPPXQLW\ RI0XVOLPV KDVDJUHHGWRDFFHSW%XNK$ULDQG V 0XV
OLP V6LKLKDVDXWKRULWDWLYH DQGWKLVDJUHHPHQW DPRXQWHG LQKLVYLHZWR

 0XK\L DO'LQ6KDUDIDO'LQDO1DZDZL DO7DTULEZDO7D\VLUOL0D ULIDW6XQDQDO%DVELUZDO

1DGEIUHG $EG$OODKDO%LULGL%HLUXW 'LUDO-LQLQ
 5REVRQ9DULHWLHVII
,EQ.KDO
GLQ0XTDGGLPD
 1DZDZL7DTULE0XVOLP 6KDUK,,
6DKLK,72IL
  7DTLDO'LQ,EQ'DTLT DO ,G IW%D\GQDO,VWLOGK HG 4DKWLQDO'ILUL%DJKGLG
 ,EQ
0DWED DWDO,UVKLG DO6DO$K0XTDGGLPD7ILIL
DOOTWLUGK 6KDUK
 ,EQDO6DOLK
0XTDGGLPD1DZDZL7DTULE
 ,EQ'DTLTDO OG,TWLUGK
7IL6KDUK,,
 ,EQ'DTLTDO OG,TWLUGK
,EQDO6DOLK 0XTDGGLPD
 1DZDZL7DTULE ZDLGKEG TLODVDKLKIDEGGEG PD QGKX ,GDQQDEX XQELEL
  1DZDZL7DTULE6LULMDO'LQDO%XOTLQL 0DKGVLQ SULQWHGZPDTW
LWK,EQDO6DOLK V
0XTDGGLPDHG $ LVKD $EGDO5DKPLQ &DLUR'LUDO0D ULI ,QIDFW
DOOVWOVLK $PLU%DGLVKLK
7D\VWU ZLWKRXW
DO7DKULU PDNLQJ GLVWLQFWLRQV UHPDUNV
JHQHUDOO\ WKDWSUREDELOLW\
LVWKHIXQFWLRQRI
WKHVDKLK
DQGWKHKDVDQ



This content downloaded from 128.59.222.12 on Thu, 26 Mar 2015 01:38:32 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
 :$(/% +$//$4

FRQVHQVXV LMPA  ZKLFKJHQHUDWHVFHUWDLQW\  ,WLVLPSRUWDQW WR

REVHUYHKHUHWKDWFHUWDLQW\ IRU,EQ GRHVQRWVWHPIURPWKH
PRGDOLWLHV E\ZKLFKWKHVDKaLK LVWUDQVPLWWHG
DO6DOOK EXWLVGHGXFHGIURP WKH
H[WUDQHRXV IDFWWKDWDFRQVHQVXVZDVFRQFOXGHGRQWKHDXWKRULWDWLYH
FKRLFHVRI0XVOLPDQG%XNK$UL 7KHLPSOLFDWLRQV RILJQRULQJ OLQHVRI
WUDQVPLVVLRQ DQGWKHFKDUDFWHU RIWUDQVPLWWHUV DVWKHHVWDEOLVKHG FULWHULD
RISURRI LQIDYRXU RIDQH[WUDQHRXV PHWKRGRIHYDOXDWLRQ DUHJUDYH)RU
,EQDO6DODK V SRVLWLRQ DPRXQWV LQHIIHFW WRDUJXLQJ WKDWWKH0XVOLP FRP
PXQLW\ LQ DQG E\LWVHOILV WR
HPSRZHUHG OHJLVODWH E\HOHYDWLQJ LQV
IRU
WDQFHWKHVWDWXVRIDVRXUFHRIODZIURP DOHYHORISUREDELOLW\ WRFHU
WDLQW\ 0RUHLPSRUWDQWO\ KLV DUJXPHQW RQFH WDNHQWR LWVORJLFDO
FRQFOXVLRQ GHVWUR\V WKHYHU\IRXQGDWLRQV RIFRQVHQVXVDVDVRXUFHRI
ODZVLQFH D V,KDYH VKRZQ HOVHZKHUH WUDSVLWLQWKHLQVROXEOHTXDQ
LW
R D
I
GDU\ SHWLWLRSULQFLSLL ,WZDVSUHFLVHO\ WRDYRLGWKLVYHU\WUDS
WKDWJHQHUDWLRQ DIWHU JHQHUDWLRQ RIMXULVWV FRQVHFUDWHG WKHLULQWHOOHFWXDO
HQHUJLHV ,WPXVW KDYHEHHQLQWKLVVSLULW WKDW WKHLQIOXHQWLDO VFKRODU,EQ
$EGDO6DOLPG UHSURDFKHG,EQDO6DODK FDOOLQJKLVYLHZ
GHIHFWLYHUDGL   3HUKDSVWKHPRVWHYLQFLYHDUJXPHQW DJDLQVWWKH
ILFWLWLRXV DXWKRULW\ EHVWRZHG E\ F RQVHQVXV L V*ROG]LKHU V
LQVLJKWIXO VWD
WHPHQW WKDW>G@HVSLWHWKLV JHQHUDO UHFRJQLWLRQ RIW KH LQ,VODP
WKHYHQHUDWLRQ QHYHU ZHQWVRIDU DVWRFDXVHIUHH FULWLFLVPRIWKHVD\LQJV
6DKLKDQ
DQGUHPDUNV LQFRUSRUDWHG LQWKHFROOHFWLRQVWREHFRQVLGHUHGLPSHU
PLVVLEOH RUXQVHHPO\ 
7KHUHPDLQLQJ VXEW\SHV RIWKHVDKLKRQZKLFK%XNKQUL DQG0XVOLP
FRXOGQRWDJUHH DVZHOODVWKRVHRIWKHKDVDQDUHXQTXHVWLRQDEO\
FRQVLGHUHGWREHSUREDEOHDQGWKXVEHORQJWRWKHOHJDOWKHRUHWLFLDQV 
FDWHJRU\ RIWKH $QGLIZHWDNHH[FHSWLRQWR,EQDO6DODK V FODLPV
FRQFHUQLQJ WKHVD]KLK
KGDG RQZKLFK%XNKULG DQG0XVOLPDJUHHGWKHQDQ\
QRQPXWDZDWLU VDKLKRIWKLVFDWHJRU\ LVDOVRFRQVLGHUHG E\GHILQLWLRQ
DQ IDOOLQJ VKRUW RIHQJHQGHULQJ FHUWDLQW\ ,QIDYRXU RIWKLV
SRVLWLRQ
ZHFDQOLVW
KAG QRWRQO\WKHWUDGLWLRQLVWV ZKRRSSRVHG,EQDO6DODK V YLHZ
EXWDOVRDOOWKHOHJDOWKHRUHWLFLDQV DQGMXULVWV IRUZKRPDIWHU DOOWKH
HQWLUHKDGLWK OLWHUDWXUH ZDVFROOHFWHG RUJDQL]HG DQGVFUXWLQL]HG ,QIDFW
6KDZNDQL H[SOLFLWO\ VWDWHVWKDW OHJDOUXOLQJV PD\ZHOOEHFRQVWUXFWHG RQ
WKHEDVLVRIWKHVDK]LK DQGWKHKDVDQ EHFDXVHWKHVHWZRFDWHJRULHV
HQJHQGHU SUREDELOLW\ ZKLFKVXIILFHV LQOHJDOPDWWHUV 

 ,EQDO6DOILK
6L\GQDW6DOLKW 0XVOLP
 +DOODT2QWKH$XWKRULWDWLYHQHVVRI6XQQL&RQVHQVXV

 %XOTLQL0DKWOVLQ 
DO,VWLOGK
 0XVOLP6WXGLHV ,,DQGWKHIROORZLQJ
SDJHVZKHUHKHVXEVWDQWLDWHV
KLVDVVHUWLRQ
 ,UVKGGDO)XKIOLOG7DKTLTDO+DTTPLQ ,OPDO8\O 6XUDED\D6KDULNDW
0DNWDEDW E
$KPDG
6D GE1DEKLQQG 



This content downloaded from 128.59.222.12 on Thu, 26 Mar 2015 01:38:32 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
 2)3523+(7,&+$',7+$36(8'2352%/(0
7+($87+(17,&,7<

)LQDOO\ ZHWXUQ WRWKHSUREOHP RIWKH ZKLFK HQJHQGHUV

:H UHFDOOWKDW,EQ PXWDZHDWLU WKDW
KLPVHOI
FHUWDLQW\ DO6DOLK DFNQRZOHGJHG WKHWUD
GLWLRQLVWV 
UHSHUWRLUH RIKDGLWK GRHVQRW LQFOXGH WKLVFDWHJRU\ %XW,EQDO
6DODKVDLGPRUH +HDUJXHG LQFDWHJRULFDO WHUPV WKDWWKHPXWDZDGWLU LVD
UDULW\ +H ZKRLVDVNHG WRSURGXFH DQH[DPSOH RIDKDGLWK WKDW LV
WUDQVPLWWHG LQD PXWDZGDWLU >IDVKLRQ@ ZLOOEH H[KDXVWHGE\KLV
VHDUFK0 ,QKLVRZQVHDUFK IRU VXFKKDGLWKV KHFRXOGFLWHRQO\ RQH
SUHVXPDEO\ QDUUDWHG E\ P RUHWKDQ DKXQGUHG &RPSDQLRQV +HZKR
LQWHQWLRQDOO\ OLHVFRQFHUQLQJ VRPHWKLQJ ,>YL]
WKH3URSKHW@ KDYHVDLG
ZLOOJDLQDVHDWLQ+HOOILUH 7KH
  R WKHUKDGLWK ZKLFK KH FRXOG ILQG
WKDWVHHPLQJO\ PHW WKHVWDQGDUGV RIWKHPXWDZDWLU ZDV$FWV DUHMXG
JHGE\LQWHQWLRQV +RZHYHU KHDFNQRZOHGJHV WKDWDOWKRXJK WKLV
KDGLWK ZDVUHSRUWHGO\ QDUUDWHG E\ D 
PXWDZGWLU QXPEHU RIWUDQVPLWWHUV
LWVDSRGLFWLF PDQQHU RIWUDQVPLVVLRQ RFFXUUHG LQWKHPLGGOH WLHUVRI
WUDQVPLVVLRQ QRWIURP WKHRXWVHW 
7KHODWHU OHJDOWKHRUHWLFLDQV $QVaUL DQG  ,EQ$EGDO6KD
N2UDFFHSWHG
 WKHJHQHUDO WHQRU RI,EQDO6DOLK V DUJXPHQW
DERXWWKHVFDUFLW\ RIWDZDWXU EXWVHHPWRWKLQN WKDW WKHUH DUHPRUH
KDGLWKV RIWKLV W\SHLQH[LVWHQFH +DYLQJ HQXPHUDWHG ZLWK ZKDW VHHPV
WREHJUHDW GLIILFXOW\IRXU VXFKKDGLWEV WKH\ FDOOXSRQ,EQDO-DZ]L G
ZKR  LVTXRWHG DVVD\LQJ ,KDYH WUDFNHG GRZQWKHPXWDZD
WLUKDGLWKV DQGIRXQG DQXPEHU RIWKHP +HHQXPHUDWHV VL[DWOHDVW
RQHRIZKLFK DQGSUREDEO\ WZR KDGDOUHDG\ EHHQOLVWHG E\$QVDUL DQG
,EQ$EGDO6KDNXU &  7KXV D WKRURXJK VHDUFK E\ D QXPEHU RI WKH
PRVW HPLQHQW WUDGLWLRQLVWV DQGMXULVWV RI,VODP FRXOG \LHOGQRPRUH WKDQ
HLJKWRUQLQH KDGIWKV RIWKHPXWDZGWLU W\SH
7KLV QXPEHU PD\ OHIW
EH WRVWDQG RQO\ LI
ZHDGPLW WKDW DOOZHUHWUXO\
RIWKHPXWDZDWLUW\SH+RZHYHU LQKLVFRPPHQWDU\ RQDSDVVDJHLQ
ZRUN,EQ $EG DO6KDNLLU
$QVQUL V LQIRUPVKLVUHDGHUVWKDWWKH\ZLOO
HQFRXQWHU\HWRWKHUVXFKKDGLWKVLQWKHODWHUVHFWLRQVRIKLVFRPPHQ
WDU\ RQHZKLFKVSHDNVRIWKHLQIDOOLELOLW\
LQFOXGLQJ RIWKH0XVOLPFRP

  7KLVVKRXOGQRWEHWDNHQWRFRQWUDGLFW KLVHDUOLHUDVVHUWLRQV
DERXWWKHDSRGLFWLFVWDWXV
RIWKH
VDKLK7KHNQRZOHGJH HQJHQGHUHG E\WKHPXWDZGWLU DOODJUHHGZDVRIWKHLPPHGLDWH W\SH2QWKH
RWKHUKDQGKHKHOGWKDWWKHVDLKRQZKLFKERWK%XNKLUL DQG0XVOLP DJUHHGZDVFDSDEOHRI\LHOGLQJ
PHGLDWHDFTXLUHGNQRZOHGJH
  0XTDGGLPD ZDPDQVX LOD DQ LEUG]LPLWKGOLQOLGKGOLND IOPG\XUZGPLQDO
KDGLWKD \GEXWDDOOXEXKX
 ,ELG0XKDPPDG E DO'LQDO$QVLUL
)DZGWLOK SULQWHGZLWK*KD]LOL V0XV
YROV&DLURD0DWED1L]P
DDO$PLUL\\D  DO5DKODPUW
,,PDQNDGKDED DOD\\DPXWD DPPL
WDVIG
GDQIDO\DWDEDZZD PDT DGDKX PLQDOQGU 
 0XTDGGLPDLQQDPG DODPGOXELOQL\\GW
  DO5DKDPDLW ,,
)DZGXWLL



This content downloaded from 128.59.222.12 on Thu, 26 Mar 2015 01:38:32 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
 %+$//$4
:$(/

PXQLW\ 7KLVVXJJHVWV ZDV

WKDWZKHQDWOHDVW,EQ $EGDO6KDNILU
RIWDZDWXU
VSHDNLQJ KHPD\
QRWKDYHDOZD\V
PHDQW
WKHWDZGWXU
ODI]L
VLQFHWKHKDGLWKVSHDNLQJ RIWKH0XVOLP
RIWKHLQIDOOLELOLW\ FRPPXQLW\
LVRIWKHWDZGWXUPD QDZO W\SH& 7KHUHIRUH LWLVSRVVLEOHWKDWWKH
QXPEHU
WRWDO RIPXWDZDGWLU KDGLWKVKHFLWHGPD\HYHQEHOHVVWKDQIRXU
ZLWKWKHSRVVLEOHUHVXOWWKDW
WKHQXPEHU RIVXFKKDGLWKV LQWRWRPD\IDOO
VKRUW RIHYHQHLJKWRUQLQH

,9
7RVXPXSZHVWHUQ KDVFRQFHQWUDWHG
VFKRODUVKLS LWVDWWHQWLRQ
XSRQ
DQDUHDRIWUDGLWLRQDO
0XVOLP
GLVFRXUVH LVQRWSDUWLFXODUO\
WKDW LQVWUXF
GLVFRXUVHLVVWDWHGLQWHUPV
WLYH7KHWUDGLWLRQLVW WKDWDUHODUJHO\LQFRQ
JUXHQW ZLWKWKHHSLVWHPLF HYDOXDWLRQ RIWKHKDGLWK
DQHYDOXDWLRQ WKDWLV
GLUHFWO\UHOHYDQWDQGLQGHHGFHQWUDO WRWKH,VODPLFLVW
SDUDGLJP RIKLVWR
ULFDOUHVHDUFK
,IPLQLPDO WUDFHVRIWKLVHSLVWHPLFLQWHUHVW
DUHWREHIRXQG
LQWKHWUDGLWLRQLVWGLVFRXUVHLWLVEHFDXVHOHJDOWKHRU\ FRPPDQGHGD
PHDVXUHRIDWWHQWLRQ IURP WKHWUDGLWLRQLVWV7KHHSLVWHPLF HYDOXDWLRQRI
WKHKDGLWKZDVILQHO\ DUWLFXODWHG DQGHODERUDWHGE\WKHOHJDOWKHRUHWL
FLDQVDQGMXULVWVDQGLWLVLQWKLVDUHDRIWUDGLWLRQDO
GLVFRXUVHWKDWZHV
WHUQVFKRODUVVKRXOGKDYHEHJXQWKHLUHQTXLU\LIVXFKDQHQTXLU\QHHG
DWDOOEHHPEDUNHGXSRQ
7KH OHJDOWKHRUHWLFLDQV FODVVLILFDWLRQRIWKHKDGLWK LQWRPXWDZGWLU
DQGDGKGGOHDYHVXVZLWKDFRORVVDOQXPEHURIWKHODWWHU
PHUHO\ SUREDEOH
DQGOHVVWKDQDGR]HQRIWKHIRUPHU
W\SH UHSRUWHGO\ DSRGLFWLF
YDULHW\
7KHDKGDGLQFOXGLQJWKHKDVDQZHUHXQLYHUVDOO\ DFNQRZOHGJHG WRKDYH
FRQVWLWXWHGWKHEXONRIKDGLWKZLWKZKLFKWKHWUDGLWLRQLVWV
GHDOWDQGRQ
WKHEDVLVRIZKLFKWKHMXULVWVGHULYHGWKHODZ  7KHDSRGLFWLFW\SH
ZDVVLPSO\ LQFRQVLGHUDEOH(YHQLIZHDVVXPHIRUWKHVDNHRIDUJXPHQW
WKDW
WKHPXWDZGWLU KDGLWKVDUHPRUHWKDQDGR]HQVD\DVFRUHRUHYHQ
PDQ\PRUH  WKHSUREOHPRIDXWKHQWLFLW\
QHYHUWKHOHVVWXUQVRXWWREH

 0XVDOODPDO7KXE'W 6KDUO )DZGWLOLDO5DKDPIOW SULQWHG ZLWK*KD]LOL V0XVWDI\G YROV

&DLURDL0DWED DDO$PLUL\\D  ,,6HHDOVRQDERYH
  ,QIDFWRQHRIWKHKDGLWKVHQXPHUDWHG E\ DQG,EQ$EGDO6KDNILU LVWKDWRIDOPDVK
DOGDONEKXIID\QZLSLQJRQH VIRRWJHDU ZLWKZHWKDQGV VDLGWREHRIWKHPXWDZDWLUPDQDZL W\SH
$QVUL
E\$EGDO:DKKLE ,EQ1DVUDO%DJKGLGL6HHKLV,MPG SULQWHG 0XTDGGLPDILDO
ZLWK,EQDO4DVVU
8VOHG0XKDPPDG 6XOD\PLQL%HLUXW 'LUDO*KDUE DO,VO$PL  
 1DZDZL7DTULE ,EQ'DTLTDO ,G,TWLUGK$EELGLDO6KDUK ,,-DPLO
DO'LQ HG%DVKVKLU DO.DELU
<ILVXI
DO0L]]L7DKGKLE DO.DPGOIL$VPG DO5LMGO YROV%HLUXW
0D UILI 0X DV
VDVDWDO5LVDOD
 ,6HHDOVR,EQ$EL6K$PD V FULWLTXH RIWKHSUDFWLFHVRIKLVIHOORZ6KLILLWHV
ZKRPKHFKDUJHV RIHPSOR\LQJ ZHDNKDGLWKVLQWKHFRQVWUXFWLRQ RIODZ0XNKWDVDU.LWGEDO0XDP
PDOIL DO5DGGLOGDO$PUDO$ZZDOSULQWHGLQ0DMPD  DO5DVG LO &DLUR0DWED DW.XUGLVWLQ
  
 ,QKLV4DWIDO$]KGU DO0XWDQGWKLUDIL DO$NKEEGU DO0XWDZ XWLUD ZKLFKLVDQDEULGJPHQW RI
DO)DXGLG DO0XWDNGWKLUD FROOHFWHGOLDGLWKV
6X\ULWL FODLPHGWRKDYHEHHQQDUUDWHG WKURXJK WHQRU



This content downloaded from 128.59.222.12 on Thu, 26 Mar 2015 01:38:32 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
 2)3523+(7,&+$',7+$36(8'2352%/(0
7+($87+(17,&,7<

DPLQRU DPLQXVFXOH
RQHLQYROYLQJ RI3URSKHWLF
ERG\ PDWHULDO
WKDW
FDQ
OHQGLWVHOI
HDVLO\ WRRXUFULWLFDO
DSSDUDWXV
V WKDW
,EQDO6DODKFODLP WKHVDKLK RQZKLFK
W\SH DQG0XV
%XNK$UL
HQJHQGHUV
OLPDJUHHG FDQQRW
FHUWDLQW\ EHWDNHQ E\PRGHUQ
VHULRXVO\
VFKRODUV WKHFODLPZDVKLJKO\
DQGWKLVIRUWZRUHDVRQV)LUVW FRQWUR
DPRQJWUDGLWLRQDO
YHUVLDO 0XVOLP
VFKRODUVWKHPVHOYHV EHHQ
KDYLQJ
IRU DQG UHDVRQV
UHMHFWHG ORJLFDO HSLVWHPRORJLFDO D 
E\ VLJQLILFDQW
PDMR
,IFRQVHQVXV
ULW\ ZKLFKLVDOOHJHGWRHOHYDWHWKHVDK]LK
WRDQDSRGLFWLF
WKHDXWKRULW\
OHYHOVDQFWLRQV WKHQKDGIWK
RIKDGLWK FDQQRWVDQFWLRQ
WKH
DXWKRULW\RIFRQVHQVXVIRU
WKLV
ZRXOGHQWDLODFLUFXODULW\
RIZKLFK0XV
OLPVFKRODUVZHUHDFXWHO\DZDUH%XWKDGLWKGRHVLQUHDOLW\ VDQFWLRQ
FRQVHQVXV LQ
HVSHFLDOO\ OLJKWRIW ZLGHO\DFNQRZOHGJHG WKDWLWLV
KH IDFW
WKHRQO\ WH[W
DXWKRULWDWLYH ZKLFK
FDQ7KXV
FRQVHQVXV
FDQQRW
VDQFWLRQ
KDGLWKDOVRDZLGHO\DFFHSWHGFRQFOXVLRQDPRQJWUDGLWLRQDO
0XVOLP
LQWHOOHFWXDOV DQGPRUH
 6HFRQG FODLP
WKH
LPSRUWDQWO\ LVWKHRORJLFDO
LQQDWXUH
IXQGDPHQWDOO\GHSDUWLQJ WKHFULWHULD
IURP RIKDGLWKHYDOXD
E\WKH0XVOLPWUDGLWLRQLVWV
WLRQHVWDEOLVKHG WKHPVHOYHV7KHFHUWDLQW\
ZKLFKWKHVDKLK] LV
\LHOGV QRWHVWDEOLVKHG PHDQV
E\ R I
W KH RI
PRGDOLWLHV
WUDQVPLVVLRQ RIUHFWLWXGH
RUWKHTXDOLW\ WRWKHWUDQVPLWWHUV
DWWULEXWHG
)RU LWQHYHU
LQVWDQFH ZDVWKH
FDVHWKDW
WKH RIDQLQGLYLGXDO
DXWKHQWLFLW\
KDGLWKRIWKHVDaKLKFDWHJRU\ ZDVGHFODUHGDELQLWLRDQGDSULRULFHUWDLQ
MXVWEHFDXVHLWEHORQJHGWRWKDWJURXSRIWUDGLWLRQV DJUHHGXSRQE\
%XNKLULDQG0XVOLP$ SRVLWLYHDIILUPDWLRQ RIDXWKHQWLFLW\ DOZD\V
UHTXLUHG RILQGLYLGXDO
DQLQYHVWLJDWLRQ KDGLWKVLQVRIDUDVWKHLU
SDUWLFXODU
PRGHRIWUDQVPLVVLRQ ZDVFRQFHUQHG:KHQWKHVHIRUPDO PHWKRGVRI
HQTXLU\ ZHUHDSSOLHG,EQDO6DODK
KLPVHOI IRXQGWKDWWKHPXWDZDWLULV
YLUWXDOO\QRQH[LVWHQW5DWKHUZKDWZDVVDLGWRJXDUDQWHH ,EQDO6DOaOK V
DSRGLFWLF ZDVWKHG LYLQH
JUDFHPHWDSK\VLFDOO\ EHVWRZHG XSRQWKH
0XVOLP FRPPXQLW\ QRWDQ\VFLHQWLILF
VDKLK DVDFROOHFWLYLW\ HQTXLU\LQWRWKH
FRQFUHWHKLVWRULFDO DQGVRFLRPRUDO FRQWH[W LOP DOULMGO LQZKLFK
WKHVHKDGLWKV ZHUHWUDQVPLWWHG
,WLVTXLWHSRVVLEOHWKDWVRPHKDGLWKVRIWKHVDK]LK W\SHZHUHFRQVL
GHUHGWREHORQJWRWKHPXWDZGWLU FDWHJRU\:KDW PDWWHUV LQWKHILQDO

PRUHFKDQQHOVRIWUDQVPLVVLRQ ([FHSWIRUWKHWLWOH QRZKHUHLQWKHPDQXVFULSW

LWVHOI GRHVKHTXDOLI\
WKHVHKDGLWKVDVPXWDZGWLU ,WLVQRWHZRUWK\ WKDW LQFOXGHVKHUHDQXPEHU
6X\&LWL RIKDGLWKVWKDW
ZHUH
FOHDUO\GLVPLVVHGE\PRUHGLVWLQJXLVKHG WUDGLWLRQLVWV
DVIDLOLQJWRPHHWWKHVWDQGDUGVRIWDZGWXU)RULQV
WDQFH'HHGVDUHMXGJHGE\LQWHQWLRQV ZDVGHHPHGE\,EQDO6DOaKL DVIDOOLQJ
VKRUWRIPDLQWDLQLQJD
WDZIWXUWUDQVPLVVLRQ WKURXJKRXW DOOVWDJHV6LPLODUO\
6X\ILWLLQFOXGHVWKHUHLQ WKHWZR,KDGLWKVUHODWLQJ
WRWKHLQIDOOLELOLW\
RIWKH0XVOLP FRPPXQLW\ DQGWRWKHZLSLQJRIWKHIRRWJHDU ZKLFKZHUHFRQVLGHUHG
DVWDZGWXUPQD QDZLQRWODI]L2QWKHVHVHHQQDQGDERYH,WLVDOVRQRWHZRUWK\ WKDWPRUH
WKDQRIWKHKDGLWKV KDYHWRGRZLWKULWXDOV
OLVWHG DQGPDWWHUV RIEHOLHI
6HH PV
4DWIDO$]KGU
<DKXGD6HFWLRQ *DUUHWW&ROOHFWLRQ 3ULQFHWRQ 8QLYHUVLW\,DPJUDWHIXO WR0V$QQD/HH3DXOVRI3ULQ
FHWRQ8QLYHUVLW\ IRUKHUH[WUDRUGLQDULO\
/LEUDULHV SURPSW KHOSLQPDNLQJ DYDLODEOHWR
WKLVPDQXVFULSW
PH
 6HHQDERYH



This content downloaded from 128.59.222.12 on Thu, 26 Mar 2015 01:38:32 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
 :$(/
%+$//$4

LVWKHIDFWWKDWWKLVODVWFDWHJRU\
DQDO\VLV LVTXDQWLWDWLYHO\
LQVLJQLILFDQW
LWPD\
KRZHYHU EHPHDVXUHG ,WFDQEHHDVLO\
RUFDOFXODWHG FRQWUROOHG
DQGLQYHVWLJDWHG $QGVXUHO\WKHPRGHUQ ZHVWHUQ GHEDWHDERXWDXWKHQ
ZRXOGEHFRQVLGHUHG
WLFLW\ DEVXUGLILWVREMHFWZHUHWREHFRQILQHG WRD
KDQGIXO RIVXFKKDGLWEV
7KDWWKHGHEDWHZDVQRWVRFRQILQHG DQGWKDW
LWGHDOWLQIDFW
ZLWKWKHYDVWPDMRULW\ RIWKHKDGLWKLVTXLWHREYLRXVDQG
QHHGQRWEHGHPRQVWUDWHG ,IERWKWKHWUDGLWLRQLVWV
DQGWKHMXULVWVWKH
WZRPRVWLPSRUWDQW JURXSVLQWKHVWXG\ RIKDGLWKVKDYHDFNQRZOHG
JHGWKHSUHFDULRXVHSLVWHPRORJLFDO VWDWXVRIWKHOLWHUDWXUHWKHQZH
QHHGQRWVTXDQGHURXUHQHUJLHV LQDUJXLQJ DERXWWKHPDWWHU RIDXWKHQ
:HKDYHEHHQWROGWKDWH[FHSWIRUDVFRUHRIKDGLWKVWKHUHVW
WLFLW\
HQJHQGHUV DQGSUREDELOLW\
SUREDELOLW\ DVZHNQRZDQGDVZHKDYH
DOVREHHQXQDPELJXRXVO\ WROGE\RXUVRXUFHVDOORZVIRUPHQGDFLW\
DQGHUURU :KDWPRUHGRZHZDQW"

:DHO%+$//$4
0F*LOO8QLYHUVLW\ 



This content downloaded from 128.59.222.12 on Thu, 26 Mar 2015 01:38:32 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions