Arnott - Beat The S&P

10/21/21, 11:11 AM Anyone can beat the stock market, new research suggests | Fortune
Most Popular
Which vaccine booster CONTENT FROM BCG New U.S. COVID cases are
should you get: Moderna, Meet the companies leading down 22%. See how your
Pfizer, or Johnson & Johnson? the charge to achieve net state is doing
zero
FINANCE • STOCK MARKET
Anyone can beat the stock market, new research suggests

BY GEOFF COLVIN
July 11, 2021 8:00 AM MDT
New subscriber trial
$1 FOR 4 WEEKS
SPECIAL OFFER Award wining business news, insight and analysis
Investment insight and trend analysis
Exclusive access to rankings and list data
Subscribe for the analysis you need-
without all the noise.
SUBSCRIBE NOW
https://fortune.com/2021/07/11/how-to-beat-the-stock-market/ 1/8
Subscribe to Fortune Daily to get essential business stories straight to your inbox each morning.
Is it possible that ordinary individual investors, without the help of ultrafast computers or a PhD in math, can
reliably beat the stock market?
Most Popular
should you get: Moderna, Meet the companies leading down 22%. See how your
Pfizer, or Johnson & Johnson? the charge to achieve net state is doing
zero
PAID CONTENT
How a spirit of collaboration fuels Cadence's

success
FROM CADENCE
Sixty years of Nobel Prize-winning theory say no, it is not possible. But just maybe it is. Ironically, the
widespread belief that it’s impossible helps to make it possible.
To see how, recall a high-buzz stock market event last December 21, when Tesla became a component of the S&P
500. Research Affiliates chairman Rob Arnott and colleagues made a bold prediction: Tesla stock “is likely to
underperform the market (S&P 500) in the year after entry” and “Apartment Investment and Management, the
stock removed from the S&P 500 to make room for Tesla, is likely to outperform the index over the next year by
as much as 20%.”
Today, just over six months later, the only flaw in that prediction is that it may have been too modest. The S&P
500 is up 17%. Tesla is indeed underperforming badly; it’s flat. Apartment Investment and Management (known
as Aimco) is outperforming the S&P, and by way more than 20%; it’s up 44%.
Arnott, whose firm develops investment strategies used in managing $166 billion of assets
New subscriber trial worldwide, argues
$1 FOR 4 WEEKS
that what happened is no fluke. It’s a particularly dramatic example of a predictable phenomenon that can be
exploited by traders.
SPECIAL OFFER
The opportunity, he says, is in the fundamental nature of index mutual funds and business
Award wining
obviously, is to track the performance of an index, which means trackingInvestment
it exactly.
ETFs. news,
Their objective,
insight and analysis
insight and trend analysis industry has
The index fund
become intensely competitive, and any divergence of a fund’s price fromExclusive
the index’s movement,
access to known
rankings and list data as
tracking error, will be seized upon by competitors as evidence that the fund is poorly run. The danger of tracking
error multiplies when one stock replaces another in the index. The reason: To avoid tracking error, every index
fund wants to buy the new stock and sell the departing one at the closing prices on the day before that day
because the index will be calculated on that basis. The result is trading mayhem on the trading day before the
switch. SUBSCRIBE NOW
ADVERTISING
Most Popular
For Tesla traders, thebooster
Which vaccine big day was Friday, DecemberCONTENT18,
FROMand
BCG trading mayhem duly ensued. Oncases
New U.S. COVID each
are of the
Meet the companies leading
previous fewshould
days youabout
get: Moderna,
5% of
Pfizer, or Johnson & Johnson?
the company’s outstanding shares
the charge to achieve net had been traded, down on
but 22%. December
See how your
state is doing
18, 23% was
zero
traded as indexers stampeded to buy the stock as near to the closing price as possible. The price jumped 6%,
then fell all the way back down the following Monday.
But that’s only half the story for Tesla or any other stock being added to the index. The S&P U.S. Index
Committee announced Tesla’s addition a month in advance, on November 17, 2020, and for the next month
hedge funds and other traders bought it up, knowing they could sell it to index funds that had to buy it on
December 18. Partly as a result, Tesla rocketed 57% in that month from the announcement until December 17.
For Aimco it was the opposite: Over the same period, its stock fell 17% as investors dumped it.
The trading opportunity is obvious: Buy the outgoing stock, which has been pounded down, and sell the
incoming stock, which has been pushed to the sky, on the big day before the switch becomes effective. Those
opportunities occur fairly often, about ten times a year on average, Arnott’s research shows. Over the past 20
years, an average of 23 stocks have been exiled from the index annually, to be replaced by 23 newcomers. Most
of those deletions are practically automatic when a company merges, is bought, or goes bankrupt. The rest are
discretionary switches, like Tesla-Aimco, and those are the ones to focus on.
It isn’t necessary to follow the formula exactly. Individual investors may not own any of the incoming stock to
sell and may not have the stomach for short-selling. That’s fine. Just buying the outgoing stock works great, on
average.
“Stocks being dropped from the index inevitably are deep value stocks that have performed badly, are struggling
as a business, and are dropped at distressed prices,” Arnott says.
New
His firm’s research finds that buying the outgoing stock in discretionary subscriber
deletions trial
from the S&P 500 at the
$1 FOR 4 WEEKS
closing price on the day it’s removed from the index has beaten the market by an average of nearly 20% over the
following 12 months.
SPECIAL OFFER
That is supposed to be impossible. The efficient market hypothesis holdsAward
market will quickly become known and almost immediately be arbitraged
thatwining
away
any business
as
reliable
traders
system
news,
jump
insight for beating the
and analysis
aboard.
Investment insight and trend analysis Why
hasn’t it happened in this case? “The big force that prevents it from happening is thetosheer
Exclusive access rankingsscale
and listofdata
the indexers,”
says Arnott.

SUBSCRIBE NOW
Nearly $5 trillion of assets are indexed to the S&P 500, says the index’s parent, S&P Global. When the managers
of all that money must buy a particular stock and sell a particular stock on a given day, almost at a given hour,
that’s an opportunity for other traders. Everyone knows it’s coming, yet it doesn’t get arbitraged away because
not enough money is trying to do so. In part—here’s the irony—that’s because so many trillions are invested in a
wide array of index funds on the belief that picking individual stocks doesn’t work.
Investors in S&P 500 index funds are the losers. Consider that the fund giants wage war to attract customers by
offering the lowest expense ratio; for Vanguard's S&P fund it’s four basis points, for Charles Schwab's it’s two,
for Fidelity's it’s 1.5. Yet the annual cost to clients of rebalancing for additions and deletions is 20 to 40 basis
points on average, Arnott calculates.
That cost, which is significant over time, can be at least partially avoided. A strategy of rebalancing three months
after
Most the effective date rather than the day before the effective date has beaten the index by 13 basis points on
Popular
average overshould18 years, Arnott and his colleaguesMeet
you get: Moderna, found. It seems
the companies leading an easy way for a fund to See
down 22%. improve
how your its
the charge to achieve net
performance.Pfizer,Butor Johnson
index& funds
Johnson?
don’t do it because it
zero would introduce tracking state is doing
error—and never mind that it
would be positive tracking error.
“The indexing community has trained customers to think zero tracking error is the goal,” Arnott says. “Even
positive tracking error is bad.”
Index funds on the whole are a boon for investors. Turns out they can be a boon in an unexpected way. An S&P
500 rebalance, says Arnott, “is a great opportunity to do the opposite of what the index does: buy the deletion
and sell the addition.” It may not pay off in every rebalance, but over time it “has historically proven to be an
excellent investment idea.” Even if it is supposed to be impossible.
SoundLink Color
Bluetooth® Speaker II
– Refurbishe
"Great Sound At An Even

BE"
New subscriber trial
$1 FOR 4 WEEKS
SPECIAL OFFER SHOP NOW
Award wining business news, insight and analysis
Investment insight and trend analysis
Exclusive access to rankings and list data
without all
Related the noise.
Articles
SUBSCRIBE NOW
CONFERENCES
Pandemic unemployment is cutting into stock market returns for women
October 12, 2021

BY JESSICA MATHEWS

Arnott - Beat The S&P

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Arnott - Beat The S&P

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

10/21/21, 11:11 AM Anyone can beat the stock market, new research suggests | Fortune

FINANCE • STOCK MARKET

Anyone can beat the stock market, new research suggests

New subscriber trial

How a spirit of collaboration fuels Cadence's

without all the noise.

"Great Sound At An Even

Pandemic unemployment is cutting into stock market returns for women

October 12, 2021

You might also like