Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The vitreous levels of the angiogenic poly- processes, the vascular endothelial cells that
peptide vascular endothelial growth factor comprise the network of blood vessels in the
(also known as vascular permeability factor) normal adult rarely proliferate and exist in a
were measured and compared in eyes with differentiated quiescent state. 2 · 3 In angiogenic
and without proliferative diabetic retinopa diseases such as proliferative diabetic retinopa
thy. Undiluted vitreous samples from 20 eyes thy, vascular endothelial cell growth control is
were collected at the time of vitrectomy, and lost, resulting in severe intraocular tissue inju
vascular endothelial growth factor levels were ry and blindness. Retinal ischemia precedes the
determined by using a time-resolved immuno- onset of retinal and iris neovascularization, and
fluorometric assay. Vitreous vascular endo ischémie retina has been identified as a poten
thelial growth factor levels were significantly tial source of diffusible angiogenic factors. 46
higher in eyes with proliferative diabetic reti The search for angiogenic factors has been
nopathy than in eyes without proliferative extensive, resulting in a growing list of endoge
diabetic retinopathy (P = .006; Wilcoxon Rank nous angiogenic and antiangiogenic factors1·7;
Sum Test). The median vitreous concentration however, the factors necessary for ocular neo
in the eyes with proliferative diabetic reti vascularization remain unknown.
nopathy was 29.1 pM and exceeded the known Vascular endothelial growth factor refers to a
concentration required for the maximal pro family of vascular endothelial cell mitogens
liferation of vascular endothelial cells in vi derived through alternative splicing of mRNA
tro. These data are consistent with vascular that promote vascular permeability and angi
endothelial growth factor serving as a physio ogenesis in vivo. 810 Unlike basic-fibroblast
logically relevant angiogenic factor in prolif growth factor, vascular endothelial growth fac
erative diabetic retinopathy. tor is a secreted angiogenic factor and targets
only vascular endothelial cells and mono-
ANGIOGENESIS is a necessary biologic process cytes. 911 Hypoxia in vitro and ischemia in vi
for development, ovulation, placental matura vo dramatically increase vascular endothelial
tion, and wound healing. 1 Exclusive of these growth factor mRNA in certain human tumors
and normal tissues.12·13 In a model of exper
imental iris neovascularization in the cy-
Accepted for publication April 8, 1994. nomolgus monkey, experimental retinal vein
From the Department of Ophthalmology, Massachu occlusion is associated with large increases of
setts Eye and Ear Infirmary (Drs. Adamis, Miller, Bemal,
and D'Amico); the Department of Surgery, Children's
inner retinal vascular endothelial growth factor
Hospital (Drs. Adamis a n d Folkman); a n d t h e Depart mRNA, as well as vitreous and aqueous vascu
ment of Pathology, Beth Israel Hospital (Drs. Yeo a n d lar endothelial growth factor protein. 14 In the
Yeo); Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts. same model, a spatial and temporal association
This study was supported in part by research grant
EY00325 from the National Institutes of Health (Dr.
between increased vascular endothelial growth
Adamis); and by the Beth Israel Pathology Foundation, factor protein levels and iris neovascularization
Inc. (Drs. T.-K. Yeo a n d K.-T. Yeo). This study was has been established, with the degree of vascu
presented in part at the Annual meeting of the Associa lar endothelial growth factor increase corre
tion for Research in Vision and Ophthalmology, Saraso-
ta, Florida, May 4, 1994.
lating with the severity of iris neovascular
Reprint requests to Anthony P. Adamis, M.D., Massa ization. 14 In separate studies of vascular
chusetts Eye and Ear Infirmary, 243 Charles St., Boston, endothelial growth factor-associated tumor an
MA 02114. giogenesis, neutralizing antibodies to vascular
endothelial growth factor directly inhibited tu regard to presence and degree of vitreous hem
mor angiogenesis and indirectly inhibited tu orrhage and retinal detachment (Table). Vitre
mor growth, 13 implicating vascular endothelial ous hemorrhage was graded as follows: 0 = no
growth factor as a requisite growth factor for vitreous hemorrhage; 1 = less than one fourth
tumor angiogenesis in vivo. of the retina obscured by blood; 2 = one fourth
In this study, we sought to determine if in to three fourths of the retina obscured by blood;
creased vascular endothelial growth factor lev 3 = total obstruction of the retina by fresh
els were associated with intraocular neovascu blood; 4 = total obstruction of the retina by
larization in human eyes. Utilizing a highly organized blood. Retinal detachment was de
sensitive and specific vascular endothelial scribed as fractional or rhegmatogenous, and
growth factor immunoassay, vitreous vascular graded according to the number of quadrants
endothelial growth factor levels were measured attached: 0 = retina attached; 1 = less than one
in eyes with and without proliferative diabetic fourth of the retina detached; 2 = one fourth to
retinopathy. We now show that vitreous vascu one half of the retina detached; 3 = greater than
lar endothelial growth factor protein levels are one half but less than three fourths of the retina
increased to physiologically relevant concen detached; 4 = three fourths to total retinal
trations in eyes with proliferative diabetic reti detachment.
nopathy. Patients 1 and 2 underwent extensive panret
inal photocoagulation for persistent neovascu
larization including fibrous proliferation pre
operatively. Patient 2 had a long-standing
Material and Methods history of neovascular glaucoma, controlled at
the time of surgery. Patient 7 underwent endo-
Human vitreous samples from 20 patients laser panretinal photocoagulation intraopera-
were collected in accordance with the guide tively but developed iris neovascularization
lines and recommendations of the Massachu three months later that was subsequently con
setts Eye and Ear Infirmary Human Studies trolled by supplemental panretinal photocoag
Committee. At the onset of vitrectomy, undilut ulation.
ed vitreous (50 to 100 μΐ) was collected via In the nonproliferative group, Patient 9 had
vitrectomy probe, transferred to a heparinized, grade C, type 1 proliferative vitreoretinopathy.
siliconized 1-ml tube, and frozen ( — 20 C). All Patient 14 had sustained blunt trauma that
patients were examined preoperatively and in- subsequently necessitated cataract extraction.
traoperatively by one of us (D.J.D. or J.W.M.), At the time of vitrectomy, the retinal detach
each of whom documented the clinical history ment was deemed irreparable secondary to
and status of each eye enrolled in the study. multiple posterior breaks, a large giant tear,
Samples were collected from eyes with either and grade C, type 2 proliferative vitreoretinop
proliferative diabetic retinopathy (n = 8) or athy. Patient 15 had a traumatic cataract re
other conditions requiring vitrectomy (n = 12). moved and a vitrectomy for a traumatic macular
None of the latter samples were from eyes with hole. Patient 17 had a vitreous hemorrhage,
intraocular neovascularization. All eyes in the subluxed lens, and phacolytic glaucoma after
proliferative diabetic retinopathy group were blunt trauma. At the time of surgery, the retina
categorized according to the modified Airlie was found to be attached but there was evi
House criteria as having neovascularization of dence of traumatic maculopathy. Patient 19 had
the disk, neovascularization elsewhere, fibrous long-standing uveitis and had a large traction
proliferation of the disk, or fibrous proliferation detachment with grade C, type 1 proliferative
elsewhere. 15 Fibrous proliferation was defined vitreoretinopathy.
as fibrous tissue with or without visible vessels. A two-site, time-resolved immunofluorome-
All eyes with proliferative diabetic retinopathy tric assay was used to measure human vitreous
had panretinal photocoagulation, in some cases vascular endothelial growth factor protein lev
incomplete, at some point before vitrectomy els using antibodies prepared against the N-
(range, three days to 36 months before vitrec and C-terminal peptides of vascular endotheli
tomy). Retinopathy was graded intraoperative- al growth factor.1617 Briefly, rabbit polyclonal
ly in all eyes because preoperative photographs antibodies were raised against synthetic pep
were precluded in some eyes by the presence of tides corresponding to the N-terminus of hu
vitreous hemorrhage. man vascular endothelial growth factor. Be
The ocular findings were further graded with cause the C-terminus is conserved in guinea pig
Vol. 118, No. 4 Increased Vascular Endothelial Growth Factor Levels 447
TABLE
PATIENT DATA
RETINAL VASCULAR
LASER DETACHMENT VITREOUS ENDOTHELIAL
PATIENT (MOS GRADE HEMORRHAGE GROWTH
NO. DIAGNOSIS NEOVASCULARIZATION PRIOR) AND TYPE GRADE FACTOR (pM)
and human vascular endothelial growth factor, LKB Nuclear, Gaithersburg, Maryland) to yield
a rabbit polyclonal antibody corresponding to a highly fluorescent chelate that was measured
the C-terminus of guinea pig vascular endothe in a time-resolved fluorimeter. The antibodies
lial growth factor was used. C-IgG was affinity- recognized all four forms of human vascular
purified and used to coat Maxisorp microtiter endothelial growth factor, and standardized
wells (Nunc, Inc., Naperville, Illinois). Sepa controls containing known concentrations of
rately, affinity-purified antibodies (IgG) direct human vascular endothelial growth factor were
ed against the N-terminus of human vascular used for calibration. The lower limit of detec
endothelial growth factor were labeled with tion was 5 pM vascular endothelial growth
Eu 3+ -chelate and used as second antibodies. factor (200 pg/ml).
After binding and washing, Eu3+ was dissociat The two groups were compared by using the
ed from the second antibodies with an enhance Wilcoxon Rank Sum Test. Samples with con
ment buffer containing ß-diketone (Pharmacia centrations below the detection threshold of
448 AMERICAN JOURNAL OF OPHTHALMOLOGY October, 1994
the immunoassay (<5 pM) were entered as stimulation of vascular endothelial prolifera
5 pM for all statistical calculations. No vitreous tion in vitro.14·20·21
samples were excluded in the analysis. By demonstrating increased vascular endo
thelial growth factor levels in the vitreous of
eyes with neovascularization secondary to pro
liferative diabetic retinopathy, our results are
Results
in agreement with the experimental data re
viewed previously. The median levels mea
In the proliferative diabetic retinopathy cate sured in our patients with diabetic retinopathy
gory (n = 8), the range of vascular endothelial are above the known concentration necessary
growth factor measurements was from < 5.0 to for the maximal proliferation of vascular endo
72.9 pM (Table). The median was 29.1 pM. In thelial cells in vitro (22 pM)21 and are similar to
the nonproliferative diabetic retinopathy cate those reported by others. 22 The vitreous con
gory (n = 12), the range of measurements was centrations in the eyes with proliferative dia
from <5.0 to 25.6 pM. The median was 8.1 pM. betic retinopathy are therefore likely to be
Analysis of these data demonstrated a statisti physiologically relevant.
cally significant increase in the vitreous vascu The source of the increased vitreous vascular
lar endothelial growth factor levels in the eyes endothelial growth factor is presumably isché
with proliferative diabetic retinopathy com mie retina; however, the possibility exists that
pared to the eyes without proliferative diabetic the increased levels are derived from the blood,
retinopathy (P = .006). serum, or elsewhere within the eye. Monocytes
The median level in eyes with vitreous hem are capable of synthesizing vascular endotheli
orrhage was 23.9 pM (range, 5.0 to 72.9 pM) as al growth factor and could conceivably contrib
compared to 6.1 pM (range, 2.0 to 25.0 pM) in ute to the levels measured. Moreover, analysis
eyes without vitreous hemorrhage. This differ of the data disclosed a statistically significant
ence was statistically significant (P = .02). association between vitreous hemorrhage and
There was a trend toward increase in the medi increased vascular endothelial growth factor.
an vascular endothelial growth factor levels in However, this is not surprising since vitreous
eyes with traction retinal detachments; howev hemorrhage is frequently associated with reti
er, the difference was not statistically signifi nal neovascularization and is not an indepen
cant (P = .07). dent variable. Although simultaneous blood
levels were not obtained, serum measurements
in normal humans 17 and in cynomolgus mon
keys both with and without intraocular neovas
Discussion cularization are consistently below detection
(5 pM).14 These data are consistent with the
Vascular endothelial growth factor was orig increased vitreous vascular endothelial growth
inally characterized as a vascular permeabil factor levels not being serum-derived. Finally,
ity factor which is 50,000 times more potent in situ hybridization of whole cynomolgus
than histamine. 8 In 1989, vascular endothelial monkey eyes with ischémie retinas and iris
growth factor was sequenced and found to be a neovascularization localized high vascular en
potent and specific angiogenic factor.9·10 It is dothelial growth factor mRNA transcript levels
present in a variety of tissues, including normal to the inner retina and not elsewhere within the
human retina and human retinal pigment epi eye.14 Although not direct proof, these data are
thelium in vitro. 1819 After laser retinal vein consistent with ischémie retina being the pri
occlusion, ischémie cynomolgus monkey inner mary source of intraocular vascular endothelial
retina expresses high levels of vascular endo growth factor protein.
thelial growth factor mRNA, whereas it is bare One eye with proliferative diabetic retinopa
ly detectable in nonischemic retina. 14 Similarly, thy had no detectable vascular endothelial
hypoxic human retinal pigment epithelial cells growth factor in the vitreous. This may repre
in vitro upregulate vascular endothelial growth sent protein degradation during collection and
factor mRNA and secreted protein. 20 Secreted processing, or vitreous sampling outside the
vascular endothelial growth factor levels in time period of maximal vascular endothelial
both experimental systems are increased to growth factor production. Vitreous sampling
concentrations above those necessary for the outside the time period is a distinct possibility,
Vol. 118, No. 4 Increased Vascular Endothelial Growth Factor Levels 449
as our sampling represented only a single time fibroblast growth factor may be a potent angio
point in the disease. In the monkey model of iris genic combination in vivo. We and others have
neovascularization, aqueous levels decreased demonstrated marked synergism between vas
before the regression of the new vessels. Never cular endothelial growth factor and basic-fibro
theless, the possibility remains that vascular blast growth factor in their ability to stimulate
endothelial growth factor is not increased angiogenesis in vitro.24,25
above the detection threshold in some eyes Although this study demonstrates a strong
with diabetic retinopathy and that other growth association between increased vascular endo
factors (for example, basic fibroblast growth thelial growth factor levels and proliferative
factor) are the primary angiogenic growth fac diabetic retinopathy, and identifies vascular
tors driving neovascularization. endothelial growth factor as a potentially im
The eyes with proliferative diabetic retinopa portant ocular angiogenic factor in diabetic
thy all had panretinal photocoagulation before retinopathy, its confirmation as a physiologi
vitrectomy, whereas none of the control eyes cally relevant and requisite ocular angiogenic
had any laser photocoagulation. It is possible factor awaits the results of in vivo intraocular
that laser photocoagulation resulted in the in vascular endothelial growth factor neutraliza
creased vascular endothelial growth factor lev tion experiments.
els. This is unlikely, however, because animal
studies have demonstrated that laser photoco
agulation of monkey retina (without retinal
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
vein closure) does not result in any appreciable
Elizabeth N. Allred, M.S., Neuroepidemi-
increase in the vitreous or aqueous vascular
ology Unit, Children's Hospital, Boston, Mas
endothelial growth factor levels for 15 days, the
longest time point measured. 14 Furthermore, sachusetts, provided statistical analysis.
the vascular endothelial growth factor levels in
the lasered human eyes in this study do not
correlate with the timing (Table) or extent of References
photocoagulation. The best way to address this
concern is to measure vitreous levels in diabetic
human eyes without prior panretinal photoco 1. Folkman, J., and Klagsburn, M.: Angiogenic
factors. Science 235:442, 1987.
agulation; however, this is problematic, as al 2. Hobson, B., and Denekamp, J.: Endothelial pro
most none of these eyes initially progress to liferation in tumours and normal tissues. Continuous
vitrectomy. labelling studies. Br. J. Cancer 49:405, 1984.
Although the median vascular endothelial 3. Engerman, R. L., Pfaffenbach, D., and Davis,
growth factor levels were significantly lower in M. D.: Cell turnover of capillaries. Lab. Invest.
eyes without diabetic retinopathy, there were 17:738, 1967.
several notable exceptions. All four nonprolif- 4. Michaelson, I. C: The mode of development of
erative diabetic eyes with retinal detachments the vascular system of the retina, with some observa
tions on its significance for certain retinal disease.
had increased levels. Similarly, most of the eyes Trans. Ophthalmol. Soc. U. K. 68:137, 1948.
with proliferative diabetic retinopathy had reti 5. Ashton, N.: Retinal vascularization in health
nal detachments, a condition that results in and disease. Am. J. Ophthalmol. 44:7, 1957.
outer retinal ischemia and potentially in 6. Wise, G. N.: Retinal neovascularization. Trans.
creased vascular endothelial growth factor ex Am. Ophthalmol. Soc. 54:729, 1956.
pression. Formal comparison disclosed a trend 7. Folkman, J., and Shing, Y.: Angiogenesis. J. Biol.
toward higher levels in the eyes with retinal Chem. 267:10931, 1992.
detachments (P = .07). Additional measure 8. Senger, D. R., Van De Water, L., Brown, L. F.,
ments may uncover a true association. Nagy, J. A., Yeo, K.-T., Yeo, T.-T., Berse, B., Jackman,
In a similar study of human diabetics, in R. W., Dvorak, A. M., and Dvorak, H. F.: Vascular
creased levels of the angiogenic peptide basic- permeability factor (VPF, VEGF) in tumor biology.
Cancer Metastasis Rev. 12:303, 1993.
fibroblast growth factor were demonstrated 9. Keck, P. J., Häuser, S. D., Krivi, G., Sanzo, K.,
in the vitreous of eyes with proliferative dia Warren, T., Feder, J., and Connolly, D. T.: Vascular
betic retinopathy, implicating basic-fibroblast permeability factor, an endothelial mitogen related
growth factor as a potential ocular angiogenic to PDGF. Science 246:1309, 1989.
growth factor in vivo.23 This is notable because 10. Leung, D. W., Cachianes, G., Kuang, W. J.,
vascular endothelial growth factor and basic- Goeddel, D. V., and Ferrara, N.: Vascular endothelial
450 AMERICAN JOURNAL OF OPHTHALMOLOGY October, 1994
growth factor is a secreted angiogenic mitogen. Sci (VEGF) has a different distribution than basic fibro-
ence 246:1306, 1989. blast growth factor (bFGF) in the adult human retina.
11. Clauss, M., Gerlach, M., Gerlach, H., Brett, J., ARVO abstracts. Supplement to Invest. Ophthalmol.
Wang, F., Familletti, P. C , Pan, Y. C , Olander, J. V., Vis. Sei. Philadelphia, J. B. Lippincott, 1992, p. 651.
Connolly, D. T., and Stern, D.: Vascular permeability 19. Adamis, A. P., Shima, D. T., Yeo, K.-T., Yeo,
factor. A tumor derived polypeptide that induces T.-K., Brown, L. F., Berse, B., D'Amore, P. A., and
endothelial cell and monocyte procoagulant activity, Folkman, J.: Synthesis and secretion of vascular per
and promotes monocyte migration. J. Exp. Med. meability factor/vascular endothelial growth factor
172:1535, 1990. by human retinal pigment epithelial cells. Biochem.
12. Shweiki, D., Itin, A., Soffer, D., and Keshet, E.: Biophys. Res. Commun. 193:631, 1993.
Vascular endothelial growth factor induced by hy- 20. Shima, D., Adamis, A. P., Yeo, K.-T., Yeo,
poxia may mediate hypoxia-initiated angiogenesis. T.-K., Berse, B., and Brown, L.: Hypoxie regulation of
Nature 359:843, 1992. vascular permeability factor (vascular endothelial
13. Kim, K. J., Li, B., Winer, J., Armanini, M., growth factor) mRNA and protein secretion by hu
Gillett, N., Phillips, H. S., and Ferrara, N.: Inhibition man retinal pigment epithelial cells. ARVO abstracts.
of vascular endothelial growth factor-induced angio Supplement to Invest. Ophthalmol. Vis. Sei. Phila
genesis suppresses tumour growth in vivo. Nature delphia, J. B. Lippincott, 1993, p. 990.
362:841, 1993. 21. Ferrara, N., Houck, K. A., Jakeman, L. B.,
14. Miller, J. W., Adamis, A. P., Shima, D. T., Winer, J., and Leung, D. W.: The vascular endothelial
D'Amore, P. A., Moulton, R. S., O'Reilly, M. S., growth factor family of polypeptides. J. Cell Bio
Folkman, J., Dvorak, H. F., Brown, L. F., Berse, B., chem. 47:211, 1991.
Yeo, T.-K., and Yeo, K.-T.: Vascular endothelial 22. Plouet, J., Chollet, P., Pagot, V., Chauvaud, D.,
growth factor/vascular permeability factor is tem Korobelnik, J., Favard, C , Mathis, A., and Malecaze,
porally and spatially correlated with ocular angio F.: Vasculotropin/VEGF levels in the vitreous of
genesis in a primate model. Am. J. Pathol. In press. patients with proliferative diabetic retinopathy.
15. Diabetic Retinopathy Study: Report number 6. ARVO abstracts. Supplement to Invest. Ophthalmol.
Design, methods, and baseline results. Report num Vis. Sei. Philadelphia, J. B. Lippincott, 1992, p. 1363.
ber 7. A modification of the Airlie House classifica 23. Sivalingam, A., Kenney, J., Brown, G. C , Ben
tion of diabetic retinopathy. Invest. Ophthalmol. Vis. son, W. E., and Donoso, L.: Basic fibroblast growth
Sei. 21:1, 1981. factor levels in the vitreous of patients with prolif
16. Yeo, K.-T., Sioussat, T. M., Faix, J. D., Senger, erative diabetic retinopathy. Arch. Ophthalmol.
D. R., and Yeo, T.-K.: Development of time-resolved 108:869, 1990.
immunofluorometric assay of vascular permeability 24. Goto, F., Goto, K., Weindel, K., and Folkman,
factor. Clin. Chem. 38:71, 1992. J.: Synergistic effects of vascular endothelial growth
17. Yeo, K.-T., Wang, H. H., Nagy, J. A., Sioussat, factor and basic fibroblast growth factor on the prolif
T. M , Ledbetter, S. R., Hoogewerf, A.-J., Zhou, Y., eration and cord formation of bovine capillary endo
Masse, E. M., Senger, D. R., Dvorak, H. F., and Yeo, thelial cells within collagen gels. Lab. Invest. 69:508,
T.-K.: Vascular permeability factor (vascular endo 1993.
thelial growth factor) in guinea pig and human tumor 25. Pepper, M. S., Ferrara, N., Orci, L., and Monte-
inflammatory effusions. Cancer Res. 53:2912, 1993. sano, R.: Potent synergism between vascular endo
18. McGookin, E. D., Stopa, E. G., Kuo-LeBlanc, thelial growth factor and basic fibroblast growth
V., Baird, A., Gonzalez, A., Hanneken, A., and factor in the induction of angiogenesis in vitro.
Streeten, B.: Vascular endothelial growth factor Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 189:824, 1992.