You are on page 1of 12

Big shifts,

small steps
Survey of Sustainability Reporting 2022

Executive Summary

KPMG International October 2022


About the survey
Welcome to KPMG’s biennial Survey of Sustainability Reporting 2022
First published in 1993, this 2022 survey marks the Estonia, the Philippines, Uruguay, Venezuela and
twelfth edition, examining sustainability reporting Vietnam. While Chile and Israel return to the survey Visit home.kpmg/sustainabilityreporting
trends around the world. Over the past two decades, after not reporting in 2020, Ecuador — a 2020 for more information about the survey and
sustainability reporting has been largely voluntary, so the participant — has not participated this time. KPMG to explore the data in more detail using an
purpose of this survey was to offer meaningful insights professionals analyzed financial reports, sustainability
interactive online tool.
about how to improve levels of disclosure by business and Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG)
leaders, sustainability professionals, and company reports, and websites for 5,800 companies in
boards. Today, we are on the precipice of adopting 58 countries, territories, and jurisdictions. The survey
mandatory and regulated sustainability reporting and provides information and insights for those preparing
the reporting landscape is poised to change drastically. their own organization’s sustainability report, as
The findings in this report reflect on the current state of well as for investors, asset managers and ratings
reporting today, the gaps that should be filled to meet agencies who now factor sustainability and ESG
regulatory requirements and the overarching business information into their corporate performance and risk
strategy considerations that can allow companies to assessments.
meet increasing regulatory expectations while still The 2022 survey includes a number of new topics,
creating impact and generating value. including the use of materiality assessments, reporting
This is our most extensive survey to date, with five on social risks, and reporting on governance risks.
new member firms contributing to the research:

© 2022 Copyright owned by one or more of the KPMG International entities. KPMG International entities provide no services to clients. All rights reserved. Big shifts, small steps 2
Foreword
As business owners and professionals, we know that as well as broader ESG considerations, into greater and
what gets managed gets measured. sustained account. These HQ conversations become
Today’s corporate sustainability reporting less about what a company ‘must’ do (comply) and more
requirements provide solid frameworks that make about what a company ‘wants’ to do (bring change). This
reporting consistent and relative, as well as enable us is a good thing.
to measure and compare our impacts and outcomes. And it’s not free.
Established requirements like GRI have traction, and Without question, this modern and holistic approach
new and emerging frameworks such as the TNFD will include sustained discretionary spending with
are necessarily expanding the reporting landscape. ESG remaining a line item on the annual financial plan.
Leading practices and lessons learned accelerate our John McCalla Leacy
Company leaders should budget the required human and
capabilities to maximize the frameworks effectively Head of Global ESG
financial resources to face our global ESG predicaments
and efficiently. Together, these tools help us KPMG International and Partner,
head-on — with grit and zeal — continuously. There is
achieve our shared goal of greater consistency and KPMG in the UK
no one-and-done. This is a long-term commitment; an
consolidation in this reporting realm. annual expenditure we should get comfortable with if we
But it can’t be just a casual tick-the-box exercise. genuinely intend to effect real change within and across
Companies need to continue to make urgent progress our borders.
with ESG reporting in a way that supports their short- With significant concerns of the changing climate,
term and long-term business objectives. A robust increased conflict, rising inflation subsequently
sustainability reporting ecosystem will help businesses escalating the cost of living, and the looming threat
not only measure progress on executing their ESG of another recession in less than two decades, this
strategy, but also support businesses in driving value has become a critical intersection for leaders. Those
while mobilizing capital markets to help support with vision and an unyielding focus on the future will
innovative and much-needed solutions to the many likely seek and embrace business opportunities for
societal issues we face. long-term value creation in a purpose-led, sustainable,
Corporate sustainability reporting can — and should — low-carbon economy.
start driving a different conversation such that business We have tools. We have knowledge and awareness.
owners stretch their thinking and ensure, from the top We have responsibility. Let’s commit.
down, leadership across our organizations are making
principled and strategic decisions that take the climate,

© 2022 Copyright owned by one or more of the KPMG International entities. KPMG International entities provide no services to clients. All rights reserved. Big shifts, small steps 3
Glossary
CSRD: IPCC: TCFD:
Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change Task Force on Climate-related Financial
Disclosures

ESG: ISSB:
Environmental, social and governance International Sustainability Standards Board TMT:
Technology, media and telecommunications

EU: N100:
European Union Worldwide sample of the top 100 companies by TNFD:
revenue in 58 countries, territories and jurisdictions Taskforce on Nature-related Financial Disclosures

G250:
World’s 250 largest companies by revenue SASB: US SEC:
based on the 2021 Fortune 500 ranking Sustainability Accounting Standards Board United States Securities and Exchange
Commission

GRI: SDG:
Global Reporting Initiative United Nations Sustainable Development Goals

© 2022 Copyright owned by one or more of the KPMG International entities. KPMG International entities provide no services to clients. All rights reserved. Big shifts, small steps 4
Big shifts, small steps
The survey’s title ‘Big shifts, small steps’ acknowledges the many ways in which the Over the past 3 decades, our surveys have shown that sustainability reporting has
world has changed over the past 2 years. Regulators and non-profit standard-setters become an accepted part of disclosure and transparency for many large companies,
around the world have taken significant action around non-financial disclosure during with a continued uptake of sustainability reporting globally and increasing integration
this period, as shown below. More importantly, corporations are evolving in real time into mainstream financial reporting. With this increased transparency comes greater
with shifting priorities in the world around them. Events like the IPPC ‘Code Red for accountability for action around reducing carbon emissions, halting biodiversity loss,
Humanity’ report, the COVID-19 pandemic, the Black Lives Matter movement, and and tackling societal inequality. Yet, this work is challenging and growth in reporting
the Russian government’s invasion of Ukraine have drawn strong reactions from the has slowed as companies focus inward, assessing the investment necessary to
public, but now the public expects corporations to react to such events as well. mitigate their risks and take advantage of the opportunities that have come to light.

April 2021 November 2021 February 2022 April 2022


European Commission adopts • IFRS Foundation announces the • The EU adopts a proposal • European Financial
the CSRD proposal, which will formation of its global reporting for a Directive on Reporting Advisory Board
require large companies to report standardization initiative through the Corporate Sustainability issues exposure draft of
on social and environmental ISSB. Due Diligence with rules the European
impacts starting in 2024 • UK Financial Conduct Authority for companies to respect Sustainability Reporting
releases Sustainability Disclosure human rights and the Standard (ESRS) for public
Requirements discussion paper environment in their global commentary
• Hong Kong Stock Exchange publishes value chains
mandatory climate disclosure guidance • Targeted revisions issued
for the CSRD proposal

March 2021 October 2021 December 2021 March 2022 June 2022
Sustainable Finance Disclosure • GRI standards updated • Singapore Stock Exchange • US SEC announces • China‘s voluntary Guidance for
Regulations (SFDR) go into issues mandatory disclosure climate disclosure Enterprise ESG Disclosure
effect for asset managers and recommendations on climate proposal takes effect
and board diversity • ISSB releases • Johannesburg Stock Exchange
financial advisers operating in
the EU • The European Commission publishes guidance
exposure draft for
published the first delegated documents on voluntary
public commentary
act on sustainable activities sustainability and climate
for the first two • change disclosure
environmental objectives of Council of the EU and
the EU Taxonomy European Parliament reach
agreement on CSRD
Note: This timeline is intended to provide a sample of developments in non-financial disclosure and is not intended to be provide a complete or comprehensive view.

© 2022 Copyright owned by one or more of the KPMG International entities. KPMG International entities provide no services to clients. All rights reserved. Big shifts, small steps 5
What can you do?
The world is facing complex climate, social and In light of the trends highlighted in this Each company’s sustainability reporting
geopolitical issues and addressing ESG priorities is
more important than ever.
survey, here are some tangible ways journey will be unique. Whether you
businesses can begin to navigate the report on climate-risk or biodiversity,
As we publish this edition, the looming threat of a sustainability reporting landscape:
recession is raising concerns that ESG issues may be align with the SDGs or SASB, or
put on the back burner in favor of financial survival. • Understand stakeholder expectations choose to report on 10 or 100 metrics,
But the world has changed since the last recession
using stakeholder materiality a successful program will comply with
and ESG provides insights into the long-term
sustainability of a business. The COVID-19 pandemic assessments to inform your business mandatory reporting rules, accurately
placed a spotlight on the need for business resiliency strategy and prioritize your focus. and reliably reflect the material impacts
and disclosure is necessary to communicate how
the company has on the environment
you are prepared for the future. The findings in this • Determine strategic imperatives
report provide a roadmap to the following key trends and society, and effectively describe
against key ESG topics and define
you should know as you plan your approach to ESG how the company integrates ESG risks
reporting. We have seen much progress over the key metrics, considering impending
and opportunities into its business
past few years in climate-related reporting — the E in regulations.
ESG — but this now needs to translate to social and strategy. As we continue to see big
governance. Companies continue to find it challenging • Establish a cross-functional shifts, you can be confident that KPMG
to strike a balance in sustainability reporting, with governance structure to collect, report is ready to walk alongside you as you
a continued slant towards positive reporting and
and approve sustainability and ESG take your next steps.
qualitative descriptions of impact and limited insight
into the impact of the environment and society on the information.
business itself. Companies must find a way to address
both their positive and negative impacts. • Consider investing in quality non-
financial data management, including
Uncertainty has become the new normal for
businesses and our advice to business leaders is to documenting process and testing
prepare now on sustainability reporting as change is controls over the information, or
coming at a rapid pace.
system implementation.

© 2022 Copyright owned by one or more of the KPMG International entities. KPMG International entities provide no services to clients. All rights reserved. Big shifts, small steps 6
About the lead authors

John McCalla-Leacy Jennifer Shulman Richard Threlfall


Head of Global ESG Global Lead for the ESG Advisory Hub, Head of Global Infrastructure,
KPMG International and Partner, KPMG International and Partner, Government and Healthcare,
KPMG in the UK KPMG in Canada KPMG International

John has more than 20 years of experience in Jennifer works at the intersection of economics, Richard is Global Head of Infrastructure,
senior and leadership roles at KPMG, and is a finance and ESG. She has more than 20 years Government and Healthcare. He has almost
strong external advocate for the ’S’ in ESG driving of experience helping clients with complex 30 years of experience in policy, governance,
inclusion, diversity, and social equality outside economic analyses, value and cost/ benefit issues strategy and financing, advising both public and
of the firm. John is very experienced in leading in multiple settings, including ESG strategy and private sector clients in the UK and overseas.
rapid, complex change. He is a former senior business transformation, ESG measurement and
Richard has an extensive network of contacts
leader within KPMG’s Global Center of Excellence impact analysis, and ESG reporting.
across the infrastructure, transport, utility and
Mergers & Acquisitions team. To date, he has led
Jennifer helps clients with multiple stakeholders construction markets and the related political,
both the overall and technology aspects of some
to develop and implement funding and costing financial and legal communities, in the UK and
of the largest multi-billion-dollar client mergers,
methodologies and strategies, thereby bringing internationally. He has a long-standing reputation
acquisitions and divestments that KPMG has ever
together elements of economics, statistical for leading clients through complex and politically
supported across multiple sectors and geographies.
modeling, cost accounting, and game theory. high-profile transactions and providing strategic,
John focuses on inspiring and driving rapid ESG- financial and governance advice.
related change for KPMG firms and their clients.
Richard is Chair of the International Coalition
for Sustainable Infrastructure, and KPMG’s
representative on the World Business Council for
Sustainable Development.

© 2022 Copyright owned by one or more of the KPMG International entities. KPMG International entities provide no services to clients. All rights reserved. Big shifts, small steps 7
Executive summary
96% 64%
Less than half
of companies
report on
of G250 companies report on
sustainability or ESG matters
of the G250 acknowledge climate
change as a risk to their business biodiversity loss
TCFD adoption nearly doubled
GRI, TCFD and SDGs in 2 years, going from

form the most commonly used anchors for


sustainability reporting
37% to 61%
among the G250

49% 71%
Fewer than half of
G250 companies
have leadership level
of the G250 acknowledge social of N100 companies representation for

sustainability
elements as a risk to their business, with identify material
Western Europe as the leading region ESG topics

© 2022 Copyright owned by one or more of the KPMG International entities. KPMG International entities provide no services to clients. All rights reserved. Big shifts, small steps 8
The 2022 survey findings indicate five The number of companies reporting against TCFD these risks are overwhelmingly narrative-driven and
major trends in sustainability reporting: has nearly doubled, leading to more consistent and do not quantify the financial impact of these risks on
comparable climate disclosure. companies or on society.
1. Sustainability reporting grows Sustainability continues to become a priority
3. Growing awareness of biodiversity risk for company leadership but there is room for
incrementally with movement towards improvement. Only one-third of companies in the
2022 is a pivotal year for nature and biodiversity with
the use of standards framed by international efforts stepping up to halt biodiversity N100 have a dedicated member of their board or
stakeholder materiality assessments loss. Despite growing awareness of biodiversity loss as leadership team responsible for sustainability matters.
a critical issue, less than half of companies recognize Compensation conditions related to sustainability
The rates of sustainability reporting among the world’s
this loss as a risk to the business. On the positive side, outcomes for leadership teams are prevalent for only
leading 250 companies are at an impressive 96
most sectors now acknowledge this risk, even many of 40 percent of G250 companies.
percent. Reporting rates are expected to grow as new
regulation on non-financial reporting is introduced. those that can be considered low risk. The launch of the
TNFD and CSRD frameworks are expected to drive up
While there is still a need for global consistency in ESG reporting in the immediate years.
reporting, existing standards have increased in usage.
The GRI remains the most dominant standard used
around the world, though some regions have a clear
4. UN SDG reporting prioritizes
preference for SASB or local stock exchange guidelines. quantity over quality
For the first time, the survey looked at how many The majority of companies report on SDGs, with
companies carry out materiality assessments, finding 10 percent of companies reporting against all 17
that around three-quarters across both the N100 and SDGs. Three SDGs remain the most popular for
G250 use materiality assessments. companies: 8: Decent Work and Economic Growth;
12: Responsible Consumption and Production; and
2. Increased reporting on climate- 13: Climate Action.

related risks and carbon reduction


5. Climate risk reporting leads, followed
targets, in line with TCFD
by social and governance risks
The survey found that nearly three-quarters of
Since 2017, there has been a marked improvement in
companies report their carbon targets, although
the number of companies that acknowledge climate
20 percent do not disclose any link to an external
change as a risk to their business. However, less than
target (such as a 1.5˚C scenario).
half of companies report on social and governance
risks to their business. In general, the description of

© 2022 Copyright owned by one or more of the KPMG International entities. KPMG International entities provide no services to clients. All rights reserved. Big shifts, small steps 9
Research samples: G250 and N100
Our 2022 report is based on data
from two different research
samples: the G250 and the N100.
The G250 refers to the world’s 250 largest
companies by revenue based on the 2021 Fortune
500 ranking. Large global companies tend to lead
in sustainability reporting and provide a useful
gauge for broader trends that are eventually
adopted more widely.
The N100 refers to a worldwide sample of the
top 100 companies by revenue in 58 countries,
territories and jurisdictions researched in this
study. These N100 statistics provide a broad-
based snapshot of sustainability reporting.
See page 73 for more details of these research
samples and the research methodology.

The representation of Chinese


companies in the G250 has grown from
61 companies to 74 companies.
China now represents the largest
contributor to the G250.

© 2022 Copyright owned by one or more of the KPMG International entities. KPMG International entities provide no services to clients. All rights reserved. Big shifts, small steps 10
Contacts
Angola Hong Kong (SAR), China Johann Schnabel Kazuhiko Saito
Martim Santos Pat Woo E: jschnabel@kpmg.com E: kazuhiko.saito@jp.kpmg.com
E: martimsantos@kpmg.com E: pat.woo@kpmg.com Greece Kazakhstan
Argentina Colombia Dimitris Papakanellou Gabit Musrepov
Romina Bracco Juanita Lopez E: dpapakanellou@kpmg.gr E: gmusrepov@kpmg.kz
E: rbracco@kpmg.com.ar E: juanitalopez@kpmg.com Hungary Timur Omashev
E: tomashev@kpmg.kz
Australia Costa Rica István Szabó
Adrian King Luis Rivera E: istvan.szabo@kpmg.hu Luxembourg
E: avking@kpmg.com.au E: lgrivera@kpmg.com Iceland Julie Castiaux
E: julie.castiaux@kpmg.lu
Austria Cyprus Hafþór Ægir Sigurjónsson
Peter Ertl Antonis Bargilly E: hsigurjonsson@kpmg.is Malaysia
E: pertl@kpmg.at E: antonis.bargilly@kpmg.com.cy India Oy Cheng Phang
E: oychengphang@kpmg.com.my
Belgium Czech Republic Shivananda Shetty
Steven Mulkens Miroslava Prokesova E: sshetty6@kpmg.com Mexico
E: smulkens@kpmg.com E: mprokesova@kpmg.cz Ireland Juan Carlos Resendiz
Colm O’Se E: jresendiz@kpmg.com.mx
Brazil Estonia
Nelmara Arbex Siim Kannistu E: colm.ose@kpmg.ie Netherlands
E: narbex@kpmg.com.br E: skannistu@kpmg.com Conor Holland Marco Frikkee
E: conor.holland@kpmg.ie E: frikkee.marco@kpmg.nl
Canada Finland
Tomas Otterström Israel New Zealand
Doron Telem
E: dorontelem@kpmg.ca E: tomas.otterstrom@kpmg.fi Hadas Mishli Ian Proudfoot
E: hmishli@kpmg.com E: iproudfoot@kpmg.co.nz
Chile France
Jeremie Joos Italy Nigeria
Karin Eggers
E: karineggers@kpmg.com E: jeremiejoos@kpmg.fr Piermario Barzaghi Tomi Adepoju
Fanny Houlliot E: pbarzaghi@kpmg.it E: tomi.adepoju@ng.kpmg.com
China
E: fhoulliot@kpmg.fr Japan Norway
Patrick Chu
E: patrick.chu@kpmg.com Germany Junichi Adachi Stine Hattestad Bratsberg
Jan-Hendrik Gnändiger E: junichi.adachi@jp.kpmg.com E: stine.hattestad.bratsberg@kpmg.no

E: jgnaendiger@kpmg.com

© 2022 Copyright owned by one or more of the KPMG International entities. KPMG International entities provide no services to clients. All rights reserved. Big shifts, small steps 11
Pakistan Romania Spain UAE
Syed Ahson Ali Shah Ramona Jurubita Ramon Pueyo Fadi Alshihabi
E: ahsonshah@kpmg.com E: rjurubita@kpmg.com E: rpueyo@kpmg.es E: falshihabi@kpmg.com
Panama Saudi Arabia Sri Lanka UK
Arturo Carvajal Fadi Alshihabi Pyumi Sumanasekara George Richards
E: acarvajal@kpmg.com E: falshihabi@kpmg.com E: psumanasekara@kpmg.com E: george.richards@kpmg.co.uk
Peru Singapore Sweden Uruguay
María Julia Sáenz Kam Yuen Lau Torbjörn Westman Italo Elola
E: mariajuliasaenz@kpmg.com E: kamyuenlau@kpmg.com.sg E: torbjorn.westman@kpmg.se E: ielola@kpmg.com
Philippines Slovakia Switzerland US
Kristine Aguirre Michal Maxim Silvan Jurt Maura Hodge
E: kiaguirre@kpmg.com E: mmaxim@kpmg.sk E: sjurt@kpmg.com E: mhodge@kpmg.com
Poland Miroslava Plevova Taiwan Venezuela
Iwona Galbierz-Sztrauch E: miroslavaplevova@kpmg.sk Niven Huang Yanelly Marquez
E: igalbierz@kpmg.pl South Africa E: nivenhuang@kpmg.com.tw E: ymarquez@kpmg.com

Portugal Poogendri Reddy Thailand Vietnam


Martim Santos E: poogendri.reddy@kpmg.co.za Ganesan Kolandevelu John Ditty
E: martimsantos@kpmg.com South Korea E: ganesan@kpmg.co.th E: jditty@kpmg.com.vn
Pedro Cruz Kim Jung Nam Turkey
E: pqcruz@kpmg.com E: jungnamkim@kr.kpmg.com Sirin Soysal
Dong-Seok Lee E: ssoysal@kpmg.com
E: dongseoklee@kr.kpmg.com

Some or all of the services described herein may not be permissible for KPMG audit clients and their affiliates or related entities.

home.kpmg/socialmedia

The information contained herein is of a general nature and is not intended to address the circumstances of any particular individual or entity. Although we endeavor to provide accurate and timely information, there can be no guarantee that such
information is accurate as of the date it is received or that it will continue to be accurate in the future. No one should act on such information without appropriate professional advice after a thorough examination of the particular situation.

KPMG refers to the global organization or to one or more of the member firms of KPMG International Limited (“KPMG International”), each of which is a separate legal entity. KPMG International Limited is a private English company limited by
guarantee and does not provide services to clients. For more detail about our structure please visit home.kpmg/governance.

© 2022 Copyright owned by one or more of the KPMG International entities. KPMG International entities provide no services to clients. All rights reserved.

Throughout this document, “we”, “KPMG”, “us” and “our” refers to the global organization or to one or more of the member firms of KPMG International Limited (“KPMG International”), each of which is a separate legal entity.

The KPMG name and logo are trademarks used under license by the independent member firms of the KPMG global organization.

Designed by Evalueserve | Publication name: Big shifts, small steps | Publication number: 138331-G | Publication date: October 2022

You might also like