eBook

ETL Tools in 2024

How to Evaluate Effectively?

Extract Transform Load

 Table of Contents

Introduction 02

What is ETL ? 03

Top ETL tools in 2024 04-05

Best Practices for Evaluating ETL Tools 06-08

Key issues & Solutions 09-11

Introduction
In today's digital landscape, all IT systems are intrinsically tied to
data, whether they're producers or consumers of data. Integrating
these systems isn't just a luxury; it's becoming a necessity. That's
where ETL tools (Extract, Transform, Load) step in, addressing a
critical business need: the seamless integration of disparate systems,
be it in real-time (synchronous) or scheduled (asynchronously).

In this eBook, we'll explore the leading ETL tools of 2024 as assessed
by CloudTDMS customers and how they're affected by AI and the
Cloud technologies. We'll also discuss best practices and key
considerations for selecting the right ETL tool to meet your business
needs.

www.CloudTDMS.com 2/12
What is ETL?
ETL stands for Extract, Transform, Load. It's the process of extracting data
from different sources, transforming it, then loading it into a destination like
a database or datalake.

Retrieving data from different sources such as databases,

Extract
files, or web services.

Manipulating the extracted data to meet specific

Transform requirements, such as cleaning, aggregating, or converting
formats.

Inserting the transformed data into target destinations, such

Load
as a database, datalake, or application.

Is ETL still relevant or is it dead ?

Despite the emergence of alternative methodologies like cloud, big data &
streaming, ETL continues to serve as a cornerstone for many businesses.
ETL has evolved significantly over the past four decades, and its
transformation shows no signs of slowing down. Today, ETL solutions are
increasingly cloud-based, automated, and customized to meet diverse
use cases.

Impact of AI & Cloud on ETL landscape

AI and cloud technologies have impacted the ETL landscape by introducing
automation and scalability.
With AI, ETL tools can automate data processing tasks like data
cleansing, quality assurance, correlations and regressions.
The emergence of Synthetic Data (Generative AI), plays a pivotal
role in expediting ETL projects and implementing a shift left
strategy that was challenging in many ETL projects due to the
unavailability of test data.
Cloud platforms provide scalability and flexibility, allowing ETL
processes to handle large datasets from various sources
seamlessly. Additionally, cloud-based ETL solutions offer faster
deployment.

www.CloudTDMS.com 3/12
 Top ETL Tools in 2024

Data Integrator InfoSphere

Informatica DataStage Fivetran Integrate.io

Azure Data Google Stitch

Factory Data Fusion AWS Glue (Qlik) Matillion

Apache Airflow Apache Nifi Cdata Dbt

Airbyte Meltano

A robust tool for seamless extraction, transformation, and

Informatica
loading (ETL) of data across disparate sources and targets.

Comprehensive platform for all data integration needs, from

Oracle Data
batch loads to real-time processes, including SOA-enabled
Integrator
data services.

IBM A graphical data integration tool supporting real-time

DataStage integration from diverse sources, including Hadoop.

ETL tool for comprehensive data integration, covering

Talend
preparation, quality, application integration, and big data.

Automated data movement platform moving data out of,

Fivetran
into and across your cloud data platforms.

Cloud-based ETL platform with intuitive interface and

Integrate.io scalability for seamless data integration, transformation, and
management across sources and destinations.

Cloud-based data integration service for orchestrating and

Azure Data
automating the movement and transformation of data
Factory
across various sources and destinations.

www.CloudTDMS.com 4/12
 Google Data Managed service for building and managing data pipelines
Fusion for ETL and data integration on Google Cloud Platform.

Managed extract, transform, and load (ETL) service that

AWS Glue makes it easy to prepare and load data for analytics on
Amazon Web Services.

Cloud-first data integration service that simplifies data

Stitch (Qlik) movement and replication for analytics and business
intelligence purposes.

Data processing and analysis platform focusing on ETL tasks,

Ab Initio data warehousing, and business intelligence solutions.

Cloud-native data integration platform empowering

Matillion organizations to extract, transform, and load data effortlessly
across various sources.

Open-source platform for easy data integration, allowing

Airbyte
users to sync data from multiple sources effortlessly.

Apache Open-source workflow management platform using DAGs for

Airflow simplified task organization and management.

Open-source ETL tool with flow-based programming and web

Apache NiFi UI for easy real-time data flow management (drag & drop).

On-prem/cloud data replication tool automating data

Cdata movement with near real-time updates & change data
capture capabilities

SQL-based data transformation tool tailored for analytics

Dbt workflows, facilitating the extraction, transformation, and
loading of data from diverse sources into data warehouses.

Open-source data integration platform simplifying workflows

Meltano from extraction to visualization, with pipeline management
and analytics capabilities.

www.CloudTDMS.com 5/12
Best Practices for Evaluating ETL Tools
1. Know your specific requirements
When evaluating ETL tools, several factors should be considered to ensure
they align with your organization's requirements. Based on our experience,
here are the critical considerations to keep in mind :

Core Capabilities
Evaluating core ETL capabilities ensures seamless
alignment with business needs. It should include
essential connectors & transformation functionalities,
orchestration, and error handling for comprehensive
data processing.

Retrieving data from multiple sources, such as DBs, APIs, SaaS

Extraction
apps, data lakes, files, sftp, and streaming as well.

Restructure data to fit the target system's requirements, like data

Transformation
cleansing, filtering, aggregating, and structuring.

Ensuring data accuracy, completeness, and consistency through

Data Quality
validation, standardization, and error handling mechanisms.

Data Enrichment Combining data with additional information from external sources

Profiling Analyze data quality and characteristics for better insights.

Seamless integration with the target systems, such as DBs, Ddta

Loading lakes, warehouses or SaaS to ensure efficient loading of
transformed data.

Managing and scheduling ETL workflows & dependencies to

Orchestration
ensure timely execution and data availability.

Monitoring and logging capabilities to track ETL job progress,

Monitoring
identify issues, and troubleshoot errors.

Mechanisms to handle errors gracefully and recover from failures

Error Handling
without compromising data integrity or consistency.

www.CloudTDMS.com 6/12
 Scalability
Assess the tool's ability to handle growing data volumes.
Does it support horizontal & vertical scaling for increased
data needs? Evaluate its efficiency in workload and
performance maintenance as data expands.

Ease of Use
Assess the tool's user interface and design environment.
Is it intuitive and easy to navigate? Consider the learning
curve for your team members and whether the tool
offers features to simplify development processes.

Performance and Reliability

Assess the tool's performance across varied workloads
and conditions. Does it provide features such as parallel
processing to enhance throughput and reduce
processing time? Evaluate also its reliability for job
scheduling, error handling, and recovery mechanisms.

Security and Compliance

Ensure the tool offers strong security measures to
protect sensitive data, including features like data
encryption, role-based access controls, and audit trails.
Verify also compliance with regulations such as GDPR.

Cost & Pricing Model

When assessing ETL tools, consider total ownership costs.
Evaluate licensing fees, implementation, maintenance,
professional services, and support. Compare pricing
models (e.g., per-user, per-data volume) and additional
costs for scaling or customization to find the best value.

www.CloudTDMS.com 7/12
2. Conduct a Pilot or a PoCs

Pilot or PoC
PoC (Proof of Concept) : A small-scale experiment to
validate technical feasibility and basic functionality.
Pilot: A real-world evaluation to assess effectiveness
& viability under representative conditions.

Objectives & Scope

Clearly define the goals and objectives.
Establish measurable success criteria.
Define specific use cases or scenarios to be tested.
Outlining the scope, timeline, resources, and budget.

Stakeholders
Identify all stakeholders involved, including project
sponsors, end-users, experts, and decision makers.
Assign essential experts and end-users for a
proficient execution and comprehensive evaluation.

Iterate and Refine

Monitor the performance, functionality, and usability.
Evaluate the results against the success criteria.
Iterate, make necessary adjustments, and refine the
use-cases as needed.

Findings & Next Steps

Document all findings, observations, challenges, and
lessons learned.
Present the findings to key stakeholders.
Based on the outcomes, develop next steps plan.

www.CloudTDMS.com 8/12
Key Issues & Solutions
1. Key issues for ETL projects

Time is money
1 Developers and testers are often spending a huge time
waiting for test data, which can slow down development
and delay deliveries. Particularly in large-scale projects
as well as those involving highly sensitive data.

Data Quality
Incomplete or inconsistent test data leads to defects

2 and bugs causing delays and additional reworks. It

undermines the accuracy and reliability of testing
outcomes affecting the overall product quality and
undermines user satisfaction

Testing with real data ?

It can be risky as it may contain sensitive information.
3 Current data anonymization & masking techniques is
making it difficult to conduct project’s development
and testing in a realistic environment.

Garbage in = Garbage out

If test datasets are unreliable or incomplete, the project
4 shall fail to meet its objectives or deliver the desired
outcomes, which is often resulting in cost overruns and
huge delays.

Data Privacy & Protection

The rise of data breaches and privacy concerns has

5 made it important for companies to prioritize data

protection and restrict its access. If a company persists
in using cloning its data for development purposes, it's
not a matter of IF, but WHEN they will face a data leak !

www.CloudTDMS.com 9/12
2. How to accelerate and ensure success?
Thanks to emerging AI technology, like synthetic data, we can ensure
successful data-driven projects by leveraging fake-data that
mimics real-data characteristics while maintaining privacy and
security. This innovative approach accelerates the process of
sharing data with team members & partners.

Safe Shareable Data

By mimicking the properties and characteristics of real
data, synthetic data provides a reliable shareable
data while ensuring data privacy and security.

Fast
Generating synthetic data is fast and efficient.
Developers and testers can quickly create a wide
range of scenarios, including edge cases and rare
events.

Realistic & Sophisticated

Thanks to AI/ML, synthetic data generation is
becoming increasingly sophisticated and realistic,
making it a viable alternative to real data in many
data-driven projects.

Risk Free
Synthetic data eliminates the risks of data breaches
caused by the cloning of production databases during
project’s development and testing phases.

Cost effective
Synthetic data is a cost-effective solution that addresses
many challenges the companies are facing for data-driven
projects.

www.CloudTDMS.com 10/12
3. Solution : Synthetic Data Factory

In today's data-centric world, how we manage data

dictates not only the efficiency of companies but also
their very existence in the near future.

Nowadays, data is one of the most valuable resources. Let’s keep

it safe by stopping the cloning of production databases and
share only fake copies to be more relevant, resilient and socially
responsible. Persisting in cloning production databases makes it
a matter of when, not if, a company will face a data breach. Years
of brand-building effort can be swiftly undermined by a single
data leak.

CloudTDMS is a Synthetic Data Factory that simplifies

the generation of fake but realistic data, thanks to
generative AI techniques, without compromising the
confidentiality of personal or business information.

With CloudTDMS, users can create synthetic

datasets that looks, feels, and acts like real-data.
This enables a shift-left approach by enhancing
quality & reducing bugs/defects. And of course,
make data-driven projects effectively compliant
with data regulation policies such as GDPR.

CloudTDMS provides generators that cover many

data types including reference data, ensuring that
users can create any kind of dataset with confidence,
while keeping PII (Personal Identifiable Information)
out of their lower environments (dev &test).

www.CloudTDMS.com 11/12
 Ready to see how you can create

Synthetic Data that perfectly mimics your

real-data, ensuring a safe, shareable,
and tailored dataset suitable for your
project needs ?

Create your free account now