Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Pulmonary Aspergillosis: Early Diagnosis Improves Survival: Original Paper
Pulmonary Aspergillosis: Early Diagnosis Improves Survival: Original Paper
Respiration 1995:62:341-347
M von EiJJ*
N. Roosb
Pulmonary Aspergillosis:
R. Schultena
M Hessea Early Diagnosis Improves
M. ZiihlsdorJ51
J. van de L o o a Survival
Departm ents of
* Internal Medicine and
*>Radiology, U niversity o f Munster,
Germany
Abstract
Bronchoscopy obtaining bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) fluid and bronchial
secretions (BS) and/or high-resolution com puted tomography (CT) of the
lungs were performed in 33 patients with pulm onary aspergillosis from 1987
to 1992. The sensitivity of BAL fluid or BS for detecting histologically proven
fungal disease was 33 and 50%, respectively, whereas positive serologies were
only documented in 8% o f the cases. CT scans contributed to the early diagno
sis o f opportunistic fungal pneumonia: characteristic CT signs were found in
16 of 19 episodes. The more frequent use of bronchoscopy and CT scans
between 1990 and 1992 compared to 1987-1989 for the differential diagnosis
of new pulmonary infiltrates resulted in earlier appropriate treatm ent. The
average introduction o f intravenous (i.v.) antifungal therapy after the onset of
pneumonia was shifted from 12 to 7 days (p < 0.05). The timely implementa
tion of i.v. antimycotic therapy had a significant impact on survival. Initiation
Key Words o f antifungal treatm ent later than 10 days after the onset of pneum onia
Aspergillosis resulted in a m ortality of 90%, as opposed to 41% with an earlier start of
Bronchoscopy antimycotics (p < 0.01). The earlier use o f appropriate antifungal therapy in
Bronchoalveolar lavage the second treatm ent period im proved survival from 33 to 50% (NS). Bron
Bronchial secretion choscopy and high-resolution CT scans are mutually complementary diagnos
High-resolution computed tic tools and should be performed as early as possible in the course of pneum o
tomography nia for patients at high risk for aspergillosis.
[ 15-17]. High-resolution com puted tomography (CT) has 1,200 H. For the m ediastinum , a window level between 40 and 60 H
been advocated for the early diagnosis of opportunistic and a window width between 300 and 500 H were used.
fungal pneumonias [ 18-20].
BAL Studies
Between January 1987 and December 1992, 33 immu- For BAL, a bronchoscope was advanced and wedged into a seg
nocompromized patients developed invasive pulmonary mental bronchus supplying an area of radiographic abnormality.
aspergillosis in our departm ent. O f these, 32 Aspergillus Alveolar lavage was performed by the sequential instillation and suc-
infections were diagnosed while the patient was alive, and tioning o f 50-ml volumes of sterile physiologic saline. The procedure
was repeated four times, and the fluid returns pooled. An aliquot of
treatm ent with antifungals was instituted within 24 h of
BAL fluid served for culture o f aerobic bacteria, Legionella, myco
the diagnosis. bacteria. fungi and viruses. Cytopreparation smears were routinely
In all these patients, either bronchoscopy and/or CT of stained with Grocott for detection o f Pneumocystis carinii and fungal
the lungs were performed for the differential diagnosis of organisms, gram stain for bacteria and auram ine-rhodam ine for
new pulmonary infiltrates. We present here our experi mycobacteria. Assays for Legionella and for cytomegalovirus used
direct immunofluorescence. Papanicolaou stains were examined for
ence with this disease entity, review the clinical features
the presence o f malignant cells, intracytoplasm atic or intranuclear
and diagnostic approach, and discuss the therapeutic viral inclusion bodies and hemosiderin-loaden macrophages. Bron
management. chial secretions (BS) were suctioned via the working channel o f the
bronchoscope and examined for bacteria, fungi, mycobacteria and
Legionella.
Patients and Methods
Diagnostic Criteria
The patients’ records and autopsy results were evaluated retro A diagnosis o f aspergillosis was either established by histological
spectively. The following param eters were analysed in addition to the demonstration o f pulmonary invasive disease or, in patients with
clinical courses: (1) histological exam ination o f tissue collected in clinically documented infections, Aspergillus spp. were cultured in
vivo and/or postmortem; (2) conventional chest radiographs and CT respiratory secretions and, additionally, characteristic radiographic
scans o f the thorax; (3) microbiological findings in bronchoscopic patterns, positive serological results or clinical and/or radiological
specimens, and (4) Aspergillus IgM antibody titres (Aspergillus-HA response after starting intravenous (i.v.) antifungal treatm ent were
test. Roche*) and surveillance cultures. documented. The CT criteria for an invasive pulmonary aspergillosis
(IPA) were angiotropic nodular parenchymal lesions (>0.5 cm) with
C T Scan or w ithout the accompanying so-called ‘halo-sign’ and/or wedge-
CT scans were performed on a Philips-Tomoscan 350-Scanner. shaped. pleura-based infiltrates [ 18-20].
In all cases, scans were obtained at 0.9-cm intervals using 0.9-cm
collimation. The lungs were viewed and photographed at a level of Statistical A nalysis
600-700 Hounsfield units (H) and at a window width o f 1,000- For statistical analysis, %2 and Student’s t tests were used.
Num ber
Aspergillosis was diagnosed in 15 cases histopathologi-
cally. In the other 18 cases, Aspergillus spp. were cultured Acute myelogenous leukaemia 13
16 times from BAL fluid and/or BS and twice from sputum. Acute lymphoblastic leukaemia 3
Additionally, characteristic signs o f aspergillosis in high- Chronic lymphocytic leukaemia 3
resolution CT (n = 10), significant anti-Aspergillus anti Chronic myelogenous leukaemia 2
Non-Hodgkin's lymphoma 5
bodies (n = 3) and clinical and/or radiological response after
Agranulocytosis 1
starting antifungal treatment (n = 11) were demonstrated. Non-small cell lung cancer 1
The patient's characteristics are given in table 1. The Kidney transplantation 3
majority o f patients had haematologic malignancies (ta Moschcowitz’ disease 1
ble 2). 25 patients had received intensive cytostatic treat W aterhouse-Friderichsen syndrome 1
ment and had subsequently developed severe neutropenia
and thrombocytopenia. 17 patients were pretreated with
steroids (>20 mg prednisone daily for > 2 weeks). 3
patients had additionally been treated with cyclosporin A
for more than half a year. All patients had fever refractory Table 3. Microbiologic findings in BAL
to broad spectrum antibiotic therapy. On average, tem fluid and BS (n = 28)
The prognosis of our patients with aspergillosis has invasive aspergillosis in immunocompromized patients.
improved during the last few years. Patients with fungal However, surveillance cultures as well as antibody or anti
pneum onia treated between 1987 and 1989 had a m ortali gen detection often present false-negative results [12, 13].
ty of 67% (10/15). Between 1990 and 1992, the mortality The low sensitivity and specificity o f serologic tests as well
decreased to 50% (9/18; NS). Between the former and lat as o f surveillance cultures was reaffirmed by this study.
ter periods, the introduction of i.v. antifungal treatment However, bronchoscopy and CT scans o f the lungs
after onset o f pneum onia has been shortened from 12 to 7 established or substantiated the early diagnosis of pulmo
days (p < 0.05). The duration of pneum onia o f surviving nary aspergillosis in our patients. 6 of 12 histopathologi-
patients has been shortened from 39 (23-64) to 31 (16- cally proven aspergilloses were diagnosed by bronchosco
50) days (NS). py. In comparison with BAL, BS had a slightly but not
significantly higher sensitivity. Apart from the positive
cultures of Aspergillus, an additional advantage o f bron
Discussion choscopy was the identification of other organisms.
Mixed infections o f Aspergillus with Candida spp., Pneu
Invasive pulmonary aspergillosis has become an in mocystis carinii, herpes viruses and/or bacteria were doc
creasingly im portant cause of m orbidity and mortality in um ented in more than half of the patients with invasive
immunosuppressed patients. The im m une defect most aspergillosis. Comparable data for the diagnostic yield of
clearly associated with invasive aspergillosis is prolonged bronchoscopy have been published. Albelda et al. [23]
neutropenia [21, 22]. At a tim e when institution of high- reported a success rate o f 50%. Bronchial washings and
dose antifungal therapy may improve survival, invasive brushings established the diagnosis o f invasive pulmo
biopsy procedures are often prohibited by the patients’ nary aspergillosis in 8 o f 16 patients. In the study o f Kahn
marked thrombocytopenia. Thus, a num ber o f investiga and Jones [16] BAL enabled the diagnosis o f 7 o f 13
tors have used a variety o f laboratory methods in an patients with invasive fungal pneumonia. Yet, Saito et al.
attem pt to make an earlier and more reliable diagnosis of [24] reported a lower diagnostic yield of BAL in patients
345
with acute leukemia. BAL detected none of 9 Aspergillus be im proved from 33 to 50%. At the same time, the dura
pneumonias. In a prospective study into the diagnostic tion of fungal pneum onia of surviving patients was re
role o f BAL in immunocompromized patients, we found duced from 39 to 31 days. The influence of early appro
that the detection of Aspergillus spp. in bronchoscopic priate antifungal therapy on survival has also been pub
specimens was 100% specific [ 15]. The significance of the lished by others [5, 19,27,28].
isolation o f Aspergillus from the respiratory tract in pa In conclusion, both techniques, bronchoscopy obtain
tients with neutropenia was also affirmed in a 3-year pro ing BAL fluid and BS and high-resolution CT scans have a
spective study by Yu et al. [25], Identification o f Aspergil high diagnostic yield in detecting aspergillosis and are
lus spp. in respiratory secretions of immunocompromized mutually complementary diagnostic approaches. CT scan
patients predicted aspergillosis accurately, with 17 of 17 is a sensitive tool in the early diagnosis o f pulmonary
patients with positive cultures for Aspergillus showing aspergillosis when assessed together with the clinical set
invasive pulmonary' disease on subsequent diagnostic ting. The identification of Aspergillus spp. in broncho
biopsy procedures. Yet, other authors reported that iden scopic specimens in immunocomprom ized, particularly
tification of Aspergillus in BAL eventually proved to be severe neutropenic patients, proves aspergillosis. From
pathogenic in only 25% of cases, retrospectively [ 17], the data reported here, we arrive at the following recom
Chest X-ray findings at the onset of infection were mendations. In immunocompromized patients at a high
non-specific and indistinguishable from other infectious risk for pulm onary aspergillosis, particularly patients w'ith
pneumonias, particularly in our patients with neutrope prolonged neutropenia, empirical treatm ent with antibi
nia. CT played an im portant role in establishing the early otics and antimycotics should be started as soon as infil
diagnosis of fungal pneum onia in these patients and trates are detected on X-ray. Bronchoscopy with BAL and
guided management. In the appropriate clinical setting, BS and a high-resolution CT scan should be performed as
the presence of a CT halo sign strongly supported the diag early as possible to establish the diagnosis. Hopefully, ear
nosis of invasive pulmonary aspergillosis. CT was more ly diagnosis and therapy will significantly improve surviv
sensitive and, in particular, more specific than conven al in these patients.
tional chest X-rays. CT scan recognized fungal disease in
3 cases, where simultaneous conventional chest films did
not show any abnormalities. All 7 cases with radiographic
halo signs and/or air crescent signs were finally confirmed
histologically as invasive pulmonary' aspergillosis. The
contribution of CT to early diagnosis and management of
invasive pulmonary aspergillosis has also been described
by others [ 18-20,26]. The halo-like lesions were shown to
correspond to a central fungal nodule surrounded by a rim
o f coagulative necrosis [ 18]. In this retrospective analysis,
CT diagnosis had the highest sensitivity in the early diag
nosis of aspergillosis. However, the specificity of the CT
halo and/or air crescent signs must be determ ined in
future studies. Like Kuhlman et al. [19], we have not yet
found docum entation of any infections in neutropenic
patients other than with Aspergillus dem onstrating these
signs.
The more frequent use of bronchoscopy and CT scans
in our departm ent between 1990 and 1992 compared to
1987-1989 resulted in an earlier appropriate antifungal
therapy and led to greater therapeutic success. The start of
i.v. antifungal treatm ent after the onset of pneum onia was
reduced from 12 to 7 days. Early employment of antifun
gal treatm ent within the first 10 days after onset of pneu
monia had a significant impact on survival. The survival
of our patients in the more recent treatm ent period could
347