Professional Documents
Culture Documents
In the mirror of the pertinent literature, we present our experiences gained in /6/ operations for pectus
carinatum. The Type I (keel chest) deformity is corrected by bilateral resection of the costal cartilages,
transverse osteotomy of the sternum, detachment of the xiphoid process, and resection of the lower end of
the body of the sternum. The sternum is maintained in its corrected position by utilizing the pulling force
of the rectus muscles through the reattached xiphoid and by tacking the pectoralis muscles together in
front of the breast bone. Type 1/ (pouter pigeon breast) is handled by double transverse osteotomy,
chiseling off the protuberant portion of the sternomanubrial junction, and by supporting the lower sternal
body with either the suspended xiphoid process or with Marlex mesh. Limited forms of Type 11/
(asymmetrical or lateral pectus carinatum] are managed with simple resection of the involved cartilages
only. If the anomaly is more extensive, bilateral resection of the cartilages and correction of the sternal
axis is carried out.
Francis Robicsek, M.D., Joseph W. Cook, M.D., Harry K. Daugherty, M.D., and
Jay G. Selle, M.D., Charlotte, N. C.
We believe it has been demonstrated for the con- chicken breast, sternogladiolar prominence, pyramidal
ventional pectus carinatumthat operation is indicated chest, thorax cunei forme , and others. Anatomically
and achieves excellent results.
these "carinatum" deformities can be conveniently
Mark M. Ravitch
divided into three groups:
Type I: Keel chest. This anomaly, which resembles
the keel (carina) of the ship, consists of symmetrical
Pectus carinatum is the second most common anom- protrusion of the sternum and the costal cartilages.
aly of the anterior chest wall. 1-6 In our own surgical Usually the sternum arches forward more in its middle
experience, it constitutes about 22 percent of 720 pa- and lower portions than in its upper part. 1 In the more
tients operated upon with anterior chest deformi- severe cases, there is also a forward angle at the junc-
ties. 7- 13 Pectus carinatum was already widely known tion of the middle and lower third with the tip of the
and recognized during the time of Hippocrates, who xiphoid process pointing in the dorsal direction. This
described it in connection with other abnormalities of condition is commonly associated with bilateral de-
the rib cage and the spine: " ... the chest becomes pression of the lower cartilages,": 15 mistakingly iden-
sharp pointed and not broad, becomes affected with tified by Brodkirr'" 17 as Harrison grooves.
difficulty of breathing and hoarseness; for the cavities Type II: Pouter pigeon breast. An interesting va-
which inspire and expire do not obtain proper ca- riety of pectus carinatum is the chondromanubrial
pacity. "14 prominence, 16 which Lester" called arcuate pectus
carinatum and Ravitch I coined pouter pigeon breast. In
Anatomy and development this anomaly, only the manubrium and the first two
The common feature in the different forms of this sternal cartilages are protruding. The body of the ster-
deformity is the prominence of the sternum. Besides its num usually arches backward (chondromanubrial prom-
most common designation, "pectus carinatum ," it is inence with chondrosternal depression), and the tip of
also known under several other aliases: pigeon breast, the xiphoid process points anteriorly.
Type III: Lateral pectus carinatum. Asymmetrical
From the Department of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery, Char-
lotte Memorial Hospital and Medical Center, and the Heineman
or lateral pectus carinatum is characterized by unilat-
Medical Research Center, Charlotte, N. C. eral protrusion of the anterior chest wall. Sometimes it
Received for publication Dec. 15, 1978. is associated with contralateral depression. The anat-
Accepted for publication Jan. 17, 1979. omy is usually dominated by the deformity of the carti-
Address for reprints: Francis Robicsek, M.D., The Sanger Clinic, lages, and the malposition of the sternum is less sig-
P.A., 1960 Randolph Rd., Charlotte, N. C. 28202. nificant. In the most common form of this lateral pectus
Fig. I. The contour of carinatum deformity in a child (top) and in an adolescent (bottom).
carinatum, there is marked chostochondral prominence To suppose the opposite would be equal to the ac-
of one side and rotation of the sternum around its lon- ceptance of the fact that the reason the neck of the
gitudinal axis toward the opposite side, which is mod- giraffe is so long is that otherwise it would not reach its
erately sunken. Less frequently seen varieties of this head. After resecting these elongated, distorted carti-
disease are the localized protrusion of one or more ribs lages from more than 200 patients, it is our firm belief
that the displacement of the sternum is secondary and
or cartilages (or both) without sternal involvement.
due to an overgrowth of the costal cartilages. If the
Pathogenesis sternum is pushed inward, pectus excavatum is the
result; if it pushed outward, pectus carinatum de-
The pathogenesis of pectus carinatum, like that of velops.*
most congenital anomalies of the chest wall, is uncer-
tain. The earliest hypothesis on this subject was for- Sixteen years and nearly 600 operations later, we are
warded by Brodkin": 17 who, like Chin" a decade later, even more convinced about the validity of this view.
blamed the underdevelopment of the central portion of The question naturally arises-what is the cause of
the sternal attachment of the diaphragm with concomi- this overgrowth of costal cartilages? Ravitch, I who
tant hypertrophy of the lateral muscular component. He wrote the most indepth study on this subject, is inclined
thought that this combination causes displacement of to accept the explanation of Humberd'" given in his
the sternum because "changes in the costal cartilages paper' 'Giantism of the Infantilism Type and its Disclo-
then occur as these have no option but to follow the sure of the Pathogenesis of Pigeon Breast and Funnel
sternum to its displaced site." 16, 17 Chest," written in 1938. Humberd pointed out that in
The Brodkin-Chin theory to explain the development giants who are not acromegalic, "both pigeon breast
of funnel chest, just like the very similar hypothesis of and funnel chest are common and this to be a kind of
Brown " has now largely been discarded. The reason infantilism in which they retain the infantile chest at the
undoubtedly is that the changes described in detail by same time the ribs are growing excessively rapidly."
the authors have never been confirmed by later inves- Ravitch ' believes that the same mechanism may be re-
tigators': 18. 20 who, like us,7-13 kept looking inten- sponsible for the development of pectus carinatum,
sively for the anatomic and functional changes of the even if the subject's development is otherwise normal.
diaphragm described by these authors and found none. This overgrowth of costal cartilages is usually already
Our opinion on this subject always agreed with that present at birth. Interestingly enough, however, where-
of those!: 18 who believed that the diaphragm plays very as the presence of pectus excavatum is usually recog-
little role, if any, in the development of pectus defor- nized in the very young, not infrequently pectus
mities, and the abnormal position of the sternum is *From Sanger PW. Taylor FH, Robicsek F: Surg Gynecol Obstel
secondary and due to the overgrowth of the costal carti- 116:515-522, 1963, published by permission of Surgery, Gyne-
lages. As we stated before: cology & Obstetrics.
The Journal of
54 Robicsek et al. Thoracic and Cardiovascular
Surgery
Fig. 4. Keel chest with significant protrusion of the lower-most part of the sternum before and after repair. (From
Robicsek F, Sanger PW, Taylor FH, Thomas MJ: J THORAC CARDIOVASC SURG 45:691-701, 1963, published by
The C. V, Mosby Company.)
normal shape of the chest, they walk and sit slightly alone-a procedure that he continues to use with con-
bent forward with dropped shoulders. As school chil- siderable success.' Chin" in 1957 and Brodkin!" in
dren, they are exposed to mockery, and they avoid 1958 employed an operation which used the traction
locker rooms, swimming pools, and outdoor activities. effect of the rectus muscles to bring and maintain the
All these factors may lead to an abnormal posture sternum in a corrected position, They performed
which may further aggravate the anomaly. limited resection of the costal cartilages bilaterally, de-
tached the xiphoid process, and sutured it into a notch
Treatment high on the anterior surface of the sternum. Howard"
Various nonoperative methods, such as physiother- further modified this method by resecting the cartilages
apy, plaster of Paris cast, external compression, and so more radically and by performing a transverse os-
on,24-26 can be dismissed with the words of Howard: teotomy of the sternum at the level of maximum de-
"The remedy for the deformity is operation, Physio- formity. These procedures were used with or without
therapy is useless without operation, and retaining ap- minor modifications by several other authors. 4.26.30-33
paratus is worse than useless, "1,5 Our own techniques in the different forms of cari-
Surgery, as the only effective method for the treat- natum deformities, first applied in 1957, are as follows:
ment of pectus carinatum, was first suggested by Type I: Keel chest. The operation is performed
Ravitch and Handelsman in 1952,27 but it was Lester" through an upward convex transverse submammary
who I year later performed the first corrective proce- incision. The length of the incision is proportional with
dure for this anomaly by resecting subperiosteally the the extent of the deformity, and the planned extent of
lower body of the sternum as well as the sternal ends of exposure and is carried down to the level of the sternal
the costal cartilages. He 28 later extended his procedure periosteum in the midline and to the fascia of the chest
by removing subperiosteally the entire body of the ster- muscles bilaterally, Flaps of skin and subcutaneous tis-
num and excising the costal cartilages in the total extent sue are developed and retracted in the cranial and
of their involvement. In 1960, Ravitch.F' "feeling that caudal directions, The pectoralis muscles are detached
the sternum was not primarily at fault and that the prob- from the sternum and mobilized laterally enough to be
lem was with the ribs and cartilages," resected the allowed later to be pulled and sutured together in front
involved costal cartilages, shortened the perichondrial of the sternum without undue tension. The small pec-
strips with reefing sutures, but left the sternum toral branches of the intercostal vessels are divided by
The Journal of
56 Robicsek et al. Thoracic and Cardiovascular
Surgery
Fig. 5. Significant protrusion of the lower two-thirds of the sternum before and after repair in a child. (From
Robicsek F, Sanger, PW, Taylor FH, Thomas MJ: J THORAC CARDIOVASC SURG 45:691-701, 1963, published by
The C. V. Mosby Company.)
Fig. 6. Significant protrusion of the lower two-thirds of the sternum before and after repair in an adolescent.
means of electrocautery. The sternum is then carefully Caudal to the line of the transverse osteotomy, the
inspected, and a wedge-shaped transverse osteotomy is sternal ends of all costal cartilages are then sub-
done at the beginning of the abnormal forward curve, perichondri ally resected. Short segments of the upper
usually just below the angle of Louis. Care is taken that cartilages with progressively longer segments of the
the line of osteotomy corresponds to an intercostal lower ones are removed. If a cartilage appears to be
space rather than to a sternocostal junction. protuberant, elongated, or knobby, it is removed in its
Volume 78
Number 1 Pectus carinatum 57
July, 1979
Fig. 7. Schematic drawing of the repair of chondrogladiolar Fig. 8. Schematic drawingof repairof stemogladiolarpromi-
prominence with xiphoid support. nence with Marlex mesh.
entire length of involvement. Achieving an appro- the rectus muscles will exert a traction strong enough to
priately smooth contour to the anterior chest wall bring and maintain the breast bone in a corrected posi-
sometimes necessitates the removal of portions of osse- tion. If there are protuberances left on the sternum, they
ous ribs as well. are shaped with osteotomies and rongeurs. The edges
The lower end of the sternal body is now grabbed of the pectoralis muscles then are sutured together in
with a towel clip, elevated, and the xiphoid process is front of the sternum to exert an additional depressing
detached. If the xiphoid appears to be very rudimen- force upon the sternum and to provide a smooth contour
tary, the line of resection is carried superiorly to leave a to the anterior chest wall.
short portion of the sternal body in continuity with it. If the deformity is quite advanced and extensive,
Both the sternum and the xiphoid process are now mo- dissection is necessary, a wide communication is es-
bilized, the sternum distal to the osteotomy is de- tablished between the retrosternal space and the right
pressed, its posterior lamina is broken at the level of the pleural cavity, and an intercostal water-sealed catheter
osteotomy, and thereby its abnormal forward position is inserted. This provides adequate drainage and as-
is corrected. An appropriate portion, 2 to 6 cm. in sures a smooth wound healing.
length, of the distal sternum is resected. The new distal Type II: Pouter pigeon breast. The operation
end is smoothed off and united with the xiphoid process applied for the correction of pouter pigeon breast dif-
with several stainless steel sutures. This maneuver, la- fers considerably from the procedure just described,
beled as "acceptable but probably unnecessary" by because it has to correct two anomalies: (l) upper
Ravitch, 1 is in our opinion an essential part of the repair chondromanubrial prominence, which has to be de-
of pectus carinatum. Our view is based not only on the pressed, and (2) lower sternochondral depression,
good postoperative results but also on the pathological which has to be raised.
anatomy of this deformity. In pectus carinatum, the The exposure of the sternum is done in a fashion
sternum not only is in an abnormally elevated position, similar to that of the keel chest, but the incision is made
but it also is abnormally long; ergo, the position of the somewhat higher and longer because of the necessity to
sternum must be normalized and it also has to be reach the manubrium. The protruding manubriosternal
shortened. Resecting a portion of it will correct its ab- segment is molded with a wide osteotome, the carti-
normal length, and the reattached xiphoid process of lages are resected subperichondrially from the second
The Journal of
58 Robicsek et al, Thoracic and Cardiovascular
Surgery
Fig. 9. Sternogladiolar prominence with chondrosternal depression before and after repair.
Fig. 12. Sternal rotation occurring after unilateral resection of costal cartilages.
tissues are closed, the operator approximates the skin recurrent pectus excavatum. J THoRAc CARDIOVASC
edges with towel-clips, inspects the contours and pal- SURG56:141-143,1968
pates the surface of the chest wall, and, if necessary, 12 Sanger PW, Robicsek F, Taylor FH: Surgical manage-
removes additional portions of the deformed ribs. This ment of anterior chest deformities. A new technique and
report of 153 operations without a death. Surgery
simple maneuver can practically exclude the possibility
48:510-521, 1960
of unacceptable postoperative results. By and large, it
13 Sanger PW, Taylor FH, Robicsek F: Deformities of the
can be stated that, because of the nature of the pectus anterior wall of the chest. Surg Gynecol Obstet 116:515-
excavatum deformity, there probably will always be a 522, 1963
definite percentage of true "recurrences" which can be 14 Hippocrates: Genuine Works, London, 1849, Sydenham
decreased but cannot be eliminated even by the proper Society
choice of operation and operator. By contrast, unsatis- 15 Naish J, Wallis H: The significance of Harrison's
factory results in pectus carinatum operations usually grooves. Br Med J 1:541-543, 1958
indicate unsatisfactory surgical technique. Of the 13 16 Brodkin HA: Congenital chondrosternal prominence (pi-
unsatisfactory results, nine were readily detectable geon breast). A new interpretation. Pediatrics 3:286-294,
within 2 months after the operation and only four ini- 1949
tially showed a satisfactory appearance. The reason for 17 Brodkin HA: Pigeon breast-congenital chondrosternal
prominence. Etiology and surgical treatment by xyphos-
this is undoubtedly that in excavatum deformities the
ternopexy. Arch Surg 77:261-270, 1958
vector forces of the corrected human tissues have to
18 Lester CW: Pigeon breast (pectus carinatum) and other
raise the sternum and keep it elevated in its new posi- protrusion deformities of the chest of developmental ori-
tion; the operation in pectus carinatum simply allows gin. Ann Surg 137:482-489, 1953
the sternum to fall back into its proper place and keeps 19 Brown AL: Pectus excavatum (funnel chest). Anatomic
it there. That is not a particularly difficult task. basis; Surgical treatment of the incipient stage in infancy;
and correction of the deformity in the fully developed
stage. J THoRAc SURG 9:164-184,1939
REFERENCES 20 Mullard K: Observations on the aetiology of pectus ex-
Ravitch MM: Congenital Deformities of the Chest Wall cavatum and other chest deformities and a method of
and Their Operative Correction, Philadelphia, 1977, W. recording them. Br J Surg 54: 115-120, 1967
B. Saunders Company 21 Humberd CD: Giantism of the infantilism type and its
2 Welch KJ, Vos A: Surgical correction of pectus cari- disclosure of the pathogenesis of pigeon breast and funnel
natum (pigeon breast). J Pediatr Surg 8:659-667, 1973 chest. Med Rec 147:444-449, 1938
3 Chin EF: Surgery of the funnel chest and congenital ster- 22 Currarino G, Silverman F: Premature obliteration of ster-
nal prominence. Br J Surg 186:360-376, 1957 nal sutures and pigeon-breast-deformity. Radiology 70:
4 Asp K, Sulamaa M: On rare congenital deformities of the 532-540, 1958
thoracic wall. Acta Chir Scand 118:392-404, 1959-1960 23 Scoberry JH: Sodernan's Pathologic Physiology, Phila-
5 Howard R: Pigeon chest (protrusion deformity of the ster- delphia, 1961, W. B. Saunders Company
num). Med J Aus 2:664-666, 1958 24 Bianchi C, Pizzoli A: Metodica sui trattamento incruento
6 Kjaer A, Poulsen T, Vestengaard E: Funnel chest and del "petto carenato " 0 "cifosi stemale." Fracastoro
pigeon breast. A follow up study. Acta Chir Scand 61:769-778, 1968
(Suppl) 365:140, 1965 25 Bianchi C, Pizzoli A, Campacci R: Risultati a distanza su
7 Robicsek F, Daugherty HK, Mullen DC, et al: Technical 20 casi di "cifosi sternale" trattati incruentemente.
considerations in the surgical management of pectus ex- Fracastoro 61:779-792, 1968
cavatum and carinatum. Ann Thorac Surg 18:549-564, 26 Jaubert de Beaujeu M, Mollard P, Peschaud R: Thorax en
1974 carene. Lyon Chir 60:440-443, 1964
8 Robicsek F, Sanger PW, Taylor FH, Starn RE: Xiphoid 27 Ravitch MM: Unusual sternal deformity with cardiac
interposition. A technical modification for the repair of symptoms-Operative correction. J THoRAc SURG 23:
pectus excavatum. Am Surg 26:329-331, 1960 138-144, 1952
9 Robicsek F, Sanger PW, Taylor FH, Thomas MJ: The 28 Lester CW: Surgical treatment of protrusion deformities
surgical treatment of chondrosternal prominence (pectus of the sternum and costal cartilages (pectus carinaturn,
carinatum). J THORAC CARDIOVASC S URG 45:691-701, pigeon breast). Ann Surg 153:441-446, 1961
1963 29 Ravitch MM: The operative correction of pectus cari-
10 Robicsek F: Marlex mesh support for the correction of natum (pigeon breast). Ann Surg 151:705-714, 1960
very severe and recurrent pectus excavatum. Ann Thorac 30 Lam CR, Taber RE: Surgical treatment of pectus
Surg 26:80-83, 1978 carinatum. Arch Surg 103: 191-194, 1971
II Sanger PW, Robicsek F, Daugherty HK: The repair of 31 Ashmore PG: Management of some deformities of the
Volume 78
Number 1 Pectus carinatum 61
July, 1979
thoracic cage in children. Can J Surg 6:430-433, 1963 Therapy, SS Gellis, BM Kagan, eds., Philadelphia,
32 Locquet LK, Dietrick R: Pectus carinatum. Acta Chir 1964, W. B. Saunders Company, pp 395-397
Belg 8:621-625, 1969 36 Ravitch MM: Disorders of the sternum and the thoracic
33 Guilleminet M: In discussion of Jaubert de Beaujeu et al 26 wall, Gibbon's Surgery of the Chest, ed 3, DC Sabiston,
34 Lester CW: Funnel chest and allied deformities of the FC Spencer, eds., Philadelphia, 1976, W. B. Saunders
thoracic cage. J THoRAc SURG 19:507-522, 1950 Company
35 Ravitch MM: Chest wall deformities, Current Pediatric