Professional Documents
Culture Documents
George Peach MBChB MRCS is a Clinical Research Fellow at St George’s Critical limb ischaemia
Vascular Institute, London, UK. Conflicts of interest: none declared. Whilst some patients follow steady progression from asymp-
tomatic PAD to IC and then CLI, this is the exception rather than
Ian M Loftus MBChB MD FRCS is Consultant Vascular Surgeon and Reader the rule. Patients with PAD often have significant co-morbidity
in Vascular Science at St George’s Vascular Institute, London, UK. limiting physical activity and may develop CLI without pre-
Conflicts of interest: none declared. ceding IC.
Peripheral arterial disease (PAD) e Atherosclerosis that leads to Clinical features: ischaemic rest pain and tissue loss (i.e. ul-
arterial stenosis and occlusion in the major vessels supplying the ceration or necrosis) are key symptoms of CLI (Figure 2). True
lower extremities6 rest pain usually affects the toes or foot of the limb. It is most
Intermittent claudication (IC) e Ischaemic muscle discomfort in pronounced at night when cardiac output is at its lowest and
the lower limb reproducibly produced by exercise and relieved by elevation of the leg prevents gravity from assisting perfusion.
rest within 10 min6 Patients classically describe hanging the affected leg out of bed to
Critical limb ischaemia (CLI) e Ulcers, gangrene or ischaemic rest ease symptoms.
pain for more than 2 weeks attributable to objectively proven Arterial ulcers are typically ‘punched-out’ and have a have a
arterial occlusive disease6 white base due to the absence of healthy granulation tissue. They
Acute limb ischaemia (ALI) e A sudden decrease in limb perfusion are often found on the dorsum of the foot or digits and usually
that threatens viability of the limb6 associated with multiple stenoses or occlusions in the arterial
tree.
Figure 1 (a) Typical presentation of foot ischaemia/infection in diabetes. Note generalized swelling and purulent discharge. (b) Good healing after hallux/
2nd toe amputation (different patient).
Box 2
Figure 3 CT-angiogram images showing (a) normal lower limb arteries and (b) heavily diseased arteries with previous femoral to anterior tibial bypass.
patients and they are five to ten times more likely to require major is generally not advised for those with simple PAD, but dual an-
amputation (i.e. above ankle level) than patients without diabetes. tiplatelet therapy may be useful for maintaining graft patency of
Hypertension should be treated aggressively and angiotensin prosthetic bypass graft. Warfarin is not routinely advised for pa-
converting enzyme inhibitors (ACEI) may significantly reduce tients with PAD unless they have another indication for its use.
the risk of cardiovascular events in patients with PAD. b-blockers Patients with a BMI greater than 25 kg/m2 should be encouraged
can also be used safely by these patients and may reduce peri- to lose weight and take regular exercise,6 though greatest clinical
operative cardiovascular events in those requiring surgery.6 benefit is derived through structured exercise programmes (dis-
A statin should be prescribed to lower cholesterol unless cussed below).
contraindicated, since cardiac-related mortality is reduced by
approximately 20% with every 1 mmol/litre reduction in low- Management of claudication symptoms
density lipoprotein cholesterol, irrespective of initial cholesterol Exercise: exercise regimes involving at least two sessions of
level.15 Use of fibrates and niacin should be reserved for those exercise per week may improve a patient’s walking distance by
patients who have specific abnormalities of triglycerides or high- 50e200%. Structured exercise programmes appear to confer
density lipoprotein cholesterol. greatest benefit, with those in supervised programmes showing
All patients with PAD should also be on an antiplatelet agent 30e35% greater improvement in walking distance after 3 months.
and clopidogrel is now considered to be safer and more effective NICE therefore recommends that all patients with IC should be
than aspirin.16 Concurrent use of more than one antiplatelet agent offered a supervised exercise programme.10
For those patients unable to comply with exercise programmes, Though few studies have compared the efficacy of angioplasty
mechanical intermittent pneumatic compression of the calf may and surgical bypass in the treatment of severe limb ischaemia,
offer some benefit, though evidence for this remains limited. the BASIL trial (Bypass versus Angioplasty in Severe Ischaemia
of the Leg) found no difference between groups for amputation
Vasoactive drugs: the two drugs currently available in the UK for free survival, all-cause mortality or quality of life at 2 years,
treatment of intermittent claudication are cilostazol and naftidrofuryl though the angioplasty group had significantly higher rates of re-
oxalate. Both of these may offer modest improvement in walking intervention (28% vs. 17%) and many ultimately required sur-
distance, though studies of their efficacy have presented very limited gery. Subgroup analysis from this study suggests that surgery
follow-up data and cost-effectiveness remains questionable. may be the favoured option for fit patients with usable vein. Vein
Though antiplatelet agents (e.g. aspirin) and vasodilators (e.g. is used for the bypass whenever possible, as 5-year primary
nifedipine) are important for reducing overall cardiovascular patency rates are far higher than with prosthetic grafts (70% vs.
risk, there is little compelling evidence that these drugs offer any 20% for femoro-distal bypass).6
benefit in treating the symptoms of claudication. Angioplasty alone may be beneficial for patients with CLI
and infra-inguinal disease who are otherwise too unfit for
Intervention for intermittent claudication bypass. Though long-term patency results are poor, short-term
Intervention should be considered when conservative measures improvements in distal perfusion may be sufficient to allow
have failed and PAD is severely affecting a patient’s lifestyle or ulcer healing.
becoming limb threatening. This may be either endovascular (i.e. When revascularization is unlikely to be successful or the
angioplasty or stenting) or surgical. The most suitable treatment patient has comorbidities that might prevent them making use of
option should be determined on the basis of site/extent of the a salvageable limb, primary amputation may offer the best
lesion, patient fitness and local expertise. quality of life. The knee joint is preserved whenever possible for
Patients with focal iliac disease are more likely to be offered the sake of mobility, though this must be balanced with the need
endovascular treatment than those with femoral disease, since to ensure good wound healing.
intervention at iliac level is more durable (Figure 4). Meta-
analysis has shown that 5-year patency is 79% after iliac an- Non-surgical management of CLI
gioplasty versus 55% after femoral angioplasty. However, Non-surgical treatments are generally considered to have little
structured exercise programmes may be just as effective as an- long-term benefit and those patients that are unsuitable for
gioplasty for improving walking distance.6 revascularization should be managed symptomatically and un-
Surgical bypass is generally reserved for those patients who dergo amputation as appropriate.
have debilitating claudication and a pattern of disease not Prostanoids such as iloprost may improve healing of ischae-
amenable to angioplasty. mic ulcers as well as reducing pain and amputation rates in those
with CLI. However, the long-term benefit remains unproven and
Intervention for critical limb ischaemia
their use is therefore limited.
Patients with CLI typically have multi-level disease and surgical
Spinal cord stimulation (SCS) may be useful for some patients
bypass is often more appropriate, though endovascular tech-
and has been shown to improve limb salvage rates at 1 year,
niques may be used as adjuncts to improve flow in vessels
though the cost-effectiveness of this treatment remains in doubt
proximal or distal to the bypass. Newer technologies such as
and it is not widely available There is no clear evidence that
drug-eluting balloons and stents may improve the efficacy of
lumbar sympathectomy improves limb salvage for patients with
endovascular techniques. Endovascular techniques to re-open
unreconstructable CLI, though it may be of use in pain control.
long-segment occlusions (such as sub-intimal angioplasty) have
also demonstrated encouraging results in expert hands.
TASC guidelines suggest that patients with diffuse aorto-iliac Management of acute limb ischaemia
disease should be treated with surgical bypass (unless other Initial management should involve rapid resuscitation with
factors such as co-morbidity prevent this) and 5-year patency of oxygen, intravenous fluids and analgesia as necessary. Unfrac-
aorto-bifemoral bypass grafts is over 85% in those with CLI.6 tionated heparin should be given intravenously (5000 units) and
Figure 4 Digital subtraction angiography images taken before (a), during (b) and after (c) angioplasty/stenting of the right common iliac artery.
if the patient is not progressing to surgery immediately a found. All patients with ALI should therefore be anticoagulated
continuous heparin infusion should be started. for 3e6 months and those with evidence of thromboembolism
Diagnostic imaging is only appropriate when patients present should be considered for longer-term anticoagulation, or anti-
with no sensorimotor deficit and the limb is considered to be platelet therapy if anticoagulation is contraindicated.6 A
viable. If the limb is threatened, imaging is unlikely to change
management and simply delays revascularization.